Hypothetical perpetual motion machines, part2 , movimiento perpetuo
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ต.ค. 2024
- When people stop inventing perpetual motion machines, the decline of civilization will come.
5 workable models of Perpetual motion machines Ideas
Watch Part 1 HD Remake:
• Perpetuum Mobile Máqu...
パーペチュアルモーションマシン
#veproject1
#perpetualmotionmachine
"The most difficult part of designing a "Perpetual Motion Machine, is deciding where to hide the batteries."
Haha
The "designers" don't make it too complicated. In 90% of cases they use the base. I doubt that a thick wooden plate is necessary to support 4 rods and 2 bearings🤣
JAJAJAJ
The only real perpetual motion machine in this video is the comment section...and eventually friction will stop this one too.
hahahahhahahahahahahahahhahha you got it ;)
but if you could make some of this machines floating between 2 magnets in a container with no air but only Vacum then I belive infinite or really long motion could be achieved
no there will still be friction on the rotation axe
The magnets also lose power over time. There is nothing perpetual.
lmao
Read what is in the description link before judging!
You will find this: "Perpetual motion, although impossible to produce, has fascinated both inventors and the general public for hundreds of years."
"Perpetual Motion Machines" do not generate energy. They are just very efficient at transferring very little force into a lot of motion. Any attempt to havest that energy or even rubbing your hand against it, will reveal that there is very little energy powering these devices to begin with, in fact, slightly less energy than it took to start it.
I don't understand what do you mean by putting quote marks?
+Mārtiņš Rozenbergs True Perpetual Motion Machines do not exist. Even the most well made ones will eventually slow down and stop due to friction and other factors if they do not have additional outside energy put in to sustain it.
Think of a pocket watch, taking a few seconds to wind it and it will run a very complicated and precise machine running all day. However, the next day it needs to be wound again, or it'll eventually slow down and die. Same idea.
A true perpetual motion machine would be wound once and would be able to sustain itself without being touched or having a batter or even taking in solar energy or being moved to self wind.
Prolly meant scare-quotes around 'perpetual'.
My grandfather built a basic PMM when I was a kid. It was just a basic unbalanced wheel design. He knew perpetual motion could never happen, but he thought the machines were neat. Well, he spun it, and it just kept going. We eventually went upstairs and had some dinner, and later on went to bed. The next morning, we went down into the basement, and the thing was still spinning. We all knew it was impossible, but there it was. Three days later, still going. So on the fourth day, we went downstairs, and it had finally stopped. It turned out that the unicorn we kept in the basement got loose and bumped into it, causing it to slow, and finally stop. Makes you wonder how much longer it could have kept going. True story.
skeeter197140, Thanks for the laugh.
The first one might be my favourite design I've seen. It does a great job of showing where the free energy is supposed to be coming from, while hiding the energy sink.
2nd one has a similar, visually persuasive system for seeming to whack each arm into continued/continual motion.
Great hoaxes of perpetual motion machines. It's just a shame they aren't actually running without external energy source.
Tom Hoehler along with super upscaled models to drive a generator and power a house
Do you not consider gravity to be a source of energy?
Tom Hoehler
Explain how satellites orbit earth.
Tom Hoehler
I know how it works. I was making a point. Hilarious that you responded in such a foolish way.
Rasberry Jam Even though you know how, for the record for all comment readers, it's not possible to take energy from those because they only orbit in low-friction environments, If there was more than a tiny number of particles in space, they would crash very quickly.
Too bad friction is a thing lol.
"Perpetual motion" my ass.
the freeman said it, therefore it must be true! and where's your next game! it's been like 12 years man!
mrtannzr
Don't tell GabeN you saw me here, that may delay the game another century.
Gordon Freeman your secret is safe with me!
+mrtannzr me too ;-)
hl4 confirmed
My favorite is the carousel. I love how the weight that is supposedly keeping it moving falls behind the arm and gets whipped forward again.
this guy:
i have a perpetual motion machine
friction:
i'm about to end this man whole career
The fact that it keeps moving is fine. If you tried to take energy from it it'd stop. It's just an efficient machine that will stop eventually. Perpetual is impressive but not valuable.
