Anette's ability to sing faster songs is gold , people gave her so much crap for not having the stage presence but if you look at the songs she had to sing and how fast she had to sing it takes a lot of breath work to pull that off, if you look at Floor attempting these songs she struggles with them and cant go nearly as fast.
THIS!!!🙌 Those songs are so hard to sing in terms of breath, rhythm, speed that they will roll over you if you don't keep up. I tried to sing Amaranth and I was literally out of breath like running a marathon after the first chorus.... I think people who never sung themselves will have a hard time recognizing this because the songs sound so nice and melodical but they are actually cruel😅
I'm so glad somebody finally pointed this out. It takes a lot of skill and breath control to sing at such a quick tempo, and neither Tarja or Floor does it as well as Anette. Floor has even admitted she has trouble with some of the faster Anette songs, and that's why they are limited in the set list. Btw I love all three vocalists.
@@funcentral9121 Yes I agree, in addition if you have listened to the studio version of Storytime the phrases are superimposed together , I don't know how to explain, but once a sentence is almost finished, it begins , which is impossible to reproduce live and which makes it more difficult to reproduce live =)
@@drekthar2447 Yes I do know what you mean :) It's almost impossible and if so very hard to sing live... This is also why covers on YT are edited/cut a lot etc. because singing this live is killing most singers😅
@@poopstain9333 better then floor could ever do with this song, she runs out of breath and struggles to come even close to the speed the song was written for.
@@Aaron-zl5gq Floor out of breath? Ever heard how long she could hold notes without breathing? :) Yes Annette was/is a good singer. But she has more of a pop voice then a metal/rock/classical voice. Also she doesn't even do the higher notes and doesn't have such of a stage presence.
La voz mas encantadora que hay, esta canción transmite eso, magia y sueños y me parece que la voz de Anette es perfecta. Adoro a cada vocalista que ha tenido Nightwish pero durante su etapas reaoectivas, por lo que siente que nadie interpreta esta cancion como Anette.
i love Floor with all my heart, i love Tarja too. They are all talented, but to those who are putting Anette down, remember that 2 of nighwish's best selling and successful albums was sung with Anette as vocals. Open minded music lovers back then didn't compair but instead they appreciated the music that was created after Tarja's era, and that was amazing. Even Tuomas respected them enough to decline all the requests of having Floor re-record all the old songs.
Well, Rock and metal music used to sell A LOT in those years. No hate for Anette at all, I really respect her. To be honest I find Tarja the most overrated of the 3 Nightwish singers. She was monotonous, repetitive (always uses that Falsettone in evrything) and she never had to prove her skills singing songs written for another singer, on the other hand Floor and Anette had to do that, they had to proove their skills singing songs written to fit another singer (tarja). That aside , I respect Anette and loved the album with her but, to be fair, I don't find the argoment of "the CD with Anette sold a lot of copies" to be honest Metal and rock music used to sell TONS of copies in those years, not only Nightwish. The era post 2013-2014 is the hip pop/ trap/ Kpop, pop, elettronic era. Even Huge band like Korn and slipknot are selling a very low numbers of copies in their last albums confronted with the years of golden era of metal and rock music. And even leaving the metal world aside, evrey artist is struggling to sell copies nowadays. Always a lower number of people buy CD , even pop CD. Imaginarium was a great album but sold way less copies than Dark Passion Play, something like half of the copies. Why ? Because DPP was in 2007(great years for rock music and metal) and Imaginarium was relased in 2011 when the decrase of rock and metal was already beginning. In 2015 the metal industry was already down as hell. Just look at the numbers of cd sold by huge names like Slayer, Slipknot, Korn, Pearl Jam...all of their latest albums are bad selled albums confronted to their previous.
I love Annette's voice so much, she's my favourite Nightwish singer. She doesn't deserve the hate she gets at all, completely uncalled for. Her voice is lovely in this, I wish there were more live videos with her.
Check out, if you haven't already, Annette's original songs, she's genuinely very good in them. The problem was that she is a rock singer and was given largely metal material. Take another very good female rock singer, let's say Alanis Morisette - she'd also perform typically metal songs so so. But it cuts both ways, switch the material and Tarja/Floor could very well be underwhelming in rock material.
Curiosamente los doa albunes que Nightwish elaboro con Annette han sido de los mas vendidos en las historia discografíca de la banda, Annette fue una estrategia de tomas para abrirse a un mercado mas amplio y captar otro tipo de publico y a mi parecer lo logro.. todas son espectaculares cada una a su forma pero yo soy team Annette
.. Las voces poperas siempre venden más, pero eso no quiere decir que son mejores. Es como el McDonald's es la hamburguesa y alimento más vendido del mundo, pero no quiere decir que es el mejor alimento. No desmerito a Anette es buena voz, pero su rango es muy limitado. Por eso Toumas prefirió una voz como la de Jansen, más versátil para sus futuros proyectos el cual aunque no alcanzaron las ventas de Dark Passion Play, fueron más influyentes ya que por ejemplo "Human" fue el álbum de Nigthwish más escuchado de toda su carrera gracias al internet y el disco de Metal más pirateado del 2020 en todo el mundo según google.
@@pedrotrujillo2397hay voces poperas de mujeres que son excelentes, no las puedes desmerecer, que no te guste el pop eso es otro tema...lo importante, no es solo la voz es lo que te transmite cuando Anette canta. Floor quizás sea mejor cantante que Anette, pero esta canción me llega más y la prefiero cantada por Anette, sin desmerecer lo excelente cantante que es Floor, Saludos
Tiene una hermosa voz, creo que con el tiempo la gente que dudaba de ella o le tenia enojo por haber sido el reemplazo de tarja se va a dar cuenta lo buena que era, y es..
