ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ก.ค. 2011
- This scene was cut from the theatrical release of Dune, but is included in the "Extended Edition"
This does not appear in any of the available scripts for Dune.
Duke Leto Atreides (Juergen Prochnow), Paul Atreides (Kyle MacLachlan), Doctor Wellington Yueh (Dean Stockwell), Thufir Hawat (Freddie Jones) and Doctor Liet-Kynes (Max Von Sydow) listen to Gurney Halleck (Patrick Stewart) playing on the Baliset (actually a modified Chapman Stick - see stick.com) - บันเทิง
Max Von Sydow feeling the jam is gold. Rest in peace Von Sydow
Well, he did smoke a big fat blunt 10 minutes before.
Such a comfy scene. The set design and costuming are absolutely wonderful.
And then when you look back and realize that Yueh was trying to save Liet...
Captain Picard, the lost member of Toto.
LOL!
I'd listen to him sing Africa.
Alastair Ward Toto had nothing to do with this particular song
Like Tony Levin without moustache
😂
Nice to know even 10,000 years later Beach Boys surf songs are still popular.
8000* years later
@@lolanifenring2692 more than that, like 18000. they count years from after ai was defeated which around 10000 ad, they are in like 10000 after ai now
Not Beach Boys (it does sound like them) it's a rif from 'Sting' who was, of course, in the movie.
Sounds more like some early Rush intro, like something from '2112'
@@Plathismo pretty much
This scene should have totally been in the movie, it really shows and develops the Atreides / Fremen alliance plus the music is very cool too.
Watch Ryder reflection of the moon in the floor is dope.
The moon reflection now makes sense!
Totally agree.
@Floyd1504 That's good. I'd like to see that some time. There's a lot of good scenes that didn't make the later releases.
This scene is in the 3-hour extended cut
Synopsis: they sit around like the kids from the 70s show listening to Captain Picard play the bass/cello thing, then the u-boat commander pours one out for the homies.
in the book it's called a Baliset. In real life it's called a Chapman Stick.
that is some funky shit!
check out King Crimson if you like this. It will flip your lid. They got a guy who plays this instrument live at venues in England.
that guy is tony levin, a fucking god
For reals - who played that piece? 'cause it is KILLER!!!
Usually I can see why certain scenes are deleted from films but this, the 'Jamis Fight (Paul becomes a killer)' & especially 'Thufir's Fate' scenes are some of the best of the movie. Damn you De Laurentiis, damn you to hell.
Vaultboy101 ~ and the "History will call us wives" scene?? That's the last line of the book FFS!
I completely agree, and Thufir's Fate was just heart wrenching.
My god ive never seen the movie in full but ive read the book a couple times, the fight with Jamis is a pretty important part.
Wasn't it fault, it was Universal Studios. De Laurentiis regretted bowing to them
so many great actors in this scene.
Wait so Captain Picard is playing a little tune to Father Merrin, the Quantum Leap guy, the Das Boot Captain and Special Agent Cooper?
Ariel Prendergast ... now that’s a movie definitely worth making... and Freddie Jones once played Sweeny Todd on the bbc and scared the bejesus out of me ....l
It’s not the quantum leap guy
@@sounsure9108 Dean Stockwell played Al in Quantum Leap as well as Doctor Wellington Yueh in 84s Dune. The guy with the forehead tattoo talking to Max von Sydow. #RIP Dean #RIP Max
I'm pretty sure the guy in the Fremen Stilt suit is the evil brother from "Strange Brew". It's a Canadian adaptation of "Hamlet".
I kid. It's true, but von Sydow is a legend.
Captain Picard plays a tune to Ming the Merciless, Al Calavicci, the Commander (Das Boot) and Agent Dale Cooper,yes.
Gurney: Wow, I'm good.
Liet: Note to self: Must give the Fremen some balisets.
Yueh: This is totally out of character for the movie.
Thufir: I wonder if that pillar might be a Harkonnen...
Paul: How the heck did this get deleted?
*Looks at Moon*...”Muad’dib”. This scene would have connected to the visions in the beginning. Damn you whoever cut this movie.
If they had left in all the cut scenes, the movie would have been even longer than it already was. Not that I would complain about that...
@@amberyooper The theatrical version was pretty standard length at 130 mins - the trouble is that the preferred cut was over 3 hours long.
@@mnomadvfx It would be worth seeing the entire move , in 2 parts, just to see all the footage.
