I love Super Mario Odyssey. I started a new save file today. I remember first seeing the game and watching the trailer on my dad's phone in 2016. I got so hyped over it, and even got it in 2016. When the game came out, I watched a bunch of walkthroughs on it on my TV on Amazon. It should have gotten DLC.
nearly cried when i went to peaches castle and looked up like in 64 and got the moon for it with the star texture and sound... What amazing fan service
Mario Odyssey is my personal favorite video game of all time, and this video perfectly highlighted why. It feels like a true adventure in a way that almost no other game does, with so many sights to see and things to play around with, all while feeling like a true celebration of Mario. Even the little things work to help craft the experience, and to this day I find new small details and easter eggs. The thing you mentioned about seeing a desert in the background and how that’s a callback to the “World 2” of most Mario games was amazing, I had never noticed that lmao
Great video!! I love odyssey as it’s the perfect balance of giving you linear levels and exploration something evidently missing from a 2D game. Still can’t wait for wonder though 😊
Well, technically, there is a way to get hints for where the Purple Coins are. But it's locked behind amiibo! Why couldn't they just let you pay coins to reveal their locations, like they do with Power Moons - those get THREE NPCs to help you! But with Purple Coins, it's only amiibo!
I really love this game! I've played this game so much because of casually playing a ton and speedrunning it! I also love how you have flawless movement, you can't stay in a level after collecting a moon, you have all these references without them being shoved down your throat in a bad way! This is and potentially always will be my favourite video game ever! Great video, man!
I thought the moon system was well thought out for people of all ages and skill levels to enjoy. If a 6 year old is playing, they can still get some easy moons. I don't have a problem with it because they offer plenty of moons with higher difficulties. I don't think it was due to laziness.
exactly and people complaining that it was a 'poor reward system' because you get the same reward for getting 1 hard moon vs 1 easy moon confused me, like in 64 you could do the exact same and i've NEVER seen it brought up at a point against that, it honestly feels like a minor nitpick to me, but it does ofc come down to preference I just think Odyssey does not get it half as easy as 64 does. (still love 64 tho)
Wow! 🤩 I never thought that this game was that great! 😊 Even though it's been over 7 years since the game came out, I still haven't been able to complete it yet. I just never took the time to really play it and finish it. I will make sure to definitely play and finish the game, if possible for me. I really do love your narration of each video that you do. :) Especially this one! It makes the game even more spectacular and alive. Thank you for creating a video about how awesome this game really is! 😊
its crazy that the game is already 6 years old it still feels like its just came out, i'm honestly having a hard time deciding if either this game or 64 is my favorite mario game,
Got this game all the way back in July of 2019, decided to put the Switch in the dock, and seeing the introduction to the Cascade Kingdom on my kingdom made my jaw dropped. Mind you, this was before lunch, and by the time after dinner I had finished the Metro Kingdom. I restarted the game 4 times because of how fun it was and got nearly 800 Moons. Genuinely one of the greatest experiences I’ve ever had in my entire life, along with Wonder.
I absolutely love this game that in fact I 💯 percent this game, my only gripes with the game were the amount of moons and Luigi's Balloon World on the required task just to make Luigi's balloons golden. I still haven't finished that as of yet and am currently working on it, but yes I give this game a 9/10.
the cappy mechanic nailed it. its not too complicated like fluid in sunshine, or too limited like luma in galaxy. even after finished this game, I just simply astonished by how many trick jump is possible while watching so many of odyssey challenge videos.
The level of impact 2017 brought us especially from Nintendo really hit hard because 2015 and 2016 was a really tough time to be a nintendo fan. Because of this I can’t help but be emotional with BOTW and Mario Odyssey
I’m still bummed that the Cloud and Ruined Kingdom weren’t fleshed out to their potential. As I stated in a comment, it makes this game feel a tad incomplete to me in a strange way. Like if you’re not going to fully realize such a cool idea (Ruined Kingdom) don’t blueball me by adding it
I had a burnout working for a year, after finishing my game education. Then for 4 years i didnt play any games. Never played mario before. Picked it up about 2 years ago and felt like a child all the way through. Whatever it does. If you are really craving games it even makes you feel the same things that games make you feel when you are 6 years old. And that's why it is great. It is unexplainable. Mario odyssey is just pure fun. Its perfectly paced. Perfectly designed, has perfect art. It is the perfect game.
This Game is such a masterpiece and also financial success, what are the chances Nintendo would give us a sequel? The only time they did that was with Galaxy 2! I‘ve been waiting my whole life for Galaxy 3 which will sadly never happen, but Odyssey 2 could be realistic 🤞
I just beat the metro kingdom and I love how you have to explore and platform to get the music festival running and I love the ending of it So I can say metro kingdom is my favourite kingdom in Super Mario odessey
I don't think people realize is that having so many easier and even trivial moons helps make the game much more accessible to a younger audience. One of my friends has a younger sibling, like less than 10 years old, who loves to play Odyssey and I feel like without those easier moons, he would have had a much harder time getting into the game.
