“Got a letter from Mary. What did I expect? What did I want? Weren’t never meant to be and never really was, and yet somehow, in the end, I discovered I had a heart because it was broken. Oh, you fool. You sad, deluded fool. Torn in two by different ideas of who you were, and it turns out you weren’t neither of them.” :(
Damn this is so sad for Arthur. He suffered so much. Knowing the gang fall apart,suffering from TB, and now the woman he always love leave him. He suffered so much. still he never gave up and redeemed himself to the end😢😢. What a character Arthur truly is.
Just imagine if he had left with Mary. Left the gang, left that life, just took off with her. And he was finally happy and lived a good life with the woman he loved. But instead, Rockstar kicks us in the balls.
I think she sent a letter while Arthur was in guarma which he didn’t get obviously. Mary would’ve left while Arthur was still in guarma or while they were running. She probably would have sent that last letter once she got to wherever she was going to.
"There's a good man within you, Arthur, but he is wrestling with a giant. And the giant, wins, time and again.: This game is just littered with some of the most powerful lines in fiction.
When Tilly says it's from Mary, he snatches it up in anticipation that he will be able to see her again. Pretty sad! A lot of amazing details in this game.
You have to understand that during Guarma, Mary Linton thought Arthur was dead. Had the Saint Denis bank heist actually have gone well, Arthur would have booked it out of the gang and ran off with Mary like no tomorrow (admittedly though, you get a FUCKTON of money during the story missions before the heist). I really wish there was an alternate story line where Arthur runs off with Mary Linton, living out on a homestead out West with Mary, all the while raising a son or daughter. That would be another good ending, but it wouldn't line up with Red Dead Redemption's storyline all too well, so I could see why the option is never available. But tl;dr: IF SHE BREATHE SHE A THOT
I think maybe their could be three different endings; 1. “Bitter sweet regret” Arthur abandons John in the Dutch van der linde gang instead of helping him and runs away with Mary Linton where they use the money they have to buy a property, they both feel happy but deep down Arthur feels terrible for knowing what he did and regrets it everyday leading to an unhappy relationship and another break up. (Before bank heist to guarma) 2. “Farewell for now.” The bank heist turns out successful and Micah tries to sabotage it, ending up with them splitting paths, Dutch and Micah going one way, abandoning John and Arthur forced to face the police and run. Big shootout and Arthur and John make it out alive, they get back to camp have big shoot off with Dutch and Micah and ultimately helps John with a better life. Gives him some stuff and goes off on his own. He finds mary Linton letter and goes to see about it. And they happy ever after 3. “The ending we got” Arthur dies and John goes happy with his family Idk just something I wrote lolol
Wouldve been cool if there was an Easter egg where if you get a certain amount of money you can just leave. Before Guarma I had like $3000+ from story missions and treasures, so it wouldn't make sense for Arthur to need more.
Arthur Morgan, a true hero and a character that everyone will and shall remember, if it wasn't for him Red Dead Redemption 1 or even John Marston would'nt of been true, he cares for others and time again he gets kicked in his ass for nothing, we will truly miss Arthur Morgan as the man he is.
well , he didn’t said it will cure your TB he said it will cure your cough and herbs need time to take action , also with TB you have to rest and get somewhere with low humidify and warm temperature
@@arthurmorgan6951 He would’ve at least died happy with Mary by his side instead of having to get stranded in Guarma, put up with Dutch’s BS, and Micah manipulating the gang.
You know can you really blame Mary, she was willing to give Arthur a chance to leave. She waited for him to change and she was right all along about how Arthur needed to change so that he can live or die in peace. Arthur recognizes that with the Downes, Charlotte, the Fisherman veteran, and the ower who had a NA wife. Got to start doing good deeds before it's too late. It was too late to be with mary.
she knew he wouldn’t though. it was just her last chance and she was hopeful but she knew what arthur was and that he couldn’t leave, not that he didn’t want to.
For people who's saying that Linton's a bitch and that Arthur's love is unrequited, she wrote this letter with a context that Arthur is dead (or dying) based on the newspaper. She even stated her doubt whether her letter is going to reach him or not. It is all summed-up to: she simply weren't aware that Arthur survived the failed robbery.
