ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Did Al Husayn do Khurooj?! Debunking the Myth
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ส.ค. 2024
- Timestamp:
00:00 Introduction
01:17 Foundations
02:49 Allegiance to rulers
04:32 Consensus among scholars
06:08 How did it start
08:42 People of Kufa
10:46 Statements of the companions
17:48 Yazid's troops
22:54 Al Husayn - A Brave Martyr
25:48 Wrap up
30:45 Al Fawzan's statement
31:44 Al Albani's statement
41:25 Outro
#farishammadi #hadith #khawarij #madkhali #Husayn #Salaf
زادك الله علما...و وفقك الله
Jami at-Tirmidhi 3768
Narrated Abu Sa'eed:
that the Messenger of Allah
(ST) said. "A-Hasan and AI-
Husain are the chiefs of the youths of Paradise."
بارك الله فيك Ustadh
جزاكَ اللهُ خيرًا أخي الكريم
بارك الله فيكم و جزاكم الله خيرا
بارك الله فيك
Jazāk Allāh khayr for this wonderful clarification and defense of the Sunnah from the ignorant khawarij! Bārakallāh feek! ❤
sahaba solved sall their disputes and agreed that khurooj is impermissible
@@jalidahmad8485Watch the whole video and you will know it.
JAK. Much needed and well clarified. ❤ sake of Allah.
جازاك الله خير.
جزاك الله خيرا وبارك الله فيك
Ustadh you should also do a full video for Muawiyah رضي الله عنه and Aisha رضي الله عنها as they use these as well as evidence
جزاك الله خيراً
بارك الله فييييييييييك
@@tahsin_rahi وفيكم بارك
JazakAllah khair ya sheikh, subhanAllah couple days ago someone used the hussein incident as that u can do kharouj and I didn't know how to answer him so I Said the prophet is better than al husain, hussein is not infallible. Jazak Allah khair in explaining the story and removing doubts
Barak Allahu feekum
1: What do you think about the battle of Tawabeen?
A sahabi was the leader of that battle.
Which sahabi?
سليمان بن صرد الخزائي
Battle against whom?
Ans: Against YAZEED LA and his armies.
2: Why did Muawia did khurooj on the righteous caliph of his time? 2 battles against a righteous caliph and Ammar ibn Yasir RA died from the army of Mawla Ali RA killed by Ahlul Sham.
Wait ustadh, how is the Hadith about dying the death of jahiliyyah if you don't bound yourself with bayah applied to us Muslims in western lands?
Does this mean we will die the death of jahiliyyah if we do not migrate and give bayah?
جزاك الله خيراً
That Muslim leader doesn't not govern that Western land where you live in.
Assalamu alaykum shaykh how do you say that Al-Hussain wasn't aware of the matter of bay'a and that it was an ambiguous situation, when infact the sahaaba clarified it to him and advised him against hes decision to go to Iraq?
Al Husain RA as esteemed highly exalted and the best in lineage in that time was not infallible and got betrayed by Ahl Iraq just like his brother and father before him
What happened to him and his followers was tragic criminal and uncalled for may the curse follow upon the murderers and betrayers
That’s the correct stance
@EM-tx3ly But my question is do we categorise the people who rebel against muslim rulers as one because what seems to be the case is that is not correct to say everyone who rebels against a leader is a khaariji, he may be and may be not there is more to it than just khurooj from what I seen now.
The sahaba didnt clarify to him that Kufa has already given baya'ah as they did not know that, the sahaba had wisdom on whats happening and knew the people of Kufa are traitorous as they killed Ali ra and other sahabaa. It was a land under Majous and had a lot of hypocrites who accepted Islam by mouth not by heart. The khawarij who killed Uthman ra many of them came from Iraq, even so called shiat Ali who killed Ali ra came from there.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😊
بارك الله فيك نقل سديد أخي فارس
Subhan'Allah people ignore the statements of the sahaba, it clarifies the matter. Anyone with integrity and intellectual honestly can not take his action as a justification for khuruj.
Sheikh can we get the slides you were presenting?
جزاك الله خير🤍
Now talk about Zaid, and Abu Hanifah supporting him, and the shift from Ummayad to Abbasid
😂😂😂
How about Sahaba and Tabieen in Makkah and Medina breaking their Baiyah against yazid after Karbala and openly rebelling against him. Of course they were correct. They died as martyrs fighting yazids army.
Husayn A.S was absolutely correct in setting out against a tyrant whose caliphate was never established. Yazid's appointment was illegal, and he sent his forces to Medina and Makkah which forced Husayn A.S to go on the move. Even though Husayn A.S didnt raise his sword until his enemies did, even if he had openly rebelled against the tyrant king, he still would have been totally correct. Though I believe that Husayn A.S eventually planned to go on the offensive after going to Kufa, I don't know if his initial plan was simply preaching the truth nonviolent or if he had other plans. Both would've been correct.
