BMW X7 M60i vs Range Rover P530: battle of the V8s | PistonHeads
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 พ.ย. 2022
- Both have 530hp. Both are gigantic SUVs. But there can only be one winner.
We’ll start with the BMW. Not much of a looker, but it’s packing a punch. It’s arguably the sportier of the two, with some mild hybrid assistance giving it some extra low down punch over the Range Rover despite matching it on power. But, when it comes to outright luxury, look no further than the almighty Rangie. We can’t choose, so we’re leaving this up to John to decide.
🔴 Subscribe to PistonHeads: bit.ly/2aKvdVO
Follow us on social media:
🗣 Facebook: / pistonheads
📸 Instagram: / pistonheads
🐦 Twitter: / pistonheads - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
The X7 does not look that bad. I like it
Right. The X7 looks aggressive, while the RR is understated. It really comes down to if you want something that will get attention vs fly under the radar.
ok, stewie wonder
Oh yes it does, it looks horrendous
I agree I think the new split headlights really suit it, unlike the 7 series
Love it actually
That X7 going through the corners is really impressive.
Of course, that’s what BMWs do best…drive.
I would choose the X7
The side window wind noise on both of these cars is a deal killer. And, yes, I’ve driven both extensively and own the X7.
My P530 is as quiet as my Continental GT and S8 (more quiet than the Bentley) before, as you can expect it from a Range Rover. I've heard about that issue a few times. Maybe pre-series vehicles used as demo cars? I've had Range Rovers since 2007, 322s and 405s, no problems at all, always the petrol V8.
I used to drive multiple previous gen Range Rover sports over 8 years and they were completely fine. I’m not sure id go so far to call it a ‘deal breaker’ but I’m a fan that you own an X7👌
@@TheBS80Audi s8 ?
It’s a deal killer…. But you’ve bought an X7? Makes sense.
@@jonb4248I didn’t know it was an issue in 2020 when I bought an X7 M50i. Don’t worry, it’s not that complicated.
I am surprised that the BMW is quieter than the RR? That was a key thing in the videos I have seen before.
X7 to me is modern and gorgeous bought a black sapphire one a week ago. Like it more and more
X7 is the sportier drive. Has an updated engine and is better suited for the 99% of the time used for on-road driving rather than off - road 😁
IDrive 8 needs some time for accommodation, but the interior is looking a little bit more premium with it... of course, depending on the personal taste and needs, can't go wrong with either... ✌
Nicely put
Great review! Love your work!
John is a great reviewer. Hold onto this man PH.
I find this Facelift X7 better looking than the previous one.
Granted though that the Range Rover is a stunning piece of design
U on drugs
I totally agree. I really do not like that boring l/meh look of the previous one
Great review, thank you John.
Well done mate ! you are a well and truly great reviewer.. keep up the good work
If you need to go real offroad I'd chose RR, but as a regular suv I'd go for x7. RR does 0 to 60 in 4.7 while x7 does it in 4.4 sec.
Me personally I don’t really care about a .3 0-60 difference nor will I notice it and the Range Rover is way better at what it was designed for
Trust Me.. no one is taking this expensive RR off roading… maybe to the Mall
You are a top class motoring journalist. Sublime comparo review; getting to the nitty gritties without getting boring.
Great film, you certainly hustled these manors through the countryside
Very good review. You’ve been a good addition to the team and your videos are always informative. I wonder which one is best for a more modest and realistic spec such as the Range Rover P440e vs equivalent rivals. I can’t see the big V8 being the pick of the bunch.
I don't mind the look of the X7 at all. Yes the RR looks inoffensive, but its styling is essentially just a slightly smoothed over copy of same again look of the previous version. The X7 is at least daring and tries something different.
Leader
He has a very good diction, the choice of words and phrases is exquisite!
I definitely choose Range Rover because it's a two in one package compared to the BMW. It also looks more fancier and luxurious than the BMW. Thanks for sharing! It was awesome to watch
Overall I think i will choose the X7 👍
You're an excellent car reviewer
I'll take the x7, it's really grounded impressively. ❤
It looks like the nissan rogue lol
At 12:00 you say the interior is at least at the level of the bmw. But then at 13:16 you say the interior feels like you’re in an X1. Can you make up your mind?
I am admittedly a BMW fan and have owned them since 1998… Currently own a 2022 X5. The Range Rover is fabulous but I’m not a fan of Tata so objectively I would take the X7!
Refusing to buy a Range Rover just because it is owned by an Indian company automatically deducts 25 points off your IQ
Excellent review John,I like your tone and delivery.
