This Judge has NO BUSINESS being a Judge.I cringed everytime she was in the courtroom shouting at people, fighting with lawyers-EMOTIONAL Outbursts, finger pointing and just being too emotional.She should never have been allowed near the trial and it still leaves a bitter taste in my good mouth every time i see her
No we don't. She can't even do the job of a Judge. If more judges were like her the legal system would be in trouble. A Judge's most important responsibility is to be impartial and she couldn't even do that.
I love hearing her speak! And the fact that she chose not to contest to prevent the families from going through another trial shows how much she cares. That case was a case like any other! Emotions were everywhere! Games were played during the trial! The disrespect was HIGH! She’s human and she handled the best way she could! The families were grateful for her and that’s all that matters.
I heard that cellphone call she’s talking about and it’s as horrifying as she said it is. I was cleaning and had the trial on in the background. It played during the trial and I ran to turn it off. I had to sit and I couldn’t stop crying. I have ptsd and I promise you all those parents, students, victims, witnesses, etc. all went home and had panic attacks or meltdowns, or whatever. There’s no question about it.
This Judge has NO BUSINESS being a Judge.I cringed everytime she was in the courtroom shouting at people, fighting with lawyers-EMOTIONAL Outbursts, finger pointing and just being too emotional.She should never have been allowed near the trial and it still leaves a bitter taste in my good mouth every time i see her
@@Rasira2023 and what do you want me to do about it? Apparently she did just fine, the people who were investigated were on the defense. Idk but if lawyers were giggling and flipping people off when a child’s head was hanging off by skin I’d be mad too.
The perpetrator is now setting precedent for others…you will get life and not death. There is no deterrent. Life in prison means nothing to these people…death is something else
She managed to accomplish nothing less than a miracle given the gravity of horror that was at the core of this tragedy. She treated the families with utmost respect and empathy. The defense attorneys got what they asked for. They should have known better.
Enough already!! Her behavior during the Cruz trial....UNPROFESSIONAL!! A danger to all fair proceedings to our justice department!! GOOD RIDDANCE! 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉She does not have what it takes to stay unbiased!!!!
oh so u could’ve been flipped off and laughed at by a school shooter and his attorney and felt no need to defend the victims? Just say that you didn’t watch the trial and stfu
@@TheAnimalWolverine ok thanks. I just came across one of her latest interviews and she says it was her decision to step down from the bench even before the cruz trial was going on .
If she did so great, why did the hire a pellet court? Tell her your attitude towards the public. Defender's office was atrocious and unprofessional. And at this point you can either step down. Or you can be fired. So obviously she stepped down good judges. Don't step down when they get beat by a bunch of low level public defenders. She's just a spoiled little brat who didn't get her way on this one. And she thought Dylan Cruz was gonna have incompetent counsel and he didn't and she was mad about it. Not to mention the jurors couldn't stand the families. They were unlikable they didn't want Justice. They just wanted blood and the jury knew it. But I don't really think they liked the judge neither.
No actually she got some more Botox in her lips she needs to calm down and learn how to practice law and no she's not real and authentic and that's what the problem is and that's why she was removed out of the Department of Justice because she is not authentic she does not have what it takes to stay unbiased
I watched the whole trial. Thank God justice was served. Love this woman so much. She has a big heart and really cared about the victims and their families.
@@lisachlastawa5105 It pissed off a lot of people that three of the jurors voted to spare Cruz's life due to falling hook, line and sinker for the sob story put forth by the defense of how poor little Nikolas Cruz shouldn't be executed because of his lifelong history of mental health issues. Of course following this trial; Florida governor Ron DeSantis overruled the 2016 decision by the Florida Supreme Court that required a unanimous jury in Death Penalty cases and allowed for majority rule as a means of preventing so-called "activist jurors" from being able to lie their way onto the jury in a Death Penalty trial and allow monsters like Nikolas Cruz to get away with murder. Though you have people like Forensic psychiatrist Dr. Carole Lieberman who were singing high praises of the jurors who voted to spare Cruz's life and calling Judge Elizabeth Scherer a monstrous diva. Though I hope the Lifetime network never makes a movie on the Parkland tragedy out of respect for the families of the victims; I could easily see Judge Scherer being portrayed by either Kristin Davis (Charlotte on "Sex and the City") or Constance Marie (George Lopez's on-screen wife Angie on the George Lopez show.) I only stated that the Lifetime network would have made a movie on the Parkland tragedy as they have the ability to make "ripped from the headlines" true crime movies down to a science.
Justice was going to be served regardless. There was no way he was being found not guilty. The fact you wasted hours of your life on this side-show trial, speaks volumes.
The fact that she sacrificed giving up being a judge to not put the families through another trial is absolutely selfless and really is a testament to her character. She could have fought it and she probably (and rightfully) would have won in the end. I'm even more impressed with her now after watching this than I was from how she handled the trial.
The defense lawyers were a bunch of disgusting “ professionals” . She gave up her job to prevent the victim’s families from having to testify in yet another trial. Respect for her 👏👏👏
Never blame lawyers. They are doing their civic duty... Remember John Adams represented the British soldiers who opened fired on civilians in the Boston Masacre.
She resigned out of embarrassment. The judiciary was appalled at her behavior. She was so bad the FL Supreme Court recused her on another death penalty case. The other Judges wanted her gone.
