Coraline Movie Timeline from Ghost Kids to Coraline - The Fangirl Theory
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ก.ค. 2024
- This is my version of the Coraline Timeline. The fun thing about analyzations is that everyone can have different observations, and you can decide for yourself which ones you like!
Find neat Coraline stuff on Amazon: amzn.to/2SD0ews
Find me elsewhere:
sayhalogoobye
the_fanily
SayHaloGoobye Gaming - / @sayhalogoodbye
The Fanily Family Vlogging - / @thefanily
This video and description may contain affiliate links, which means that, if you click on one of the product links, I'll receive a small commission. This helps support the channel and allows us to continue to make videos like this. Thank you for the support!
#coraline #coraline10 #laikastudios #thefangirl #timeline - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
![THE TOYS x NONT TANONT - ดอกไม้ที่รอฝน (spring) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pPa1d5cC8M4/mqdefault.jpg)
Mr. Bobinsky wears a liquidator medal, being Russian I'm thinking it was from the Chernobyl Disaster in 1986. How can Mr. B be trapped in limbo around 1936, meaning he couldn't leave for Russia around the time of the disaster? That's kind of a plot hole for me, idk. I'd also like to point out that the fact that Mr. B is Russian supports the Baba Yaba theory. She was the center of a Russian folklore that matches up with what the Beldam may be.
There are a few earlier Nuclear Disasters in Russia I was able to find but even if earlier, they weren't early enough. That doesn't add up to Mr. Bs timeline. Unless there is a way he moved in around the late 50s?
It makes more sense to say that Wybie's grandma as a young girl, moved in around 1936. If we do say that this is based in 2009 then subtracting 1936 from that would put her to be at least 73, but assuming she wasn't born living at that house, she was probably between 7-13 when she actually moved in with her twin and the rest of her family. If she moved in in '36, That means we can say that Mr. B moved in in 1960 instead, giving him time to have participated in the cleanup of a Nuclear Disaster in the 50's. This would explain how he has a liquidator medal, which are gained through helping clean up nuclear disaster. It may also explain his skin color.
I was just looking around for a disaster event that made sense and found this: Kyshtym Russia Disaster 1957. Happened at the end up 1957 and cleanup lasted for about two years. Assuming that he moved into the Pink Palace right after, that puts his arrival around 1960, which would match up with the taffy candy dishes.
Sairah Peters Interesting, before I go with my theories: how does a nuclear disaster turn ones skin blue?
My theory is that the Beldam is not only in a pocket dimension but also has access to multiple dimensions. Mr. B's skin could be blue bc of being from worlds like Corpse Bride, Frankenweenie, Nightmare Before Christmas etc. Also explains time line issues due to time/event variations between dimensions.
Please KEEP DOING THESE CORALINE THEORIES I LIVE FOR THEM
:D
The Theorizer SUP
Well then, somebodies subbed to somebody! xD
The Theorizer lol
ello theorizer
The Theorizer Best comment of 2017
Just a couple of points of my own-
- I don't think that she's trapped in an inception-style dream world, namely because the beldam can't create things out of thin air, meaning every single thing that they see in the town and such would have to be made of something else, and the town is heavily populated and such, even after she first goes through the small door.
- If the house is limbo, then why did Wybe's grandma leave? Was she not trapped? I mean, she did move and is able to operate freely.
- If the cat's her familiar, then why does he help Coraline win the game? And why, even when Coraline can't see, he hates the dolls? Also, why would she even need to make dolls that could be hints if she can just use the cat? He also actively sways, at the very least, Wybe, from the house, and also Coraline.
Also, this is just sorta something that I've observed and idk if you believe the Theorist's theory on the well being a portal to the other world, I noted 2 things that are both canon and contradict that idea-
- Wybe says that it's so deep that if you look up you see stars, which could indicate that you fall into the other world where it's always nighttime
Contradicting that idea though-
- When they drop the rock in the well with the key at the end, there's a clear splash heard.
What I think that means is that since there are no longer any souls in it, no children, no fairy soul or whatever, the well is now just a well again and the Beldam is trapped in that other world, or she's trapped in the crawl space Coraline goes through when she opens the small door.
These are just sorta rough ideas I got after my last viewing. You've clearly done more analysis then I have so idk, just some thoughts.