أحسن اله إليك
Ustadh how do you tie that shemagh beautifully like that
اسلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته أخي الكريم. ،hope you brothers doing well. What shud some one like me in the west do foe bay3a. Hijra seems little difficult right now. Baraak Allah oe fik um. Ustadh .☝️✅️🌎
Rabbi FARIS speaking of what he knows not 😂. Dude stick to prohibiting the boycott of israel this is deep waters for you.
You're the kind of guy who would happily live under Netanyahu. Unlike Imam Hussain and his followers, they'd rather fight to Martyrdom.
JazakAllahu khaira Usthadh
Could you also explain the issue of Ali and Muawiyah رضي الله عنهما. Ali رضي الله عنه was ولي الأمر at that time. Is it allowed to stay seperate without giving baiah in certain situation? Could you explain these issues in detail?
أحسن الله إليك
all the rhetorical questions you are asking were answered in Faris's video which you have cut off
I’m pretty sure Saeed Ibn Musayyib wasn’t a sahabi but from the tabi’een.
Indeed, I believe he is the one who married the daughter of Abu Huraira. One of the greatest scholars of the tab'een.
Hussain did not seek dunya, nor did he seek power, he sought the virtue of Khalif of the Muslimeen, he sought we ha tought was best for the ummah.
Allahu allam.
Faris pls do a video explaining the definition of khurooj... The acts and the intentions behind it
Asalamu Alaykum ya sheikh. If we live in the lands of the kuffar, do we still give bayah to a Muslim ruler? JazakAllah Khair.
Land belongs to Allah.
There are many countries and many rules who are Muslim. If you live in a foreign country other than those countries then to whom are you going to give your allegiance and for what?
No. And even if you did, that Bayah would be invalid, because there is no point in giving Bayah to a ruler who is not ruling over you.
"When the angels seize the souls of those who have wronged themselves-scolding them, “What was wrong with you?” they will reply, “We were oppressed in the land.” The angels will respond, “Was Allah’s earth not spacious enough for you to emigrate?” It is they who will have Hell as their home-what an evil destination!" Quran 4:97)
@user-cx3vo3pe1u
There is a shadow in my background
Are we allowed to rebel against non-Muslims rulers in non-Muslim countries
- Whilst we have NO ability (strength)
- Whilst we DONT have another ruler to replace him
- Whilst we rebel it will more more harm then not
Subhaana'Lah that's sounds like someone who wants to take millions of muslims into the jaws of death and terror, the refuge of Allah is sought!
Why do you want to rebel against any ruler? Do they prohibit you to practice Islam i.e. prayer, fasting, performing hajj, pay zakat etc?
@@courierton9217 The question is for learning purposes.
If the shaykh says, NO you cannot rebel against them.
Then I want to show the people then how can we do that with Muslim rulers
@@IbrahimIbnkhas The question is for learning purposes.
If the shaykh says, NO you cannot rebel against them.
Then I want to show the people then how can we do that with Muslim rulers
@@MAli99923
Hasan al-Basri on Khawarij: Rebels fight for sake of the world, not Islam
Abu Hayyan al-Tawhidi reported: A man from the Khawarij came to Hasan al-Basri, may Allah have mercy on him, and he said, “What do you say about the rebels?” Hasan said, “They are seekers of the world.” The man said, “Why do you say that when one of them goes out with his spear until it breaks and he leaves his family and children?” Hasan said, “Tell me about the ruler. Does he prevent you from establishing prayer, giving charity, and performing the pilgrimage?” The man said no. Hasan said, “As I see it, he has only prevented you from seeking the world and you have fought him for it.”
Source: al-Baṣā’ir wal-Dhakhā’ir 1/34
Beautiful video
According to faris he is presenting authentic narrations.
Here are excerpts from his evidences, on what the companions said while advising Hussain ra. My comments in italics.
Hussain himself:
I will take biyah from the ppl of kufa.
_He was going to take biyah while ppl had already given biyah to yazid_
Ibn Umar:
I entrust you to God as a martyr.
_ibn Umar was very clear on what he was going out for i.e. something that will get him killed_
Abu Saeed Al khudri:
do not go against your Imam.
_abu Saeed was very clear on what hussain was heading out for.
Jabir bin Abdullah:
don't cause ppl to fight.
What you are doing is wrong.
_jabir was very clear on what hussain was heading out to do_
While I am thinking, wow what was Hussain doing which was wrong, would cause ppl to fight, would end up him him a martyr.