Decoloniality, Hindutva, Victimhood Nationalism? | AG Krishna Menon, Sanjay Nirupam & J. Sai Deepak
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- India Today Conclave 2022: The India Today Conclave - Mumbai, is back with its latest edition scheduled to be held on November 4 and 5, 2022. An extension of the India Today Conclave, this edition will provide a platform for an intellectual and informed exchange of ideas between some of the most powerful voices in the country. Branded as the ‘Mumbaikar special’ the conclave offers a full spectrum for the intellectual appetite of Mumbai.
#jsdeepak #agkrishnamenon #sanjaynirupam
Subscribe to India Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
India Today TV is India's leading English News Channel. India Today TH-cam channel offers latest news videos on Politics, Business, Cricket, Bollywood, Lifestyle, Auto, Technology, Travel, Entertainment and a lot more.
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of news from India and around the world!
Download App: indiatoday.lin...
Follow us: Official website: www.indiatoday...
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
Every comment here is on Sai Deepak ji. Says alot about the kind of intellectual he is and the fanbase he has attracted by his perspectives.
👍👍👍
😍👍👍
Exactly chutya
Came here only to listen to thoughts of Shri Sai Deepak ji .
Always an absolute delight cause you know he is going to kill every propaganda with logic facts and a perspective that's both fresh and deeply rooted in Sanaatan Sanskriti of Bharat .
Can't get enough of the Genius.
Jai Hind
Jai Bharat
Jai Shri Krishna
Just because he talks good English it doesn't mean he is talking sensibly
@@MrAntonysimon your brain is incompetent bro 🤣
@@MrAntonysimon just because you don't wanna digest facts doesn't mean he is not speaking facts
And to find Sanjay nirupam sharing the podium 😝😝😝😝😝
@@MrAntonysimon he is good in English hindi tamil, but he is best in facts
Sai Deepak, amazing intellect and clarity of thought....real honest unbiased people will follow what he is saying...salute Sir.
15:30 What is Nirupam speaking?? Neheru vehemently opposed Somnath Temple restoration and also introduced norms in legal books of India to destroy temples for roads
He did... he was a pathetic human being ...u dont know so many things
They blatantly lie. It’s how u know they’re the snakes.
Indian book history are all doctored false. In converted islamist Pakistani history book they promote hatred against Hindu and used bad wards openly. That's a reason educated Pakistani support Rpe ,killing, forceful conversion on live news channel
He just wants to say " arre baba Aisa mera dhoti mat khol sabke saamne Rahul bhaiya marenga mere ko ".
Nehru didn't oppose that .......he opposed the visit of President in official capacity to the temple...learn facts
Should have been an entire one hour program with J S D... Jai Sai Deepak..
I am amused by Mr. Menon’s point on Kashi Vishwanath corridor? How can you develop the area without altering the previous narrow lanes and the surroundings?
निरुपम जी स्वयम ही उपनिवेशी मानसिकता के मूर्तिमंत उदाहरण है।
J sai deepak clarity of thoughts is at another level.
J sai sir is just another level of wisdom. He hits and beats everyone with logical truth. Jai hind
Sanjay Nirupam is marvellous. Superb.
Tipu Sultan destroyed Mangalorean Churches and Hindu temples in Kerala. There was forceful conversion of them into Islam as well. I feel frustrated and sad to learn him as the India's freedom struggler. He fought to save his kingdom. In that respect, he helped also Hindus in his kingdom
This should been at least a two hour discussion. And with decent panelists next JSD.
Legend Shri J. Sai Deepak 🇮🇳
No one can match sai Deepak 🔥🔥🔥
19:56 he forgot to add only in india we have SUPER POWER provided to particular religion and that's not in majority,they can claim anything and everything they wish to No Questions asked even by government.
*90% people in the comment section came here for Sai Deepak* 🙏🏻🚩
100% AGREE
Yes
True
and you came for Muhammad ibn Abdullah, Musalte aur Rohangiyas. Right?
100%
Came here just to listen J SAI DEEPAK Sir. Damn he's just an awesome personality
Deepak is a great speaker.
I like him for hid knowledge
Mee too
Sanjay Nirupam sounds like a roadside PFI worker
Correct. Doesn't deserve to be in this discussion.
@@arunpatil5150 yes. Nirupam ancestors are illegal immigrants from Bangladesh when Islamists took over yet today he is a foot soldier of PFI
He's a smart Bihari who made a fool of marathis especially shiv sena. Used his journalists skill in "dophar ka samna" tabloid.. became SS MP, made his million. Collected North Indians voters & shifted to congress.