Ah, nice comments! Let me see if I can tackle any of them :)
- I agree that the town can be a challenge, but only if we limit ourselves to thinking we understand the extent of the Beldam's power. Keep in mind that, once the cat becomes her familiar, she has visual access to a whole lot more in the real world than she did before. Not to mention, the doll would have allowed her to see different things over time. We also get told that she can see through anything with button eyes - which might mean truly anything in any part of the world. I mean, the Beldam has the stars outfit ready to go right after Coraline is upset over the gloves - how could the Beldam see this when the doll and the cat wasn't present? Well, if Coraline is still in a part of the Other World, then the Beldam can see and hear everything that's going on regardless.
And, did Coraline ever see the downtown area before traveling to the Other World? I don't believe anyone mentions them going beforehand, which gives the Beldam an incredible amount of artistic liberties when she created something. Technically, the Beldam's never seen the Pink Palace either, because she lives in a magical world that supposedly has no access to the real world. And, as far as the thin air part, I don't think that's true. I think she has to have a way to see it to recreate it, but, if the Beldam cannot create at least some things independently, then how did she build the Pink Palace at all? The mice might be able to do a lot, but they aren't moving building materials and paint cans! And, notice two of the people that we're clearly shown downtown - they're actors, and Shakespearean-esc actors at that. They may also be long-term residents of the Pink Palace Limbo world, they just live in a different house since an entire city, or maybe ever world, is in the Other World.
- I'm not 100% convinced that Mrs. Lovat actually went into the Other World. I think she could have gotten an eye full from the portal, and maybe she left it open to see/hear a lot, but whether or not she actually went in there is debatable. Now, I know I said that she strikes a deal with the Beldam to save her son, but, again, she didn't necessarily have to step foot into the Other World to do that, or, if she did go through the portal, the deal may have included Mrs. Lovat going back to the real world too. Or, she could be a puppet or incarnation of the Beldam, which would help explain why she left the key in the house.
- As for the cat's familiar role, there is a reason that he doesn't have button eyes, and it's not just so he can hang out in the real world, it's so that he looks trustworthy to someone who's told that everything with button eyes is a spy of the Beldam. I get asked a lot why the cat helps Coraline get the circus ball if he's working for the Beldam. Well, I think a better question is why doesn't the Beldam call them out on cheating since she sees and hears everything? And why doesn't the Beldam kill the cat after Coraline throws him at her? She'll kill little kids, but she draws the line at animal cruelty? I think thou doth protest too much - if you have to repeatedly beat the viewers over the head with the notion that the cat and the Beldam hate each other (but you don't really offer a lot of visual evidence for this being true), then something is off and it starts to sound like misdirection. Why would the cat return to the Other World at the end of the film if he was so deathly afraid of the Beldam now?
With using the dolls and the cat - habit? Over kill? A desperate, dying, magical entity who's getting hungry may get over zealous to get a new body into the Other World and use all the tricks in her bag. Now, if the cat is Wybee's father, it makes sense that he would want to keep Wybee out. But, the cat does react differently to Coraline, the sacrificial lamb, and he prompts her to return to the Other World at least once by showing her the mirror with her parents. But, since the cat doesn't have button eyes, and because he's pretended to help Coraline by showing her the rats, she blindly trusts, follows, and believes that the cat is her friend. That's a tad bit useful as a tool for manipulation, don't you think?
- You have a good observation with the well, too. I think in the book that it's just a well, nothing special about it (and the gateway to the Other World is more like a hallway than a round tunnel), but the movie does go a few steps further to imply otherwise. The fairy ring is a big draw in for me believing that it's a portal. But, you're right, I think the rock in the beginning also eventually makes a splash. So, the question becomes, can it be both a portal and a real well? And, it's possible! We've seen other stories where they do things like "when the clock strikes 12 the portal opens," so it's not totally out there to think that the well may do the same kind of thing and only be a portal sometimes. There could also be a barrier where things could enter through the bottom of the well, but the Beldam cannot exit that way. It's also possible that an up-and-coming animation studio was reusing props to save money, so the well and the portal are the exact same item in different lighting for the sake of accounting purposes.
About the well being a portal: It's entirely possible, if not definite that the well sometimes has water at the bottom, and sometimes is an open portal, the only other portal we know of, behind the door, is sometimes a brick wall.
Thefangirl plz explain that all in a video
@@TheFangirlWatches loved UR VIDS.!
