@@gaminglam1519 I mean yeah you could buy a gaming computer and will be worth it but if a company wants a logo or someone with a job that needs a logo I dont think they'll want a gaming computer.
Agreed, that P is too similar, especially when you’re pairing it with red. And the 4th one seems too close to Adidas for me or any other logo you’d find in a sporting goods store. I’d be afraid it wouldn’t stand out enough.
There are plenty of logos like this. I’m not a full pro but it looks like a guy just used a free font, which isn’t even very good fit. Even if that isn’t the case, it doesn’t matter. Don’t like it one bit.
Will! Marcus here. It was so great working with you - thank you for the kind feedback, and so interesting to see how others have interpreted the brief! After working for many years within other companies or from word of mouth, it took a leap to get my own solo career (Wadsworth Branding) up and running, so to get your message right at the start of that journey was such a great boost, and I really appreciated it. To those asking about the low rates - as I get more clients, feedback and trust, I gradually raise my rates - this was just to kick off and make new connections, which works really well. Thanks again for opportunities like these, Will. Makes a big difference for us out there!
Thank you for bringing up embroidery! My parents used to run a shop and you’d be surprised by the amount of people that think machine embroidery is just like screen printing. It’s not black magic. No matter how much you try, you cannot make a tiny star look like a tiny star, it’s gonna look like a really sad circle lol
I could totally see Marcus' labyrinth O alone on a TON of merch. It's mysterious enough that people would see it and go "what is that logo I'm seeing everywhere???" knowing and owning something with it on there would feel like being part of a club. Plus he's right, you could be subtle with it and just put it on the buttons. Instant classic.
1:03 it’s also a downturned ‘e’ that is an irrelevant symbol baked in 5:43 is cool. You should read what he’s written is explains why it’s a maze, it’s pretty clever. 9:37 it’s made of ‘P’ and ‘T’ and I think it’s a pencil (looks like a pencil tip which refers to drawing process crucial to prototyping perhaps) the plain version is too close to PinTerest 9:53 based on the write up, I’d choose the labyrinth
Marcus designed the branding / logo for our company! He was amazing to work with! So knowledgeable. I love the logo he designed for this video. It’s worth pausing the video and reading the reasoning behind his logo design! It’s all the extras and explanations that come with his logo designs that made him the best choice for us. Highly recommend! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Normally when a Designer submits 3 logo options, the first one is the better one cause that's definitely the one they spent more time on... the other two are just for professionalism and to confuse the client a bit.
Typeface designer here. No, the second one is a custom lettering, not a font. The connecting t’s give away which is pretty hard to do in fonts. Also look at her other works! The quality of Bézier curves is the best among the crowd in the video.
Not sure if you mentioned it in the vid, but I love that the rocket ship one isn't just the P but also the T. Having both the P & the T form a rocket ship is very clever, I think. Probably my favorite from this lot.
Retired designer here (35 years experience) -- you said all the things I would. Great video. Teaches others what to look for and how to represent. Nice talent Marcus and Arundaskm!
Maze logo looks awesome. It has deep meaning which is really important for marketing. Besides of that, having a symmetric shape it has more ways to be used than the last logo (which is also not bad by the way).
Honestly this speaks to how flooded the logo market is with people who lack creativity and only work from pages like fiverr. You got a whole bunch of slightly different looking "P"
I definitely prefer the last one. There's some kind of cleanliness and simplicity to it that reminds me of Burton, yet it's still very original. Love it, he/she should definitely charge more.
The longer you look at the last one the better it gets ❤️ I love how the icon is just a stylish P, it also looks like a tilted rocket (I LOVE THAT) it's super clean and minimal 10/10 The Labyrinth is also a 9.8/10 but I like this better
If you didn't already know the business name, the 3rd logo by Marcus makes it look like it's PROT TYPE with an icon separating the words. Still, this one could be the best of the bunch.
I still haven't gone to college to learn how to charge logos and all that but I've talked to graphic designers. I am impressed on how much you can make by a really simple logo. Of course it's only the looks that is simple,the process I believe is not.
I think Marcus's Logo design was my choice. He delivered not just the brand identity with the logo, but lead you through the design almost like a story, so it connects way more.
Surprised you liked the maze logo so much. A previous point you made was that the icon needs to look good when sized down. We didn't get to see or hear your thoughts on that aspect for that particular design.