@@Jackferrett6781 the lawyers are just public defenders making successful vigorous defense on the first hand, and absolutely vanquished the trial judge on the other hand
She wasn’t a good judge. She made a mockery of the justice system. A good judge has control of their court room, and their emotions. She has no business wearing a robe anyone that think she’s a good judge and that her behavior was appropriate as a judge is ignorant of law. Judges are a higher standard, It’s a good thing that you’re not judges. they toyed with her cuz they could. You do not get emotional. You keep your emotions out of it. She was so biased. I feel sorry for the victims and families. Yes the kid was a serial killer and a horrible human being. May God have mercy.
If a judge cannot be impartial, then that person should not be a judge. Yes, judges are human, but they must put aside their biases when they are on the bench. It's called being a Professional. Maybe she went to the wrong law school. I'm glad she is no longer on the bench. She doesn't have the temperance for it.
@@elektra3222 IT IS IMPOSSIBLE. I don’t care what you say. You are ALWAYS going to have an opinion. There is no way around it. That is why we have a jury and not one singular person deciding someone’s fate. This murderers lawyers were annoying AF and dealing with a matter as crucial as this one- no, she didn’t put up with any nonsense given the gravity of the matter. She did an excellent job.
Wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong basically this has nothing to do with you being human it has to do with you being professional you are not allowed to demonstrate bias towards the defendant basically made a mockery out of that courtroom and allowed parents to flip off the defendant you're not allowed to do that that is why she was given a choice to just resign would have been removed you cannot have judges like this in the Department of Justice it basically ruins the fair trial process and yes it is possible for someone to remain unbiased yes it is
@@Abcdefghijk920 you have no right to take out your feelings on the defendant is the violation of courtroom procedure and you will be removed as a judge what you can see that happened because she does not have what it takes and don't talk to me about what you know my brother is a district attorney I'm an ex law student this is why I had to quit because I do not have the temperament to go into a courtroom you better have the right attitude in order to do this job professionally and if you cannot do it you have to get out the game that is the reality
This Judge has NO BUSINESS being a Judge.I cringed everytime she was in the courtroom shouting at people, fighting with lawyers-EMOTIONAL Outbursts, finger pointing and just being too emotional.She should never have been allowed near the trial and it still leaves a bitter taste in my good mouth every time i see her
She showed partiality when she hugged the victims’ families and prosecutors. That’s a huge no-no when being a judge. Judges have to show neutrality at all times during a trial no matter what the circumstances are.
Did the people who were victims at the school get a fair trial and get to cross examine & question motives of the shooter, prior to them being murdered ? Did they get to show neutrality, in spite of the circumstances of the shooting ?
What an amazing person and judge. She was massively disrespected, But to step away from her profession so the victims parents didn’t have to be called as witnesses speaks volumes..Liz starts her own show next judge Judy… 😊
Anyone who thinks she was fantastic does not understand the role of a judge or has been watching too much Judge Judy. When she ordered a defense attorney to go to the back of the room like a misbehaving second grader the game was over.
umm glad she bounced back... she does NOT belong in the court system... It was easy to tell she didnt earn her way to the top... daddy bad some people off to get her that judgeship... obviously! She had no command of her court... It was like a kangaroo court... embarrassing and sad l...
I have the utmost respect for Former Judge Scherer. She handled a brutally tough case with respect, class and strength. I watched every single day and not once did she show “favoritism “! She dealt with a team of immature, unprofessional, extremely disrespectful and disgusting defense attorneys. The needed to be addressed, and she did so. In no way, shape and form is her change a step down! She now has the opportunity to work with her family and heal from the trauma she too has. God bless all the innocent, beautiful lives lost, the families, and Elizabeth Scherer.
She was awful. She is supposed to APPEAR impartial , even if she is not. She was in the public eye at the same time as the Judge for the Christmas parade debacle in Wisconsin. That judge made this Miami judge look like a law clerk.
Why does everything she do make me like her more. Her resigning to spare the family more pain is in itself one of the most respectful things I've seen of a human being.
I think you're a fantastic judge and I'm sorry this was a really rough case for you I'm an Equine Business Management Major at Johnson Wales University . You're just as good as judge Judy really l like you.🙏🐴💪🇺🇲🏆
I know judges are supposed to be impartial until they make their verdict, but it was refreshing to see some compassion. Her heart is too big to be cold and stoic.
I'm a trial lawyer. I would have been perfectly fine if Cruz got the death penalty if SHE was not on the bench. I don't see the dp as much of a deterrent as most of those animals expect their lives to end during the rampage anyways, but I digress...Her punishment was NOT about Cruz or the people he murdered. Justice is supposed to be blind. She didn't merely put her thumb on the scale. She stood on the scale like a bathroom scale and brought dumb bells with her. Rooting for an outcome, and cheering on biased refs is fine and dandy until it is YOU sitting at one of the tables in the courtroom and the judge has it out for you. It doesn't have to be a capital murder case. It could be about custody of your children, someone that injured you and is trying to escape liability, someone screwing you over in a contract, the government trying to put you in jail with out due process, anything. If judges like Liz Scherer are what the people want, we might as well adopt the North Korean or Iranian system of "justice". (Also, she would have lost decisively on her appeal. It was not about the families. If they liked her so much they would have gladly supported her appeal. She didn;t appeal because she acted inappropriately on numerous occasions. She was toast. The decision would have been made by lawyers, not commenters under You Tube videos)
Mrs. Scherer, you did your job as a judge. You helped make the justice system work for the people. Their support for you shoed faith in the system. Thank you!