I want Coraline 2😣😔
Midnight Flame Same
Same
They sold every prop
laika has a strict no sequels policy tho
Same :(
Do you have a theory for why when Coraline's mom comes home with groceries they're all moldy suddenly?
I haven't been able to figure out why that is yet
Julian - TheWolfInBlue Since Coraline is still in the limbo pink palace, i think it is to make Coraline believe that her parents were gone fore a long time.
Julian - TheWolfInBlue I Have a thought. The beldam might make it look like she’s been there for only a few minutes but really she’s been there for days and it’s all an illusion
It could be since she was gone for a day or 2 and they weren’t in the fridge and when it rains it is humid making the grocery’s go of quickly
I believe that time goes faster in the different worlds. Time goes slower for the other world, and the limbo share the same time, wheraes the real world is faster. It would be good for the beldam to make time go slower to save energy, by giving the illusion of a short amount of time, while subconsciously being years.
I think it indicates that shes been gone for an very long time. Maybe time works differently in the other world than this one.
you say that the neighbors are trapped in the limbo pink palace but if that is the case how do you see the neighbors in the beginning of the movie during the moving in scene?
The game would debunk the cat being the beldamns servent cause she stomps on it when you mess up in her boss fight
oh okay! my friend went as wybie for Halloween
Happy Halloween. Thats crazy igat was hallaween yesterday my freinds. Be blessed
Since we never see wybies parents I think it’s kinda fun to think of wybies grandmother as being his actual mother, but since she’s old she told him she’s his grandmother so he doesn’t feel different from other kids. By the estimate of when she moved to the pink palace as a kid she would only be in her fifty’s in coralline and since wybie is a tween(11-12)she would’ve been in her 40s when she gave birth to him, she wouldn’t have gone through menapause yet so I mean I could be plausible.
I’m 13 and my mum is 54 and I have friends with old parents so it’s not like it’s impossible.
But this is just a theory
I agree with everything except the limbo thing, but i still love this!!
Loving all of the coralline videos. It helps with my anxiety of sleep and for the first time in ages I am able to sleep. Watching one before bed stops my chronic night terrors. You are awesome and so are the videos. :)
Hi FanGirl!
Maybe dogs see future and show it like they are sick (deading) First group dogs dead because the first girl dead too. and the second and the third groups death too. and the fourth group of nearly died because Coraline was in danger.
PLEASE READ IT
hmmm... Well, I have to say that I never thought of that angle before. That's why I love my awesome commenters!
The Fangirl will you tell it in your new theories?
Slep Step
Sorry if i'm commenting now,but I want to tell you that you have a good point about the dogs!
What (since Wybie only exist in the movie) Wybie is what he sounds like: Why Be? Maybe he is a clue Why Be Loved? Wybie Loveat- Why Be Loved At? Since the Beldam uses love to lure them in, maybe she created Wybie as well?
Or maybe Ms. Lovat created that name as a hint to the Beldam that she isn't getting him?
@@JoeMama-kj7bq That is even better :)
I feel like the cat thing is wrong Because the cat actually tries to helps coraline all through the film and seems to hate the other mother so maybe the cat had a previous encounter with the beldam but definitely is not working with her that just seems out of place completely
Emmagabbyl 09 I believe it's a setup, to make her think it's on her side, when it's actually, a) it's own being and is the beldams alley or b) is one of the beldams puppets and is one the beldams traps
Helgalicious Netball i disagree. i don't believe the black cat is working for the beldam. i believe the mice work for the beldam though .
Emmagabbyl 09 ש ארץ
I know this comment is quite old but maybe the cat knew coraline had a big ego so he trying to push her away would only make her want to do it more
That's because the cat works for the beldam and is tricking Coraline
These are amazing!🙌
I love all your coraline theories!
Thank you! They're by far my most popular subject, no matter what else I try, so I'll keep going as long as people keep watching!
The Fangirl So true... I even spilled milk over my freshly folded towels while folding the laundry. It never ends!
Anyway, I watched some more of your videos and they were all interesting. Also, you have a good voice, pleasant.
The Fangirl haha, I replied to the wrong comment of yours. :p
Has anyone notice that Bobinsky's mouse act revolves around the music the mice dance to in the "other world"? This would further support the theory that he has been there and seen the act himself.
Oooh, nice catch!
not sure about that one, since the beldam is recreating Coraline's world to improve it and impress her, it seems more likely she's copying bobinkin's musicand not the other way around. Not to mention the mice travel back and forth from the other world too just like the cat, making it easier to communicate to the beldam
Omg , I love your coraline theories , also It's actually one of my childhood movies.