Te recomiendo su último álbum de solista, excelentes reseñas por la crítica y es un masterclass de como cómo interpretar canciones. Se llama Strong el álbum
Estoy sorprendido,es la primera vez que veo este vídeo y quedé maravillado con Annette,que energía en el escenario,se sentía feliz saltando y eso me hizo sentír a mi feliz ,de verdad que lástima que no la supimos valorar cuando estuvo en la banda
Es que en sí los dos álbumes que grabó están hechos para ella, también es la primera vez que veo esta canción en vivo con Anette y me gustó mucho, pero a nivel de Tarja (con su tono de ópera) obvio las canciones anteriores no alcanza los tonos, y Floor (que es mi favorita por siempre) tiene esa combinación entre metal y ópera que a todos nos vuelve locos, y sin problema canta los éxitos anteriores como los nuevos. No tengo nada contra Anette, pero de verdad no me gusta como canta las demás canciones, yo por eso dejé de escuchar a Nightwish cuando ella entró. Tiene muy chida energía pero el mismo Tuomas lo dijo "su personalidad no encajaba con el resto de Nightwish" 🤷🏻♀️
magnifica, gran grupo y gran cantante, sus conciertos super entretenidos, cada una de las vocalistas de Nightwish a tenido exito, Annete tal vez no tenga el rango vocal de Tarja ni su elegancia, tal vez no tenga la voz de Floor y su presencia, pero su actitud , su estilo y conexión con el público es maravillosa
Really? Did you hear Floor singing it? That's another level. Higher lever. When Anette try to sing high, shamefull. She can sing pop but not Nightwish!
@@Arend010 This song was made to match Anette voice. Floor can sing it but its not the same. Just like Floor is way better at high pitch songs than Anette.
I like this version, this is the version of the band that recorded and Anette does a great job. In the studio it was perfect, live it was still really great. If you compare the individual singers for Nightwish, remember that Anette was chosen because she was really great and very different from her predecessor. And so is Floor.
Y la verdad que los trabajos con Floor son los de menor calidad de Nightwish, algo muy curioso es que Anette es en la actualidad la que está sacando mejores trabajos musicales. Para la muestra su último álbum de solista Strong que no baja de una media de 4/5 por la prensa en general. Si no lo has escuchado te lo recomiendo, está muy bueno
I think Anette performances are actually a hit or miss, for example this was pretty good in my opinion, I don't expect her to try and sing opera, and she controlled the voice as much as she could without overdoing. A lot of other times I heard her change the melody or doing always the same things with her voice in random parts of the song and a lot of times it didn't turn out well.
fair enough but so does floor . Listen to Waken 2018 and you'll realise it's not just Annette the touring is a tiring business for the girls. But when Annette gets it right I don't think Floor can touch her on most songs.
Live is another thing alltogether. She has the stronger midrange voice of all them three and that is a blessing and a curse. I mean floor can't do this song like her but when she goes high like on the poet she even does the choir boy tenor voices lol. Which is different. Tarja is zero on the lower registers and midrange as well...she sings unforgiven and it makes it operetic. Well everybody does its own thing I guess. Annete is the most easily exposed. She would do gospel pop rock etc great.
Here's a fact. Anette's voice is the one on two of the best Nightwish albums. And she kills it on those. So say what you want but her voice is immortal.
Me gusta Annette como cantante, el problema que tengo con ella es que no es metalera y eso se nota muchisimo en el escenario, cuando empieza esta cancion Floor hace un headbanging super epico. Y con Annette me falta esa "actitud metalera"
@@dojacatstanaccount7936 y si encima le sumamos esos vestidos de vecindario, la terminaba de embarrar!! Por lo menos hubiera comenzado con otros looks!! No sé!! Por ahí era una cuestión de la imagen que querían dar en esa época!! Vocalmente y a nivel feeling con el público estuvo bien!! Se movía bastante por todo el escenario, bailaba y bromeaba con los demás miembros de la banda!! Eso me gustaba!!
Nightiwsh said there was a dark cloud over this tour with Annette but I don’t see it here. Who knows what goes on behind the scenes but I hope to see her share the stage with them again on at least one song
Thats because this song is set in a lower range. In the songs were she doesnt have to belt high notes she does well. But when she has to sing at the top of her range she struggles. The problem is that she came following Tarja who can sing almost an entire octave higher than her, so most of the old songs were out of her confortable range. And even many of the songs written for her, in a few songs she would be required to hold G5's, which she just couldnt do consistently live and would either crack or go flat. The constant cracking on the high belt parts also affects the rest of the performance as the voice feels sour as a result.
Este álbum es de Anette, mejoró muchísimo, una pena que no la valoren, pero aunque les duela esta canción queda mucho mejor con su voz que con la de Floor.
A mí sí me encanta "Storytime" en voz de Floor pero solo en el "Showtime Storytime", qué presentación tan llena de energía. Luego la volví a escuchar en el "Vehicle of Spirit" y "Live in Buenos Aires" y terminó sonando acartonada, simplemente tratando de repetir una fórmula, se siente vacía.
While I like Tarja and Floor, I find myself going back to the DPP and Imaginaerum albums the most. And to the Anette haters out there, I think the albums weren't their best in spite of Anette, it was because of Anette, Tuomas, Jukka, Marco, Emppu, and Troy. That combination made those albums great. And yes, I am on a first name basis with them. ;-)
Her voice is a real contrast for the music, much brighter than the other two. I love the three equally, but I'd say Anett had the most uplifting voice, possibly because it's the brightest.
Everyone has their own opinion and understand Storytime was written for Anette and I have big smile on my face seeing her on stage. It is hard to compare a apple and a pear...but in favour of Floor,. The 'opera.part" in this song is a tape with Amette while Floor sings that part herself.
With Tarja - Nigtwish is a unique progresive symphonic metal band with classic female singer With Anette - Nigthwish is a unique progresive symphonic alternative metal band with pop rock female singer With Floor - Nightwish is a metal band with metal female singer I'm Progresive Republic, so I know what I should hear it from the band :)
The songs recorded by Anette can only be sung with excellent quality by herself. Not even the idolized Floor conveys the same emotion as Anette in the songs from Dark Passion Play and Imaginaerum. In fact, Imaginaerum is the band's best album by far.
You can tell this song was written for her because she can sing it really well..... Floor does have a really amazing and powerful voice, but she can't sing the line "I am the empty crib of Peter Pann" like Anette does. Because they are different voice ranges. None is better or worse... Just different
I like Tarja and Anette as Female singers, and i know that there will be no new records of the old songs with Floor, that is for me the reason to buy only there live concerts albums, because, i like the performance from Anette and respected that, but for me the best singing of storytime is with Floor as a female singer.