I feel so bad for Arthur. He probably felt really hurt and used by Mary. I didn't help her a second time because I felt like she was just using me. She knew that Arthur had a soft spot for her and exploited that. Arthur deserved better. At the same time, considering the lifestyle he lived it makes sense that it made things difficult for their relationship to survive.
What the fuck are you even saying? Do you mind shutting the fuck up? Mary loved Arthur and asked to run away with him but Arthur declined. Arthur said no. Mary knew she couldn’t have Arthur and let go.
arthur did them. arthur isnt a simp. hes a good man. who kept his word to the woman he loved. but deep down he knew shed never be able to love him forever.
As much as it is upsetting to see her leave him it also makes me sad that there incounters made me think of a best friend I had she was awesome last time I saw her was my high-school graduation in 2017
On my play through I was purposefully neglecting the Thomas Downes mission, so I went to read the first letter Mary sent and it ended with a cutscene of Arthur just staring at it and then Strauss came to remind him of the Thomas Downes debt then I was forced to do it. Nice touch from Rockstar.
I thought its mary seeking for another help, it kept them in contact for a brief period of time once in a while, but seeing good bye at the end killed my mood.😭😭🥺
When I received the letter, I rolled my eyes, got up to "My Dear Arthur...", then closed it and went to look for Mary-Beth to give the ring to (not possible unfortunately)
John lived the life Arthur always wanted, to a certain degree... John : - Got to leave his past behind (for some time) - Built a house - Got to be with his family for some time - Had an actual wedding with his friends around him - Raised his son for most of his youth - Had a loyal wife who loved him But even then, it never did last too long, but he sure wished he had that...
I had the same love story like arthur in the end she married someone else the woman i used to love im not a romantic kind a guy but i understand now when she is gone how to live without a heart
Honestly this reminded me of Rachel Dawes from the Dark Knight because even though Rachel loved Bruce she decided to be with Harvey because she thought that Bruce would never give up being Batman which is similar to how Mary still loves Arthur but left him because she thought he would never give up gang life.
Remember the shady belle cutscene where dutch woke arthur up? You can see that dutch picked up a letter and threw it away after briefly reading it. possibly from mary with another request.
bro this just made me so sad you know arthur is dead inside he just saw sean,lenny,hosea,molly, all die in like a month span and then loses the only women who really understood arthur and his demons but she knew arthur was never gonna get straight and by the time he would have TB would have ripped him away from her….what a brutal world…..
Its interesting to see what peoole did with Arthur after this I'd always ride up to ocreighs run, arthur would chill in the grizzlies for a few days and come back, pretty much did that shit IRL a month back in colorado. Clean air and simple living for a while helps get us back from heartache.
I feel sad for Arthur but I don’t think it would ever have worked with Mary. She would’ve found something else she didn’t like about him, something else she wanted to change and would never put him about her drunk father. I also don’t think she’d want to live on the run or in a cabin somewhere in the middle of nowhere when she’s clearly quite middle class and used to having things. Even if Arthur survived he was still a wanted man.
Mary Linton really doesn't deserve Arthur Morgan, she’s weak and devoted to her family too much even if they’re a pain. Arthur is a great man, even if he says otherwise. She couldn’t even stop Arthur from following Dutch and still being an outlaw, unlike Abigail did with John. If only Mary eloped eith Arthur then perhaps things could have been different.
@@christianmoreno7317 True but even before it died John was showing signs of wanting out and his family gave him the motivation. It gives so much more to his character
Imagine after all of this . . . . . . when you're with John Marston, you can still check the letter and _photo of young Mary and Arthur_ which hit me in the feels since I thought of doing it alone at night by the campfire. Nothing but distant wind, crickets, fire crackles and the feeling of someone who doesn't exist and never will, for Mary. Yet there they are in my hand, all nicely drawn and happy.
Dear Bruce. I need to be honest and clear. I'm going to marry Harvey Dent. I love him, and I want to spend the rest of my life with him. When I told you that if Gotham no longer needed Batman we could be together, I meant it. But now I'm sure the day won't come when *you* no longer need Batman. I hope it does; and if it does I will be there, but as your friend. I'm sorry to let you down. If you lose your faith in me, please keep your faith in people. Love, now and always, Rachel.
