.357 Mag vs .44 Mag vs 500 Mag!!! - How Many Paper Plates???
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 พ.ค. 2022
- Which one is your favorite???
Deals and Discounts HERE: linktr.ee/whoteewho
HUGE discounts on My Hearing Protection:
35-50% OFF GS extreme 2.0 35-50% OFF - bit.ly/3JN18lb
35-50% OFF TRACKR BLU - bit.ly/3DfOHMt
35-50% OFF TRACKR electronic - bit.ly/3iJfA1K
Please Subscribe to the channel HERE: bit.ly/2xQ9ap2
Add me on facebook: / whoteewho
Add me on Instagram: / mrwho_tee_who_
Truly appreciate you watching the videos!!!
.357 Mag vs .44 Mag vs 500 Mag!!! - How Many Paper Plates???
New Merch available - bit.ly/2W68Gqp
Heavy Metal here: bit.ly/30wF6wW
Support us on Patreon / whoteewho
.
.
.
.
500 magnum,.500,.50,50 cal,50 ae,s&w revolver,.44 magnum,44 magnum,.500 s&w magnum,smith & wesson,s&w 500,s&w 460,460 magnum,slowmo,slow motion,slow mo,500 mag,.500 mag,magnum revolver,S&W 500,smith and wesson 500,smith and wesson 500 magnum,most powerful revolver,big revolver,500mag,sw500,357 vs 44 vs 500,.357 vs .44 vs .500,357mag vs 44mag vs 500mag,44 mag vs 500 mag,357 mag vs 44 mag,coonan,coonan 357,coonan .357 magnum,coonan .357 - บันเทิง
![พาแม่บินครั้งแรก..เกือบวูบ! ให้เกาหลีเยียวยาใจ I Korea Ep.1 [Seoul] x อุงเอิง](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/waL3__dEQBU/mqdefault.jpg)
Well now this was a interesting video and I would like to see the 460 Smith & Wesson put up against the 500 Smith & Wesson.
Fun video! I’m a “Revolver Guy”! Would have enjoyed seeing the .357 Revolver in action! Keep the vids coming!
That was a really fun video. I predicted the 500 wouldn't penetrate as far, or closer to the other two. I was thinking the velocity would be about the same, but with deformation the greater mass would be offset, because it would have to plow a wider hole. What a beast of a caliber.
Big, bigger and biggest this will be interesting to see. None of these are known for no power. Hide you plates WHO TEE WHO is coming for em all. Thanks again for fun educational bing bang videos. 💪🏽🎥💯👍🙏🏻
Hide the plates, along with the coconuts, cantaloupe, and clay blocks.
Great video as always! KEEP IT UP! Personally I've always been a huge fan of the .357mag. Still have one of my dad's Ruger Blackhawk 3 screw models, my brother has the other half of the brace. I also have a 1911 in 45acp, it's my second one and I love them! I've wanted a 1911 in 357mag since I was a kid back in the 70s, but they are rare and expensive. I've shot many 44mags, but still preferred the.357. My brother also bought a.500 S&W. He asked me if I wanted to shoot it, I told him, nope not interested. If I wanna get behind that much powder I'd rather have a rifle. 😆
That 1911 is my favorite. I love my 1911’s and 357 mag. To be able to have both in one firearm would be a dream for me. Great video as always man!
People!
Good News!
All of these cartridges performed beautifully! If you are packing the.357 mag or .44 mag you are well armed!
If you are packing the.500 S&W you are probably lying like a rug ! A good revolver with quality ammunition will serve you very well and no Bear no hog no badger no coyote is going to argue with a 4.2 inch GP100 Ruger with 180 CorBon jacketed soft points! It ain’t gonna happen!! Enjoy!
Now that was a really awesome fun video WTW. I've always found these paper plate test to be more fun than the gel test, they have a way of showing the real power & penetration effect of a round. Thanks for all you do, your time and effort behind the scenes are greatly appreciated. Keep the faith and stay safe.
But gel test shows the damage it does..it's amazing how much a gel block can expand
All my fav calibers , but first I had was a Ruger super nlkhek in 44 mag , now I have the full lug Smith in 44 mag and now the 500 mag , really love the hog leg !! 👍👍😁
I held me a .44 Magnum and a 500 Win in my hands for the first time yesterday at Kings Sports in Durban. Sure make the little 9mm feel trivial…
Impressive
I have a Rossi lever action carbine in 357mag.
I hand load for this sweet gem.
