Ya Boi Yeah I feel like he just wanted to keep the score as low as possible. It’s one of those albums where IMO for most people who are not a Stan or a hater it would be about a 7 or a 6, and that seems to be Anthony’s opinion too if you listen to what he’s actually saying. Giving it a 5 however just about allows him to continue the narrative that “Eminem bad rapper now”.
I mean, he put Darkness in his best tracks of the week, so he clearly doesn't mind giving Em high praise. He clearly just rates what he feels and anyone looking for some ulterior motive in his reviews is deluding themselves. I mean he even mentions that some tracks he had to convince himself not to skip, though the whole experience was an improvement on Kamikaze. 5 is a fair score.
Tom Williams Sure he likes an Eminem song here and there, but I feel like an album with skippable songs could easily be a 6 or 7 out of 10, especially considering the way he speaks about it here. The fact that it’s an improvement on Revival and Kamikaze for him isn’t really saying much, he really seemed to hate those albums. Giving Kamikaze a 4 and this a 5 doesn’t really reflect the improvement he actually describes in the review. The flaws that Revival and Kamikaze have don’t really dominate this album, they just turn up often enough to not give it an 8 or a 9 or anything. And you can’t deny that Anthony prefers the narrative that Eminem fell off this decade. After giving MMLP2 a really positive review he never really mentions it and just states that all Eminem’s projects since his “first three” haven’t been good. He’ll give some songs as well as this album a relatively positive review too but in the end just end up saying “nah not good enough” by giving it a 5, even though he clearly doesn’t think it’s a bad album. (And yes, I consider a 5/10, or 2.5/5 stars to be a bad album)
@@ozzymandias8137 I still like the song a lot, and I like THE Skylar Grey hook (for on Eminem albums there is but only one), but it was another example of literally the exact same Skylar Grey hook lol
@@Mistakia I’m not good at explaining it but all those hooks have a similar sound. They all sound like her hook on I Need a Doctor. It’s a sound I really like so I enjoy listening to it over and over again but her hook on Black Magic sounds very similar
Music to be murdered by: 5/10 What happened on may 10th 1969? James earl ray pleaded guilty to assasinating MLK JR Where was MLK killed? Memphis Tennessee. What are the first three letters in Tennessee? Ten. Therefore, this album is a 10/10.
I don’t see what your assertion that Iran “Did the right thing” by shooting down a civilian airliner because “people are not meant to fly in metal birds” has to do with Eminem’s album.
great review Anthony but did you really have to give your opinion and then assign a numerical score to the album based on that opinion? seems a little too far tbh
I know it's nice because he's calling it slightly above average which is acknowledging the few validly good parts of the works. A lot of people seem to make the phrase 'Above Average' basically synonymous with trash
Lord Takyon I loved Godzilla, you gon learn, premonition, those kinda nights, stepdad, marsh. But the songs with Don Toliver and Young M.A. were horrific, little engine was trash and yah yah was just insanely bad. I listen to the album everyday, but with so many songs being trash, I give it a 5
@@Dylan-xf4em How can you listen to the album everyday when you say almost half the album is trash? Or are you only keeping those specific songs in rotation?
@@paynekaufmann403 Actually most people that "hate" him are 14 year old white kids that listen to odd future and uzi. But yeah most of his stans are also white people that only listen to Eminem and call Tupac the goat without listening to his music.
I liked the review for the most part, but I thought the last 3 minutes where you were holding a tiki torch shouting “blood and soil” was a little unnecessary.
I was really excited to see your review of the new Eminem album, but I was surprised to see 13 minutes of your un-interrupted ceremony for being promoted to grand wizard. It was also a little jarring that for the last 2 minutes you read out my home address and my family’s names in order from oldest to youngest.
manuelgm he said “I was really excited to see your review of the new Eminem album, but I was surprised to see 13 minutes of your un-interrupted ceremony for being promoted to grand wizard. It was also a little jarring that for the last 2 minutes you read out my home address and my family's names in order from oldest to youngest.”
Should I drop it and Donald Trump probably not but that’s all I got to come up with a solid plot. Got a plan now I got a hatchet like a damn Apache with a tomahawk I'ma walk inside a mosque on Ramadan and say a prayer that every time Melania talks. She gets her mua- ah ima stop, but we better give Obama props cause what we got in office now is a kamikaze that’ll probably cause a nuclear holocaust and while the drama pops and he waits for shit to quiet down and he’ll just gas his plane up and fly around til the bombing stops.
Here's an army shot, for Charlie's top. Nickie threw a Hail Mary, you're not even *partly* Pac. I wonder how many mollys popped in the parking lot Before you came to ruin your career, like PAPA DOC!
@@ralissedarysv2497 PRE SCHOOL??!!!! This is a new level of arrogance and hate. Your just pyur hating on him. The best rapper. The goat. The rapmaster. The rap god. Let me see your line that's better than em.
I really enjoyed this review, that was until those last couple minutes. Was it necessary to say the Armenian genocide was justified? I feel like thats a little much.
Johnny Bravo look at it this Way while i agree Marshall mathers lp 2 is a lot better than Lil pumps album he gives albums a score of how good they do what they are supposed to do. Lil pumps album was supposed to have a lot of hits with it did. It had atleast 6 Huge hitsongs so it pretty much did what it was supposed to do and s bit more. Eminems album Got rated on the quality though and 7 was a good rating for that album i would probaly give it 7,5
When I first heard this album, I initially thought it was decent, but I found it to be lacking substance in a few areas. Then, it grew on me overtime and I listened to it a few more times and now I like it a lot more. I initially thought it was too much of a retread of Kamikaze, but when I took that notion out, it became a better album with time for me. Not every track is a winner, I did find tracks like Those Kinda Nights and Never Love Again to be kind of...blah, and I like the hook to Leaving Heaven, but most of the song was pretty underwhelming. However, I liked most of the stuff on there, even if the horror theme was inconsistent. I can understand why that may be a problem for some people, but I see this more as an Eminem album than a Slim Shady one, and I liked the various topics that were used in the songs. Some of my favorite tracks include Stepdad, Godzilla, Little Engine, Marsh, and Lock It Up, which has one of the greatest features Em has ever had in his songs in Anderson .Paak, whom I have recently become a fan of in recent memory. It is dumb in some places, but I find most of this album to be pretty strong overall, and even when it gets dumb, it never gets Encore levels of dumb for me (although songs like Rain Main and Ass Like That are a guilty pleasure for me). I give this one an 8/10.
he didn’t mention the line where he says he’s getting head like a pillow pet. and that’s what i’m upset about (edit) yes eminem actually said this on unaccommodated
That's not an unpopular opinion. That's most people's favourite track. I find most Em fans just like when he talks literal, in a simple flow, about his life. It's super boring to me "BUT BRO I CAN RELATE!!". Gay.