Thank you!
FANGIRL FANGIRL IN THE PART THAT THE OTHER MOTHER ASKS CORALINE TO SEW BUTTONS INTO HER EYES THARE ARE 3 SILHOUETTE PHOTOS OF 1 KID IN EACH PHOTO
How do the Jones' see the neighbors at the beginning before Coraline went through the door?
found your videos today. they are very nice. I folded all my laundry while watching them. ♡
Thank you! And congratulations on finishing the laundry (oh, wait, another pile just built up while I said that!). :)
Thank you I needed more coraline in my life!!!
Your theories are amazing!
I just found your channel and I have beed watching all of your videos. This one is my favorite!
Thank you for finding me and enjoying my ramblings enough to stick around!
Amazing vid fan girl. love your therios xx keep up the good work
Thank you so much!
The Fangirl yay another good Coraline vid. Never stop, your channel is amazing
The Fangirl WAIT A SECOND. When Coraline brings the cat to the main room for the final battle she said a name like You brought (his name) and Coraline says no it's just a friend
I think the Beldam says "you brought vermin" like a rodent-type creature. I have searched and tried to get that cat's name, but the best I ever got was when the book said that the cat sounded like the voice in Coraline's head, except male.
The Fangirl I left a comment on this video that you may find very insightful. It's recent.
Video starts at 2:08
To add to the candy dish relating to the residence theory, I'd add that's the one Caroline ruined was actually the Cats! Because she ruins it, we never get to see the date in the bottom cabinet stating Wybie's father being taken and used as a henchman. It couldn't have related to Coraline bc for all we know, she's going to be trapped forever. Also could explain the hidden room, and could explain the missing mother?
One of the things that bothers me about the ghost children is that the pink palace is said to be about 150 years old I think that the movie takes place in the early 2000s but the ghost boy says in one of the scenes “thou art still living” this type of language was used in Shakespeare’s time witch does not line up with the boy being from the 1850s.
I really kind of still a little suspicious the Beltran wouldn’t try to put so much with the games and made coraline think she was safe all along
The Fangirl, why is there an other Wybie? did wyborne go to the real world?
I found this channel and been watching so many vidss. subb and now im glad i found this channel
The Fangirl 😄
one thing why is mr. bubinski blue
Remy Leyva he is radiated because of cleanig up radiation that's why he had amedal
He helped in the Chernobyl cleanup. That's what his medal's for
Pretty sure the book takes priority to what is and isn't canon.
I just finished watching all of your coraline theories
lol, thank you! I wish I had a medal and an apology note for people who can listen to me ramble on for that many videos.
Could you please do a theory on the Beldams 'clue' for Coraline when she looks for the ghost eyes? Cause I have a feeling that it has a more sinister meaning.
This is a better explanation of your theories than the “core theory” video
Hi Mia again you might be on to something here that the timeline fits perfectly I think the cat is protecting Coraline just like Mr Bobkinsky may have lost his child.
while he was in the circus act when he moved to the pink palace apartments
Another thing I think the cat was trying to protect coraline bc when she goes to try and hide the key the cat seems to already know that she would head for the well and tries to stop her but he can only speak in the other world, the Cat does try to reason with coraline but coraline is very stubborn and he could only do buy so much.
Nice timeline, you really explained yourself well. Also the fairy makes my thought on the cat possibly being a Puca work. If the Beldam caught a fairy to feed off, perhaps the Puca was also drawn to her. But instead of killing it she was enamored by it's behavour and smarts. But then they had a falling out during lean years when she might have tried or actually fed off some of it's energy and it used a cat form to go to the real world much more often to keep itself alive. Just a thought not an official theory on Coraline or the cat.
That makes sense. U know when coraline goes through the door only to find her parents missing? Could the parents already be in the pink palace limbo?
Yeah but the cat said he didn't want to go in the tunnel, and the other video you said the doll could see what people are doing and could spy on the cat. The cat had tore the eyes out of the other mother which had meant in my opinion that the cat had enough of the other mother, once a kid had moved in the cat had hoped that she would not see her way and she didn't. The cat just needed someone to help get rid of her. Anyways this is just my opinion so don't get any hate comments on this. This was one of the best videos of coraline, The Fangirl lots of support!