+William N Finally someone with some sense!! =)
+William N I still have trouble with the fact that the title includes the word "perpetual" in it. It is by no means perpetual, as the definition of such means NEVER ending, not almost. I know you already know this, but the title still irks me.
+William N I still have trouble with the fact that the title includes the word "perpetual" in it. It is by no means perpetual, as the definition of such means NEVER ending, not almost. I know you already know this, but the title still irks me.
lonewolf333 True. Motion machines isn't good click bait though.
ever notice how all of these are sitting on or connected to some kind of box? never is everything open to public scrutiny. thats because 100% of "perpetual motion" machines are bullshit
Ok, that first one was honestly hilarious. It's always interesting to see something so jerky turn so smoothly. I wonder why that is? . . .
Cool desk toy ideas. Great craftsmanship and interesting contraptions regardless.
+eltonq See, I LIKE your comment: healthy, non-bantering, honest and yeah, would love all of these in my home somewhere =)
+eltonq *I WOULD LOVE A "PERPETUAL MOTION" DESK TOY!*
Take my money! Please!
+eltonq How would you get power to the toy besides drilling a hole in the bottom of your desk and mounting the motors underneath it?
I'm fully aware these are all motor or pump driven :)
Roughrider Gatlinghammer
The few that I'm interested in wouldn't have to be powered for my pleasing. They last minutes on their own after you first "play" with it hence the term "toy" for me. It would be something on my desk/tables to fiddle with.
These may not be perpetual motion machines, but goddamn if they aren't cool mechanisms to look at. As a desk toy, I mean.
motor driven*
porras are you have the stupid
He literally said it wasn’t actually perpetual he was just saying it would be a nice office toy
this man would think that if two people were falling and push eachothers hands down at the same time they would go up
Perpetual Trolling Machines.
8900 people liked a fake video
lol
Omg your here
+Rulof Maker Che grande che sei! ahah
+Rulof Maker rudy, you couldn`t come up with these, so, you heckle. small mind.
+Rulof Maker rudy, you couldn`t come up with these, so, you heckle. small mind.
Of course those are driven. ;-) Well done presentation! Very nice workmanship on those models, IMHO. I most especially liked the last one shown; very clever. Also, nice choice of tune. Can you name the band and song?
Thank you much.
+glasstronic Darker Thoughts Silent Partner
Leonardo Victor
Thank you again. :-)
Far The Days Come - Letter Box
Love the carousel setup at the end, very cool. Nice work man.
Perpetual motion exists my finger perpetually moves to the next perpetual motion video
love these ,trying to figure out where the electric motor is hidden LOL
2:50
Look at the shadow - engine detected
bro its representing how its SUPPOSED to work, its obvious that its fake
Cool video.
Though I'm a bit ignorant on the subject, isn't perpetual motion supposed to be impossible? Sure, most of these machines can run for awhile, but will eventually halt due to external conditions, right? Give most of these (including your Part 1 video) a couple hours and they may stop functioning.
Bah, impressive and interesting no less.
+SlamifiedBuddafied i cant say all, but most of them are being runt by an egine of some sort,
for example on part 1, the blue water one, it says that the weight of the water pushes it down, but water pressure varies only on height, so it must have some kind of pump, probably in that black brace that secures the pipe to the table
+Explore&ShootTV If you look closely, similar observations to the one you wrote are valid for almost all braces you see in the vid. The shots are meticulously taken so that the source of energy is hidden, in most cases (if not in all).
There is even a screw that starts and stops moving at some point, which is probably associated with a torque given by a motor. But those are nice toys to fool people.
VeteranVandal and they must have given a load of hoursn to make, and they are well made
Explore&ShootTV
I have to admit that they are well made - and will create a good conversation topic (but not energy), if not anything else.
+Explore&ShootTV It must. You can even see air bubbles shooting through the water at first. Plus the delay as the pump fills. That water should have gone through the tube instantly. No doubt camera angles hiding the giveaways.
Although these are fake, look nice :P
Though I'm already know it is impossible,but just can't stop watching
If people actually bothered to go onto his site, he actually says himself that these are battery/other energy source powered and that he only made them to show the concept of these machines if they were to work.