I love you forever Meg Du Schultze!! I'm sorry I didn't get my shit sorted! I'm sorry I cheated! I'm sorry I kept drinking and getting in fights I love you so Fucking much I will find you in heaven and make up for all the shit I did wrong 😭😭😭
Wish Arthur wrote back saying "Okay ill catch you later then"
Nah he should of hit back with kbro.
He wrote back. “You sir. Are a fish.”
“Dear Mary Lonton
K
Regards Author Morgan”
he obviously just sent 8-ball pool
When Tilly said “she ain’t worth it Arthur” and Arthur responded:
“Who is?”
I FELT THAT
I was told the same thing about " she is not worth it" and I replied then show me who is... Silence everytime
😔😔😔
Just imagine if a tear drop hit the letter while he was reading it I would of died inside
That would have been a nice touch. Damn.
Yea i was expecting smth like that
TheSuperKingDan Men like Arthur don’t shed many of those.
TheSuperKingDan that doesn’t dir him
My guy, Arthur is not a kind of guy that cries over a woman 😂
“Got a letter from Mary. What did I expect? What did I want? Weren’t never meant to be and never really was, and yet somehow, in the end, I discovered I had a heart because it was broken. Oh, you fool. You sad, deluded fool. Torn in two by different ideas of who you were, and it turns out you weren’t neither of them.”
:(
Did he say that??
poteytow he writes it in his journal 😢
Damn
You can even see how he scratches some words, he must been so hurt that he couldnt even write well, poor arthur
Damn this is so sad for Arthur. He suffered so much. Knowing the gang fall apart,suffering from TB, and now the woman he always love leave him. He suffered so much. still he never gave up and redeemed himself to the end😢😢. What a character Arthur truly is.
nobody survives even one bit what if they do a zombie mode like they did in RDR1 and Arthur comes back alive 🤟🏾💯
He got his own redemption just like John. It's a sad story but I absolutely loved Arthur's character development
That's what makes Arthur morgan one of the greatest protagonist in video game history
Just imagine if he had left with Mary. Left the gang, left that life, just took off with her. And he was finally happy and lived a good life with the woman he loved.
But instead, Rockstar kicks us in the balls.
@@vanmorgan1867 Should have given the players an option to run away or stay with the gang
did all her missions & still got that letter
I think she sent a letter while Arthur was in guarma which he didn’t get obviously. Mary would’ve left while Arthur was still in guarma or while they were running. She probably would have sent that last letter once she got to wherever she was going to.
She sends that letter always because Arthur was that long stuck on Guarma.
And she's a little bitch
@@akilith3820 no, that’s you
Buddy what was she supposed to do? He robbed the largest fuckin bank in the south while she was recently there. You wouldn’t date a criminal either.
I went into a state of temporary depression after I got this letter.
What??
When I got this letter, I felt somewhat relieved. Because I didn’t want her to see Arthur all sick.
"There's a good man within you, Arthur, but he is wrestling with a giant. And the giant, wins, time and again.:
This game is just littered with some of the most powerful lines in fiction.
“There’s a good man within you, but he is wrestling with a lust for muneh.”
I need to see their relationship in it's hayday. They truly loved eachother, even when it was impossible to be together.
"When I'm with you, the world makes sense". I felt that 😔
I made Arthur drink up all the liquor he had after this letter.
enabler !
When Tilly says it's from Mary, he snatches it up in anticipation that he will be able to see her again. Pretty sad! A lot of amazing details in this game.
You have to understand that during Guarma, Mary Linton thought Arthur was dead. Had the Saint Denis bank heist actually have gone well, Arthur would have booked it out of the gang and ran off with Mary like no tomorrow (admittedly though, you get a FUCKTON of money during the story missions before the heist).
I really wish there was an alternate story line where Arthur runs off with Mary Linton, living out on a homestead out West with Mary, all the while raising a son or daughter. That would be another good ending, but it wouldn't line up with Red Dead Redemption's storyline all too well, so I could see why the option is never available.
