Damaging a Friendship
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 เม.ย. 2023
- The plaintiff has known the defendant for a decade and thought she could trust her. However, the plaintiff claims she rented a car for the defendant in her time of need, but the defendant returned the car with dents on the roof and doors, so the plaintiff is suing for the damages. The defendant alleges there were no damages to the car when she returned it, and the rental company is just trying to rip her off.
28-129 - บันเทิง
I ain’t putting my neck out for any adult who won’t use a bank or credit Union
Having an account is part of being an adult
She gots hers in a shoebox🤣💀
Right?!
Exactly. That’s so suspicious
Right?!😂
The judge didn't have to let the plaintiff take a recess to get the bank statements she could've just dismissed it
And then the plaintiff - She's the one who has to prove it, not me.....um.....no - she's the defendant who is being accused!
@@supportvawa2213 silly plaintiff smh
@Support VAWA I know. One of the first rules of being a plaintiff is that they have the burden of proof, not the defendant.
Which would'nt make for good TV........you DO understand that.........riiiiiight?
@Little Beaux-Peep right, I've seen it happen plenty of times on this show.
The plaintiff definitely owes the Judge an apology for her lil raggedy attitude.
😆😆raggedy chile
straight gutter attitude for someone who came in with no proof. It's the audacity for me smh
@@cynthiasanders4539 all the way tore’ up!!! 🤦🏾♀️ 😂
@@AmysExquisiteGifts yassss it’s the audacity!! The unmitigated gall. And even when she was called out for it she still refused to humble herself. Smh
I didn’t see an attitude… if the plaintiff had an attitude Judge Milian ALWAYS has an attitude
“She has to prove it I don’t” Girl! You have the burden of proof, to prove they took the money from your account, otherwise you can just say it’s any amount. That’s normal logic. Judge Milian was being kind and giving you a break. Lord!
The exact comment that I was looking for because I knew it was in here l o l
I was surprised by her statement…and then to think she’s on the same level as the judge to talk to her back in the same tone 😒
@melvill4185 these young people are clueless. Bite your tongue and win your case😊
Right i would have dismissed it after that judge milian was being nice judge mathis and judge judy would never
She sounded so stupid …
I am SO MAD at the defendant. Who needs enemies with a "friend" like that? The audacity.
I agree! No good deed goes unpunished lol
She should've come out squeaky clean but she just couldn't hold back the attitude. Pretty immature.
She's LUCKY that the judge gave her that chance to go gather her evidence
It is despicable the way people talk to the judge. I do not care if it is a TV show or not. I am astounded at the level of disrespect that society has these days. "You gave it to me first." What? I would be so embarrassed.
Is it a judge or Jesus
@@bennyvisuals9293 judges are real
I couldn't believe it when I heard that line either from the Plaintiff; YOU'RE IN COURT SIS, not arguing with your cousin!
@@VladmirPoopN does the judge not have cousins 🤣 would it make it feel better if they were related? We are human beings your job title doesn’t make you superior to the next person. If aliens took over the planet they not gonna be like oh not this one she’s a judge
@@bennyvisuals9293 judge is real and important, Jesus is fiction
How the hell do you come into court with no damn evidence!?!
These are the idiots who voted for Biden, what do you think...
Really a good idea to be a smart-mouth with the judge the two of them deserve each other
Exactly. Incredibly immature and disrespectful.
No good deed goes unpunished. That defendant is ridiculous. So, you don’t have connected brain cells to ask whether insurance was obtained? Give me a break. I completely believe the plaintiff that she didn’t want to pay the extra money.
@TraBaum. I'm not sure, but even if they bought insurance and IF an accident occurred with the defendant driving, I don't think the insurance would pay out because defendant wasn't listed as a driver. But if the plaintiff had returned the vehicle with damages, either her own insurance or the paid for rental insurance would have paid. Although the deductible might have been as much as if just pay the repair bill.
Don't rent vehicles for others unless they are listed as drivers.
@@saltpepperketchup7082 yes, she shouldn’t have rented it for her. With friends like the defendant you don’t need enemies
@@traceyaz125 for real. And with friends like the defendant, you don't need friends.
This defendant has been running from her debts for so long she stopped using a bank account. “I would have never accepted the vehicle if I’d known it didn’t have insurance” says the girl who doesn’t pay her bills.
