'Take Care of Maya' trial
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ต.ค. 2023
- Another doctor who prescribed ketamine treatments for Maya Kowalski is expected to testify on Wednesday in a $220 million case against Johns Hopkins All Children’s Hospital featured in the Netflix documentary ‘Take Care of Maya’. MORE: bit.ly/3PSOk0P
"Ketamine Girl" being used by a member/members of an ethics committee. Wow!
In all my years of a paralegal and watching live trials, I have NEVER seen where the judge has placed such stringent timeline AND refusal of so much evidence being submitted to the jury to a plaintiff. If this is the direction trials are going, I see nothing but huge problems for the justice system to work as it was originally intended. Just my opinion! And no I dont care if there are thousands of pages of medical records. It is still vital for the jury to see the good, bad, and ugly. The defendants dont want the bad and ugly to be seen!
That's 1000 percent right there is so much evidence All needs to be uncovered and brought to us tax paying non criminal people they give more time to evidence of Thugs & Druggies Sad
Social workers with a previous child abuse record. Way to go JH. Patient care is obviously not a priority to this hospital.
I m so tired of this judge we. He's so openly bias towards the defense it shameful. IT has continued throughout the whole trial. He's not the judge who should have heard this.
Now we all understand the way Beata felt. She was at her wits end and was pushed around to the point of the dr and then social workers literally driving her crazy! She commits suiside so her daughter could come home before Maya gets throwed into the system where we all know has so many flaws. She sees there's no way to to get Maya home by to end her life. Soon as she dies...Maya got to come home. The Justice system is messed up and then the family has to file a lawsuit to get justice. Here is the family AGAIN trying to get justice for Maya.
I pray the jury feels just like we do! They have an intire firm taking up one whole side of the court room versed a couple damn good attorneys that are being treated awful by the Judge. He talks down to them and smarts off to Mr.Anderson constantly and let's the defense attorneys sit over there and shake their heads constantly then the judge agree with the "Shaking Heads", it's just sick! I feel so bad for Jack, I truly do.
Every single person from this hospital is playing "dumb". They didn't see anything, didn't hear anything, didn't know anything.! Each time they place the responsibility on someone else or another department. Incredible and so obvious. This hospital failed this family in so many ways. I hope they have to compensate the Kowalski family big time❤
That hosiptal has failed 100s of families
theyres something off about that judge🤔
Im sure the judge os getting paid by the hospital
She’s a terrible ethics witness !!! Reavaluate your ethics division
Wait till you get to the "Risk Management" witnesses, I actually really laughed out loud at them, they know nothing, never heard of Maya, but Beady blames all her abuses on them, and testified that the abuses she carried out were on the orders of Risk Management. To be fair, when they explained how the Risk Management committee only meet about 4 times a year, and they had little knowledge of Maya, it looks like Beady was working of her own volition, and using them as an excuse.
WHY?! Why does this judge ALLOW the defense to sit over there and make faces and shake their heads? The judge never says anything to them. He doesn't admonish them in any way. They sit over there (all 15 or 20 attorneys smirking, laughing loud and always shaking their heads before Mr. Anderson can even get his question out AND the Judge sustains the defences objections fact. This jury is going to be so confused because of the judge 👩⚖️ 🤔 How will they ever be able to deliberate. The judge has thrown out so many things...important things that the jury needed to see or here.nThis is a mess! It's my opinion which I have a right to that he's " Allegedly" very biased toward the defense and laughing along with them. This all is no laughing matter and the judge should act accordingly. He has allowed and I'm afraid will continue to allow the "bobbing & shaking heads to run his own court room." He shows no sympathy towards the death of Beata and seems to forget Maya and Kyle are still children and most Judges and attorneys are very sympathetic to the children and soft spoken but NOT this judge...oh how he must refrain from that but yet he's very sympathetic towards the defense. I'm very disappointed and disgusted by this judge. Power and politics are running high in this country room and many others and it's sad but it trickles down from the top down...like pouring rain
This Judge is a thunderstorm and lightening strikes constantly 😳 HE gets mad so easily and his demeanor is haunting 🌩 he's scary to the point that the defense doesn't know wether to just throw in a Hall Mary sometimes😳 😨
Notice how the defence begins shakes their heads are NO Even before Mr. Anderson can even get his question out and as soon as they start shaking their heads, they judge will sustain their objection immediately and then he looks directly at Mr. Anderson and scolds him By either telling him to move on or not to ask the question or by telling him that he "the Judge" It's about to make the decision or question for him..... What kind of judge acts like this?...this kind of Behavior from a judge is unexceptable in any case!
