First Time Watching *TREASURE PLANET* (Movie Commentary & Reaction)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ก.ย. 2024
- Treasure Planet Movie Reaction and Commentary
for this week's reaction, I decided to watch Treasure Planet for the first time! pirate movies usually keep me entertained and this one wasn't an exception. the atmosphere was so magical, not to mention the song! the characters were unique and the story was interesting enough. all in all, I had a good time watching it!
hope you enjoy this reaction to Treasure Planet!
***
Instagram: / sophielents
Twitter: / sophielents
suggestions for future commentaries & reactions are welcomed
The mix of 3D scenarios with painting, unrealistic, artistic style of textures, with 2d characters is something that works pretty well.
Totally agree!
The cyborg parts are CGI while silver is hand drawn
If you like this movie then you will also enjoy these,
1. Spirit Stallion of the Cimarron
2. Road to Eldorado
3. Iron Giant
All are animated movies.
Thank you! I will put them on my list :)
@@SophieLents
You're Welcome.
Excellent choices
@@AndreNitroX
Thank You. ☺
I would add Prince of Egypt to that list. One of the greatest animated movies EVER!
This might be total pessimism on my part, but I always assumed the whole "bad luck to have a woman on board" was born from the assumption that locking up 60 men inside a shitty wooden box floating on liquid death for several months on end, _with_ a woman on board, would probably not be fun for the woman...
That’s a valid point, especially taking into account that this whole superstition was born back in the days when women weren’t even seen as equals to men…
@@SophieLents yup yup, _and_ most of those crews were made up of bums who usually had no other option apart from starving on the streets, or straight up criminals who had to be off the land. Certainly not the most "civilized" gents, even weaker men would be in danger in some of those ships. Btw great reaction.
Most likely
@@frenchynoob ay was certainly a regular occurrence for cabin boys
I'd say it wouldn't be fun for anyone as men might start fighting over a woman and there's no place for that on any ship.
One of my favorite Disney movies. So underrated
It’s truly amazing!
One of Disney most underrated movies.
When you mentioned how The Captain wasn't cautious hiring the pirates, I felt I needed to point out earlier in the movie when she told the Doctor about her distaste with "this crew *you* hired"
It was Doctor Doppler that hired the pirates
Sophie: "It's based on a book, I think."
Yes, Treasure Island by Robert Louis Stevenson. When I was 8 I had a severely broken leg that got infected because of my primary doctor. As a result I spent some serious time in the hospital. While there, one of my sisters gave me "Classics Illustrated" which is basically a graphic novel treatment of books like Treasure Island. A great way to teach kids about 19th century literature. None of those Classics Illustrated stories came up in junior or senior high because my teachers had other priorities.
I knew the movie title sounded familiar! I might have even read this book ages ago but I’m not sure. Btw, I think “classics illustrated” is a wonderful idea!
Thus, the ship is named the 'R.L.S. Legacy'. One of the reasons I fell in love with the film is that it seemed to me that the filmmakers loved what they were doing in every scene.
I was weaned, so to speak, on Classics Illustrated, in my misspent Boomer youth. The last I looked, they've been uploaded to Internet Archive. They've adapted Brothers Grimm stories, Greek myth, classic 19th century novels. Consult the Wikipedia article.
@@SophieLents By the way. there is a Russian adaptation with subtitles. It's more faithful to the book, but also more comedic and over the top. Watch it, it's very fun. th-cam.com/video/QKRG7PF73UA/w-d-xo.html
i read a lot of books about pirates when i was a kid, and treasure island was among my favorites. it's kind of a short book so you'll have no trouble getting through it, and i would recommend trying!
As someone who was raised with this movie seeing a reaction of without trashing it, makes me happy. This is one of Disney's most underrated movies. I would like to see you react to Jim Henson's the dark crystal
Trashing?? This movie is awesome!