I don't know if this judge was a good judge or a bad judge, but I _do_ know that the conduct oversight boards are a (bad) joke. They often target judges and lawyers for political reasons--not for improper conduct. Hell, dozens of judges in my cases and many more that have negatively impacted people in my nationwide network with their repugnant criminal behavior go untouched by these boards. It's completely backwards. Very Best Regards, Tom Scott Author ● Speaker ● World's Leading Expert on the Corrupt U.S. Legal System _Our American Injustice System_ _Stack the Legal Odds in Your Favor_
i know you have to walk a mile in someone else shoes but i think she let the defense get away with murder and she put the victims families through hell. i know she had the best most honest intentions but to me that is how things shook out.
love3x this woman! She is definitely going to reclaim her throne once again and prove everyone wrong how they shunned her from the judicial world. Stay strong YOUR HONORABLIZ! 💖
The other women didn’t like her because she’s pretty.. typical jealous women behavior.. I happen to think she’s a wonderful judge and has a good heart ❤
Sorry ladies that really has absolutely nothing to do with it and to even suggest something proves how narcissistic pretty women can be However the fact that she basically fails in a courtroom setting she cannot remain unbiased and that was clear to anybody that has basic Psychology 101 okay all right she's a danger in this field she does not know how to preside righteously so she is a danger to every defendant in this country and to our justice department that's why she was asked to step down it's not for everybody ladies and that's the truth of it it really has nothing to do with the fact that she's very pretty that's very narcissistic of you women to think that though it's not always about you it may be about the way you can structure mannerisms... that's for sure🤣💯💯💯💯💯 goodbye I could have told you she would have never made it after this one trial I could have told you all that
@@KourtneeMonroe because he's the client do you understand how the courtrooms work apparently you women do not my family is employed for the Department of Justice okay it's not about your feeling liberal ladies they're there to uphold the law that's all it's about once you start taking it out personally on the defendant that's when you cannot work in that environment anymore that's why she was asked to step down instead of being removed which is even more embarrassing some people just can't cut the mustard and you're not going to last too long in there💯👍🤣
I think she was a fantastic judge. The defense team was out of line and disrespectful in my opinion. The way they acted and spoke about some of the families was unacceptable. Turning that monster into a victim was absolutely disgusting. Good for you judge.
This Judge has NO BUSINESS being a Judge.I cringed everytime she was in the courtroom shouting at people, fighting with lawyers-EMOTIONAL Outbursts, finger pointing and just being too emotional.She should never have been allowed near the trial and it still leaves a bitter taste in my good mouth every time i see her
I'm glad she's gone and not on no bench anymore. Now. She can just be a little standardized ambulance Chaser, lawyer, and that's all she's good for She doesn't have the mental capacity to do. Judging and these high level trials. She's too emotional and she's to weak minded.
The female judge Mrs. Elizabeth Scherer has shown so much compassion for the victims relatives and even she gave an unforgettable example of humanity by not sentencing that monster to death! She never will wake up in the middle of the night becoming aware that she might have become guilty to announce a state sanctioned killing. There's no effect on capital punishment. The records show that the death penalty never ever lowered/decreased the crime rates in this nation. The society needs access for everybody to eduction. So people learn how to defend themselves with words instead of becoming physically violent to each other if an argument might occur. It's time to change the bill of rights according to the legal possession of owning and buying weapons wich are able to kill people. Only policemen and soldiers should be authorized to have and to use shotguns, firearms and whatsoever could finally kill people in a life threatening situation. And that's enough. God bless Mrs. Elizabeth Scherer! I wish her a long life and joy with her beloved ones and pleasure with her life! Stay healthy and stay the way you are! You made this world become a better one!
This is very interesting. Because despite lots of comments in her favour by others, both here and in previous videos during the trial, I also took the view that her conduct was noticeably biased towards the prosecution and therefore was in fact unprofessional. Very interesting indeed that the judicial conduct authority concluded the same. Sorry, but it was unprofessional. As a judge, you simply do not do things like hug the prosecution team. It’s a basic no no. How possibly can independence appear to be preserved when doing things like that? And I also saw her being very snappy with the defence on occasions, even when the defence had a point. I know it was an emotional and very sad case. But as a judge you have a duty to sit in the middle. You simply cannot decide to align yourself with either the prosecution or the defence. That is the mistake she made. Also very difficult to see how failing to challenge this could possibly help the families. Sounds to me like failing to challenge is a slam-dunk appeal point. You can rest assured that if she had any chance of challenging this given that she was a judge and comes from a large family of lawyers she would have definitely challenged it. She knows there was no proper challenge.