I feel like this is a fair review, in terms of giving the album praise where praise is due and not getting caught up in the wave of just hating because it’s Eminem, while also giving it fair criticism where that is due also. Good job
Mister M Facts, and I hate the term, but Em has some real haters, more than any other rap artist I’ve seen so far, at least any of his stature. But I guess it makes sense considering how absurd and rabid his stans are. Wish people could be more objective tho
@@MrRzkr balanced review blah blah great points blah blah why'd you say the n word 56 times tho, thought that was a weird choice blah blah reported, disliked, subscribed
Dang Anthony, I respect your decision to give this album a 10, but did you have to say "it's the greatest thing to happen in earth since the Holocaust?"
Why are you twisting his words ? He said Hiroshima and even emphasized it. Just because both starts with H doesn't mean they are the same just like every Asians and Jews are same-same but different. smh
It's not a needledrop Eminem review without at least a minute of Anthony looking deadpan at the camera reading sick lines from the songs as if they're bad lines.
@@datboi945 omg r u dumb that is the worst comparision He showcased his lyrical ability through those corny lines and puns. And that has been done by many and I mean many great rappers U little dogshit
This album is his literally his best since a longgg time. I enjoyed every track. He’s 25 yrs into his career and I’m way more than impressed. Production was almost flawless. It’s my 5th favorite Em album. Yes, however good recovery is I don’t go back and play that as much as I bump this one. Replay value is just huge.
I’m disappointed the memes in the comment section haven’t changed with the decade And I’m disappointed in melon for saying Eminem is the greatest white man since Obama wtf?
I KNOW. He refused to acknowledge ‘CAN’T SAY’ on ASTROWORLD and didn’t mention him here, I’m sure he’ll find some way to avoid it if he reviews JACKBOYS
Can't fault the guy for trying something outside his comfort zone. He included a few trap rappers and production that he generally wouldn't be used to so I appreciate him for that
Jaime yeah but he hated pop music and has an Ed Sheeran feature and now he’s backpedaling on calling Tyler the Creator sacrilegious.. Which by the way is a great line on Kamikaze... meh
@@dfeezzy2 he always had pop features his greatest song has Dido on the chorus and it was 20 years ago and going at Tyler was a weird situation cause Tyler was on tour with him a while back and they were friends kamikaze was dope but he sounded very butthurt on it so melon is saying that it s refreshing to hear him a little less biter on this one
saying "thats an awfully hot coffee pot" and pouring boiling hot coffee on your naked body until your skin started to melt for 13 minutes isn't a review, anthony.
I feel like eminem's writing has definitely suffered from his own success. His early stuff clearly draws on past experiences as a child and young adult, and his middle stuff addresses the perils of fame and his personal struggles with alcoholism and his relationship with his family. The more recent stuff where he discusses his relationships with his fans (outside of Stan, obviously) feels like he's trying to draw from his life in the same way and it's coming off kind of holier-than-thou, which is the exact opposite of his original brand. Edit: to be clear, I think it's pretty obvious that he's trying REALLY SUPER HARD not to do this, given all the political material he's been covering over the last three albums. My point was more that he used to draw a lot more from his personal life, which has (hopefully) stabilized a great deal. It seems like he has a harder time with a more sociological POV, that's all. It's not like it's impossible to do this well, it's just not what he's known for.
How i see it is that he's trying to push himself lyrically too much and wants to see how far he can take it, but in the process ends up having weaker content
@@auggiedoggie4968 ever since proof died he kind of shut himself off from the public and stuck with his close group of friends. Honestly you cant blame him too much
@@tofuteh2348 that's a weak excuse honestly. He has kids, friends...there's a whole world that's open to him. Hell, even if he shut down Disneyland for a day and took his daughters and labelmates out for a day would be an improvement. People die everyday, B.
I give this album a 8 tbh I only hated 2 tracks Fantano is just reading the lyrics and not actually listening and nitpicking bars that are a little corny and those bars are intentional and most rappers have 10x more cornier bars than that.
Fantano looks like one of those pirates from terraria
🤣lol thanks for that
glad you said this
Them bitches were strong as shit
Lmaooo
Are you related to Arsene Wenger ? 😂
"at the end of the day hes white .. im white we look out for each other....strong 10" .. so thats how it is now melon ?
Melon History X
hahahahahaha omg normally these troll comments don’t get me no more but damn hahahaha
This is the funniest one by far
Hahahahahahahaha
God bless you man for this comment😁😅
“Could have been a lot worse” has to be one of the worst compliments you can ever receive
Not even a compliment.
I bet Eminem would be fucking estatic that he got that good of a compliment from melon boy.
Eminem fans will take it as a holy fucking grail tho.
Karmen Võ well it’s better than most rap albums in awhile. It’s not incredible but it’s good.
Jye Taylor stop it, get help.
"I'm only giving it a 4 because there wasn't enough N words"
Dude wtf
🤣🤣🤣
Alot of lines went over the melon, I'd give this a 8.25 objectively. Personally, a 7.
@@GreyerSkiez agree with your objective rating, personally it's an 8.