@NinjaRider777R I think that back in the mid 1980s when this movie came out, it was one of the longest movies of the time. The producers probably thought that people wouldn't be willing to sit through a movie that was even longer than it already was cut to. Obviously, for home release, that's not a problem.
@@amberyooper Not true, there were many movies that were 3 hours long or more before this. Godfather, Deer Hunter, the Twelve Commandments, Greatest Story Ever Told, Lawrence Of Arabia, Barry Lyndon and quite a few others. It was a Producer/studio decision but the wrong one. Oddly enough in the same year Once Upon A Time In America was cut for US theatrical release from the original 3 hour+ version and also butchered and ruined, luckily Once Upon A Time had the full version released in Europe so people knew there was a real version out there too, shame we never saw Lynch's Director's cut.
Interesting... in the book its Stilgar who meets and spits on the table, bringing him into it as an important figure. I see why Lynch changed it to Kynes, his importance and leadership of the Fremen is more pivotal at this juncture of the movie. shame the scene was not left in.
every deleted scene of this movie need to stay in it.......
+bennynutts16 try to find the original film, it is about 3 or so hours long, there you can find them,
That is NOT the original film, that is the TV cut put out by the studio that the director took his name off.
Krister Andersson is it really? I read reviews every so often that suggest as an aside there wasn't.
Alastair Ward Oh yes you can find the almost Three hours version here on youtube, It has Greek subtitles though.
There are also one that are almost four hours long.
Just type in Dune.
Krister Andersson I'm not sure I'd be ready for the whole four hours.
I have no idea, but apparently, 80's prog-rock is alive and well in the year 10'191AD
weldonwin and Picard's descendent is a big fan of it apparently
It's actually 10191 AG (After Guild)
If we go by our dating system it is the year 21267 AD
@@jasonfenton8250 I think they changed it to AD for the movie, with the Butlerian Jihad, or Great Revolt, occurring in 6041.
Gurney Halleck on the Chapman stick.
After 8207 years of ridicule, prog rock finally became popular again
Lynch movies are shot like a dream, depths and muted hues are otherworldly. Very British sensibility, probably from his past live as an English magician
Anyway was a difficult task to put all Frank Herbert books in one film!
In memory of Max von Sydow! Thank you!
Right thanks for being a shitty actor and ruining the beginning of force awakens with his old decrepit ass 😂
The only thing missing is a bong.
Baghuul The thing about the Caladan Carrot...
@@Ceaseless_Watcher lol xD
ummm 1:46
But that wasn’t in the book 🤣🤣🤣💨👍🏼
@@leeskinner9627 ha! nice one
I always liked the Dune film but found it a bit clunky, having watched a few of these deleted scenes I understand why, these are the missing bits that actually would have made it flow, as a narrative I mean.
Just to much content for the run time.
The original script runtime was something like 12 hours. I wish we could have seen that.
Yes, I agree. Only those who read the books can fill up the gaps otherwise...
The first two acts aren't too bad, a bit clunky but not terrible. The whole thing falls apart for me though the moment Paul and his mother meet up with the Freemen. Everything after that point is so insultingly rushed along from him rising through the ranks and becoming their leader, his relationship with Chani, him taming the Sandworm to his eventual overthrow of the Harkonnens and making himself Emperor. Then you hear how Lynch wanted the film to be over three hours but the studio told him to cut down the run time really explains a lot why the third act's pacing is so rushed.
No, show don't tell
Blimey, that Patrick Stewart's good. Doesn't just play alien flutes brilliantly, but far-future motor-guitars too.
He apparently took some basic stringing lessons from Sting to make it believable that it was him playing the instrument.
This is a tune written by the instrument's creator, Mr. Emmet Chapman, called Backyard, that appears on the album Parallel Galaxy.
Somebody who actually recognizes a Chapman Stick! Right on!
Nice! Thanks for that info.
I was about to say that it reminded me of a Chapman Stick.
@@HappyMSI1 Stewart asked Sting to teach him for the scene
I didn't know what the instrument was. All I know that I love the sound it makes.
I've only just noticed that there appears to be the shape of a hand on the moon that Paul looks at.
I just saw the new movie where they called it the hand of God. Now I see why
He's playing a Chapman stick of all things.
This whole movie feels pretty progressive rock honestly.
I really like it. Like its set in a future where the influences of bands like Pink Floyd, Genesis and King Crimson and of course Toto is still around like an ancient musical memory that you could perhaps listen to deep in the media archives of a museum.