Using hardcast 158 gr swc bullets loaded a bit hot, they run around 2000fps, and 135 gr lead hp at around 2200fps across the chrony a number of years back (IF I remember correctly).
Thing is, by sound of impact and visually on the range, they are outrunning factory ammo by a long shot. The hand loads make the factory ammo seem pedestrian by comparison (hirtenberger and speer gold dots).
I regularly used the carbine for pig and dense bush smaller buck hunting.
Never fired a second shot with the 158gr swc.
Boils down to this:
None, and i mean NONE of these calibres are toys. They will sure ruin your day if you are the receiving end of the muzzle flash....
Enjoy
Keep on keeping on
Heads up
Eyes open
No fear
Cool
Great video. I've learned a lot from your rifle testing but I'm a handgun guy at heart and love it when you do these videos.
I’ve got a Dan Wesson 44 mag n it’s enough gun for about anything you need !! Great video !!!👏👏
Bought my Dan 40 years ago come October for my 21 birthday and it’s still my no1 .
That is a very well balanced revolver!
Love these videos!!!
Been here since you started the channel. Still loving every video you make brother. Thank you.
🙏🙏🙏
Great stuff. It could be that bigger is better here. You never know when an extra 150-250 grains will be needed to close the deal. Nice group of guns there. I put Pachmayr Diamond grips on my S&W 44 Magnums. It is excellent at taming the beast.
Koodos to you Mr WTW for always counting the plates!! Great video!!
Great video, thanks
Awesome video!
I love the paper plate videos!
Cool video! Try pentrator brass bullets for them! You may go through them all!
have all 3 firearms used great video don't know if done 5.7 with FN blue tip vs American Eagle vs Green Tip
This is about to be a really good video I'm looking forward to it
I am very surprised thanks for the video 👍🏻
Awsome video, I like seeing the ol pistol videos. Tomorrow, I'm going to a gun show. It'll be a hoot
Love .357 (first pistol I ever bought) and .44 Mag. Pistol and lever action carbine make the rounds incredibly versatile. .500 is just a bit much to hold onto as a pistol for most.
.500 carbine would be fun. As far as I know, only one company out there that makes one. Only $2500? Well dang, I'll take two...
hello Adam, u knew the revolvers would git my attention ! good video. Hope all the kids are doing well and you and Mama too.
Couldn't catch the premier while I was driving last night, definitely missed my evening interaction with everyone. Nice inclusion of the Coonan 1911.
Awesome video man. That .357 1911 is Sweeeet! God bless everybody out there.
With hard cast lead or the newer extreme penetrator bullets .They all shine for big dense muscle and bone big game! The most used caliber for me is the .357 magnum. I will step up to the. 44mag on bear or elk but the .500 is just to much for my smaller frame to reliability get possible follow up shots on game animals if needed! Have worked as predator control hunter. Big cats in the dark and alone the .357 mag has shined ! The .44 mag gets a little sketchy! It's little older brother or parent cartridge the .44 special is also a very versatile and easy to use cartridge for that use! I only speak from hunting experience and only recommend what you can accurately and safely can use for your own personal use! God bless you all and stay safe and healthy! Great review HTH and thank you for making this video! Have a great time and enjoy your time hunting and shooting in the great outdoors! Safety first! From Oklahoma City!
Great video
Wow that Coonan is cool. I love the paper plates tests.
Another excellent video! Would love to see a 44 mag vs 41 mag sometime!
That's the coolest test I've ever seen
That 357 1911 is a Beaut! Great video WHOTEEWHO! Yeah, definitely gotta see more videos of that 1911. I have a soft spot for those, but who doesn't 😁
Thing is pretty nice. They quit making them
It’d be interesting to see an ar video similar to this cartridge comparison, 5.56/300 blk/350 legend.
I took my 13 year old grandson out with a bunch of guns to shoot. When he ran out of 12 gauge shells, I got out my Redhawk.
I put in 3 44 special in with the last 3 using 44 magnum. When he got to the magnums his eyes bugged out a bit. Yep, I am the coolest grampy ever...
If you make sure he doubles up his ear protection, you're probably correct.
(My dad has permanent tinnitus from shooting guns as a kid).
Love it! 😀
I have owned the same S&W model 27 six inch barrel .357 mag since 1978, it does everything I will ever need a handgun to do, I also have a Rossi 1892 carbine with a sixteen inch barrel ( Okie Assault Rifle, lol). I never met any critter, two legged or four that these two weapons couldn’t handle. Yes, I own many other calibers, .243, 30-06, 44 mag, 45 auto, several 9 mm, a bunch of .22’s, several shotguns. I use these other weapons for specific things, for example if I am elk hunting I take the 30-06, deer past 100 yards, the .243……however, 90 percent of everything else gets handled by the first two mentioned above.