I played Sunshine when I was like 5 and had a Blast. I never knew nor cared if the game even had an ending so I just played in the levels my older sister and father had unlocked. By Odyssey stringing you along the story, it actually makes you engage with the game less, because they want to make sure everyone can see the credits but young kids do not care about beating games and very rarely do I see a kid put a game down out of frustration, they'll either just find something else to do in the game, play a different game, or *gasp* ask their PARENTS for help? That's why simulators and tycoons with no end goal are so popular Roblox and Fortnite, kids just like running around in colorful, toy-like environments, touching stuff and seeing what happens. Their inherent goal isn't to reach the end of a narrative unlike Teens and Adults, it's to do whatever interests them in a virtual space even if that means they only get access to the first world. They don't even know that there IS anything beyond the first world.
I remember 7 year old me playing this in the hospital after my surgery, even after my surgery I would play this game every weekend for 8 hours a day and finished it. Best Mario game ever
@@Eliormier Let's examine the core tenets of these games and see which areas are better in each. 1. move-set 3D Mario games focus on a consistent move-set from Mario. Odyssey's movement is closest to Galaxy's, but significantly nerfs Mario's long jump and wall jump to make players use his cap abilities more. While Mario has a larger move-set in Odyssey because of Cappy, the nerf and subsequent lack of demand for Mario's other moves sets Odyssey back. I hate what they did to Mario's move-set, but to be extra fair, I'll say that this is a tie, and subjective. So, for move-set, it's 0-0. 2. abilities All Mario games use special temporary abilities to increase Mario's move-set or give him a new way to move entirely. In Odyssey, this is done via "possessions." However, the lack of added complexity of possessions in Odyssey sets them back, compared to Galaxy which's abilities added complexity and were equally easy to use (cloud Mario and rock Mario come to mind). Spring Mario from Galaxy 1 (and 2, I think) is an example of Galaxy doing "possession" style abilities better than Odyssey. Compared to Frog Mario, Spring Mario requires more input and thought to control, and allows for unique challenges. 3. Graphics / Aesthetic Grouping these together. Despite being many years apart, Odyssey looks very similar to Galaxy 2 if you ignore the lack of fidelity the Wii was capable of. While it is subjective which style you prefer, I do think that Galaxy 1 and 2 have a more consistent and appealing aesthetic. 4. Story Mario games don't have complex stories, but Galaxy 1's story is far more interesting and engaging than Odyssey. This is not really that important, as "get back the princess" is all the story Mario really needs. 5. Level Design The level design in Galaxy is superior in every way to Odyssey. Instead of turning red coins into "Moons" to give the player a never-ending positive feedback loop, Galaxy 1/2 created dozens of unique worlds with 1-4 objectives, which change each time you play them. The worlds in Galaxy are usually interesting, while the worlds in Odyssey are mostly boring, with a few exceptions (the food kingdom). Even the end-game content is boring. It could have been mid-game Galaxy 2. The majority of content in Odyssey is recycled over and over again, and is often the most tedious and unengaging "gameplay" imaginable. Only about 10-20% of Galaxy is recycled content, and it always is upgraded in some way. 6. Difficulty Neither games are particularly challenging, even to 100%. However, Odyssey was clearly designed for children to beat with ease, while Galaxy 1/2 were meant to be playable by children, but not easy to beat per say. For example, the boss battles in Odyssey are painfully easy. In order to make them fun, you have to intentionally try to speedrun them. Imagine how much better it would have been if, for the 3rd Broodal fight, you had to fight the two Broodals you just beat at the same time, in the same ring? That would be interesting. But, no.
I’m honestly surprised this game is as well loved as it is. I thought most of the moons were really repetitive and simplistic. Also I’m not a big fan of the transformations, Mario is way more fun to control than any of them, I’d rather they added unique movement and attack abilities to Mario’s base moveset instead of make us play as much less mobile and dynamic characters.
Best mario game ever made! And on the switch the best mario game not even close! Wonder might do what odyssey did to 3D mario it made it perfect! It's been years since Odyssey released I wouldn't be surprised if a sequel has been in the works and I am not ready for what the heck Nintendo has for a sequel to one of the best games they have ever made period! Love ur videos I've seen all your other 3D Mario videos! I really wonder what the game industry would be without a red plumber (and a knight with a legendary sword) this video was amazing! ❤
Everytime i see a clip of getting that last multimoon im reminded of how i felt when i got it, i was so bad at the game that i had been playing on and off for years when i finally did it on a random school night. I loved it and hated it at the same time
It's great to see that gamers like Mariomikester truly understand games like Super Mario Odyssey. The complaints of "long-time fans" do not change the fact that their preferences are the real issue with this game. I can think of many ways that this game is a masterpiece. Collecting Power Moons may have been repetitive, but that's consistency and it keeps the action going, much like traditional collectibles in previous 3D Mario games. Although some activities to obtain them felt just as repetitive, but they still kept the action consistent without overwhelming gamers with RANDOM content. The game is still diverse, but not overboard. The Capture System may have limited Mario's actions, yet that was to emphasize clarity. Throwing Cappy onto almost anything could turn a creature or Bowser's weaponry into a useful tool to get through a certain obstacle or solve a problem (like stacking Goombas and using a Pokio bird to reach higher areas). Plus, you can dispose of them afterward and keep playing as Mario, so it's not like you're GLUED to the Capture System. Saying that it "limits Mario's mobility" is illogical. The real challenge should've been overcoming the change in mobility and skill set to use it to the best advantage. Even the courses in each Kingdom complement the mechanics, which is why each locale is designed a certain way. Plus, it feels more fun to pull off Cap Dive Jumps in these Kingdom Courses. Honestly, it takes the right attitude and perspective to see that Super Mario Odyssey is a harmless, user-friendly, fun game that is only regarded as a Masterpiece because of how well-polished it is on its OWN merits. I enjoyed this video and thank you for your time...a CAPtivating one. 🤣🤣🤣
I didn't think the purple coins at 12:38 were unfair at all, if they wanted to convey that the gap was dangerous they would not have placed the parallel walls on the drop. To me, the designers were giving a clear hint to wall slide downwards to find something, then walljump up to get back.