Seen as part of some mythic past.
well the chapman stick is the only functional part of that instrument. the rest is just a prop with a mechanical fan being in the bottom for example.
You just summarized Dune.
Yeah, Prog Rock is really the best kind of music for Dune. Real old school European Prog from the early days, not the watered down stuff we got in the eighties. Jodorowsky wanted bands like Magma and Gong to do the music for his failed version of Dune and I can't help but wonder how it would have sounded. The music for the 2021 version had some interesting ideas, like using throat music for the Sadaukar and bagpipes as the battle theme of the Atreides, but on the whole it just didn't feel weird and out there enough for me. A bit too conventional.
Wasn’t Pink Floyd slated to provide the music for an adaptation of Dune planned for the 1970s?
Music's so fire the baliset comes with a cooling fan.
Chapman stick in the movie? Brilliant move on David Lynch's part. Chapman should issue a limited edition "Gurney Halleck" model for the upcoming 2020-21 series. Put me down for one, Mr. Chapman!
Are they still making it ? Will it be released soon ?
He might...if he was still alive.
Oh why oh WHY did David Lynch remove this scene!?? Gourney was ALWAYS playing his instrument in the book dune, amd ive often wondered what the melodies sounded like
david lynch didnt remove any scenes. he shot the whole thing, then they took it from him and gave it all to de laurentiis to cut.
david lynch has somewhat "disowned" this movie since he didn;t get any say in the editing
But if they kept this scene we wouldn't have the cat milking scene, which is way too crucial to the plot.
They definitely didnt sound like this piece of shit
Jason Soliva 🤣
@@GenericInternetter kind of ironic that it was from this disown movie that Westwood made the awesome game trilogy Dune, Dune 2000 and Emperor: Battle for Dune.
And it was from the Dune game, that Westwood built the whole Command and Conquer lore.
A father's pride, a son's appreciation
Paul was thinking, "Dad, don't you think pouring out a whole glass of water is kinda rude? I mean in Fremen culture your just supposed to loogie, man. Dayum..."
My guess is that the Duke realized he was in a precarious position, needed all the allies he could get, and that the greater the volume spilled, the more Kynes would notice his devotion to their cause.
It was basically on the level of a blood oath or pact.
LabTech nice. I can dig it
Not rude at all.
Kynes's gesture was one of respect - Leto's gesture was one of fidelity and with great intensity, a reinforcement of his earlier demonstration toward men over spice with the thopters when the carry all disappeared leaving them stranded against the coming worm.
To a man like Kynes possessed of a singular vision requiring such a vast amount of water, such a gesture is one that cannot be simply ignored or laughed away - to the Fremen water literally means life, and Leto offered precisely that.
Kenny Hill yeah but then he farted so i wuz like dayuuuuummmm sun
Wow captain picard/prof. X did not aged a day in 32 years
I've thought the same. It seems like he rushed age to 50 and then held steady for decades.
He was born old
The spice prolongs life. He ate all theirs too.
That's nothing, check him out in Excalibur, he's ripped.
The spice is a real thing, then
The bit with Gurney Halleck jamming was hilarious, everyone listening thinking 'what is this shit?" and "who's going to tell him it sucks"?
80s music sounds like it's both from the future and the past.
Maybe because it is :)
I love Max von Sydow
A brilliant actor. A very rare talent. God rest his soul.
This film is brilliant
Алмаз ! A'm fan !
Water is so precious that if you do the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge, you would get your ass beaten.
Haha yeah and most likely you would immediately be killed and your water used to replace some of what you wasted. It's interesting thinking of a culture that essentially made a religion out of water.
That was a stupid waste of water on this world too
If I only had someone like Gurney Halleck to play for me during the Covid-19 lockdown
In the books the conversation at the end involved Stillgar and Duncan Idaho, neither of which are in this scene. Stillgar asks if Duncan can be assigned to the Fremen. Someone on the Atreides side asks if Duncan can split allegiances and Stillgar says something like “It can be done. There is precedent.” Referring to Kynes in the scene here. It’s Stillgar who spits and Duncan who defends, citing the Fremen custom.
UGH!!! Another wonderful scene that was cut!
Anyone else needed a piss after this?
That's how me and my boys be chillin at the crib too.
Yeah, but the alternative edition has some fantastic scenes that really shouldn't have been cut. The theatrical version felt disjointed and rushed.