I love these videos and seeing how different people handle the same breif. Hope you make more of them. It'd be cool if you collabed with TH-camr designers and did the same thing, each creating a logo using the same breif. Also, anyone know what the font was on the last logo?
This was great! Very interesting designs! The last one looks awesome, wasn't too sure about the triangle shape at the bottom left, but it makes it look more balanced actually!
Great content. The thing I liked you haven't hired someone doing logo for 5$ and then complaint about their creative skills. I've seen people hiring web developers for 5$, asking them to do custom code and then complaining about their coding skills. Thumbs up man 👍👍👍
They were all great, but the two that really stood out to me are Marcus, the labyrinth design I would wear that. Arun looked like a skater brand logo. Very interesting.
The logo by Marcus is a cool idea, but I can't help but read it as 'Prot Type' rather than as Prototype. For that reason I definitely think the last one (which looks like a comet to me) is the best.
Really liked the work and presentation of Marcus and Arun's submissions. Strong workdmarks and iconography. Also appreciate the how Arun worked the 'T' into the logo too
The prototype one was so dope. I think those they missed the opportunity to make the maze a P with the entry space (the center of the logo). But maybe it wouldn't have worked. Need to see it irl
Arund - a great job! Clean and primitive strength. Does not simple have the P in the logo, but is composed of the 3 letters that are duplicated in the brand name ie x2 P/T/0)
Just made a seller account on fiverr because of your video, hope I will get some clients soon. Got a lot of inspiration on how to present a logo package.
great discussion and great reveiwing, great accent. Plus i really like the maze once though the rocket was also good and I can see infinity symbol in it also which was amazing but still maze one was classy.
It would be cool if you designed a logo along with other logo designers designing the same logo but remain anonymous and have us vote on what we prefer.
how did you not mentioned that one of the logos in icon mode is just like Pinterest? I wouldn't pay a dime for a logo that looks like another, no maqtte rhow well it's presented, much less 450$
The problem with the last logo is that it clearly has a number 2 in the icon. However, if your company is called prototype, you really want people to think you are doing things before others.
How are these mockups made? I've seen hats, posters and even walls painted with fictional logos. But how do you these things? Is there a great tool where you can paste your logo or is this extensively created in photoshop?
5:38 one is so clean like holy sh*t. It is just so god damn clean. Only problem I see with it is that the maze O is too big, maybe if it was just a bit smaller or the same size as the letters then it would be perfect.
The $60 was hands down the best in terms of value. The logo itself is amazing and while I prefer the $160 more, the fact that it’s $100 more doesn’t make it as worth it.
Hope you guys enjoy the second video! If you did enjoy it consider subscribing to the channel for more videos all about graphic design and creativity!
You deserve more subscribers lad❤
Will how to work with you
Will you should make merch with these designs I feel like a lot of people would buy them and you could also get some use out of the logos
Place order on my gig 😂
Though u have alot of bucks Place order on my gig please ☺️😊😂😂
Should've hired the $135 guy again, just so we'd see his work one more time
NOW HE IS THE "FROM $300 GUY"
$1.300 now
@@mauriciorodrix good for him, he is finally charging what he is worth.
@@gaminglam1519 A logo is way more important and expensive than you think 1300$ is nothing.
@@gaminglam1519 I mean yeah you could buy a gaming computer and will be worth it but if a company wants a logo or someone with a job that needs a logo I dont think they'll want a gaming computer.
The second one kind of looks like Pinterest...like a lot.
Agreed, that P is too similar, especially when you’re pairing it with red. And the 4th one seems too close to Adidas for me or any other logo you’d find in a sporting goods store. I’d be afraid it wouldn’t stand out enough.
@@BriannaTerese I thought it looked somewhat familiar but I really couldn't place it. But yes it really does.
i dont like script logo it looks like just a tshirt print
There are plenty of logos like this. I’m not a full pro but it looks like a guy just used a free font, which isn’t even very good fit. Even if that isn’t the case, it doesn’t matter. Don’t like it one bit.
@@Siikapelle Yess, it is clearly free font that u can find even in playstore free app
Can you put all designs in 1 shot in the end of the video with a price, so we can see the difference? Would be nice to compare 👀
Will! Marcus here. It was so great working with you - thank you for the kind feedback, and so interesting to see how others have interpreted the brief!
