The amount of comments on this video that very obviously didn't watch it all the way through is ASTOUNDING. GUYS. I was GASLIGHTING you. Do you think the fandom has any say in whether or not CCM would come out at all? The entire first half of the video is me playing it up and acting angry at the fandom, before revealing that it probably isn't cancelled. There are a STAGGERING amount of comments down here that very obviously paused the video halfway through just to get angry. Jeez.
Na I think the comics are to adult, The changlings killed some cute animals in one comic, and they contradtic the show anyway. Do the camp cutie mark idea that looks cute,
The fact that Hasbro is trying so hard to scrub the internet of these leaks means there probably is something going on behind the scenes, but at this point there’s so much disinformation circulating that the truth has been lost.
I would 100% be down for this in all honesty. My biggest issue with G5 was how they completely ruined G4's world just by having the two of them be connected. But having everyone share the same space at the same time could really help the G5 characters.
Yo who cares what Hasbro wants I'm tired of all these companies being jerks to each other just aur a pony show of any type I do not care 💅😘 at all if they rebrand the characters so long as I can read butt loads of fanfiction pony. 🐴 🐎 nonsense just give me horses and poneys or I will go play ⏯️▶️ star ⭐✨ stable instead lol 😂 XD oveisly there's more than one pony 🐴🐎 show game 🎮🎯 toys and apps lol 😂 XD 🪀🧸 horses are cool 🆒 and I love all poneys and horses everywhere lol 😂 XD
Hasbro Executive: "Oh NO! Our G5 toy sales have plummeted! Quick add more G4 member berries! Hell add ALL the G4 member berries!" Marketing Team: "You realize that 30% of the target audience wasn't born until after Friendship is Magic ended right?" Hasbro Executive: "You realize thinking is my job not yours?"
That doesn't really matter considering Hasbro is still posting G4 videos and episodes to their official channels, and they get many more views than G5 to boot. In shops I only see G4 merchandise. G4 notebooks, G4 backpacks, G4 yoghurt. G5 is absent. G4 is, ironically, much more present in a very young girl's life than the newer series.
I don't want to be that guy guys but you guys are literally the reason why we can't have good things lol dude in the video literally just said give it a chance instead of just hating it off the bat. I understand not liking G5 but if that's the direction has been wants to go with don't try to clamor on to the past
At the end of the pilot, they set out to explore equestria searching for stuff, so it's not going to mostly take place at the camp, it's still going to take place all around equestria.
@@Pearl.Is.Autistic.SU.900 the GOD AWFUL spongebob Spinoff series. If you were a spongebob veteran, You'd know how spongebob and sandy originally met. Not in Kamp Koral.
The reason why so many are against this idea is because by this point nobody trusts big corpos to write a story, the only things they do in recent years is easy to produce slop with nostalgia bait. People are turning towards creator driven stories made by independent indie studios with unique visuals and attention to details, beacuse people who work on these shows usually personally connected to them in one way or another. This cutie mark camp thing is the most toothless idea imaginable, the nasty popular girl and her annoying friends, main 4 consisting of the marketable 3 and Misty, the most recognizable pony of gen5, the characterization is confusing... those are the reasons why people are so sceptical of the new pony cartoon.
I agree mostly. But I don't think the intention was to reuse these characters. Probably just reusing their personalities as placeholder. But again, the concept itself does feel like a hasbro exec using chatgpt to create a 'trendy' reboot for mlp.