This is what unicorns would look like, if they actually existed.
Всё гениальное просто!!!
Оказывается надо просто два зубчатых колеса соединить цепью, подтолкнуть и каждое колесо будет вращать другое. Почему мой велосипед не едет сам? ))
Гравитация это тоже источник энергии, но он всего 9,8G, следовательно нужно строить массивные огромные шестерёнки чтобы вырабатывало вольты. Велосипед не поедет, нужно больше G.
Просмотрев видео, мне захотелось вдруг построить такую электростанцию!
Alexander Shatalov Твоя электростанция будет размером с планету ))) Хотел бы я узнать, где ты возьмёшь столько материала, чтобы её построить.
какую нахуй планету? 10-100 метров и норм крутиться будет)
Vasiliska Ilyushin Куда проще без цепей и шестерёнок: раскрутить обычный лом, иногда называемый железным карандашом. Один конец лома будет вращать другой конец лома и наоборот.
Ин Ни это отличная идея, только колесо ещё лучше
Again, we see an example of a comment section collectively not using their critical thinking skills.
Meaning the video is fake? Or real?
Gabe adorno I don't know, I didn't watch it. I'm talking about the insane number of people trying to rationalize something which is _physically_ impossible.
It looks real and it makes sense tho
+Gabe adorno no it does no. it defies the first (and possibly the second) law/s of thermodynamics meaning that these people are trying to fool you by hiding a rotor somewhere which powers the device, or just being a really efficient device that is given energy at the start to create an illusion of a gain in energy
joebog1 laws get broken and if it's efficiency is good enough it could go for a very very long time. But it's useless because as soon as you try to hook a turbine up to it to generate energy, it would slow it down
if your stuff was really creating energy it would accelerate infinitly
EXACTLY!!!!!!!!!!!
+ThePapino134 and can't be stopped...
No, it wouldnt, because its Fake. xD
No shit!
+ThePapino134 A prepetual machine would only accelerate if it had no forces to stop it! On earth you will have gravity and air recistance, but everywhere in the universe you have friction to overcome....
Than again making a machine that does neither accelerate and decellerate would be impossible. for example a "newton's cradle" seems to have figured out that stuff, but if you wait long enough they also stop...
1:50 I like how the drums are synced to the thingamajig.
the only perpetual thing are this videos, they never end!
В первом я так понимаю в серпе электромагнит?
Во втором или тот же электромагнит, или вал и моторчик или пружина в стойке.
Третья вообще непонятно что и работать в принципе не должна.
В четвертом похоже тоже снизу моторчик стоит...
В последнем тоже моторчик похоже что внизу...
или кто-то считает иначе? ;-)
там скорее всего постоянные магниты. Но, в любом случае - это не вечный двигатель. Да, эти механизмы могут работать довольно долго (но не вечно, это точно :)) и мощности их хватит лишь на самих себя.
в последнем очень хорошо видно, что это моторчик, поскольку поворотная штанга каждый раз заходит немного дальше каждой из стоек при повороте, значит ее что-то туда тянет помимо самого груза
можно так долго не писать. любая система находит точку равновесия и по окончании силы импульса (толкания рукой) остановится. не зависимо от того какой сложный механизм, как расставлены магниты и т.д. ЛЮБАЯ система находит точку равновесия, что бы система продолжала работать нужно внешнее воздействие. так что все эти механизмы не вникая в их суть фейк по дефолту
Да, я посмотрю вы все тут институт высшей физики закончили, а нет вы наверное Бакалавры
Влад Андреев Тому, что создание вечного двигателя невозможно - учат в школе. Класс 7-й, если память мне не изменяет. Так что, ваша ирония тут неуместна.
Te creator of these confirm that there is an electrical motor involved. This video is supposed to show how perpetual motion machines wood work if they did.
10,550 people are bad at physics.
Or they know how to read the description
+shut your face! actually this description doesn't mention that
sorry yup, it was in part 1's
Oh but it only takes one person not to read the part one description.
