ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ย. 2017
- Premium estate cars: style shouldn't come at the expense of practicality, but in order to compete at the top of the class, a car needs to deliver on both fronts. The BMW 5 Series Touring, Mercedes E-Class Estate and Volvo V90 are three of the most handsome and capable posh wagons money can buy, but which should you choose? To find out, I'm going to give them a thorough going-over inside and out, before hitting the road in each to find out which is best.
BMW 5 Series Touring review -
www.carwow.co.uk/BMW/5-series...
Mercedes E-Class Estate review -
www.carwow.co.uk/mercedes/e-c...
Volvo V90 review -
www.carwow.co.uk/volvo/v90?ut...
Subscribe to carwow on youtube -
th-cam.com/users/Carwow?sub_c...
Awkward haggling is a thing of the past with carwow. Choose your perfect car with our configurator tool and let the country’s best dealers compete over you. Compare the five best offers by price, location and dealer ratings and choose the one that’s right for you - no hassle, no haggling, just a great deal.
Visit our site to save money on your new car - www.carwow.co.uk/ - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
Not watched yet however I know he will say the BMW has the best infotainment
I was right
Oliver Lowe
Yup... it's logic
Yeahh about iDrive system
Oliver Lowe because its a fact
autistpain the screens are better in the merc, only a small screen in the bmw. Also merc is very easy to use once you get used to it. Maybe its better but double screen wins for me.
Bmw with m-package. Merc with amg line. But the volvo without the sporty r-design? Cmon m8!!
You have the polestar I believe
DCPlaysHD i have a 2019 Audi A7 S-Line (interior & exterior). But my parents have an Volvo V90 R-Design and also an XC90 R-Design.
@@drterrible8069 yh ok rich guy.. Dunno how much I believe what u said but I'll take ur word for it
Skengman those cars aren’t really expensive..
bcxw24 79 ok... I might need to catch up then, I don’t have 40k lying around for a car
Imagine talking on the phone with hand gestures and the BMW keeps turning up the volume
MERTZY hahahahaha
broo Mertzy
i'd take that as a sign ang hang up
It’s why it’s disabled on Italian market cars.
😂
I’d have the Volvo personally
I would take the Audi A6😃
i love volvo
The combination of tailgate and luggage net means you can use every drop of space safely in BMW estates, it's been like this for generations even in the 3 series, such brilliant features I have no idea why this is not more common in other cars.
I'm a BMW guy, but that Volvo is downright sexy!
It's to look away, really. What an eye catching car! But Merc is teasing the left side of my brain 😅
The front looks luxurious and futuristic but the back of the car doesnt look that new
It really screams chinese.... The old ones were much better!
Screams chinese how?
@The Equinox the V90 is still built in Sweden. S90s are built in China.
The Volvo V90 is the best imo, it doesn't have the best infotainement nor is it available with 6 cylinder diesels. But if you're looking after a hybrid it's easily the best choice
me too
U dum
built in china with loads of electrical faults here in the uk. bmw all the way over volvo unless its old school volvo
@@1769gordy Built in torslanda ,Sweden.Maybe do a little research ,ive had my V90 for 4 years,never had an issue🤷♂️
@@1769gordy Built in China? I didn’t know Sweden was in China. I think you are confused, Volvo is owned by a Chinese company, Geely, but is run as an independent operation, in Sweden.
I've had Volvo's since 1979. Yes the V90 has lost some of the little things over the years that people expect from a Volvo Estate. The other two are good cars, but it will all ways be the Volvo for me. She is awesome. The seats are to die for and the looks. They have come into their own. Volvo rocks😊.
They're amazing 🤩
Old Volvo is best Volvo.
Boomers unite
I felt good about buying Volvo until a Chinese multinational company bought a majority interest in the company. It’s feels like it makes the brand less true to its Nordic roots.
Still a fantastic car, but I’d rather ride with the silver star these days. 🤷♂️
Volvo V90 looks way better in the R Design trim with the Bursting Blue colour
I prefer inscription
V90 cc looks even better
@@yuriytymoshchuk9233 what a joke, the normal version is wide and low with nice lines and contours, then youre gonna raise it and put plastic bumpers on it and call it better looking? ridiculous
@@MrKevlarkent it actually is
@@Niels_f2704 Ideally, I would prefer, if possible, the R Design exterior with the Inscription interior!
