Using a tree diagram in transformational analysis
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 พ.ค. 2024
- This video demonstrates how to analyze sentences that undergo transformation. The transformation shown in this video includes particle transformation, adverb clause transformation, and relative clause transformation.
#treediagram #syntax #linguistics #transformation #transformationalrules #adjectiveclause #adverbclause #complexsentence #relativepronoun #transformationalsentence #particletransformation #deepstructure #surfacestructure
Good morning sir, thankyou for the explanation, A transformational grammar rule that connects two phrase markers during the derivation of a sentence's deep to surface syntactic representation, such as by reordering, inserting, or deleting elements; a rule that converts deep structures to surface structures. a transformational grammar rule that connects two phrase markers during the derivation of a sentence's deep to surface syntactic representation, such as by reordering, inserting, or deleting elements; a rule that converts deep structures to surface structures.
Great idea of visualizing the analysis of transformational sentences👍
Hopefully the video is useful
thank you sir.
after watching this video i can sum up that transformation is involve the changes of a sentence structure. so there is a process of changing the structure from deep structure into surface structure. deep structure contain mental structure, meanwhile the surface structure is the word that we spoken. there are 3 kind of transformation rules that explain in this video which are Particle Transformation(T-prt), Adverbial Phrases transformation(T-AdvP), and Relative Clause Transformation (T-Rel).
Thank you for your explanation, sir! According to this video, transformational is the technique of utilizing a tree diagram to change a sentence's deep structure to its surface structure. A sentence's deep structure is its structure before any modifications have been performed. We obtain the surface structure after changing or transforming the deep structure.
That's all from me, Thank You.
Mohammad Owen 20018075
Thank you for the explanation sir.
It is a clear explanation. Based on the explanation, there are some types of transformation that is particle transformation, Adverbial Phrases transformational Rules ( T - AdvP ), and Adjective Claude or Relative Claude Transformation ( T - Rel ). Based on the examples, transformation is to change the deep structure into surface structure.
Agnia Elvy ( 20018045 )
Thanks for the explanation, sir. What I got from your explanation is that the process of changing the structure from the inner structure to the surface structure is called transformation.
Thanks for the explanation, sir. Based on the theory and examples that you explained, I already quite understand. Just need a little more practice.
Thanks for the good explanation, sir. From the video I came to understand that the deep structure is a mental structure that exists in the mind and the surface structure is the written or spoken.
Thank you for the explanation, Sir. Based on this video, I learned that there are three types of transformations such as T-prt, T-AdvP and T-Rel. In addition, the important point I got from the video is that if we want to transform a sentence, we must first determine its deep structure and then we can transformation the sentence.
Thank you for the great explanation, sir. From this video I understand that transformational is the process of changing the sentence from deep structure to surface structure by using tree diagram. The deep structure of a sentence is the structure before any transformations have applied. After we change or make transformation from the deep structure, we get the surface structure.
Thank you for the explanation, sir. From the video we know that the deep structure is a mental structure which is in our mind and the surface structure is the structure which is written out or spoken.
thank you for your explanation sir.
we learnt from the video that transformation is the process of changing the sentence structure from deep structure to surface structure. There are 6 types of transformation structure such as; particle transformation, adverbial phrase transformation, Adj clause or relative clause, inflectional, negative sentence, and interrogative sentence. However, in this video we have only learned 3 of the 6 types.
Thank you for the material, sir. I have gotten three points from the video to make three kinds of transformation (T-prt, T AdvP and T-Rel). Firstly, it is for T-Prt, we should know about where the particle place on the sentences so that we can be easily draw tree diagram. Secondly, T-AdvP has main point that we should identify the element of AdvP so that the analysis is more easy to write. Thirdly, we should able to identify the structure of Relative Phrase in the element of NP so that we can draw where Relative pronoun place. That's all for me. Thank you so much, Sir.
Nadhira Puti Isladara (20018077)
K-1 2020
Thank you for your explanation, Sir. So, from the video we know that transformation is a process of changing the structure from the deep structure into the surface structure.
Thank you for the explanation about noun phrase, sir. I really understand about noun phrase after watching your videos. But, i curious about something. Is it possible to use sentence like the example in the videos for writing in academic context such as thesis or article? and why?
thank you sir
Thank you for the good explanation sir. Here i want to ask you a question. Based on the ambiguity sentences structure that we found , are the ambiguity sentences can be associated to these six kind of transformation ?. Thank you.
Transformation is the process of changing the structure from the deep structure (a mental structure which is in our mind) into the surface structure (the structure which is written out or spoken)
In this video we study three kind of transformation : Particle transformation (a transformation that involves particles), Adverbial phrases transformational rules and Adjective clause or relative clause transformation.
Thank You Sir 🙏
Thank you for the explanation, Sir.
To convert a sentence, we must first establish its deep structure, and after that, we can do the transformation. The sentence structure that was previously in the deep structure can be moved to the end or vice versa.
Thank you for your explanation, sir.
Now I understand more about tree diagrams. A tree diagram is a new management planning tool that depicts the hierarchy of tasks and subtasks needed to complete an objective. The tree diagram starts with one item that branches into two or more, each of which branches into two or more, and so on.
Great understanding...
Thank you for the great explanation sir. After watching this video, we know that there are three types of transformations such as T-prt, T-AdvP and T-Rel. After we change or make transformation from the deep structure, we get the surface structure.