I hope in mario oddysey 2, after the story mode you can do the paintings category like 64. You get the stars in paintings and finish challenges like "Kill 50 goombas", etc
Best Mario game ever by far and the best part isn't even just playing through it normally. The best part (in my opinion) is speedrunning this game its a phenomenal game to speedrun and its fun to speedrun it.
Mario Odyssey was the first game I played on the Nintendo Switch, and what I remember about playing it for the first time was being able to play that would on the Wii U like it’s a portable game. Looking back, it makes me sad that it’s been 7 years since Nintendo gave us a 3D Mario game. Nintendo, plz give us an open world Mario game instead of Mario parties and Mario sports.
When I did Darker Side, I skipped the whole Pokey Bird section by using the Glydon in the Fork section. I'd like to say it was an accident, but as soon as I saw that I could skip it, I did.
I was a kid when this game came out i remember tax return my mom bought me the switch and she only had enough for one game I went with Mario over zelda... Take me back man
That is some bold assumption, saying that the core audience prefers 64 and Sunshine... I largely prefer 2d ones, like SMB3, SMW or SMBW ("Wonder" in case it isnt clear), my first Mario game was "the first super mario bros", so i've been around for long enough to have criteria on the matter... While Odyssey is hands down THE BEST 3D game, both 3d World and Galaxy take 64 (which is grace but age disgracefully, was my fav 3d mario game till i finally started replaying it last week), and specially Sunshine, which is a rushed, borderline unfinished mess, and the worst 3d Mario game by a huge margin. Cause while 3D World and Galaxy play it safe with the more linear structure, they dont have bad levels at all, like 64 and Sunshine do. So as a core Mario audience member, i say your statement is little more than an opinion, and some some established fact. And i get where it comes from, because im a resident evil fan aswell, and the "core ones" are the ones you can speed run, with no interruptions be it from chapter systems, too many playable QTEs, setpieces and so on, but the games where you can map optimal routes. And still does not apply to Mario, because Galaxy is the second best 3d Mario, and 3dworld + bowsers fury is the third, with Bowser's fury being as good if not better than both Odyssey and Galaxy. 64 i love, but unless you're playing it on its original hardware... It's an absolute mess. Sunshine is just not great (for a 3d mario game, which means it's better than most of the games that release the same year)
I really liked this game, I can't help but wonder what if the earlier ideas of the game being Mario traveling through a multi-verse had been stuck to. I think some of the weirder worlds like the Luncheon Kingdom, or the Nightmare before Hat-mas Kingdom or complete genre shifts with places like the Ruined Kingdom are evidence of that idea.
@@againsttheleftandright4065 First off, this is not Galaxy. Second, you didn’t play the post game. Third, nobody agrees with you. Fourth, it adds everything people wanted in a Mario game. Fifth, shut up.
Please make a video about luigis mansions 2. I remember you had a poll about making either this or odyssey and dark moon lost. I dont know if that means that you are not gonna make a video about luigis mansion or that you will just make it later but i am pretty sure a lot of people would like to see your insights on the game.
Sadly, in my recent experience playing the game for the first time, I found it far from perfect. I think the level with the dinosaur soured me a bit from the start. Felt gimmicky and dumb, like it was supposed to be a big wow moment, but from a gameplay standpoint, it felt very inconsequential. That was barely a level and then it was over. Was also the first level to introduce the 2D segments, which are cute, but always took me out of the experience and just seemed like an unserious addition. I couldn't shake the feeling for a long time that it didn't really feel like a Mario game. It felt weirdly like a Sega game or something from some other lesser platform developer. It has a ton of wonderful and charming moments, but it didn't have that sublime feeling you get from top notch Mario gameplay. The game is too easy, too basically designed, and often doesn't give a strong feeling of accomplishment. The dialogue writing is uninspired, bland, and seems geared entirely towards kids--no cleverness, no funniness. The Broodals are also terrible and annoying. For me, Wonder is the Mario masterpiece on the Switch. Possibly the best two player experience I've ever had. While some might feel the wonder seed segments are also gimmicky, I found them surprising and entertaining till the end. And virtually the whole game puts you into that sublime Mario mindset, where you feel like you're playing something that is just better than 99% of other video games. Though it is quite fun, I barely ever got that feeling playing Odyssey.
