the people in the comments completely missing the point that EVEN THOUGH they made all the characters technicolor, they still decided to make all of them have light skin (as in, all of them are light versions of their original colors). even if they arent any literal human skin color thats still a conscious decision, they could just as well have made all of them darker shades of the rainbow instead. its still implying that light skin is the default. most arguments i see defending the decision go so far as to imply light skin is the superior aesthetic choice, like the character designs would be unreadable, match poorly, or in any way uglier with darker skin. that mentality is the issue.
I mean...I've even seen people say dark skin just "doesn't work" with pastel colors. Which, is completely wrong. Easiest way to tell someone either doesn't know about color theory (or colors in general), is colorist/racist, or both. Often both, because nobody who isn't a racist would argue for the lightening of fictional skin colors...or cry about a horse getting a human skin color alongside a human form.
fr like people being like "oh it isn't technically white-washing because x and y" and it's like the video + your comment explains pretty clearly why it is it's not that hard to comprehend
Please. I literally have an oc with dark blue skin, and light brown eyes, and hair that's white and sky blue. The colors go super well together actually.
@@Vesperad0 dark skin can completely work with pastel colors if it's slightly washed out. See Luna's pony form. She's not a saturated dark blue, she's a more dull dark blue to not be a burden to the audience's eyes.
As a child I had never seen a doll I wanted so desperately as much as I wanted catty. I wish there were more dolls with a whole range of skin colors, including black and "ugly" colors. Who knows, a lot of ugly colors look amazing when paired right. ...aside from the minstrel dolls I found a lot. I would prefer the all black dolls don't look like blackface "jokes". Catty should be the blueprint
@@Vesperad0 As a sprite artist who's done SO MANY RECOLOR JOBS for people's pokesonas and pokemon trainers: there are no ugly colors, only artists who need to let go of their security blanket color swatches and learn color theory. I was able to make KHAKI GREEN WORK. KHAKI GREEN. _BABY POOP GREEN_ WORKED OUT. If someone like me can make undigested poop green work as a legitimately pretty color on something with just two hours of fussing with shading, highlights, and secondary/tertiary colors, then no color can be genuinely ugly. And I managed to make an outfit that was literally aggressively high-visibility mandarin-orange-peel orange look good on myself, just because I chose the right clothing pieces to pair up and pull the outfit together. If I could do those two miracles, then it really isn't that hard to make dolls with a good range of colors and dolls with "ugly" colors work out, because I'm no fashion designer and my color theory knowledge comes from Megaman fans' sprite recolor tutorials.
I personally love the idea of Celestia being a dark tan/middle brown tone and Luna being extremely pale to reflect their different relationships with the sun.
i just think it would be hilarious if celestia was pale and burned extremely easily, and luna is the opposite, for the exact same reason. the irony and sisterly joking about it would be wholesome lol
@@skootergirl22 Luna's Coat Color is Supposed to Match the Night sky more supposedly so Our Night sky as she Doesn't Match the night skies of Equestia,Her Design is not Just the Moon but the Concept of Night itself afterall The Moon itself is Only One of the things she brings and Even with the Moon in the Sky reflecting the Sun's Rays shine as Bright as it might but the skies Still gonna be Dark Regardless. Especially on Starless nights And full Moons
@@skootergirl22 and Most People Just Don't Look at her and think She's White there is Fanart of a White Luna. but Most of the Fandom Agrees that She is a Black Woman or atleast a Darkskinned Woman Even the Company that Makes Offical Mlpfim Anime figures Saw Luna and made her Black plus Fo someone Like Me Growing up As a African American girl Seeing her Coat and how drop dead Gorgeous she was Just Gave me the Reassurance that Dark colored characters and People in fact gorgeous so for me if she was a Human she was a Black princess and one of the Only three I know. Princess Luna,Princess Aisha (winx club)and Princess Tiana
@RubyCat_7 They mean she's often drawn with purple skin. There isn't exactly a deficit of black twilight drawings, but it's slightly less prevalent nowadays
@@RubyCat_7 Guess i havent been on twitter as much lol, from my experience twilight was drawn consistently as the whitest lady you ever seen post Equestria Girls but then again that was ten years ago and i havent been keeping up as much
@@OceanGlow-jv8kj That's a good thing. Purple twilight is neutral. It's better than people fighting over her being white or black when she isn't even a human to began with
Thing is, there IS darker skin tones in Equestria Girls… in Sunset’s and Twilight’s “demon” forms. The character designers had the full knowledge and ability to design appealing, readable characters with darker skin tones, and they only used it for the villains. That to me makes it *worse* than just having no darker skinned characters at all tbh. I remember a few years ago on a EQG retrospective video someone brought up the whitewashing of the characters in the comments and people acted like they were being ridiculous, I’m glad someone else is speaking about this because I DO love EQG but we can still point out its flaws
People were acting like they were being ridiculous because they were being ridiculous. Modern westoid race obsession is an uniquely obnoxious phenomenon. If a humanized version of a cartoon horse being white causes you distress you should discuss it with your therapist.
Let's not forget about Silver Spoon. She may not appear in the media as much, but she still falls under the "Miss Cheerilee" treatment with her hair and skin colors being swapped. Honestly, I kinda hate the fact that Hasbro made basically every character's skin color as light as possible because it becomes very jarring when you compare it to their pony counterparts. Now that I'm thinking about it, the background characters in EQG are so much more interesting to look at rather than in FIM because at least in EQG all the characters look very unique from each other rather than copy/pasted versions of each other with different colors. I mean, as an example, just look at Twinkleshine and Lemon Hearts. They literally have the EXACT SAME HAIRSTYLE!!! I get it's probably easier to not have to animate background ponies this way, but if EQG can make the background characters look unique then why can't FIM
6:55 there is this one person who made a 100% human Luna once that made her have the skin condition of vitiligo so she has the dark skin to match her dark fur as a pony and the light skin to match the fandoms headcanon of her human skin color.
I also think it's an interesting idea because, unless you have a tattoo on your design, there's no physical trait on them to represent their cutie mark besides their outfits. So, the light parts of the skin caused by vitiligo could help represent that in a way...? Idk if my point is getting across well, but the moon on her cutie mark is light and the dark sky on it has a spotting pattern to it like it fades out into her dark blue coat.
That's why I like Sonic franchise. You can choose any headcanon for any Sonic character and no one has a right to bash you for this. I headcanon Sonic as a Whasian (like fr, how can he tolerate so much spicy chilidawgs?!!).
Im a doll collector myself & i think the darker dye cost is lowky BS , equstria girls in the end of the day is a rip off of monster high & monster high from the beginning had characters with darker skintones , cleo & clawdeen for example both have darker skintones, hell they even made catty & wydoma who are straight out black , mattel clearly had no issue w this then why cant hasbro do the same? They have the money to give the dolls darker skintones they just obv dont want to
Yeah. Keeping Luna's lips darker with her skin tone works better like the way you drew it. If you keep them light, it looks too much like blackface. I agree that they did overcorrect. I think ultimately they didn't go with human skintones is because of doll sales. They might have considered matching them up with human skintones (Indian Twilight) but it wouldn't have sold as well as a white Twilight. I remember reading that sales numbers have shown, even among black children, white dolls sell better. Which is its own sad can of worms. I also remember talking to a grandma who "couldn't find a white Dora the Explorer" doll because had never seen the show. Eventually after talking to her grandchild's parents she laughed at herself and got the doll obviously but it shows a certain prejudice we haven't shaken yet. I don't think Hasbro was willing or ready to move the needle on that yet. They wanted a success and to try and sidestep the issue for now (plus, they'd be more immediately recognizable). They also wanted to compete with Monster High from Mattel which had lots of unnatural skin tones.
@@liiil8492 Where the hell have you been? Conservative? Ultra right? Do you go to actual conventions? Do you see the content the fandom produces? Don't believe the one article and memes taken out of context. The MLP fandom is LGBTQ af.
@@liiil8492 @liiil8492 I highly disagree. I've found them very liberal and very pro LGBT. There's a small minority who are vocal who created aryanne. I've been to lots of cons and lots of websites. Bronies are very lgbtq. Lots of bronies with very masculine hobbies who are the same way. The aryanne thing is blown so out of proportion it's ridiculous. I saw her creation. I've been in those spaces. It's not what you think. Yes those people exist. Obviously. But a lot of it is just teenagers with unfunny edgy humor who don't know when they're talking to people who think these things unironically.
@@liiil8492 I don't know what group you hang out with but I strongly disagree. The vast majority are not that way and the ones that are like that are a vocal minority.
@@Hyreia This fandom borns in 4chan, I think that's enough to explain what's was going on lol. According to a survey in its golden age (2012-2014), mostly of bronies were white and leftist. There are articles reporting that this fandom is a hotbed of extremists (worse: natzeh). The way they react when they banned Aryanne? Marenheit 451. I want to think things has changed cuz i'm in this fandom.
“It would be harder to read their facial expressions ):” MLP uses colored lineart, and tbh because of that it’s sometimes already hard to read their facial expressions. If they really cared about that they would’ve made the lineart slightly darker in the first place. There was no good reason to change Cheerilee and Luna’s skin tones like that imo. It’s just cause they didn’t want their humanoid characters to be too dark skinned. 😔
Coming from an autistic person who’s SPECIAL INTEREST is My Little Pony, I had no idea that was CHEERLIEE. I am literally just finding this out. That does NOT look like her.
@@Helloqiiand theres plenty of background ponies who use cheerlie’s base model Of course if you don’t use the normal colors people wouldn’t tell who it was
every time theres a discussion about race in equestria, people always fail to mention Zecora and the other zebras from the comics, the Ponies of Saddle Arabia, and the town of Somnambula, Corriander Cumin and his daughter Saffron Masala all have very obvious inspiration from real life cultures, including Pinkie's family of Amish inspiration. Furthermore, its not subtle the American AND Canadian influence in the MANE part of Equestria. so there is no canon race for the main characters cause none of them are of those very obvious influence. And not for malicious reasons, its for the same reason they made them pastel humans, so a kid of any skin color can have a chance to connect with all the main characters and buy ALL THE DOLLS!
Unfortunately Zecora wasn't used in the show _nearly_ as much as they wanted to, and a lot of those other characters were just one-offs, but I totally agree with you
Luna and Cheerilee are definitely the worst cases of whitewashing in Equestria Girls' case. Luna is a darker shade of blue in Friendship Is Magic (following Luna Eclipse) and Cheerilee is also darker toned in the actual show. So, why are both of them suddenly super pale-toned in Equestria Girls?