The defendant is triggering me 😂the entitlement is crazy
Becareful who you call your friends.💯
⚠️💯⚠️💯⚠️💯
Judge Mathis would’ve dismissed her case soooo quick as soon as she started getting sassy about not having her own proof
Judge Milian is toooo nice sometimes to the ones who don’t deserve it
And judge judge would have ate her up like a shark
My thoughts exactly!!!
Same with Judge Judy. They aint putting up with lack of evidence and sass.
Everyone deserves a chance, in this case a second chance. Despite the plaintiffs " sass " She was in the right plus she isn't a bad person, how many people would help out a friend in that way?
when renting a car, always take pictures of the condition of the car inside and out, when you rent it and when your return it! Also wouldn't hurt to note the milage also.
VIDEO
@@StephiiLoVa90both! Some of these companies are sneaky
@@kakishisfriend1126 enterprise can be at times. This comes from a former enterprise employee
I take a video of everything on the inside and outside everytime I rent a car! I'd do it before I leave the lot and before I return it, and I keep all my paperwork! Also, I grt the insurance!
Yes.
I love Judge Milian, but I hate when she calls someone "Hun" and they reply with "Ma'am" and she retorts with, "It's 'Judge', not 'ma'am'." Well it's "Rebecca", not "Hun".
She’s earned that right, hon 🤣
@@Catloudan bc she’s on tv ???
I’m with you…my mom didn’t name me sweetheart either 😆
@@ruefullysage lmfao you think she's only a judge because she happens to be on TV lmfao 😂😂😂😂 I can't our world is to fucked at this point.
@@spacepanda9037 , You said a mouthful!
The defendant is horrible but yeah if I was the Judge I would have dismissed the plaintiffs case with her smart mouth stupid comment on her way out...and STILL stood on her attitude when the Judge returned🤦🏾♀️ I hope they have both grown up by now...smh
The audacity of the defendant 🤦🏾♀️ and with the plaintiff too for even putting herself in this situation.
When the defendant is like "I don't see why it's my problem"....because YOU drove the car. She has no right to be frustrated when it's her fault for damage and tickets on the rental car. She had it a week and it ends up damaged in her care. How bad of a driver do you have to be to damage a car in a week that's not even yours?
Idk why Harvey just doesn't answer the questions himself 😂😂😂
Didn't want either of these people to win this case.
ya i have a feeling their clevage isnt goingto impress me for long lol just started watching
How would the defendant prove that money was or wasn’t taken from you like that made me so mad lmao
The plaintiff has a bad attitude. She's the one who made a poor decision to rent a car for someone else.
IKR she did it to herself😬no good deed goes unpunished
The defendant was so ungrateful. It was her fault the car got damaged. Who needs a friend like her.
the defendant trying to look SO! innocent, quite sure those other 2 friends GLAD! they dodged a NASTY! bullet! defendant is VERY! irresponsible!🙄🤔🤨
There’s a reason that a grown woman doesn’t have a bank account. That in and of itself, should be enough of a red flag.
Doesn't matter whether she opted for the insurance or not, the insurance wouldn't insure her since she's not the renting party.
In order for her to be covered shed have to be listed as a driver as well which would cost more.
She knew she didn't have insurance.
Enterprise would have no way of knowing how the car was damaged or who was driving the car when it was damaged. If the renter had collision damage then it would be covered.
Usually the rental includes a second driver automatically nowadays. At least at Alamo which is owned by Enterprise.
Enterprise walks around the car with you to inspect it while your there for damages prior to you renting it and they makes notes about any prior damage, so basically the damage to the rental car by the defendant is definitely her fault
The audacity of the plaintiff to be so rude to the judge! "You gave it to me first!" What?! Crazy!
The defendant doesn’t have a bank account is huge 🚩
Ungrateful KAREN 🤣
No good deed goes unpunished
I cannot stand the speech pattern of the defendant. She should lose the case just for sounding annoying lol
I can't stand it either.. she's so dopey and slow.
As a previous Enterprise Employee, if they did accept the insurance from Enteprise and Enterprise found out that the plaintiff had the Defendant drive the car at any time even if the accident or damages wasn't while the defandt driving and let say the plaintiff was the one that was driving.... The insurance is cancelled due to brief of contract between the plaintiff and Enterprise. Enterprise and majority rental companies require additional drivers to be added to the contract. Anyone who is not (with exception of legal spouse) will be considered not authorized and the contract and insurance is terminated.