That's exactly how I felt, The game feels like some C-Tier platformer with Mario skin stretched over it. And I disagree about the game feeling like it's made by Sega. Even Sega and Square Enix do a better job of making their games charming. Game quality aside, Sonic Superstars, Super Monkey Ball and even Balan Wonderworld are miles more charming than Odyssey.
Im convinced nintendo has been chained the the top #1 spot in gaming, really no matter what sony does they will never beat nintendo, just because of how deep nintendo is rooted in many people's childhoods. For me atleast, nintendo has been in my life ever since i started remembering memories lol, they have been everything for me, and still are. Even if you call it parasocial, i dont care, i love nintendo, and i always will.
Tbh Super Mario Odyssey is too easy even for Mario game standards. Most of the moons are just sitting there waiting for you to collect them and that’s not good. I hope the next game is more challenging.
it would be perfect if it was even a little bit difficult. its not reusing mechanics wich at first seems like a positive but in the end doesnt let the devs create difficult areas. thats why new donk city is the best area. because it makes up for the lack of difficulty with its terrain
You know a game is good when even just moving around is fun.
YES
The balloon mini game is something else
Which is why I dislike Odyssey
@@stomboyyuffie Sorry that you didn’t like it, at the end of the day you can’t please everyone.
I love Super Mario Odyssey. I started a new save file today. I remember first seeing the game and watching the trailer on my dad's phone in 2016. I got so hyped over it, and even got it in 2016. When the game came out, I watched a bunch of walkthroughs on it on my TV on Amazon. It should have gotten DLC.
nearly cried when i went to peaches castle and looked up like in 64 and got the moon for it with the star texture and sound... What amazing fan service
I totally forgot about looking up at first glance. I never owned mario 64. But I sure loved it and memorable
@user-hm8mt2ql6nbro shut up do you just go on this video to shut on people's fun? You're pathetic
Mario Odyssey is my personal favorite video game of all time, and this video perfectly highlighted why. It feels like a true adventure in a way that almost no other game does, with so many sights to see and things to play around with, all while feeling like a true celebration of Mario. Even the little things work to help craft the experience, and to this day I find new small details and easter eggs. The thing you mentioned about seeing a desert in the background and how that’s a callback to the “World 2” of most Mario games was amazing, I had never noticed that lmao
I hope Wonder ends up turning out like this installment did. Strong ideas, Fun theming, Fun Level design, Fun Gameplay, Just Plain Fun
Same.
It’s kinda like what Into the Spider Verse and Across the Spider Verse did with the movie industry.
Good graphics
@@michaelmayers3622 Find some grass to touch
@@autismandgaming4532 i think you're just being rude for the sake of being rude
I can't believe this game is turning 6 years old this year. Wonder better turn out like this installment did.
It will!
This aged beautifully
@@Jonny312. Yup, and I'm glad of it. :)
I am almost 40 years old. This is the best Mario Game ever. This game blew my mind
I really hope they make a sequel to this game, everything combined just made it a fantastic title, although it’s hard to top perfection.
Great video!! I love odyssey as it’s the perfect balance of giving you linear levels and exploration something evidently missing from a 2D game. Still can’t wait for wonder though 😊
Great retrospective! Made me want to play the game again
Well, technically, there is a way to get hints for where the Purple Coins are.
But it's locked behind amiibo! Why couldn't they just let you pay coins to reveal their locations, like they do with Power Moons - those get THREE NPCs to help you! But with Purple Coins, it's only amiibo!
The ending of Odyssey makes me want a Mushroom Kingdom Warriors game so badly
I just got this game and I love love every minute of it. It rewards your curiosity to explore, which I love even more.
I really love this game! I've played this game so much because of casually playing a ton and speedrunning it! I also love how you have flawless movement, you can't stay in a level after collecting a moon, you have all these references without them being shoved down your throat in a bad way! This is and potentially always will be my favourite video game ever! Great video, man!
This was very fun to watch, Mr. Mikester. Keep up the work bro you are a big inspiration for me
This is about as perfect as video games get.
Agreed. I'm currently making a 2D version of it.
@@mohamedhamis853be careful, the Nintendo ninjas could strike at any time.
@@guywitcurlyhairOn scratch
@@mohamedhamis853they’d want the head of an elementary schooler who drew Mario in art class you’re never safe
Really?!?