Yo me enamore de nightwish por ella.. Su calidez vocal.. El esfuerzo que hizo y el peso que cargo.. Una mujer valiente al aceptar semejante reto y a mi parecer lo cumplió a cavalidad... Los dos discos más vendidos de la banda fueron con ella y su estilo vocal abrió un nuevo mercado arrastrando nuevo público para la banda..
I'm a Floor's fan even before she was with Nightwish, but I must admit Annette's voice somewhat fits a bit better for this song... I dont know, I feel the backing vocals in the studio version along her voice gives that whimsical feeling Thoumas was searching to express in "Imaginareum"
@@JohnSmith-nz2yq of course, that’s why I made specifically emphasize in Imaginaerum, cuz you cant deny Floor owns this song Live. I mean not any singer can completely replace an entire Choir 🤷🏼♂️
@@kpsmorera I mean, I never heard anyone say what you said. I actually see your pov. That whimsical feeling, that dusk before the horror in the fair after midnight. Floor would be an entirely different feel.
I have to agree, I have always found her voice so addictive. I am crazy about Floor and Tarja, but people don't appreciate just how good Anette is. Her belting is terrific. I love the emotion she adds.
@@maxrav1831 Dude, grow some intelligence. Floor Jansen is without any doubt the best female singer AND performer. Anette has a very thin voice and just is a mediocre pop singer. Tarja has a nasal touch and I don't like the tone of her voice. The choice is oh so easy.
@@MarcelH666 Floor is massively overrated. Tarja gets the plaudits she deserves and Annette is massively underrated. I did have a chuckle to my self when you wrote Annette has a thin voice and Tarja is a bit nasal... LOL. I think you are a bit deaf personally.
Que emoción ver a Anette cantando su super éxito en vivo!!! no la había visto antes! ........ Pero es espectacular ver a Floor dándole ese toque tan metalero con su headbanging y excelente ejecución en vivo!!!!
th-cam.com/video/pvkYwOJZONU/w-d-xo.html if you still think so, take a listen to Floor's version, especially the ending. Both are nice, just wanted to share. :D
@@freedomsign2885 floor's voice is more powerful and mature and anette's voice is cute and girlish this song is cute etc so anette's better here floor's amazing but she sounds too mature for this song in my opinion
I think every Nightwish singer has a reason to be and I don't think they've ever chosen a wrong or bad singer. Anette may not have had the control of Tarja or the power of Floor but she did have her own personality and lyricism, and to be honest she is the one who sounds the most like her studio version live (on her own songs). The issue for me was that she could unfortunately not carry Tarja's songs, but many of my Nightwish favourites are on Imaginareum anyway... My point in the end is it's useless to hate anyone. I've seen many Floor haters in these comments and like... ok? She can sing many of both Tarja's and Anette's songs beautifully live, she's versatile and knows how to carry a show, so even if you preferred Anette you can't deny Floor's power and vocal ability. Just like I, who prefers Floor, can't deny Anette's or Tarja's talent. Let's just enjoy Nightwish now ok :)
Tredorre They all have their own style, and while I have my utmost respect for Tarja, and just LOVE Floor, Anette has an undeniable advantage that on my list of favourite songs from Nightwish, half of the songs are performed by Anette. Just think about that for a moment. My ultimate night’s wish is to see all three of them on the same stage, each shine in their own area. Because as much as I respect Tarja and love Floor, neither of them could perform Amaranth or The Islander (just to name my top favourites from the Anette era) in a way that satisfied me. If only they would all be still part of Nightwish, working together and do what they do best and let the another do their best where they cannot (if it makes sense). That would be heaven. Well... perhaps in another life.
@@CelestisForgeUK I wholeheartedly agree with you! Most of my favourite songs are also from Anette's time but I must admit there are a lot of them which I prefer when Floor is singing them live, which is why she is my favourite Nightwish singer. But Anette does have many songs that are way better when she sings them, like slow, love slow which I LOVE! My dream would be even just one concert where they could all get together, do their signature songs and perhaps sing some together, it would truly be the greatest show on earth (pun intended).
when you look at the TimeLaps of Nightwish.. Anette had also 5 Years in the Band...She is a realy good Singer too...But its so in the Live You got 1 Perfect Match to Fit and it will be the first or the Fivehundred...No one Knows....
It was the night before When all through the world No words, no dreams Then one day A writer by a fire Imagined all of Gaia Took a journey into a child-man's heart... A painter on the shore Imagined all the world Within a snowflake on his palm Unframed by poetry A canvas of awe Planet Earth falling back into the stars I am the voice of Never, Never Land The innocence, the dreams of every man I am the empty crib of Peter Pan A silent kite against the blue, blue sky Every chimney, every moonlit sight I am the story that will read you real Every memory that you hold dear I am the journey I am the destination I am the home The tale that reads you A way to taste the night The elusive high Follow the madness Alice you know once did Imaginarium, a dream emporium! Caress the tales And they will dream you real A storyteller's game Lips that intoxicate The core of all life Is a limitless chest of tales... I am the voice of Never, Never Land The innocence, the dreams of every man I am the empty crib of Peter Pan A silent kite against the blue, blue sky Every chimney, every moonlit sight I am the story that will read you real Every memory that you hold dear I am the voice of Never, Never Land The innocence, the dreams of every man Searching heavens for another earth... I am the voice of Never, Never Land The innocence, the dreams of every man I am the empty crib of Peter Pan A silent kite against the blue, blue sky Every chimney, every moonlit sight I am the story that will read you real Every memory that you hold dear
Gente ❤️ oq dizer sobre as três vocalistas da minha banda favorita ? ❤️ São maravilhosas , cada uma com sua extensão vocal ... Tarja : nossa sereia Annete : nossa fadinha Floor : nossa skjaldmö ( dama do escudo )
Cada vocalista que tuvo nightwish tienen sus sello impreso en los respectivos álbumes que grabaron, ya que ninguna canción se siente igual si no se escucha la vocalista original, por más que se diga que una canta mejor que otra, y definitivamente Dark passion play e Imaginaerum, son los discos de Anette Pd: Tuomas es quien supo adaptar las voces de cada una para crear esas obras maestras y que Anette llego en la época más turbulenta de nighwish, y se rifo sin titubear
Floor didn't have to either, but she did! Wacken 2013 is the Platinum standard! If you haven't seen it, you can't make a reasonable judgment.@@MNISZECZ
@@rolandconnor575Some singers don’t have to do it if they don’t want to. Floor likes freestyling a lot and it gets redundant sometimes I rather hear the band play their parts or hear the choir by itself, it’s ok to freestyle or sing along but it becomes too much after awhile
as a previous"tarja-only, thank god for floor, forget anette "nightwish fan I've finally grown the fuck up and went over to see how she's doing in the dark element and I'm a fan of her now. idk what went down within the band but she's a part of nightwish's story and I think she's handled the drama in a mature complete opposite way of what a "diva-complex" would've. imo time has shown her character, she tried her best to cover tarja's originals , not even floor can totally replace tarja's sound. which makes fucking sense, like why would we want a tarja 2.0? 3.0? tarja's voice is unique that's why we liked her in the first place, suggesting she can be replaced is stupid. and suggesting anette and floor are only her replacements is also stupid. anyway THIS PERFORMANCE WAS REALLY GOOD.