I mean not hate but ether your trying to say Celestia and luna are mixed or they are both white lol. Because Celestia is her sister and very much white.
I always viewed Pinkie as a white Irish redhead but there’s this mlp human 1920s au art where she is Hispanic (not sure on the specifics) and it was so beautiful
I mean it's like what he said about rainbow, if we were to apply real life medical diagnoses such as sunburn, we would have to apply cyanosis to rainbow but there's no way around that bc shes.. simply blue. Big Macintosh is simply red.
I really don’t like how they did Luna and Celestia in general. From princesses to Principal and vice principal? Really? Luna is whitewashed and celestia is pink… celestia also seems to have a different personality at least in the first movie.
@@raineblackstar3522that is Not Canon the Only reason why she Pink was For the Toys and then When Cadence came into the Picture they Made her White. We don't know If she was Pink when she was Younger,Plus That's a Weird jump From a Pink coat to a White One. Yes,Luna has a blue coat that turned Dark Blue But at Least the Shade of Blue they used for her Younger self Was in the Same Color Family of the Darker Blue. Pink is a Different color from White and Pink is Basically just a Lighter shade of Red,If she was Pink She would have Still been Pink as a Adult probably just a Lighter shade.
@@shamiyahzow8525 you know white can come from any colour in the palette, right? Most often, it's from red. But what if it's from pink, hmmm? It would still be a very light shade of pink, appearing as white.
@@ethancox9737 bout 9 or 10 i'd say, mind you i obviously wasnt thinking those exact words but i remember feeling extremely offput by the fact luna's skin was turned so pale for reasons i genuinely couldnt figure out (i grew up to illustrate/design so i guess being nitpicky about this stuff put me down that path a bit too LOL) but yeah to this day i think luna's original fur color would've worked better on her than what they ended up doing
I always found it strange what they did to Big Mac, and never noticed what they did to Cheerlie. I didn't notice Luna's appearance until recent, so how I am just so confused now.
If i can throw my hat in the ring i feel like this combined with how hasbro treated Zecora and Zeberas in general might also play into it - i dont think they wanted to really incorporate many prominent diverse characters for fear of backlash (( which. Is stupid. )) and so instead we got washed out gross colored eqg humans and 33 minutes series total screen time of zecora
"(( which. Is stupid. ))" I mean obviously not that stupid considering you ppl still created backlash over it even after every attempt to avoid it was made.
I can't imagine "having" to change not even the races, but the harmless skin colors of humanized colorful ponies for grown men that made a whole children's show about them. Let me be clear, I am nowhere near against people having "childish" interests. I am, however, endlessly annoyed with and frustrated by grown ass people who decide they're the main audience to pander to, and in this case have their racism impact the toys meant for children. There's a huge difference between appreciating children's media and invading spaces meant for children, and everyday I hate how those fourchan users practically exposed a generation to gore and unnecessarily sexual content.
@@Vesperad0 I get that. but i think there are more adults that watch mlp than children, so hasbro probably DID try to pander to them a bit more. not by much probably, it being a kids show and all. now i dont know if thats true so correct me if im wrong.
Doug did it for the same reasons & s a result, people started theorizing that the city Doug lives in(Bluffington) is ultra-radioactive & polluted to the point of giving everyone wild techno colored skin.
@@Vesperad0The idea that Hasbro didn't give them human races because of bronies is actually pretty ridiculous if you think about it for any length of time. If they were basing the show on bronies, Flash Sentry wouldn't have been a part of it, and the setting wouldn't have been high school. Bronies didn't like Equestria Girls at all when the concept art was first leaked. Hasbro made that decision because they wanted to sell toys to more children. Full stop. What Hasbro cares the most about is their bottom line. They probably showed some kids in a focus group test images and asked them which one they like the best and the colorful ones were the most popular.
Thank you for bringing this up!! I usually don't see other mlp fans talking about this issue even though it's, at least to me, pretty bothersome. Just a heads up though, one of the other reason Hasbro might've lightned big mac's skin tone besides it just looking off, is the bright red skin would've been way too reminiscent to offensive native american caricatures, which very often had bright red skintones. I do agree with you, though!
That still doesn't really make sense though because nothing about big mac implies that he's based off of native americans. And its not like theres really much of a history of people accusing characters with red skin being caricatures unless they were clearly meant to be native american caricature's. Plus if that IS somehow the reason big mac's red skin was taken away then why did sunsets demon form get red skin? If your not letting one of the good guy's family members have red skin because of racist caricatures would it not arguably be more offensive to then give the villain red skin?
@@LizzieMaee Honestly, this is simply one of the theories I saw floating around on why Hasbro made that creative choice and since MLP does have a big usamerican audience, it made enough sense to me. However, your point about sunset shimmer is very valid! It could be argued that maybe since it's a demon form, demons are usually depicted with red skin anyway, but maybe that's giving Hasbro the benefit of the doubt too much... Fair point either way!
I feel like the colors on the characters speak to an odd fear with the character design. Making technicolor humans meant keeping the pony colors, but that would make half their cast tan (at best.) The way it's done almost makes me feel like someone on the team with decision making power sat down and went "the skin needs to be lighter than the original coat, that's how skin works" without any notice or care for how fucked up that sounds.
I always thought it was weird how light they made luna, i get they made everyone shade light but they made her EXTREMELY LIGHT to the point I didn't register her as luna at first
I genuinely feel they should've just made them have human skin tones. Yeah, a lot of people would be angry if their headcanons weren't true, but I have always personally thought the unnatural skin tones created a weird problem with the designs. I get them wanting to make all the colors lighter is to make them read as more human, but like... They could fix it by just making them have human skin tones? Also, just for funsies because you mentioned your headcanons, I have always headcanoned human Luna as being black with vitiligo as a human, with the vitiligo representing her cutie mark being of a night sky with a moon (the moon is a light color of course, and the night sky seems to fade out with a spotted pattern, like the patterns people with vitiligo get on their skin). Then I flip flop with Celestia, because I also headcanon her as black but I sometines imagine her as a human having albinism and sometimes not.
Luna is literally the Princess of the Night. Seeing her reduced to this vice principal, easily tricked by every villain, barely relevant, certainly not immortal or magical, and obviously *whitewashed* version of herself is sad beyond words. What happened to Luna really feels like a metaphor for Equestria Girls as a whole. It's just this sad, watered-down, washed-out version of MLP.
"Seeing her reduced to this vice principal," Nothing wrong with being a vice-principal. "easily tricked by every villain," What villains was she tricked by besides Sunset and The Dazzlings? And even then, everyone was tricked by them. That's not exactly a low-bar for her. "barely relevant," For as much as I like Princess Luna... She's kind of barely relevant, too? That's something her, and her human counterpart, have in common. "certainly not immortal or magical," True, fair enough. "What happened to Luna really feels like a metaphor for Equestria Girls as a whole. It's just this sad, watered-down, washed-out version of MLP." Is it really all that much of a watered-down or washed out version of MLP? It barely tries to emulate MLP in the first place, Its own thing, and personally, I think it did alright with what it was/is.
About the dye for toys, some darker dyes tend to make the plastic/vinyl/polymer they are used in more brittle then lighter dyes. The brittle brown Lego bricks come to mind here
Pinkie's family is objectively based on the Amish or similar cultures. There is nothing that remotely suggests she's "black," not even having curly hair. We know this because there are characters like Sapphire Shores who is based around the black pop diva archetype.
The argument I used to see was when she dressed like flava flav and also she wore her hair as "afro puffs" once. But tbh this is just cope. White people can have hair curly enough for fros and pinkies family all have straight hair. I can see the races stated for the other ponies though. I'd say there's a chance Pinkie is MIXED but other than that she's white coded
@Sea_Anemone I don't think Pinkie Pie would care. She probably just rolled her eyes at best if not outright ignore any specific observations about her race and resume partying or making somebody question reality.
@@liiil8492 JKHDSJKSGJJG youre not wrong 😭 rarity's behavior in spice up your life makes me lean toward her at least being lightskinned for this very same kinda reason
@@Sea_Anemone It can also make sense if she was a ginger since a lot of gingers have really wavy/curly hair (I would know I am a ginger and mine naturally waves)
personally, i think big mac should've been a bit more orange-red toned to compensate for the sunburnt look. still looks fine from official palette standards, but doesn't look jarring. though i don't know what was going on with the standards, because luna is just atrocious.
Giving the eq girls races doesnt mean anything That sounds bad, lemme explain basically, it doesn't matter if Pinkie was black, that shouldn't offend anyone at all! Pinkie is still pinkie, so I don't get why people make such a big scene and whine when the ponies are given races which are HEADCANONS cause hasbro was too scared to do anything. (and body types...i hate those people who get so offended when someone draws a pony not as the "beauty standard"
Unfortunately this world is still far more racist than people realize, especially the people who get upset with something like Pinkie being black, it's racism.
I thought they made the humans skin lighter to be more pastely so that they could "work" with more clothes colors, cuz pastels are thought of as a "cheat to mame colors go together" sometimes, but yeah human luna is a hate crime
@maybelater6282 I mean it's not just because of the hair. I mostly headcanoned her to be black because I love finding myself in different pieces of media. At the end of the day, you shouldn't argue about what race a fictional pony is because WHO CARES???
@@ratsicle2107 I like that the ponies have very varied colors without sticking to a real skin color. That makes it possible for anyone, no matter what race they are, to identify with the character.
I do agree that they probably did do it for toy reasons I also think they were trying to avoid being accused of blackface and/or redface. (Native American equivalent of blackface) I also want to point out that they lightened Rarity as well. I don't know why but my guess is since they lightened the other characters Rarity looked darker in comparison
For the concept art, while I much prefer it I 100% think they made the right call with going with colored skin, because they would've definitely pissed people off by giving them canon skin colores/races
..So, why exactly are we making a huge deal out of the color of the rainbow -? I mean, if they changed their hair color I bet nobody would give a shit (unless if it was hideous). Kids aren't going to give a shit if they're a bit lighter or darker compared to their pony form. I mean I didn't notice it as a kid, so why should we care? They're all treated equally in the show. They even made differet creatures in the seasons to show different "races". I seriously don't understand the drama here. Is skin color the most important thing to worry about in MLP?