I thought the moon system was well thought out for people of all ages and skill levels to enjoy. If a 6 year old is playing, they can still get some easy moons. I don't have a problem with it because they offer plenty of moons with higher difficulties. I don't think it was due to laziness.
exactly and people complaining that it was a 'poor reward system' because you get the same reward for getting 1 hard moon vs 1 easy moon confused me, like in 64 you could do the exact same and i've NEVER seen it brought up at a point against that, it honestly feels like a minor nitpick to me, but it does ofc come down to preference I just think Odyssey does not get it half as easy as 64 does. (still love 64 tho)
Wow! 🤩 I never thought that this game was that great! 😊 Even though it's been over 7 years since the game came out, I still haven't been able to complete it yet. I just never took the time to really play it and finish it. I will make sure to definitely play and finish the game, if possible for me. I really do love your narration of each video that you do. :) Especially this one! It makes the game even more spectacular and alive. Thank you for creating a video about how awesome this game really is! 😊
its crazy that the game is already 6 years old it still feels like its just came out,
i'm honestly having a hard time deciding if either this game or 64 is my favorite mario game,
Doesnt matter whats your favorite its whats fun about it
Got this game all the way back in July of 2019, decided to put the Switch in the dock, and seeing the introduction to the Cascade Kingdom on my kingdom made my jaw dropped.
Mind you, this was before lunch, and by the time after dinner I had finished the Metro Kingdom.
I restarted the game 4 times because of how fun it was and got nearly 800 Moons.
Genuinely one of the greatest experiences I’ve ever had in my entire life, along with Wonder.
You didn't even talk about the amazing baloon hiding dlc! Its so fun!
This is a really incredible video. I really appreciate the effort you have put in it.
I havent watched the video, but my guess is the amazing concept of being able to throw a cap and become things, its just amazing
I absolutely love this game that in fact I 💯 percent this game, my only gripes with the game were the amount of moons and Luigi's Balloon World on the required task just to make Luigi's balloons golden. I still haven't finished that as of yet and am currently working on it, but yes I give this game a 9/10.
the cappy mechanic nailed it. its not too complicated like fluid in sunshine, or too limited like luma in galaxy.
even after finished this game, I just simply astonished by how many trick jump is possible while watching so many of odyssey challenge videos.
I like how Mario resorts to fighting Bowser via punching him in the dick
The level of impact 2017 brought us especially from Nintendo really hit hard because 2015 and 2016 was a really tough time to be a nintendo fan.
Because of this I can’t help but be emotional with BOTW and Mario Odyssey
One of my favourite games! I honestly love how everything is designed and all the movement options
I can't wait for the day when I first get to play this game. It's been such a wonder
I’m still bummed that the Cloud and Ruined Kingdom weren’t fleshed out to their potential. As I stated in a comment, it makes this game feel a tad incomplete to me in a strange way. Like if you’re not going to fully realize such a cool idea (Ruined Kingdom) don’t blueball me by adding it
I had a burnout working for a year, after finishing my game education. Then for 4 years i didnt play any games.
Never played mario before. Picked it up about 2 years ago and felt like a child all the way through.
Whatever it does. If you are really craving games it even makes you feel the same things that games make you feel when you are 6 years old. And that's why it is great.
It is unexplainable. Mario odyssey is just pure fun. Its perfectly paced. Perfectly designed, has perfect art. It is the perfect game.
This Game is such a masterpiece and also financial success, what are the chances Nintendo would give us a sequel? The only time they did that was with Galaxy 2! I‘ve been waiting my whole life for Galaxy 3 which will sadly never happen, but Odyssey 2 could be realistic 🤞
havent seen the video yet but i know that its gonna be a good one
Was it?
Babe, wake up. Mariomikester uploaded another 3D Mario retrospective!
I'm playing this game on and off for the first time. I'm gonna come back to this video and watch it when I'm done
I hope that we get a "Super Mario Odyssey 2" on the next console but knowing nintendo now days it looks unlikely
Only thing I didn’t like about the game was not being able to wall kick out of a long jump like in 64. Other than that tiny thing, perfect game
I just beat the metro kingdom and I love how you have to explore and platform to get the music festival running and I love the ending of it
So I can say metro kingdom is my favourite kingdom in Super Mario odessey
when you leave the controller alone for a little he falls asleep and dreams about pasta 🍝😌
*Then outta nowhere, in New Donk City especially, a pigeon lands on your face, lol!*
That's been a thing since Mario 64 1996.
I don't think people realize is that having so many easier and even trivial moons helps make the game much more accessible to a younger audience. One of my friends has a younger sibling, like less than 10 years old, who loves to play Odyssey and I feel like without those easier moons, he would have had a much harder time getting into the game.
When i was 10 i could beat smb1 and smb3 .. that kid just needs to git gud 😂
@@SarahConnor618 What part of "less than 10" did you not read? 😂
I played Sunshine when I was like 5 and had a Blast. I never knew nor cared if the game even had an ending so I just played in the levels my older sister and father had unlocked. By Odyssey stringing you along the story, it actually makes you engage with the game less, because they want to make sure everyone can see the credits but young kids do not care about beating games and very rarely do I see a kid put a game down out of frustration, they'll either just find something else to do in the game, play a different game, or *gasp* ask their PARENTS for help?
That's why simulators and tycoons with no end goal are so popular Roblox and Fortnite, kids just like running around in colorful, toy-like environments, touching stuff and seeing what happens. Their inherent goal isn't to reach the end of a narrative unlike Teens and Adults, it's to do whatever interests them in a virtual space even if that means they only get access to the first world. They don't even know that there IS anything beyond the first world.