How do these people sleep at night?
Why so many comitees if none of them care about patient care.
Well clearly they only CARE about paycheck not CHILDREN
Omg these chief or whatever they are in charge of the departments don’t know anything that’s going on… as soon as they found out she kill Herself and blamed the hospital an investigation should be in place and everybody should be aware of what happened
I can certainly feel the frustration and desperation Beata must have felt.... Beata remembered how she felt when she was separated for no apparent reason from her own father. She knew what Maya was going through. Beata knew she was doing the best thing to reduce the suffering of her child, on the advice of several doctors. Maya is then held captive in the hospital blaming Beata, who knows this separation and misdiagnosis (proven) is going to cause more harm to Maya. Then the social workers start talking about putting Maya in a foster home...so in Beata's mind, her daughter is going to be separated from her mother no matter what (whether she removes herself from the world entirely, or Maya is dragged into foster care after the hospitalization). So she sees those choices: suicide (Maya comes home) or continue to fight (Maya goes to foster care and never receives the right treatment for her real and diagnosed CRPS disease). It makes sense that Beata sacrificed her own life to save her daughter. And as it turns out, Beata was right. Maya was released in less than a week after her mom took her life.
That's how I see it too. I'm confused how some people don't see this. That is the picture that has been painted thus far. My parents unalived themselves over financial issues, they only saw loosing everything they worked so hard for, they were hopeless and that was the only way out to them. They lost hope, as did Beata. Granted, my parents death was more complicated than that, they felt as if they were a burden to us kids. And in no way did I think they didn't love us, they loved us unconditionally our whole lives.
💯% agree and couldn't have sausage it better! Thank you!!! I wish you would repost your comment daily, if not several times daily. I know the judge and attorneys read these comments and I'm suck of this JUDGE BEING BIAS TOWSRDS DEFENSE. AND he's not even trying to hide it any longer. He is just awful to Mr.Anderson period!
@@ondi37
Judges don't read the comment section let alone TH-cam.
Well said!
Spot on.
The irony of Beata saying "take care of Maya" in her departure letter, knowing this hospital was unable to do anything close to that. Sickening
Heartbreaking 💔
ThIs Dr. ANTHONY NAPOLITANO...states that there is no one at the hospital qualified to diagnose an adult mental illness. So how did a judge feel it was ok to order this child to be take from her parents without a proper diagnosis of the mother? The judge has no real cause! Even if the judge felt there could be a truth to the "hear say" wouldn't he want further investigation to substantiate the truth? This whole case is so disturbing...everyone involved failed this family!
An entire one side of the whole courtroom is full of about 15 attorneys and then we have 2 defense attorneys. And the Judge wants to jump out loud down the throat of 2 defense attorneys trying to work against them and staying up til 2 or 3 am just to prepare for the next day. My husband is a judge of 42 years. Longest sitting in Tennessee and he said in all his years he's never seen a "a younger" judge for one thing, plus a person in his power, let the defense run HIS COURT ROOM! Plus show this much bias and in this case towards the defense. If he calls a mistrial then I hope the state throws him off the trial. Appeal is definitely coming due to this judge being bias. He reminds me of one of those kids that grew up rich, was spoiled by his parents and was a big bully then after being elected to the bench...God I can see it as many others can that he's being a bully in this case and he's very biased towards the Defense, very.