To my eyes
The range rover looks classier than the X7
But a £30'000 price difference is huge.
Great video. Thanks for the review.
He was right about the exterior look of the new BMW. same front as my wife's Nissan Rogue 2021. That's why I got the X5 2022 before they change it to the same front as the X7. However, regarding the IDrive physical buttons, I think he forgot that most cars depending on the voice commands now.
X7 for me. It's definitely not ugly
Nothing will break down as mush as the RR either
EXACTLY
The BMW has better tech and looks more intimidating. Really like the looks of the X7
She's a beast!
Absolutely nice video!
No suv or car looks as elegant as Range Rover. It’s a beauty.
X7 is ok looking in my opinion, it needs PHEV and EV options soon.
I think it has a PHEV version but it has a 3L engine. The XM is a V8 PHEV tho
@@NotMyAccount i am affraid not yet. X5 has PHEV, range Rover has PHEV, i can't see it with X7. I hope IT would not elominate 3rd row, like in Q7 PHEV
A refreshing reviewer, long time no see
I actually like x7 looks.
Should have gone to Specsavers
I love it. It's only the old people that hate it because they don't like changes. It's one of the best looking SUVs in my opinion. I wish the smaller X5 looked like this.
@@N1ckZ
Please look up Hyundai Bion 2022 model. Tell me the new X7 doesn't resemble this cheap SUV from South Korea?
@@kb9072 I don't see any resemblance from any angle apart from the fact that they are both cars
@NickZ
Get you eyes tested !
I'd also choose the Range Rover, luxury that can drive up a mountain...nothing beats that!
Driving a bus around and the unreliability that all Jaguar/Land Rover cars have
Am I the only one who thinks he and Chris Harris have similar sounding voices?🥲
I can't stop hearing Chris Harris 😭
Excellent review
The Range Rover still lags behind BMW in the infotainment department and most certainly the reliability department. Also, the engine in the X7 is a true "M" engine, whereas the engine in the RR is not.
BMW💥
To summarise, comparing these two is like a comparison between a strong cheddar and Parmesan, both are great but for different reasons, the Range Rover is surely the best overall vehicle. Ps Third row of seats is a nonsense, too many compromises and often total destruction of practicality and space! Three rows of seats was invented for motor manufacturers to increase vehicle appeal so they could make more money, smart folk realise the very idea is flawed, really want your kids sat in the rearmost seats when you’re rear ended by another vehicle, I don’t think so! Despite the mismatch of vehicles, I enjoyed the review, cheers 👍
Great video
I’d take both. For different purposes
X7 over RR. It’s more likely to spend time on the road taking you to your destination and not in the dealerships garage with its 75th fault. RR is nothing but a posers machine these days
Nice review - as to aesthetics - why is everyone raging at the X7 grill when the Range's back is the ugliest thing since the 60's - It is like a London cab of old - saw one live the other day with lights on. Interior of Range indeed screams luxury and minimalist, better than the X7 - I have the old X7 in Le Mans blue (very rare) and thought I should have bought the Range (but wait for it for 9 months) - after i saw the back I knew the choice was right. Enjoy your drives whatever they are!
Has to be the rr any day
Range Rover every time. The X 7 is god awful. The design is absolutely shocking
Sure. Drive an old bmw engine. Which is awesome but bmw gets a newer engine.
Kindly X5 GLE 450 vrs range rover sports comparison
Range Rover always
The X7 I’m sure has way more power than stated (probably to keep Land Rover happy as a client, the Range may not handle more power well). I’ve seen it do under 4 seconds 0-60.
Yeah mat wattson from car wow showed the x7 is a whole lot faster than stated
True
Range Rover is only good for the first 10,000 miles until it breaks down.
X7 any day, especially with a much better drive..generations ahead. It actually has some exterior design instead of a bland melted look. Range rover also has a laggy screen...deal breaker
Good review
Which one is more reliable?
Bmw x7 ranger rover are unreliable
I smoked both previous versions of these 2 cars. Nimble like an elephant. As per reviewing the engine noise, please keep in mind the cabin speakers are playing it.