I totally agree. Back in the day when Nightwish had their first album, I really liked the idea of their sound but I just couldn't get into Tarjas voice. I even tried to pretend I liked them and listenend to their songs regularly. But at one point I just had to admit to myself that it's just not for me. More than a decade later I come across their Wacken show with Floor. I was totally surprised that there was a new singer and thought "Nightwish without Tarja, how's that gonna work?" but one minute later I was blown away by Nightwish with Floor. Only then I realised how much I missed, Tarja being fired, Anette, Anette being fired... I like Anette. If I had known her back then, she would have gotten me into Nightwish. Having missed all the drama, I feel like Anette never had a chance. Not because of her or because she did something wrong. But Tarja was such a big part in Nightwish, people missed her unique voice. While I agree that Floor sounds "more" Nightwish than Anette with her operatic and metal training, I don't think the fans would have welcomed her with such open arms if she directly replaced Tarja and not Anette. Anette was the rebound singer the band and the fans needed.
I thought Annette did this better live than Floor. Floor is one of the best live singers I've ever seen, but Annette destroys this song in terms of delivery.
Anette's ability to sing faster songs is gold , people gave her so much crap for not having the stage presence but if you look at the songs she had to sing and how fast she had to sing it takes a lot of breath work to pull that off, if you look at Floor attempting these songs she struggles with them and cant go nearly as fast.
THIS!!!🙌 Those songs are so hard to sing in terms of breath, rhythm, speed that they will roll over you if you don't keep up.
I tried to sing Amaranth and I was literally out of breath like running a marathon after the first chorus....
I think people who never sung themselves will have a hard time recognizing this because the songs sound so nice and melodical but they are actually cruel😅
I'm so glad somebody finally pointed this out. It takes a lot of skill and breath control to sing at such a quick tempo, and neither Tarja or Floor does it as well as Anette. Floor has even admitted she has trouble with some of the faster Anette songs, and that's why they are limited in the set list. Btw I love all three vocalists.
@@funcentral9121 Yes I agree, in addition if you have listened to the studio version of Storytime the phrases are superimposed together , I don't know how to explain, but once a sentence is almost finished, it begins , which is impossible to reproduce live and which makes it more difficult to reproduce live =)
@@drekthar2447 Yes I do know what you mean :) It's almost impossible and if so very hard to sing live... This is also why covers on YT are edited/cut a lot etc. because singing this live is killing most singers😅
I saw Nightwish in my City, Rio de Janeiro, with Tarja, Anette and Floor. All fantastic singers with unique caracteristics.
Annette is brilliant here!!
Whahaha, yeah right.
Nahh
@@poopstain9333 better then floor could ever do with this song, she runs out of breath and struggles to come even close to the speed the song was written for.
@@Aaron-zl5gq Floor out of breath? Ever heard how long she could hold notes without breathing? :) Yes Annette was/is a good singer. But she has more of a pop voice then a metal/rock/classical voice. Also she doesn't even do the higher notes and doesn't have such of a stage presence.
I miss Annette. All my favourite songs were sung by her.
La voz mas encantadora que hay, esta canción transmite eso, magia y sueños y me parece que la voz de Anette es perfecta. Adoro a cada vocalista que ha tenido Nightwish pero durante su etapas reaoectivas, por lo que siente que nadie interpreta esta cancion como Anette.
i love Floor with all my heart, i love Tarja too. They are all talented, but to those who are putting Anette down, remember that 2 of nighwish's best selling and successful albums was sung with Anette as vocals. Open minded music lovers back then didn't compair but instead they appreciated the music that was created after Tarja's era, and that was amazing. Even Tuomas respected them enough to decline all the requests of having Floor re-record all the old songs.
Anette's talent was so amazing her voice is rare and hard to copy she sounds like "aqua" she's beautiful too and descent lady on a metal band
November Harrow absolutely correct
Well, Rock and metal music used to sell A LOT in those years. No hate for Anette at all, I really respect her. To be honest I find Tarja the most overrated of the 3 Nightwish singers. She was monotonous, repetitive (always uses that Falsettone in evrything) and she never had to prove her skills singing songs written for another singer, on the other hand Floor and Anette had to do that, they had to proove their skills singing songs written to fit another singer (tarja). That aside , I respect Anette and loved the album with her but, to be fair, I don't find the argoment of "the CD with Anette sold a lot of copies" to be honest
Metal and rock music used to sell TONS of copies in those years, not only Nightwish. The era post 2013-2014 is the hip pop/ trap/ Kpop, pop, elettronic era. Even Huge band like Korn and slipknot are selling a very low numbers of copies in their last albums confronted with the years of golden era of metal and rock music.
And even leaving the metal world aside, evrey artist is struggling to sell copies nowadays. Always a lower number of people buy CD , even pop CD.