She is a very smart attorney assigned as a young judge to a heinous and senseless mass murder case. I am a retired attorney and I watched that trial live on a regular basis. I thought that she was fair and deliberate. Given the pressure, the extraordinarily long trial with all of the gruesome testimony, and unwarranted attacks, she did a remarkable job. The 17th Circuit lost an excellent judge. John Kelley
This Judge has NO BUSINESS being a Judge.I hated EVERY MOMENT SHE LOST HER MIND AND STARTED SHOUTING AT ALL LAWYERS like little children-I cringed everytime she was in the courtroom shouting at people, fighting with lawyers-EMOTIONAL Outbursts, finger pointing and just being too emotional.She should never have been allowed near the trial and it still leaves a bitter taste in my good mouth every time i see her
Ms judge wants to write and sell her book so she’s doing early press I was not a fan of hers when I saw her in trial, I guess she wants people to like her so she sells more books
I liked her. She was so poised and handled probably the hardest case any judge ever had to deal with very well. The defense team was just horrible. Hard to believe that they even passed the bar.
This Judge has NO BUSINESS being a Judge.I cringed everytime she was in the courtroom shouting at people, fighting with lawyers-EMOTIONAL Outbursts, finger pointing and just being too emotional.She should never have been allowed near the trial and it still leaves a bitter taste in my good mouth every time i see her
Hey ex judge babe They may be above the law and this world may be a disgusting place, and they may have stopped that fierce goodness in you. But they aint above me and God or the devil Amen
Good for her she will be fine she’s well off in daddy’s firm. I’m sure she has multiple properties, she has horses that lifestyle ain’t cheap plus offers for law commentating and I’m sure job offers elsewhere
She is an amazing judge anyone who gets her as a lawyer is lucky... what a smart family... she did amazing and shame on those horrible defense lawyer yuck no class from them
She was a disgrace. It’s possible that she caused jurors to be more sympathetic to that idiot defendant because she showed so much bias towards the prosecution.The only favorable thing I can say for her is that her hair and makeup were on point for Court TV everyday. There’s nothing wrong with showing sympathy to the victims. However, a rational judge invites them back to her chambers in private, not in public. .
I really enjoyed getting to know Judge Scherer a little better through watching these interviews. I think she is a lady of high principals.
She’s truly beautiful inside & out !! We need more judges like her !!!
You said that very well
This Judge has NO BUSINESS being a Judge.I cringed everytime she was in the courtroom shouting at people, fighting with lawyers-EMOTIONAL Outbursts, finger pointing and just being too emotional.She should never have been allowed near the trial and it still leaves a bitter taste in my good mouth every time i see her
@@Rasira2023🤖
No we don't. She can't even do the job of a Judge. If more judges were like her the legal system would be in trouble. A Judge's most important responsibility is to be impartial and she couldn't even do that.
I love hearing her speak! And the fact that she chose not to contest to prevent the families from going through another trial shows how much she cares. That case was a case like any other! Emotions were everywhere! Games were played during the trial! The disrespect was HIGH! She’s human and she handled the best way she could! The families were grateful for her and that’s all that matters.
It's Judge Hottie. 🥰😍
I heard that cellphone call she’s talking about and it’s as horrifying as she said it is. I was cleaning and had the trial on in the background. It played during the trial and I ran to turn it off. I had to sit and I couldn’t stop crying. I have ptsd and I promise you all those parents, students, victims, witnesses, etc. all went home and had panic attacks or meltdowns, or whatever. There’s no question about it.
This Judge has NO BUSINESS being a Judge.I cringed everytime she was in the courtroom shouting at people, fighting with lawyers-EMOTIONAL Outbursts, finger pointing and just being too emotional.She should never have been allowed near the trial and it still leaves a bitter taste in my good mouth every time i see her
@@Rasira2023 and what do you want me to do about it? Apparently she did just fine, the people who were investigated were on the defense. Idk but if lawyers were giggling and flipping people off when a child’s head was hanging off by skin I’d be mad too.
@@missspell4897I think ☝️is a 🤖. Same comment, just like copying and pasting in every other post.
@@Rasira2023No body gives a rats ass about your opinion here .
@@Rasira2023how many times are you going to comment that ?
The perpetrator is now setting precedent for others…you will get life and not death. There is no deterrent. Life in prison means nothing to these people…death is something else
seriously life in prison is worse than death
She managed to accomplish nothing less than a miracle given the gravity of horror that was at the core of this tragedy. She treated the families with utmost respect and empathy. The defense attorneys got what they asked for. They should have known better.
She got a raw deal. However, I'm sure she'll end up being a TV judge and have a great life after this.
Enough already!! Her behavior during the Cruz trial....UNPROFESSIONAL!! A danger to all fair proceedings to our justice department!! GOOD RIDDANCE! 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉She does not have what it takes to stay unbiased!!!!
AGREED! Thank you!
if the judge had treated the defense kinder cruz might have gotten the death penalty ?
He should have got the death penalty. The Judge should have not resigned at all. Why is she even resigning at all.
Special lady right there
A Male Judge would've been less emotional...
If looks and mannerisms defined attention seeking
No judge should favor one side over the other. Judges are supposed to be impartial. She is not and does not deserve to be on the bench.
oh so u could’ve been flipped off and laughed at by a school shooter and his attorney and felt no need to defend the victims? Just say that you didn’t watch the trial and stfu
Either she’s the youngest judge in history or has had lotsa work.
❤❤❤❤❤
She should not have resigned just because of 1 trail.
Brilliant with high morals. Extraordinary Anericans
She’s beautiful…and badass!