I love my 629. I have the full under lug classic
That was a fun video 😊
Great job testing. I wonder if you ran the same test using buffalo bore hard lead bullets, what the difference in penetration would be???
Great 👍 test
Ida liked to have seen 10mm and 357sig in this here vidjeo too. Both of them are basically magnum cartridges as well.
It's always fun watching the big bore big boys. Thanks wtw for another great video
Always appreciate you watching!
Love the Coonan! They are fun guns
Cool, need to try some solid copper or Matt’s Bullets 390 grain spire point for the 500, that might get through all those plates (I might have some extra projectiles)
This should be pretty Awesome!!
Wow, that is interesting, I thought a 10mm was supposed to be the equivalent of a 357 mag but the 10mm only penetrated 193 plates v the 357 penetrating 547.
I love them all!🤘🏽🤘🏽
Sweet tests. I been wanting to get a 44 but sense im getting up in age ill stick with my 357. That being said i wouldve loved to seen the 44 go toe to toe with the 357 loaded with buffalo bore heavy outdoorsman cast bullets. Thats what i carry in my ruger GP 100 aint no grizzlies here in kentucky but there has been a few bigfoot sightings tho. Hahahaha. Great video bro. I never yawn waching this channel. God bless.
What a great video. The. 357 is my favorite round. The 44 is a not too distant second favorite.
I built a holder for paper plates for my own personal tests. I took a 5 gallon bucket and screwed a 2x4 on the side so it sits level on the table. I filled the first 8" with compressed plastic grocery bags and then the stacks of compressed paper plates came right up to the lip of the bucket. I took 3 ups boxes and stuffed them with compressed plastic grocery bags as well and set those, duct taped together and set them behind the bucket. Seems to work fairly well!! I did my new Rock Island Armory 1911 10mm vs my Rock Island Armory M200 38 special. The 10mm penetrated 288 paper plates the 38 special 188 plates. That 10mm is a real beast
That was a cool video. Take Care.
Nice , haven't seen the paper plates in awhile. Thought you were going to pull out BFR 350 legend for a sec.
Nice !, I was not expecting anything to go thorough 1300 plates, but I was expecting a more even spread through the plates but the .357 and .44 were fairly close.
They were closer than I thought they would..I will keep my 357
Awesome, was what I expected with the weight. Like I always say the weight is where it's at, despite what some say or think!! Have you done rifles in the plates, I can't remember lol? Sure you probably have. That 500 reminds me of a 150gr .30 cal round.
Always fun with Who_Tee_Who..
Thanks for watching Martin!
Great video, I thought the 500 would go all the way too. I'd like to see the 41 mag put between the 357 and 44....would be a great test
Try the 700 grain hard cast out of the 500 S&W on those plates.
Awesome as always! Try hard cast next time see if it makes a difference.
Great video. Can you put the .357 m revolver against the .357 m 1911
See if there any difference.
I don’t know about paper plates but once when I was younger and bolder, I took a 65 yard shot at a very young buck with my 6 inch barrel .357 mag. The deer went straight down and never flinched. The post mortem exam showed a frontal entrance wound in the brisket and an exit wound just right of the tail, every internal organ was damaged. If that isn’t enough penetration I don’t know what else anyone could ask of a handgun. Granted that little buck only dressed about eighty pounds, but it appeared that bullet made a wound channel about 40 inches long or more.
Very cool video
You should shoot a pack of printer paper with the .44 magnum
Should try it with hardcast
3very sweet revolvers i love ALL3 of those have a good weekend sir.
Try this with the ruger Redhawk and use the .44mag +p+ 340gr lead flat point gas check rounds by underwood.
I’d be curious to see what a hot loaded solid .357 magnum would do
U omitted my favorite magnum cartridge the ..41 Rem Mah
Like the paper plate uploads
Plates that hold up to 500 Mag- I’m going to Sam’s Club 😂
😝😝😝 plates are getting expensive these days!
@@WHOTEEWHO everything is getting expensive these days..
I would be really interested in you doing a video comparing that .357 semi-auto to the revolver, exact same ammo. Would there be a difference in the amount of paper plates? I'm thinking there might be a slight power loss from the semi-auto. Also try to use guns with the same barrel length, please! That would make a great video!