After working for many years within other companies or from word of mouth, it took a leap to get my own solo career (Wadsworth Branding) up and running, so to get your message right at the start of that journey was such a great boost, and I really appreciated it. To those asking about the low rates - as I get more clients, feedback and trust, I gradually raise my rates - this was just to kick off and make new connections, which works really well.
Thanks again for opportunities like these, Will. Makes a big difference for us out there!
i loved ur logo so much!!
Great Work Marcus. Can you share some tips on getting my first fiverr gig? I haven’t had any luck trying to sell on that platform.
I reaaally love your logo!
By far the best logo from the five imo. I loved the maze O that can be used as a logo on its own.
Amazing logo 👏
The second one cost $450, and is literally just a font...
You usually pay designers not for the complexity or for "hardwork", but for expertise and experience.
I will say though...it's a nice font and would work well with an apparel product.
Pr0t0type
There yah go. Imma charge only $200
@@sevensolaris the 60$ is better, isn't it?
i mean, 450$ just for fonts only
and COPYCAT of Pinerest Logo lmao
Not necessarily, he could have draw the letters, I don't think we can say anything before we know
Bro you payed someone $450 to type ProtoType in a coop font
So infuriating
Amen.
And?
@@MM-MLT I would not even pay someone a dollar to do that, I could do that in a minute
@@ziphah2810 it’s not how fast you can make it. Take a look at the Nike logo. How long does that take to make?
Thank you for bringing up embroidery! My parents used to run a shop and you’d be surprised by the amount of people that think machine embroidery is just like screen printing. It’s not black magic. No matter how much you try, you cannot make a tiny star look like a tiny star, it’s gonna look like a really sad circle lol
I feel you bro, trust me I feel you, we're not in the same industry but struggling the same 😂
I could totally see Marcus' labyrinth O alone on a TON of merch. It's mysterious enough that people would see it and go "what is that logo I'm seeing everywhere???" knowing and owning something with it on there would feel like being part of a club. Plus he's right, you could be subtle with it and just put it on the buttons. Instant classic.
the $135 guy from part 1 is still the best of them all.
hahahaha
Me, who has absolutely no knowledge about logo design: "Hmmm yes, symbol."
1:03 it’s also a downturned ‘e’ that is an irrelevant symbol baked in
5:43 is cool. You should read what he’s written is explains why it’s a maze, it’s pretty clever.
9:37 it’s made of ‘P’ and ‘T’ and I think it’s a pencil (looks like a pencil tip which refers to drawing process crucial to prototyping perhaps) the plain version is too close to PinTerest
9:53 based on the write up, I’d choose the labyrinth
The logo based on the maze and the last one was great.
Marcus designed the branding / logo for our company! He was amazing to work with! So knowledgeable. I love the logo he designed for this video. It’s worth pausing the video and reading the reasoning behind his logo design! It’s all the extras and explanations that come with his logo designs that made him the best choice for us. Highly recommend! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Well dayum
Normally when a Designer submits 3 logo options, the first one is the better one cause that's definitely the one they spent more time on... the other two are just for professionalism and to confuse the client a bit.
More time spent is not equal to more quality
Wow. The third one is insanely good. As soon as I saw that maze, I had to finish it.
The last one is awesome too! Very chic.
Fatima is the name of a girl, not a boy, hahahahhhhh
A lot of love from Pakistan.
Apologies! :')
Fatima for the win
my grandmas name :)
Typeface designer here. No, the second one is a custom lettering, not a font. The connecting t’s give away which is pretty hard to do in fonts. Also look at her other works! The quality of Bézier curves is the best among the crowd in the video.
Not sure if you mentioned it in the vid, but I love that the rocket ship one isn't just the P but also the T. Having both the P & the T form a rocket ship is very clever, I think. Probably my favorite from this lot.
imagine paying 450 to get the pinterest logo
Retired designer here (35 years experience) -- you said all the things I would. Great video. Teaches others what to look for and how to represent. Nice talent Marcus and Arundaskm!
5:38 is my favorite.
Same! As soon as I saw that maze, I had to finish it.
i liked the reaction
After mindspace, prototype amazing video and amazing series of logo designing.
I'm glad you're enjoying it!
The P and the T merged logo that also looks like a rocket is genius, love it.
