@@MrGemHunter I think Electrochemistry is more responsible for managing what Harry wants in most cases. Imo, Volition keeps a deliberately firm grasp on what Harry NEEDS, and it does its damnedest to try and make him want the same thing, even if it's only one of the myriad voices in his head clamouring to be heard over the crowd. Helping him to help himself.
@@samcook4207 lenval brown has a different cadence for each skill its very subtle and you might not even notice it unless you listen side by side but i think its great
The only disappointment that I have with Final cut version of the game is that all of the voices for skills were done by the same person, which is sad, as this video perfectly shows that skills by themselves are rather unique. Thanks for doing this! The electrochemistry voice was the best reading of "boy" I heard in english language.
one voice actor is fine though i wish he'd play more with his voice to match the "personalities', anyway, it's still really great that they voiced them all.
I mean, it makes sense in the narrative sense to have one voice actor. To my knowledge there’s no allusions to Harry having schizophrenia where it would make sense to have multiple different voices talking to you.
@@Loofty777 You can literally talk to your tie. Who has its own unique voice. Also the Ancient Reptilian Brain and the Limbic System have unique voices despite them just being Harry talking to himself.
@@juliagoetia You make some good points. Harry does talk to his tie, but only when you invest enough points into Inland Empire, which basically translates to gameplay as imagination. The Ancient Reptilian Brain and the Limbic System (and the spinal cord) all have the same voice actor despite being so different from the other. Perhaps the Limbic System represents the feminine, emotional, side of Harry while the ARB is biological, hardwired over years of evolution with the goal of survival.
I would pay ungodly amounts of money to get your skill voices into the game. It's absolutely perfect. This is almost exactly what I had imagined the skills would sound like. Major props to you!
Maybe, but authority also goes into histrionics every time you fail a test so that... actually wait, now I absolutely wanna hear judge dredd screaming “FUCK THE HAT?!”
"No, this is somewhere to be. This is all you have, but it's still something. Streets and sodium lights. The sky, the world. You're *still* alive." God that reading broke my heart.
I used REAPER to record and Audacity to edit it all together! Shivers' voice is a riff on a Warcraft Lich King effect (as demonstrated here th-cam.com/video/ythJI6Bq88Q/w-d-xo.html) and Inland is just me putting together two separate recordings where you pan one of them through the left speaker, and the other through the right.
I'm honestly surprised I can't find anyone else's take on this. I stopped playing only a little bit through the game so I could wait for the Final Cut version to drop so I could experience the game in all its glory (and to avoid burnout), and I'm very much hoping that the skills are all voiced. And if they're as good as this, it's going to be a magical experience.
Ever since I heard the voices for Ancient Reptilian Brain, etc, in the intro, I've been wondering what the other internal voices sounded like. This is fantastic, great job! I'm hoping you continue this and do Esprit du Corps, Savoie Faire, Physical Instrument, etc
Savoir faire is a frat bro to me. Hand-eye coordination speaks like a distracted toolsmith. Composure is a dignified noble or diplomat Physical instrument is your average tough guy
I think we should keep our expectations proportional to the reality, the budget required to have each skill voiced completely different and time would be insane. I love this version but I am definitely not dissatisfied with the Final cut. It's still fully voiced and that on it's own is incredible.
I feel like just with their writing style and opportunities offered, the skills are unique enough. The same voice actor performing all of them seems a little boring, but it makes sense seeing as every one of them is part of Harry, and (unless in situations where they do get individual voices e.g: shivers) Harry probably isn't bothered enough to actually give them a unique voice, as they are constructs of his mind, their advice alone is enough for him, and your thoughts are generally monotone and unpronounceable, just as the actor makes them all.
even now with final cut i kinda want these voices for the skills, i'd love to see a mod for these voices or maybe even like a dlc pack or something, i'd also love to see all the voices for the skills you could come up with.
Oh man....this is what we should have gotten...the inner voices are too much the same. Shivers is supposed to be sad. Final Cut voices are....odd. The narrator is phenomenal don't get me wrong, he was made to VA. But it the fact that the voices don't have their own tone is...):
They all do have their own tone, granted. Credit to the Narrator again, you can hear the distinctions between the four attributes overtime, all carrying their own cadence and energy. I do completely get what you mean, though; It was my expectation too when it was first announced, and I was admittedly a little upset when it wasn't the case. Hopefully, there can be a community voice pack in the future to remedy such a thing!