Companies don't write a story the creative team behind the scenes and the shows write the story not the corporations themselves they just making their money and control the projects they either high budget the projects to make sure the best it can be or completely screw it over
Yeah your right I’m so tired of animation studios that I’ve given up hope, I’m just watching their old shows because those ones were the only good things they made (and I have no respect for Disney or Netflix those two are the most horrible studios in the whole world in my opinion) this is why I watch indie shows like TADC or BFDI or anything that is indie because those creators are the only ones who care now
One thing id like to add is please don't bring back social media/advanced technology, it really kills a show when you need cellphones or tablets to push it forward even if its just for one small episode that doesn't mean much to the plot
The disaster of G5 also makes me feel bad for some of the amazing artists who worked on it as one of them known as Imalu started as one of the most famous and talented artists in the fandom before being hired to work on MLP G5 in 2017 as a lead concept illustrator and character designer so the visual style of the characters was pretty much based on her iconic art style that she had established after a few years of doing commissions full time for members of the fandom! :)
I've come to the conclusion that whenever a "leaker" tells us something is "dead" we just have to wait to find out what they REALLY MEAN cause they're absolutely just giving us a red herring rather than giving the whole answer 😂
Absolutely. IMO that guy was just playing with us and lying to get attention. People do that all the time, why would this random ass guy be any different lol.
The idea seems rather cringey... Well, and the fact that only half of the original six remains sounds rather depressing. However, given that the pony-verse has been cancelled, there is less reason to worry UPD By the way, I'm interested in these accusations that we, the MLP fandom, killed the ponyverse, considering that it was canceled before we even knew about it. Like, what? I would understand this discontent if the project was canceled after Hasbro saw our reaction, but no, as far as I understand, it was canceled long before the leak happened Personally, I would give a ponyverse a chance, even if my first impression of it is negative, just to either make sure I was right or to learn that I was wrong. Low expectations do not equal hatred and refusal to watch the show, they are just low expectations.
It isn"t that hasbro cancelled because of the fans, it is the fact that the Mlp fandom don"t seem to give the project a chance, it was the same thing when the first G5 leakers happened. Alsp, it is supossed to be a new generation, so i don't see why it is such a problem to be just three of the mane 6, you don't see G3 fans complaining about Starsong not being in G4 or Scootaloo, Cherille and Sweetie Belle not being part of the main cast for example.
@@flowerdaisystar9593 I can't say anything about Scootaloo, Cheerilee and Sweetie Belle, because I don't know what role they played in the plot of G3, but I see a complete transfer of characters from G4 to the new cartoon. This is of course a personal opinion, but for me the new cast of main characters will always seem incomplete in this case, even if the plot turns out to be good, I can't help myself
@@flowerdaisystar9593 Actually, I thought about the plot a bit and now it doesn't seem so bad to me... This idea that the main characters of the cartoon live together in some educational institution, search for some artifacts and simultaneously confront bullies from another group, it sounds like fucking Harry Potter, and I love Harry Potter, haha! The only confusing factor is the attempt to combine the characters of G4 and G5. I think many will agree with me that if these characters are to be divided, making only half of the old characters part of the new cast of main characters, then at least it would be nice to have the old characters at least as secondary ones (like the residents of another house in the camp). Well, in fact, I feel sorry for the fans of G5 despite my dislike for the new generation. They probably loved all the characters from there, and seeing only Misty from them is even more depressing than seeing only Twilight, Pinkie and Rainbow from M6. In short, I am all for the new project, but I hope that all the other characters from G4 and G5 will also be in the plot at least occasionally.
The trailer almost feels like the set-up or intro for a mobile game, with the animation and plot - I wouldn't be surprised if this did come out, and what we've seen is the equivalent of the MLP FiM mobile game intro.
I feel like they need to branch out and finally try to market towards the adult/ teen side of the fan base. The reason g4 did so well in my opinion is because it wasn't super childish, and had heavier themes in some episodes; if they leaned into that we could have a pretty cool show. there's clearly a market for a more adult themed magical pony show as crazy as that sounds and i wish we could get it tbh!
You ask why the fandom so quickly lashed out at this concept and not give it a chance... were you not there for the Twilicorn drama? Or the Equestria Girls backlash? The fandom was ready to call these the end of the franchise and the death of the fandom when all we had was leaked promo art! This is pretty par for the course
Honestly a new Mlp series using g1 and g4 medieval/fantasy visuals with trying a little of the modern stuff of g5 would be fire, i just wish they focused in 2D animation or at least a 3D animation that looks better than G5, they could take a lot of inspiration from the g4 comics as well. Also i love the Banjo Kazooie music you use in these videos, they really fit with your narration haha.