But tl;dr: IF SHE BREATHE SHE A THOT
I know this is 1 year old but he had TB so I think he would have eventually died. Arthur can't get a break😭😭😭
BasicMonkey but there was a cure in California. Really wish this was an ending...
I think maybe their could be three different endings;
1. “Bitter sweet regret”
Arthur abandons John in the Dutch van der linde gang instead of helping him and runs away with Mary Linton where they use the money they have to buy a property, they both feel happy but deep down Arthur feels terrible for knowing what he did and regrets it everyday leading to an unhappy relationship and another break up. (Before bank heist to guarma)
2. “Farewell for now.”
The bank heist turns out successful and Micah tries to sabotage it, ending up with them splitting paths, Dutch and Micah going one way, abandoning John and Arthur forced to face the police and run. Big shootout and Arthur and John make it out alive, they get back to camp have big shoot off with Dutch and Micah and ultimately helps John with a better life. Gives him some stuff and goes off on his own. He finds mary Linton letter and goes to see about it. And they happy ever after
3. “The ending we got”
Arthur dies and John goes happy with his family
Idk just something I wrote lolol
Yeah, i made a video about both of them. I am so addicted to mary and arthur
Wouldve been cool if there was an Easter egg where if you get a certain amount of money you can just leave. Before Guarma I had like $3000+ from story missions and treasures, so it wouldn't make sense for Arthur to need more.
Arthur Morgan, a true hero and a character that everyone will and shall remember, if it wasn't for him Red Dead Redemption 1 or even John Marston would'nt of been true, he cares for others and time again he gets kicked in his ass for nothing, we will truly miss Arthur Morgan as the man he is.
She comes to his grave when he is dead
seb asstion during credits
1:28 (Low honor.)
1:44 (High honor.)
For me the greatest scammer was Eagle Flies dad. Rain fall made me find his Bagpipe in exchange for medicine that never worked.
Lmao
That noise should've done the trick, Oarthur. N O I S E
well , he didn’t said it will cure your TB he said it will cure your cough and herbs need time to take action , also with TB you have to rest and get somewhere with low humidify and warm temperature
It’s a medicine for temporary use dumbass, to keep Arthur strong for a while since he has that outlaw life and fighting
Part of me wishes Arthur had just ran off with her in Chapter 4.
Already too late….. Arthur’s fate was sealed in chapter 2
@@arthurmorgan6951 He would’ve at least died happy with Mary by his side instead of having to get stranded in Guarma, put up with Dutch’s BS, and Micah manipulating the gang.
You know can you really blame Mary, she was willing to give Arthur a chance to leave. She waited for him to change and she was right all along about how Arthur needed to change so that he can live or die in peace. Arthur recognizes that with the Downes, Charlotte, the Fisherman veteran, and the ower who had a NA wife. Got to start doing good deeds before it's too late. It was too late to be with mary.
she knew he wouldn’t though. it was just her last chance and she was hopeful but she knew what arthur was and that he couldn’t leave, not that he didn’t want to.
The saddest part of it is that it doesn’t seem to bother knowing he was going to die of TB at any point, this is when I knew he was doomed
For people who's saying that Linton's a bitch and that Arthur's love is unrequited, she wrote this letter with a context that Arthur is dead (or dying) based on the newspaper. She even stated her doubt whether her letter is going to reach him or not. It is all summed-up to: she simply weren't aware that Arthur survived the failed robbery.
If I was Mary, I would've kept it for memorabilia. At least she didn't sell it 💀
I remember getting a message like this, it made my blood go cold, and my heart even more so.
I feel so bad for Arthur. He probably felt really hurt and used by Mary. I didn't help her a second time because I felt like she was just using me. She knew that Arthur had a soft spot for her and exploited that. Arthur deserved better. At the same time, considering the lifestyle he lived it makes sense that it made things difficult for their relationship to survive.
She asked him to run away with her, which he declined. He had his reasons, but u can't blame her imo.
@@Tommygy1 like his mentor dutch arthur need the MUNEH if he and mary would run away
What the fuck are you even saying? Do you mind shutting the fuck up? Mary loved Arthur and asked to run away with him but Arthur declined. Arthur said no. Mary knew she couldn’t have Arthur and let go.