@@dru8137 After I sat down and binged the game how I normally did, I absolutely agree. I didn't give it much of a chance at first, and I do 100% hear the tone differences now. I do think a community pack would be really fun though, for the people who want that dramatic difference!!
Considering the amount of dialogues the narrator's VA have to do,I don't think it's even possible to have this level of detail to every single line unless they hire more people for each the attributes :(
the actual VA was interviewed on this, and essentially the voices have the same tone to demonstrate that they are not _characters_ with _personalities_ , but rather processes of one character who percieves the world through a set group of lenses & filters. they're the same tone because it is, both in a figurative and literal sense, the same person reading the same lines, but with different tonal language that indicates they're not all the same. they do have their own personalities in the end because they're, well, personified, but they're very subtle in comparison to if harry was written like a system or someone with imaginary friends . :0
I agree with everyone in the fact that the skills should have different voices but I think we fail to realize in a way it’s Harry’s brain and that’s just how his thoughts sound.
Gotta say, while I think the narrator for The Final Cut of Disco Elysium does a great job, I would of loved to hear more distinct skill voices. You really nailed what I think would of gone great in the game. Can't help but wonder what your take on some of the other skills'd be.
i think people are being ungrateful as hell here, it's a completley free update with new content after all, and the characters have unique voices, just not the thoughts
They better cast you for all the skills. I'll be doing another run after the update drops, and you can bet your ass I'll be rolling half-light if I don't hear your voice then.
Heavily dissapointed official game devs never did this in the Final Cut, the reasoning behind that was so weak. Genuinely wish someone would voice skills exactly like in this video, maybe a mod or something
It was a genuine solution, to make inner voices the way they did it. As if it was an audiobook, plain - so that players own imagination would work more. Not to disrupt peoples view of the PC
Personally I think that Authority is way more serious and monotone, since it's how I imagine Tequila Sunset sees authority, but all of these are still very great and amazing
Truth be told, I'd still prefer the original for Authority (the variation presented here sounds more like Drama to me), but everything else is top-notch! Damn good acting, sir!
I've seen the offical voicing of the skills. And I must say that for me personally your voicing is so much better and it is such a shame they didn't do it the way you did.
After playing the Final Cut, I enjoyed the voices of the skills so much that it made me wish that each had their own tone, like this. Hopefully some fan project can make it happen~
I would LOVE to make a mod replacing ALL the skill lines with your lines! It would be a simple swap around and a quick and relatively easy install package for other users.
All wonderful, especially Shivers, I was just a bit disappointed by Electrochem, I always thought of it as something more inviting and seducing, but I get your take on it. Authority also sounded too comic, like a cartoon police officer.
![[Disco Elysium] Drunk gay communist sorry cop ending](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bF8nj2Wtcio/mqdefault.jpg)
I love how you portrayed Volition. Perfectly average-sounding but with a tired determination to back it up.
truly the Mom Friend of the group
Volition is perfect. In my head, Volition sounds EXACTLY like Harry, but tired of his bullshit
Volition wants exactly what Harry wants... *exactly* what Harry wants
@@MrGemHunter I think Electrochemistry is more responsible for managing what Harry wants in most cases.
Imo, Volition keeps a deliberately firm grasp on what Harry NEEDS, and it does its damnedest to try and make him want the same thing, even if it's only one of the myriad voices in his head clamouring to be heard over the crowd. Helping him to help himself.
GET A GOD DAMN RUM AND LEMONADE BOOOOOOOOOOOOY
0:54 if anyone is having brainworms and wants to go right to electrochemistry
Damn you got skills man
Which ones?
He showed so many ones that i cant pin point his exact build.
Shivers gave me legitimate shivers. Can’t wait to see how your interpretations stack up against the fully voiced definitive edition
Honestly, both are so great.
I'd have vastly preferred something like this, but I understand it's not very feasible for hundreds of thousands of lines of dialogue.
@@samcook4207 lenval brown has a different cadence for each skill its very subtle and you might not even notice it unless you listen side by side but i think its great
That 2nd person perspective with the shrill voice really nails it
Volition and Half-Light are my favorites of the bunch.