But if mrs. Lovett was working for the bedlam why wouldn't she allow families with children to move in?
Remember, even though the Other Whybie did save Coraline from the mirror room ( I don't want to know what happened in there ), he did still trick her in to going into another level of the Other World. And when Coraline did the piano song with the Other Father the song seems to be giving her a message and a warning, so, whose side are the Other Father and Other Whybie actually on ?
my mom told me that cats have been known to travel between worlds
i know this is unrelated to this video but has anyone else noticed the medal that mr bobinsky wears is a liquidator medal which is for helping with the clean up after the chernobyl nuclear disaster
Hi I am thinking of you should do a theory of grandma’s missing Sister
That ghost boy has to relate to the boy with ice cream!!!!!!!😲😲😲
skittle tree because it literally looks the same so guess yeah
If coraline is stuck in the other world is there any way for her to escape, like idk making all the house guests go against the beldam, and kinda force her to let them free???
I know this is the timeline on the ‘Coraline’ story we know, but should you/we apply US history. Oregon was originally land of the British, the Polk agreed on taking half at the 49th parallel. Could that be used in the location, timeline, and when the house was built?
Have you ever thought that maybe since the beldam hasn’t eaten in decades, that she was on the verge of dying? And when coraline and wybe killed the hand that was foreshadowing that the beldam has died? Idk but that’s an interesting thought tho
I'm watching the movie as I type this. I can't believe I missed this and I don't know if you got this information or not. BUT when Coraline meets Wybie for the second time when he's on a motorcycle, playing with a slug or whatnot...he talks with Coraline about Grandma's missing twin sister. While they talk, the cat is seen on the roof with a discerning face. He then looks at the doll that's in Coraline's room and whimpers as if he had done something wrong. Wybie is then called home by his grandma.
I find this scene to be a little sketchy now that I have paid a lot of attention to the details in the movie.
Another thing I've noticed is that when the Other Wybie and Coraline go to the mouse circus, the ball the lead circus mouse is on is the same exact pattern as one of the (ghost) children's eyes are.
I enjoy your work! Keep it up :)
I found something in coraline the movie that proves fan girls theory that the belldam feeds off of love from the children that come into her world. It's at almost the end of the movie were she thinks she escapes for real this time and she's through the portal and you can hear the beldam banging and screaming on the other side of the door and I heard something that struck my ears the second time I watched it the other mother says "don't leave ill die without you" so does that mean with out corolines love the bedlam will die and disappear. I thought that really supported fan girls theory on the beldam feeding of the magic of true love of a mother and a child
What if when coraline broke one of the jars it represented her breaking the cycle? Thus furthering the idea that the dayes represented the children?
If they are all in the limbo world then who’s in the real world?And when Coraline gets trapped in the limbo world do her parents wait for her to come back like Mrs.Lovat’s family
if the pink palace is really the limbo and not the real world, would Mrs. Lovett (spelling???) really be the missing twin who went into the otherworld? say like both of the girls believe the other is missing because they dont know which is the real world.
I've noticed that many things in the Beldams Lair are a fusia pink color.Why do u think that is?Also, I think I've figured out why the cat goes through the sign portal at the end of the movie. Maybe that is a portal to the real world and the cat is going through it so he can lure more kids into her trap.
What if the cat turned into the cat by seeing what the beldam did to the other kid so he traded his life for the protection of his son this is why wybie can get so close to the pink palace without anything bad happening and and why he falls him around and why he try’s tricking coralline into going to the other world
I find it interesting that the childrens souls are found with Spink and Forcible, and Bobinski, and the eay the childrens wings look like the dogs wings. Kind of bat like.
Did Spink and Forcible and Bobinski participate in their abductions? Why do they keep their souls?
are you going to make a part 11
Eventually, but I don't have a release date yet. I'm trying to get my core theory out first, and it is SOOOO long that it's taking forever to tackle.
I Love the theory when The other father sung The song
I don't understand why everybody thinks the cat is Wybies ancestor? I mean like why? And I believe Coraline is in the real world, and has escaped the other world. But I believe the beldam and the cat are thinking of ways to bring Coraline back to the other world.