4:58 "could you at least give this a chance??" Yeah I'mma stop you here my guy, I saw the actual pitch video and I have some...Things to say... To try and not have this comment be removed I'll say that while describing the video contents, Cxcd left out a very important character that was also featured in the video... There's another unicorn who is not a fan of the "main" unicorn in the camp. She is best described as your typical "popular/I'm better than everyone here" type of character. and no, this isn't Trixie or Starlight Glimmer, she's a new character for this series. It's just so wild that the purple unicorn had such a well established personality, was booksmart but also understanding and whatnot to only then have that stripped away and just have her be "lol I'm a quirky lil pony who doesn't know how to make friends" JUST USE NEW CHARACTERS!! I can genuinely see this series be better suited for a new group of characters. Maybe have the main character still be a unicorn who is really good at magic but not that great at social interaction. Show examples of her (or him! let's get real crazy) following steps from a book on "how to make friends" but always failing because real friendships don't work that way. The other characters can also have some sort of "fault" to them that also makes it difficult to make friends also but whenever they're together, they just somehow "work" Apologies for the long comment I just honestly can't really suspend my belief on a new show with established character that are just shells of their former selves :/
They probably will use nee characters. Twilight pinkie, Rd and misty are probably placeholder. Their personalities worked before and will probably work again. They'll probably model new characters after them
I binge watched the entirety of G4 for my first time earlier this year & absolutely loved it! Honestly can't wait for more FIM - really do hope they are able to make it appealing to adults & maturer audiences again...
Regarding that project: Hasbro has a strict policy of NEVER accepting unsolicited scripts or pitches under ANY circumstances. I know people who have looked into similar things before. I didn't personally so I cant' exactly call them out, so if you wanna ignore this, that's fine. I tried. If you submit something to them you will get a form letter in response saying they do not accept unsolicited pitches. If you are lucky they will ignore anything further you put out on it. They are usually pretty chill about fan stuff.
If we are, in fact, getting Camp Cutie Mark as an official show, I hope that it will be good. Great. Amazing, even! I may not like the idea of meshing G4 and G5 together and calling it Friendship is Magic 2.0, but it CAN be done well if the writers know what they're doing, which I'd hope they would. My main grievance is that G5 got cancelled so soon. Only thing that isn't clear is if we'll see any more of Tell Your Tale Season 2.
@@daraghokane4236 Agree to disagree on the shows. I absolutely love the movie, but I for one think Make Your Mark is really great, and Tell Your Tale is also of high quality (Albeit it's held back a bit more by more frequent writing issues, its general pacing, and its cancellation).
@@SmokeTheHorsehog I liked the song when they beat opilnce that was a banger, more villains beaten by songs in G6 make the elements of harmony musical instruments
To be fair, I would still give "Camp Cutie Mark" a shot but the concept itself is super disappointing seeing has how it shows they haven't learned from why G5 failed in the first place. CCM seems like a desperate attempt to follow trends instead of making a show that people would really care about and that would have longevity- the concept itself limits what they can do with the characters and world building super hard.
I went and looked at the tweet. I feel like it would be a super fun and cozy show to watch. I already recognize so many really old characters, to the newer ones, and all new ones. Something that would make this even greater? G3 Minty and her wonderful collection of socks. (Although it seems hasbro loves Minty just as much as me for having her in so much random merch, even with g5)
honestly I think also having even older characters come back would fix my problem with it. I personally am very unhappy with them only seeming to bring back half of the main 6... ill miss fluttershy too bad😭. But having someone like minty would feel like a good enough addition that I think I could put up with it.