Maze logo looks awesome. It has deep meaning which is really important for marketing. Besides of that, having a symmetric shape it has more ways to be used than the last logo (which is also not bad by the way).
It looks like the black sun logo
@@eminkirac4712 wow it really does
That rocket guy is spot on.
What I've learned from this video is that I'm better at designing logos than I thought and that I'm totally not charging enough
Yep. Shocking how they charge $160 for a copy of the Pinterest logo😂
I think they all did a good job. Submit a logo for review to me and I'll critique. ;)
the maze one was the best one in my opinion, he did his research, the icon is so simple yet so complicated and it would look like an iconic logo.
the one with the maze is just amazing! Too bad it's not a real company
Who needs a monthly pay to skillshare where there are amazing channels like this
Yassshhh👍👍👍
Indeed Wills channel is great !!!!
Now I'm scared if my future clients check for anchor points, I'll have to start cleaning up a bit more haha...
Honestly this speaks to how flooded the logo market is with people who lack creativity and only work from pages like fiverr. You got a whole bunch of slightly different looking "P"
I definitely prefer the last one. There's some kind of cleanliness and simplicity to it that reminds me of Burton, yet it's still very original. Love it, he/she should definitely charge more.
I love these. You should do your own “The Apprentice” style reality show centered around design!
The longer you look at the last one the better it gets ❤️
I love how the icon is just a stylish P, it also looks like a tilted rocket (I LOVE THAT) it's super clean and minimal
10/10
The Labyrinth is also a 9.8/10 but I like this better
Not just a stylish P... Also a hidden T which nobody seemed to notice 😉
@@garywalsh7289 I see it now ;)
@@garywalsh7289 thank you, was looking for this comment. The T makes it so much better
If you didn't already know the business name, the 3rd logo by Marcus makes it look like it's PROT TYPE with an icon separating the words. Still, this one could be the best of the bunch.
I still haven't gone to college to learn how to charge logos and all that but I've talked to graphic designers. I am impressed on how much you can make by a really simple logo. Of course it's only the looks that is simple,the process I believe is not.
I think Marcus's Logo design was my choice. He delivered not just the brand identity with the logo, but lead you through the design almost like a story, so it connects way more.
Surprised you liked the maze logo so much. A previous point you made was that the icon needs to look good when sized down. We didn't get to see or hear your thoughts on that aspect for that particular design.
The rocket one was definitely the best. The p and the t making a rocket is incredibly clever and unique but still very simplistic
Marcus logo is my fav..
Not only presenting a logo, but also a brand-guide
the second guy charged you $435 for something that probably took him 10 minutes
This was great, Will. I learned alot about showcasing for the client. I think this helps sell and minimize the back and forth.
I really like the one Marcus did with that greekish circle symbol I really would of liked to see what you would have done for this.
Man paid 450 dollars for someone to type prototype in a font and slap it on anything he can find.
I love these videos and seeing how different people handle the same breif. Hope you make more of them. It'd be cool if you collabed with TH-camr designers and did the same thing, each creating a logo using the same breif.
Also, anyone know what the font was on the last logo?
Great suggestion!
Probably Trueno
I like how this video makes me happier than I was before.
Will: -I'm probably the worst client out there
Me: *who always interacts with people who doesn't know what they want* 🗿🗿🗿
This was great! Very interesting designs! The last one looks awesome, wasn't too sure about the triangle shape at the bottom left, but it makes it look more balanced actually!
BBC CT h GM Mr
The third one was cool. can be a streetwear brand. I can wear their Logo anytime. ahahahhhh
Great content.
The thing I liked you haven't hired someone doing logo for 5$ and then complaint about their creative skills.
I've seen people hiring web developers for 5$, asking them to do custom code and then complaining about their coding skills.
Thumbs up man 👍👍👍
I'm in class but I took a little time to see the new video😎
Make sure you do your work though! hahaha :)
@@willpatersondesign xd yeah😅
This video motivated me to create more and more design, really excited to learn
The last one looked an ice cream cone and I couldn’t unsee it. My favorite was definitely Marcus with the maze.
Not gonna lie.
You outfit is making you look handsome😳
They were all great, but the two that really stood out to me are Marcus, the labyrinth design I would wear that. Arun looked like a skater brand logo. Very interesting.
Marcus one is awesome, love it! The last one as well, wow.