I love Perception myself
Inland empire is my favorite
The only disappointment that I have with Final cut version of the game is that all of the voices for skills were done by the same person, which is sad, as this video perfectly shows that skills by themselves are rather unique.
Thanks for doing this! The electrochemistry voice was the best reading of "boy" I heard in english language.
one voice actor is fine though i wish he'd play more with his voice to match the "personalities', anyway, it's still really great that they voiced them all.
It's not about the numbers it's about the talent, you need one person who can mimic different voices.
I mean, it makes sense in the narrative sense to have one voice actor. To my knowledge there’s no allusions to Harry having schizophrenia where it would make sense to have multiple different voices talking to you.
@@Loofty777 You can literally talk to your tie. Who has its own unique voice.
Also the Ancient Reptilian Brain and the Limbic System have unique voices despite them just being Harry talking to himself.
@@juliagoetia You make some good points. Harry does talk to his tie, but only when you invest enough points into Inland Empire, which basically translates to gameplay as imagination.
The Ancient Reptilian Brain and the Limbic System (and the spinal cord) all have the same voice actor despite being so different from the other. Perhaps the Limbic System represents the feminine, emotional, side of Harry while the ARB is biological, hardwired over years of evolution with the goal of survival.
I would pay ungodly amounts of money to get your skill voices into the game. It's absolutely perfect. This is almost exactly what I had imagined the skills would sound like. Major props to you!
Really well done. That's basically how I imagined Half-Light would sound.
Great video. Loved Werner Herzog as Perception lol
I would picture Authority more as a Judge Dredd type of voice
Maybe, but authority also goes into histrionics every time you fail a test so that... actually wait, now I absolutely wanna hear judge dredd screaming “FUCK THE HAT?!”
That sounds nothing like Herzog.
"No, this is somewhere to be. This is all you have, but it's still something. Streets and sodium lights. The sky, the world. You're *still* alive." God that reading broke my heart.
I love the effects you added to shivers and inland empire! What software did you use?
I used REAPER to record and Audacity to edit it all together! Shivers' voice is a riff on a Warcraft Lich King effect (as demonstrated here th-cam.com/video/ythJI6Bq88Q/w-d-xo.html) and Inland is just me putting together two separate recordings where you pan one of them through the left speaker, and the other through the right.
I also love how Half Light has a subtly quiet Hardcore Theme overlayed.
I'm honestly surprised I can't find anyone else's take on this. I stopped playing only a little bit through the game so I could wait for the Final Cut version to drop so I could experience the game in all its glory (and to avoid burnout), and I'm very much hoping that the skills are all voiced. And if they're as good as this, it's going to be a magical experience.
"THAT'S THE SPIRIT! _Never forget!_ The _whole_ world is a wooden house, and _you, are a goddamned_ *_FLAMETHROWER!"_*
Ohohohoho yes~
ngl i was expecting this to be cringy, but... it's actually great? nice job.
Ever since I heard the voices for Ancient Reptilian Brain, etc, in the intro, I've been wondering what the other internal voices sounded like. This is fantastic, great job! I'm hoping you continue this and do Esprit du Corps, Savoie Faire, Physical Instrument, etc
Savoir faire is a frat bro to me. Hand-eye coordination speaks like a distracted toolsmith.
Composure is a dignified noble or diplomat
Physical instrument is your average tough guy
I cant wait for you being able to do audio books with your voice
I think we should keep our expectations proportional to the reality, the budget required to have each skill voiced completely different and time would be insane. I love this version but I am definitely not dissatisfied with the Final cut. It's still fully voiced and that on it's own is incredible.
You don't need a huge budget for this, just one talented person who can mimic several different voices.
You're the personification of imagination what do you mean "be realistic"!
I feel like just with their writing style and opportunities offered, the skills are unique enough. The same voice actor performing all of them seems a little boring, but it makes sense seeing as every one of them is part of Harry, and (unless in situations where they do get individual voices e.g: shivers) Harry probably isn't bothered enough to actually give them a unique voice, as they are constructs of his mind, their advice alone is enough for him, and your thoughts are generally monotone and unpronounceable, just as the actor makes them all.
Would be fun as a fan mod though
even now with final cut i kinda want these voices for the skills, i'd love to see a mod for these voices or maybe even like a dlc pack or something, i'd also love to see all the voices for the skills you could come up with.