Esta jueza está muy famosa 😂😂😂
I think she did an incredible job during a very difficult and trying case. She’s also gorgeous.
Onlyfans?
Why has she resigned from being judge
She has had enough of the stress of being a judge that’s why
@@TheAnimalWolverine ok thanks. I just came across one of her latest interviews and she says it was her decision to step down from the bench even before the cruz trial was going on .
@@gdggggggno she resigned because she knew she was getting reprimanded
@@TheAnimalWolverinefalse
I respect the hell out of her for her decision. Those families have been through enough. 💗
This woman is a queen. Credit to her family, she was raised well.
I will support whatever she does!! She was an amazing judge and the defense showed zero respect for her!
She showed zero respect. She wasn't impartial or professional.
@@MathieuLLF you get what you give
@@alannashea6344 that's not how the law or court rooms work. If she can't control her emotions, she has no place being a Judge.
@@MathieuLLF well defense attorneys shouldn’t be flipping the judge off and disrespecting and disregarding the judge
@@alannashea6344 Agreed as well, but that was a sidenote. This judge showed unprofessionalism and wasn't impartial for much more than just that.
What an incredible woman❤ So much respect for her. I stand with you, Judge. Good luck in your new career.
I could have presided over that case. The defendant was clearly guilty.
@@jaymike3302 Okay.
She did Great!!!!!!!!! They shouldnt had done her that way, she helped the families get through this trail.
If she did so great, why did the hire a pellet court? Tell her your attitude towards the public. Defender's office was atrocious and unprofessional. And at this point you can either step down. Or you can be fired. So obviously she stepped down good judges. Don't step down when they get beat by a bunch of low level public defenders. She's just a spoiled little brat who didn't get her way on this one. And she thought Dylan Cruz was gonna have incompetent counsel and he didn't and she was mad about it. Not to mention the jurors couldn't stand the families. They were unlikable they didn't want Justice. They just wanted blood and the jury knew it. But I don't really think they liked the judge neither.
I absolutely love this judge! So real and authentic
And fine
No actually she got some more Botox in her lips she needs to calm down and learn how to practice law and no she's not real and authentic and that's what the problem is and that's why she was removed out of the Department of Justice because she is not authentic she does not have what it takes to stay unbiased
@@MaryHartman-ei9pvcalm down and add punctuation 😭
@omgrawr7161 yeah yeah I don't care about punctuation this is social media I could care less I'm not getting graded on it okay 🤣
Shut up! You just love what’s on her chest!
I watched the whole trial. Thank God justice was served. Love this woman so much. She has a big heart and really cared about the victims and their families.
Her heart isnt the only thing thats big.....IF you know what I mean
I thought Nick Cruz was going to get the death penalty. People have got the death penalty for a lot less than that.
Justice wasn’t served.
@@lisachlastawa5105 It pissed off a lot of people that three of the jurors voted to spare Cruz's life due to falling hook, line and sinker for the sob story put forth by the defense of how poor little Nikolas Cruz shouldn't be executed because of his lifelong history of mental health issues. Of course following this trial; Florida governor Ron DeSantis overruled the 2016 decision by the Florida Supreme Court that required a unanimous jury in Death Penalty cases and allowed for majority rule as a means of preventing so-called "activist jurors" from being able to lie their way onto the jury in a Death Penalty trial and allow monsters like Nikolas Cruz to get away with murder. Though you have people like Forensic psychiatrist Dr. Carole Lieberman who were singing high praises of the jurors who voted to spare Cruz's life and calling Judge Elizabeth Scherer a monstrous diva. Though I hope the Lifetime network never makes a movie on the Parkland tragedy out of respect for the families of the victims; I could easily see Judge Scherer being portrayed by either Kristin Davis (Charlotte on "Sex and the City") or Constance Marie (George Lopez's on-screen wife Angie on the George Lopez show.) I only stated that the Lifetime network would have made a movie on the Parkland tragedy as they have the ability to make "ripped from the headlines" true crime movies down to a science.
Justice was going to be served regardless. There was no way he was being found not guilty. The fact you wasted hours of your life on this side-show trial, speaks volumes.
The fact that she sacrificed giving up being a judge to not put the families through another trial is absolutely selfless and really is a testament to her character. She could have fought it and she probably (and rightfully) would have won in the end. I'm even more impressed with her now after watching this than I was from how she handled the trial.
The defense lawyers were a bunch of disgusting “ professionals” . She gave up her job to prevent the victim’s families from having to testify in yet another trial. Respect for her 👏👏👏
Lawyers have to defend the absolute worst of humanity. Take the good with the bad
Never blame lawyers. They are doing their civic duty... Remember John Adams represented the British soldiers who opened fired on civilians in the Boston Masacre.
Professionals no way not at all.
She resigned out of embarrassment. The judiciary was appalled at her behavior. She was so bad the FL Supreme Court recused her on another death penalty case. The other Judges wanted her gone.
@@Jackferrett6781 the lawyers are just public defenders making successful vigorous defense on the first hand, and absolutely vanquished the trial judge on the other hand
She wasn’t a good judge. She made a mockery of the justice system. A good judge has control of their court room, and their emotions. She has no business wearing a robe anyone that think she’s a good judge and that her behavior was appropriate as a judge is ignorant of law. Judges are a higher standard, It’s a good thing that you’re not judges. they toyed with her cuz they could. You do not get emotional. You keep your emotions out of it. She was so biased. I feel sorry for the victims and families. Yes the kid was a serial killer and a horrible human being. May God have mercy.