Perhaps do some research before you malign the Judge… you may learn a thing or two
This hospital obviously does not have very good doctors if I listen to the testimony of their doctors. It seems like they do not know what is going on in their hospital. Incompetance. Or what are they hiding.
Ms. Beata Kowalski was incredible loving and caring Mother. Tragically maternal instincts took over survival instincts and she sacrificed her own life in order to safe her daughter. 😢
JH is an extremely badly run hospital. All these people should be fired and decent and caring people appointed. I cannot believe non of these people knew about Mayas situation was never discussed. The only conclusion I can get to is that those who treating her or taking care of Maya hid all information from senior people. Why would they be doing that and why.
So JHACH have two mothers commit suicide b/c they believed it was MBP. I wonder how many parents have had their kids taken away due to MBP diagnosis??? It's a very rare condition yet they have 2 and I'm sure there's more.
Ruling for Maya
Man, this guy doctor deposition is terrible. They basically said don't admit to anything. It makes the hospital look soooo much worse.
Judge is biased
This sounds like South Africa's government. A lot of comittees but no decisions being made by them.
Seriously judge give them cause for appeal. It's wrong how you are biased d, how you and Hopkins lawyers treat the complainants and witnesses. Stuff happens
I immediately felt anger in large amounts when this woman spoke. Ethics ??? Sick, twisted, disgusting trash human. She's better off not having a job....or a life anymore. Does anyone want this ethics blimp to suffer with the pain and agony that Maya and family went thru? 😡😢😢😢
We had the same in Germany regarding Covid. 😡
Judge is gifting the defense. JHCOH (John Hopkins Chamber of Horrors) clearly treated Maya with deception and disrespect. It makes me want to vomit.
Lawyers pull witnesses ALL the time. Sometime it’s a “tactic” and sometimes in civil cases, it’s because of time constraints. The hospital has a team of lawyers and some you don’t even see sitting there.
Degrading and Dehumanizing
🤬🤬
Sounds like plaintiff's thought they would settle, these guys are clearly not prepared for trial.
You have it backwards. The defense tried to settle out of court but the plaintiffs turned it down.
This hospital has a history of mother's taking their life???? Now we know theirs malpractice in this hospital. Of course the committee talked about Maya, they all knew her case by that awful nick name they made for her. This witness sealed the deal that this hospital is corrupt. Maya should sue for more, enough to shut them down. So they can't continue to destroy families.
This chief of staff is really earning his paycheck
I'm in agreement the judge is so frustrated in trying to get the two lawyers to communicate. I understand Mayas attorney not wanting to tie up anymore time on CRPS and Ketamine due to being limited time however they have to communicate this between the parties. The judge is going to throw stuff out if they cannot communicate. It may not have changed anything to Mayas attorney however they still need a heads up. I can't imagine how Mayas MOM must have felt and Maya. If lawyers and Dr's aren't on the same page can you imagine how the patient and a family can get lost in explaining all of this. I can. My Dr's don't agree on treatment and it left me feeling very isolated , in pain and traumatized. Please communicate together.
Replay crew.
The judge being pissed off first thing in the morning is not a good thing. Yikes!
Im with judge on first issue. Cant not tell the other side youre pulling a witness
Happens all day, every day, in trials.
Actually you can. It happens all the time. They don’t have to call anyone on their list
If he says I’m unaware one more time!!!!!!!! Omg! Who’s in charge here! Come on now! This is absolutely crazy.
Wow this happened before in the same hospital! I would definitely want to look into that situation.
It’s so crazy to me that this very knowledgeable doctor diagnosed Maya and prescribed her medication and these people flipped it and blamed mayas mother! Wtf is wrong with these people!