Gonna have to figure out a way to get people to record hundreds of lines
Oh man....this is what we should have gotten...the inner voices are too much the same. Shivers is supposed to be sad. Final Cut voices are....odd. The narrator is phenomenal don't get me wrong, he was made to VA. But it the fact that the voices don't have their own tone is...):
They all do have their own tone, granted. Credit to the Narrator again, you can hear the distinctions between the four attributes overtime, all carrying their own cadence and energy. I do completely get what you mean, though; It was my expectation too when it was first announced, and I was admittedly a little upset when it wasn't the case. Hopefully, there can be a community voice pack in the future to remedy such a thing!
@@dru8137 After I sat down and binged the game how I normally did, I absolutely agree. I didn't give it much of a chance at first, and I do 100% hear the tone differences now. I do think a community pack would be really fun though, for the people who want that dramatic difference!!
Considering the amount of dialogues the narrator's VA have to do,I don't think it's even possible to have this level of detail to every single line unless they hire more people for each the attributes :(
It makes me think that the voice they all have is Tequila Sunsets real voice
the actual VA was interviewed on this, and essentially the voices have the same tone to demonstrate that they are not _characters_ with _personalities_ , but rather processes of one character who percieves the world through a set group of lenses & filters. they're the same tone because it is, both in a figurative and literal sense, the same person reading the same lines, but with different tonal language that indicates they're not all the same. they do have their own personalities in the end because they're, well, personified, but they're very subtle in comparison to if harry was written like a system or someone with imaginary friends . :0
Shivers and Perception were my favorite
Me too
I love this game and the personality dialogues are my favorite part of it!!! you have a great take on them :)
I love that Half-light voice, so perfect.
You picked some really good lines. Half light destroyed me hahaha
Oh, this is brilliant. I can’t wait for the Final Cut re-release!
What the Final Cut skills should have been.
Shivers. That was awesome.
This is absolutely amazing !! love the accent on perception.
perception is my favorite
the accent is perfect and the line is beautiful
This is exactly as I imagined it to be, great take
Electro-chemistry has that dumbassery, it's so fitting
I agree with everyone in the fact that the skills should have different voices but I think we fail to realize in a way it’s Harry’s brain and that’s just how his thoughts sound.
Gotta say, while I think the narrator for The Final Cut of Disco Elysium does a great job, I would of loved to hear more distinct skill voices. You really nailed what I think would of gone great in the game. Can't help but wonder what your take on some of the other skills'd be.
*would have. would of doesnt mean anything...
russian accent really fits perception. this is amazing, voices are so fitting, i can't explain my happiness :)
This is way better than the Final Cut Voices holyshit they should've just hired you to do them
For real, I can't listen to the narrator he's so bored
@@Orbotus Whaaat? I *loved* the narrator!
The narrator is good but it would've been better if the skills had unique voices. Would've given the game more personality.
Quick reminder this is the same guy that reads the animals Middle English wiki pages like FROGGE
Very cool! 👍
But i think authority need more heavy, be self-controlled sound.
And thank you for made this wonderful fan voice vedio.
Bro this made feel a lot of things honestly thank you I love your channel
Shivers gives me the shivers...
Oh god this is so well done, youve got skills indeed !!
i think people are being ungrateful as hell here, it's a completley free update with new content after all, and the characters have unique voices, just not the thoughts
so free means better? I wish they'd charge me to choose Final Cut. That way i would still be able to play original version officially.
They better cast you for all the skills. I'll be doing another run after the update drops, and you can bet your ass I'll be rolling half-light if I don't hear your voice then.
Ya well guess what they arent so live with the almost masterpeice we got
Heavily dissapointed official game devs never did this in the Final Cut, the reasoning behind that was so weak. Genuinely wish someone would voice skills exactly like in this video, maybe a mod or something
Totally agree with you, the voice acting in the final cut was a major let down for me
Budget cuts...
Since you think you can do better why dont you make your own indie game with a shitload of lines and quite a few voice actors
It was a genuine solution, to make inner voices the way they did it. As if it was an audiobook, plain - so that players own imagination would work more. Not to disrupt peoples view of the PC
Everything is perfectly on the mark. And it's beautiful.
I would love to see you do more!