@@GreyerSkiez this deserved an 6
I'm just happy to know em can now blend
In more features,many albums are better than this tho
Dude you got me, I thought Anthony really said that 😂
This is the most positive 5/10 review I’ve ever seen
Ya Boi Yeah I feel like he just wanted to keep the score as low as possible. It’s one of those albums where IMO for most people who are not a Stan or a hater it would be about a 7 or a 6, and that seems to be Anthony’s opinion too if you listen to what he’s actually saying.
Giving it a 5 however just about allows him to continue the narrative that “Eminem bad rapper now”.
I mean, he put Darkness in his best tracks of the week, so he clearly doesn't mind giving Em high praise. He clearly just rates what he feels and anyone looking for some ulterior motive in his reviews is deluding themselves. I mean he even mentions that some tracks he had to convince himself not to skip, though the whole experience was an improvement on Kamikaze. 5 is a fair score.
Ysiv review for logic was also pretty positive 5/10
Tom Williams Sure he likes an Eminem song here and there, but I feel like an album with skippable songs could easily be a 6 or 7 out of 10, especially considering the way he speaks about it here. The fact that it’s an improvement on Revival and Kamikaze for him isn’t really saying much, he really seemed to hate those albums. Giving Kamikaze a 4 and this a 5 doesn’t really reflect the improvement he actually describes in the review. The flaws that Revival and Kamikaze have don’t really dominate this album, they just turn up often enough to not give it an 8 or a 9 or anything.
And you can’t deny that Anthony prefers the narrative that Eminem fell off this decade. After giving MMLP2 a really positive review he never really mentions it and just states that all Eminem’s projects since his “first three” haven’t been good. He’ll give some songs as well as this album a relatively positive review too but in the end just end up saying “nah not good enough” by giving it a 5, even though he clearly doesn’t think it’s a bad album. (And yes, I consider a 5/10, or 2.5/5 stars to be a bad album)
Yessir
anthony you can't just rap the lyrics to lose yourself that's not a review
😆
Haha it's funny because that is not what happened in the video!!! Wacky!!!
Melodica Dude stfu
you mention that but not him saying MLK doesn't deserve a holiday because white people invented time
Brett You stfu bitch
Dude, nobody wants to see your coin collection. I thought this was a review.
I just want another COIN COIN album
“You wanna see how many I can fit in my mouth?”
That just took away valuable time from an otherwise good review and he nearly choked to death.
*Toss a coin to your melon*
@@WK12112 I thought you said, "Wanna see how many times I can fit in my mouth" which would've have been even better 😂
Bruh lmao
“How many hooks with Skylar Grey are you going to do that sound EXACTLY LIKE THIS?”
*Sweats in Side B*
Seriously, I enjoyed a decent amount of MTBMB Side B but I groaned when it kicked off with Black Magic
@@ozzymandias8137 I still like the song a lot, and I like THE Skylar Grey hook (for on Eminem albums there is but only one), but it was another example of literally the exact same Skylar Grey hook lol
@@hi00118 how is it the same as her other hooks?
@@Mistakia I’m not good at explaining it but all those hooks have a similar sound. They all sound like her hook on I Need a Doctor. It’s a sound I really like so I enjoy listening to it over and over again but her hook on Black Magic sounds very similar
@@ozzymandias8137 black magic was a better verse by skylar in em songs imo
Anthony, you can’t just say “im more of a skittle guy so 0/10” that’s not fair
You're probably too proud of that joke
especially when his reasoning is he "doesn't like browns in the mix, both with candy and society"
Ya Boi White Chedda he really did this
Wow 2 really over done jokes in one. You've outdone yourself
TOONCAST you come up with a better and more original joke then. Come on. I’m waiting
Giving this album a 10/10 because you listened to it while actually murdering someone seems like a weird choice Anthony
I’m commenting just to be the first comment on this comment.
Who tf did he murder?
@@Competent_ he murdered Thatistheplan
@@Competent_ mgk?
@@Competent_ logic
It was a decent review until you said the album was terrible because it features black people on it. You took it too far, Melon.
I'd say he over stepped his boundaries with the "jewish people control the media" rant
What is happening in this whole comment section 😂😂😂
@@grabs_you5954 that's what I'm wondering! 😂
@@snoozyq9576 newfriends detected
@@grabs_you5954 y'all must be new lo
Talking about how hot Eminem's daughters are is not an review
Careful bro
Don't you remember what happened with mgk?
@@karumotoart5040 nothing lol. Mgk diss was better
@@halogod0298
"His fkin beard is weird"
"we know that you're the greatest rapper alive"
yeah bro better diss 💀💀
@@halogod0298 your profile matches your comment. Or what you basically look like in general when you thought about commenting this
@@halogod0298 mgk literally cries about how his album is getting shit on cause of em beef lol
Eminem has gone from 2 to 4 to 5. At this pace he only has about 4 or 5 years until he gets a 10.
Feel like he’ll plateau in the 6 area at most
Progress is progress
IMMA
BOUT TO
GET A
MFING
10
WITH MAH
STACCATO
FLOW
Only took Cudi 3- 4 years to go from a 0 to a 10 🤷🏿♂️
The idea of a 50-something Marshall Mathers somehow making the best music of his career just made me laugh uncontrollably.
You would have given this a 10/10 if Eminem was white
WHAT IF HE WAS WHITE WHITE WHITE WHITE WHITE WHITE
Nah it would be a 10 if he was a white cis male. But alas
Who’s gonna tell him? Haha bro Eminem is white you idiot
@@vosvenieks4EVER have to hope that's a joke
@@vosvenieks4EVER r/WOOOOOOOOOOOSH
chanting “white america” for 10 minutes isn’t a review melon
Yes it is
Ha it's hilarious because that's not what happened in the video.
HAHHAHAHHAAHHAHHAHAHHAHA
What?
primo nl honestly racism is sos stupid
Music to be murdered by:
5/10
What happened on may 10th 1969? James earl ray pleaded guilty to assasinating MLK JR
Where was MLK killed? Memphis Tennessee.