"I don't have a bank account." Ok, and why can't you have a bank account?
How people think it's okay to show up in court without evidence I'll never understand. Plus plaintiff's smart mouth -- no, it is the obligation of the PERSON WHO BROUGHT THE LAWSUIT to prove their case, not the defendant's. Further, I would NEVER do a risky financial favor like this for someone who is so dishonest as to not open a bank account to avoid paying their legal obligations. Plaintiff is plain dumb, but defendant is a user, a liar, and didn't even bother to take care of the car her friend rented for her. Plaintiff is bad, but defendant is far worse. I hope she gets what's coming to her.
“She’s the one that has to prove that ” - girl, are you dumb? Lmao . It’s crazy to me when people are wrong and strong
D has a space cadet look in her eyes
HEY PC FAM!!
I'll never understand why we think ppl like this are our friends. Smh..
What a smart Alec young woman.
No bank account? That’s crazy for an adult
Lazy, irresponsible, and someone who most likely can’t be trusted.
nope when one does not work.
@Mansfield Man When has a bank stole my money? Don't worry. I'll wait.
@@markpolice3585 how 'bout this...go into your bank and try to get a withdrawal of more than $600 and see how they act
ALWAYS GET INSURANCE!! It'll be less than what's going to be due if something happens.
Alright.
Enterprise associates do try to make up damages. It happened to me. When I said go through my insurance company they dropped the charges. I did the same thing. I had to be to work so I walked in to the office. there was someone ahead of me. I asked can I leave the key? The associate said yes. I left the key and then they sent me an email saying there was damages of 900 and something dollars. I said show me the damage. They sent a picture with some circle on the bumper. I said to them I need to see the car in person because there was no damage when I dropped the car off. They said their body shop place fixed it already, so there was no car for me to see. 🙄 So they were lying from the beginning. Somebody might get a commission off of charging for damages or something.
You inspected every single inch of the vehicle prior to returning it? I don't get how that makes them liars just because they already fixed the damages so you couldn't see it in person. They do not wait for people to pay them before they fix the damages on the vehicles, there is nothing sketchy or abnormal about that. Most people do not request to see it in person and even if they do, that would add a lot of issues and delays for the company (such as having to schedule a convenient time for the customer to come in and view the vehicle, taking staff away from other duties in order to have someone show the customer the vehicle, and the inevitable nuisance of those customers who would never show up but instead only delay the shop from being able to make repairs). They definitely do not get a commission for that. People who work at Enterprise are normal every day people like you and me... they do not care enough to go and do all of that. If you know that you didn't do any damage then it's probably just a very human mistake. Like the damage was there already and was somehow missed before, therefore unfortunately placing the blame on you. Or the damage occurred during the period of time between when you dropped it off and when they inspected it. Or there even could have been a different car with this damage that was the same make/model as yours and the employee just made a mistake. Accidents happen. I worked as an insurance Adjuster and people seriously believed that I purposefully went out of my way to deny their claims, pay them less, etc lol as if I am not human. If the piece of paper (policy) signed lists the type of incident then its approved, if it says the incident isn't covered then it's denied. I can't control it and it always amazed me how many people think insurance company's are evil or malicious as if they are not just normal people working there.
@@MalloriaAnn wow do you work for a rental company 😂 they definitely make up charges. It happened to quite a few I know. They dropped off the cars did a whole walk through with the employees and days later see that enterprise charged them with NO CALLS to inform why or anything. I hope if ever happens to you people so sympathetic 🤡
@@MalloriaAnn they couldn't fix it before claiming if it was insured as no insurance company is going to accept photos. So they were lying, and if you took the rental company to court they'd want more evidence than not so clear photos.
People love to be so relevant, loud and wrong. If the person who chose to respond to you had done just a wee bit of research they would find that there are discrepancies regarding damage to vehicles just left without a walk around. Child these people act like they are obligated to respond to random people and then just look silly.
The plaintiff was pissing me off with all that extra lip. The judge was being nice by allowing you to retrieve evidence. Shut up and go get it!! 🤦🏾♀️
People struggle. I get it. The friends behavior is bummy though.
Why do ppl think “Pay for everything in cash” is a good thing lol
as they say, no good deed goes unpunished.
Since when do rental car companies care who returns a car? Maybe this "judge" should spend a minute living in our society so she can understand how things work in our society.