Thank you
I went for the X7 because it can do both calm wafty driving and somewhat sporty/engaging driving. The 7-seat implementation is the best there is... an actually usable 3rd row! The S68 engine is an absolute force of nature, it will do 4.3's 0-60 all day. They've improved most of the unintuitive iDrive features with v8.5 so thankfully its much more user-friendly now. Although I will still NEVER understand why BMW removed the cruise control distance setting buttons from the steering wheel and replaced them with NOTHING... could understand if they put something more important there, but to leave them blank is just STUPID
I own an X5 I have used the X7 as a loaner for a week. I choose the X7. After 2 years of ownership only one repair covered by warranty. The Range Rover is more luxurious by reliability means something. The BMW V8 had problems pre 2018. My X5 50i has been reliable through 30k miles
Great video and agree with your choice!
My dream car range rover 🔥❤️👑
Great review and very balanced although looks are a very subjective thing 😎 Would also add that total cost of ownership over three years would be interesting given reliability and insurance delta’s. You can tell in an X7 fan !!
Dude started dropping shit bombs on the BMW at 13:00 🤣
I've been reading PH on the old litterweb since the early 2000s and great to see it evolve to TH-cam media. It's slow buts always gotten better! I won't even mention the infamous forum!
Since when did Range Rover start using BMW V8's again? I thought that ended in 2006 with the L322?
And apparently out of all the engine options in the new Range Rover the bmw one is the one causing trouble already, they haven’t learned. The L322 was a big enough lesson.
If you don't look at his face it's Chris Harris.
does the X7 40 with the dynamic handling package handle better than both on the road?
You can see the Range Rover leaning more than the X7 through those corners
Not for people like you.
Range rover is Range rover nothing comparison it is awesome peace of engineering
Range Rover 😍
Yes I agree Range Rover all the way!!!! But it would have to have a twenty year warranty with unlimited kilometres!!!! Regards Ian 👨🎤🇳🇿😇
You can’t get All Season run flat tires on the X7. That’s not going to work for most people in colder climates.
Don’t liberal elite clueless buyers of these just call the bmw emergency road service anyway? They push the button on the head rail and complain. Amazing how they save the environment with these, isn’t it?
@@Bmwguy2011 I think you are just upset you can't afford a car over 6 figures but that is ok the internet is a great place to vent all your anger and grievances :)
@@tankman66 :-). You’re partially correct. While I own 285 apartment units in 7 complexes in 3 states and 3 BMW’s, I would find it difficult to spend 6 figures on a new car as precious few of them would begin to hold their value. Definitely a foolish business decision.
Obviously a Range rover, all you British car journalists are extremely biased.
Let's hope the security has been improved on the Range Rover.
They’re all just as easy to steal
BMW 🔥
BMW X7 all the way
Nahhhh
I would also not go for the M60i, but rather the xDrive40i with the legendary B58. Way cheaper than the RR.
These two want to reach completely different customer, I never don't know idea why it might be important to compare a painting by Dali and a Monet. BR: Sz
Range Rover ; It is said that the life of the engines is very short and there is a safety problem. For example, in some forms, complaints rained down on the sites. for example; The engine exploded at 2.000 km, in some of them while on the road, the engines would suddenly crash and stop, causing an accident. WHAT IS YOUR THOUGHT ABOUT THIS?
How tall are you when you don't have enough room in the backseat.
Range rover much much much better looking now
Had multiple Land Rover products with many issues. Had multiple BMW products with zero issues. X7 please
Go on then what models have you had?
Get the Range Rover with the BMW engine.
@@mbizozo6271 the worst ones, the ford tdv8 is the one to have.
Love the RR aesthetic but the reality is just too unpredictable. My playlist was a 2009 BMW X5 then swapped it for a 2011 RR sport - but 13 dealer trips later gave up by 2012 - then had a 2012 BMW X5 which had zero issues but in 2017 swapped to the 2017 RR Sport but again had issues from day 1 (basically it was just a a facelift) so traded it for a 2018 BMW X5 50d and then flipped that for a X5 45e in 2021
@@jameshogg601 well I've had 2 Disco's and an RRS, and from BMW stable I've had starting at e39 5 series, 335i coupe, 2 650's and now an M850 GC - all spanning many years with no issues to speak of. Admittedly, the LR products were for the mrs.
Mechanically BMW takes it, however x7 looks are not for me. I agree and would opt for Range Rover, but it would be one of hybrid options.
I think the main reason why I’d chose such a car is comfort. And the Range Rover having worse suspension and worse sound insulation is criminal. Add the fact that the x7 handles much better and is more than capable for the off roading that 99.99% of people do, it’s the obvious choice regardless of the looks.
With the Range Rover it seems you have to pay extra to get a better looking but worse car. Just not sure about that.