What are the first three letters in Tennessee? Ten.
Therefore, this album is a 10/10.
👏👏👏
No
This should be the top comment not those stale ass overused memes up there.
@@akielsteewart8577 that's an awfully hot coffee pot
@@ABC-op2nz feel like I should I drop it on donald trump
Melon, you aren’t the real slim shady, please sit down
He’s sitting down in all of his videos
He is 🙂
PotatoBurd they’re both white, they look alike
Best comment
this aged well
Great review, could’ve toned it down with the whole ‘Rosa Parks belonged at the back of the bus’ thing but aside from that, well put.
W
What is it with people click baiting other peoples video by shitting out controversial lines 😂
Never forget this man gave Lil pump a 9/10. He lost all credibility that day
@@CR7Update e
So original dude hell yeah
Anthony, filming yourself hiding behind a curtain saying “Where’s Waldo” just because you have a striped shirt doesn’t make this a review.
🤣🔥🔥
anus i love this comment section
thanks anus
why did i immediately think of Squidward with "no Patrick, mayonnaise is not an instrument"...
*Where's Wally? Who's this Waldo character you Americans speak of? 😂
After all these years... WE FOUND WALDO
💀
Good one... 😂🤣💀
You realize Eminem’s not even black right. So when you call him the n word, it doesn’t even make sense.
Clarence Nit I fucking love melon’s comment section
MorbidMaddi same
Ok this ones top tier
@@madison3514 that's sarcasm correct? These copy paste jokes are beyond terrible.
@@CkyGuy69 they ruined the comment section on here 😑
saying "your beard is weird" for 13 mins is not a review melon
It is wierd tho
@@jhin4474 it isnt a review tho
It is weird
@@kalemorrow2243 not a review
It is very weird
I was really moved when Anthony tearfully cried along to the lyric "I-I hate my-my stepdad" for the whole last half of the video
@Boe 612 you salty cause yall dont have fathers to hate
I am black and cant stand my step mom
@@bakicicek8866 BRO THAT'S OVERKILL 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
I was listening to this review until he called 'NO REGRETS' a boring song.
Shit goes hard. One of the best songs on here
Yeah , don't know how musically it's not good as he says . I personally loved it . It sounds awesome.
Don toliver killed the hook. Shit goes hard
No regrets is fcking fire
That is one of my favorite songs from the album
I don’t know Melon.
Granting Eminem the N-Word Pass feels like too big of a reward for this ngl.
Looool
Fry Szopen we know, it's a joke
@Fry Szopen r/wooosh
@Fry Szopen his gf is black though, maybe she gave eminem one on behalf of anthony.
Fry Szopen thats the joke you numbnut
Melon screaming the n word at Em doesn't make sense at all, he isn't black, and it's definitely not a review. I give this review a 4/10
But eminem is black?
Light or strong?
Ralph ohhhh makes sense
No Marshall Mathers is a fucking Martian... don't forget that.
I will give 2/10
"Eminem has his moments but spends too much time featuring rappers who aren't white. 5/10 " Really fantano that's how we're judging this now?
retrosuspect yes
Hahaha funny
YEAAAaaa hows this fuck boi have so many subs LOL his criticisms are totally ridiculous.
@@RavenCroftLoft he knows his shit
@@moeloehoe Like what?
"I'm unavoidable, I'm unavailable, I'm on a toilet bowl."
Poetic.
indeed.
This is literally what he used to write in his shady days
And the fans be impressed by this lol
@@bruh......2005 its like some 45 sec where em shows off his fast rap skills and u cant expect em to rap about something everytime
it's supposed to be funny, i dont know why people want super fake deep lyrics at all times like the dude in the vid, its so pretentious
I don’t see what your assertion that Iran “Did the right thing” by shooting down a civilian airliner because “people are not meant to fly in metal birds” has to do with Eminem’s album.
They did it by mistake
Anprim fantano here
Be original for once...so tired of these copy paste sheeple "comedians"
@@karimpardayev We know, but Anthony saying it made him happy because "it was against god" is disturbing
@Waistband Tuck it's a joke that's gone on for like 10 years.. it's pretty old now mydudes!
great review Anthony but did you really have to give your opinion and then assign a numerical score to the album based on that opinion? seems a little too far tbh
Zach Webb nice
HE DONT MISS!!
Nice
Nice
Nice
This is the most positive 5/10 review I’ve ever seen lol
I know it's nice because he's calling it slightly above average which is acknowledging the few validly good parts of the works. A lot of people seem to make the phrase 'Above Average' basically synonymous with trash
I loved the album but I would give it a 5 too, because it’s about rating every song altogether.
Lord Takyon I loved Godzilla, you gon learn, premonition, those kinda nights, stepdad, marsh. But the songs with Don Toliver and Young M.A. were horrific, little engine was trash and yah yah was just insanely bad. I listen to the album everyday, but with so many songs being trash, I give it a 5
@@Dylan-xf4em How can you listen to the album everyday when you say almost half the album is trash? Or are you only keeping those specific songs in rotation?
Z B right? He compliments the album and gives it such a low score?
Melon would have rated the album 10/10 if it was called "A Butterfly to be Pimped by"
Why are you mad an album was properly reviewed 😂😂😂??? TPAB is what Em WISH he could still do 😎😎😎
@@keithlangfordjr.689 r/woosh moment
a 10/10 because eminem is “a well respected white man” isn’t fair melon.
Well respected... I wish.
CaptainThor2000 respected by whites, most African Americans hate him and think he’s corny, understandably of course.
@@paynekaufmann403 Actually most people that "hate" him are 14 year old white kids that listen to odd future and uzi. But yeah most of his stans are also white people that only listen to Eminem and call Tupac the goat without listening to his music.
@King's Rampage sorry pal guess thats the way it is
@@paynekaufmann403 He's corny, but don't say “most”.
Damn can't believe this was the first ever 12/10 album just because Eminem revealed he's biracial like his father Logic
Logic? His father?