Imaginarium was a great album but sold way less copies than Dark Passion Play, something like half of the copies. Why ? Because DPP was in 2007(great years for rock music and metal) and Imaginarium was relased in 2011 when the decrase of rock and metal was already beginning. In 2015 the metal industry was already down as hell. Just look at the numbers of cd sold by huge names like Slayer, Slipknot, Korn, Pearl Jam...all of their latest albums are bad selled albums confronted to their previous.
Yes...but only because they were commercial....Floor suits Nightwish best of them all IMO
Lefty Me that’s just your opinion
best version of storytime its annette by far
Agreed, Floor version is good, but this song is perfect to Anette.
absofuckinglutly@@kingwakanda4252
Floor is much better
@@mikescaserra3069 not with this song
@@felipeemanuel5790 With every song!
Anette is simply the best.
Las canciones de esos dos álbumes son perfectas en la voz de Anette.
No todos, pero algunos son mejores siempre con la vos de Anette.
I still love her
What a beauty Anette is
I love Annette's voice so much, she's my favourite Nightwish singer. She doesn't deserve the hate she gets at all, completely uncalled for. Her voice is lovely in this, I wish there were more live videos with her.
Check out, if you haven't already, Annette's original songs, she's genuinely very good in them. The problem was that she is a rock singer and was given largely metal material. Take another very good female rock singer, let's say Alanis Morisette - she'd also perform typically metal songs so so. But it cuts both ways, switch the material and Tarja/Floor could very well be underwhelming in rock material.
@@Sanderus Floor certainly wouldn't, she's amazing at rock material, it's pretty much what she specializes in.
@@nocturnal03 Yes. I'll go one step further and say I haven't heard Floor sound underwhelming in any type of music.
Whatever people say, Both albums with Annete were fucking amazing, especialy Dark passion play… her voice is mesmerizing ❤️
@@smiljanlucic1934 For a pop singer. Not a Nightwish singer!
Curiosamente los doa albunes que Nightwish elaboro con Annette han sido de los mas vendidos en las historia discografíca de la banda, Annette fue una estrategia de tomas para abrirse a un mercado mas amplio y captar otro tipo de publico y a mi parecer lo logro.. todas son espectaculares cada una a su forma pero yo soy team Annette
.. Las voces poperas siempre venden más, pero eso no quiere decir que son mejores. Es como el McDonald's es la hamburguesa y alimento más vendido del mundo, pero no quiere decir que es el mejor alimento.
No desmerito a Anette es buena voz, pero su rango es muy limitado. Por eso Toumas prefirió una voz como la de Jansen, más versátil para sus futuros proyectos el cual aunque no alcanzaron las ventas de Dark Passion Play, fueron más influyentes ya que por ejemplo "Human" fue el álbum de Nigthwish más escuchado de toda su carrera gracias al internet y el disco de Metal más pirateado del 2020 en todo el mundo según google.
@@pedrotrujillo2397hay voces poperas de mujeres que son excelentes, no las puedes desmerecer, que no te guste el pop eso es otro tema...lo importante, no es solo la voz es lo que te transmite cuando Anette canta. Floor quizás sea mejor cantante que Anette, pero esta canción me llega más y la prefiero cantada por Anette, sin desmerecer lo excelente cantante que es Floor,
Saludos
Por lo que leí hace años el más vendido fue el ONCE
Hermosa Anette...…La que mas me gusta !!!!!!!!!!
She is so lovely
Tiene una hermosa voz, creo que con el tiempo la gente que dudaba de ella o le tenia enojo por haber sido el reemplazo de tarja se va a dar cuenta lo buena que era, y es..
Te recomiendo su último álbum de solista, excelentes reseñas por la crítica y es un masterclass de como cómo interpretar canciones.
Se llama Strong el álbum
Lovely voice!!
Estoy sorprendido,es la primera vez que veo este vídeo y quedé maravillado con Annette,que energía en el escenario,se sentía feliz saltando y eso me hizo sentír a mi feliz ,de verdad que lástima que no la supimos valorar cuando estuvo en la banda
Es que en sí los dos álbumes que grabó están hechos para ella, también es la primera vez que veo esta canción en vivo con Anette y me gustó mucho, pero a nivel de Tarja (con su tono de ópera) obvio las canciones anteriores no alcanza los tonos, y Floor (que es mi favorita por siempre) tiene esa combinación entre metal y ópera que a todos nos vuelve locos, y sin problema canta los éxitos anteriores como los nuevos. No tengo nada contra Anette, pero de verdad no me gusta como canta las demás canciones, yo por eso dejé de escuchar a Nightwish cuando ella entró. Tiene muy chida energía pero el mismo Tuomas lo dijo "su personalidad no encajaba con el resto de Nightwish" 🤷🏻♀️
Yo sí la valoré, desde el primer sencillo que sacaron con ella, "Eva"
Anette maravilhosa
la perfecccion!!!!!!!!!!! hermosoooooooooooooo la amooooo
magnifica, gran grupo y gran cantante, sus conciertos super entretenidos, cada una de las vocalistas de Nightwish a tenido exito, Annete tal vez no tenga el rango vocal de Tarja ni su elegancia, tal vez no tenga la voz de Floor y su presencia, pero su actitud , su estilo y conexión con el público es maravillosa
Y es muy hermosa
This song is so.... Anette❤
Nobody can do storytime like her.....
Really? Did you hear Floor singing it? That's another level. Higher lever. When Anette try to sing high, shamefull. She can sing pop but not Nightwish!
@@Arend010 ya
I stand by it.....floor just doesn't do it for me
@@Arend010 This song was made to match Anette voice. Floor can sing it but its not the same. Just like Floor is way better at high pitch songs than Anette.
agreeed suits her so nice
yup ! also makes me want to sing along unlike the other version ^-^
I like this version, this is the version of the band that recorded and Anette does a great job. In the studio it was perfect, live it was still really great.
If you compare the individual singers for Nightwish, remember that Anette was chosen because she was really great and very different from her predecessor. And so is Floor.
Siempre he preferido a Anette sobre Floor. Se llevó además todo el peso de ser la sucesora de Tarja. Hizo un trabajo increíble.