FAX FAX FAX FAX SPITTIN FAX!!🗣🗣 Ngl it's so old and annoying that ppl "blame" race on everything. Not everything is about race. Tbh if you keep non stop talking about it, doesn't that make you racist by itself? Like common ✋️🙄
as a kid i was confused as to why they had different shades, especially luna i was like who is that?? and now as an adult character designer it’s interesting to speculate why certain choices were made, not to the extent of blaming it on race, but it wouldn’t be the end of the world to use the og saturated colors (yet the world didn’t end with literally using white to make them pastel so whatever). i just find it amusing to make fun of the designs overall, it’s stupid and that’s the point (to me)
@@honeybeeboThe designs are stupid, but it's frankly not white washing like the dude says and none of the characters have confirmed races... That's why this video is silly, unnecessary and just rekindling the age old drama in the fandom. Headcanon characters however you like but never act like it's actually canon without solid proof evidence.
I agree. Nowadays, people think the only problem in the world is racism and every person in power is racist. I may not know if this is true but I know that not everything about color is about race. I lived in a place where racism wasn't very talked about because it wasn't a problem. Then I moved to a place where everyone keeps talking about how we should stop racism and the same people keep seeing racism in everything. I think it's about perspective.
Please use any other word other than whitewashing the word is used wrong already. Taking a dark blue horse and making her light blue isn't whitewashing. Yes, it's weird, yes, it probably has weird racial implications, my little pony isn't exactly known for good race representation anyway (i.e. the buffalo episode.), but it isn't whitewashing, there is no canonical race being taken away from any characters.
No, the words almost always used right already. I think you're confusing it for "blackwashing", which does not exist and only has a term because of "whataboutism" racists online who decided that there were too many brown characters. Not even just black ones, literally any character with the slightest hint of a tan. I blame anime. Whitewashing doesn't necessarily mean making a character white, as in the race, but taking their skin and lightening it to any degree with the assumption being that a lighter skin color is better, prettier, more attractive, cleaner, etc. Because apparently even a skin tone slightly darker and more natural than a tan is "unrelatable" and "off-putting", of course unless it's in anime and somebody has a gross fetish for brown skin.
@@caydorcat You are correct. what they did with Big-mac is fine. making him white is also fine. yes the pony version is dark red, and yes it would have made more sense for them to make him slightly darker. But applying that to pastel colored horses seems a bit far fetched.
big mac, why not make him brown? brown is a shade of red. red-ish orange... and it would look nice with the red. So why not? this isnt a genuine question, i know why not, but rip
How _dare_ you headcanon Twilight as Indian when she's _clearly_ Chinese? I even have (dubiously) canon evidence to back it up! In Feeling Pinkie Keen, Twilight burst into flame when she got suitably enraged. What else in MLP bursts into flame when angry? The Kirin. What culture do the Kirin originate from irl? China. Twilight = Kirin and Kirin = Chinese, therefore Twilight = Chinese, therefore Twilight = me. I can also prove that Rainbow Dash is Greek (Cloudsdale = Greek and Rainbow Dash is from Cloudsdale), Pinkie is Amish (her family has Amish vibes and Weird Al wrote Amish Paradise), Fluttershy is Japanese (anime stuff in Scare Master + fitting the Yamato Nadeshiko archetype), Starlight is Croatian (Tito and Communism), Sunset is Spanish (Dance Magic outfit), Smolder is a fox, Cranky Doodle is Assyrian, Tirek is Homo Erectus, Chrysalis is Martian, Discord is a literal dinosaur, Luna is a rabbit, and Celestia is a liquid
I burst out laughing seeing Starlight be Croatian because of Tito😂 (I'm Croatian so it was really surprising to see any mention of Croatia let alone like this)
Holy cow why is this such a massive deal. I mean most of the simpson's characters are bright yellow so why are the talking magical horses being raceless such an offensive terrible thing when they've never been coded to any race or ethnicity in the past. I'm just deeply confused on why people make this a big deal.
Twittards just can’t help but turn every little thing into a big deal and create issues where none exist. They need that validation for their insincere sense of morality.
0:30 "They just took the colors of the ponies (shows the ponies) and gave them to the humans (shows human pony hybrids that are all notably lighter in color than the original ponies)" well that answers the question
8:22 I’m not gonna lie I did laugh my ass off when I saw you’re artist rendition but you are correct 👍 as an artist and animator my colour theory went nearly bonkers whenever I saw how different they truly where. Like I get it they wanted to maybe turn down the saturation of the colours sure, fine whatever but they just went stupid with it.
I honestly hate how everyone think Pinkie is black. For what reason? Because she has curly hair? It's not even the extreme curls, it's quite light. I mean, she's inspired by Amish culture. Did people forget white people with curly hair exist? Did people forget anyone can have curly hair..?
@@reallyradrabbit Yeah. She's based on the Amish yet people portray her as black all the time? It's disrespectful to the Amish tbh. That's like a character being inspired by an African culture but people would portray them as white. Her only 'black' trait is curly hair (mane) which is NOT only a black people thing.
@Moravian_Mf huh bro? It's just a headcannon man and Amish doesn't exist in the mlp world so why does it matter? And who knows If that's true or not that it's inspired by that. The creator didn't say it's inspired so people can headcannon pinkie pie anything they want it doesn't matter dude
@@Sillybillycloudat_adaycare It's just a headcannon, sure but normal skin colors also don't exist in the MLP world. Pinke is based of the Amish culture, that's a fact. She wouldn't be black, she would be white because the Amish are so.
ok so i made a Reddit post about it but here are my Headcanons pony ethnicity based on real life fact and equestria fact,, of course its based on the old Equestria because if we really follow the rules of equestria and where every Pony type come from in canon of the show we can actually give a canon ethnicity to every member of the mane 6 so Unicorn are asian,, british and french (like seen from every Unicorn in the show) Earth Pony being creole with sub saharan descent and scandinave (again,, seen all along in the show) and pegasus are Mediteranea (being based of Roman and what they invaded) so ! with these information ! here is what i can say Twilight is Indian but grew in UK (if we see the concept art of Twilight for EG plus the fact that her hair are naturally curly like seen some time in the show,, and we ad the fact that shes asian we get an indian ! Rarity is Korean/japanese (litterally every commercial of EG played by real people is making her play by a korean/japanese girl,, dont be mad at me,, im not good enough to distinct both,,) but also her parents are the caricature of the foreigner in vacation Rainbow Dash is Italian,, litterally every design of clothes she wear is roman inspired so yeah we dont have to look more to see what shes going with Fluttershy is Greek ! most of her outfit is Gaïa depiction looking and Cloudstale is based of the Olympe ! Applejack is a Tennesse/Oklahoma Cowboy with German roots like seen from her uncle Apple Strudel and Finally ! Pinkie Pie is an Indiana Amish girl ! (people often forget that her hair are naturally flat and that she just doesnt take care of them and thats why they are messy,, but to make everyone happy,, ill mention that she maybe have Creole ancestor because it does work with the canon) and there we go ! thats the actual most canon ethnicity of the Mane 6 post you will see because i took litteral information from the show seen time and time again ! edit for youtube:if you want pictures to prove my points,, the original post i made have pictures
Good point, but the punctuation hurts my brain. I also do not want to look up a specific reddit post about MLP races, so please link so I can see the pictures.
I will never get these twelve minutes back... it's just a horse... it's not that deep... we don't actually see what the horse version's skin looks like because they have fur... they're *horses*
Fun fact: only a few EG characters actually have normal human skin colours when translated from their pony counterpart's. Examples being Applejack, Indigo Zap, Vinyl, who is a yellowish white skin toned human, but her skin tone is close to being like a normal lighter skinned human, Mr Cranky Doodle, Juniper Montage, possibly Scootaloo, Applebloom, Timber Spruce in a way, but that's mostly it.
Cheerilee looks acceptable in both palettes, Big Mac looks sunburnt to death and Luna's reattempt at fixing her palette just looks offensive. At least change the lips as well 😭 This is not whitewashing overall. They had to make change when they transcripted the palettes to humans. Whitewashing is not just making rainbow things lighter to help to the eyes.
YES! this is more making weird design details than whitewashing! they dont even have normal skin color, how can that be whitewashing when they're technicolor humans?!
why did they HAVE to do it tho? the colors read fine on the pony forms. i think the pony palettes on the humans seem jarring now because we’re used to the composition, and changing a big aspect of the color combos on the characters (more than they have in their pony forms) without working the other colors around to match the tone shift does make it look weird. big mac does look like he has a sunburn, but rainbow dash looks like she’s choking/freezing and fluttershy like she has jaundice, we just don’t notice it as much because we’re used to those color combos
idunno why people make pinkie black, there's a lot of white women with curly hair like her, and she's from an "amish" family, and when Hasbro made a collaboration with kotobukiya she was white. I'm just curious, cuz' saying she's black just cuz she has a curly hair is ironically racist XD
@@Friday1207 urrmh, actually the pie family is inspired in conservative and old Amish culture, where black people was like- well, not welcomed if ya' can tell, besides I'm just pointing a few reasons why I don't think she would be black, but it isn't an statement 🤫🧏♂️
@@caregato_zzz Okay, Amish people can still be black and saying you think a pony is black isn’t racist. Black people tend to have more curly hair and Amish people are predominantly white communities. You’re allowed to think what you want, and that “reverse racism” thing you tried to pull was weird
I'm fine with ur opinion, though it doesn't really seem like it's white washing since they're cartoon horses. Any of the ponies can be in any race personality wise since personalities aren't really locked with any sort of race. And I do get why Hasbro had to also use more pastel like colors to the eqg characters, due to the dark/super vibrant colors, it's hard to make them look somewhat normal, since most of their skins are mostly just different colors other than actual skin tones from white to black(which if they do this in the show, most of them would look normal since the colors are actual skin color.)
How would you describe Luna and Big Mac’s EQG versions? Cause they sure ain’t accurate to the pony versions…. Because they’re WHITER…. Being white washed literally by definition
@@caidwab Every character in Equestria Girls was given a lighter skin tone, even Rarity if you look side by side. If Equestria Girls is whitewashing than Pony Life is too.
@@caidwab I'm sorry that humans based on cartoon horses being white causes you this much distress. You should probably talk about that with a therapist
@@caidwab the skin tone that most of the characters in the show have more pastel skin tones. The only one that I could make of as a "super vibrant" color is sunset shimmer. Which works for her design at least. The reason you gave about white washing does make sense, though it should be noted that white washing is not only just changing the skin tone, but it's changing the race of a character to being a white person. Sure Luna could be a black person since it's a head canon of mine, but making her skin tone the way it is as the original show wouldn't look great. And adjusting like cxcd would work in a way for this one since blue on blue could work a lot more for the expressions. But in my honest opinion I do not have any problem with luna's final design as a whole in eqg.