I wanna hear your take on the empathy skill, I can imagine a deep and raspy but gentle and sophisticated voice
Personally I think that Authority is way more serious and monotone, since it's how I imagine Tequila Sunset sees authority, but all of these are still very great and amazing
Truth be told, I'd still prefer the original for Authority (the variation presented here sounds more like Drama to me), but everything else is top-notch! Damn good acting, sir!
Wish we had these voices instead of the narrator in the game, these voices give off so much more personality that just make me FEEL it.
Narrator is pretty great imo but yeah the thoughts really needed their own voices
That shivers is great. Would love to hear it say “where the hood, where the hood, where the hood at”
Damn, how you voiced Inland Empire, Half-Light and Shivers is 99% how I imagined them. How you voiced Perception is how I actually imagined Drama.
Holy shit Luke, you gotta return to this game sometime- your voices for it are so good.
Мне нравится как они звучат, все выделяются не только характером, но и голосом❤
Inland empire sounds like gman
I have no idea what any of this is from
Let's be honest here, inland empire needs David Lynch himself to be perfected xD
Kinda wish they did something like this instead of just having the one guy
I've seen the offical voicing of the skills. And I must say that for me personally your voicing is so much better and it is such a shame they didn't do it the way you did.
yeah, oh well
Get a god damn rum and lemonade *BOOOOOY!*
Damn, just IMAGINE how the inner conflict should sounds like.
After playing the Final Cut, I enjoyed the voices of the skills so much that it made me wish that each had their own tone, like this. Hopefully some fan project can make it happen~
Seriously, that's the only thing missing that would make the game perfect.
Shivers sounded like David Bateson Hitman's voice.
Amazing job, man. Loved them all.
Как это прекрасно!
Holy shit, this would’ve been glorious
Shivers actually sent shivers down my spine, that's absolutely insane. Amazing work!
I wish I had volition in my head all the time
Ok but like I totally want to hear your interpretations of Physical Instrument and Interfacing!
You did Shivers really good. I had shivers after i heard your version of it.
Damn this is so much better than what we got.
I would LOVE to make a mod replacing ALL the skill lines with your lines! It would be a simple swap around and a quick and relatively easy install package for other users.
Man I love this voices. I'd love to hear some of them in the director's cut.
Just as I thought, just as I afraid - your version is actually better than the official one!
as much as i like this, i expected you to voice the tie.
I want to hear you say *братан*
Great job holy shit. Really increases my enjoyment of the game putting a voice to the...well, the voice
Wow it's actuallyy really, really good! Well done, man!
I guess this is canon now
I wanna know the accent in Perception, that was actually amazing.
sounds like slavic accent
So much better than what they actually did... Imagine that, personalities having emotion and being unique, what a crazy idea.
holy moly i actually shivered
This is better than the official final cut version
0:47 "You shiver with..............................anticipation".
Perceptions voice be the best.
I had finished this game recently. Pretty funny I haven't seen this any point earlier at all. I've been subbed for a bit.
How the fuck did I not see this sooner!?
i absolutely love perception and the slight accent in their voice it feels so fitting
Be a voice actor Luke, be a voice actor
You nailed half light so well
Damn these are wonderful. Especially Volition, Inland Empire and Electrochemistry! I'd love to hear more of them.
ngl, the perception one reminds me of one of the League of Legends champion voiceline
The only VA change in Disco Elysium that I would've actually wanted.
I would LOVE to do a project like this and lend my voice to it. I loved some of these here, and the game was amazing. Instantly a favorite.
I know that having the narrator do different voices for each thought would be incredibly impractical (wirral untethered behavior) but it’d be real fun
Shivers actually gave me shivers. Nicely done.
I just finished the game for the first time, and I will say this would have definitely made it feel more impactful.
this works so much better!!!!!
Would love to see the others, these are so good. I really like Inland and Half-Light in particular.
This video is a fucking treasure.
I only wished it had a voice for empathy (my favourite skill) as well
Funny man got scary real scary quick
So glad to see more love for Disco Elysium
(Ignore that I'm two years late lol)
god damn this is such a good interpretation of their voices
I didn't notice it was luke until electrochemistry
All wonderful, especially Shivers, I was just a bit disappointed by Electrochem, I always thought of it as something more inviting and seducing, but I get your take on it. Authority also sounded too comic, like a cartoon police officer.
ohhh man that Inland empire tickled my brain!