@@prestige8477 you do make a good point. Odyssey being so easy is my only real problem with it.
I remember 7 year old me playing this in the hospital after my surgery, even after my surgery I would play this game every weekend for 8 hours a day and finished it. Best Mario game ever
Mario Galaxy is way better than this.
@@againsttheleftandright4065Nope. Fight me.
@@Eliormier
Let's examine the core tenets of these games and see which areas are better in each.
1. move-set
3D Mario games focus on a consistent move-set from Mario. Odyssey's movement is closest to Galaxy's, but significantly nerfs Mario's long jump and wall jump to make players use his cap abilities more. While Mario has a larger move-set in Odyssey because of Cappy, the nerf and subsequent lack of demand for Mario's other moves sets Odyssey back. I hate what they did to Mario's move-set, but to be extra fair, I'll say that this is a tie, and subjective. So, for move-set, it's 0-0.
2. abilities
All Mario games use special temporary abilities to increase Mario's move-set or give him a new way to move entirely. In Odyssey, this is done via "possessions." However, the lack of added complexity of possessions in Odyssey sets them back, compared to Galaxy which's abilities added complexity and were equally easy to use (cloud Mario and rock Mario come to mind). Spring Mario from Galaxy 1 (and 2, I think) is an example of Galaxy doing "possession" style abilities better than Odyssey. Compared to Frog Mario, Spring Mario requires more input and thought to control, and allows for unique challenges.
3. Graphics / Aesthetic
Grouping these together. Despite being many years apart, Odyssey looks very similar to Galaxy 2 if you ignore the lack of fidelity the Wii was capable of. While it is subjective which style you prefer, I do think that Galaxy 1 and 2 have a more consistent and appealing aesthetic.
4. Story
Mario games don't have complex stories, but Galaxy 1's story is far more interesting and engaging than Odyssey. This is not really that important, as "get back the princess" is all the story Mario really needs.
5. Level Design
The level design in Galaxy is superior in every way to Odyssey. Instead of turning red coins into "Moons" to give the player a never-ending positive feedback loop, Galaxy 1/2 created dozens of unique worlds with 1-4 objectives, which change each time you play them. The worlds in Galaxy are usually interesting, while the worlds in Odyssey are mostly boring, with a few exceptions (the food kingdom). Even the end-game content is boring. It could have been mid-game Galaxy 2. The majority of content in Odyssey is recycled over and over again, and is often the most tedious and unengaging "gameplay" imaginable. Only about 10-20% of Galaxy is recycled content, and it always is upgraded in some way.
6. Difficulty
Neither games are particularly challenging, even to 100%. However, Odyssey was clearly designed for children to beat with ease, while Galaxy 1/2 were meant to be playable by children, but not easy to beat per say. For example, the boss battles in Odyssey are painfully easy. In order to make them fun, you have to intentionally try to speedrun them. Imagine how much better it would have been if, for the 3rd Broodal fight, you had to fight the two Broodals you just beat at the same time, in the same ring? That would be interesting. But, no.
@@againsttheleftandright4065Just because a game isn’t challenging doesn’t make it a bad game. Shows that you’re a gank.
@@Eliormier
Already responded to this one. Without challenge, games are boring. If your game is boring to most gamers, it is not a good game.
My favorite Mario game is Super Mario 3D World. That game is amazing!!!
Great video! I wish I could play this game
I NEVER NOTICED HOW SMOOTH BOWSER’S HAIRCUT IS IN THIS GAME, MF FLY AS HELL
I’m honestly surprised this game is as well loved as it is. I thought most of the moons were really repetitive and simplistic. Also I’m not a big fan of the transformations, Mario is way more fun to control than any of them, I’d rather they added unique movement and attack abilities to Mario’s base moveset instead of make us play as much less mobile and dynamic characters.
Best mario game ever made! And on the switch the best mario game not even close! Wonder might do what odyssey did to 3D mario it made it perfect! It's been years since Odyssey released I wouldn't be surprised if a sequel has been in the works and I am not ready for what the heck Nintendo has for a sequel to one of the best games they have ever made period! Love ur videos I've seen all your other 3D Mario videos! I really wonder what the game industry would be without a red plumber (and a knight with a legendary sword) this video was amazing! ❤
4:46 but i also turned into a frog in a nightmare like a few years ago
Everytime i see a clip of getting that last multimoon im reminded of how i felt when i got it, i was so bad at the game that i had been playing on and off for years when i finally did it on a random school night. I loved it and hated it at the same time
Its so wild that we are now at the point where we can say: mario oddysey retrospective.
It's great to see that gamers like Mariomikester truly understand games like Super Mario Odyssey. The complaints of "long-time fans" do not change the fact that their preferences are the real issue with this game. I can think of many ways that this game is a masterpiece.
Collecting Power Moons may have been repetitive, but that's consistency and it keeps the action going, much like traditional collectibles in previous 3D Mario games. Although some activities to obtain them felt just as repetitive, but they still kept the action consistent without overwhelming gamers with RANDOM content. The game is still diverse, but not overboard.