Less Is More yeah, and her mother is Barack Obama
Rómulo Figueroa yea, sorry I forgot
If his dad is biracial how can he be biracial
Hahah🤣
To me the album is great, but I'll rate it 0/10 cuz he hasn't released "My Salsa"
Still waiting on that lol
“Next single will be my salsa, my salsa, salsa, salsa...”
“my salsa makes all the pretty girls want to dance and take off their underpants...”
HuwoOwOowOO look out for my next single it's called my salsa
Eating my salsa with mom's spaghetti 🤤🤤😋
I have a feeling that the next eminem album is either gonna be a light 7, or a red flannel
@ECCO MTBMBs producer was dre lol
@ECCO actually holy shit yes I hope his next album is exclusively produced by dre
Tbh I think his next album could be atleast a 9
@ECCO unfortunately we're not in 1999 anymore, so I don't know how well that would work out
@@alm3368 i think it's gonna be 4 or something.
Might as well start the stats for 2020:
1/10: 0
2/10: 0
3/10: 0
4/10: 0
5/10: 1
6/10: 0
7/10: 0
8/10: 0
9/10: 0
10/10: 0
NOT GOOD: 0
Don't forget he gave MBDTF a 6 again
@@kanon3335 we don't talk about that
What were the stats for 2019?
I want to see this comment In every single album review, keep liking it boys
Lovely balance
Thank god. I was almost forced to form my own opinion on this album.
.
Super Kawaii Kitty simply false.
@Super Kawaii Kitty Glad you know the collective opinion of all music listeners.
Super Kawaii Kitty on the hate train on twitter? Because the album is getting a lot of good response from people not only fans
yikes
Melon, calling Eminem a fake white man while screaming “White Power” for the entire video while waving a Confederate flag is not a review 😔
Why does Fantano hate Eminem?
@Matthew Dowling Eminem’s not a Neo nazi
These comments are amazing 😂
@@yopierre2048 o my..I can't hold it anymore😂😂😂😂😂
@Nightstalker_55_420 you can't really explain these fluctuations in prices. It is just how markets operate.
I liked the review for the most part, but I thought the last 3 minutes where you were holding a tiki torch shouting “blood and soil” was a little unnecessary.
I never thought this day would come, but it actually happened:
I found Waldo.
I found Wally (the proper and original British name)
@@franklingoodwin this
😂😂😂😂 I got halfway through this comment and thought it would be serious
@@lordnermal4361 Someone's triggered 🤣 fuck Waldo, it's Wally, you douche
franklingoodwin Are we really arguing about weather it’s Waldo or Wally? Lmao
I was really excited to see your review of the new Eminem album, but I was surprised to see 13 minutes of your un-interrupted ceremony for being promoted to grand wizard. It was also a little jarring that for the last 2 minutes you read out my home address and my family’s names in order from oldest to youngest.
Wut?
manuelgm he said “I was really excited to see your review of the new Eminem album, but I was surprised to see 13 minutes of your un-interrupted ceremony for being promoted to grand wizard. It was also a little jarring that for the last 2 minutes you read out my home address and my family's names in order from oldest to youngest.”
@@Arentings Wut?
Spoony 848 lmfao “grand wizard”
xd Jay 💀
I originally had this at a 2/10 but my rating just changed to a 5/10. Weird.
Ex Mavro me too, what the hell
the fantano effect
yung caterpillar joe
I've had it at a 6/10 the whole time
yung caterpillar Nobody asked you either. It’s the internet. People say stuff. If you don’t like it, don’t look at it.
Don’t understand how nobody is talking about Black Thought’s verse on Yah Yah. He goes absolutely nuts
imo he's one of the very few people with royce who put Em in his place on a track and em verse wasn't bad at all lol
Seriously
Review was going great until you started taking your clothes off.
CriketRogers this is the best one, needs more likes
Yoo Im screaming
wdym that was by far the best part
😂😂😂
Underrated comment just like Marsh song on this record
I'm not sure if the 5 minute rant about how you are the 'real boy in the striped pyjamas' was very tasteful melon
That's an awfully hot coffee pot.
Should I 👏 drop it 💦 on Donald Trump 😤 probably not ❌ but😲 that's all 😢 I got 💯
Should I drop it and Donald Trump probably not but that’s all I got to come up with a solid plot. Got a plan now I got a hatchet like a damn Apache with a tomahawk I'ma walk inside a mosque on Ramadan and say a prayer that every time Melania talks. She gets her mua- ah ima stop, but we better give Obama props cause what we got in office now is a kamikaze that’ll probably cause a nuclear holocaust and while the drama pops and he waits for shit to quiet down and he’ll just gas his plane up and fly around til the bombing stops.
Here's an army shot, for Charlie's top.
Nickie threw a Hail Mary, you're not even *partly* Pac.
I wonder how many mollys popped in the parking lot
Before you came to ruin your career, like PAPA DOC!
And also, fuck you, Chris D'elia.
Sincerely,
Stan.
@@alexismedor6182 THANK YOU FOR PUTTING THIS HERE!!
Maybe may taste in bars is horrible, but " I get dough like Ed Sheeran, call me the ginger bread man" is straight fire for me 😂😂😂
That line is hysterical
@@ralissedarysv2497 PRE SCHOOL??!!!! This is a new level of arrogance and hate. Your just pyur hating on him. The best rapper. The goat. The rapmaster. The rap god. Let me see your line that's better than em.
I really enjoyed this review, that was until those last couple minutes. Was it necessary to say the Armenian genocide was justified? I feel like thats a little much.
As much as I didn't enjoy/agree with this review, that was clearly a joke.
Finally, a classic Fantano comment!
*System of a Down wants to know your location*
alright this one actually made me cackle
*wOoOoOoOoOoW*
Anthony, just because Eminem is taking a “new direction” doesn’t mean you had to spend the rest of the review talking about your One Direction fan fic
Bruh😂😂😂😂
You won the internet! LOL 😂
Perfect comment
Needledrop has the weirdest comments from fans.
i laughed out loud
It’s A 5 Because He Doesn’t Say “We Tha Best Music” At The Start Of Every Song.