This movie was supposed to have a sequel, but the movie kinda failed cause it launched the same week as harry potter. But Jim was supposed to have a love interest and the villain was a robot pirate or something... I'd love to see that.
Oh, it sucks that it didn’t get a sequel! I’d watch it in a heartbeat
Frozen gets a sequel but not this masterpiece!!!!!?????
@@SophieLents worst of all, the villain was going to be played by willem dafoe and he was on his way to the studio to start recording his lines when the movie was cancelled
The marketing for the movie was also done very poorly which contributed to it failing, disney was more focused on lilo and stitch. On top of all the fighting that was done for this movie to be made in the first place.
Maybe one day we'll get a remake (that is good) or the sequel... i will keep hoping
At least this film exists
I always get this feeling in my chest at the song... THE SONG! With his father leaving :(
Yes!! Honestly, they said so much through this song, it was such a clever way of explaining Jim’s story
This movie is a re-imagining of the original 'Treasure Island' novel and you might be surprised how little the overall story actually changed from the original. The original also had the evil pirate captain find his soft side and leave in basically the same way, including the tossing him a handful of treasure part if I'm not mistaken. (It has been many years since I read the book so I might be wrong)
Most underrated movie ever
Agreed!
Next to Atlantis
Unfortunately Disney scrapped the sequel, the script was already written :(
I would have gladly taken a tv series. Why Disney!???
😢 why?! 😭
Disney pretty much sabotaged this movie's chances at the box office by releasing it on the same day as Harry Potter. It's also likely that they did this just so they'd have an excuse to shut down their 2D animation studio and switch completely over to 3D animation.
The worst part is that this was the movie makers' passion project.
@@dragonsword8129 Yeah, they had absolutely NO faith in the film, so they refused to give it a lot of press, even though the directors were promised they could work on this if they work on the others. It's a truly clever take on the source material and came out the same year as Lilo and Stitch.
@@realar Have you seen the trailer? It straight up spoils most of it
11:31 in the Latin Spanish dub, Scroop’s nickname was “patas de araña” (spider legs). It was funnier than “bug thing”
Not sure if anyone mentioned but the Captain gets to chose their first mate not their crew when a trip is being financed by a outside source. Unless they buy the boat which crew attached which is something the doctor did not do here.
She even makes it abundantly clear in her first scene with the Doctor and Jim when she says, “I dont much care for this crew, YOU hired.” Talks about how they shouldn’t share information about the treasure with the crew, And goes on to say they are a, “Luducrus parcel of driveling galutes.”
But it’s written so cleaverly that when your watching her say these things we are more focussed on wether of not she is evil and miss her well formulated warnings.
Needless to say loved your reaction. 🥰💕
I'm honestly sad that they stopped doing hand-drawn/CG hybrid films after this. Also, it was awesome we felt to say "Yet" at the same time.
Similar techniques are still used in anime. Some of the air combat in Youjo Senki for instance has 2D animated characters (or 3d for small background characters) in a 3D environment The cityscape in Ep 8, the clouds in the big battle from Ep 11 and the final battle in the movie both really show this off. The 3D graphics software Blender also has "grease pencil" which is a set of tools for similar kinds of 3D/2D hybrid animation. You can see an example here: th-cam.com/video/pKmSdY56VtY/w-d-xo.html or here th-cam.com/video/KlHDe4KqQ64/w-d-xo.html So Disney isn't doing it any more, but other people are.
I love Treasure Planet! One of my all time favourites.
It’s so good!
If you remember at the beginning of the movie, when Captain Amelia was introduced, she expressed her distaste for the crew that Dr. Dobbler hired. She always had the suspicion that they were bad.
I remember hearing about a tv show that they were planning, but apparently this movie absolutely flopped in the box office and it was very expensive for them to make, since they were using new animation technology at the time. Now Disney want to pretend this movie doesn't even exist. =/
I cant belive that the girl who is voicing Captain Amelia is Emma Thompson.