That og concept art is pretty cute, I don't know why they didn't do that style. I like the sort of chibi, it matches the pony's style but human. They could still make her purple, just keep the design. Reminds me of Strawberry Shortcake.
The Luna swap is pretty extreme. Like it makes her look sort of like a black character design. I feel like they would've realized the issue if they had to convert a brown pony instead of a dark blue. Like "wait, we're turning this dark brown pony into a very light tan, maybe we should rethink this". They're meant to be race ambiguous, but they're still turning a dark character into a light character for "design and marketability" reasons. Not egregious, just shortsighted.
though i agree with your gripes with their designs, this is a terrible understanding of what whitewashing is and borderline insensitive to the real representation issue of whitewashing genuinely hope nobody's take after this is that whitewashing is a non-issue. because in this context it seems like it
i think that them having colorful skin tones can be nice as a way because everyone can have their own interpretations of them, in a way. but then, with some of the official figures, it undoes that a little. like with the Hello Mini World figures, theyre ALL very pale. i sort of wish they didnt do that, because it ruins the whole idea of keeping their fantasy skin tones in the first place. for example, i like to imagine rarity as Filipino because she reminds me of my grandma :) and its not necessarily 'wrong' OR right because its a fun fan interpretation of a fantasy character
The fact that people will find a way to bring race into EVERYTHING will always amaze me. Like who tf really sat down to watch EG and went, "... why tf are the colors like this? They should be THIS shade of blue!!🤬😡🤬" and then get offended because they assume it's a racist decision. I guarantee those kind of people are a big reason racism is still a big issue today.
Unless everything til minute 1:14 is satire...I think its your headcanon...so what I think the argument is is that people are bothered that equestria girls took a rainbow route instead of accomolishing thier headcanons. For me the reason of the lighter colors is that now they have to match with an outfit...and just putting the same shades of color is too heavy on the eyes.
While I see your point…. ITS A FLIPPIN FICTIONAL CHARACTER 😭 I’m positive that most people didn’t notice because they don’t hyperfixate on skin color when watching movies unless it’s specifically about skin color
I am a person of darker color and see no problem with it cause. When I am watching a movie I don’t really care about the characters skin color, unless it is blatantly obvious like Ariel
Hasbro making human Big Mac look sorta Caucasian, and moving his pony color to a clothing scheme color makes some sense, since it'd fit better with him being kin to Applejack, and how "white" she looks, and how related humans often have similar skin colors. Dunno if I see any sense to the other character palette changes outside the Apple family, though. Seem pretty arbitrary for the others.
It wouldn’t have been an issue if they simply color picked the ponies’ coat colors and slapped them on the human designs. Instead they lightened every single coat color to some extent for every human counterpart. It’s not as noticeable on the mane 6 but it’s there, the colors are all at least a few shades lighter.
Granted, I compared EQG's and our MLP characters side by side. They pretty much lightened everyones skin tone, even Rarity's somehow. I think its way more an artistic choice rather than anything
Pinkie has a family based on the amish culture, a culture that has almost none or basically non black people, i'm sure Pinkie isn't black Because she's pink
As an artist, I thought it was because they wanted to clarify the difference between skin and fur. I mean, I don't know what kind of skin color horses actually have, but I did realize, even as a kid, that giving the human characters the fur color of the ponies would have been confusing character design. Although I also thought as a kid, that the whitewashed characters you showed were bad design. Because of the inconsitency in logic compared to the other human characters.
Me and my friends were discussing this topic not even that long ago. They did Luna, Cheerilee, and Big Mac SOOOO DIRTYYYY. Luna’s EG Design pisses me off the most. The pale ass blue is so UGLLYYY, they really could’ve been used her season 1 design instead of making her this ugly ass pale blue.
While analyzing Luna I noticed something, it may seem at first like her skin tone came out of no where, but no, they made her pony EYESHADOW her SKIN TONE. Yep. Eyeshadow 😭 and then had the AUDACITY to give her that OUTRAGEOUS pink eyeshadow 😭
it could’ve been a smidge (A SMIDGE) better (but still bad overall lol) if they just made her human eyeshadow her pony fur color. flipping her eyeshadow and fur color is a bit less weird than that stupid pink
The reason the pony skins were changed is because they look ugly as humans with their base colors. It's harder to read Big Mac's facial expression as a red human. Ms. Cheerilee being inverted is peak parallel universe character design. Luna just looks offensive. Twitter would have lost it seeing human Nightmare Moon. At the end of the day Hasbro is trying to sell toys, ain't nobody wants a red hillbilly.
that’s cause they’re hastily edited recolors with no changes to the surrounding colors and overall palette balance, and not enough outline contrast. if big mac had his saturated pony hair color, darker red outline, and not red shirt color, it would overall look/read better. plus we’re just used to their palettes as humans, again if their whole composition was edited to fit more saturated/darker colors overall, the skin change wouldn’t seem so jarring. i find it weird that simply keeping the palettes from pony to human form is more offensive than deliberately choosing different colors. also i want a red hillbilly :( (they’re called rednecks for a reason LOL SORRY) but they never even sold dolls of big mac so what’s even the point lol
I think the reason why they didn't give Big Mac any type of Redskin tone is because they were worried about native American offensiveness especially considering I believe when Equestria girls is being developed there was a lot of controversy around the Redskins team
![กี่หมื่นฟ้า | Your Sky Series EP.1 [1/4]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vLGjxFL6U_I/mqdefault.jpg)
the people in the comments completely missing the point that EVEN THOUGH they made all the characters technicolor, they still decided to make all of them have light skin (as in, all of them are light versions of their original colors). even if they arent any literal human skin color thats still a conscious decision, they could just as well have made all of them darker shades of the rainbow instead. its still implying that light skin is the default. most arguments i see defending the decision go so far as to imply light skin is the superior aesthetic choice, like the character designs would be unreadable, match poorly, or in any way uglier with darker skin. that mentality is the issue.
I mean...I've even seen people say dark skin just "doesn't work" with pastel colors. Which, is completely wrong. Easiest way to tell someone either doesn't know about color theory (or colors in general), is colorist/racist, or both. Often both, because nobody who isn't a racist would argue for the lightening of fictional skin colors...or cry about a horse getting a human skin color alongside a human form.
fr like people being like "oh it isn't technically white-washing because x and y" and it's like the video + your comment explains pretty clearly why it is it's not that hard to comprehend
Please. I literally have an oc with dark blue skin, and light brown eyes, and hair that's white and sky blue. The colors go super well together actually.
Perhaps it's because the actresses are white???
@@Vesperad0 dark skin can completely work with pastel colors if it's slightly washed out. See Luna's pony form. She's not a saturated dark blue, she's a more dull dark blue to not be a burden to the audience's eyes.
The biggest gripe with these designs is that they gave our himdo ,Big Mac, a twink body😔
so true
Definitely. He should've been a muscular god. He is the muscle of the family
@@nerfpup3089 word. Apple Jack should’ve been a bit more muscular, but I have less of a problem with that
LMAO THE OPPOSITE OF TWINK DEATH
@@Napkinthekat twink revival
Catty from Monster High has black and pink color palette. Everyone loved her. Why did hasbro assume we wouldn’t accept Luna or Cheerilee etc.
oh my god catty’s design is so peak
As a child I had never seen a doll I wanted so desperately as much as I wanted catty. I wish there were more dolls with a whole range of skin colors, including black and "ugly" colors. Who knows, a lot of ugly colors look amazing when paired right.
...aside from the minstrel dolls I found a lot. I would prefer the all black dolls don't look like blackface "jokes". Catty should be the blueprint
@@Vesperad0 As a sprite artist who's done SO MANY RECOLOR JOBS for people's pokesonas and pokemon trainers: there are no ugly colors, only artists who need to let go of their security blanket color swatches and learn color theory.
I was able to make KHAKI GREEN WORK. KHAKI GREEN. _BABY POOP GREEN_ WORKED OUT. If someone like me can make undigested poop green work as a legitimately pretty color on something with just two hours of fussing with shading, highlights, and secondary/tertiary colors, then no color can be genuinely ugly.
And I managed to make an outfit that was literally aggressively high-visibility mandarin-orange-peel orange look good on myself, just because I chose the right clothing pieces to pair up and pull the outfit together.
If I could do those two miracles, then it really isn't that hard to make dolls with a good range of colors and dolls with "ugly" colors work out, because I'm no fashion designer and my color theory knowledge comes from Megaman fans' sprite recolor tutorials.
omg! I had catty as a kid! i remember thinking she was so cool and unique looking
I personally love the idea of Celestia being a dark tan/middle brown tone and Luna being extremely pale to reflect their different relationships with the sun.
My main human Headcaonon of Them is that they are Mixed race Luna is Darkskined and Celestia is White passing.
i just think it would be hilarious if celestia was pale and burned extremely easily, and luna is the opposite, for the exact same reason. the irony and sisterly joking about it would be wholesome lol
@shamiyahzow8525 I have seen luna with dark skin in fan art, but why does she if the moon only reflects from the sun ?
@@skootergirl22 Luna's Coat Color is Supposed to Match the Night sky more supposedly so Our Night sky as she Doesn't Match the night skies of Equestia,Her Design is not Just the Moon but the Concept of Night itself afterall The Moon itself is Only One of the things she brings and Even with the Moon in the Sky reflecting the Sun's Rays shine as Bright as it might but the skies Still gonna be Dark Regardless.
Especially on Starless nights And full Moons
@@skootergirl22 and Most People Just Don't Look at her and think She's White there is Fanart of a White Luna. but Most of the Fandom Agrees that She is a Black Woman or atleast a Darkskinned Woman Even the Company that Makes Offical Mlpfim Anime figures Saw Luna and made her Black plus Fo someone Like Me Growing up As a African American girl Seeing her Coat and how drop dead Gorgeous she was Just Gave me the Reassurance that Dark colored characters and People in fact gorgeous so for me if she was a Human she was a Black princess and one of the Only three I know. Princess Luna,Princess Aisha (winx club)and Princess Tiana
This is also a problem with the toys. Luna wasnt her actual color until 2018 with the reboot line
the hello mini world figures haunt me
And they made her older sister pink instead of white for some reason
Her toys have a very pretty color palette but they definitely aren’t Luna
@@PatchworkRose567 I think the toys where luna
Pikawh0 I think the toys are good just the way they are
I remember back in the day where human Twilight in fanart was consistently drawn with darker skin and i miss that time
She still is today 😊 🤎🤎🤎
Yeah don't know what you're talking about. I RARELY ever see white twilight or pinkie pie so this is just bs
@RubyCat_7 They mean she's often drawn with purple skin. There isn't exactly a deficit of black twilight drawings, but it's slightly less prevalent nowadays
@@RubyCat_7 Guess i havent been on twitter as much lol, from my experience twilight was drawn consistently as the whitest lady you ever seen post Equestria Girls but then again that was ten years ago and i havent been keeping up as much
@@OceanGlow-jv8kj That's a good thing. Purple twilight is neutral. It's better than people fighting over her being white or black when she isn't even a human to began with
Thing is, there IS darker skin tones in Equestria Girls… in Sunset’s and Twilight’s “demon” forms. The character designers had the full knowledge and ability to design appealing, readable characters with darker skin tones, and they only used it for the villains. That to me makes it *worse* than just having no darker skinned characters at all tbh. I remember a few years ago on a EQG retrospective video someone brought up the whitewashing of the characters in the comments and people acted like they were being ridiculous, I’m glad someone else is speaking about this because I DO love EQG but we can still point out its flaws
That's actually insane to think about
I FORGOT ABOUT THIS. gdi
People were acting like they were being ridiculous because they were being ridiculous. Modern westoid race obsession is an uniquely obnoxious phenomenon. If a humanized version of a cartoon horse being white causes you distress you should discuss it with your therapist.