No its a 5 because its average
Unknown he gave lil pumps mixtape a 7 the same score as Marshall mathers lp 2 this dudes a donkey. Idk why he’s taken seriously
Unknown it’s not average stop being a sheep and jumping on the Eminem hate bandwagon
Johnny Bravo look at it this Way while i agree Marshall mathers lp 2 is a lot better than Lil pumps album he gives albums a score of how good they do what they are supposed to do. Lil pumps album was supposed to have a lot of hits with it did. It had atleast 6 Huge hitsongs so it pretty much did what it was supposed to do and s bit more. Eminems album Got rated on the quality though and 7 was a good rating for that album i would probaly give it 7,5
Then it would've been a NOT GOOD
When I first heard this album, I initially thought it was decent, but I found it to be lacking substance in a few areas. Then, it grew on me overtime and I listened to it a few more times and now I like it a lot more. I initially thought it was too much of a retread of Kamikaze, but when I took that notion out, it became a better album with time for me. Not every track is a winner, I did find tracks like Those Kinda Nights and Never Love Again to be kind of...blah, and I like the hook to Leaving Heaven, but most of the song was pretty underwhelming. However, I liked most of the stuff on there, even if the horror theme was inconsistent. I can understand why that may be a problem for some people, but I see this more as an Eminem album than a Slim Shady one, and I liked the various topics that were used in the songs. Some of my favorite tracks include Stepdad, Godzilla, Little Engine, Marsh, and Lock It Up, which has one of the greatest features Em has ever had in his songs in Anderson .Paak, whom I have recently become a fan of in recent memory. It is dumb in some places, but I find most of this album to be pretty strong overall, and even when it gets dumb, it never gets Encore levels of dumb for me (although songs like Rain Main and Ass Like That are a guilty pleasure for me). I give this one an 8/10.
Ass like that is great 😁
Rain Man fans unite
Yah yah is one of the hardest em songs ever
If you smell shit long enough, it stops smelling bad. This can be applied to music. Your brain just starts to accept it.
@@ElGaby323 Okay.
Calling yourself the ‘real slim shady’ and saying that Eminem stole your ‘damn identity’ for 13 mins is not a review melon
Lmfao
Yes it is delete this comment
Identity theft is not a joke Em!
you can’t give him a 0/10 just because he’s white, melon.
And bc her pee is bright yellow
yes he can, he's a warrior of social justice
Dray Lee I think he gave it a 5 to 6 /10 🤔
@@mulla2748 wait shit really
Nicó Taylor E3 is destroying it
Revival : 2/10
Kamikaze: 4/10
MTBMB : 6-5/10
I agreed with all your points up until you gave him a zero “because he was black”
Bing Bong 😭😭😭😭
@@kings9724 the Best part about this comment is the fact that there are no actual edits.
@@MrCHI2cool 'what is a copypasta'
This is nitpicking and biased. I win. Bye bye.
LMAO 😂😂😂😂😂
anthony, screaming 'MAKE SEGREGATION LEGAL AGAIN' isn't a review
You know I respect everyone’s opinion, but to call “Stepdad” the greatest song ever recorded may be a stretch Melon
These troll comment are killing me
Furaha Aswan Comments to be murdered by
aw man, I liked Stepdad :/
The sample is kinda good
JTM 21 euthanasia like kids in Taiwan
i have eaten so much chalk that it caused a huge blockage in my intestines and now i am paralyzed from the waist down
K
Nice
Stay grounded for good this time please
Send pics?
nice dude
he didn’t mention the line where he says he’s getting head like a pillow pet. and that’s what i’m upset about
(edit) yes eminem actually said this on unaccommodated
SCAVNGER that’s such a funny line
SCAVNGER is that real, because it made me laugh super hard
@@bigpenny8223 holy shit it is i just looked it up
This and alot of it sounds like what lil Wayne lyrics would be on his songs
cheekybananaboy that’s great, it’s not a good line but still
Unpopular opinion “no regrets” is one of the best songs on the album
Don Toliver carried hard
That's not an unpopular opinion. That's most people's favourite track. I find most Em fans just like when he talks literal, in a simple flow, about his life. It's super boring to me "BUT BRO I CAN RELATE!!". Gay.
@Ura Kanaki lmfao you're mad
@Ura Kanaki sure buddy whatever you say 😂
@Ura Kanaki that sounds like a corny Eminem bar, congrats you're a true Eminem fan
If you play this video at "2" playback speed, Melon makes another Eminem album
This comment has no replies so I’m satisfying myself
LOGETON - lol
LMAO
lmaooo fr
Do it at 2:50
I feel like this is a fair review, in terms of giving the album praise where praise is due and not getting caught up in the wave of just hating because it’s Eminem, while also giving it fair criticism where that is due also. Good job
Yeah. Too many people are either a stan or reject anything eminem. Its hard to find people who think critically abt eminem
Whoa, a legit, appropriate, non-memey take on theneedledrop comment section?
Wild
where your punchline at ??????????
Mister M Facts, and I hate the term, but Em has some real haters, more than any other rap artist I’ve seen so far, at least any of his stature. But I guess it makes sense considering how absurd and rabid his stans are. Wish people could be more objective tho
@@MrRzkr balanced review blah blah great points blah blah
why'd you say the n word 56 times tho, thought that was a weird choice blah blah
reported, disliked, subscribed
This dude looks like old logic got addicted to opium and went to audition for a where's waldo book
But is he using steroids or just fat? cant say.
you're trying too hard
@@leonthethird7494 I could try you😘
Killed me with that one 😂
I nearly died laughing at this.Thanks dude 😂😂😂
I give this album 7/10 it grew on me in past 2 years its been out.
it's a 10 out of 10
no it's a 10
@@eyosyastebeje9555 8/10 at best
“Music To Be Murdered By”
“5/10”
I think we found Grimthony Reaptano's next victim.
