Oh yes! I found a fairly recent video on here of just Roger singing the song and most of what he does is sit and rock back and forth. That's how most people can tell Don't Leave Me Now is a sad song.
@@qteep6112 I always thought it was too. And some of it probably is. Could also be Syd Barrett’s relationship with Lyndsey Korner. According to “ Saicerfull of Secrets” there was an incident where Syd hit her
That voice!! He's certainly not the best technical singer, but nobody else's voice punches you in the gut like his does. When he sings One of My Turns and Don't Leave Me Now, it is visceral... you feel that.
Like Peter Gabriel of Genesis and Rick Davies of Supertramp, Roger Waters was a master of melodic narration. He isn't really singing, but conveying social commentary.
What I like so much about Roger Waters is that he's one of the very few people who can sing with so much emotion. It's pretty obvious in most of the songs on The Wall album that he's gone through a lot of hurt and anguish...a father who was killed in combat, an overprotective mother, and a broken heart b/c of being cheated on.
@@joellaz9836 Although, in the film the phone call ("...a collect call for Mrs. Floyd from Mister Floyd Will you accept the charges...") comes before Young Lust, so in the film his wife cheated first.
This performance strikes me an absolute mastery of theater.....insanity, depression, anger, and raw talent bottled into a perfect blend of lyrics and music........ it describes and illustrates EXACTLY whats going on with Pink .... I can listen to it over and over again. WOW Cant wait to see Mr Waters on Nov 18 in Atlanta and then again in San Fran on Dec 6. My favorite artist ever
Oh how have missed all their wonderful concerts, I am sadly too young to have attended any. Hope your time was magical, as Rogers wonderfully mysterious music presented.
OK Pink Floyd has always appealed to young kids coming of age feeling like no one understands them or the emotions they have. I can still remember falling in love with Floyd at the age of 15 I'm 30 now. And on days where emotions run high I fall in love with them all over again.
I fell in love with them at age 15 as well...now in two years I will be 70. Gilmour and I are almost the same age, and we were both in our early 20's when I saw him on stage...I felt our eyes met with my then fantasy-driven observations. Best night of my young life!
'How could you go when you know how I need you to beat to a pulp on a saturday night?' It's harrowing how though the narrator is a wicked man his desperate voice still breaks our hearts.
I may sound crazy but I've felt this before I ever heard it. I remember a night in my life where I begged for someone to stay with me because I had a breakdown and was in absolute turmoil. And then years later I hear this song and was mortified, but I absolutely love it. No long lasting effects from that night thankfully.
"Animals" y "The Wall" = creatividad al palo. Este tema si que te vuela la cabeza. Ese piano bien grave es un hachazo loco. La primera vez que lo escuche tenía 10 años y dije: "eso no es un tema, no tiene ritmo".
@TheLegend313 I know exactly how you feel; a few years back I went through a tough one and I can remember just sitting at my computer [drinking whiskey] playing this song as loud as it would go. It was the greatest therapy I could have ever had. Even though the song is haunting and sad, it makes you feel like someone or some thing understands the pain. The screams feel real. It got me thru it.
Absolutely. Great comment. I finished a book just last night that described this track as, along with Rog's vocal, possibly the Floyd's LEAST viable of them all, if you can believe that! I think it's one of their best, actually. It's all in the lyrics and his delivery TOTALLY fits the mood.
Before Nine Inch Nails, before Tool , before many others , we had this beautiful,creepy, haunting music from Roger. He had that voice that was like broken glass or thin ice , while David had a much smoother tone. Worked so well together.
The original is amazing, and this is even more so. I always felt that certain songs on this album were too short. Gems to be sure, but never crowns. Needed to be longer.
Roger Waters is a phenomenal singer - absolutely perfect for these songs; the perfect expression. It's SOOO much better with him singing than the guest vocalists he's had over the years. This concert should have been released on video decades ago!