I am curious about this as well . I have a S&W 357 model 28-2 highway Patrolman N frame. (Infamous police loads)
Im picking the revolver ... im also curious how hotter loads with a 125gn. would perform in both simiauto and revolver???
I think it would go the other way.. semi auto would penetrate better if there's any difference at all because there's no gas seal on the revolver so the velocity might suffer
@@FAtE_454 i didn't think of that. Now i really want to see this video made!
@@chamblen4 me too!
Very impressive. They all smack those plates pretty hard.
Thanks for the test, I've always been interested in that.
Well, I would have thought the 44 would cut through some more paper, but paper is a hell of a drag. I'm so proud of my 357 revolver baby 😄. Greetings from Germany
Pop vs Bang vs Boom
I like the coonan pistols aswell!!
How bout trying this test with the 460SW?
Fun video! How about a Smith & Wesson 460 and a 454 and a 45 long colt out of the same pistol. How many paper plates?
Interesting pistol ammo comparison. Would like to see a comparison with RIFLE calibers against the same paper plate set up. For instance, how would a .223 compare with it's high speed, light bullet? How about a .243 caliber with it's pointed, medium weight bullet? How about a .300 Winchester magnum with a Barns copper bullet? Should make the difference between PISTOL calibers and RIFLE calibers obvious even to experienced shooters.
Paper plates !
True science at work !
Ya' godda' luv-it !
500 magnum is just ridiculous, super fun video lol.
Interesting. Those plates are tough. How about a repeat with hard cast bullets? Semi-wadcutter and pointed cast bullets are available. And you might shoot a side by side comparison in .44 Magnum using both a revolver and a carbine. WTW.
Guessing the .357 and .44 bullets were of cup and core construction, that would explain the jacket separation. The .500 bullet was definitely of sturdier construction to stay together.
Thanks for the video.
When I saw the title to this video, I was expecting to see a comparison between three revolvers. Was very disappointed when a semi-automatic was substituted for a revolver.
Also, was hoping to see hard-cast lead ammo used for a penetration test ... not partially jacketed soft-lead ammo.
Also, was hoping to see 180 grain 357 magnum ammo used ... not 150 grain 357 magnum ammo.
I was hoping u may find another channel , for all your wishes.
@@jimmyruger7529
Sorry if my feedback to the creator of this video offended you. I usually enjoy his videos. I know I have watched over 7 of them and have found them informative and very entertaining.
I do not understand why you would hope that I look to another channel.
I Have an idea, if you take a few different colored markers and mark a line (in different colors for different packs of plates) on the side of each pack of plates. It will be easy to know how many plates each shot went through.
WTW man I wish you hadn’t shown that .357 in the 1911 set up. Now I’m going to have to wash dishes, do laundry, mop floors, wash my wife’s car just to get her to consider me getting one.
😆😆😆
Try some Underwood Extreme Penetrators' and see what the results are.
Ahhh missed the paper plates test ....... Reminds me of the old WTW days
Handy to know if I'm ever attacked by a bunch of paper plates.
Good video, I have the 357 and the 44 mag and was surprised how close they were. For the 500 mag I would have to shoot my 4570 with 400 grain bullet.
Digging the Coonan!
When I was a police officer in the 90's, (and very poor!). I would gather old newspapers and bundle them together with twine. I would put them in an ice chest and soak them with water until they were saturated all the way through. I test fired various defense ammo into the bundles. Not very scientific but kinda informative. The PMC Starfire was my favorite, expanded perfectly every time.
how about a comparison between those two 357s? it would be interresting to see if theres a difference between the semiauto and revolver.
Good idea
Yeaaaahhh bud 🤘🏼
Damn ive been looking for one of them 1911s
wondering if you reuse them plates at the dinner table, only have to wipe up a little spot of bean juice, lol
Wish I saw this on the premier I wish also wrong on what I thought what would happen thank again wtw . Love that 1911 always wanted one .
Thanks for watching Ian!
Don't remember but did you ever shoot shotgun slugs threw the plates ? Thanks
If you measured front to back on paper plate penetration the. 357 penetration was approx 10" deep, more than enough for a through and through chest wound on a 200 lb man unless the round stuck in the spine which would be shattered. This is the reason back before departments switched to 9mm semi autos they only allowed .357 pistols to be loaded with .38 sp ammo to prevent over penetration injuries to civilians on the other side of drywall, or across the street from law enforcement shootouts
Odd question 🤔
What thickness of steel does hevy metal use for their steel targets?
.308 fmj putting holes in 1/2"