But I agree on Dune. It really is a special movie.
Lynch's Dune is a flawed masterpiece :)
Lynch may have strayed from the story a bit too much, but his movie made me feel like I was there.
The Allen Smithy cut?
@@Slopmaster no, the fanmade alternative edition redux
Duke Leto looks like he wants to be break Gurney Halleck's "baliset" over his head. The others are all listening polite but bored apart from Paul who's high.
lol good one :D
LOL !
The Atreides really know how to party!
I've seen a lot of deleted scenes from movies, and this ranks high in the "how could they possibly delete this", right up there with the security guard scene from Avengers.
Or Gandalf releasing horse which later brought Aragorn to Helm's Deep.
Even in the remastered extended cut of this film they left this out. Stupid. Stewart actually learned to play that thing.... For real. Too much effort went into that incredibly short scene to be cut.
Why'd they take this out?!! It was a wonderful scene!
Maybe it was too slow for the pace they wanted to press on...
If you ever hear David lynch talk he is sorry that he didn’t have Final Cut
@@sounsure9108 If he ever talks about the film at all.
1:40 I bet Dr. Kynes is thinking "my dude you're just supposed to spit on the ground, not waste a whole gallon you monster"
Kamin: "Guess you guys aren't ready for that yet .... But you're kids are gonna love it."
I saw the VHS of this film today. I have the feeling that the extended edition is WAY better.
It's like Jethro Tull ... in space. Spacero Tull.
TO be Thick as a Brick.
cqtaylor More like King Crimson
Jethro Muad Dib just doesn’t sound right.
What a fantastic cast, all in one room! 😊👌🏻
I wish it would be used in the Denis Villeneuve's version. After all, this scene explains the friendship between Atreides and Fremen. God I love how different yet noticable this world is.
and shows why father is a father and not a mother
awesome, thanks. I love the prefaces in the books with little Princess Irulan excerpts... enlightening, even..
Anyone: spits
Dune readers: *Press F to pay respects*
My word the Captain of the Enterprise and the Captain of U96 in the same room chilling.
"I feel very comfortable here!"
What a wonderful scene
Baron Harkonnen: (spits in Jessica's face)
Jessica: thanks, dad
Ending of that clip is really important to whole movie.
Yes. Paul chooses the 'hand-of-god' on the first moon, and not the 'mouse-shadow' on the second moon. This choice alters his entire life.
Also he delays in Kynes' research station because Duncan Idaho is in danger, which results in Kyne's death and Paul becoming the new leader of the Fremen, also a choice which defines his entire life.
One of the few scenes all the major principles are in scene together!
Knowing the fremen culture, I would imagine dumping water on the ground in front of them like that would be one of the most absolutely disrespectful things you could do. I was going to say it would be like lighting a cigar with hundred dollar bills, but water for the fremen is MUCH more precious than money is to (most of) us. Maybe it would be like going to Africa where everyone is starving and taking several crates of food rations and lighting them on fire.. Keeping eye contact the whole time you are doing it. But considering how water is so precious, they literally render ounces (probably less than he dumped out here) out of their dead and "giving your water" for the clan is considered an honor and duty. So what he did would be like throwing away a clan member's final and most precious offering after death. I love how the book made me think about things so differently
I'm thinking the same thing because in real life in other countries there are some things you just don't do or say because it could result in imprisonment or executions.
+swish007 The Fremen had the access to the water hidden underground. Also in Africa I would say the war lords control the food supply and those lighting food rations on fire are not starving.
I did think the duke poured way too much water. Just a splash would have done, Leto!
All true, I felt the same thing from this scene but like others have said Leto was ignorant of the culture entirely and this was a clumsy gesture on his part. To add to this though it also foreshadowed his own precious water that would be lost soon after, so I don't think the scene loses any value or credibility to the story.
frank addeo good point
I need the six-hour Dune or whatever it was.
I REALLY love this movie. (I really like the new one too. Looking forward to part 2 later this year). I remember seeing it in the theater with my older sister. She had read the books and I had not. She absolutely HATED it because it diverted so much from them, but me, having not read them (yet) was completely enthralled by every aspect of it. Since then she has come to appreciate this movie for what it is, though she much prefers the new one.