This guy is replicating perpetual inventions made before. He knows they aren't perpetual he just makes them to make them
I don't know why there's so many people saying these things are fake. They are completely possible. You may say that, by the laws of thermodynamic, you can't get energy out of nothing, but these machines don't work all by themselves. You give them a bit of energy when you set up the contraption in place. By lifting it, you transform your physical energy into potential energy, and then, thanks to gravity, that potential energy is transformed into kinetic energy, making the contraption move. This movement also transforms kinetic energy into potential energy again on the other side of the contraption, and the cycle starts again. Basicly, you give it some initial energy, and then it is transformed constantly. At least that's how I think they work. Theorically, they are not perpetual, as friction produces heat, which makes the system lose energy over time. Eventually it will stop working, but it could take years. Why isn't this used as full electrical generators? Well I think the amount of energy produced by a wheel of that size and rotating at that speed is absurdly low. Making a bigger version of this would be costly, and it wouldn't produce much energy either. Also, as it depends on gravity, it can't be rotated or moved, so it doesn't work as a mobile energy generator. The relation between cost and energy production is too low. Why would people invest in a giant gravity generator when they can produce the same amount of energy with a cheaper wind or water turbine? "Perpetual" motion machines are interesting to have there in your room, but they aren't a reliable source of energy.
mechanically possible ,
oooh the last one is gorgeous
You don't get something for nothing.
***** What's your theory?
***** Alright.
DrLeroyGreen what is nothing ?
Gravity is a force
SUCKRPUNCHED If it keeps on moving, then he's using more than just gravity.
The last one makes me laugh..you see clearly that the weight is being pulled hahaha :p
+Caculated What is it being pulled by?
+Mod MINI The arm it was suspended by. The concept of the contraption is that as it unwinds its momentum throws it towards the next leg to wrap around, however such a device would probably never manage a full revolution. in this case, you can clearly see the arm is throwing the weight towards the legs as its moving far faster then the weight is. If it was working on its own, the weight would swing out ahead of the arm. Just like how the first device was clearly using a rotor to spin (The weights moving and jostling about give you a hint that energy is being added to the system by an outside force) since the orbital weights had no impact on its speed.
in the first round, it rolls around the innermost arms 3 times (u may see it), after some time it rolls around it just 2 times, therefore after some time it will just stop. good mechanism though
bro its representing how its SUPPOSED to work, its obvious that its fake
Вечный двигатель работающий за счёт гравитации это не вечный двигатель. Ни одна из этих хреней не будет работать в невесомости.
Тима Леньфиёв и не надо
вечный двигатель, подразумевается что он будет работать вечно, а не в любой среде
Metalcommand странно подразумевать именно это потому как ничто не вечно
Тима Леньфиёв это смотря в каких условиях содержать этот двигатель. Я повторюсь, вечный двигатель это такой который работает без остановки
Понятие "вечность" это есть вечность. В данном случае мы имеем просто механизмы, которые питаются не от батареек, а от гравитации земли. Земля как и её гравитация не вечны. Если уж на то пошло, то Вселенная (теоретически) расширяется бесконечно. Соответственно механизм должен работать в открытом космосе и брать энергию от самого себя. Но так же он и должен отдавать взамен. Как получить в данном случае КПД 100% от механизма который питает сам себя? В простонароде это называется "манна небесная"
Flippin unbalanced wheel is in sync to the music, i'm dying XD
В первом механизме можно увеличить КПД путём создания направленного удара, как при втором. Третий выходит за рамки моего понимания - это представляется мне открытием.
Impossible or not, Its interesting seeing some of the mechanisms people have created
DJ L-Money™ it's truly amazing why batteries can do
Dragon Paragon Batteries weren't used in a lot of these.
DJ L-Money™ Yes, very intresting indeed.
The V8 we haven't found energy or matter that makes more energy than it consomes
Energy can't be created nor distroyed
the last one was amazing !
Yeah batteries are greatly hiden
"Perpetual Motion _Idea_ Machines" Should be the correct title. Any perpetual motion video will of course be BS anywho.