Floyd was in the zone through this whole concert but it’s Waters performance here that is just another level😀 the emotion he delivered was absolutely amazing
😢❤I appreciate how the words go... When ya know how much I need you, to beat 💓 to a pulp on a Saturday night, Ohhh baaabe! Don't leave me now❤❤😊😊😊 quite strong and honest though painful😢❤😊
Damn, why I was born in 1991... The 70's and 80's were the best years of rock music in my opinion. Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, King Crimson, Sonic Youth, Metallica...
ive been listening to this video since i was 12 n im pulling the big for now..!! n i never get tired of it..!! i recall it gives me the chills everytime..!!
of all people not to have OD'd, or kill themselves from depression, Roger Waters did not. I have no idea how he could write these masterpieces and perform them on a basis like this and not get depressed
Like a week ago, a friend of mine, who's a HUGE fan of old rock bands, told me we would love to be borned at the '70s and asked me in witch decade I would like to be borned. I said I was OK with the '90s, the decade I was born. But after seeing this videos of the tour... well, I would loved to be there in the August 9th 1980. sorry for the bad english
The reason why I dislike so much music today is because they never give you the full story. They only show you the fun parties and never the morning after when you feel depressed, but Pink Floyd tells you.
@akgrizzly2006 The show was indeed life altering..... just SOOOO much different than anything else. The visuals were massive and poetic, the music was loud and crisp, and Rogers singing was great. I loved it. I hope he comes back across the US next year for a few more shows. I could go over and over and watch the same thing.
Probably one of the most overlooked songs in the History of music.
Just listened to the studio one before this, always liked this one better. I think the studio one doesn't give it its due, that might be the problem.
I think the crescendo into the end part is one of my favorite moments out of all the music I have listened to.
I have to agree.
same here
Agreed. That ending was literally the first piece of music that genuinely made me go..."WOAH...LET'S LISTEN TO THAT ON A LOOP!"
YES EXACTLY
OoooOoooOOOOOOOOOO
what makes the song even sadder is how roger is holding himself rocking back and forth
Oh yes! I found a fairly recent video on here of just Roger singing the song and most of what he does is sit and rock back and forth. That's how most people can tell Don't Leave Me Now is a sad song.
Abandonment is a MONSTER ...😰😥😓💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔
This song ain’t even about Rodger but he’s still feels the pain
@@kirbyloks6473 I thought this song was inspired by his relationship with Judith Trim?
@@qteep6112 I always thought it was too. And some of it probably is. Could also be Syd Barrett’s relationship with Lyndsey Korner. According to “ Saicerfull of Secrets” there was an incident where Syd hit her
That voice!! He's certainly not the best technical singer, but nobody else's voice punches you in the gut like his does. When he sings One of My Turns and Don't Leave Me Now, it is visceral... you feel that.
He really knew how to take advantage of his peculiar/ not so sophisticated voice to trigger deep emotions in the listeners
Like Peter Gabriel of Genesis and Rick Davies of Supertramp, Roger Waters was a master of melodic narration. He isn't really singing, but conveying social commentary.
He wrote it to match his voice,that's the point of writing for yourself
Love it too
now you are talkin man 🤗
Holy fuck this band is the greatest of all time
You bet!
i wish the end of this song never stopped such an amazing riff
i love how they're actually building the wall onstage
warguy403 That was the point. Roger wanted to be sperated from the crowd because of what happened at Montreal 77' (the spitting incident).
But they did tear down the wall in the end right?
@@mickenziedavis3068 yeappp
why are you runnin awayyyyyooOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO BAAAAAAAAAAAAAAABE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
3:03
Buena como vamos
been lucky enough to see them 3 times, they never disappoint. . best concerts of my life.. Rogers voice is so haunting....
like pre final cut pink floyd live?
This is one of the most depressing songs ever written in rock history.
Pink Floyd is really good at hitting you with the depression then instantly following it up with one of the greatest instrumentals you’ve ever heard😭
What I like so much about Roger Waters is that he's one of the very few people who can sing with so much emotion. It's pretty obvious in most of the songs on The Wall album that he's gone through a lot of hurt and anguish...a father who was killed in combat, an overprotective mother, and a broken heart b/c of being cheated on.
He cheated on his wife first
Joella Z Really?
From the way the songs go, it seems as if it was the other way around.
+madkittyjoey70 he said in an interview that he did first.
Wow!
@@joellaz9836 Although, in the film the phone call ("...a collect call for Mrs. Floyd from Mister Floyd
Will you accept the charges...") comes before Young Lust, so in the film his wife cheated first.
The Wall is one of the greatest achievements in music history
Brought tears to my eyes... So much emotion, you can hear it in every single note Roger hits... Absolutely moving.
that bass fill at 3:26 destroys all
+Ryan Carpenter this fill alone is the reason I took bass lessons!
pasdautreidee that is pretty bad ass
That is kick ass!
the whole album is built on rogers bass
100%
This performance strikes me an absolute mastery of theater.....insanity, depression, anger, and raw talent bottled into a perfect blend of lyrics and music........ it describes and illustrates EXACTLY whats going on with Pink .... I can listen to it over and over again. WOW Cant wait to see Mr Waters on Nov 18 in Atlanta and then again in San Fran on Dec 6. My favorite artist ever
Oh how have missed all their wonderful concerts, I am sadly too young to have attended any. Hope your time was magical, as Rogers wonderfully mysterious music presented.