Also, the cat is the one who RIPS THE BELDAMS EYES
Rip mr. Bubinsky 1904-1944
Okay these videos are awesome but I’m still not seeing evidence for the cat being a) the beldam’s familiar and b) wibey’s father. There is just none in the source text that I can see besides the insinuation that the cat is secretly in on the beldam’s plan and the cat being voiced by a Black actor. Film theories are awesome but sometimes they can stray into fan fiction. I know this video is somewhat old so maybe you have some newer thoughts on this piece of the theory? Very much enjoying your coralline work as I make my way through this hefty playlist :)
Before watching the video I have to say she's doll trapped in the beldums an because it looks like there's a portal in the well and she threw it in the well
What about the boy in the otherworld who first appears
I love your Coraline theory that she doesn’t leave the limbo pink palace, but regarding Mr.B theres a wiki page that explains the medal he wears is from the Chernobyl clean up coraline.wikia.com/wiki/Sergei_Alexander_Bobinsky under the “Trivia” section, I still agree with what’s been said in the core theory vide and hope this info can be part of more theories
I love these theories !!
I have a theory
since wybie was in the other mothers world maybe miss lovat I don't know how to spell her name but maybe that is why she let Coraline and her parents move into the pink palace she traded Coraline for wybie because since u said they had to go to the other world for the other mother to put u in it so maybe she traded Coraline for wybie why? because she didn't want her family being trapped again
I believe exactly what the movie says . It's just a kids show .. like all it is is pupets and dolls being filmed ..
Puppets *
In the real world there is a household behind the pink palace but in the other mothers world the house is missing
'and because of that they end up being trapped in the limbo pink palace from then on.' What if that's where the parents actually went to along with every other (or at least most of the) tenant of the house.
Edit: that's what she said anyway. Whoops.
so im geussing that beldam actuly lost her eyes so she hast to use button eyes and thats why the ghost kids were wearing button eyes bc they lost there eyes bc beldam ripped them off
How about the cat was turned into a cat for escaping but before he got out the little door the beldam was able to use a magic to turn him
The cat stop Skaarland from going to the other world so therefore he was she didn’t know what to get Jen there is bad he’s gone and he doesn’t want them to go there to the other world
look at the limbo wrorld gardon
they couldn’t have moved in in 1921 cause they aren’t nearly that old! they look younger than ms. lovat
I think the twin which went to the other world traveled the same way Coraline did if it wasn’t then why would the door be locked and have wall paper over it
The door could have locked to the other side while The twin was inside so her mother could have known she disappeared in there:locked the door and covered it with wall paper and didn’t throw the key away because she didn’t think there was no purpose then told Wybie’s grandma she went missing.What if The twin is still locked inside the *other* world 🌍
how was coraline forever trapped in the other world she got out through the door
:OOO
😲what if his dad took place of wybe and turned into the cat and is suppose to take kids to her but sort of betrays her
My theory is that the other mother is the real mother
What if the ghosts are the kids of Bobinskie and Marion and ms.spink Forciable
But what about coraline father
but wait if coraline is trapped in limbo along with the other tenants wouldn't that mean that wybie and his grandma are in the limbo pink palace world so how did they get there same with her dad
Elva Berg no wybie and his grandma aren't real in the limbo pink palace they are the beldams illusion to make coraline think she's back home but she just went through the wrong portal and it wasnt even her fault it was set up by the beldam
I have a theory I saw in the movie that when other mother was making the doll to give to coraline that her hands looked familar from were coraline almost gets dragged in the well and after that cat scratched the bedlam so is that what the bedlam really looks like if you think about it would make sense because if the belldam showd what she really looks like kids would fear so she would not get the true loves magic from the kids. I also have another theory see the other mother looks like corilines real mom exept with botton eyes coraline stated that to her "real mom" at breakfast so is the other mother posing to be corilons mom because the other mother can morph into coralines real mother according to the movie so she probably could have done it because at the beginning the mother seems mean and rude but the end when praline wins the mother seems nice and normal those are my theoris
but the cat and wybee were shown in the same scene
I hate to do this, but I think I might have debunked either your residents living in the limbo pink palace theory, or your candy jar dates theory. Look closely at the medal Mr. Bobinski has on during the scene when Coraline first meets him, or even throughout the movie, I think he always has it on. It is a metal given to the liquidators for Chernobyl when it exploded, which happened in 1986. Based on this, here are my conclusions:
1. The candy jar dates theory is wrong. Bobinski moved to the pink palace after his service as a liquidator for Chernobyl. If I'm not mistaking, the liquidators were fire fighters. Bobinski could have been a fire fighter in any of the stations that came to help when the facility exploded, whether it be one of the 37 that came on the first night, or a different one later on. Being so close to the radiation could be why his skin is blue (I'm sure that doesn't happen in real life, but the creators might have used it to convey a sickly feel to him), and could have made him unable to work as a fire fighter, so he left and tried pursuing a circus career, which could have been a hobby of his while in the fire department. He started in Europe with no luck, so he went to America in hopes to make it big, and ended up moving to the pink palace when he failed. His pride and desperation for making his act work could be him trying to hold onto his last passion.