Y la verdad que los trabajos con Floor son los de menor calidad de Nightwish, algo muy curioso es que Anette es en la actualidad la que está sacando mejores trabajos musicales.
Para la muestra su último álbum de solista Strong que no baja de una media de 4/5 por la prensa en general.
Si no lo has escuchado te lo recomiendo, está muy bueno
I think Anette performances are actually a hit or miss, for example this was pretty good in my opinion, I don't expect her to try and sing opera, and she controlled the voice as much as she could without overdoing. A lot of other times I heard her change the melody or doing always the same things with her voice in random parts of the song and a lot of times it didn't turn out well.
well written
fair enough but so does floor . Listen to Waken 2018 and you'll realise it's not just Annette the touring is a tiring business for the girls. But when Annette gets it right I don't think Floor can touch her on most songs.
Live is another thing alltogether. She has the stronger midrange voice of all them three and that is a blessing and a curse. I mean floor can't do this song like her but when she goes high like on the poet she even does the choir boy tenor voices lol. Which is different.
Tarja is zero on the lower registers and midrange as well...she sings unforgiven and it makes it operetic. Well everybody does its own thing I guess. Annete is the most easily exposed. She would do gospel pop rock etc great.
She is perfect singing her own songs
Here's a fact. Anette's voice is the one on two of the best Nightwish albums. And she kills it on those. So say what you want but her voice is immortal.
3:13 Que mujer por dios....
Storytime is Anette
Scaretale is anette
Shame she couldn't do all of the song, the part she sings is so good.
Only Floor sings it ten times better.
@@Harolddespui I prefer story time by Anette too, that song suits her so well with her more cute voice if i can say
Not after Wacken 13 it's not. Scaretale is though.
love the way Anette speaks English, sounds beautiful~
Cara, Anette é linda demais!!!!
Brazil 2020!!!
Everyone has a great movingness about them.
La mejor cancion de Nightwish
No leo lloros
Always felt extra positive with Annete songs.
Storytime is your song.
Amazing performance... 😍😍😍 I love her little dance in the end👌
This is SO good! ❤
Anette tan poco valorada por ser la sucesora de Tarja pero me encanta su voz y su energía que trasmite en el escenario
Ela trouxe muita leveza para a banda. Gosto muito dela no palco, sempre animada.
Me gusta Annette como cantante, el problema que tengo con ella es que no es metalera y eso se nota muchisimo en el escenario, cuando empieza esta cancion Floor hace un headbanging super epico. Y con Annette me falta esa "actitud metalera"
Annette es única ❤️❤️
@@dojacatstanaccount7936
y si encima le sumamos esos vestidos de vecindario, la terminaba de embarrar!! Por lo menos hubiera comenzado con otros looks!! No sé!! Por ahí era una cuestión de la imagen que querían dar en esa época!! Vocalmente y a nivel feeling con el público estuvo bien!! Se movía bastante por todo el escenario, bailaba y bromeaba con los demás miembros de la banda!! Eso me gustaba!!
Grabó dos discos más que decentes 😁😁
I love Annette
Fantastic, and superb control of her voice.
Esta canción es de ella, realmente ella la interpreta, la canta increíble!!!
Los dos discos que hicieron con Annette son totalmente de ella ❤️.
Ame a Anette y me encanta Floor,ambas en su gran estilo interpretan de manera maravillosa Storytime
Nightiwsh said there was a dark cloud over this tour with Annette but I don’t see it here. Who knows what goes on behind the scenes but I hope to see her share the stage with them again on at least one song
Annette does such a great job on this.... I so wish there were more examples of her performing to this level
and that sums up anette's career with nightwish. every concert was a crapshot.
Thats because this song is set in a lower range. In the songs were she doesnt have to belt high notes she does well. But when she has to sing at the top of her range she struggles.
The problem is that she came following Tarja who can sing almost an entire octave higher than her, so most of the old songs were out of her confortable range. And even many of the songs written for her, in a few songs she would be required to hold G5's, which she just couldnt do consistently live and would either crack or go flat. The constant cracking on the high belt parts also affects the rest of the performance as the voice feels sour as a result.
Anette the best singing for nightwish
Este álbum es de Anette, mejoró muchísimo, una pena que no la valoren, pero aunque les duela esta canción queda mucho mejor con su voz que con la de Floor.
A mí sí me encanta "Storytime" en voz de Floor pero solo en el "Showtime Storytime", qué presentación tan llena de energía. Luego la volví a escuchar en el "Vehicle of Spirit" y "Live in Buenos Aires" y terminó sonando acartonada, simplemente tratando de repetir una fórmula, se siente vacía.
Horrible quality... but I suppose that's what we got. Nightwish damned to Hell not providing any decent quality live videos of Anette's era.
It's a crime against humanity.
yep fukers
Made in Hong Kong mate👍
@@maxrav1831 Made in Hong Kong is audio only.
THE DARK ELEMENT 2019 I Love Anette
Finn Emmanuel Zabala Enriquez tremendo disco!
Great performance Anette! Great voice!!! 🔥
While I like Tarja and Floor, I find myself going back to the DPP and Imaginaerum albums the most. And to the Anette haters out there, I think the albums weren't their best in spite of Anette, it was because of Anette, Tuomas, Jukka, Marco, Emppu, and Troy. That combination made those albums great. And yes, I am on a first name basis with them. ;-)
Same
Me too... I love the two albums with Annette the most
There really was just something special about those albums weren't there!
Tapp Morningwood totally agree
I agree
Beautiful song
I think anette is great n deserves to be appreciated alot more
Anette is the most interesting of the NW singers, most interesting voice as well.
Completely agree! She really is the most charismatic and intriguing singer they had.
nice joke
Her voice is a real contrast for the music, much brighter than the other two. I love the three equally, but I'd say Anett had the most uplifting voice, possibly because it's the brightest.
Everyone has their own opinion and understand Storytime was written for Anette and I have big smile on my face seeing her on stage.
It is hard to compare a apple and a pear...but in favour of Floor,. The 'opera.part" in this song is a tape with Amette while Floor sings that part herself.