Wow, it’s like hearing it for the first time all over again
Absolutely no one rips his heart out and feeds it to his fans like Waters does.
OK Pink Floyd has always appealed to young kids coming of age feeling like no one understands them or the emotions they have. I can still remember falling in love with Floyd at the age of 15 I'm 30 now. And on days where emotions run high I fall in love with them all over again.
I fell in love with them at age 15 as well...now in two years I will be 70. Gilmour and I are almost the same age, and we were both in our early 20's when I saw him on stage...I felt our eyes met with my then fantasy-driven observations. Best night of my young life!
Lori Raf im 15 and just fell in love with pink floyd omg
@@lilRadRidinHood you locked eyes with Gilmour, to have seen what you have seen 💕
this song kicks my ass every winter, actually the wall in general. Roger had an amazing way of showing dispair in his lyrics.
this song is so damn sad
so fuckin good though
so emotional
and the breakdown oh my god!
one of my favorite floyd jams
I think this is one of the best PF songs
This song saved my life.
This is an absolutely amazing song! Creepy, deep, emotional, sad, angry, ironic... just brilliant!
Excellent singing live on this song. Roger puts so much emotion into it. A really beautiful heartbreaking song.
Roger ROger ...... damn he is so fucking amazing ...... he is the greatest icon in rock history,, anyone agree????
Too fkn right
Of course he is
This is so perfectly beautiful that literally makes me cry, thank you very much Roger...
This song has always cut right through me, chilling
whoever dislikes this doesn't deserve to listen to any kind of music. or even hear anything for that matter.
Comment of the decade
@@MK-nn7gm last decade, i guess
1:50 his voice. I don’t know why but this part hits me in the gut
I love everything from this song. For me is: between 2.25 and 3.27 incredible perfect 🎼
'How could you go when you know how I need you to beat to a pulp on a saturday night?' It's harrowing how though the narrator is a wicked man his desperate voice still breaks our hearts.
I may sound crazy but I've felt this before I ever heard it. I remember a night in my life where I begged for someone to stay with me because I had a breakdown and was in absolute turmoil. And then years later I hear this song and was mortified, but I absolutely love it. No long lasting effects from that night thankfully.
The last ‘oooooooooooooo’ at the end makes me tear up every time, don’t even know why.
The bassist in this concert kept his rep level up ! Awesome playing
"Animals" y "The Wall" = creatividad al palo. Este tema si que te vuela la cabeza. Ese piano bien grave es un hachazo loco. La primera vez que lo escuche tenía 10 años y dije: "eso no es un tema, no tiene ritmo".
Il Gabe y ahora te gusta o no??
Olvida el pasado, lo importante es que sabes que este tema es increíble
@TheLegend313
I know exactly how you feel; a few years back I went through a tough one and I can remember just sitting at my computer [drinking whiskey] playing this song as loud as it would go. It was the greatest therapy I could have ever had. Even though the song is haunting and sad, it makes you feel like someone or some thing understands the pain. The screams feel real. It got me thru it.
David guitar solo is the best!!!
Absolutely. Great comment. I finished a book just last night that described this track as, along with Rog's vocal, possibly the Floyd's LEAST viable of them all, if you can believe that! I think it's one of their best, actually. It's all in the lyrics and his delivery TOTALLY fits the mood.
its hard to believe nobody in pink floyd was insane, all there song are great but can be very dark. I Love It!
Syd was
Who would have thought 40 plus years we would be listening to the wall
I still shake my head in wonderment
fell in love with his singing the second i heard it. its always the unique ones that know just how to sing to make it even better
To put through the SHREDDER in front of my friends!!!
i fucking love pink floyd
I was negative 13 years old when this tour was going on. I wish I was positive 13 so I could see it. Looks to be of an amazing experience.
i dont think anyone can ever capture the emotions of this song and one of my turns better than floyd did.
This is slowly becoming my fave Floyd song
damn 80's video quality..... still just seeing this live is amazing...
Priceless performance...man.
Waters gave the lyrics and the Soul to PF
Holy Mary! The most heartbreaking angst ridden performance I've seen, love the song as well.