People around the world is watching your content for their knowledge. Language should not be barrier. so make it simple to understand. Thank you. 🤗
Banger of a video mate - Fiverr videos are weirdly so enjoyable to watch!
Legend!
The second guy just made a mockery of the design challenge 😂.
Just typed it and sent it 😂
I think the first was meant to look like the paragraph symbols for Microsoft word as well. It worked really well with the tagline
You should do a king of the mountain style video where the $135 guy is the champion that goes against everyone until he gets knocked off.
1:35 i thought you were gonna say it looks like a swastika
The logo by Marcus is a cool idea, but I can't help but read it as 'Prot Type' rather than as Prototype. For that reason I definitely think the last one (which looks like a comet to me) is the best.
That second one, the P alone looks exactly like the pinterest logo.
Really liked the work and presentation of Marcus and Arun's submissions. Strong workdmarks and iconography. Also appreciate the how Arun worked the 'T' into the logo too
Well I didn't think you weren't going to notice it you weren't going to notice but the 160 one had a "p" AND a "t"
Before i watch till the end, i like the vibe of your studio...
Thank you! I'm thinking about changing it up a little bit :).
@@willpatersondesign Hey, maybe in the next video, i suggesting that you are the one who gonna be creating fiverr account then making logo.
Best series on youtube!
Thank you! :)
The prototype one was so dope. I think those they missed the opportunity to make the maze a P with the entry space (the center of the logo).
But maybe it wouldn't have worked. Need to see it irl
Marcus's and Arun's logo were the best!
Arund - a great job! Clean and primitive strength. Does not simple have the P in the logo, but is composed of the 3 letters that are duplicated in the brand name ie x2 P/T/0)
07:45 logo looks like logo right next to f1 site logo, very similar so not at all original. F1 site has has that logo
Just made a seller account on fiverr because of your video, hope I will get some clients soon. Got a lot of inspiration on how to present a logo package.
The last logo (that looks like a rocket), doesn't only have P in there, but also the T (the stem of the P with the horizontal line crossing it)
Marcus killed it, really cool. I think the one for $450 was very unoriginal and not creative. The most expensive isn't always the best option
Mock ups area great way to showcase your logo. Simple yet iconic logos always go over well with clients
The last one also looks a bit like the top of a cloth hanger, so top notch design IMO
The one at 6:50 reminds me alot of the ESprit logo.
great discussion and great reveiwing, great accent. Plus i really like the maze once though the rocket was also good and I can see infinity symbol in it also which was amazing but still maze one was classy.
Ehhh…. Might just be me but that graphic empire’s second logo hits me with a swastika feel. 😬
Yes man thank you for this video!
It would be cool if you designed a logo along with other logo designers designing the same logo but remain anonymous and have us vote on what we prefer.
As soon as I see the second logo, first thing came to my mind was: "Hey, it's Deep Purple logo."
These guys are amazing!!!💯
The third one is inspired by Versace Logo?
the $260 one looked like Guilty Spark, all of them were done really well though!
Let's play a game! Name that typeface on the last seller! 😃
My guess is Eastman Standard Extrabold
how did you not mentioned that one of the logos in icon mode is just like Pinterest? I wouldn't pay a dime for a logo that looks like another, no maqtte rhow well it's presented, much less 450$
The problem with the last logo is that it clearly has a number 2 in the icon. However, if your company is called prototype, you really want people to think you are doing things before others.
How are these mockups made? I've seen hats, posters and even walls painted with fictional logos. But how do you these things? Is there a great tool where you can paste your logo or is this extensively created in photoshop?
This is fun! And I love the Marcus’s one the best. Really iconic!
Again an enjoyable video and the flock of ideas. Thanks!
5:38 one is so clean like holy sh*t. It is just so god damn clean. Only problem I see with it is that the maze O is too big, maybe if it was just a bit smaller or the same size as the letters then it would be perfect.
I love you Will Paterson!!! I’m learning so much from you!!!! TY!!
These videos are pretty cool! I liked the last logo as well. It was different!
Glad you liked it!
The $60 was hands down the best in terms of value. The logo itself is amazing and while I prefer the $160 more, the fact that it’s $100 more doesn’t make it as worth it.
I really like the first logo. You have hidden first and last letter of the brand name in tho whole logo. It is kinda genius.
the third one looks very similar to VSCO
Love will patersons videos, Ive learned soo much from their videos.