Merc shape is old.... Very similar to 2011 shape
Volvo looks sexiest
I really like both however I prefer the Merc design of the rear compared to the sloping design of the Volvo.
@@MaZEEZaM i really love those fake exhaust!
SirBlank so what fake exhaust. You won’t race in formula 1 with it
The Engi Behind The Slaughter dude cars is my favorite hobby. Only wannabe people complain about fake exhaust pipes in 190hp family cars. Maybe if it’s a s6 or a C63 with fake exhaust pipes I would agree. But the hate is stupid for having them in normal estate cars
The Engi Behind The Slaughter and you kinda don’t get what I was trying to say
Drove the V90 recently and it's such a treat to be inside of.
For me a Volvo is far more desirable than a bmw.
@G MG that means your fucking high volvo is very desirable
Or people treat you like a typical beemer driving twat
@G MG lol, only BMW drivers would think the looks are jealousy and not just annoyance at their absolute lack of basic driving skills.
@G MG Haha, Volvo is in the same price range you doofus (and superior cars at that).
And I _can_ buy I BMW, but thank god for giving me the good sense to not get one.
Got my eyes on a beautiful V90 CC though. Going to check it out this weekend actually, wish me luck!
@G MG they’re all in a similar price range tho... and have u seen the new BMWs ew
I am an Audi fanatic, and I would've gone for the BMW all day.
BosnishMaffia this is a fact that we don't see everyday 😅
Same
Keli K. I Think the volvo is the best looking car out of these 3, but as a complete package, I would choose the BMW honestly.
BosnishMaffia especially on this class.. no :D but out of those 3 maybe
sadly that "all new" 5-series has had same interior layout since e6x 5-series :/
Mercedes! But... Damn! This Volvo is amazing!
You have betrayed your own kind!
Good test.
I bought the e estate myself and it's almost identical to this one.
I also optioned the two rear facing xtra seats in the boot which gives it so much more flexibility on the school run, I don't think BMW or Volvo do that.
Great all rounder, wonderful over long distance, have done 600 miles in one day and it's great.
Only real disappointment is that it has so far over 20k miles only averaged 42mpg which is almost identical to what my 04 2.7 merc CLK averages!! Thought it might be better:/
That bmw looks absolutely stunning especially in that blue colour
Soon you will see BMW and Mercedes fanboys fighting which one is the best. 😂 Meanwhile i can't afford a used bicycle.
I love Leblanc change your profile picture msybe you have a six pack but you get that caus your skinny
Hessel Bleeker well instead of criticizing others. Just use your own profile picture. :)
Edit: also fix your grammar, you can't even spell "cause and "you are" correctly.
I love Leblanc i'm not even from a country were the motherlanguage is English so don't judge
Mercedes
Volvo
I love estates more than crossovers
all the practicality without the drawbacks of extra weight, decreased fuel economy, and poor handling.
HowieYisBored AYE buddy
Matt I'm really liking your presentation style! Great job mate! The fake exhaust tips wind me up too, given the money you're paying ...
I'm from Germany - I think the idea is simply wonderful and authentic. It was really fun to watch. Thanks and keep it up! 👏👍
I, like many other fan boys, got an old Audi A4 for my first car. I used to be a huge fan boy for all German cars. Now that I've become a true car guy and appreciate all cars, that Volvo is just stunning. Inside and out. That's my pick. After that, I'm not sure. I like the Mercedes interior, and the BMWs exterior.
Great choice 👍
Just bought an E Class estate as my retirement car.
Perfect blend of luxury and driving pleasure.
The M-B basket ... totally outclassed by the grocery sorter my 2012 Nissan Murano included. Have not ever once used the sillly box, but used the Murano's pop-up grocery sorter every week.
I really like the style of your reviews guys! Thumb up!