Nah
No she's not
Who else did all the missions like a simp 🥺
ew what
arthur did them. arthur isnt a simp. hes a good man. who kept his word to the woman he loved. but deep down he knew shed never be able to love him forever.
@@internalwhack9638 it's not that she didnt love him. she didnt love his life
@@Nomad413z she’ll always hold him dear but it’s mainly what she couldn’t love his life.
As much as it is upsetting to see her leave him it also makes me sad that there incounters made me think of a best friend I had she was awesome last time I saw her was my high-school graduation in 2017
Dude that was barely a year ago, Arthur probably hasnt seen Mary in atleast 10 years possibly more
On my play through I was purposefully neglecting the Thomas Downes mission, so I went to read the first letter Mary sent and it ended with a cutscene of Arthur just staring at it and then Strauss came to remind him of the Thomas Downes debt then I was forced to do it.
Nice touch from Rockstar.
Mane I hate how obsessed I am with this game I’ve never played a story game over and over again and it still hits every Godamn time🤝🏾
After I received her 2nd letter, I just completely ignored it.
Yeah, I sat there in stunned silence for a second too
Feelings unspoken, are unforgettable.
Imagine just a single droplet hitting the letter before he folds it back up.
Missed opportunity
Corny ahh
This is honestly some of the most heartbreaking writing in the game.
I got a letter. The name on the envelope said... Mary.
I'm glad that I only made Jamie's mission and left her to deal alone with her father
I thought its mary seeking for another help, it kept them in contact for a brief period of time once in a while, but seeing good bye at the end killed my mood.😭😭🥺
So the law can’t find them without having someone lead them to the hideout but the post office still delivers the mail exactly where they are…
Они сами вроде идут получать письма на выдуманное имя, как например Тацит
why do I relate to this bro ... like my ex said something so similar to me.
When I received the letter, I rolled my eyes, got up to "My Dear Arthur...", then closed it and went to look for Mary-Beth to give the ring to (not possible unfortunately)
John lived the life Arthur always wanted, to a certain degree...
John :
- Got to leave his past behind (for some time)
- Built a house
- Got to be with his family for some time
- Had an actual wedding with his friends around him
- Raised his son for most of his youth
- Had a loyal wife who loved him
But even then, it never did last too long, but he sure wished he had that...
“She ain’t worth it Arthur.”
Arthur: “Well, who is.”
*Realist line in video game history*
I'm assuming Jack got ahold of the ring. Wonder what he did with it.
He probably buried Abigail with it
''bro worst she can say is no''
this is much better than a no, its closure and it makes sense for them individually
This letter is better because if you do all the missions, she is less apologetic
Thanks
And this is exactly why, every time I re play the story. I am the meanest som bitch that ever walked the earth 😂
I had the same love story like arthur in the end she married someone else the woman i used to love im not a romantic kind a guy but i understand now when she is gone how to live without a heart
Honestly this reminded me of Rachel Dawes from the Dark Knight because even though Rachel loved Bruce she decided to be with Harvey because she thought that Bruce would never give up being Batman which is similar to how Mary still loves Arthur but left him because she thought he would never give up gang life.
"My dear Arthur, You never showed up." Um excuse me?
Remember the shady belle cutscene where dutch woke arthur up? You can see that dutch picked up a letter and threw it away after briefly reading it. possibly from mary with another request.
@@asslover1513 Arthur: Dutch who was that from?
Dutch: it’s none of your business Orther
If this doesn't make you cry then hell idk what does
0:46 "my dear Arthur" 😔
Is this the only ending they can get?I helped and risked my life and when she don’t need me anymore she leave me with a letter?
bro this just made me so sad you know arthur is dead inside he just saw sean,lenny,hosea,molly, all die in like a month span and then loses the only women who really understood arthur and his demons but she knew arthur was never gonna get straight and by the time he would have TB would have ripped him away from her….what a brutal world…..