Villains are dark for obvious reasons though. It's not skin colors, it's normal colors.
Anything darker seems scarier.
dark = bad. its not a race thing, its been a media trope since media began.
Let's not forget about Silver Spoon. She may not appear in the media as much, but she still falls under the "Miss Cheerilee" treatment with her hair and skin colors being swapped. Honestly, I kinda hate the fact that Hasbro made basically every character's skin color as light as possible because it becomes very jarring when you compare it to their pony counterparts. Now that I'm thinking about it, the background characters in EQG are so much more interesting to look at rather than in FIM because at least in EQG all the characters look very unique from each other rather than copy/pasted versions of each other with different colors. I mean, as an example, just look at Twinkleshine and Lemon Hearts. They literally have the EXACT SAME HAIRSTYLE!!! I get it's probably easier to not have to animate background ponies this way, but if EQG can make the background characters look unique then why can't FIM
I didn't even notice her color scheme was swapped until I looked it up- rare case of it looking good, ig?
Silver Spoon's original colour pallet would have looked like Vaggie from Hazbin Hotel.
That is to say, _fine._
I deadass thought you were talking about an object show character and almost shit myself, but agreed
@@GrayAvian same
@@GrayAvianBRAH SAME
6:55 there is this one person who made a 100% human Luna once that made her have the skin condition of vitiligo so she has the dark skin to match her dark fur as a pony and the light skin to match the fandoms headcanon of her human skin color.
Vitiligo is almost always the answer. It's just cool, no matter how much people try to make it a ""woke"" thing to endlessly complain about.
I also think it's an interesting idea because, unless you have a tattoo on your design, there's no physical trait on them to represent their cutie mark besides their outfits. So, the light parts of the skin caused by vitiligo could help represent that in a way...? Idk if my point is getting across well, but the moon on her cutie mark is light and the dark sky on it has a spotting pattern to it like it fades out into her dark blue coat.
@@WeAreKAV you talking about Michael Jacksons skin thing ❔❔
@@Safalmao yeah.
That makes so much sense! Especially with Luna’s cutie mark
I love your "they shouldn't have race... but X is totally Y". It's every conversation I ever have about this. lol
I like they don’t have a race too so everyone could pick which race they want the characters to be. Or at least skin colors or whatever.
That's why I like Sonic franchise. You can choose any headcanon for any Sonic character and no one has a right to bash you for this.
I headcanon Sonic as a Whasian (like fr, how can he tolerate so much spicy chilidawgs?!!).
@@peachesandcream22 my Lola is Asia and she can’t even handle pepper because it’s too spicy 💀my Mexican friend can’t handle spicy food either
he's wrong about fluttershy, she's totally arab /lh
@@AstronomicalJelly Mmmmm okay- but he's also wrong about rainbow dash- shes definitely filipina.
Im a doll collector myself & i think the darker dye cost is lowky BS , equstria girls in the end of the day is a rip off of monster high & monster high from the beginning had characters with darker skintones , cleo & clawdeen for example both have darker skintones, hell they even made catty & wydoma who are straight out black , mattel clearly had no issue w this then why cant hasbro do the same? They have the money to give the dolls darker skintones they just obv dont want to
Yeah. Keeping Luna's lips darker with her skin tone works better like the way you drew it. If you keep them light, it looks too much like blackface. I agree that they did overcorrect.
I think ultimately they didn't go with human skintones is because of doll sales. They might have considered matching them up with human skintones (Indian Twilight) but it wouldn't have sold as well as a white Twilight. I remember reading that sales numbers have shown, even among black children, white dolls sell better. Which is its own sad can of worms. I also remember talking to a grandma who "couldn't find a white Dora the Explorer" doll because had never seen the show. Eventually after talking to her grandchild's parents she laughed at herself and got the doll obviously but it shows a certain prejudice we haven't shaken yet.
I don't think Hasbro was willing or ready to move the needle on that yet. They wanted a success and to try and sidestep the issue for now (plus, they'd be more immediately recognizable). They also wanted to compete with Monster High from Mattel which had lots of unnatural skin tones.
I want to add MLP fandom -especially bronies- are like conservative and ultra right. It's the same people who created Aryanne, so
@@liiil8492 Where the hell have you been? Conservative? Ultra right? Do you go to actual conventions? Do you see the content the fandom produces? Don't believe the one article and memes taken out of context. The MLP fandom is LGBTQ af.
@@liiil8492 @liiil8492 I highly disagree. I've found them very liberal and very pro LGBT. There's a small minority who are vocal who created aryanne. I've been to lots of cons and lots of websites. Bronies are very lgbtq. Lots of bronies with very masculine hobbies who are the same way. The aryanne thing is blown so out of proportion it's ridiculous. I saw her creation. I've been in those spaces. It's not what you think. Yes those people exist. Obviously. But a lot of it is just teenagers with unfunny edgy humor who don't know when they're talking to people who think these things unironically.
@@liiil8492 I don't know what group you hang out with but I strongly disagree. The vast majority are not that way and the ones that are like that are a vocal minority.
@@Hyreia This fandom borns in 4chan, I think that's enough to explain what's was going on lol. According to a survey in its golden age (2012-2014), mostly of bronies were white and leftist. There are articles reporting that this fandom is a hotbed of extremists (worse: natzeh). The way they react when they banned Aryanne? Marenheit 451. I want to think things has changed cuz i'm in this fandom.
“It would be harder to read their facial expressions ):”
MLP uses colored lineart, and tbh because of that it’s sometimes already hard to read their facial expressions. If they really cared about that they would’ve made the lineart slightly darker in the first place. There was no good reason to change Cheerilee and Luna’s skin tones like that imo. It’s just cause they didn’t want their humanoid characters to be too dark skinned. 😔
Coming from an autistic person who’s SPECIAL INTEREST is My Little Pony, I had no idea that was CHEERLIEE. I am literally just finding this out. That does NOT look like her.
They literally just inverted her colors of her skin/fur and hair 🤚😭
that's a stretch, she still has the same hairstyle and eyes, all they did was invert the colors..
I agree. i think it might just depend on the person.
Same, i thought she was a random extra character.
@@Helloqiiand theres plenty of background ponies who use cheerlie’s base model
Of course if you don’t use the normal colors people wouldn’t tell who it was
every time theres a discussion about race in equestria, people always fail to mention Zecora and the other zebras from the comics, the Ponies of Saddle Arabia, and the town of Somnambula, Corriander Cumin and his daughter Saffron Masala all have very obvious inspiration from real life cultures, including Pinkie's family of Amish inspiration. Furthermore, its not subtle the American AND Canadian influence in the MANE part of Equestria. so there is no canon race for the main characters cause none of them are of those very obvious influence. And not for malicious reasons, its for the same reason they made them pastel humans, so a kid of any skin color can have a chance to connect with all the main characters and buy ALL THE DOLLS!
Did they also forget Mistmane/her kingdom & the kirins, inspired from East Asian folklore?? Lol
Unfortunately Zecora wasn't used in the show _nearly_ as much as they wanted to, and a lot of those other characters were just one-offs, but I totally agree with you
Why wouldn't a kid connect to a character if they were a little darker?
@@KnightDog145why would they? it’s blue
Nah fr- say pinkie is black but yall remember how she treated/talked about Zicora? Like internized racism? I guess-
Luna and Cheerilee are definitely the worst cases of whitewashing in Equestria Girls' case. Luna is a darker shade of blue in Friendship Is Magic (following Luna Eclipse) and Cheerilee is also darker toned in the actual show.
So, why are both of them suddenly super pale-toned in Equestria Girls?
Thats what the video is about
@@milesd0texe385 I made the comment before I watched the rest of the video.
@@wadeyhyena1657 rookie mistake
@@wadeyhyena1657 But why though
I mean not hate but ether your trying to say Celestia and luna are mixed or they are both white lol. Because Celestia is her sister and very much white.
I always viewed Pinkie as a white Irish redhead but there’s this mlp human 1920s au art where she is Hispanic (not sure on the specifics) and it was so beautiful
ooh is it the one by bixels? i love their au
me too? But not irish but german ish? Because her parents are amish. Unless she's adopted. Which ig was a popular theory in the fandom
@@AstronomicalJelly yup that’s the one
@@lapetitefleur3482 ooh those make sense too
Honestly, i thought pinkie would be a mix of German and Irish, maybe a bit of Scandinavian.
4:10 he looks sunburnt tho
I understand making him tan, but this tone just looks like he fell asleep on the beach
I mean it's like what he said about rainbow, if we were to apply real life medical diagnoses such as sunburn, we would have to apply cyanosis to rainbow but there's no way around that bc shes.. simply blue. Big Macintosh is simply red.
and Fluttershy looks like she has jaundice. what's your point
@@regigigaslover6541 that it looks bad.
I really don’t like how they did Luna and Celestia in general. From princesses to Principal and vice principal? Really? Luna is whitewashed and celestia is pink… celestia also seems to have a different personality at least in the first movie.
About the personality, since she is a Principal and not an Queen with more than 1000 years i think it kinda make sense
I mean, when pony Celestia was younger, she was pink too. This is the only one where i don't think anything needs to be changed.
@@raineblackstar3522that is Not Canon the Only reason why she Pink was For the Toys and then When Cadence came into the Picture they Made her White.
We don't know If she was Pink when she was Younger,Plus That's a Weird jump From a Pink coat to a White One.