2. You could debunk the "residents in the pink palace limbo" theory from the first conclusion as well. You said something along the lines of "people in the real world couldn't see those in the pink palace limbo, and vise versa" in one video, correct? Well, during that scene where Coraline first meets Bobinski, she hasn't gone into the other world yet. Bobinski said that his mice told her to stay away from the little door. Coraline was confused and said something along the lines of "there's only brick behind the little door." And since Bobinski is claiming his mice are talking to him before Coraline even goes into the other world, he could have developed some sort of mental issue when he was in Chernobyl, causing him to have delusions like this (or possibly making him vulnerable to the beldam controlling him to a degree via the mice, I'm not sure).
3. This one could debunk either theory. He got the metal at some sort of yard sale, pawn shop, auction, from a friend or loved one, etc (either meaning he got the metal before moving into the pink palace or meaning that he isn't in the limbo pink palace). He wasn't a liquidator, he might have known someone who was and was gifted it. He also could have bought it somewhere thinking it was a cool looking metal, and since the writing is in Russian, he could try to pass it off as some sort of circus achievement to those who can't read Russian, and to pass himself off as a hero to those who can.
The only time when the portal comes alive when there is moonlight at night and I think the spider came from the house is the beldame to lure children of capturing the fairy in her trap by using dna from parents to replica them vice versa cheers Mia martin
I was with you until the end where the belle-dame is posing as the real mother because it didn't explain how the parents got trapped in the other world's snow globe. To me, it would make more sense for her parents to have also been sucked into the limbo Pink Palace (going off the movie) when their book was picked up by the big publisher. From there, after having their dreams realized, they wouldn't want to leave, but probably wouldn't have responded too well to impersonators. So, the other mother stored them in the limbo pink palace. Still, she hadn't forgotten Coraline and after weighing her gains and losses from feeding off the parents, decided to make a quick meal off of their confidence, and then use them as a trap to lure Coraline back in. This was when she saw them in the mirror saying help, it was an illusion, and decided to go back and play the game. The parents are now already dead, so the theory of her then going on to impersonate the real mother and what not moves forward, but I just feel like the theory is a bit incomplete without addressing that piece because at some point the parents do have to somehow end up in the other world.
I like the cat theory but at the end the cat saves her by getting wybie and wybie saved coralline
I don’t think the cats anything to do with the Beldem because he warned coralline about her and her games and everyone keeps saying that omg he’s her spy but he rlly isn’t he tried to help coralline like bloody ell!
In an interview, Henry Selek says the beldam eats children’s souls not magical love. so........
why doesn't Mr. Bobinscee look Human?!
Hello The Fangirl! Me and my so called "team" (studio) have been thinking of making a live action film adaptation of Coraline for the internet. We want to base it heavily on the book but also give it our own little twist to it. We were wondering if you could do a review or theories on our film. the story/ dialogue is extremely similar from the book to our film however there are a lot of visuals that clue the viewers in more at what may be going on. I definitely think you would like our adaptation but fair warning it is not as "bright" as the kids film. This film will be PG-13. Hope to hear back from you soon.
Sincerely,
Head of Dark Garden Films- Seth Philyaw
what if the mrs lovat was the beldems sister
will you do a face reviel
I was considering it for the Coraline Core Theory, because I'm guessing it will run about 40 minutes long, and I only have so many photos to show, lol.
oh, if the beldam trapped coraline in the limbo palace remember she lost her hand, why wasn't the original mother woth a hand still???
with
So, I think I watched all/most of you Coralline videos, and I agree with her being trapped, but if her " parents " are really just the Beldam, then where are Coraline real parents?
At home, with no clue where she went.
Why does whybiey want corolines doll back in the movie
If the beldam makes carbon copies of everybody she encounters, that proves that the two women moved in when they were young ladies. Otherwise, the beldam would have no way to have re-created them when they were younger. Perhaps this says something about aging in the other world versus the real world.