You find 90% intellectual, philosopher is PFI worker or Hindu hater secular , Islamist.
But the truth is he is a roadside Congress worker
People like Sanjay Nirupam are important. They give us an insight into demented mind of Congress from time to time.
Absolutely right 😂😂😂😂
So so true. Sai D is capable of annihilating him and Hindu haters like him time and again.
Well said
This is why Congressis are being strategically preserved. We need them to know who our enemies. Once we lose the sight of the shatru we also lose.
Dimag se paidal hai ye Nirupam, very feeble arguments like a pidi
J Sai Deepak is a modern day Abhimanyu, who has not just mastered the art of breaking into the Chakravyuh and tearing up his opponents asunder, but just as effectively also learnt the trick of barreling his way out, so as to come back and fight another day👏🙏
Your comment is well taken, I agree with your praise of Sai. However, tragically, that is not what Abhimanyu did, he got in but couldn't get out.
@@dhnunj Not this time 😊
@@dhnunj Pls read my comment once again. That is exactly the point of distinction which I made.
That's Arjuna, not Abhimanyu.
@@RitwikRaghavRead MAHABHARAT again and read about Abhimanyu and Chakravyuuham. Arjuna is not the one that is being referenced here. Jai Shree Ram!
There is a Break at 2:50 Minutes (Speech by JSD).. Are you doing sensorship of the speech ??
Absolutely!! They completely cut him off!! BUT.. @India Today itself is a quasi congressi outlet & they like mainstream Indian media need urgent decolonization too!!
Yes why there is cut while @JSD was speaking???
@@rka-truthalwayswins5127 They couldn't even do it properly without us knowing. Editing skills bhi nahi hai🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
After watching and understanding j sai deepaks videos regarding decolonization i feel the other two doesn't even deserve to share podium besides him with all those childish mentality..with all seriousness...the man speaking in hindi perfectly explains Congress's moderate and useless stand on the issue..
Correct!! They talk nonsense!!
You mean CON/gress' collaborative stand??
Seconding dat
They start reciting poetries when they don't have any practical solutions; as they know their propaganda is about to get disclosed .
Exactly. The other two guys are so myopic in their worldview that they aren't deserving and capable to debate J Sai Deepak. It's a good thing to unveil the demented principles of Congress.
Sai Deepak is rocking! Sanjay ji is talking things that makes no sense.
Jha is a puppy of Antonio
It is clear Sanjav Nirupam was a last minute invitee. It’s a shame he is sharing stage with Sai
He moderator used word AATATAI instead of Muslim invader that is the 70 year education effect where we are not speak truth. He used the word Christian invader but not used Muslim invader .
Sanjay has only one response to every question... Why why are you speaking truth ; we made it tough for people to speak up the visible facts , why are you obliterating our mountains of hypocrisy.
@@hrishikeshbandgar2162 That has been the mindset of Congress ever since its formation. They are cowards who can't face the truth and rather sweep the muck under the carpet. And they continue to do so without any shame
If they did a one-on-one between JSD and that deracinated ex mp dodo, JSD would simply gulp him down and make him regret his stupid existence.
Superb 👍 But could someone help me with the word ‘deracinated’ - what does it mean?
A Rabid Sanghi dog can always Blabber about Bullshit communal bigotry.
The other two MPs offer something else other than the same communal Rhetoric.
@@blistering2900 For rabid Nehruvian Socialist SICKularist rogues truth is certainly unpalatable‼️
@@blistering2900 The only dog here is you. There are panch makkars in our society. Maulana, Missionary, Marxist, Macaulay putra and a section of Media, what breed of dog are you?
As regards to your ‘communal rhetoric’ claim. Well whatever JSD speaks is based on real facts of history, coming from primary sources. Just because they make you look like an imbecile and dare I say deshdrohi for taking the idealogical positions that you do doesn’t make it rhetoric.
And get atleast some of your facts right, the other two are not mps, one of them is an ex mp.
Savarkar was right when he said the real enemy of Hindu is the Hindu against Hinduism.
SAI is great. He moderator used word AATATAI instead of Muslim invader that is the 70 year education effect where we are not speak truth. He used the word Christian invader but not used Muslim invader .
At 2:50 minute why did you guys censure JSD. Give us a reason really pathetic approach by India Today...
,?
They deleted this speech there
Yes. I too am stunned. First I thought I had mistakenly moved the video forward then realised the truth. Shame on the organisers. When you provide a platform for free speech stick to it!😒
Quite clearly India Today didn't like what he said 😏
Quite clearly India Today didn't like what he said 😏
SAI DEEPAK! YOU ARE A LEGEND!
