It's not lacking emotion, it's just lacking fender. people who's been listening to songs long time ago when pretty much everybody used fender think that's emotion. it's not, it's the tone and the nostalgia, not emotion. petrucci puts a lot of care into what he plays, and he has just about enough of emotions of gilmour does.
So let me get this straight. You think Hendrix's cover of "All Along the Watchtower" should sound just like Dylan's original? Wow. Good thing you weren't Hendrix; we wouldn't have one of the greatest songs of all time.
The keyboards in this are the closest live performance I've ever heard. If he had Richard's Farfisa Compact Duo and an Echorec, I'm sure it would be dead on!
Have you ever heard about Keith Emerson? Richard Wright? Wakeman? Lord? I mean, I love the wizard Jordan, but in the 70's there was lots of keyboardists playing better than this, and on top of everything they were high on drugs. ps: I don't mean to sound rude, this just my opinion, and I respect yours. cheers.
I am a Floyd fan for the last 40 years and here is not the question are they beter or not, what we should say is if Gilmour or Waters or any floyd listen and watch this, what would they say??? I belived they would be very please to see groups going to this extent and be that good. My rating is a 5 I was very please with it
I am not a keyboardist but I've seen it done before. Keith Emerson playing Bach Tocatta while lying on the floor through a hammond organ. With the instrument on top of him and backwards.
El mejor "cover" de "Any Colour" que yo haya escuchado jamás.Trance trippin' p,al cuerpo......Casi me da más emoción esta canción que la original.Gracias x subirla.
I love reading butt hurt grandpa Pink Floyd fans who are uptight about a newer band covering their favorite band with some flashy playing. Get over it. Dream Theater respects PF, it's not about a competition.
I love how when Petrucci covers a guitar solo, he adds a load of his own style too it, but really emulates, or tries to emulate, the person who played it originally's style :)
They did the whole dark side of the moon album for a live event They do do a lot of Pink Floyd covers though, it's probably because it's one of their main influences?
I absolutely loved the keyboard, virtually every melodic note... Beautiful! The guitar solo, however, not-so-much. It seemed to be drawn-out.. sounding like a jam that went too long.
awesome by adapting to their own sound. if you listen to the DSOTM experience version of Any Colour You Like it's more subdued and spacey than the album version. this one is closer to the album version in style
This shit slaps so fucking hard. That guitar solo especially the part at 3:52 brings tears to my eyes and chills all over my body. This whole jam sesh is just pure orgasmic. One of my favorite Pink Floyd songs too, so underrated imo.
Actually you’re wrong, the drummer is being faithful to nick mason’s live drumming. His live drumming is insanely more intense han his studio drumming. You should listen to the live version of them when they were young and it’s quite similar. Also the live version is fukin insane
Gilmour is great, but not in the same league with Petrucci...and Jordan, you can play from the regular side of the keyboard and we will still love you!
Guitaraficionado I disagree and it doesn’t even need to anyways, its a tribute, don’t you think it would be slightly boring if if it was exactly the same?
There's three types of covers: 1. Played exactly like the record, note-for-note. 2. The band puts their own spin on it, but it sounds like shit. 3. The band puts their own spin on it, and it sounds killer. In some cases, better than the original. Gonna go with 3. here. Jordan definitely ate his Wheaties.
As the lead guitarist has shown, no matter how good you can be, Dave Gilmour is inimitable. Although I enjoyed the song, its just not the same. You cant improvise on Gilmour's lead which is a world away in depth, tone, note sustenances, etc.
I personally think that Petrucci does have Gilmour's feel and emotion; he expresses himself differently to Gilmour in that he uses speed much more to create and relieve tension in his solos. Expression is as subjective as emotion, and to me at least JP has it all =)
I've never seen john enjoy himself like that. It's like he time warped back into an old guitar class he took in h.s. and decided to blow his friends away with how good he'd gotten. Lol
It's a frickin cover! They do it THEIR way...which is the way it should be. If you want to hear it exactly like Floyd, go listen to Floyd. I like them mixing it to their style...
honestly idk how you anyone can say this is emotionless. i thought this did justice to the original. you dont have to look constipated to have emotion in your playing.