With Tarja - Nigtwish is a unique progresive symphonic metal band with classic female singer
With Anette - Nigthwish is a unique progresive symphonic alternative metal band with pop rock female singer
With Floor - Nightwish is a metal band with metal female singer
I'm Progresive Republic, so I know what I should hear it from the band :)
She was the rocker of group of singers. She moved around the stage better.
Que brutal interpretación
Yes no one is better than her songs made to be
The songs recorded by Anette can only be sung with excellent quality by herself. Not even the idolized Floor conveys the same emotion as Anette in the songs from Dark Passion Play and Imaginaerum. In fact, Imaginaerum is the band's best album by far.
You can tell this song was written for her because she can sing it really well..... Floor does have a really amazing and powerful voice, but she can't sing the line "I am the empty crib of Peter Pann" like Anette does. Because they are different voice ranges. None is better or worse... Just different
We love all NIGHTWISH SINGERS, we must remain united
That song belongs only to her.
Just as the Phantom of the Opera is for Tarja... story time is only for Anette
I like Tarja and Anette as Female singers, and i know that there will be no new records of the old songs with Floor, that is for me the reason to buy only there live concerts albums, because, i like the performance from Anette and respected that, but for me the best singing of storytime is with Floor as a female singer.
This song will belong to Anette Tilly the end of time
los discos mas vendidos de nightwish es con anette.y las canciones ya son clascas.son de su sello de voz nadie como ella.me gusta.y me enamora.
Yo me enamore de nightwish por ella.. Su calidez vocal.. El esfuerzo que hizo y el peso que cargo.. Una mujer valiente al aceptar semejante reto y a mi parecer lo cumplió a cavalidad... Los dos discos más vendidos de la banda fueron con ella y su estilo vocal abrió un nuevo mercado arrastrando nuevo público para la banda..
She is cute
I'm a Floor's fan even before she was with Nightwish, but I must admit Annette's voice somewhat fits a bit better for this song... I dont know, I feel the backing vocals in the studio version along her voice gives that whimsical feeling Thoumas was searching to express in "Imaginareum"
Precisely. Imaginerium. Exactly.
@@JohnSmith-nz2yq of course, that’s why I made specifically emphasize in Imaginaerum, cuz you cant deny Floor owns this song Live.
I mean not any singer can completely replace an entire Choir 🤷🏼♂️
@@kpsmorera I mean, I never heard anyone say what you said. I actually see your pov. That whimsical feeling, that dusk before the horror in the fair after midnight. Floor would be an entirely different feel.
La voz de Anette es hermosa.
In my personal opinion, she is the best nightwish singer.
I have to agree, I have always found her voice so addictive. I am crazy about Floor and Tarja, but people don't appreciate just how good Anette is. Her belting is terrific. I love the emotion she adds.
it's her bright vocal that is captivating . I love tarjas dark vocal Floor is more of a middle of the road singer imho.
@@maxrav1831 Dude, grow some intelligence. Floor Jansen is without any doubt the best female singer AND performer. Anette has a very thin voice and just is a mediocre pop singer. Tarja has a nasal touch and I don't like the tone of her voice. The choice is oh so easy.
@@MarcelH666 Floor is massively overrated. Tarja gets the plaudits she deserves and Annette is massively underrated. I did have a chuckle to my self when you wrote Annette has a thin voice and Tarja is a bit nasal... LOL. I think you are a bit deaf personally.
I love Floor in Ayreon but Anette's brightness got me attracted to Nightwish. Tarja was just too dark for me. All boils down to personal taste
nice performance of hers
The Dark Element is where Anette should be. Tarja solo is where she should be. Fronting Nightwish is where Floor should be.
03:55 😍😍😍👌
Que emoción ver a Anette cantando su super éxito en vivo!!! no la había visto antes! ........ Pero es espectacular ver a Floor dándole ese toque tan metalero con su headbanging y excelente ejecución en vivo!!!!
Nightwish and Megadeth are the best!
やっぱりこの曲はAnetteが一番いい！
As much as I love Floor, Storytime is Annette’s song.
th-cam.com/video/pvkYwOJZONU/w-d-xo.html if you still think so, take a listen to Floor's version, especially the ending. Both are nice, just wanted to share. :D
I feel like storytime was meant to be a Pop-metal song, thus written for Anette
Floor's performance was great, it made a Pop-rock song more Metal.
@@freedomsign2885 floor's voice is more powerful and mature and anette's voice is cute and girlish
this song is cute etc so anette's better here
floor's amazing but she sounds too mature for this song in my opinion
@@freedomsign2885 sorry, it's great, but you can't take this song away from Annette. It fits her voice so perfectly.
LA MEJOR VERSION ES CON ELLA! ANNETE!
I think every Nightwish singer has a reason to be and I don't think they've ever chosen a wrong or bad singer. Anette may not have had the control of Tarja or the power of Floor but she did have her own personality and lyricism, and to be honest she is the one who sounds the most like her studio version live (on her own songs). The issue for me was that she could unfortunately not carry Tarja's songs, but many of my Nightwish favourites are on Imaginareum anyway... My point in the end is it's useless to hate anyone. I've seen many Floor haters in these comments and like... ok? She can sing many of both Tarja's and Anette's songs beautifully live, she's versatile and knows how to carry a show, so even if you preferred Anette you can't deny Floor's power and vocal ability. Just like I, who prefers Floor, can't deny Anette's or Tarja's talent. Let's just enjoy Nightwish now ok :)
Tredorre They all have their own style, and while I have my utmost respect for Tarja, and just LOVE Floor, Anette has an undeniable advantage that on my list of favourite songs from Nightwish, half of the songs are performed by Anette. Just think about that for a moment. My ultimate night’s wish is to see all three of them on the same stage, each shine in their own area. Because as much as I respect Tarja and love Floor, neither of them could perform Amaranth or The Islander (just to name my top favourites from the Anette era) in a way that satisfied me. If only they would all be still part of Nightwish, working together and do what they do best and let the another do their best where they cannot (if it makes sense). That would be heaven. Well... perhaps in another life.