Only kills if it’s a NOT GOOD red flannel review dummy
Eminem got a 2 and 4 previous to this. Man's bullet proof
finalthony destinatiano
Dang Anthony, I respect your decision to give this album a 10, but did you have to say "it's the greatest thing to happen in earth since the Holocaust?"
Yikes
people need to stop doing this
That's funny shit bro
@@ShowtimeDon nah can't stop won't stop
Why are you twisting his words ? He said Hiroshima and even emphasized it. Just because both starts with H doesn't mean they are the same just like every Asians and Jews are same-same but different. smh
anthony, saying “i must say, Em can write!” over and over again is not a review.
seiichi Nathanthony Slimetano
r/hhhcirclejerk represent
harsh dwivedi scary black man
You have an anime profile pic your opinion does Not matter anymore more
@@Harsh-bx2mf cringe indian
It's not a needledrop Eminem review without at least a minute of Anthony looking deadpan at the camera reading sick lines from the songs as if they're bad lines.
they usually are pretty terrible lines
@@datboi945 they are meant to be corny and if u feel it's corny it did it's fucking job
@@oblivionreaper9307 stop pulling shit out of your ass
@@oblivionreaper9307 dog shit is supposed to be dogshit, does that make it any better?
@@datboi945 omg r u dumb that is the worst comparision
He showcased his lyrical ability through those corny lines and puns.
And that has been done by many and I mean many great rappers
U little dogshit
Everyone wants Shady back until they're wearing a Waldo shirt.
HHG of Antioch FOUND HIM!
Hahahha damn u beat me 2 it...well done sir
I agree with 99% of this review, however, the originality in rhyming Unavoidable with "toilet bowl" is one of the reasons Em is a legend. Gold rhyme.
It's unavoidable that he'll end up in a toilet bowl, that's a pretty genius line I agree.
@@papayer He released more classics than your favourite mumble rapper will ever drop
@@ThePhreakass I... I don't have a favorite mumble rapper. I don't listen to mumble rap period.
@@ThePhreakass mumble rap doesn't even exist. Name one rapper that actually mumbles
@@aminulamin4813 Future
No way man I thought the "pupils are getting cornier" line was genius. Laughed out loud when I heard it.
Yea I think that whole scheme was dope af
It's a corny line about cornyness. It's unironically genius.
@@thomaswiseau2421 at this point kids like you find everything corny and yes I know, this comment is corny so don't reply
I think he's reviewing it too seriously, lines like that are fucking funny Eminem is fucking trolling lmfao
@@JEMmusic-sn9qm Exactly!! 20 years in the game yet it's hard for people to get that he's trolling...
This album is his literally his best since a longgg time. I enjoyed every track. He’s 25 yrs into his career and I’m way more than impressed. Production was almost flawless. It’s my 5th favorite Em album. Yes, however good recovery is I don’t go back and play that as much as I bump this one. Replay value is just huge.
Eminem's production has been dead since Relapse.
@@HULKHOGAN1which is considered one of his worse
@@HULKHOGAN1HOW THE FUCK IS RECOVERY not well produced… WHAT
Recovery is his best album.
Melon you can’t give every Eminem rélease a 0 because he dissed you on Calm Down
anthony, you can’t give the album a 10/10 just because “he my white brudda”
No fantano is biracial
@@amadeusx2270 yeah half man, half melon.
He's not wearing a shirt in the video, that's his skin
Anthony you missed the homework from class last Friday, I can bring it to you if you want.
Bunni9 he was too busy crying to circles
@@ProdbyJason weren't we all?
“If he moaned like a female I would have given it a ten instead of a two”
Bro wtf is wrong with u man
“However, I’m going to have to give it a 5 because of all the black people featured” 😐 WTF
Lmao hell yeah
Shits funny
Facts, he only liked Kendrick but since Kendrick said he was an Israelite on his last Album Melon head ain't been feeling him the same.
@@DLloydisDFG lol
This the funniest one I seen so far😭
I’m disappointed the memes in the comment section haven’t changed with the decade
And I’m disappointed in melon for saying Eminem is the greatest white man since Obama wtf?
Zap! the band He isn't lying
I’m disappointed that the new Em album is what caused you to look up his videos for the first time in a decade
"Eminem - Music to Be Murdered By ALBUM REVIEW"
Who is Album Review and how is he going to murder Eminem - Music
So... Light 6, huh?
It's almost a MBDTF
I was looking for this
My Beautiful Dark Twisted Music To Be Murdered By
"But at least he's white though" - Anthony Fantano 2020... god this year started off well
What’s your excuse to just never mention Don Toliver
Edit: Thank god you gave him the attention he deserves on the JACKBOYS review
He’s the new Nate Dogg honestly
who?
I KNOW. He refused to acknowledge ‘CAN’T SAY’ on ASTROWORLD and didn’t mention him here, I’m sure he’ll find some way to avoid it if he reviews JACKBOYS
@@garfism12 he isn't gonna review jackboys
EDIT- LEMME JUST EAT MY WORDS RIGHT QUICK SMH
@@yahstino Has he said so explicitly? It could appear in a YUNO review or by some astronomical chance an independent standard review
Ed Sheerans record label is Gingerbread Man Records.
I swear the bars go over people's head.
" so when I bark I still think the roof would go over your head"
@@joseppicornholio8558 yepp even the bar about missing bar is a double entendre.
The bar is still trash.
@@insayno lol so what makes a bar not trash if rhyme, multiple layers, and humor doesnt?
I know it’s not your thing but I fucking love those shitty corny lines like the eyeball line and the Nintendo cartridge one. They just crack me tf up.