Wow, very smart thinking. The big arc piece does 3 things. 1) It takes the weight off of the spinning assembly at the top of the down hill trek, 2) it rotates the weight on that same smaller wheel so that it cocks it back to create a kenetic downhill golf swing potential, then 3) releases the weight into the golf swing to maximize the downhill swing thrust, while the weights on the other two wheels have their weights hanging free and closer to the center, allowing them to rise due to the fact that the big wheel has less weight to lift on that side. In turn, PM, and a very nice version of an alternating weight wheel PMM.
this fuels my bizarre fascination with PM machines, glad its not just me.
I like how all the comments regurgitate what grade 8 science taught. we know the physics ok . just because all of you can repeat what greater people than yourselves once said, doesn't mean you got the universe on lock down. great video and very cool gadgets
The V8 he's just explained how everyone already knows it's bs. But he's just saying he still likes the gadgets. Stop being a douchebag, at the end of the day they're just fun to watch.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perpetual_motion Read the first two lines
"This kind of machine is impossible, as it would violate the first or second law of thermodynamics"
Anto Mani Wikipedia is not the most reliable source of information....but it is true that these machines are cool, but the whole motion thing is probably fake
jody024 not just probably, 100% fake. Cool ideas but the perpetual motion machines are all fakes. This is one of the oldest concepts of physics. You can never generate more energy than you the one you have used to generate it in the first place.
elmareao Its ironically unscientific for you to try to make absolute statements like that.
dylarmage Well, it's not me. This is the actual physic paradigm. One thing is to try to challenge the paradigm and other thing to cheating people don't understand why this could not work.
Who is cheating anyone? Don't go adding in accusations if you aren't going to follow through. "Paradigm" is not a fixed principal that is without exception or without possibility of disproof. As soon as you start making absolutist statements like "X proves Y" then you have ceased science and moved into entirely new fields of rhetoric. There's a reason that every article that says "Study proves X" is categorically false. That's not how the scientific method works and its definitely not the way that science on a basic philosophical level works.
Cases like this show up very commonly around discussions about things people like to think they understand through even the most basic of pop science concepts. Newtonian physics is 1) Not an absolute set of rules 2) Is not as simplistic as the standard you're attempting to establish here.
Honestly, I'm not even concerned about the content of your post. Well, beyond your absolutism. That's the problem. You think science is about protecting what already is and not about discovery beyond what is known. I can tell because you jump to "these are fakes" (a nonsense statement to make about a physical object that is clearly real) instead of making a correct statement like "friction and or entropy will probably cause it to come to rest at some point in the future, even if it preserves momentum for a long time."
If you're going to throw words around, know what they mean first.
"in this house we obey the laws of thermodynamics!!"
I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship that has gone into fabricating these contraptions.
Very cool. BTW if anyone is still gullible enough to think these are real, read the guy's website, it say's "My Perpetual Motion Machines models are of motorized versions that were built to illustrate how they were supposed to work in the minds of
Inventors. "
最後のやつすげぇ欲しい
東急ハンズとかで売ったらいいのに。
@もっちたろう オッス、オラ悟空！
more bs
ghettohillbilly1 sure
+ghettohillbilly1 i agree
+ghettohillbilly1 but he's generating enough views(ads) to keep him going...
+Aaron “Tyme2wakeup” Melancon idiot
+veproject1 Perpetual motion os not possible. Sooner or later, all machines will run out of energy if they are not supplied.
I don't care what anybody says the idea of perpetual motion it's still cool
I love that you can even see the last one slowing down lol
The annoying thing about these videos is that they don't run long enough to watch the momentum decay.
+Dave Olifent no, the thing about these videos is that they are hooked up to motors. All these machines are cyclical. All of the machines make more than one cycle in the video. If these machines were not hooked up to motors, it would be impossible for them to even complete a single cycle without an initial force.
+stuffandpoop Post a link to a video you made of your machine?
Robert Ray this response makes no sense.
+stuffandpoop Sure it does. Before you trash someone else's machine you know nothing about show us what you can do and what makes you the expert. Last I checked you didn't have a TH-cam channel with subscribers checking out anything you made
Robert Ray I don't have to build a machine to be an expert, or to know his machines are bullshit. I just have to have a basic understanding of the law of the conservation of energy. One cannot break the laws of physics, which is what these machines appear to do if they are not hooked up to a motor.
what is the title of the music used here? answer pls. . .