Go ahead pick the Range Rover and I’ll pass you on the Highway in the bmw when you break down
I'm not so confident you'll get tht much further...😁
What’s powering the Range Rover? 😂
@@Offensivebeast yeah because they got smart and it’s everything about the Range Rover to its chassis and springs and rods. They are just junk
@@dnice362 the 4.4 from bmw is the engine option causing the most issues out of all the engine options available on the new Range Rover, and the chassis’s are brilliant? The suspension components claim is nonsense, air suspension is something that’s bound to wear out on any vehicle, it becomes a known thing to look out for on majority of vehicles with it, and we wont get into why the L322 was the most unreliable Land Rover, even Ford was able to improve upon what BMW had left behind.
I Agree with you on the Most critics to the beemer. But if it was a diesel, it'd be much cheaper than the Rover yet again. Therefore the verdict should include this aspect aswell.
Currently own both - X7 handles better and is faster
RR in certain/most colours catches more eyes and has more clout
23’ X7 and 911 is a nice combination. Was always a Mercedes person but 23’ BMW is killing it ha
You better show us all the engine lights on the dash of RR
Modern BMWs are literally THE least reliable cars you can buy, especially ones with turbo V8s and air suspensions. I mean even a Durango or Trackhawk is more reliable than the X5/X7. As for the Range Rover, yes it's no Toyota but it has an exquisite interior, great ride quality and infotainment. Not to mention the unbeatable off-road ability.
Range Rover doesn’t have the stupid front grill - so will always win, even when broken down on the M1
It is not stupid
@@elliaselliyasa3885 you are correct - it is more than stupid...its idiotic 😬
What? That’s the product of an advanced German design team. Beaver teeth in glorified school buses are in vogue. Everyone needs a safari ready 7500 lb school bus with room for 8 and a height to make America’s housewives feel powerful. And because their time is so valuable, it must make it to 60 in 5 seconds. Junior can’t be late to soccer practice.
Whaaaa. I don’t like something!!!
At least the Range Rover now has a more reliable engine
Lol, the age old BMW vs whatever test. BMW better here, better there.... I'll choose the other one. If anything, this test confirmed the X7 the clear winner. Having said that, I'm not British.
Why am I even here and I don't even own a car? The devil is a liar 😂😂😂
X7 40d 340 bhp and 700 nm + (200nm electric torque) is the best engine
In real life situation.. Wonder which one breakdown first? Perhaps within the first or second week of ownership
Isn't your point cliche to the point of almost puking 🤢. Try something new buddy
Whilst the BMW is way better in some respect,Its not a grand as the range rover in my opinion. RR all the way babe!
I'll keep the $30000 and it's the X7 all day long for me
Test drove both. Got the X7. X7 allllll the way and it’s not even close.
X7 all day long
BMW worth to buy 👍
Range Rover have been outclassed by the bmw here
I'll take the x7 because of price point and get an s class coupe or an 8 series for the same price of the range rover.....but that range rover is gorgeous and sophisticated
What do you mean? The X7 is more expensive than the Range Rover and both the s class coupe and 8 series is much cheaper than the Range Rover
So he picked Range Rover because he is tech illiterate..😂😂
What's the point comparing a BMW to a Range Rover? Nobody rich enough to buy a Range Rover is cross shopping it with a BMW.
What do you mean? They are in the similar price bracket. If you're in the market for a £100000+ SUV surely you would consider both.
@@kb9072 not really. If you're used to a luxury brand like Range Rover, you're not going to want to slum it with the 1 Series owners at BMW. Same with Mercedes, you're not going to want to buy your luxury SUV from the same brand as an A Class and Sprinter Van.
@GC
I'm sure there are people who think that way but it can't be many.
Range Rover up to very recently made the Defender, cool to some, but crude, agricultural and ancient. Also the Evoque, a small, cheaper SUV. Let's not forget owned by an Indian company. With almost the worst reputation for reliability in the motor industry.
Mercedes-Benz make cars like the S-Class, SLS, SLR with McLaren, AMG One, there is an F1 team.
BMW made the engine for McLaren' F1 car. Infact Range Rover used BMW engines for many years.
This argument that buyers of Range Rover wouldn't consider Mercedes or BMW is ......... I'll be kind and just say flawed.
@@kb9072 haha, everyone is entitled to their opinion, even when they are hopelessly wrong. You think a Range Rover Evoque is equivalent to a BMW 1 Series and Mercedes Sprinter Van? 😂 The Evoque is a luxury SUV in a compact package. The other two are driven by chavs and plumbers. But good luck to you. 👍
Pride does not allow the British to use cars with left-hand drive like normal people.
I’d take the range all day long