Absolutely loving the BM 👌😍
I've had two 5s which I quite liked, then an E-class which while great to drive, the command system is a nightmare which after two years I was glad to see the back of. Have had a V90 for two months and it is the best of the three by a country mile. The interior is fabulous and the ride/handling way better than anything comparable. Engine the weakest of the three is a bit rattly at low speed. Kit is amazing. Boot has this flap device thing that when folded up secures numerous bags of shopping...Pilot assist/ACC is epic..thr app will do everything remotely and download business miles as an esv file etc..But bottom line is used V90 is several £1000 cheaper...
I think that delay is there for a reason. It is a safety feature :) If I am not mistaken, VW also had it on their Golf's at some point. You had to press the pedal a second time in order to get a kickdown - in case you fell asleep or something.
I love all of them. Great video, Mat!
Thank you so much .
I was looking between 5 series and xc60.
I made up my mind to 5 series.
Wow. That Volvo is gorgeous. Outshining the rest 😲
Well...this is your opinion. :)
Defo getting a e class premium plus estate after this review thanks 🙏
I really think you should do the test again, now when the Volvo D5 engine has got the 'Power Pulse' feature. An extra compressor, to get instant response when you touch the gas pedal
BMW 5 series....everytime for me...
its common knowledge that volvo has always made great looking estate cars, going back to the 90s the 850 was known as the best estate looking estates
I loved my 960, what a stealth car. Could take just about anything at traffic lights, but did have a propensity to step out.
The quote as intro lol loved it mate ;)
My two previous cars were e class estates and this time I choose the Volvo V90 R Design , so much more for your money compared to the Merc which is fitted with the dreadful standard Garmin sat nav and lack of toys.
Very pleased so far and glad I made this choice
This was 4 years ago. Do you still like the V90 better?
I love how volvo are in the majority of comments. Volvo with family packages are around £50,000. Volvos interior design is simple but beautiful
I love BMW but I have a xc60 Volvo and it is AMZING!!
Love the side profile of the Merc and the Volvo is nice too
Somehow i knew you Will go for the merc even before i watched the video. Its kind a mats personal favourite brand.
The Swedes have hit a sweet spot with Volvo Design,props
I would agree except I don't like the sloping tail, I prefer the Merc rear end.
i 100% agree but if you buy it the polestar R-desgin looks way better so you should go with that
@Adam Marcinkowski and?
@Adam Marcinkowski 😕😕
Owned both merc and bmw, and quality in bmw much better, feels a class above the merc. Also drives better, with better gearbox
What models did you have and from which year?
Yes, this is very important as you had to have the same class (f.i 5series Vs eclass) and also the comparable model years (E60 Vs w211) The E60 is a better car than the w211, but the w212 parks the F10 imo
Yeah but the bmw is also 15 thousand Pounds more expensive than the merc
Mercedes is waaaaaaay better quality than BMW. Sugest otherwise, means u don't know what you are talkin about....
Hey Matt can you do a review for the new Nissan Qashqai? I'm thinking of getting it in 2018 down under and would love your opinion on it! Thanks Matt!
Great comparison!
I think mercedes in the last year made a huge step forward and became the best in pretty every aspect.. before that was only the most comfortable, now it's just the best, maybe because of the last generation of engines and weight reduction
Outside Front - Volvo
Rear - BMW
Inside design Volvo/Mercedes
Infotainment - BMW
Price once configured same- Volvo
Rear Seats - Mercedes
Trunk/ Storage - Mercedes
Front - Volvo
Rear - BMW
Interior design - Mercedes
Interior quality - BMW
Rear seats for 2 - BMW
Rear seats for 3 - Mercedes
Boot - Mercedes
Sound System - Volvo
Reliability - Volvo
I travelled to Sweden alone and hired a Volvo. I drove across the country twice. I had the time of my life and spent time 'talking' to the car. I was incredibly impressed.
I have a v8 back home in Australia, but would have handed it over to kept that Volvo. I loved it. Had a tear in my eye when i handed it back. We had great adventures and became friends. Glad to see I'm not the only one to bond with a Volvo 😂❤
That G31 is so stunning!
i agree with u about design
v90 looks the best
The V90 r design with 20" rims looks out of this world.
Justin Small shame on them, they didn‘t choose one in that trim. Also does my head in!