Legend chutya
Please rename this debate as Sai J Deepak vs 2 Jaded Losers.
brother you nailed it.😂😂😂😂love from a hindi speaker.
INDIA TODAY be like edit kar kar ke kitna edit Karu har jagah saideepak ne maar Li hai aapki 😂😂😂😂
👍👍😂
You cannot beat the knowledge n wisdom this man has...J Sai u rocked!
this debate shows why Congress n loosing everywhere.. they r so cut off from bharat.
They always were cut of from Bharat! Nehru had threatened Gandhi that he will balkanize India if he was not made PM even when Sardar Patel was elected as PM by the Congress committee!!
After Gandhi's request, Sardar Patel relinquished his PM seat! In fact, if not for Sardar Patel, Nehru might have followed through his threats as he already tried to destroy Kashmir!!
They were always known for anti-India sentiments , it's just now people got another option besides them ; today people are not helpless like they were in past under the rule of modern Mughals popularly known as congress
Heritage is something that adds value. How can aurangazeb become heritage.
Because Hs have failed to honor their ancestors and their balidaan.
Suvar bharat pak kashmir Avam ko gulami Nafrat Luut Padha Rahe the
Dumbass heritage is something That is part of history. Taj Mahal is a World heritage site. So can you only talk about Taj Mahal without mentioning ShahJahan.
Aurangjab is R and conversion specialist and temple destroyer. He moderator used word AATATAI instead of Muslim invader that is the 70 year education effect where we are not speak truth. He used the word Christian invader but not used Muslim invader .
Aurangzeb is a father figure to congress
Dear Sanjay, it was Vijayanagar and Marathas who defended Hindu dharma.
Valid points raised by Sri Sai Deepak. Future generations should feel attracted to visit our holy places. Clean , well kept surroundings are a must to appeal to young people. They should be maintained well
Spik and span and infra in and around the Temples is a must to attract the young visitors from abroad.
J sai deepak Rock rock and rocks God level intellect and courage
Don’t say rock. Rockers r drug infused imbicils with serious superiority complex and super ego.
Truth is a Truth even by a MINORITY of ONE. That is SAI DEEPAK.
07:50- Idea of Swaraj in mainstream was first used by Dadabhai Naroji in 1906 as per 9th class History.. Not Neheru
Swaraj was first popularized by Shivaji and then by Dayanand Saraswati... Later on naroji adopted it
Idea of Swaraj was first used vs British by Vaudev Phadke who led Ramosi force in Maharashtra
He is Sanjay nirupam dude , he will give nehru a credit for his birth as well .
@@hrishikeshbandgar2162 🤣🤣🤣 so true
It was idea not an official demand .....Nehru along with Bose were the first to demand poorna swarajya from the British.....any way naoroji was also a congressi
The uninformed politician says - “Panini Sanskrit works are outdated, why should we read them now?” While until this day, Panini’s works are citied and analyzed in analytical linguistics, NLP etc. by the West. People like this are the reason Bharat’s intellectual spirit remains crushed. We need 1000 more Sai Depak’s!
Indian government wastes thousand crores of rupees in teaching anti-k** fir scriptures in some well-known institutes ; no one makes a noise .
16:35 Why is S Nirupam being allowed to spew misinformation after misinformation?? Chicken Curry has a history predating islam let alone Mughal
Mr. Sai deepak is correct, to do attrocities you don't need to be in majority. In this case too, sai deepak was in minortiy but he ravished these so called intelectual with sheer logic and actual intellect!
unfortunately- it was timed out or intentionally made time out!! i was waiting on nirupaman ji counter to that !!
wanted to see his response in shame 😀
Mr. Menon ka Kashi ka contract pass nhi kiya BJP ne 😂 , Sai Deepak as always Awesome with facts and point to point discussion. Question for India Tv : Why did you call Mr. Nirupam?, let him enjoy his retirement as he is just irritating.
Thats my point..
Nirupam is not intellectually equip like sai.. Shashi tharoor would be best option..
Gulami padhane Vale kamunisttani gyan de Rahe
Well whoever questions this bullshit Conclave and it's topic of discussion.
Nirupam raised very good point the first step of decolonisation by declaring poorna Swaraj in 1930 and adapting our own constitution in 1950.
But you dumb heads have no sense you only believe BS BJP propaganda
@@sahilmishra6529 gulami tu tum log kar rahe ho BJP ka. Aur bhulo mat 5 mafinama aur 60 Rs pension kisne liya tha Britishers ke talwe chat rahe ho.