Yes,Luna has a blue coat that turned Dark Blue But at Least the Shade of Blue they used for her Younger self Was in the Same Color Family of the Darker Blue.
Pink is a Different color from White and Pink is Basically just a Lighter shade of Red,If she was Pink She would have Still been Pink as a Adult probably just a Lighter shade.
@@shamiyahzow8525 you know white can come from any colour in the palette, right? Most often, it's from red. But what if it's from pink, hmmm? It would still be a very light shade of pink, appearing as white.
@raineblackstar3522 Her Coat is Mainly just White...but some sources say it does have a little tinge of pink....But it Mainly is Just White.
I feel the term 'lightwashed' is more appropriate for this kind of cartoon.
THANK FUCKING GOD SOMEONE POINTS THIS OUT even as a brainwashed kid i looked at luna and immediately thought 'what the fuck wheres her melanin'
How old were you then?
@@ethancox9737 bout 9 or 10 i'd say, mind you i obviously wasnt thinking those exact words but i remember feeling extremely offput by the fact luna's skin was turned so pale for reasons i genuinely couldnt figure out (i grew up to illustrate/design so i guess being nitpicky about this stuff put me down that path a bit too LOL) but yeah to this day i think luna's original fur color would've worked better on her than what they ended up doing
@@skippingseaglass Ok, got it. I was already an older teen when Equestria girls came out.
I always found it strange what they did to Big Mac, and never noticed what they did to Cheerlie. I didn't notice Luna's appearance until recent, so how I am just so confused now.
If i can throw my hat in the ring i feel like this combined with how hasbro treated Zecora and Zeberas in general might also play into it - i dont think they wanted to really incorporate many prominent diverse characters for fear of backlash (( which. Is stupid. )) and so instead we got washed out gross colored eqg humans and 33 minutes series total screen time of zecora
"(( which. Is stupid. ))"
I mean obviously not that stupid considering you ppl still created backlash over it even after every attempt to avoid it was made.
@@misakayy1911 check out this beautiful tree ==> 🌳
@@misakayy1911 look at this beautiful tree 🌳
I head cannon rainbow dash as Latina
why tho
Lmaooooo
I can't not see her as Brazilian. I also raise you... Sunset being a white latina. (I'm projecting a little cause I'm latina)
Latina Rainbow Dash is so real!!
Or Greek
And that is why they went with techno colored humans as well
Cause some folks are really weird about race
Yup i totally agree
I can't imagine "having" to change not even the races, but the harmless skin colors of humanized colorful ponies for grown men that made a whole children's show about them.
Let me be clear, I am nowhere near against people having "childish" interests. I am, however, endlessly annoyed with and frustrated by grown ass people who decide they're the main audience to pander to, and in this case have their racism impact the toys meant for children. There's a huge difference between appreciating children's media and invading spaces meant for children, and everyday I hate how those fourchan users practically exposed a generation to gore and unnecessarily sexual content.
@@Vesperad0 I get that. but i think there are more adults that watch mlp than children, so hasbro probably DID try to pander to them a bit more. not by much probably, it being a kids show and all. now i dont know if thats true so correct me if im wrong.
Doug did it for the same reasons & s a result, people started theorizing that the city Doug lives in(Bluffington) is ultra-radioactive & polluted to the point of giving everyone wild techno colored skin.
@@Vesperad0The idea that Hasbro didn't give them human races because of bronies is actually pretty ridiculous if you think about it for any length of time. If they were basing the show on bronies, Flash Sentry wouldn't have been a part of it, and the setting wouldn't have been high school. Bronies didn't like Equestria Girls at all when the concept art was first leaked. Hasbro made that decision because they wanted to sell toys to more children. Full stop. What Hasbro cares the most about is their bottom line. They probably showed some kids in a focus group test images and asked them which one they like the best and the colorful ones were the most popular.
In Big Mac's defense, I thought they changed his skin color cuz red skin on a human would resemble the racist caricature of native americans too much.
Thank you for bringing this up!! I usually don't see other mlp fans talking about this issue even though it's, at least to me, pretty bothersome.
Just a heads up though, one of the other reason Hasbro might've lightned big mac's skin tone besides it just looking off, is the bright red skin would've been way too reminiscent to offensive native american caricatures, which very often had bright red skintones. I do agree with you, though!
That still doesn't really make sense though because nothing about big mac implies that he's based off of native americans. And its not like theres really much of a history of people accusing characters with red skin being caricatures unless they were clearly meant to be native american caricature's. Plus if that IS somehow the reason big mac's red skin was taken away then why did sunsets demon form get red skin? If your not letting one of the good guy's family members have red skin because of racist caricatures would it not arguably be more offensive to then give the villain red skin?
@@LizzieMaee Honestly, this is simply one of the theories I saw floating around on why Hasbro made that creative choice and since MLP does have a big usamerican audience, it made enough sense to me. However, your point about sunset shimmer is very valid! It could be argued that maybe since it's a demon form, demons are usually depicted with red skin anyway, but maybe that's giving Hasbro the benefit of the doubt too much... Fair point either way!
Seeing these side by side made my jaw DROP- they could've just not included those characters 💀💀💀
I feel like the colors on the characters speak to an odd fear with the character design. Making technicolor humans meant keeping the pony colors, but that would make half their cast tan (at best.) The way it's done almost makes me feel like someone on the team with decision making power sat down and went "the skin needs to be lighter than the original coat, that's how skin works" without any notice or care for how fucked up that sounds.
I always thought it was weird how light they made luna, i get they made everyone shade light but they made her EXTREMELY LIGHT to the point I didn't register her as luna at first
I genuinely feel they should've just made them have human skin tones. Yeah, a lot of people would be angry if their headcanons weren't true, but I have always personally thought the unnatural skin tones created a weird problem with the designs. I get them wanting to make all the colors lighter is to make them read as more human, but like... They could fix it by just making them have human skin tones?
Also, just for funsies because you mentioned your headcanons, I have always headcanoned human Luna as being black with vitiligo as a human, with the vitiligo representing her cutie mark being of a night sky with a moon (the moon is a light color of course, and the night sky seems to fade out with a spotted pattern, like the patterns people with vitiligo get on their skin). Then I flip flop with Celestia, because I also headcanon her as black but I sometines imagine her as a human having albinism and sometimes not.
Ooooh I’ve never thought about vitiligo for Luna before. I really like that headcanon!
7:28 this could definitely work if the eyeshadow and lips were darker.
IKR
Luna is literally the Princess of the Night. Seeing her reduced to this vice principal, easily tricked by every villain, barely relevant, certainly not immortal or magical, and obviously *whitewashed* version of herself is sad beyond words.
What happened to Luna really feels like a metaphor for Equestria Girls as a whole. It's just this sad, watered-down, washed-out version of MLP.
How was she Whitewashed? Celestia is always portrayed as White and she is her sister.
"Seeing her reduced to this vice principal,"
Nothing wrong with being a vice-principal.
"easily tricked by every villain,"
What villains was she tricked by besides Sunset and The Dazzlings? And even then, everyone was tricked by them. That's not exactly a low-bar for her.
"barely relevant,"
For as much as I like Princess Luna... She's kind of barely relevant, too? That's something her, and her human counterpart, have in common.
"certainly not immortal or magical,"
True, fair enough.
"What happened to Luna really feels like a metaphor for Equestria Girls as a whole. It's just this sad, watered-down, washed-out version of MLP."
Is it really all that much of a watered-down or washed out version of MLP? It barely tries to emulate MLP in the first place, Its own thing, and personally, I think it did alright with what it was/is.
@@MrConredsX Celestia is the Princess of the Day. Of course she'd be a light color. Luna is the Princess of the Night. She should be a dark color.
OI. Equestria Girls is PEAK. I will not stand for this SLANDER. /s
@@Cxcd XD
i don't think the right term is whitewashing since they are ponies, but ik the point ur trying to get across
BENRY PLUSHIE PFP!!!
What term would you suggest instead?
@@bumblebly I don't think there is one. they're pastel colored people. i think saying it's straight up whitewashing is a bit far fetched.
It makes sense technically, since it's of making something too light or 'clean' unnecessarily
It does make sense because theyre dark skin coded. Coding is a real thing
About the dye for toys, some darker dyes tend to make the plastic/vinyl/polymer they are used in more brittle then lighter dyes. The brittle brown Lego bricks come to mind here
Pinkie's family is objectively based on the Amish or similar cultures. There is nothing that remotely suggests she's "black," not even having curly hair. We know this because there are characters like Sapphire Shores who is based around the black pop diva archetype.
The argument I used to see was when she dressed like flava flav and also she wore her hair as "afro puffs" once. But tbh this is just cope. White people can have hair curly enough for fros and pinkies family all have straight hair. I can see the races stated for the other ponies though. I'd say there's a chance Pinkie is MIXED but other than that she's white coded
@Sea_Anemone I don't think Pinkie Pie would care. She probably just rolled her eyes at best if not outright ignore any specific observations about her race and resume partying or making somebody question reality.
Makes sense, she was the same pony who spread rumors and was scared of Zecora 😭
@@liiil8492 JKHDSJKSGJJG youre not wrong 😭 rarity's behavior in spice up your life makes me lean toward her at least being lightskinned for this very same kinda reason
@@Sea_Anemone It can also make sense if she was a ginger since a lot of gingers have really wavy/curly hair (I would know I am a ginger and mine naturally waves)
personally, i think big mac should've been a bit more orange-red toned to compensate for the sunburnt look. still looks fine from official palette standards, but doesn't look jarring. though i don't know what was going on with the standards, because luna is just atrocious.
3:52 he looks like a strawberry with his freckles
I would like drawing him like that
Cheerlie looks like a student in Equestria Girls. Putting her colors in the correct spot makes her look older
Giving the eq girls races doesnt mean anything
That sounds bad, lemme explain
basically, it doesn't matter if Pinkie was black, that shouldn't offend anyone at all!
Pinkie is still pinkie, so I don't get why people make such a big scene and whine when the ponies are given races which are HEADCANONS cause hasbro was too scared to do anything.
(and body types...i hate those people who get so offended when someone draws a pony not as the "beauty standard"
Agree. If she's under 180, she ain't a lady.
omg thank you, i've always thought this, never found anyone who agrees with me.
Unfortunately this world is still far more racist than people realize, especially the people who get upset with something like Pinkie being black, it's racism.
pinkie pie is amish.