I just commented again. I think another problem with metal I have is not just the amount of gain but the fact that it's "distortion" and not fuzz. Fuzz is the only kind of gain I use/like. My opinion is that it allows for a great crunch but without sacrificing the capacity for those nuances and subtleties that make the electric guitar (and blues) so personal, a la the sentiment you shared. Robert Fripp (who basically invented metal) even used fuzz, and I think still does to this day. I miss it.
One of my favourite interpretations of one of my favourite pieces ever --, well, the beginning actually. Rudess has understood everything there is to understand about the song, and when he goes reverse, it's not just a trick, but actually a metaphor of what the sound is about. Petrucci, on the other hand, thinks it's about a cool guy playing cool guitar, and he totally missed the point, srry but it's what it is. This vibrato is so out of place. It's good again when he's supporting Rudess' phrasés, but then it's sh.t again. So strange.
They performed the whole Dark Side of The Moon album in 2005 and released the DVD last year. If you're familiar with BitTorrent you should find the DVD there... it's where I got it from.
The guitar is Petruccis own custom Erbieball/Musicman and it doesnt have that kind of unique sound what fender does, altough its a great guitar and i love it! And so i do love JPs playing!
EXACTLY! I've been saying that exact thing for so long except for the controller part, which is a great analogy. A clean(er) tone conveys so much more. You can go to the other extreme with B.B. King, who adds nothing but a bit of reverb. There's so much character and feel (not feelING) to the playing that he can make one note sound like lightning with a bit of vibrato. There are a few exceptions... like two-handed tapping, which sounds best with tons of gain... you get almost a wah effect.
When thinking about which musician is better, we should think about what those musician should answer to that question. Probably they will say they work hard to be the best musician they can be, but they'll find ridiculous to be compared with any other musician. Always it seems to be kind of competition in which no musician involved should actually participate. Just stop making comparisons and enjoy that we share our lifes with big and extremelly good musicians as DT and many others are.
it should be a rule. if you're going to play Dave Gilmour solos you must have a fender. there's no excuse for butchering his clasic tone with anything but. I don't care how good or fast or clever you are. its NOTHING without tone. too many hours in front of Marshall stacks they're all deaf. Fender has 'something', I don't know what, but they got it.
Its not that he doesnt play it exactly right or sound like Gilmour, its the fact that just sounds like someone playing up and down scales. Its pretty much like the way Tremonti plays. I cant stand it. Its TOO studied and thats the problem.
that is a very racist comment.... Dream Theater in this concert did a true tribute to a band that influences them in many of their songs....and guess what they did a fantastic job with it.....part of all that hate is jealousy...You can't master your instrument as these guys do...They are not american..they are universal....so is their music They are coming to my hometown....can't wait :-P
sure i guess u can say petrucchi can run circles on the guitar around gilmour.. but music is not totally about that.. ESPECIALLY floyd music. im sure gilmour coulda become amazing at running circles on the guitar too if he wanted to.. but he lets the notes breathe.. he also lets the audience digest the music.. hitting 200000 notes doesnt make the song sound nicer.. tho this is a nice version anyway..
Well it's obviosu that this is acover but why do people have to search for the album version of the song? trhey're just paying tribute to pink floyd and better to appreciate cause ı think it could not have been better (excluding pf). I mean think of classical music then, shouldnt orchestras play the compositions of former composers just beacause it wouldn't sound like what they had in their minds back then in 27. century for instance?
![ลองสั่งของจากแอพ temu ถูกจริงหรอ?? [โกงไหมครับ ep.88 ] | DOM](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RTcZSQTiDZw/mqdefault.jpg)
I know Richard Wright would love this cause he was a phenomenal keyboard player way ahead of his time with half of the technology that exists now.
that keyboard solo was ethereal
Unbelievable, I have never seen a keyboardist play back
to front from the other side.
Incredible Talent here!
Keith Emerson
@@andredagenais5844 lol you have a point
Great Cover but Richard Wright remain n°1.................Best n°1!
I don't care if this isn't completely melodic sounding. This song was meant for jamming. I absolutely love this.
Hey, what do you mean by not being a melodic sounding?
This song is a total Trip of LSD
@@da87m I’m not sure. I wrote the comment 15 years ago.
@@jd87alol
@@jd87awelcome back
It's not lacking emotion, it's just lacking fender. people who's been listening to songs long time ago when pretty much everybody used fender think that's emotion. it's not, it's the tone and the nostalgia, not emotion. petrucci puts a lot of care into what he plays, and he has just about enough of emotions of gilmour does.