It is impossible for someone to be completely unbiased. We are human. I thought she handled it very well.
If a judge cannot be impartial, then that person should not be a judge. Yes, judges are human, but they must put aside their biases when they are on the bench. It's called being a Professional. Maybe she went to the wrong law school. I'm glad she is no longer on the bench. She doesn't have the temperance for it.
@@elektra3222 IT IS IMPOSSIBLE. I don’t care what you say. You are ALWAYS going to have an opinion. There is no way around it. That is why we have a jury and not one singular person deciding someone’s fate. This murderers lawyers were annoying AF and dealing with a matter as crucial as this one- no, she didn’t put up with any nonsense given the gravity of the matter. She did an excellent job.
Wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong basically this has nothing to do with you being human it has to do with you being professional you are not allowed to demonstrate bias towards the defendant basically made a mockery out of that courtroom and allowed parents to flip off the defendant you're not allowed to do that that is why she was given a choice to just resign would have been removed you cannot have judges like this in the Department of Justice it basically ruins the fair trial process and yes it is possible for someone to remain unbiased yes it is
@@Abcdefghijk920 you have no right to take out your feelings on the defendant is the violation of courtroom procedure and you will be removed as a judge what you can see that happened because she does not have what it takes and don't talk to me about what you know my brother is a district attorney I'm an ex law student this is why I had to quit because I do not have the temperament to go into a courtroom you better have the right attitude in order to do this job professionally and if you cannot do it you have to get out the game that is the reality
This Judge has NO BUSINESS being a Judge.I cringed everytime she was in the courtroom shouting at people, fighting with lawyers-EMOTIONAL Outbursts, finger pointing and just being too emotional.She should never have been allowed near the trial and it still leaves a bitter taste in my good mouth every time i see her
God bless this Woman! She helped put that monster in jail for the rest of his life. So thankful for her and I'm glad she was the judge in this case.
I watched the entire trial, and she was amazing! I have nothing but respect for her. Other judges could learn from her. She's a class act.
She's a feminist 💀
I could have presided over that case. The defendant was clearly guilty.
She is still amazing 😍
She was amazing if she wasn't a judge. As a judge she was awful.
She showed partiality when she hugged the victims’ families and prosecutors. That’s a huge no-no when being a judge. Judges have to show neutrality at all times during a trial no matter what the circumstances are.
"during the trial" but not after. When trial has concluded, isn't she free to show emotion per her own wishes ?
Did the people who were victims at the school get a fair trial and get to cross examine & question motives of the shooter, prior to them being murdered ? Did they get to show neutrality, in spite of the circumstances of the shooting ?
What an amazing person and judge. She was massively disrespected, But to step away from her profession so the victims parents didn’t have to be called as witnesses speaks volumes..Liz starts her own show next judge Judy… 😊
The judge that handled Darrell brooks case was way better at doing her job while remaining professional. Which this judge could learn from
Judge Elizabeth Scherer ♥ To me, she is forever THE Judge.
Esa mujer no me agrada, se le nota arrogante, prepotente, ademas ella no tuvo suficiente criterio para manejar el juicio de parkland.
The defense team was completely out of line and Scherer should not have been disciplined at all
So glad she's not a judge anymore. She belongs with her Daddy not in a court.
She’s a true warrior for justice
Why is there even a special about this silver spoon fed, spoiled 🤡? Who cares? Guess they ran out of real news to report.
Anyone who thinks she was fantastic does not understand the role of a judge or has been watching too much Judge Judy. When she ordered a defense attorney to go to the back of the room like a misbehaving second grader the game was over.
Ridiculous that anyone would have had any issues with her conduct. She was flawless. Please tell us **WHO** is/was behind this nonsense!!!
What a title?! There’s only opinions. The truth never changes. 🤦🏽♀️
She allowed the victims families to talk about the defense’s kids but got offended when the comparison was brought to her attention.
umm glad she bounced back... she does NOT belong in the court system...
It was easy to tell she didnt earn her way to the top... daddy bad some people off to get her that judgeship... obviously! She had no command of her court... It was like a kangaroo court... embarrassing and sad l...
I have the utmost respect for Former Judge Scherer. She handled a brutally tough case with respect, class and strength. I watched every single day and not once did she show “favoritism “! She dealt with a team of immature, unprofessional, extremely disrespectful and disgusting defense attorneys. The needed to be addressed, and she did so. In no way, shape and form is her change a step down! She now has the opportunity to work with her family and heal from the trauma she too has. God bless all the innocent, beautiful lives lost, the families, and Elizabeth Scherer.
She was awful. She is supposed to APPEAR impartial , even if she is not. She was in the public eye at the same time as the Judge for the Christmas parade debacle in Wisconsin. That judge made this Miami judge look like a law clerk.
agreed! obviously daddy paid her way to that judgeship
She should model
I LOVE THIS JUDGE! The fact that she took the families in consideration is so admirable! I wanna hug her 💕
Lol wtf... Who cares about what the judge thinks... This is a shitty 2020 interview
She is absolutely awesome! Amazing judge, best of the best. And shes so darn beautiful!