@@sahilmishra6529 Tum log Bul Bul or Savarkar ka history padho wahi tum logon ko suit karega
Good points raised by Mr Deepak. Sanjay's perspectives are age old we were hearing from last many decades.
Yes. What old school congressis utter. And a bunch of morons from Kerala still believe. They ask nothing happened to Hinduism in past centuries. Someone should remind him that Hinduism is completely wiped out from present day Pakistan and Bangladesh because of changing demographics
Macauly Mindset , Sanjay Nirupam.
Only
Deepak
Only
Deepak
Is the real speaker. All others including the anchor better not to mention.
Appeasement
Appeasement by Gandhi Nehru consented devision of this country for appeasement of jinna. Again that shameless party continue appeasement of jinna and english type. Excellent thrown out jeorge.
Sai Deepak's points and observations are damn true, and bang on 🔥
Aurangazeb is not part of our culture and heritage.Barbarian are not part of our heritage
Absolutely correct!!
Woh Sanjay nirupam ka baap hain 😂
J sai Deepak the man of knowledge and wisdom 👍👍may lord Krishna save you from all evil eyes 🙏🙏
J Sai is the pre-eminent intellectual of our time. His arguments/discussions are crisp, laced with logic backed by facts, and figures. Nirupam looks like a pre-primary kid in the company of adults; shallow, bombastic, noisy, and lacks substance. The third person, a senior citizen, is still in 1950s Nehruvian India.
Wow Sai Deepak! What clarity and conviction
We are with PM Modi on the path for reclaiming the glorious and rich civilisation of the holy land of Bharat 🇮🇳..we are not fed up by freebies.we always stood for nation and now it’s time to stand for Dharma as well as For nation…
Nothing new, Sai doing Sai things! Destroying opposition with facts & logic, his thoughts are so clear as always!
Question: Please run a brief discussion with J Sai Deepak can never get enough of him!
Agree with you
We are lucky to have J Sai Deepak in our nation
Sai is fantastic always..
The rise and rise our Dharmic leader Shree J Sai Deepak🙏🏼🕉️🙏🏼
All kendriya vidyala and hindu schools must implement compulsory sanskrit and vedic maths without shame and thinking twice.
Sadly tn will protest
Hope every Bharatiya has 1% of Jai Sai Deepak's clarity n ideology of BHARATHA.... This civilization will never be destroyed by invaders.....
Excellent points put forth by Sai Deepak. His arguments are logical and with data. For this topics, more time is needed
Mr. SaiDeepak, you rocked as always. Hats-off to you for your depth of knowledge.
Sai deepak you are a very pure soul. We all love you.
Sanjay Nirupam is a totally misfit among the erudite speakers.
Why call a misfit like Sanjay Nirupam ?
This Nirupam guy has said most fake facts in the few minutes he got than any satire website could ever think of.. 😑😑😑
Please bring JSD more on your channel.
Shree Sai Deepakji as always to the point with rational.
J Sai Deepak anna rocks !!
Wished Mr. Menon's points were discussed further. This discussion was very airy to say the least. Our cities and architecture needs serial booster dose of decoloniality and freedom from netas, contractors, babus and milords.
SAI DEEPAKJI WOW WHAT A LEGEND MAN THAT.EACH WORD SPOKEN IS A PIECE OF DIAMOND. JAI SHREE RAM KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK.
Something is terrible with congress politicians understanding it seems . Complete illogical thoughts and sounds like British slaves . Sad 😔
What a wonderful and thoughtful speaker J Sai 👏
J Sai deepak already destroyed each and every stupid logic given by Sanjay Nirupam.
Regular listeners already know it.
देखो देखो कौन आया....
Deepak Sai शेर आया.... 🙏🙏
Sai Deepak 🔥🔥
Y is this cutting off JSD?? Where’s the full version??
Anand Ranganathan, J Sai deepak, Vikram Sampath and Sanjeev Sanyal great author and debaters which I like to listen. Debate with facts and figure.
J sai Deepak rocks as usual!!
Just to make it clear, I am here to listen Only and Only The J SAI DEEPAK.
Rest seems to be brainless talk.
JSD being himself, just objective and smart
I think listening to j sai deepak what i realise is our current generation should start reading books of our ancient past not just listen to it.
You will be able to articulate our sanatani point of view because to protect the other idealogy they have many ardent followers we don't!!.Start your journey now.