@@CelestisForgeUK I wholeheartedly agree with you! Most of my favourite songs are also from Anette's time but I must admit there are a lot of them which I prefer when Floor is singing them live, which is why she is my favourite Nightwish singer. But Anette does have many songs that are way better when she sings them, like slow, love slow which I LOVE! My dream would be even just one concert where they could all get together, do their signature songs and perhaps sing some together, it would truly be the greatest show on earth (pun intended).
The Best
La Amo ... :D Joder Hermano, canta hermoso...
Yo también la amo y a floor también
Las 3 son muy buenas
No pensé que rivera la misma voz en vivo:000
Floort is the best but Anette in story time is one of the beat nw songs.
when you look at the TimeLaps of Nightwish.. Anette had also 5 Years in the Band...She is a realy good Singer too...But its so in the Live You got 1 Perfect Match to Fit and it will be the first or the Fivehundred...No one Knows....
Gr8 performance 👍
It was the night before
When all through the world
No words, no dreams
Then one day
A writer by a fire
Imagined all of Gaia
Took a journey into a child-man's heart...
A painter on the shore
Imagined all the world
Within a snowflake on his palm
Unframed by poetry
A canvas of awe
Planet Earth falling back into the stars
I am the voice of Never, Never Land
The innocence, the dreams of every man
I am the empty crib of Peter Pan
A silent kite against the blue, blue sky
Every chimney, every moonlit sight
I am the story that will read you real
Every memory that you hold dear
I am the journey
I am the destination
I am the home
The tale that reads you
A way to taste the night
The elusive high
Follow the madness
Alice you know once did
Imaginarium, a dream emporium!
Caress the tales
And they will dream you real
A storyteller's game
Lips that intoxicate
The core of all life
Is a limitless chest of tales...
I am the voice of Never, Never Land
The innocence, the dreams of every man
I am the empty crib of Peter Pan
A silent kite against the blue, blue sky
Every chimney, every moonlit sight
I am the story that will read you real
Every memory that you hold dear
I am the voice of Never, Never Land
The innocence, the dreams of every man
Searching heavens for another earth...
I am the voice of Never, Never Land
The innocence, the dreams of every man
I am the empty crib of Peter Pan
A silent kite against the blue, blue sky
Every chimney, every moonlit sight
I am the story that will read you real
Every memory that you hold dear
can you compose another witch song???thank you
Anette may not be the best singer Nightwish had, but the most beautiful one for sure
Matter of taste.
Gente ❤️ oq dizer sobre as três vocalistas da minha banda favorita ? ❤️ São maravilhosas , cada uma com sua extensão vocal ...
Tarja : nossa sereia
Annete : nossa fadinha
Floor : nossa skjaldmö ( dama do escudo )
I Love You ANETTE OLZON.
Essa música sim eu prefiro ela do que a floor.
Óbvio isso não é música pra ser rock pauleira e sim reflexivo!
Gosto mais da Anette também.
Concordo em tudo..
Anettes's songs work on with her on vocals. Sorrir my english.
We miss you Anette :(
Storytime is Anette, but how is possible to hate Floor?🤔
@@gazprom8731 some people just want to spread their poisonous hatred
Floor ♾️
Her "teenage" voice really fits this song. Way better than Floor.
Cada vocalista que tuvo nightwish tienen sus sello impreso en los respectivos álbumes que grabaron, ya que ninguna canción se siente igual si no se escucha la vocalista original, por más que se diga que una canta mejor que otra, y definitivamente Dark passion play e Imaginaerum, son los discos de Anette
Pd: Tuomas es quien supo adaptar las voces de cada una para crear esas obras maestras y que Anette llego en la época más turbulenta de nighwish, y se rifo sin titubear
I can't believe she could not sing the middle interlude and had to have a recording. More evidence that Floor is not of this world.
So why she has to? Choir part is the choir part, it sounds sterlingly itself. Anette was good and organic at singing her part
Floor didn't have to either, but she did! Wacken 2013 is the Platinum standard! If you haven't seen it, you can't make a reasonable judgment.@@MNISZECZ
@@rolandconnor575Some singers don’t have to do it if they don’t want to. Floor likes freestyling a lot and it gets redundant sometimes I rather hear the band play their parts or hear the choir by itself, it’s ok to freestyle or sing along but it becomes too much after awhile
as a previous"tarja-only, thank god for floor, forget anette "nightwish fan I've finally grown the fuck up and went over to see how she's doing in the dark element and I'm a fan of her now. idk what went down within the band but she's a part of nightwish's story and I think she's handled the drama in a mature complete opposite way of what a "diva-complex" would've. imo time has shown her character, she tried her best to cover tarja's originals , not even floor can totally replace tarja's sound. which makes fucking sense, like why would we want a tarja 2.0? 3.0? tarja's voice is unique that's why we liked her in the first place, suggesting she can be replaced is stupid. and suggesting anette and floor are only her replacements is also stupid. anyway THIS PERFORMANCE WAS REALLY GOOD.
I totally agree. Back in the day when Nightwish had their first album, I really liked the idea of their sound but I just couldn't get into Tarjas voice. I even tried to pretend I liked them and listenend to their songs regularly. But at one point I just had to admit to myself that it's just not for me. More than a decade later I come across their Wacken show with Floor. I was totally surprised that there was a new singer and thought "Nightwish without Tarja, how's that gonna work?" but one minute later I was blown away by Nightwish with Floor. Only then I realised how much I missed, Tarja being fired, Anette, Anette being fired... I like Anette. If I had known her back then, she would have gotten me into Nightwish. Having missed all the drama, I feel like Anette never had a chance. Not because of her or because she did something wrong. But Tarja was such a big part in Nightwish, people missed her unique voice. While I agree that Floor sounds "more" Nightwish than Anette with her operatic and metal training, I don't think the fans would have welcomed her with such open arms if she directly replaced Tarja and not Anette. Anette was the rebound singer the band and the fans needed.
I thought Annette did this better live than Floor. Floor is one of the best live singers I've ever seen, but Annette destroys this song in terms of delivery.
👍🌹👏🥂❤
I like her last riffing in storytime. Her agility surprised me.
Anette's new album ( 2020 ) if you haven't heard it.
th-cam.com/video/6QHqQj0WrcA/w-d-xo.html