I wish there was more judges like her. Beautiful,smart ,fair ,outstanding! Those defense lawyers are disgusting, disgraceful,disrespectful!
Agreed 💯
Why does everything she do make me like her more. Her resigning to spare the family more pain is in itself one of the most respectful things I've seen of a human being.
I think you're a fantastic judge and I'm sorry this was a really rough case for you I'm an Equine Business Management Major at Johnson Wales University . You're just as good as judge Judy really l like you.🙏🐴💪🇺🇲🏆
She’s an amazing & strong woman! ❤
I know judges are supposed to be impartial until they make their verdict, but it was refreshing to see some compassion. Her heart is too big to be cold and stoic.
I'm a trial lawyer. I would have been perfectly fine if Cruz got the death penalty if SHE was not on the bench. I don't see the dp as much of a deterrent as most of those animals expect their lives to end during the rampage anyways, but I digress...Her punishment was NOT about Cruz or the people he murdered. Justice is supposed to be blind. She didn't merely put her thumb on the scale. She stood on the scale like a bathroom scale and brought dumb bells with her. Rooting for an outcome, and cheering on biased refs is fine and dandy until it is YOU sitting at one of the tables in the courtroom and the judge has it out for you. It doesn't have to be a capital murder case. It could be about custody of your children, someone that injured you and is trying to escape liability, someone screwing you over in a contract, the government trying to put you in jail with out due process, anything. If judges like Liz Scherer are what the people want, we might as well adopt the North Korean or Iranian system of "justice". (Also, she would have lost decisively on her appeal. It was not about the families. If they liked her so much they would have gladly supported her appeal. She didn;t appeal because she acted inappropriately on numerous occasions. She was toast. The decision would have been made by lawyers, not commenters under You Tube videos)
Mrs. Scherer, you did your job as a judge. You helped make the justice system work for the people. Their support for you shoed faith in the system. Thank you!
The learned Judge made a right decision. She is more relaxed and looks happy.
She beautiful horse you have i hope have wishes best
She’s an amazing judge
I would marry you ❤❤❤❤❤❤
As I suspected she got in her position without actual hard work
Amazing Judge! Standing with you!
I admire you.
Glad shes gone to a law firm. She was a terrible judge
Whats her OnlySimps?
The way you guys posted this interview is very confusing. You label this "part 3" yet this is only the second video you posted. So where's part 2?
I respect the judge,great woman
She hugged the DAs and victims while wearing her robe. The Supreme Court agreed that her conduct was inappropriate for a judge. Glad she resigned.
She was a phenomenal judge in this case!
I loved this judge, I respect her very much
I don't know if this judge was a good judge or a bad judge, but I _do_ know that the conduct oversight boards are a (bad) joke. They often target judges and lawyers for political reasons--not for improper conduct. Hell, dozens of judges in my cases and many more that have negatively impacted people in my nationwide network with their repugnant criminal behavior go untouched by these boards. It's completely backwards.
Very Best Regards,
Tom Scott
Author ● Speaker ● World's Leading Expert on the Corrupt U.S. Legal System
_Our American Injustice System_
_Stack the Legal Odds in Your Favor_
i know you have to walk a mile in someone else shoes but i think she let the defense get away with murder and she put the victims families through hell. i know she had the best most honest intentions but to me that is how things shook out.
She was not ready to do this interview at all. Let her remain at her daddies law firm and be condescending to folks there.
love3x this woman! She is definitely going to reclaim her throne once again and prove everyone wrong how they shunned her from the judicial world.
Stay strong YOUR HONORABLIZ! 💖
The other women didn’t like her because she’s pretty.. typical jealous women behavior.. I happen to think she’s a wonderful judge and has a good heart ❤
I think so. And she is empathetic.
Yup. That’s a huge part of it. How they could sit there and laugh with him is disgusting
Sorry ladies that really has absolutely nothing to do with it and to even suggest something proves how narcissistic pretty women can be However the fact that she basically fails in a courtroom setting she cannot remain unbiased and that was clear to anybody that has basic Psychology 101 okay all right she's a danger in this field she does not know how to preside righteously so she is a danger to every defendant in this country and to our justice department that's why she was asked to step down it's not for everybody ladies and that's the truth of it it really has nothing to do with the fact that she's very pretty that's very narcissistic of you women to think that though it's not always about you it may be about the way you can structure mannerisms... that's for sure🤣💯💯💯💯💯 goodbye I could have told you she would have never made it after this one trial I could have told you all that
@@KourtneeMonroe because he's the client do you understand how the courtrooms work apparently you women do not my family is employed for the Department of Justice okay it's not about your feeling liberal ladies they're there to uphold the law that's all it's about once you start taking it out personally on the defendant that's when you cannot work in that environment anymore that's why she was asked to step down instead of being removed which is even more embarrassing some people just can't cut the mustard and you're not going to last too long in there💯👍🤣
I think she was a fantastic judge. The defense team was out of line and disrespectful in my opinion. The way they acted and spoke about some of the families was unacceptable. Turning that monster into a victim was absolutely disgusting. Good for you judge.
She deserves to be back in the court room as a judge. She did a fantastic job!