Amazing!! I think that this is an awesome Pink Floyd tribute
i agree ^*^
Jordan reis taşşakların için hala beton arıyoruz
So let me get this straight. You think Hendrix's cover of "All Along the Watchtower" should sound just like Dylan's original?
Wow.
Good thing you weren't Hendrix; we wouldn't have one of the greatest songs of all time.
lol so true
@@PeterGriffin-in5ut Yes, but with Dylan, you're building from a much lower base point ;-)
This is great stuff and a real tribute to Pink Floyd !
Completely agree.
One thing's for sure, Gilmour and Petrucci are both amazing MUSICIANS.
The keyboards in this are the closest live performance I've ever heard. If he had Richard's Farfisa Compact Duo and an Echorec, I'm sure it would be dead on!
So that's what Richard Wright was using
I think he'd moved on from the Farfisa by that point
Jordan coloring, the best progressive keyboard solo I have ever heard.
Camilov Sky Richard Wright Bitch
MrCiberenchufao Leave here kid.
+JoNesBlacK He is right, stfu.
Have you ever heard about Keith Emerson? Richard Wright? Wakeman? Lord?
I mean, I love the wizard Jordan, but in the 70's there was lots of keyboardists playing better than this, and on top of everything they were high on drugs.
ps: I don't mean to sound rude, this just my opinion, and I respect yours. cheers.
Well, what´s your favorite keyboard solo?, I think Richard Wright woul be so pleased with this awesome version, isn´t it?
I am a Floyd fan for the last 40 years and here is not the question are they beter or not, what we should say is if Gilmour or Waters or any floyd listen and watch this, what would they say??? I belived they would be very please to see groups going to this extent and be that good.
My rating is a 5 I was very please with it
Love this comment! So retro 😢
I am not a keyboardist but I've seen it done before. Keith Emerson playing Bach Tocatta while lying on the floor through a hammond organ. With the instrument on top of him and backwards.
THE BEST COVER EVER OF ANY COLOR YOUR LIKE GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG WOW MANN
El mejor "cover" de "Any Colour" que yo haya escuchado jamás.Trance trippin' p,al cuerpo......Casi me da más emoción esta canción que la original.Gracias x subirla.
I love reading butt hurt grandpa Pink Floyd fans who are uptight about a newer band covering their favorite band with some flashy playing. Get over it. Dream Theater respects PF, it's not about a competition.
I love how when Petrucci covers a guitar solo, he adds a load of his own style too it, but really emulates, or tries to emulate, the person who played it originally's style :)
They did the whole dark side of the moon album for a live event
They do do a lot of Pink Floyd covers though, it's probably because it's one of their main influences?
Any coloUr you like*
Matias Alanis got em
the battery the bass is amazing increible impresionante sensacional hermoso todo lo bueno de la vida . is life
davvi drum!
I absolutely loved the keyboard, virtually every melodic note... Beautiful! The guitar solo, however, not-so-much. It seemed to be drawn-out.. sounding like a jam that went too long.
Going behind the keyboard was drawn out???
awesome by adapting to their own sound. if you listen to the DSOTM experience version of Any Colour You Like it's more subdued and spacey than the album version. this one is closer to the album version in style
This shit slaps so fucking hard. That guitar solo especially the part at 3:52 brings tears to my eyes and chills all over my body.
This whole jam sesh is just pure orgasmic. One of my favorite Pink Floyd songs too, so underrated imo.
Wow huge floyd fan here this is awesome!
mike portnoy's an awesome drummer, but he really doesn't match the feel of floyd, as it has to have a laid back quality to it.
Jonathan Yung they are making it their own! only one PF. this sounds fuckin great
Yeah, the drums are too prominent in this mix and too busy
Actually you’re wrong, the drummer is being faithful to nick mason’s live drumming. His live drumming is insanely more intense han his studio drumming. You should listen to the live version of them when they were young and it’s quite similar. Also the live version is fukin insane
um, holy crap... JR completely just did that backwards and still pulled it off perfectly...
Tecladista esquisito.. tocando com o teclado de costas.. kk.. banda foda!!
The original sounds stoner but this one is more rock n roll.
Insane!! playing keyboard backwards at 00:54
Gilmour is great, but not in the same league with Petrucci...and Jordan, you can play from the regular side of the keyboard and we will still love you!