Honestly not giving the ponies definitive races was the smartest move they did
Cause man some people are weird and insane when it comes to race
I thought they made the humans skin lighter to be more pastely so that they could "work" with more clothes colors, cuz pastels are thought of as a "cheat to mame colors go together" sometimes, but yeah human luna is a hate crime
1:02 BASED?
oh brother
Bruh
Besides the hair, I will never understand why people automatically say she's black. Every race can have curly hair.
@maybelater6282 I mean it's not just because of the hair. I mostly headcanoned her to be black because I love finding myself in different pieces of media. At the end of the day, you shouldn't argue about what race a fictional pony is because WHO CARES???
@@ratsicle2107 I like that the ponies have very varied colors without sticking to a real skin color. That makes it possible for anyone, no matter what race they are, to identify with the character.
I do agree that they probably did do it for toy reasons I also think they were trying to avoid being accused of blackface and/or redface. (Native American equivalent of blackface) I also want to point out that they lightened Rarity as well. I don't know why but my guess is since they lightened the other characters Rarity looked darker in comparison
For the concept art, while I much prefer it I 100% think they made the right call with going with colored skin, because they would've definitely pissed people off by giving them canon skin colores/races
..So, why exactly are we making a huge deal out of the color of the rainbow -? I mean, if they changed their hair color I bet nobody would give a shit (unless if it was hideous). Kids aren't going to give a shit if they're a bit lighter or darker compared to their pony form. I mean I didn't notice it as a kid, so why should we care? They're all treated equally in the show. They even made differet creatures in the seasons to show different "races". I seriously don't understand the drama here. Is skin color the most important thing to worry about in MLP?
FAX FAX FAX FAX SPITTIN FAX!!🗣🗣
Ngl it's so old and annoying that ppl "blame" race on everything. Not everything is about race. Tbh if you keep non stop talking about it, doesn't that make you racist by itself? Like common ✋️🙄
as a kid i was confused as to why they had different shades, especially luna i was like who is that?? and now as an adult character designer it’s interesting to speculate why certain choices were made, not to the extent of blaming it on race, but it wouldn’t be the end of the world to use the og saturated colors (yet the world didn’t end with literally using white to make them pastel so whatever). i just find it amusing to make fun of the designs overall, it’s stupid and that’s the point (to me)
@@honeybeeboThe designs are stupid, but it's frankly not white washing like the dude says and none of the characters have confirmed races... That's why this video is silly, unnecessary and just rekindling the age old drama in the fandom. Headcanon characters however you like but never act like it's actually canon without solid proof evidence.
I agree. Nowadays, people think the only problem in the world is racism and every person in power is racist. I may not know if this is true but I know that not everything about color is about race. I lived in a place where racism wasn't very talked about because it wasn't a problem. Then I moved to a place where everyone keeps talking about how we should stop racism and the same people keep seeing racism in everything. I think it's about perspective.
@patatesdomates574 FAX FAX FAX SAY IT LOUDER FOR THE PPL IN THE BACK ‼️‼️🗣🗣
Please use any other word other than whitewashing the word is used wrong already.
Taking a dark blue horse and making her light blue isn't whitewashing. Yes, it's weird, yes, it probably has weird racial implications, my little pony isn't exactly known for good race representation anyway (i.e. the buffalo episode.), but it isn't whitewashing, there is no canonical race being taken away from any characters.
No, the words almost always used right already. I think you're confusing it for "blackwashing", which does not exist and only has a term because of "whataboutism" racists online who decided that there were too many brown characters. Not even just black ones, literally any character with the slightest hint of a tan. I blame anime.
Whitewashing doesn't necessarily mean making a character white, as in the race, but taking their skin and lightening it to any degree with the assumption being that a lighter skin color is better, prettier, more attractive, cleaner, etc. Because apparently even a skin tone slightly darker and more natural than a tan is "unrelatable" and "off-putting", of course unless it's in anime and somebody has a gross fetish for brown skin.
@@Vesperad0 I am aware black washing isn't a thing. I'm saying we shouldn't put recoloring a pony on the same level as making a black character white.
@@caydorcat You are correct. what they did with Big-mac is fine. making him white is also fine. yes the pony version is dark red, and yes it would have made more sense for them to make him slightly darker. But applying that to pastel colored horses seems a bit far fetched.
this
this feels like a really high-quality brony video id see in 2012
big mac, why not make him brown? brown is a shade of red. red-ish orange... and it would look nice with the red. So why not?
this isnt a genuine question, i know why not, but rip
How _dare_ you headcanon Twilight as Indian when she's _clearly_ Chinese? I even have (dubiously) canon evidence to back it up!
In Feeling Pinkie Keen, Twilight burst into flame when she got suitably enraged. What else in MLP bursts into flame when angry? The Kirin. What culture do the Kirin originate from irl? China.
Twilight = Kirin and Kirin = Chinese, therefore Twilight = Chinese, therefore Twilight = me.
I can also prove that Rainbow Dash is Greek (Cloudsdale = Greek and Rainbow Dash is from Cloudsdale), Pinkie is Amish (her family has Amish vibes and Weird Al wrote Amish Paradise), Fluttershy is Japanese (anime stuff in Scare Master + fitting the Yamato Nadeshiko archetype), Starlight is Croatian (Tito and Communism), Sunset is Spanish (Dance Magic outfit), Smolder is a fox, Cranky Doodle is Assyrian, Tirek is Homo Erectus, Chrysalis is Martian, Discord is a literal dinosaur, Luna is a rabbit, and Celestia is a liquid
Yo this cracked me up 🤣.
This is Genius Level interpretation
I burst out laughing seeing Starlight be Croatian because of Tito😂 (I'm Croatian so it was really surprising to see any mention of Croatia let alone like this)
Thank you. I can see maybe, some, implied white washing... I guess???? But none of the characters have confirmed races so it's just kinda stupid...
This comment feels a bit weird to me in some places…
Holy cow why is this such a massive deal. I mean most of the simpson's characters are bright yellow so why are the talking magical horses being raceless such an offensive terrible thing when they've never been coded to any race or ethnicity in the past. I'm just deeply confused on why people make this a big deal.
Fr 😭
Twittards just can’t help but turn every little thing into a big deal and create issues where none exist. They need that validation for their insincere sense of morality.
And THIS is why im 99.9999999999997% sure this video is satire.
That's what I am saying. Like they are literally magical pony skin humans, there is no "whitewashing" the characters are literally PINK AND PURPLE.
the only dark characters in the show end up being villains, that’s why.
The early bird gets the worm
How are you in the past
HOW?!?!?
How?
bro time travelled 💀💀💀
Magic
4:05 He looks sunburnt 😭 it looks even worse
THHK pfp
0:30 "They just took the colors of the ponies (shows the ponies) and gave them to the humans (shows human pony hybrids that are all notably lighter in color than the original ponies)" well that answers the question
8:22 I’m not gonna lie I did laugh my ass off when I saw you’re artist rendition but you are correct 👍 as an artist and animator my colour theory went nearly bonkers whenever I saw how different they truly where. Like I get it they wanted to maybe turn down the saturation of the colours sure, fine whatever but they just went stupid with it.
I honestly hate how everyone think Pinkie is black. For what reason? Because she has curly hair? It's not even the extreme curls, it's quite light.
I mean, she's inspired by Amish culture.
Did people forget white people with curly hair exist? Did people forget anyone can have curly hair..?
you hate that everyone thinks she’s black??
@@reallyradrabbit Yeah.
She's based on the Amish yet people portray her as black all the time? It's disrespectful to the Amish tbh.
That's like a character being inspired by an African culture but people would portray them as white.
Her only 'black' trait is curly hair (mane) which is NOT only a black people thing.
@Moravian_Mf huh bro? It's just a headcannon man and Amish doesn't exist in the mlp world so why does it matter? And who knows If that's true or not that it's inspired by that. The creator didn't say it's inspired so people can headcannon pinkie pie anything they want it doesn't matter dude
It doesn't matter what race ppl headcanons the human ponies. Just don't force ur opinions on other ppl
@@Sillybillycloudat_adaycare It's just a headcannon, sure but normal skin colors also don't exist in the MLP world.
Pinke is based of the Amish culture, that's a fact.
She wouldn't be black, she would be white because the Amish are so.
ok so i made a Reddit post about it but here are my Headcanons pony ethnicity based on real life fact and equestria fact,, of course its based on the old Equestria
because if we really follow the rules of equestria and where every Pony type come from in canon of the show we can actually give a canon ethnicity to every member of the mane 6
so Unicorn are asian,, british and french (like seen from every Unicorn in the show)
Earth Pony being creole with sub saharan descent and scandinave (again,, seen all along in the show)
and pegasus are Mediteranea (being based of Roman and what they invaded)
so ! with these information ! here is what i can say
Twilight is Indian but grew in UK (if we see the concept art of Twilight for EG plus the fact that her hair are naturally curly like seen some time in the show,, and we ad the fact that shes asian we get an indian !
Rarity is Korean/japanese (litterally every commercial of EG played by real people is making her play by a korean/japanese girl,, dont be mad at me,, im not good enough to distinct both,,) but also her parents are the caricature of the foreigner in vacation
Rainbow Dash is Italian,, litterally every design of clothes she wear is roman inspired so yeah we dont have to look more to see what shes going with
Fluttershy is Greek ! most of her outfit is Gaïa depiction looking and Cloudstale is based of the Olympe !
Applejack is a Tennesse/Oklahoma Cowboy with German roots like seen from her uncle Apple Strudel
and Finally ! Pinkie Pie is an Indiana Amish girl ! (people often forget that her hair are naturally flat and that she just doesnt take care of them and thats why they are messy,, but to make everyone happy,, ill mention that she maybe have Creole ancestor because it does work with the canon)
and there we go ! thats the actual most canon ethnicity of the Mane 6 post you will see because i took litteral information from the show seen time and time again !
edit for youtube:if you want pictures to prove my points,, the original post i made have pictures
Good point, but the punctuation hurts my brain. I also do not want to look up a specific reddit post about MLP races, so please link so I can see the pictures.
@@sharkiboi9248 i tried to link but TH-cam is not acceptin links,,, its really frustratin
@@RedAxeDisciple Darn
I will never get these twelve minutes back... it's just a horse... it's not that deep... we don't actually see what the horse version's skin looks like because they have fur... they're *horses*
u chose to watch this no one gaf if u “wasted ur 12 mins”
@@yumjums someone took what I said personally
but they are... colorfull O_o
When humans don't have skin matching COAT color:
Fun fact: only a few EG characters actually have normal human skin colours when translated from their pony counterpart's. Examples being Applejack, Indigo Zap, Vinyl, who is a yellowish white skin toned human, but her skin tone is close to being like a normal lighter skinned human, Mr Cranky Doodle, Juniper Montage, possibly Scootaloo, Applebloom, Timber Spruce in a way, but that's mostly it.