I will recommend young people my age (26) whose interest has been science fiction they can directly start with upanishad (get it on google) as it is about abstract ideas. Rest can start your journey with bhagwat geeta
Pranam🙏
I am scared that jsd may have lost some brain cells listening the other panelists .
Came to listen to J Sai Deepak..super clarity, amazing knowledge
No ummm, no ahhh, no fillers...his words are right on the money all day everyday. JSD 👏
JSD facts. Shame this important topic got same time as some far less crucial ones like sessions w failed bollywood.
Aree hindu temple tax collect karte ho toh kyu na kare temples ka renuvation, ajeeb admi hai bhai. Aur agar Nehru chacha ne science me investment kiya toh kyu ISRO bullock cart se parts carry karne pare, kyu chruch me kaam karna para, ek lab nahi deh sakte kya. Aur yeh IITs bana diye areee 1992 liberisation se pehle hamare saree IITian's America meh jake kaam karte teh.
Debate is between one broad minded person (Sai Deepak sir) and other brainless child's
India today should bring some efficient speakers who has at par knowledge and respect towards sanathana dharma and patriotism
India today has partiality towards the brainless childs
People says hindu doesn't get affected by outsiders then plz anyone tell me why pakistan exists today
Rishi Sunak did not win as a Prime Ministerial candidate in a General Election. He was selected or hoisted on to the post by certain interests in the current circumstances. Even if it were otherwise, there is nothing for Indians to be exuberant about.
Jawaharlal nehru was not selected by the British as the PM, indira was not selected by the AICC after the death of shastri , rajiv Gandhi was not selected by the Gandhi family servants masquerading as the AICC ?
@@rajeevpalthukral764 They all subsequently led the party to electoral victory. These dynasts are not democratic exemplars in any case.
@@ananthan8951 so you know already that sunak will not ? sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander
@@rajeevpalthukral764 What is your point? That Indians should celebrate a born Britisher who became a British PM in their down days?
@@ananthan8951 they deliberately made it on diwali quoting it as a diwali gift. They are imposing moral duty of west on us to support Ukraine. West wants to turn India on their side. But the present dispensation is not going to be fooled down by these colonial jaadugiri
...what a joker this Sanjay Nirupam is....no wonder Shiv Sena kicked him out and Congress too does not care ...sad that India Today conclave cld not invite somebody better even half as gd as the other 2 ....
Mr J sai Deepak speech has most logic
Shri JSD.
Good to see lot of Bengalis in comment section are in agreement with Sri Sai Deepak Iyer.
Indian book history are all doctored false. He moderator used word AATATAI instead of Muslim invader that is the 70 year education effect where we are not speak truth. He used the word Christian invader but not used Muslim invader .
Sai is gold!
The way @jsaideepak spoke without intentionally seeing nirupam khangresi..that’s true intellectuality..he nicely avoid this chatukar khangresi 😂
Never vote - support Congress party.....never support communist party.....!! In last 65 years Congress and communist destroyed India...!!.....hindu should stand together for your next generation future....!!
Sai sir be like " ye kin logo ke beech aa Gaya m"
Awesome deepak Saiji , about how far we should respect our past
What are credentials of Sanjay Nirupam on this topic?
Awesome deepak … true to your name, spreading light
JSD 🔥 Unparallel
India Today,couldn't you get a better fellow than Sanjay zeropam to add value to this discussion. Everyone is here to listen to Sai Deepak.
As usual Sai rocks. Regularly following Sai. His views r crystal clear. Jai Sri Ram 🙏
Hindu civilization 5000 saal old hai par iska Vistar Aaj sikur gaya hai, in old days Sanatan civilization Iran se Indonesia tak tha aaj ye Bus India aur Nepal tak rah gaya hai
Sai Deepak agar hindi me bolta toh uski batein or jyada....effective hoti
Unfortunately Nehru wanted Somanath mandir to be preserved like any other monument under the control and supervision of Archaeological Survey of India as we find in Halebeedu, Khajuraho or any other historical place.
And we know the INCOMPETENCE of ASI for ANYTHING outside the colonial Muslim monuments!!
He didn’t have a right to make that decision. At all!! Every H should slam such notions.
J Sai Deepak is an absolute delight to hear and a big hope of this aspiring young Bharat.
Sai literally owns the debate with his rational, fact based approach 🔥
A role model for Indian youth, to be truth driven and proud of our heritage.
Varun Dhawan 30mins
Aauditya Thakre 30mins
SaiDeepak n others on decolonization 25mins
Well done India Today! Bhesh👏🏼
Correct!! @India Today too needs to decolonize & become Indian!!