I feel this way about both her and judge Judy. Especially judge Judy.
You know what, I learned the hard way that certain employees take their job way too seriously. The defendant has a good theory, because a lot of people do stick by the rules. I want to give you a hard time just because they can. It’s sad, but people make problems for absolutely no reason. Glad they figured this out
As a previous Enterprise Employee, we don't profit from the damage money. It's solely to pay to get the car fix. And I hope they put them on DNR “do not rent” list. They are a liability. 😓
Both violated the contract the plaintiff signed.
And the fact they dotn have the contract lmao it get sent to the email and they could have called to get it. We have it in records for 1-3 years. 😭
The defendant really said she would've paid for insurance even if it was $15/day 😂😂 girl you can't even open an account because you can't make monthly payments, nevermind daily.
But you don’t need to make monthly payments to keep a bank account open….
@@josephinestafford4466 the defendant said she can't rent a car because she can't have an account and she can't have an account because she's got creditors after her and they'll seize her accounts. Creditors=monthly payments.
@@p1n3apple21 I’m just saying that you don’t need monthly payments to get a credit card and I just took what she said as an EXCUSE. Because there’s people thousands in debts that still have credit cards. There’s people who open another credit card to screw more debt because their other ones are maxed out
Both are very special.. How do you tell the judge you don’t have to prove YOUR OWN case 🤦🏾♀️
Judge Judy would have dismissed the plaintiff's case for her attitude
The plaintiff had an awful attitude about providing the proof that she needs
If there WAS insurance, would the plaintiff be covered? I would think that Enterprise would disclaim because the defendant was neither the borrower nor a listed driver.
No only listed drivers
Defendant didn't know the rental didn't have insurance, but she was standing right there🙄
The plaintiff got off easy with this case. She had an attitude about her own evidence or lack of it. These two need to get it together
The defendants little innocent attitude doesn’t fool anyone
The plaintiff made me angry when she decides to get sassy with the judge when the burden of proof is on her! Prove why you are suing and especially for the amount you are suing for! VERY SIMPLE! I despise smart mouth people who are completely wrong🙄Just loud and wrong 😑
Wow. I’m surprised the judge didn’t walk back and dismiss her case for that catty little attitude. You brought the case young lady so yeah the burden of proof is on you. Not a cuz I said I should get paid
"I would have never accepted the vehicle if I knew there was no insurance" ...that's a lie. You needed a car, and your name wasn't on the rental agreement. You have a history of poor financial decisions, so why would you care?
The Plaintiff is so beautiful.
Plaintiff's so pretty. JM is naive to think that companies like rental car places wouldn't make up damages to to enrich their employer. She has no idea how the employee is profiting from the scam. Also, I don't understand why the Def would be done w the friendship. It would hurt me to have to pay for damages that I know I didn't cause, but I'd pay it bc I wouldn't want my friend to eat the cost.
Clearly both the plaintiff and teh defandant hve attitude issues . They both deserve each other smh 🤦♀️
The plaintiff really just argued that she shouldn't have to prove her claim
No, plaintiff, it IS up to you to prove what you paid. It's foolish to rent a car for your friend. I rented a moving truck for my brother, however, he paid me cash BEFORE I signed, and I only agreed to do it if I drove it, which I did (his credit was too bad, which is why I insisted on cash up front). ALWAYS get insurance.
I can hardly wait until they invent interactive TV because I want to reach into the screen and slap the defendant.
The Defendant is a manipulative & sad little person who was totally wrong & deserves all the mess she’s in. That’s a given. But what an attitude on the Plaintiff, too! You’re the one who brought the suit: you definitely have to proof that you’re out the money. Did she really say the Defendant has to prove that money was taken from her, the Plaintiff? Why would the Defendant help you prove your case that they are the one who is wrong? What kind of logic was that. And why would you mouth off to the Judge who’s going to be deciding your case. Judge Milian actually did her a favor, because usually she’ll just dismiss the case if the Plaintiff doesn’t have proof. And quite frankly, Judge Milian should’ve sense she decided to mouth off. What a weird hill to rant on. I’m totally shocked by her behavior, too.
She probably didn't understand the situation fully...
Thus the attitude and misunderstanding
The defendant doesn't have an account how is she suppose to prove the Bank withdrawal 😅
NEVER!!!