This Judge has NO BUSINESS being a Judge.I cringed everytime she was in the courtroom shouting at people, fighting with lawyers-EMOTIONAL Outbursts, finger pointing and just being too emotional.She should never have been allowed near the trial and it still leaves a bitter taste in my good mouth every time i see her
@@Rasira2023100% MapleSyrup.
I'm glad she's gone and not on no bench anymore. Now. She can just be a little standardized ambulance Chaser, lawyer, and that's all she's good for She doesn't have the mental capacity to do. Judging and these high level trials. She's too emotional and she's to weak minded.
Not only was this woman completely out of line as a judge in that trial, she is ARROGANT as hell.
The female judge Mrs. Elizabeth Scherer has shown so much compassion for the victims relatives and even she gave an unforgettable example of humanity by not sentencing that monster to death! She never will wake up in the middle of the night becoming aware that she might have become guilty to announce a state sanctioned killing. There's no effect on capital punishment. The records show that the death penalty never ever lowered/decreased the crime rates in this nation. The society needs access for everybody to eduction. So people learn how to defend themselves with words instead of becoming physically violent to each other if an argument might occur. It's time to change the bill of rights according to the legal possession of owning and buying weapons wich are able to kill people. Only policemen and soldiers should be authorized to have and to use shotguns, firearms and whatsoever could finally kill people in a life threatening situation. And that's enough. God bless Mrs. Elizabeth Scherer! I wish her a long life and joy with her beloved ones and pleasure with her life! Stay healthy and stay the way you are! You made this world become a better one!
You are an amazing judge Scherer
This is very interesting.
Because despite lots of comments in her favour by others, both here and in previous videos during the trial, I also took the view that her conduct was noticeably biased towards the prosecution and therefore was in fact unprofessional.
Very interesting indeed that the judicial conduct authority concluded the same.
Sorry, but it was unprofessional. As a judge, you simply do not do things like hug the prosecution team. It’s a basic no no. How possibly can independence appear to be preserved when doing things like that? And I also saw her being very snappy with the defence on occasions, even when the defence had a point.
I know it was an emotional and very sad case. But as a judge you have a duty to sit in the middle. You simply cannot decide to align yourself with either the prosecution or the defence. That is the mistake she made.
Also very difficult to see how failing to challenge this could possibly help the families. Sounds to me like failing to challenge is a slam-dunk appeal point.
You can rest assured that if she had any chance of challenging this given that she was a judge and comes from a large family of lawyers she would have definitely challenged it.
She knows there was no proper challenge.
some people are made honest and wholesome and she is all that and more! Good luck all the future opportunities.
Hmm....I bet that a@#&ole Weeks had something to do with someone saying that Cherer wasn't being "fair". I thought Cherer was terrific.
She is a very smart attorney assigned as a young judge to a heinous and senseless mass murder case. I am a retired attorney and I watched that trial live on a regular basis. I thought that she was fair and deliberate. Given the pressure, the extraordinarily long trial with all of the gruesome testimony, and unwarranted attacks, she did a remarkable job. The 17th Circuit lost an excellent judge. John Kelley
I respect the fck out of her for her decision. Those families have been through enough. 💗
❤❤❤ what a brave woman ❤❤❤
This Judge has NO BUSINESS being a Judge.I hated EVERY MOMENT SHE LOST HER MIND AND STARTED SHOUTING AT ALL LAWYERS like little children-I cringed everytime she was in the courtroom shouting at people, fighting with lawyers-EMOTIONAL Outbursts, finger pointing and just being too emotional.She should never have been allowed near the trial and it still leaves a bitter taste in my good mouth every time i see her
😢😢😢😢😢😢
@@timothyluedders1244 whats up? dont you agree with me that she was biased
You guys are really milking this huh?
Instead of one 30 minute video, you are dragging it out over three < 10min videos.
Also, this says Part 3, but it’s the second video posted to the TH-cam channel.
Ms judge wants to write and sell her book so she’s doing early press
I was not a fan of hers when I saw her in trial, I guess she wants people to like her so she sells more books
I liked her. She was so poised and handled probably the hardest case any judge ever had to deal with very well. The defense team was just horrible. Hard to believe that they even passed the bar.
This Judge has NO BUSINESS being a Judge.I cringed everytime she was in the courtroom shouting at people, fighting with lawyers-EMOTIONAL Outbursts, finger pointing and just being too emotional.She should never have been allowed near the trial and it still leaves a bitter taste in my good mouth every time i see her
@@Rasira2023🤖
Hey ex judge babe
They may be above the law and this world may be a disgusting place, and they may have stopped that fierce goodness in you.
But they aint above me and God or the devil
Amen
What a sick, twisted world we live in, but the lawyers that wanted her removed can put the middle finger up in court and get away with it !!!
Good for her she will be fine she’s well off in daddy’s firm. I’m sure she has multiple properties, she has horses that lifestyle ain’t cheap plus offers for law commentating and I’m sure job offers elsewhere
She is an amazing judge anyone who gets her as a lawyer is lucky... what a smart family... she did amazing and shame on those horrible defense lawyer yuck no class from them
She was a disgrace. It’s possible that she caused jurors to be more sympathetic to that idiot defendant because she showed so much bias towards the prosecution.The only favorable thing I can say for her is that her hair and makeup were on point for Court TV everyday.
There’s nothing wrong with showing sympathy to the victims. However, a rational judge invites them back to her chambers in private, not in public.
.