You said that on the Mercedes that the track pad is in the way of the swivel wheel but as you place your palm on the track pad to use the swivel wheel the track pad will automatically deactivate for easy use of the wheel.
Mat Watson. Great stuff, is it possible to get a head to head with BMW 3 touring, Audi A4 Avant and maybe volvo v60? Possible?
The new Porsche Panamera Sport Turismo is in fact the best looking estate car
In my opinion
In another life! 😂 (it cost 2x than this) but yeah is very good, i like more The Ferrari gt4 lusso😂
If you would also test real life emissions, the BMW would win hands- down (actually the 2.0 L version is one of the cleanest diesels around)
Great test! For me it's the Volvo, but the CC version.
I drive an E220d. Awesome engine, great 9 speed box, suspension (AMG trim) a bit jumpy on b roads, infotainment (with the 2 screens) looks amazing but the touch "alien" pad makes no sense
Actually the RS6 is the best looking estate car
Each to their own, but I guess they were unique for sometime since the M5 for a period was not offered in estate and the E63 was rare as an estate
Ahahahah
Porsche Panamera Sport Turismo is the best for me!
Well actually these estates dont cost 50000000000000000 dollars to buy and maintain
Charlie Molda we are talking about normal cars for normal people.
Yes Volvo can and I’d pick Volvo
And its not even the T8 version
Made in China, lol you can have it.
@@dudndadn12212 volvo also makes cars in sweden
Hilarious
@Beezus Beez Ive had 3 bmw and six volvos so can afford both and can tell you the volvos are the better cars by far,what do you drive?
on thursdey I visited BMW dealer. I went to check 4 gran coupe. There was a 5 series next to it. When I finished with 4 GC I went to check new 5 (curiosity) and it is totaly sunning! Just by opening doors...you will feel quality. 4 GC is like a toy next to it. To me it look far better then on tv screen...
Perfect car!
Put it in the mode where you have to manage the gear up and dowm yourself and it responds immediately when puch the gas
I'd definitely get the Volvo, just as refined, but more sleek inside and out. The car is just pure art, and in the R design trim the dullness in the driving experience vanishes.
Volvo & BMW for me!
"The design its a little bit "nnjaaahh". Man i love you +carwow
Do S Class vs 7 Series vs A8, either 2018 or 2019
I am so impressed about Volvo's improvements in the last few years. In the future this brand could be the Swedish Mercedes. 😍
yeah though actually swedish chinese
BMW
guzi965 BBBMMMMMMWWWW
BMW 5-serie 530d xDrive Touring is the best car for a roadtrip.
You will definitely feel more comfy in volvo
Yes! Accept no substitute...well maybe only Porsche.
Looking to buy between merc e350d and BMW 535d. 2014-2016. After driving both still can't decide which one. I was looking at Volvo XC70 also. Probably the most comfortable of all 3. But heard it has problems with electrics. So it was written off.
Matt, with all due respect and this is the second time i am mentioning this, you are not right
on the touch pad controller, you do not need to angle your arm or hand you can rest
it on the touch pad and when it notices your arm / hand resting on it, locks
the touch pad and you can use the controller with no issue at all. In addition you have the voice activation
system which I must say is definitely getting better and better. I have 5 - 6 Mercedes and all with the touch
pad and all current models so I am aware of how it works.
I really dislike how the C, the E and the S class look absolutely identical, you can barely tell the difference, on the other 2, I would say agree the Volvo is the best looking although BMW did a pretty good job at refining the F10 and tweaking it for the better to make this generation look pretty good imo
Louis Rushbrook "you can barely tell the difference"
*if you're blind
They don't lokk identical. They look SIMILAR. Huge difference! And its only the e class and c class that look similar.
If you couldn't already tell by the massive size s class has a COMPLETLY DIFFERENT front grill grill. S class has three curve headlights, e class 2 and c ckass one. S class has thrre tail lights whereas c and e have 2. They all have different front and rear diffusers from each other. Not to mention... S class has far more chrome and more pronounced depth and proportions especially for its light carvings and shoulder's. And the interiors are massively different
So yes while they undeniably share similar design language they are still very much distinguishable. Bmw and audi do this too because by your logic 5 series looks lkke mini 7 series and a4 looks like mini a6 just with different lights. So nearly all German companies do this. Frankly there is nothing wrong with this design philosophy as sales suggest.