People need to learn that they are at the judge’s mercy. Not the other way around…
No dum dum the plaintiff has the burden of proving the case they brought to court. I would've thrown it out with tht attitude.
jesus gotta love the attitude when someone has to actually provide PROOF of what they are claiming happened, then trying to say the judge was doing it first.
gotta also love the defendant, the only way she can live her life paying all cash is if she has horrible things in her past that she's just trying to run away from.
The defendant has the audacity to say if she had known it didn't have insurance then she would never have taken it, yet she wasn't a named driver, she was fraudulently driving the car under the plaintiff's name, so even if it had had insurance, it wouldn't have covered 'her' but the plaintiff, so the insurance would have been null and void anyway...
The plaintiff is strikingly beautiful....I'd like to sketch her features...
The judge didn't know that she would MATCH her energy. Lol BUT, the Plaintiff was loud and wrong! 🥴
Also, the Defendant was pretty self righteous for someone who is in need of a friend to help her rent a car. 😒
Pretty smart ass mouth for the judge to be trying to help u.
It is concerning the way both the Plaintiff, Defendant, and people Harvey interviewed think. They lack logic yet they get to vote in elections.
The plaintiff has an attitude 😂😂😂
It's the drivers job to know if there's insurance or not!! So sanctimonious after the fact.
The defendant, just thinks everyone owes her something. This girl doesn't even have a bank account, that right there is a reason to not help her. She's extremely ungrateful.
The way she says “Veeeee-ah-cuhl “ is killing me .
People dont have bank accounts for a reason. Check systems..judgements..liens....its all BS. Terrible credit and bad choices leads to no bank account.
Judge gets mad at people respectfully calling her "Ma'am" only to then condescendingly call them stuff like "hun" and "sweetheart." Girl FOH.
She’s also selective on when offended by ma’am. She even refers to women as girls sometimes herself but gets offended by men doing it.
Speaking of damages, it wouldn't hurt the defendant to run herself by the paintless dent removal shop to process some of that cellulite in her quarter panel 🤣
The way the defendant says "vee-yek-le" grinds my gears 🙉 She didn't give two shits about the plaintiff, the nice gesture of the plaintiff nor her credit smh she knew there was no insurance on the dern rental but as long as she got what she wanted she was good.
the way she spoke so carefully says she was bunging on the voice
Once again, JM is WRONG. Enterprise has many FRANCHISED rental establishments, and they are NOTORIOUS for drumming up fake damage charges.
The defendant clearly owes the plaintiff, but chances are Enterprise is not innocent.
I have a problem with the defendant but this whole showing up to court with nothing and having an attitude about having to prove her case is getting on my nervessss
Girl PUHLEEEEZ you wouldn’t have gladly paid for car insurance when you won’t GLADLY pay your creditors and GLADLY get a bank account🙄
Not renting a car for someone else. Then you are on the hook if there's an accident
Enterprise has been apart of many lawsuits for lying about damages (literally settling millions of dollars on cases). They should have taken pics the day of pickup (on the lot) and the time of drop off (on the lot) with proof of date. Many of their employees are taught to try and upsell fees and to get as much money out of people as possible. They get commission of the fees they haggle out of people.
Yes, have often heard of similar dealings over here too, common fraud in the car rental business. When renting a car, always take photos of it from all angles and mark date and time before leaving rental lot. They also try to scam for fuel but am not sure how that one works. Judge lives in a very honest world does she?
NEVER EVER Rent a car for anyone EVER.
Never rent a car for someone....case closed.
Douglas calls Marilyn Ma'am and she doesn't yell at him so why does JM get so prickly when litigants make the mistake of addressing her as Ma'am?
Always take photos and videos around any rental car at pickup and drop off. I brought a vehicle back once and a week later they tried saying I owed them money. My photos showed the damage wasn't there when i dropped it off.
Exactly! We do that every time. Interior and exterior. And I keep them for weeks just in case
Judge myst have been in a good mood that day.
The defendant's blink-rate is off the charts. Reminds me of my ex who could never keep their story straight 🤣🤣
She is full of it!
Don't have a checking account? No way.
Former enterprise employee the defendant ain’t lying, some folks are petty and they rent out damaged vehicles all the time and blame whoever.
No bank account as an adult… what a bum smh
I agree with the defendant. I have had a car rental place try to say i returned a car with no gas..i took pics of the full tank
That’s one healthy looking plaintiff