@@craftterry9596Imagine this cute scenario: our main cast of characters are going around on their epic adventure. They’re lost, and are hostile to each other by getting upset. They then stumble upon a cottage, where a small pegesi is living, who is Fluttershy! They all become great friends before our main group leaves on their adventure again, having learned the value of kindness towards each other. There’s so much potential with this show. Just because beloved characters aren’t there right now, doesn’t mean we won’t have the chance to see them later down the road on an adventure. This has the potential to be something incredible that brings all the fans together, along with providing wonderful pony content for a new generation.
I really hope that Hasbro will not abandon the G4 timeline, because as I said it still has potential for growth. That's personally for me the most important thing
@@daraghokane4236 and I think that it's too early for new universe, because the potential of the G4 universe is not fully fulfilled. For example, we know less about ancient Equestria, so it's going to be perfect to see a prequel series about Celestia and Luna
Sadly as of now they don’t have full control of the seasons 5-9 because of Discovery. It’s been said that Hasbro will get full control back in 2025. So, a new universe is a better idea for now
Tbh I wish Hasbro would move on from G4. I get it, it was incredibly successful and made Hasbro a ton of money but at this point it feels like they trying to milk it because of said success
G4 appealed to adult fans, in part, because the main characters were adults who did adult stuff - like running a business or attending university - and faced adult problems - like Starlight's dictatorship rule, Chrysalis crashing a wedding, and quite often, literal life-or-death! The leaked video was very disappointing because it showed the characters as adolescents facing the childish problem of making friends at camp. Making friends at camp might be a big deal to kids, but it seems like a trivial problem to adult viewers who face and conquer far greater challenges in their real lives - like university exams, job hunting, and paying mortgages. Watching adolescent characters make friends just isn't interesting to adults. G4 was a success because it appealed to adults. But also, Bluey was a success because it appealed to adults! Obviously the show should appeal to kids too, but if it exclusively caters to kids it will get lost in the shuffle of all the other kids media competing for kids' screen time.
Personally, I miss them vibe of G4, but I'm not going to complain if they decide to continue with the style of G5. I'm happy with whatever Hasbro decides to do
5:22 Hey, sorry but I’m personally glad it was canceled. It’s not that I think that the show would be automatically bad- but at the same time it might’ve had a chance to be. Gen5 really needs to be left alone, why?, it’s because the series ended off on a really good note. It taught kids, like me who’s now 19 really good things that really built me as a person. And it also had a beautiful story that no longer needs adding to, sure, some characters I would love to know more about them but I don’t want the series to be added and added to.. This causes what used to be good to become bad, you don’t want to add too much to a story // you don’t wanna keep running it in the ground. This is like SpongeBob! I’m not huge into that, never was and probably never will be, I’m unsure if it has lore. But, the company it’s own by still keeps it going, it’s lost the funny in it because it isn’t the same. The humor is bad, to each their own if you enjoy it though. But it’s not the same like the old SpongeBob and that’s from it being continued instead of ended on a good note. A project looses its spark after kept going for so long. Gen6 is ASS, frankly, the writing is horrible but the comic, I’ll be honest the comic with discord is awesome, I cried at that comic from how well it was made and because they actually wrote Discord and Fluttershy right. But the show, it’s very bad, it has plot holes and the models could have more passion put into them. IM ALLOW TO CRITIQUE THAT BTW IM AN ARTIST!!! And a writer, and an aspiring cartoonist with ideas and stories and characters. I can critique all of this all I want.. Anybody creative especially a writer would genuinely understand my ranting and what I’m saying. And get what I mean when I say Gen6 has a lot of plot holes and things barely touched that needs explaining. Like lore PLEASE touch on Twilight way more, and explain how separation happened after the message Twilight and her friends spent years spreading around just for these new writers to flush it all down the drain, it’s ass writing. Nothing makes sense, and everything gets rid of a lot of the impact G5 left.