Cheerilee looks acceptable in both palettes, Big Mac looks sunburnt to death and Luna's reattempt at fixing her palette just looks offensive. At least change the lips as well 😭
This is not whitewashing overall. They had to make change when they transcripted the palettes to humans. Whitewashing is not just making rainbow things lighter to help to the eyes.
THANK YOU. This is such a non-issue, it's not even funny.
YES! this is more making weird design details than whitewashing! they dont even have normal skin color, how can that be whitewashing when they're technicolor humans?!
@@L3mon-Juic3 Oh come on, do not begin to discuss semantics you know very well what whitewashing means here
why did they HAVE to do it tho? the colors read fine on the pony forms. i think the pony palettes on the humans seem jarring now because we’re used to the composition, and changing a big aspect of the color combos on the characters (more than they have in their pony forms) without working the other colors around to match the tone shift does make it look weird. big mac does look like he has a sunburn, but rainbow dash looks like she’s choking/freezing and fluttershy like she has jaundice, we just don’t notice it as much because we’re used to those color combos
I can already tell what the comment section is going to be like
idunno why people make pinkie black, there's a lot of white women with curly hair like her, and she's from an "amish" family, and when Hasbro made a collaboration with kotobukiya she was white. I'm just curious, cuz' saying she's black just cuz she has a curly hair is ironically racist XD
Amish people can be black, saying she’s white because she’s Amish is racist by your logic
@@Friday1207 Most Amish people are white.
Realll
@@Friday1207 urrmh, actually the pie family is inspired in conservative and old Amish culture, where black people was like- well, not welcomed if ya' can tell, besides I'm just pointing a few reasons why I don't think she would be black, but it isn't an statement 🤫🧏♂️
@@caregato_zzz Okay, Amish people can still be black and saying you think a pony is black isn’t racist. Black people tend to have more curly hair and Amish people are predominantly white communities. You’re allowed to think what you want, and that “reverse racism” thing you tried to pull was weird
8:34 I immediately thought it should replace the one in the show, it's beautiful
She is ugly, but there should be no changes. She deserves to be in cinema.
I'm fine with ur opinion, though it doesn't really seem like it's white washing since they're cartoon horses. Any of the ponies can be in any race personality wise since personalities aren't really locked with any sort of race. And I do get why Hasbro had to also use more pastel like colors to the eqg characters, due to the dark/super vibrant colors, it's hard to make them look somewhat normal, since most of their skins are mostly just different colors other than actual skin tones from white to black(which if they do this in the show, most of them would look normal since the colors are actual skin color.)
How would you describe Luna and Big Mac’s EQG versions? Cause they sure ain’t accurate to the pony versions…. Because they’re WHITER…. Being white washed literally by definition
@@caidwab Every character in Equestria Girls was given a lighter skin tone, even Rarity if you look side by side. If Equestria Girls is whitewashing than Pony Life is too.
@@caidwab I'm sorry that humans based on cartoon horses being white causes you this much distress. You should probably talk about that with a therapist
@@caidwab the skin tone that most of the characters in the show have more pastel skin tones. The only one that I could make of as a "super vibrant" color is sunset shimmer. Which works for her design at least. The reason you gave about white washing does make sense, though it should be noted that white washing is not only just changing the skin tone, but it's changing the race of a character to being a white person. Sure Luna could be a black person since it's a head canon of mine, but making her skin tone the way it is as the original show wouldn't look great. And adjusting like cxcd would work in a way for this one since blue on blue could work a lot more for the expressions. But in my honest opinion I do not have any problem with luna's final design as a whole in eqg.
@@caidwab Weirdo, you most definitely have sent artists death threats over making a char, a bit lighter. These are colourful ponies with no races.
That og concept art is pretty cute, I don't know why they didn't do that style. I like the sort of chibi, it matches the pony's style but human. They could still make her purple, just keep the design. Reminds me of Strawberry Shortcake.
1:35 as someone with native genetics i agree (totally not because i love her so much shshhsh)
The Luna swap is pretty extreme. Like it makes her look sort of like a black character design. I feel like they would've realized the issue if they had to convert a brown pony instead of a dark blue. Like "wait, we're turning this dark brown pony into a very light tan, maybe we should rethink this".
They're meant to be race ambiguous, but they're still turning a dark character into a light character for "design and marketability" reasons. Not egregious, just shortsighted.
though i agree with your gripes with their designs, this is a terrible understanding of what whitewashing is and borderline insensitive to the real representation issue of whitewashing
genuinely hope nobody's take after this is that whitewashing is a non-issue. because in this context it seems like it
this is an aesthetics issue, not a race issue
boiling down race to skin color is all levels of wrong
Pinkie is amish.
i am NOT hearing yall out
i think that them having colorful skin tones can be nice as a way because everyone can have their own interpretations of them, in a way. but then, with some of the official figures, it undoes that a little. like with the Hello Mini World figures, theyre ALL very pale. i sort of wish they didnt do that, because it ruins the whole idea of keeping their fantasy skin tones in the first place. for example, i like to imagine rarity as Filipino because she reminds me of my grandma :) and its not necessarily 'wrong' OR right because its a fun fan interpretation of a fantasy character
The fact that people will find a way to bring race into EVERYTHING will always amaze me. Like who tf really sat down to watch EG and went, "... why tf are the colors like this? They should be THIS shade of blue!!🤬😡🤬" and then get offended because they assume it's a racist decision. I guarantee those kind of people are a big reason racism is still a big issue today.
What a jumpscare 9:41 also why do you have a summoning ritual in the background?
I remember being so shocked seeing Luna for the first time because WHAT ARE THOSE COLORS??
Unless everything til minute 1:14 is satire...I think its your headcanon...so what I think the argument is is that people are bothered that equestria girls took a rainbow route instead of accomolishing thier headcanons.
For me the reason of the lighter colors is that now they have to match with an outfit...and just putting the same shades of color is too heavy on the eyes.
While I see your point…. ITS A FLIPPIN FICTIONAL CHARACTER 😭 I’m positive that most people didn’t notice because they don’t hyperfixate on skin color when watching movies unless it’s specifically about skin color
I am a person of darker color and see no problem with it cause. When I am watching a movie I don’t really care about the characters skin color, unless it is blatantly obvious like Ariel
Hasbro making human Big Mac look sorta Caucasian, and moving his pony color to a clothing scheme color makes some sense, since it'd fit better with him being kin to Applejack, and how "white" she looks, and how related humans often have similar skin colors. Dunno if I see any sense to the other character palette changes outside the Apple family, though. Seem pretty arbitrary for the others.
It wouldn’t have been an issue if they simply color picked the ponies’ coat colors and slapped them on the human designs. Instead they lightened every single coat color to some extent for every human counterpart. It’s not as noticeable on the mane 6 but it’s there, the colors are all at least a few shades lighter.
Granted, I compared EQG's and our MLP characters side by side.
They pretty much lightened everyones skin tone, even Rarity's somehow.
I think its way more an artistic choice rather than anything
i grew up thinking twilight was black, but that could just be bc i saw a lot of me in her
Holy shit dude that's a big ass cat
Are you people seriously complaining about the skin tone of the characters of a multicolored fictional fantasy kids cartoon?
3:24 propyl like he about to become a nickelodeon character with those three spiky strands of hair
Fun fact g5 was going to have it's series that's based on equestria girls and there's leaked dolls about it but got cancelled last year.
“Except for pinkie, she’s definetly black”
Me: amen brother
Pinkie has a family based on the amish culture, a culture that has almost none or basically non black people, i'm sure Pinkie isn't black
Because she's pink
@@jonal5126 bro's never heard of a headcanon
I don't get it, where is the problem? This video doesn't make sense.
Read pinned comment
@@CrowExistinggggg it's a matter of taste
Why do people say pinkie is black she is so white twilight is maybe black but PINKIE thats the whitest person ive ever seen
SHE LITERALLY AMISH
8:31 THE COLOR SCHEME IS BETTER THOUGH
As an artist, I thought it was because they wanted to clarify the difference between skin and fur. I mean, I don't know what kind of skin color horses actually have, but I did realize, even as a kid, that giving the human characters the fur color of the ponies would have been confusing character design. Although I also thought as a kid, that the whitewashed characters you showed were bad design. Because of the inconsitency in logic compared to the other human characters.
Me and my friends were discussing this topic not even that long ago.
They did Luna, Cheerilee, and Big Mac SOOOO DIRTYYYY. Luna’s EG Design pisses me off the most. The pale ass blue is so UGLLYYY, they really could’ve been used her season 1 design instead of making her this ugly ass pale blue.
they did Luna the dirtiest
i like how I always try to watch your videos as objectively as possible with no side or opinion and I just keep on agreeing with you for everything xP
i saw the australian flag and immediately subscribed
Your race headcanons are so canon and so correct expect RD may be Latina or Native
While analyzing Luna I noticed something, it may seem at first like her skin tone came out of no where, but no, they made her pony EYESHADOW her SKIN TONE. Yep. Eyeshadow 😭 and then had the AUDACITY to give her that OUTRAGEOUS pink eyeshadow 😭
it could’ve been a smidge (A SMIDGE) better (but still bad overall lol) if they just made her human eyeshadow her pony fur color. flipping her eyeshadow and fur color is a bit less weird than that stupid pink
yippeeee racial discourse!!
The reason the pony skins were changed is because they look ugly as humans with their base colors.
It's harder to read Big Mac's facial expression as a red human.
Ms. Cheerilee being inverted is peak parallel universe character design.
Luna just looks offensive.
Twitter would have lost it seeing human Nightmare Moon.
At the end of the day Hasbro is trying to sell toys, ain't nobody wants a red hillbilly.
that’s cause they’re hastily edited recolors with no changes to the surrounding colors and overall palette balance, and not enough outline contrast. if big mac had his saturated pony hair color, darker red outline, and not red shirt color, it would overall look/read better. plus we’re just used to their palettes as humans, again if their whole composition was edited to fit more saturated/darker colors overall, the skin change wouldn’t seem so jarring. i find it weird that simply keeping the palettes from pony to human form is more offensive than deliberately choosing different colors. also i want a red hillbilly :( (they’re called rednecks for a reason LOL SORRY) but they never even sold dolls of big mac so what’s even the point lol
I think the reason why they didn't give Big Mac any type of Redskin tone is because they were worried about native American offensiveness especially considering I believe when Equestria girls is being developed there was a lot of controversy around the Redskins team