Captain Picard playing a Chapman Stick! :D
So glad I'm not the only one who spotted that,maybe they could have used Tony Levin as a close up stunt double
I've watched Dune 487 times. I've only ever watched the extended version, not the theatrical version. The theatrical version cuts out 40mins, and alot of it is important.
As someone who grew up seeing the TV extended version of the film (Alan Smithee cut but so much easier to follow), it’s weird to realize these scenes weren’t in the theatrical - but also explains why certain characters didn’t have blue eyes in every scene because they hadn’t finished post 😅
All high on spice. Please! Add these scenes, release. We buy.
The director's cut is still the best version of this movie. All of the deleted scenes are great!
this is the Alan Smithee version. this is a Producer's Cut
Leto: "I wish to show respect." (Unzips, pisses on the floor while grinning intently and fixing Liet-Kynes with his intense, charismatic stare).
Duke:
play us the Tipperarry song will you, captain Picard?
They removed this? This was important in the book. Too bad.
They removed like an hour of scenes all of which were in the books and were important, including by-the-book ending. Sigh.
For god sake I want the complete version of this movie so hard !!!!!!!!!!!
I forgot what a wonderful movie this was. I was not burdened by a read of the book.
I wish they would re release this on blue ray with all these scenes.
@0:55 Goddamn, you are one suave fuck, Dr Yueh!
I swore for a sec he was gonna grab a lamp and do 'In Dreams' by Roy O. RIP Dean Stockwell.
I remember this day.
I had to pee.
That rug really ties the room together
I like that little clapping noise Kynes makes. Just a little detail.
I was just going to ask who was clapping, thanks for clearing that up.
No problem. I only say Kynes because his mouth seems to move only a little at that time.
Max von Sydow can read the phone book and make it sound like a Shakespearen play
For a second there I thought he was playing "Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic"! That would have been perfect. Sir Patrick Stewart has admitted he didn't know who Sting was and hadn't heard of the Police.
Yet he asked Sting to teach him how to play the Chapman Stick for the scene
I watched the new version yesterday and so much of the meaningful dialog and events are missing from both films
The music at the end of this clip is much more ominous than the happy tune that Capt Picard is playing at the beginning.
I have never seen that scene before; it might be the best I've seen :3
Very much as it should be.
These deleted scenes should've been left in!! I also know that during an interview, one of the DeLaurentis family (Dino's Granddaughter(?)) dispelled the myth that half the movie ended up on the cutting room floor. It was just a handful of scenes--maybe an hour total--but they were great scenes, and their removal wrecked the flow of the story. Too bad.
I had never even seen this film until recently when I saw it on my "free movies" list on cable, but I fell in love with its weirdness; a "so ugly it's beautiful" sort of thing. I know it's been said a million times by a lot of "Dune" fans, but I honestly think this film could've been amazing.
Also, with Hollywood doing so many remakes that there's a small possibility somebody could remake the film again someday. I know one amateur production house did--and an awful job they did of it too. But in reality it will likely go down in history as just another really bad movie.
You got your wish!
@@patinho5589 The new _Dune_ movie isn't bad, but it's not great either.
Did Paul just see the "second moon" (Maud'dib) but only in the water's reflection?
That's not Patrick Stewart, that's Tony Levin without a moustache.
Picard rocking out!
Can’t believe that they deleted that scene from the movie?! 😫❤️
Stewart just needed a mustache and the Tony Levin transformation would have been complete!
Favourite comment I've seen for this clip: "Riker to Picard: Get out of the holodeck and back to the bridge, pronto!"
they should hear him play the flute
The only problem with this scene, as I see it, is that it is the Mentat that stands in objection to Dr. Kynes' spitting/salute of respect. Wouldn't a Mentat know of this custom, at least more than say, Gurney?
Thufir is under pressure at this point and sees threat everywhere, even Jessica remember, and isn't on top of his game.
Captain picard plays space guitar omg
Patrick Stewart never had hair!
Best instrument ever!
It's a matter of opinion. To me Lynch's Dune, i.e. the theatrical release is one of the best movies ever made. Sure it doesn't follow the book completely, but nevertheless everything the movie does is of excellent quality even by... I mean especially by modern standards.
Music is the universal language.
"The second moon!"
So what does it mean if I pee on the floor? Because any other time it just seems to upset everyone.
a reason it was cut. We watched some fan version with it in and just laughed
Notice how Thufir is most interested in Leto's reaction.
Ha ha! Who'd have guessed, the Balliset apparently evolved from the Chapman Stick! :o)