Name music?
на последнем видео отчетливо видно, насколько автор плохо скрыл обман
Что же тебе отчётливо видно?
когда верёвка с грузиком разматывается, в момент перехода с одного шеста на другой происходит смена направления движения грузика (просто внимательней приглядеться если). Хотя в силу сохранения импульса движения, грузик должен был продолжить свою траекторию, т.е если с одного шеста он разматывался по часовой стрелке, то НАМОТАТЬСЯ на второй шест он должен также по часовой, но сняться с него уже против. Тем более что палочка с грузом находится внутри круга. На видео же, если меня зрение не подводит, груз наматывается и разматывается всегда одинаково на всех палочках (против часовой и по часовой соответственно), именно это и смутило.
Хотя, если я не прав, не судите строго, а объясните. Спасибо за внимание.
Юрий Русский Груз закручивается в правильную сторону. Но даже если наоборот, вы уверены что познали логику машины которую увидели первый раз в жизни. Так в чём же обман который автор пытается скрыть?
veproject1Обмана нет, есть затухание колебаний.
Другие конструкции явно не рабочие.
veproject1в том, что без воздействия на основной шест (к которому всё это крепится) вращение его должно прекратиться после первого разматывания. Сам импульс и его гашение (посредством смены направления движения груза во время разматывания), происходит практически в одно время. Т.е всё это движется за счёт окончательного отделения грузика от шеста(начало) и наматывания на другой (точка окончания действия импульса движения), НО в середине пути происходит смена направления движения (в виде буквы S), которая противоестественна свободному перемещению тела, которое находится в состоянии движения по инерции, и тем более закреплено в одной точке.
И не нужно принимать всё так близко к сердцу. "логику", как вы выразились, я понял. Повторю ещё раз, если я не прав, то буду только рад прочитать, а ещё лучше наглядно увидеть объяснение этому. Спасибо.
There's a book called "Physics for entertainment" by Y.E Perelman. In this book Perelman extensively talks about perpetual motion machines. He gives mathematical and scientific proof to debunk these machines that you've just shown.
And none of the machines you've shown will work. You're using motors to run these contraptions.
Anyway, I suggest everyone who hasn't read it to get the digital copy, it's really an amazing book.
For those that keep saying that it's all fake and he put batteries on them, please stop and think. Perpetual Motion may be impossible but that certainly doesn't mean that creating a machine that can utilize the vast majority of energy put into to a greater efficiency is also impossible, news flash it's not. Gas engines and other engines that we use to power our world are extremely inefficient and therefore require a constant influx of energy to run but these machines do not and will continue to run for an extended period of time, it's not "Perpetual Motion" it's simply showing off efficiency in a mechanical system. Please stop being idiots.
"Gas engines and other engines that we use to power our world are extremely inefficient" haha your the idiot.
John Kens A gasoline engine is about 20% energy efficient some are a little more but that means that 80% of the energy they take in is lost, usually by heat. An engine such as these is maybe 80-90% energy efficient, for something to have perpetual motion it must be 100% energy efficient which due to entropy is impossible. That's called efficiency you should do research before calling me the idiot sir, maybe you should go back to high school and learn about it too idk i'm just an idiot.
John Kens that does not make gasoline more efficient at all, it makes it more practical in today's society. simply producing more energy than something else does not mean it is more efficient. efficiency is the relation ship oh energy leaving the system ( a ) and the total energy produced by the system( e ), which is a/e *100= % efficiency. so in the case of a motor vehicle (e) would be the total energy the engine produces in kj, let's say 1000kj. while (a) would be the energy at the crank in kj, let's say 350kj. so (350/1000)*100=35%
in this example the engine has a energy efficiency of ,35%. which means 65% of the energy is lost in heat, friction, things like that.
and you are trying to say that....
Lacrima Gasoline produces huge amount of excess energy, so it can move a car. Even if it was true those devices would work, there would be energy just to propel it itself, not even propel anything else. Those devices would need to produce many hp more energy to be possible use it as propellant. But it would mean when running free it would keep to speed up to the high revolutions until it destroys itself. But nothing like this happens, so this can't be even thought about being better than gasoline...