Oh, I knew her voice sounded familiar! Didn’t know it was Emma Thompson
I first watched this movie last year, while others have never heard of it or watched it as a little kid. Pretty good underrated movie.
It's so sad that people are sleeping on this movie!
I thought the captain already knew that the crew was a bad bunch when she details how Delbert shouldn't blabber about the tresure map.
Fun seeing these reaction videos nonethelees.
Sadly never got a continuation. The film bombed at the box office because general audiences recognized Disney’s home release schedules and decided to wait until it came out on VHS instead of buying movie tickets.
It also lost out on box office revenue because it came out after Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets which was far more popular.
This movie deserved so much more! But competing with HP is tough. They should’ve moved the release date at least.
@@SophieLents yeah. Disney has had a habit of doing that the past couple of decades.
Black Cauldron did so bad it lost to the Care Bears Movie. And Oliver & Company to Don Bluth’s The Land Before Time.
This is one of my all time favorite films. I love Jim and Silver relationship.
You should start a subseries called “Underrated Disney Bangers”. This movie definitely came out 20 years too late or 20 years too early. Martin Short as the robot is a mood. Plus I’m pretty sure Joseph Gordon Levitt was physically digitized and beamed into the movie, Tron style.
I can’t believe this movie was a flop with such great cast and plot. Definitely deserved more attention
This is actually the third time Disney has made a film based on the book Treasure Island. The first was in 1950, and the second was in 1995 in coproduction with The Jim Henson Company.
16:05 She didn't have a choice. Delbert hired the crew, she did with what she had.
Yesssss you finally watched it!!! This movie really is a work of art and it's a shame that's it's become so underrated. I loved it as a kid and I still love it now. Like seriously this and Prince of Egypt are my absolute favorite animated films. If you're curious, there are plenty of videos on TH-cam that explain how Disney basically set it up to bomb so they could justify ending their tradition of making 2D animation in favor of CGI. Oh and yeah the song I'm Still Here is a banger
Yeah, it’s so disappointing that people don’t even know this masterpiece exists! Prince of Egypt is definitely on my list :)
@@SophieLents awww yeah. I seriously cannot to see your reaction when you hear the Hans Zimmer score for Prince of Egypt
@@matthewcampos1774 omg, Hans Zimmer!! Now I’m even more excited to watch this movie
If Treasure planet released today it would probably do really well
Disney royally fucked up this movie's chances of success. Theres stories floating around that the ceo of disney at the time, micheal eisner, didnt like this movie all throughout developement and did everything to get it to fail. I dont know if i believe that. What i do know is fact is that it got released between lord of the rings return of the king and harry potter and the chamber of secrets. That was such a shit move because those two movies just slaughtered it mercilessly.
I don’t know if a ceo of a company would intentionally cause it to fail because of financial losses. It just sounds really dumb…
@@SophieLents yeah thats the thing. It just also doesn't make sense for disney to release this movie between those two other juggernauts. Like theres no way to actually think you've got a chance there
The bad luck is a historically accurate portrayal of sailors especially the timeframe that the original Treasure Island would have been based. There were a lot of superstitions especially among the lower class people of the time who would have made up most of the crew. And generally dudes who sail for months at a time without seeing a woman would think anything that bad happened on a new expedition where a woman joined them would have blamed everything that went wrong on the voyage on her. (And yes the music is really good in this movie)
I love the crap out of this movie! So glad you gave it a watch 😄
I'm really happy I did!
The other underrated Disney animated film from that time (there's a trailer for it on my Treasure Planet DVD, including pencil-test footage and other interesting bits) is 'Brother Bear'. You will laugh and cry. Really.
I love it with all my heart and there’s a commentary on this movie on my channel!
Oh hey, I haven't seen this in the comments, but... There was going to be a sequel. Disney pulled the plug when this movie wasn't the next Lion King.
If you look around online, somebody made a documentary about what the sequel was going to be, putting together the photos of the story-board (what little there was of it) and the basis for the plot. I personally think it would have been great, and I'm upset that it never got made just because it wasn't a box office hit.