That's the purpose, Eminem been doing this all his career including his first 3 albums, melon gets r/wooosh constantly by em. Shit is funny as hell
i thought the chorus to "I Will" was one of his best in a while, surprised antknee didnt like it
Maybe because he genuinely dislikes Eminem at a seemingly personal level
@@stolensentience he just gave him a good review relax kid
Guyperson 66 lmao a 5 isn’t a good review score
I didn’t care for the album so a 5 is about right to me
Just a mediocre album
Guyperson 66 thanks for trying troll good night
@@youngwhitemale1366 Anthony literally said himself that a 5 is a good review
Eminem was staring at you with a big shovel in his hand the WHOLE time. Was that not intimidating?
Lmao no ones scared of em
@@slazer4182 Except mumble rappera.
@@slazer4182 actually alot of people in rap game would not mess with eminem
@@slazer4182 Except MGK never clapped back
@Thomas Houghton lol dont mean he can box ksi and logan where trained by pros two
Can't fault the guy for trying something outside his comfort zone. He included a few trap rappers and production that he generally wouldn't be used to so I appreciate him for that
Rebirth was outside of Lil Wayne's comfort zone. Doesn't make it not trash.
And he stayed consistent at least. Juice Wrld and Young MA aren’t mumble rappers in the slightest and are/were one of the better new acts right now.
Revival was a 2 kamikaze a 4 and this is strong 5 to light 6 .. yellow flannel in about 2: albums
Jaime yeah but he hated pop music and has an Ed Sheeran feature and now he’s backpedaling on calling Tyler the Creator sacrilegious.. Which by the way is a great line on Kamikaze... meh
@@dfeezzy2 he always had pop features his greatest song has Dido on the chorus and it was 20 years ago and going at Tyler was a weird situation cause Tyler was on tour with him a while back and they were friends kamikaze was dope but he sounded very butthurt on it so melon is saying that it s refreshing to hear him a little less biter on this one
saying "thats an awfully hot coffee pot" and pouring boiling hot coffee on your naked body until your skin started to melt for 13 minutes isn't a review, anthony.
It's a dad joke.. The ones he claims to hate
Logic dressed as wheres Waldo cosplay 10/10
Review 1/10
MTBMB 100/10
ok stan
Mother Coconuts You damn right. Stanley Hudson yo
Oooooh!
So is Logic famous or just like a Soundcloud Rapper?
DAMN. 7/10
This review 2/10
The album 7/10
This comment section 10/10
Your profile pic 11/10
@@jellytruck8638 your name 9/11
This reply list 420/690
@赞成裕裕裕 2/3 of 'em are metaphors
@赞成裕裕裕 of the replies what I meant
Revival: 2/10
Kamikaze: 4/10
MTBMB: 5/10
Is Eminem growing on you, Melon?
Ali nah, em is just growing. We’ve gone from terrible, to better, to not bad. Who knows maybe we’ll get a good one next
MMLP2 got a 7 tho
@@wakkawakkagaming3710 idk man. MTBMB was pretty good.
@@TopaktasGL I don't really count his downfall until after that. Relapse - Recovery - MMLP2 were all mediocre to good, revival was the huge drop
Enzi Gee MMLP2’s good tho
honestly i loved this album and i’m not a big em fan and stepdad was a great track em channeled his anger in a great way
But the hook is trash
the hook grows on you with time. at least it did for me. it's my favorite track off the project. really reminds me of TES era.
You spent over half of your review talking about RAID: Shadow Legends, so unprofessional melon.
This comments are getting really old now...
the funny thing is this is one of the only videos on youtube that doesn't actually do that these days
Buy Ridge wallets
Really melon? Giggling for almost 14 minutes about how Eminem sounds like "m&m"? That's your review? Grow up man or I will unsubscribe. -_-
The yellow flannel was in the wash so Anthony said “screw it I’ll give it a 5”
Jonnie Hopkins misspelt red
6.5/10 for me. I was amazed that u didnt like "no regrets" easily my fav track from the album. Kinda shows just how subjective music it is.
I feel like eminem's writing has definitely suffered from his own success. His early stuff clearly draws on past experiences as a child and young adult, and his middle stuff addresses the perils of fame and his personal struggles with alcoholism and his relationship with his family. The more recent stuff where he discusses his relationships with his fans (outside of Stan, obviously) feels like he's trying to draw from his life in the same way and it's coming off kind of holier-than-thou, which is the exact opposite of his original brand.
Edit: to be clear, I think it's pretty obvious that he's trying REALLY SUPER HARD not to do this, given all the political material he's been covering over the last three albums. My point was more that he used to draw a lot more from his personal life, which has (hopefully) stabilized a great deal. It seems like he has a harder time with a more sociological POV, that's all. It's not like it's impossible to do this well, it's just not what he's known for.
How i see it is that he's trying to push himself lyrically too much and wants to see how far he can take it, but in the process ends up having weaker content
He doesn't seem to have new experiences. Like all he does is stay in the house or something.
@@auggiedoggie4968 ever since proof died he kind of shut himself off from the public and stuck with his close group of friends. Honestly you cant blame him too much
Wow.. I literally have a new perspective. I think you’re right
@@tofuteh2348 that's a weak excuse honestly. He has kids, friends...there's a whole world that's open to him. Hell, even if he shut down Disneyland for a day and took his daughters and labelmates out for a day would be an improvement. People die everyday, B.
I mean I like this review, but the part where you said “Eminem isn’t a real rapper because he isn’t black” might’ve been a bit overboard.
He didn't say that. Why would you make that up?
Crono Sapien actually lol’d
RealMetalGaming are you serious?
@@Dinjur youre new around these parts arent you?
I read this as he was saying it and tripped tf out
Anthony making sure he is getting a mention on the next Eminem's track.
He isn’t, Em doesn’t give two shits about the critics.
@@aer2856 .... have you heard Kamikaze or the first song on this album
To be fair he did say a lot of positive things about the album
@@aer2856 if he didn't he wouldn't mention them in his songs
7/10 melon. Say it
I give this album a 8 tbh I only hated 2 tracks Fantano is just reading the lyrics and not actually listening and nitpicking bars that are a little corny and those bars are intentional and most rappers have 10x more cornier bars than that.