The only real thing that is perpetual is in the way they never stop trying to con everyone!
Ce genre de vidéo est toujours faite par de perpétuels arnaqueurs
It doesn't really matter if they are fake or not, the real question should be can these designs be used in some way to improve efficiency.
Too much energy is lost to friction for these to produce near what the energy is used to power them.
no it cannot
This is strangely satisfying
A perpetual motion machine continues to move as long as no energy is lost. A perpetual motion machine does not create energy, it just uses the initial energy input to continue moving.
Every wheel is a perpetual motion machine or as close as we can get. All of these items have one thing in common and that is they act as flywheels using different methods to continue the initial motion at a relatively steady pace.
Once we have frictionless bearings and put that wheel in a true vacuum then it will be a true perpetual motion machine.The closest we see to a true perpetual energy machine is a video of a spanner lost by astronauts into space.
If any of these were true sources of perpetual motion, then don't you think someone somewhere would have already capitalized on the idea and started producing "free energy"? (I quote the words free energy because that term is 100% malarkey and breaks the laws of physics)
Jack Duno I find it funny how you cite physics like it's the fucking bible yet if you actually read a book on all the famous physicists hell scratch that, famous scientists in general. Each and every one dedicates their first words, with an iteration of "The guy before me is wrong this is how it really goes."
Shanethefilmmaker So what I'm getting here is that you doubt the laws of physics or something? Which famous scientist told you that any of the machines above are true perpetual motion machines?.. That's all I'm tring to argue
Jack Duno
And what I am trying to tell you is the people who invented, not discovered, in ven ted, are people whom time and again has done it prove the scientist and physicist before him/her wrong. the laws of physics are unreliable sources when the people that invented them kept changing them as a means to prove each other wrong.
Shanethefilmmaker Huh. My whole world makes no sense now
Jack Duno
I hope that wasn't sarcasm, but seriously look up any scientist even the ones that cite the previous ones as their idols, they often begin with some variation of "He was great, but what he wasn't right about was this."
Вранье. Такие механизмы работать не будут!!
Почему?
ЮУДУТ!
Почему же не будут? Вопрос не в работоспособности, вопрос в КПД. Для вечного двигателя КПД >=1, Для практического использования КПД >1. Представленные модели могут иметь КПД = 0,9999999999 и крутиться очень долго, но этим они не нарушают законов физики.
Языком болтать - не мешки ворочать! Прежде, чем брякнуть ты сделай, проверь, а уж потом скажи!
i still need an explanation for the "Suspended Wheel System"
+The Redstoner Look up F. G. Woodward's Wheel. That should partially explain it. I still don't fully understand it. This is one I do believe doesn't last very long due to the large amount of contact between the parts, unless properly lubricated.
If you watch closely...there is a shadow behind the right wheel....its being rotated by an engine....I think so
Luiz Milky Like I said, these don't usually run very long. So, yeah, there probably a motor behind this one just to show you how the parts move.
+The Redstoner Probably snuck a battery behind the wheel somewhere.
While possible, i'd like to understand how it works if not powered by external means... as i'd like to believe these are nearly perpetual motion machines, as I understand the mechanics behind every other machine here
all those guys who are saying friction would stop the motion, the electricity generated during the motion, a part of it can be used to maintain the motion from the friction.
I wish these all included descriptions of how they are supposed to work. In Part 1,you could get an idea of what the designer was thinking, but some of these don't even seem to have a principle which would make them work. It's totally unclear what the designer was thinking.
Energy source is gravity!
Actually the energy source is under that mysteriously opaque base unit.
Gravity isn't a source of energy, but I can see why you thought it
gravity is a force, but not a source of energy. Any energy gained by dropping something will be lost again when it is lifted, along with interest from friction. Even if you could make a perfectly frictionless wheel that ran forever, it would be useless as an energy source, since the minute you tried to extract any energy, it would stop.
super useful for trains and stuff tho, so still patent it if you invent one ;)
so add more weight... since it looses force , to gain add more weight and can power a batt or light. ???