Hell, after the absolute trials that the producers went through just to get this movie made (they literally went and made things like Aladdin on the command of Disney in order to be given the budget for this one, then Disney didn't even advertise it, which is why the movie did badly at the box office), it should have been given that chance.
It's a good movie, and it should have been given more than it got. And because it wasn't given what it deserved, we don't get the sequel we deserve either.
To this day I still feel Jim is a descendant to Aladdin. I know they were both animated by Disney but they remind me so much of each other, their moves and everything.
I'm not lying when I said "she should do treasure planet." And then j scrolled down...and I screamed. I was like "YEAAASDD" and then I had to cover my mouth cuz I was too lpud🤣
Bribing was done to hire the pirates as crew.
Got high recommendations even when questioned.
Wouldn't let any other crew get hired.
Plus docks are filled with friendly and unfriendly types, most looking the same.
Omg, Sonya! I just watched it and I am speechless, such quality content! I enjoyed every single minute of it. Gonna watch all of your videos. You go girl!❤️❤️❤️
I’m so happy you liked it ❤️❤️❤️ thank you so much for your support, it means a lot!!
At the beginning, Jim is riding his homemade Solar Surfer :))
yes yes yes this is my favorite Disney movie ever this and hunchback
"Is... based on a book, I think"... Yeah, Treasure Island by Robert Louis Stevenson. An incredibly famous books, like, seriously, it's a classic...
This is undeniably the best Disney movie for me
One of my favorite movie quotes from my childhood...
"Oh, Blast me for a FOOL!"
Loved this movie as a child and still do. John Rzenik, the lead singer of The Goo Goo Dolls sang the 'banger' song! The Goo Goo Dolls have been my favorite band since age 4 so hearing his voice in this epic movie is just the icing on the cake
This is my number 2 favorite Disney movie. The hunchback of Notre Damme is number 1, and the emperor's new groove is number 3.
Hey Sophie, just came across your channel. I love your reactions and disses on the characters. Cracks me up. You earned a sub.
There actually IS a sequel.
...Sort of. Even though it's probably not widely known, it does exist in the form of an old RTS PC game called Treasure Planet: Battle at Procyon.
25:13 always my reaction exactly lol
😂😂
I love how this film combines the past (i.e. the fashion & lifestyle) w/ the future (i.e. the amazing tecnology) 1:32 2:48 6:02 6:13 10:43 12:54 15:47 21:15 21:37 22:59 23:34
There is a game about when te war breaks out during hawkings studies but I dont remember Silver being in it xD
THE MOST UNDERRATED MOVIE OF THE CENTURY!!!
I hate the fact that this movie didn’t get great reviews on its original release, cause this was one of my absolute favorites as a child and even now
I always watching this like almost 5 times in the row, also it's my childhood movie anyway the sickest thing about this movie is the Crescent moon though they're making the Crescent moon as their Base.
If you enjoy this one, I can highly recommend Atlantis: The Lost Empire as well!
"do you know anyone who is like yeah i'm a loser and i'm proud of it" literally the whole plot of glee?
So um, this is mostly a fan theory, so feel free to ignore, but you asked what happened to silver, and I want to point out a few things that I think paint a clear picture. FIrst, he gives up a lifelong obsession, but still smiles. Then, he gives away all the riches he has to the only person he developed a genuine relationship, which he has to abandon for jim's own good. Then, after a series of events that would break most men, he still has the same smile as he gives away everything he has ever cherished and disappears. We then see his head in the clouds in the same manner simba's father. I don't think silver was around for a sequel, in a way I can't say because of youtube TOS. Sorry if this breaks your heart a little.
I was one of the few people who actually went to the cinema to see this. I LOVED it. It's one of my favourite movies alongside A Monster I Paris, which is also a criminally underrated movie that I recommend anyone to watch.
There is the book, Treasure Island, and a couple of movies before this animated gem.