I pray and hope Maya and her family gets justice. This hospital needs to be shut down or everyone involved needs to be fired. And I would definitely avoid this hospital at all cost!
45:03 consent to treat--- when you take a child to a hospital you have consented/ signed the hospital to "treat" your child as hospital personnel desires
Good strategic move on not calling Hanna.
This guy had too many duties to do but can’t remember one important meeting
How sbout using FIRED done working with any Children or Adults
Napalitano is a “doctor” with committee titles with no sense of ethics
Since the get go this untidy unkempt unprofessional judge has done everything in his judgemental power to humiliate Plaintiff's attorney, to argue with him over rubbish, become very aggressive towards him and sustain objections from Defence. He's the worst biased creep of a judge I ever saw. Turns on the charm and a completely different personality when the jury first enters. I reckon he is a narcissist though I hate to bandy the word around. This trial of all trials needed a very unbiased diplomatic, calm and mature relaxed judge. This is not what they have. He needs to go as does JHACH.
And just so jolly and laughing and trying to get the jury to laugh. This is horrific the government played a part in kidnapping this child from her parents and now they have to sit under the government rule to find fairness and this man thinks it’s all a joke.
I really don't like this Judge at all. He speaks to the defense like he respects them and talks to Anderson like he's a pos. It's weird.
This Judge is wearing on my nerves.
No ethics in the hospital nor court officials trying to cover their patners & not in the best interest of zdx m
Maya
Well
Hopefully hospitals will mind their own business when it comes to abuse. If any hospital is concerned or suspects any Munchausen's they ignore it and do whatever procedure the parent wants. A common misconception people have when it comes to Munchausen's is that the child is being hurt and is actually healthy. That's not always the case. A child can have a medical issue but the parent exploits it. The parent usually appears to be totally committed to their child, they'll go doctor shopping, is concerned with the child's health. Their life and identity is being a mother with very sick child who needs surgeries, medications, multiple stays in the er. At some point it begins to seem like the parent doesn't truly want their child to get better, even though they've devoted their entire existence towards their child's health. They've been advocating for their child.
But, is there ever a point when someone should step in and say Before we put a pump in your child's spine, how about we start with a less extreme and invasive treatment.
If a parent tells a doctor that their child is in so much pain and that their child wants to go to heaven and they try and put a nine year old in a hospice to die and are refused, should that be ignored. It's a disturbing thing to hear a parent talk like that. But nobody has a right to stop a parent from doing what they believe is in their child's best interest.
18:19 hes so rude
Shelter- aka, imprison kid til hospital sees fit?
Maya's mom was a nurse & might have been receiving second opinions from other medical experts as is her right as a parent
Lost of relationships on mom’s side of family is on the family not the death of mom. Bad line of questioning. Polish sister has been in America 20 years! She absolutely should speak English well enough to stay connected to her sister’s children!!!!!!
Bullshit
It's the parents duty to preserve the native language as many immigrants do
Liar 🤬
Poor Judge needs a break?? Geesh do your job judge
No excuse! You can’t pull crap like that! Im hopeful for the plaintiffs but they are so wrong to withhold that information
It’s perfectly allowed. They have no obligation to inform anyone
@@boomds5602 i had not heard that, but they didn’t get in trouble for it. Thank you.
I dont like this judge
Excellent judge. He is a decent, smart human being ❤
the unicorn judge
😂😂😂😂😂
I see what you did there and I can't stop laughing at your comment. Best comment of the day
how is it just to so obviously show disdain contempt and a lack of patience to one side by the judge. surely that has an influence on the jury.
If I was on the jury I’d be completely sick of this plaintiff/the attorneys ALL of it by this point, honestly. I mean…unless I just wanted to sit on a jury for weeks and weeks in hopes of ALSO profiting in some way off of this case?? No?? Bc I’m sure half of them are there for sadly just that reason.
Unfiketered lucky is the best on cases 😋Peter couldn’t measure up