Petrucci - cool shirt? no...does he need a cool shirt? no...he can come out on stage with an elephant custom and still rock balls!
I really liked the guitar solo.
+alby3115 not that good
Guitar solo have nothing in common with Floyd sound.
Guitaraficionado I disagree and it doesn’t even need to anyways, its a tribute, don’t you think it would be slightly boring if if it was exactly the same?
@@jameskostov9353 of course, i like originality as a musician no doubt in that.But i tried to say something else.
I can barely play the keyboard right let alone backwords
Petrucci is god with guitar like David Gilmour also. Wright vs. Rudess
And to think Floyd did this ,,,,,how many years ago 🤔, (I know lol) this is amazing tho
Played like a true fans of pink Floyd.....
Richard Wright would've fucking loved it awesome job doing this cover
There's three types of covers:
1. Played exactly like the record, note-for-note.
2. The band puts their own spin on it, but it sounds like shit.
3. The band puts their own spin on it, and it sounds killer. In some cases, better than the original.
Gonna go with 3. here. Jordan definitely ate his Wheaties.
+1
As the lead guitarist has shown, no matter how good you can be, Dave Gilmour is inimitable. Although I enjoyed the song, its just not the same. You cant improvise on Gilmour's lead which is a world away in depth, tone, note sustenances, etc.
***** You hit the nail on the head. Also the guitar really doesn't compare to the original. Decent but not Gilmour. 😉
Great work first time I have seen in played
damn that shit was so fire, it blew my note up
Topical
I personally think that Petrucci does have Gilmour's feel and emotion; he expresses himself differently to Gilmour in that he uses speed much more to create and relieve tension in his solos. Expression is as subjective as emotion, and to me at least JP has it all =)
They're practically the greatest PROG METAL band on earth now and having hard time sounding like PINK FLOYD.
Ah, nobody can ever match the pure talent of Pink Floyd, they’re one of a kind.
@ Risng Sun so true...
Baap to Baap hota hai mitr
@@Rekeza they never will even if they try ;).
No
I've never seen john enjoy himself like that.
It's like he time warped back into an old guitar class he took in h.s. and decided to blow his friends away with how good he'd gotten. Lol
how was this 17 years ago
are there any other all instrumental songs out there that can compete?? any?
splendid musicians, thou i can't get emotional with their play. not pink floyd
The most underrated song ever
no, that's scissors sisters version of Comfortably Numb. As always Dream Theater does a great cover and it's cool that they jam abit over this song.
It's a frickin cover! They do it THEIR way...which is the way it should be. If you want to hear it exactly like Floyd, go listen to Floyd. I like them mixing it to their style...
The beautiful keyboard playing ends at 2:14 After that, it's a dragged-out guitar solo...
The guitar torment part is horrible
Guitar solo: a shit 👍
Beautiful performance. I'm close to tears.
Never forget this cover 2020 here.
excelente... cada vez que lo escucho me siento como en mi casa, son más de 40 años escuchándolo. Es atemporal.
Grupazo australiano cover MAGNIFICCO ESTUPENDO.
It's insane! It blows you up so much!!!!!!
Nah that's ISIS.
You mean the CIA contractors...?
Sim On lmao salty
@@ryan0150 :)
Quand on fait parler un instrument,,surtout sur un best of des pink floyd,.sa donne sa..
They really took good care of the song! That ending was fantastic!
Some damn good musicians here.
I know richard Wright is loving this guy nice job jordan.
Genious
Wtf with the keyboardist...! 🤯
honestly idk how you anyone can say this is emotionless. i thought this did justice to the original. you dont have to look constipated to have emotion in your playing.
I was thinking about this is the best pink Floyd's performance but I didn't notice title. Dream theater makes me very comfortable person
Fucking awesome!!!
Christian Venditti They actually sound better than Floyd.
Christian Venditti I agree... Everything but the guitar jam!
ben vad Um No.
werdgerl Yes.
An honorable cover, buy Portnoy ruins it with his awful, over-the-top drum fills.
The magic of the Floyd is that they left the barrel half empty, here is full, almost overflowing
Wow. Im simply blown away. Time to find some more floyd by dt. I knew one if their largest influences was thr floyd...but...wow...!