Tilly > Mary . she straight up she loyal and she keep a cool head
Its interesting to see what peoole did with Arthur after this I'd always ride up to ocreighs run, arthur would chill in the grizzlies for a few days and come back, pretty much did that shit IRL a month back in colorado. Clean air and simple living for a while helps get us back from heartache.
I feel sad for Arthur but I don’t think it would ever have worked with Mary. She would’ve found something else she didn’t like about him, something else she wanted to change and would never put him about her drunk father. I also don’t think she’d want to live on the run or in a cabin somewhere in the middle of nowhere when she’s clearly quite middle class and used to having things. Even if Arthur survived he was still a wanted man.
It wouldn’t matter if Arthur ran away with Mary earlier he was already doomed with tuberculosis he would have gotten her sick too
When i read the letter my brain started playing i love you so music
Someone cutting onions here?
Mary Linton really doesn't deserve Arthur Morgan, she’s weak and devoted to her family too much even if they’re a pain. Arthur is a great man, even if he says otherwise. She couldn’t even stop Arthur from following Dutch and still being an outlaw, unlike Abigail did with John. If only Mary eloped eith Arthur then perhaps things could have been different.
I agree. Maybe Arthur was holding onto the gang life too much and Mary couldn't handle it. Either way it's sad and Arthur deserved so much better.
The only reason Abigail stopped John was because the gang basically died lol, they wanted a new life that Aurthor gave them.
@@christianmoreno7317 True but even before it died John was showing signs of wanting out and his family gave him the motivation. It gives so much more to his character
You could say the same about Arthur, Arthur was too devoted to his family, which was the gang
Arthur is a great man, so this average civilian should run off with a lawless outlaw who just massacred saints denis police force. Makes sense.
Imagine after all of this
.
.
.
.
.
.
when you're with John Marston, you can still check the letter and _photo of young Mary and Arthur_
which hit me in the feels since I thought of doing it alone at night by the campfire. Nothing but distant wind, crickets, fire crackles and the feeling of someone who doesn't exist and never will, for Mary.
Yet there they are in my hand, all nicely drawn and happy.
Bro I sobbed so bad when I read it
Your Arthur looks like B.J Blaskowicz
I'm glad someone knows Wolfenstein!!😂
Mary toxic asf, over here sending Arthur old rings to make him think about her. Knowing damn well she could’ve just threw it away
Y was tilly getting in grown folks business
Oh Arthur
After the reading I threw my controller and stood 5 minutes to compuse myself and said : Oh Mary Linton, you fixing me and hurting my darling.....
damn your arthur looks like a model, mine was a hill-fuckin-billy
Does this appear when you don’t visit her in Saint Denis
There was a ring ;(
0:36
do you get this letter if you don't help Mary?
Oh arthur😔😔😔😔
WHERE DO YOU GET THAT GUN BELT
Dear Bruce. I need to be honest and clear. I'm going to marry Harvey Dent. I love him, and I want to spend the rest of my life with him. When I told you that if Gotham no longer needed Batman we could be together, I meant it. But now I'm sure the day won't come when *you* no longer need Batman. I hope it does; and if it does I will be there, but as your friend. I'm sorry to let you down. If you lose your faith in me, please keep your faith in people. Love, now and always, Rachel.
wrong video buddy
Can someone tell me how to get this suit pleases ?
黑山羊の卵 it's not a suit, it's a shirt & a vest
@@fudo3533 my mistaken, do u know how to get ?
黑山羊の卵 you should already have the vest if not go buy it at saint denis at the tailor & the shirt too
@@fudo3533 found it ,thx anyways
What mission is this in
That is a good looking Arthur 😍😜
Ew
so sad....
Two types of people in this world... People with beards and woman.
You must really need glasses fella 😂😂
2 types of men. Men who are secure enough in their masculinity to not need a beard, and bearded pussy boys
@@dookeland8 some woman like needs tho.
I love you forever Meg Du Schultze!! I'm sorry I didn't get my shit sorted! I'm sorry I cheated! I'm sorry I kept drinking and getting in fights I love you so Fucking much I will find you in heaven and make up for all the shit I did wrong 😭😭😭
why god why!
I never heard this. Damn it. I love you Mary❤❤❤
Uzk
0:39