The Capture System may have limited Mario's actions, yet that was to emphasize clarity. Throwing Cappy onto almost anything could turn a creature or Bowser's weaponry into a useful tool to get through a certain obstacle or solve a problem (like stacking Goombas and using a Pokio bird to reach higher areas). Plus, you can dispose of them afterward and keep playing as Mario, so it's not like you're GLUED to the Capture System. Saying that it "limits Mario's mobility" is illogical. The real challenge should've been overcoming the change in mobility and skill set to use it to the best advantage.
Even the courses in each Kingdom complement the mechanics, which is why each locale is designed a certain way. Plus, it feels more fun to pull off Cap Dive Jumps in these Kingdom Courses.
Honestly, it takes the right attitude and perspective to see that Super Mario Odyssey is a harmless, user-friendly, fun game that is only regarded as a Masterpiece because of how well-polished it is on its OWN merits. I enjoyed this video and thank you for your time...a CAPtivating one. 🤣🤣🤣
I didn't think the purple coins at 12:38 were unfair at all, if they wanted to convey that the gap was dangerous they would not have placed the parallel walls on the drop.
To me, the designers were giving a clear hint to wall slide downwards to find something, then walljump up to get back.
Crazy that it is one of the few switch games not receiving paid DLC.
You have an excellent way of presenting information I was captivated from start to finish! Thank you. ❤
I hope in mario oddysey 2, after the story mode you can do the paintings category like 64. You get the stars in paintings and finish challenges like "Kill 50 goombas", etc
ngl i full on started sobbing when I finished darker side for the first time...
Wonder is great game, but not on par with Odyssey. Simply masterpiece. Watching this video brings back so many beautiful memories
Hey bro. i think your video's are heavily underrated and should at least pick up 600k views a video. I really enjoy watching them so keep it up!
Best Mario game ever by far and the best part isn't even just playing through it normally. The best part (in my opinion) is speedrunning this game its a phenomenal game to speedrun and its fun to speedrun it.
Super Mario Odyssey is one of the the prettiest games my eyes have ever had the pleasure of looking upon❤
Can’t believe this fucking game is still full price.
Believe it or not it’s still a full game
Seems like they mirrored their innovative approach to the original Super Mario World when the SNES first came out.
Mario Odyssey is the Best Mario game
I love this game
The answer is everything
Mario Odyssey was the first game I played on the Nintendo Switch, and what I remember about playing it for the first time was being able to play that would on the Wii U like it’s a portable game. Looking back, it makes me sad that it’s been 7 years since Nintendo gave us a 3D Mario game. Nintendo, plz give us an open world Mario game instead of Mario parties and Mario sports.
When I did Darker Side, I skipped the whole Pokey Bird section by using the Glydon in the Fork section. I'd like to say it was an accident, but as soon as I saw that I could skip it, I did.
I was a kid when this game came out i remember tax return my mom bought me the switch and she only had enough for one game I went with Mario over zelda... Take me back man
This game and gta 5 are the only games i've 100% 2 times.
That is some bold assumption, saying that the core audience prefers 64 and Sunshine... I largely prefer 2d ones, like SMB3, SMW or SMBW ("Wonder" in case it isnt clear), my first Mario game was "the first super mario bros", so i've been around for long enough to have criteria on the matter... While Odyssey is hands down THE BEST 3D game, both 3d World and Galaxy take 64 (which is grace but age disgracefully, was my fav 3d mario game till i finally started replaying it last week), and specially Sunshine, which is a rushed, borderline unfinished mess, and the worst 3d Mario game by a huge margin. Cause while 3D World and Galaxy play it safe with the more linear structure, they dont have bad levels at all, like 64 and Sunshine do.
So as a core Mario audience member, i say your statement is little more than an opinion, and some some established fact. And i get where it comes from, because im a resident evil fan aswell, and the "core ones" are the ones you can speed run, with no interruptions be it from chapter systems, too many playable QTEs, setpieces and so on, but the games where you can map optimal routes. And still does not apply to Mario, because Galaxy is the second best 3d Mario, and 3dworld + bowsers fury is the third, with Bowser's fury being as good if not better than both Odyssey and Galaxy.
64 i love, but unless you're playing it on its original hardware... It's an absolute mess. Sunshine is just not great (for a 3d mario game, which means it's better than most of the games that release the same year)
I really liked this game, I can't help but wonder what if the earlier ideas of the game being Mario traveling through a multi-verse had been stuck to. I think some of the weirder worlds like the Luncheon Kingdom, or the Nightmare before Hat-mas Kingdom or complete genre shifts with places like the Ruined Kingdom are evidence of that idea.
0:13 did zelda not release on wii u first?
No. It was released the same day the switch did.
nope it was on the WIIU before@@This_is_Phil
Your videos are amazing
Wonder is prob a 2d version of Oddysey. Like Cappy gave many power up possibilities so willl prob the wonder have a power up / gimmick in each stage.
Welp time to replay this again
I like the trapdoor easter egg from super mario 64. The fan service.