7:20 - I am facepalming so goddamn hard because it took me. Twenty. God. Damn. *YEARS* to notice that the rings were making an "X." As in the "X" on a treasure map.
9:22 - I love how this movie doesn't baby kids by dumbing down the vocabulary. Did I know what a lot of the words being said were? No, but I grew up reading Calvin & Hobbes as a kid, I was used to being introduced to words I didn't understand. I either used context clues or, if I was particularly curious, looked them up and built my vocabulary.
12:48 - Even as someone whose dad left as a child, it was never this scene that hurt to see because I was 1 year old and never had any memory of him. It was the shot of the mom, crying, wondering what in the Hell she was going to do, alone. That shit stings.
20:26 - Tell that to Jumping Spiders. Or the hundreds of millions of insects that would get to you if spiders weren't helping to keep them in check.
22:26 - See: Pharaohs
Amazing reaction. This was my favourite as a kid and I have it on DVD. Me and my dad would always watch it and its truly an underrated film.
Thank you so much! Yeah, it’s sad that it wasn’t a huge hit like many other Disney movies
It’s my dads favorite Disney movie we still watch it together so many years later
So many people bitch and moan "it's just Treasure Island in space!" I'm like, um...yeah, kind of the POINT!
Fun fact in the original script the male doctor was actually going to be shown pregnant in fact they animated a scene but audiences were confused so they reanimated it.
Wow 😨 that was an interesting idea for sure
This has been my favourite Disney movie since I was 3, it dealt with themes that other movies hadn’t touched on. Plus the animation was way more ahead of its time.
There was originally going to be a sequel but it was scrapped because of how badly this movie tanked at the box office. As I understand it, this movie had a similar fate to Megamind. A big name movie came out at the same time and overshadowed it.
THIS IS THE MOVIE THAT MADE ME LOVE STEAMPUNK!
Watch it with BG audio and Eng sub to see how good our voice actors are. Please, you won’t be disappointed
EDIT: I was born several days after this masterpiece that i grew up with (along with Atlantis: The Los Empire)
one of the people who helped make treasure planet worked on pirates of the caribbean 😆
Oh! I'm here for it!!!
Did anyone else notice that Jim’s back hair piece is exact like Anikan Skywalker’s from Star Wars Episode ll: Attack Of The Clones? And when you think about it Jim and Anikan have fairly similar characteristics.
Well Long John Silver-Jim Hawkins' father-son relationship is a key element of what makes Treasure Island Treasure Island, it has to remain in its adaptations 😂
They literally can change views in windows and make projector stuff. I think they didn’t have problems in finding mister turtleman 😂
One of the best, most underrated movies. And such a great twist on treasure island.
Bug thing: *commits murder*
This girl: "what an asshole >:c"
The captain didn’t choose the crew, the doctor hired the crew
I don't know if you have access to any way to view it but if you haven't seen it, I highly recommend Black Sails. It's a prequel to Treasure Island.
I think Silver is a old Jim in some way. He seeing himself in that boy who is as lost than him. I think Silver was a Jim who was never helped by anyone, who has all his life lessons lerned in the hard way and has to hold on to his potentionaly impossible dream to not sink, and it's like that it's became a obsession. He ends up to have only that left. And that why he was ready, at first, betrayind Jim even if he really loves him: he finally reach the targed after all this time, his sufferings and sacrifices. But he finally chose Jim, not only because he likes him, but also because I think he wished someone had done it for him when he needed it. I think it's why too he takes Jim under his wing, not only because he's loving him and has a link with him, not only because he's seeing in him the seeds of greatness, but also because he's seeing in Jim the potential to become like him if nobody help him, and don't wanna that for him. I think I have this feeling because the french version of the song (I'm French) don't has the feeling of Jim, but point of view of Silver and what he's trying to transmit to his boy. If someone is interessed, there is a link of the french version with eng subs: th-cam.com/video/xjyVs6jR3os/w-d-xo.html
If you want a quirky and unique animated movie, may I suggest Twice Upon a Time (1983). It’s truly one of a kind. Unfortunately, I don’t know if it’s streaming anywhere, so you’ll probably have to find it on disc.