These cars are meant to be under the radar... Hence the concept of stealth wealth.. . so by being similar they blend in well and allow the car not to be flashy. Furthermore this kind of design philosophy is good also because if they looked completly different for instance and someone didn't like the design of the e class they might give up the e classes better interior for a c class or go to another company altogether. So its actually not a bad thing at all and isn't like how you're exaggerating it.
Well said. Only a blind person cannot distinguish the difference between the Mercs'. That's a fact, the rest are just excuses.
Louis Rushbrook omg. ..and u want to tell us u can make difference between audi and bmw (3er..5er..7er) and (a4..a6..a8? Ur so funny
Jdkdkfjsj mercedes are worst
Jdkdkfjsj bmw hasnt changed their design? Are u dumb? The mercedes e and c lass are pretty much the same and go look at bmw e.g 5 series they look completely difforent every model and what do you mean volvo are pethetic? Its any volvo is better than any mercedey you drive and it definatly looks better than any mercedes out there
I want a car that exterior and interior designed by Volvo, technology from Bmw and comfy as a Mercedes.
Mercedes and bmw exterior and interiors are way more better
@@ardaxy no
@@ardaxy design is subjective.
@@Jkp564 Ahahahahaha Good old days. But now the new Audi A3's interior is not differrent than Seat Leon. Even my friend say that it's sound proof is weaker than the older one. Suddenly Bmw 1 series became the most quality one interms of interior quality.
Volvo comfy is best but Mercedes power is better
"Shed loads" of gadgets. Had to put on the captions to be sure of what you said there, mate.
My dad has 2017 Volvo V90 and it is such a nice car. He is going to get new one this year. Cannot wait to have a ride with it
Maybe the volvo gearbox is a bit slower to respond on everyday cars but I think it might be a good thing. If you not having a race car you really dont need a super kickdown gearbox. Its Quick enough. And because it slower it is smother and not a instant pressure on the gearbox which make them last incredible long. Many cars need to change their gearbox after a time, but I know lots of volvo cars that have driven over 400 000 km (216 000 miles)
Of course other cars can go that long with the same gearbox but I feel its more common for volvo. Mercedes is also long lasting cars althoug have falled back a little the past decade.
the swedish car magazine 'vi bilägare' had the same cars in for test and they came out: 1st 5 Series 2nd V90 3rd: E-Class
Jakob Sachse hur fan kan e klass komma sist förklara gjärna
Hi man because of your great videos I bought myself the Mercedes-Benz E200. And I may say iam impressed! Grtz
I chose the beamer. Taking delivery next month :)
Well i think volvo is more reliable
JD Powers doesn't say so.
@@peevee605 JD Power is a marketing firm not a consumer activist firm, aka they rate cars and products better the more they are paid. and my Volvo XC70 T6 has 300,000 miles on it and its as tight as a drum, no squeaks or rattles, only normal maintenance no major work..in fact my local volvo dealer doesn't try to sell me on another volvo whn i bring it into service it when hey have promotions . my experience with BMW and Mercedes is the other way around... even had engine failure at 190K miles on my 3 series years ago because the oil stopped getting delivered to where needed to by the time it was making noise it was too late, didn't even get a check engine light until after it puked oil out of a seal and lost pressure, and the mercedes i had was a E class, got it used from an older gentlemen, and 75K miles, mostly highway.. i sold it around 160K miles because was beginning to get fa too expensive to maintain, put $10,000+ into it by the time i sold it.
that being said i dont have a newer volvo with new engines, i have the old real T6 engine package with 6 cylinders and turbo.. however based on chat with sale's man who sold me my XC70 because i wanted reliability but not an SUV...and he doesn't BS me because that's not his game plan.. he told me hasn't been any major failures he knows of from any of their customers any issues like with P3 are isolated..
@@peevee605 I've seen Volvo at the top of reliability ratings and also near the bottom. Same as most other car brands, I don't see how they can be used reliably at all
Love the Volvos. Got a 2nd gen XC90 myself, but God Volvo chuck in a V8 to some models!