It's a force not a source
do you have a link to the song? reminds me of labradford.
+Andrew Muro in description
+veproject1 yeah, thanks, but still can't find this song anywhere. all i can find is really shitty electronic.
because this group works for YT only, I think
+Andrew Muro I guess you have found another one of this persons tracks because this is really shitty electronic music.
reminds me of 'no quarter' by led Zeppelin just way shittier and no vocals.
screw the definition of perpetual motion, why has no-one hooked a dynamo up to like 300 of these and emplyed a few people to walk around and poke them with a stick every now and again
extremally unefficient. dynamo wpuld put put near all energy in secounds fron them and even if someone would poke it constantly... well it would be more efficient to just spin dynamo by yourself but as you probably know its waaaay less efficient that for example water turbine
mine-cake , How about, get a bunch of people to push a gigantic dynamo and then poke whoever is slowing down, stumbling, or slacking off.
I'm still surprised at the number of people who's brains explode at the simple thought of perpetual motion :'D
all perpetual motion are fake.
I agree but work on your grammar
Genius....
how
Fact: Using the word “machine” with perpetual motion or energy, will give it a beginning and an end, making it finite. With this new and better understanding of perpetual devices, its meaning will need updating in defining it as finite. This way, these devices or machines will not violate the laws of thermodynamics, laws of nature, laws of physics, makes them patentable. ~Guadalupe Guerra
These are beautifully made little demonstrations, or fancies. Kinetic sculptures, even.
Appreciate these for what they are :) would make my day go quicker if I had one of these contraptions on my desk
Although these machines can't provide unlimited energy the unbalanced wheel and the three beams perpetual star can be dramatically improved and can be an electrical fan needing far less energy
While obviously friction is bound to "tear apart" each of these systems sometime, these videos show remarkable classical designs that are grasped visually.
Perpetual motion aside these are very cool sculptures. I enjoy these videos
The first one is SO OBVIOUSLY powered that I'm surprised he even showed it.
...nevermind, they're all obvious; I don't know who would fall for these.
While there is no such thing as _perpetual_ anything, (including time itself) these machines are incredible examples of their inventor's ingenuity. I was certainly impressed. On another note, I really was digging the background music on this video in particular. It reminds me of something that could be used in a Kill Bill movie, which is perpetually cool.
@veproject1 nice job keeping the beat of the music on time with the unbalanced wheel
Even if these are fakes I think that the value of this ideas is great. The contraptions are solid work, not some 5 minute fake joke. Good job.
you're really good at hiding engines😂
Motors*
Imagine if these PM machines (Like the suspended gear mecha) could be applied to large-scale industrial applications, like power generation; Electric power for ETERNITY for ANY city and totally green on top of it! Alas, in a perfect world...
All I see is visual stimulation that creates thoughtful dialogue in the comments. I think it's a win win. The fail is that we can't come up with a way to convert a slight amount of energy to a major amount of energy without combusting fuel to slam through life.
Nice handcraft. All models are driven by a motor in the base. The constant motion of the center axle at all models debunks it.
I love how the guy/girl doesn't prove their point, but only puts "sure." The perfect way to find out if someone is wrong is if they don't have a rebuttal
Loved the carousel device. Really cool. Subscribed, even though I think a few of these had a motor or two involved. :)
cool toys... (obviously not infinite free energy, but people strangely want to complain) ... LOVE the suspended wheel one :D :)
That's cool! They run on kinetic energy!
I don't care if they are fake or real
They are just cool to watch
My perpetual motion starts at night in my bed. Initially seems like infinite and forever, but than comes to a halt. Anyways keep trying guys, all efforts are admirable if you don't try to fool others.
All of them have thick pillars and are powered there. We need to make the pillars transparent. The power can also be hidden under the floor, so it needs to be placed on a glass plate.
genious minds, genious concepts... these concepts are base of modren physics....
thanks for sharing such information.
This type of stuff is so interesting, if we could use this to create power we would be so set
The suspended wheel system is going the wrong way I'm dying
Some of these machines are just too brilliant for words. Now show us a perpetual motion machine that can ACTUALLY DO WORK. You say you can't... well there's a surprise --- well not really.