Before Nine Inch Nails, before Tool , before many others , we had this beautiful,creepy, haunting music from Roger. He had that voice that was like broken glass or thin ice , while David had a much smoother tone. Worked so well together.
The original is amazing, and this is even more so. I always felt that certain songs on this album were too short. Gems to be sure, but never crowns. Needed to be longer.
Classic Floyd, A little bit scary and beautiful at the same time
La mejor banda de todos los tiempos, sin duda
Roger Waters is a phenomenal singer
- absolutely perfect for these songs;
the perfect expression.
It's SOOO much better with him singing than
the guest vocalists he's had over the years.
This concert should have been released on video decades ago!
just deep emptyness on a cold winters day, this song is perfect
Floyd was in the zone through this whole concert but it’s Waters performance here that is just another level😀 the emotion he delivered was absolutely amazing
How can you goooo?
When you know how I need you...
.
That part fuckin hurts everytime
when i listent this video there i crying i love so much this song there and poor Rog, i love u Roger Waters !!
Why are you running away?
😢❤I appreciate how the words go...
When ya know how much I need you, to beat 💓 to a pulp on a Saturday night, Ohhh baaabe! Don't leave me now❤❤😊😊😊 quite strong and honest though painful😢❤😊
Essa música é simplesmente fantástica. Roger Waters é um gênio.
Triste que ele morreu 😭😭
@@guilhermeluiz9554 ele não morreu não
Who still listening in 2021 ?
that simple note at 3:46 make me feel so strange........
It's beautiful!!
Very
Just...superb.
This is one of the songs I can't see another band playing something even like it.
Absolutely priceless
One of the best
Fuck yeah
Big band yet deep in me all their songs❤
sad yet beautiful song!
Simplemente único, cómo todo pink floyd
Always makes me feel the same way, everything about it is amazing.
I saw roger do the wall in dec. 2010, it was excellent, gotta say, this is one of my favs...
waters is my favorite artist of all time, there is a god....roger be thy name
Dammit, why did I have to be born in '76? Thanks for posting this, the next best thing to seeing it live.
Wish I Was There
Damn, why I was born in 1991...
The 70's and 80's were the best years of rock music in my opinion. Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, King Crimson, Sonic Youth, Metallica...
oh my god its just unbelievable what a song, best band ever FUCK YEAH!!!
ive been listening to this video since i was 12 n im pulling the big for now..!! n i never get tired of it..!! i recall it gives me the chills everytime..!!
of all people not to have OD'd, or kill themselves from depression, Roger Waters did not. I have no idea how he could write these masterpieces and perform them on a basis like this and not get depressed
i love life
Me too, buddy.
OMG, am I officially old? "I never heard this before?" :)
Awesome performance, gives me chills!
Bass lines are awesome !
Beautiful
Like a week ago, a friend of mine, who's a HUGE fan of old rock bands, told me we would love to be borned at the '70s and asked me in witch decade I would like to be borned.
I said I was OK with the '90s, the decade I was born.
But after seeing this videos of the tour... well, I would loved to be there in the August 9th 1980.
sorry for the bad english
Truly amazing, thanks a lot...
excelente David gilmour
4 genius in just one band
best version ever
world most pyscic song....Awsommm pink Floyd...you are only & only the one
think it was someone he loved dearly...then lost :(
Ive been here half my life. 2022 still here
Back to say this is better than album version. The bass the guitar holy fuck.
wish the guitar was more intense on the last note roger hits... that would be good
i love the wall album and definitely dark side of the moon
Ok the guitar is leader. But that 3 notes of rick needed more volume. They provides sensibility to the atmosphere of dramatism.
unbelivable performace, sounds perfect!! the wall i got hooked on as well, i seen the movie/cartoon graphic great in that movie!!
Melhor banda de todos os tempos, som de outro planeta, fico sem palavras descrever, muito foda 🤘👏 vida longa pra essa banda ❤
i saw roger live in Pittsburgh and it was amazing truely a great experince............but it just wasn't the same.
The reason why I dislike so much music today is because they never give you the full story. They only show you the fun parties and never the morning after when you feel depressed, but Pink Floyd tells you.
@akgrizzly2006 The show was indeed life altering..... just SOOOO much different than anything else. The visuals were massive and poetic, the music was loud and crisp, and Rogers singing was great. I loved it. I hope he comes back across the US next year for a few more shows. I could go over and over and watch the same thing.
Se escucha mejor en vivo que en el disco está rola es realmente algo fantástico.