For anyone struggling, hang in there, you are not alone on this Odyssee - you will reach your Ithaca! Since my main focus is long videos (usually longer than 20-30 minutes), it would be nice to have such a 3 minute short, as a kind of teaser or trailer of the whole journey. And it does work (a bit) with the current shorts.
I've been uploading above minute shorts, and here's what I found. Most of my views come from the shorts feed, the money is about the same as the other ones, actually a bit more because of how much longer they are from my regular ones. They're performing very well. I think that the stumble on THIS video in particular is either because it was a terrible retention grabbing video, so it just flopped in the algorithm or the algorithm for 3 minute shorts changed from then to now. Hope this helps! 🐖
I think it's better if they keep the 1 minute shorts but allow them to have 3 parts by sliding the screen (if that's what they want to compete with tiktok), still count it as view count per slide as one short, so if they have 3 slides, it counts as they have 3 shorts and different shorts have different view counts. it's similar to "related video" but focus for shorts, it's annoying to have creators that keep making part 2 but we don't know where it is and too lazy to scroll into their channel. meanwhile "related video" mostly linked to a long video and many people hesitating to click it if they only like to watch shorts, they'll keep scrolling instead of clicking the related video.
btw i just got 76 subs and all are from shorts (channel less than 2 months), i don't know how to attract viewers on my long videos. i made more effort here but my other channel with AI creations got more views and subs. But I don't have much passion for playing with AI so I got bored faster when making the content.
Okay 3 minutes stinks because honestly 12 seconds is about too long for most people. 😮 Of course if you put in a long video that's a different consideration.
Just as I suspected. Yet another unnecessary feature from TH-cam that favors TH-cam 🤭. Once I notice a short is running too long, I swipe away. Leave long content to the main feed.
Okay. See? This is why I'm never a fan of 3-minute shorts. What's the point of wasting time? Make it 3 minutes, and this happens. But thanks for the info. ❤
Lmao ngl been making edits for a very long while takes so much time thinking not getting and subs or views or even making a community thinking about quitting any thoughts.
I am definitely holding off on shorts longer than 60 seconds till they get it all sorted out. I am not monetized yet but I don’t need anything messing with my progress of getting there.
Thanks for 1109 subscribers (+7 this week) and almost 1600 watch hours! Only 2400 hours more to go! Let’s go for it!☺️🙌🏼
I have 1700 but 80 watch hours and 1.4M views
I have 1300 but 393.5 watch hours and like 25k shorts views
@@HYPERFORCE_EDITS Wow! That’s amazing. You’ve done a great job🙌🏼
@@speedyvpf2276 That’s really nice! Also working hard to reach the 4000 watch hours I assume?
thanks for 5 subscribers 😢@@HYPERFORCE_EDITS
Took 2months to reach 500 subscribers 🎉🎉🎉 Thanks all...Aim to reach 1000 in next 2 months
You’re there!! 🎉
@valeriecarruthers7084 will be soon
For anyone struggling, hang in there, you are not alone on this Odyssee - you will reach your Ithaca!
Since my main focus is long videos (usually longer than 20-30 minutes), it would be nice to have such a 3 minute short, as a kind of teaser or trailer of the whole journey. And it does work (a bit) with the current shorts.
Put your Shorts into a playlist and send people to the playlist enmasse - these play in the normal watch page and attract regular ads.
Love it!
Aren't you a genius 😊. Good one!
I actually never thought of this
I've been uploading above minute shorts, and here's what I found.
Most of my views come from the shorts feed, the money is about the same as the other ones, actually a bit more because of how much longer they are from my regular ones. They're performing very well. I think that the stumble on THIS video in particular is either because it was a terrible retention grabbing video, so it just flopped in the algorithm or the algorithm for 3 minute shorts changed from then to now. Hope this helps! 🐖
The thing is, it’s not even released yet. TH-cam is something nowadays 😢
Longer Shorts are now showing up as Shorts. For everyone.
The weird thing is I managed to make one, but I don't know how I did it 🫠
I got lucky! 200K views on one Short!!! Thanks guys!
Thanks Rob. This speaks volumes.
All new youtubers join here 🔥🔥
Our new outdoor cooking channel Forest Grill Kitchen Thank you
Our new outdoor cooking channel Forest Grill Kitchen Thank you
🔥🔥🔥
I'm here,😂
@@ForestGrillKitchen Subbed and waiting
No cheating plz
Comming soon 10k 😊😊😊😊
Thanks for 140 subscribers 🎉🎉🎉
Small creators let's grow 💪💪
Subbed
142 subbed no cheating
Thanks for 9 subs😢❤
Thank you all of you for 200sub 🎉❤
217 subbed
Let's connect
No cheating plz
*3 minute youtube shorts really IS a bad idea for the creators who is in the road to monetize and already on monetization program*
it's not mandatory. Those creators just need to continue making their 1 minute shorts. They don't need to extend their shorts to 3 minutes
Thx for sharing 🫶🏻
I think it's better if they keep the 1 minute shorts but allow them to have 3 parts by sliding the screen (if that's what they want to compete with tiktok), still count it as view count per slide as one short, so if they have 3 slides, it counts as they have 3 shorts and different shorts have different view counts. it's similar to "related video" but focus for shorts, it's annoying to have creators that keep making part 2 but we don't know where it is and too lazy to scroll into their channel. meanwhile "related video" mostly linked to a long video and many people hesitating to click it if they only like to watch shorts, they'll keep scrolling instead of clicking the related video.
btw i just got 76 subs and all are from shorts (channel less than 2 months), i don't know how to attract viewers on my long videos. i made more effort here but my other channel with AI creations got more views and subs. But I don't have much passion for playing with AI so I got bored faster when making the content.