No game is perfect, but as a guy who played Mario Odyssey all I can it is a damn masterpiece.
It's not a masterpiece. It's a very dumbed-down Mario Galaxy without the original environments and gravity mechanics.
@@againsttheleftandright4065 First off, this is not Galaxy. Second, you didn’t play the post game. Third, nobody agrees with you. Fourth, it adds everything people wanted in a Mario game. Fifth, shut up.
@@Eliormier
You're literally 12 years old lmao
@@againsttheleftandright4065 Well, so far this is the only 3D Mario game I have ever played so I wouldn't know.
@@againsttheleftandright4065 Again, SHUT UP. Stop making fun of me. You’re a living hat hater.
The 6th mainline 3D Mario game? What? Are we forgetting about Super Mario 3D Land...?
This is a f*cking banger that puts all the other 3D Mario and many 2D Mario games to shame in comparison
Please make a video about luigis mansions 2. I remember you had a poll about making either this or odyssey and dark moon lost. I dont know if that means that you are not gonna make a video about luigis mansion or that you will just make it later but i am pretty sure a lot of people would like to see your insights on the game.
dark moon video is coming soon!
@@Mariomikester Thank you very much for replying man! I look forward to watching it
I wish for collecting purple coins cappy gave you some sort of purple coin tracker that would work similar to botw’s shrine locater.
In my opinion….. its the best game ever made.
This video has make me cry
You had to be there. to get the hype
Mario Odyssey is Into the Spider Verse while Mario Wonder is Across the Spider Verse
Yesterday i completed the game
That was in a new save that i made on that day
Best Mario game I agree. But I have only 878 power moon. After all these years still got this 100 jumps and 100 volley ball I haven't get through.
The fog is coming!
idk if i should get this or mario maker 2 😂
I Wonder what is the next 3d mario game it will be for the future? 🤔
I work at Nintendo so I can tell you a little info on it
The next 3d Mario game is going to be open world
@@ppo1502okay prove it
@@NovaJR9 wdym prove it ?
@@ppo1502man you don't work at nintendo
@ppo1502 stop the cap man.
Do a 3ds retrospective video
Sadly, in my recent experience playing the game for the first time, I found it far from perfect. I think the level with the dinosaur soured me a bit from the start. Felt gimmicky and dumb, like it was supposed to be a big wow moment, but from a gameplay standpoint, it felt very inconsequential. That was barely a level and then it was over. Was also the first level to introduce the 2D segments, which are cute, but always took me out of the experience and just seemed like an unserious addition.
I couldn't shake the feeling for a long time that it didn't really feel like a Mario game. It felt weirdly like a Sega game or something from some other lesser platform developer. It has a ton of wonderful and charming moments, but it didn't have that sublime feeling you get from top notch Mario gameplay. The game is too easy, too basically designed, and often doesn't give a strong feeling of accomplishment. The dialogue writing is uninspired, bland, and seems geared entirely towards kids--no cleverness, no funniness. The Broodals are also terrible and annoying.
For me, Wonder is the Mario masterpiece on the Switch. Possibly the best two player experience I've ever had. While some might feel the wonder seed segments are also gimmicky, I found them surprising and entertaining till the end. And virtually the whole game puts you into that sublime Mario mindset, where you feel like you're playing something that is just better than 99% of other video games. Though it is quite fun, I barely ever got that feeling playing Odyssey.
That's exactly how I felt, The game feels like some C-Tier platformer with Mario skin stretched over it. And I disagree about the game feeling like it's made by Sega. Even Sega and Square Enix do a better job of making their games charming. Game quality aside, Sonic Superstars, Super Monkey Ball and even Balan Wonderworld are miles more charming than Odyssey.
I think something's really wrong with your mind.
Im convinced nintendo has been chained the the top #1 spot in gaming, really no matter what sony does they will never beat nintendo, just because of how deep nintendo is rooted in many people's childhoods.
For me atleast, nintendo has been in my life ever since i started remembering memories lol, they have been everything for me, and still are.
Even if you call it parasocial, i dont care, i love nintendo, and i always will.
0:12 BOTW was not new, it was on the wii U
No, Breath of the Wild was released on the same day for both the Switch and Wii U. (March 3rd, 2017)
19:50
Is there any Mario game that this channel won't call 'perfect'?
Tbh Super Mario Odyssey is too easy even for Mario game standards. Most of the moons are just sitting there waiting for you to collect them and that’s not good. I hope the next game is more challenging.
it would be perfect if it was even a little bit difficult. its not reusing mechanics wich at first seems like a positive but in the end doesnt let the devs create difficult areas. thats why new donk city is the best area. because it makes up for the lack of difficulty with its terrain
My cousin just got a switch he loves maro games on the go even wen his working 😂
the ending ruined it for me though
How many dislikes does this have? (I don’t hate the game, I’m just curious.)
No idea, but I just disliked.
@@againsttheleftandright4065 Yeahhh, you’re a living hat hater.
@TheOtherNamesWereTaken123Less dislikes than likes. OK, thanks.
PEAK FICTION