I just bought an E450 estate here in the US. I'd have gone for the BMW 5-series if they sold them here in the US. I love the E450 though. Tons of space and nice driving dynamics as long as one doesn't push it too much.
I never understood why some companies don’t sell estates in the USA. A big loss think but I would call it ignorance and arrogance by the manufacturer.
Love my D5......But mine's the older 2.4 5-pot
How could you! Volvo deserves to win😱
Its cool
Bmw on the other hand looks stunning in and out. Inside it is by far the nicest and the infotainment system is by far the best in the business
No it's the volvo
also on the BMW, it has another feature for the boot, if your hands are full of stuff then you can open it by using your foot, place your foot under the bumper, that's another way of opening it.
Looking for a new car at the moment and it's most likely going to be a decision between these 3 - but I just can't decide! They're all lovely cars really
Which one did you get at the end?
@@karannchew2534 what a blast from the past this is! Ended up with a nearly new V60 on 7k miles, list price £46k but bought for £27.5k.
Inscription spec with intellisafe, xenium, winter packs, polestar optimisation, Harman kardon audio, loads of goodies!
Actually looking to sell it now as need a cheaper car, expensive times! Otherwise bloody brilliant car
I think the new 5 series is by far the best of these, its basically next gen in everything, and weak at nothing
I agree, but my goodness they take a lot of learning. Thank goodness for TH-cam.
Is the Audi A6 no contender here or why wasn´t it included?
Free4Noob probably for the same reason as Peugeot which is not here either.
well peugeot isnt even in the same class of cars. Audi is
because the latest A6 is 7 years old, it's really that simple
Free4Noob A6 is old now
Free4Noob u cant compare a vw with a brand like Mercedes. ...understand.?
Yeah, i bought a c220d amg line with premium plus pack, keyless go, and panoramic sunroof (see bob flavin review)... it was totally the right decision; drove waaay better than equivalent bmw, despite what people might try to say who havent experienced both cars... in the trim i went for and tinted windows it looks way better than v90. The infotainment is really easy and intuitive to use after spending a day with it.. on eco mode im averaging 46mpg URBAN! Stick it in sport+ now and ive managed 0-62 in 7 seconds... mid range (overtaking) acceleration is insane for such a big car and potentially frugal engine. Seriously impressive all-rounder.
Should have had the R Design with a Polestar Optimised tune. Sorts the gearbox lag and improves the drive 10x
Volvo is always the best. Iam driving for 2 years in volvo v40 from 1999 but it still looks like its brand new. Never gona change from volvo 😁
Volvo looks the best. Especially in R design trim!! And bursting blue
ferrari junkie - writing 'FACT' in uppercase doesn't make it so.
Well take yourself to Google images and you'll be able to see why☺
Ferrari Junkie 5 series obviously looks more aggressive and sportier
Olof Hansson Thankyou! Some people are just so mean spirited and don't have anything else going on unfortunately.
Well they've chosen the more aggressive looking variant of the 5-Series, the equivalent Volvo is equally aggressive - wpmedia.driving.ca/2017/06/dsc_4581.jpg?quality=70&strip=all&w=960&h=480&crop=1
Matt, you been lifting? I see those triceps and that bicep vein!
I work in a car company and I’ve tried all 3 off these cars the Volvo is pretty ok the bmw is a very hard car to use but comfortable when driving and the Mercedes is easy to use and amazing to drive and I even own a e220d 2018
I go with volvo, I love anything from Sweden!!
So you like ikea to
That Merc looks like a hearse, the Volvo is just gorgeous
I'd get the A6, looks the best and like the interior design too even though it's not the newest
How do they rank in interior quietness? Test drive the s90 last yr and it was NOT particularly quiet. The engine and tire noise were intrusive.
I love the look of the Volvo, Though....:)
The Volvo is the best car!! Why you don't have the Volvo t6 power puls
Axel Pihl v90 sucks
Philip J your life sucks lmao
@@drterrible8069 v90 is a toy cars compared to e class
BMW has gooseneck hinges for the Hatch gate. Never seen that !
The Merc can also be remote controlled in and out of parking spaces... Weird that you didn't mention that.