I just commented again. I think another problem with metal I have is not just the amount of gain but the fact that it's "distortion" and not fuzz. Fuzz is the only kind of gain I use/like. My opinion is that it allows for a great crunch but without sacrificing the capacity for those nuances and subtleties that make the electric guitar (and blues) so personal, a la the sentiment you shared. Robert Fripp (who basically invented metal) even used fuzz, and I think still does to this day. I miss it.
This is more like the reggae version.
you stole the essence of the song!! :(
Eh it's ok...no one does it better than the Floyd tho
Nobody can ever be as good as Pink Floyd but that doesn't mean you can't appreciate a good cover.
best keyboard solo of all time
One of my favourite interpretations of one of my favourite pieces ever --, well, the beginning actually. Rudess has understood everything there is to understand about the song, and when he goes reverse, it's not just a trick, but actually a metaphor of what the sound is about. Petrucci, on the other hand, thinks it's about a cool guy playing cool guitar, and he totally missed the point, srry but it's what it is. This vibrato is so out of place. It's good again when he's supporting Rudess' phrasés, but then it's sh.t again. So strange.
seen this mind leaving body experience step right up folks
They performed the whole Dark Side of The Moon album in 2005 and released the DVD last year. If you're familiar with BitTorrent you should find the DVD there... it's where I got it from.
Bit torrent is gone now 😭
una delle versioni piu realistiche
The guitar is Petruccis own custom Erbieball/Musicman and it doesnt have that kind of unique sound what fender does, altough its a great guitar and i love it! And so i do love JPs playing!
Who the fuck is "pik flyd"?
Ese sonido viene en el korg oaysis.
now I've found a great cover of this amazing song
EXACTLY! I've been saying that exact thing for so long except for the controller part, which is a great analogy. A clean(er) tone conveys so much more. You can go to the other extreme with B.B. King, who adds nothing but a bit of reverb. There's so much character and feel (not feelING) to the playing that he can make one note sound like lightning with a bit of vibrato. There are a few exceptions... like two-handed tapping, which sounds best with tons of gain... you get almost a wah effect.
damnnn guy fierri can play..
what the ufck is this shtfive string bass? no progressive drumming? butchered the song completely
Chapeau les gars,,beau travail..anycolour you like buddy...
если этот цвет чёрный)
He made love to the keyboard
Though DT is not my kind of band (I like more trad. old Prog), I love the respect they show for their influences.
Big tribute, respect!
James LaBrie is awesome here 😁
playing while standing behind the keyboard is the equivalent to playing guitar with it behind your back
When thinking about which musician is better, we should think about what those musician should answer to that question. Probably they will say they work hard to be the best musician they can be, but they'll find ridiculous to be compared with any other musician. Always it seems to be kind of competition in which no musician involved should actually participate. Just stop making comparisons and enjoy that we share our lifes with big and extremelly good musicians as DT and many others are.
More floyd fans need to see this vid
Time and time again I'm reminded how good PF was and how tremendous DT is.
it should be a rule. if you're going to play Dave Gilmour solos you must have a fender. there's no excuse for butchering his clasic tone with anything but. I don't care how good or fast or clever you are. its NOTHING without tone. too many hours in front of Marshall stacks they're all deaf. Fender has 'something', I don't know what, but they got it.
Its not that he doesnt play it exactly right or sound like Gilmour, its the fact that just sounds like someone playing up and down scales. Its pretty much like the way Tremonti plays. I cant stand it. Its TOO studied and thats the problem.
that is a very racist comment....
Dream Theater in this concert did a true tribute to a band that influences them in many of their songs....and guess what they did a fantastic job with it.....part of all that hate is jealousy...You can't master your instrument as these guys do...They are not american..they are universal....so is their music
They are coming to my hometown....can't wait :-P
sure i guess u can say petrucchi can run circles on the guitar around gilmour..
but music is not totally about that.. ESPECIALLY floyd music.
im sure gilmour coulda become amazing at running circles on the guitar too if he wanted to.. but he lets the notes breathe.. he also lets the audience digest the music..
hitting 200000 notes doesnt make the song sound nicer..
tho this is a nice version anyway..
Well it's obviosu that this is acover but why do people have to search for the album version of the song? trhey're just paying tribute to pink floyd and better to appreciate cause ı think it could not have been better (excluding pf). I mean think of classical music then, shouldnt orchestras play the compositions of former composers just beacause it wouldn't sound like what they had in their minds back then in 27. century for instance?