At first, I thought this material would be difficult to understand because I am not familiar with the word transformation in a sentence. But, when I watch this video and you explain the sentence examples from the three sub-topics, this material is very easy to understand. If I pay attention, the changes in each sentence that have been transformed are not so different from the previous one. Therefore, I think it will not be difficult. I will try to analyze the other sentences. Thank you for the explanation sir, it helps me a lot.
👍👍👍
Thanks
Thank you for the good explanation, Sir. T-prt, T-AdvP, and T-Rel are three sorts of transformations that I learned about through this video. Furthermore, a key takeaway from the movie is that in order to modify a sentence, we must first understand its deep structure, after which we can transform it.
All the transformational analyses must begin with the sentence's deep structure.
Thank you for the great explanation sir ☺️.
I just want to make sure that I understand about this topic.
what I understand is that if we want to transform a sentence, we must determine its deep structure first, after that we can do the transformation of the sentence. We can move the sentence structure, which was originally in the deep structure it may be placed at the end and the transformation is placed at the beginning or vice versa.
And there is also the possibility that new rules will be created as happened in the Adverbial Phrase and Relative clause.
Is my understanding correct sir?
Thank you in advance Sir 🙏
Thank you for the explanation, sir. So, clause transformation from the deep structure to the surface structure makes the analysis by using the tree diagram easier I think. Moreover, it also makes an effective sentence by avoiding repetition for relative clause. However, what about the other two kinds of clause such as particle and adverbial phrase transformation? I don’t know what the benefit we got or what the purpose of the clause transformation is
thank you for the explanation sir. the video discusses about the transformation of sentence strucutre because of the transformation rules. firtsly i think that it will be hard to understand, but as long as i know the PS rules, its no longer difficult. and i just know that we can put the same constituent on the same branches. from the video, we know that there are six types of transformation but we only discuss three of them. particle transformation isnt difficult, different with relative clause and adverbial phrase where it has a new sentence as the constituent. then, in the video, we also have to identify the appropriate PROr to change the repeated phrase in the sentences. and also, i wonder that whether a sentence can consists of two or more PROr.
Thank you for your great explanation sir, my understanding is if we want to transform or change a sentence we must know the deep structure of the sentence. there are 3 types of transformational analysis such as particle transformation, adverbial transformational, relative clause transformational. I'm little bit confused on the adverbial transformational. is it only subordinate conjunction that can make a transformation in the sentences sir? what about coordinate conjunction sir?
Thanks for excellent explanation, sir🙏 I can conclude that transformation means the process of changing the sentence structure from deep structure to surface structure.
Epsa Aprilia (20018011)
Profezo, puedo ir al baño?
Thank you for the explanation, Sir 🙏🏻. From the video, we can conclude that the process of changing the sentence structure from deep structure to surface structure is called transformation.
Annisa (20018005)
Yes, the change from the structure in our mind to the structure when it is produced.
Mudah2an video tentang jenis transformasi lainnya segera menyusul ya pak....😀
Sudah saya upload. Silahkan cek di th-cam.com/video/tuca7KrB0S4/w-d-xo.html
@@rusdinoorrosa9155 Terimakasih pak🙏
It would be much better if the video is divided into each specific type of transformation.
Thank you for the siggestios
Is it correct to say that any movement performed by each element of the sentence is called transformation?
You're right. Moving the sentence element transforms its deep structure to its surface structure.
Berarti transformasi itu bermakna segala perpindahan posisi unsur pembentuk kata dari posisi yang sebenarnya diisi oleh unsur tersebut. Selama ini saya tidak merasa bahwa separable verb phrase merupakan salah satu bentuk dari transformasi. Terimakasih pak.👌
Benar sekali. Segala adanya perpindahan unsur kalimat menandakan telah terjadi transformasi.
Sir I need some help from you can you guide me about this ?.
What is it? I'll help you
Contoh relative clause yang pakai whose kok belum ada Pak? 😅
Assalamualaikum Wr Wb, I'm Aulia Rahman (20018050), first of all to thank you for the great explanation sir, from the video we know that transformation is a process of changing the structure from the deep structure (a mental structure which is in our mind) into the surface structure( which is in our mind and the surface structure is the structure which is written out or spoken).
Thank you for your explanation, sir. I got your point about the structure's changing from the inner structure to the surface structure is called transformation. This video was really helpful for me to analyze and solve my confusion of the structure rules. Thank you.
Name : Diva Puspa Ningrum
NIM : 20018055
Assalamualaikum wr wb. Thanks a lot for your explanation Sir. It's really clear by using example in written form and explained directly everything that is necessary to be discussed.
Muhammad Yazid 20018019
The sentences analyzed in this video are longer than the sentences in your other video. But, not as long as I expected.
You can check the other video at th-cam.com/video/IYrddnE0xjI/w-d-xo.html
My name Paulus Sijabat 18018046 sir, based on the video i can conclude that there are ways for transforming a sentence, from deep transformation into surface transformation. Therefore, when we are transforming those phrases we must know the PS' rules.
Thank you sir, god bless you🙏
Bagaimana dengan penggunaan relative pronoun whoes, Pak?
Penggunaan relative pronoun (whose) itu biasanya untuk menyatakan atau menanyakan kepemilikan. Dan biasanya respon atau jawabannya dalam bentuk possessive pronoun.
Sekian penjelasan dari saya semoga dapat membantu.
Paulus
@@samuelbobchannel6294 Terimakasih atas responnya.