Treasure Planet is hella underrated and it’s always been one of my favorite Disney movies
I have to say that i watched this movie a feel times, i remember when was launched in the theather and i had a magazine talking about it, but just now because you said i realize that Jim was the only human in the ship 🤣
One of my top 5 Disney movies
i heard there also making a live action version of this movie think it comes out this year or 2023 not sure which but i would go see it in a heartbeat
I am soooo glad you enjoyed the film so much, it is one of my absolute favorites and as you said completely underrated. You should listen to the Spanish (Mexico) version of the song, it hits the feels even more.
14:16 You'd make a great space pirate.
My favorite Disney movie ever!!😀
8:17 well do i have a bad news for you
*starts crying in the corner*
I dont know if someone already said this but it was the PHD guy who bought the crew they arent the captains like own crew. That's why she was roasting him for getting them for her in the beginning 😂
This movie is very underrated out of all the Disney movies that came out when this movie came out it's very good movie it's interesting I see all the twist and turns with the story lines with the characters😉 and one of my all-time favorite bad Guy character arcs who becomes a good guy very well done! also if you like this movie then you'll like what people else or commenting about
Another one of my favorites road to El Dorado and my other super super favorite one from my childhood from my middle school days The iron Giant one hilarious movie including the actor that plays the voice of forget his name it's been a while lol
And This one Did This Come From When I Watched Treasure Planet Movie
This is one of the most underrated experimental era disney films ever
Sophie... I dont know if you'll ever see this comment, its beet two years after you posted this and a half an hour since I found it.
But... *there is a sequel to Treasure Planet!*
Treasure Planet: Battle at Procyon
Its a game, but one of the few movie spin-off game that actually good.
Bottom line? If you want more Jim and Silver being a father-son duo thats where you need to go.
I'm surprised there's only one guy mentioning Treasure Planet: Battle at Procyon here, it doesn't connect *that* well with the movie story-wise, but hey, Jim is commanding ships now and Silver... let's just say he does big things not to spoil it, Amelia is also back in the navy as an admiral for some reason.
This game sets the universe better though, if you're interested in just "MORE Treasure Planet!" x)
And oh is this game big on gameplay, it's probably THE Best movie tie-in game, whole lot of fun having battles with those solar sailing ships.
this is my favorite disney movie
If you haven't seen this 2D animated movie. You must see "Titan A.E.".
Sasaki Kojiro: I’m a loser... AND I’M PROUD OF IT! ⚔️🆚🔱
This movie was the biggest fail at disney animation. After this movie they didn't do 2d animation anymore with some exceptions (princess and frog, winnie the pooh). 3D animation was cheaper and they always bring more money. The income wasn't even enough to cover the production budget
Fun fact there was going to be a sequel to this movie but because this one didn't do well in fact most people hated it they canceled the sequel ps the way you clap is adorable
This has a lot of similarities to another Disney movie called " Shipwreched" because they're both based of the same stories... so the adult tv show "Black Sails". Love this one.... pretty sure I got to see this one in theatres. Another semi space adventure that's good is "Titan A.E.". I'd also recommend "Quest for Camelot" and "Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within".
This movie is so good!!! The animation is fantastic and the story is so touching! Totally deserves a sequel (it was planned to have one but since it was a failure on box office it was canned)
I thought you should know that the Dr. Hired the crew not the Captain. She said so and that she didnt trust them when she took the map and placed it in the safe 😄
That song is a banger?
Hear the Italian version "Ci sono anch'io" singeb by famous and very good singer Max Pezzali
THAT is a banger.
This movie is so great, and SO underrated!
This is my favorite disney movie.I ve watched it at least 10 times already.Part 2 is expected.