Thanks for 26 subscribers 😢
@@VoidMitte that's more then my subs
🔥🔥🔥
Btb?
Thanks for 50 subscribers! Road to 100!!
Vidiq definitely needs a new comment section
Your vedio is very motivational
I definitely assumed this would be a problem for something. I have had to switch to making my videos at least over 3 minutes...
Thank you all of you for 1230 sub 🎉❤
Keep it going everyone ! We're all gonna make it big, just dont ever give up !!
Thanks for sharing this important information ❤
Another way TH-cam is robbing money from its creators 😮😢
சூப்பர் ப்ரெசென்ட் டியூட்
Nice 👍 Thank You Sir 🩵🩵🩵
Helpful
Hope it will be better, All I want is to grow my channel😢
Think positive everyone God bless
Thanks for sharing just hit 2k subscribers
Thanks for 1.2k subscribers and 3000 watch hours since i started two months ago
Best content
Never Giving Up Untill 1M. 🎉We are doing it together
Very nic thnkyu sir
Thanks for sharing 😊
I got 120 subscribers now thx
Done
122 let's connect
No cheating plz
Thank you for 309 subscribers
310 subbed
Let's connect
No cheating plz
Wow 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤❤
How do i increase watch time ..can you do a video on this ..am a small TH-camrs aspiring to grow
Thanks bro🥲
Thanks for 4k subscribers 🎉❤
I just started a few weeks ago I need all the help I can get!
Shorts are only going to be in the shorts feed?
I watch your videos regularly
Have anyone here done it yet?(3 min long short)?Just curious?
You *can* do longer shorts, but *should* you? Probably not…
I knew ad revenue was a problem for TH-cam shorts, but it wasn’t until I saw that graph that I realized how large of a problem it is. 😨
Yeah all my shorts above 50 or so seconds flop, people normally watch only for 30 seconds and that's about it
TH-cam becomes a lottery ticket 🤣
I love your vedio 😊
Finally reached 1k sub 😊
🥰🙏🏻
Okay 3 minutes stinks because honestly 12 seconds is about too long for most people. 😮 Of course if you put in a long video that's a different consideration.
Honest question!
How do I get a 3 minute TH-cam short because when I’m gonna upload a short my only choices are still 15seconds to 60 seconds?
Message to everyone. You will succeed at your goals.
Hey VIDIQ 😃👋
As you are growing and haven’t reached monetization, wouldn’t this be a good thing to grow watch hours etc?
Shorts watch time does not count towards the watch hours for monetization. Shorts need to qualify you via views.
@@DougHewsonYT I never knew.😫 No wonder it wasn't counting on my face less channel
Honestly I think it's unnecessary to make it 3 minutes, just keep it 1 min max.
I think 1 minute 30 seconds is a fair ground for max shorts time
The anime guy here
I have 423 subscribers over a year now . This is slow ,my friend told me I’m not good at it to make my goals
I will never use these 3 minutes shorts - already made myself to forget it!
I can’t get my slider bar to go past 60 seconds .. what am I missing ?
😊
I guess my decision to quit two weeks ago was the best decision.
Thank you so much
Woooow thanks guys for supporting small creators like me 💥
Subbed 10, you will get there
Let's connect
No cheating plz
How much earning longer shorts
I like when TH-cam randomly transforms your video into a short when it's shorter than 3 mins and you get 0 views on it
I think 3 minutes shorts will be better
Monitized yet less views ,less than 100 views what should i do?
I actually really like this because of the natures of my channel I will be on the treadmill for a long time
Helpful.
Thanks for my 731 subscribers.
Everyone, remember don’t give up no matter what happens, you will succeed so trust in yourself.
No one will actually watch such a long SHORT. People will better watch long vids. And revenue is ofc on the ground...
Why in comments people talking getting subs??
How to know if i am shadow banned?
Am at 18 so close to 20
I‘m nearly at 500 subs 🥳🥳🥳🥳
Thanks VidIQ
Time to watch ads on TH-cam shorts multiple times then.
Hi
I would do so called shorts (1:1 ratio video) over 1 minute to keep the money coming in. Shorts are becoming a no value option over long form
My Subscribers Increased Bcs of shorts
I just hit 385 subscriber!! Hopefully everyone can make it in 2025. Let's go guys 🎉🎉🎉🎉
The best way to make views is to make views 😎
Thanks i am at 91 subscribers ❤❤
W
Just as I suspected. Yet another unnecessary feature from TH-cam that favors TH-cam 🤭.
Once I notice a short is running too long, I swipe away. Leave long content to the main feed.
Okay. See? This is why I'm never a fan of 3-minute shorts. What's the point of wasting time? Make it 3 minutes, and this happens. But thanks for the info. ❤
Lmao ngl been making edits for a very long while takes so much time thinking not getting and subs or views or even making a community thinking about quitting any thoughts.
Thank you for this information helps ALOT!! ❤
Hoping to get a shoutout soon
This channel made me gain over 2.1k subs❤
I saw a short 18 minutes long
I am definitely holding off on shorts longer than 60 seconds till they get it all sorted out. I am not monetized yet but I don’t need anything messing with my progress of getting there.
🤔
😢😢😢 having even 100subs hard to earn
Thanks for that
Wow I was the second one to like🥈
3 MINUTES SHORT IS THE DUMBEST UPDATE TH-cam HAS MADE IN YEARS