"Why don't we give it a chance?" Have you seen what's been coming out of the entertainment industry lately? It's blatantly clear that media from the higher ups is made in an eco-chamber these days. After being disappointed time after time after time again, people are just sick of it. How about you make a strong first impression or get out? I'm not going to waste my time "giving something a chance" if it doesn't capture my interest to begin with. All people care about these days is formulas to success rather than actually being creative and encouraging people to see it. It is blatantly clear on first impression of this cancelled mlp thing that they clearly only cared about the formula but not the passion. As a result, I am glad that it is cancelled, and I pray Hasbro doesn't even think about touching G4 again unless on the off chance they are willing to actually understand what made G4 good to begin with.
This should be pinned, I’m honestly fine without mlp camp coral. An amazing idea would instead have a series taking place in between G4-5, kinda like rainbot is doing with their story. I’d love a story that explains how we got from point a to point b and any inconsistencies can be properly explained
Good lord did you just made a reference to Canterlot Boutique? Sassy Saddles was initially all about formulas to success, and look what happened to all the places she was employed at. Hopefully Hasbro can let their Rarity do their job with TLC this time
Bruh why are you so pessimistic? Not everytime things will be Terrible just look at puss in Boots 2 everyone thought it's gonna be garbage but they give it a chance and suprisingly it was a masterpiece! So why not MLP? Maybe they could pull out something suprising too.. :/ You will never know what will happen for sure! Not everything is a lost cause.
Tbh my first reaction when you talked about this G4+G5 concept was rather repellent aswell. But not because it clench onto G4 and i don't want them to fuck it up. Quite the contrary. In my opinion one of the biggest drawbacks of G5 was how it desperately tried to hold onto G4. G4 would've never been as great if Lauren Faust hadn't come in to try something new. I want that again. I want new colorful horses I can fall in love with all over
I really enjoy the aesthetic of your set up Its like a bunker where you get to watch mlp stuff I hope when G6 does come around Hasbro lets creative minds work and get someone who knows what their doing. Its what made G4 so magical (no pun intended) and feel fresh cause it was a world Lauren Faust built on her own and it got a chance to breathe and develop .
I actually just watched the leaked pilot last night, and when I watched it, some parts fel fanfic like, but others I really liked. The big thing I don't like, is how they got to camp cutie mark. About them using g4 characters, I have nothing wrong with that. It looks like they're doing a complete reboot, where it doesn't take place in the same universe as g4 and g5, so we will be getting a fresh take on the characters. I love this, because it can make the characters better than they originally were. Heck, they did something similar with g3 and g4, since g4 has some ponies from g3, namely pinkie pie, rainbow dash, scootaloo, sweetie belle, and cheeralee. It can work. What really would make me groan, is if they try to tie in the events of g4 or g5, because I want a fresh take on mlp, not just hasbro latching onto a previous generation.
I don’t understand fans sometimes. If you want more mlp then you to be willing to give a new show a chance or you’ll never get more content. I agree with giving new shows a chance 100%. Also, while I love g4 I’d also love to see a show take a new direction with characters from g1. I know that’s what g4 did but there are so many other characters and different directions they could go starting from g1 and I would love to see it. Probably just a dream though with what it sounds like Hasbro interested in doing.
tbh it's mainly the fact that..the g4 characters already exist, camp cutie mark could be great! The cmc could run it, putting it in the universe of g4, and get cool cameos or episodes featuring g4 characters like twilight and Rainbow. Maybe there's a rising epidemic of adult ponies not getting their cutie marks as corporate businesses rise. It could also have g4 characters in the camp! Like Flurry heart, or lil cheese if they were REALLY desperate to make a g4 character a more important character.
Hasbro could desperately drag the corpses of their cash horses for a couple more years, and still get a pretty compelling and good story, and the fans would get more of the show they still adore without it just being g4 repackaged or obliterated! Everyone is happy
when they said they would bring back iconic characters, i was kinda hoping some from older gens would return as well, such as firefly from g1 and skywishes from g3. i would argue that the other gens (g1 and g3 especially) are just as important to mlp as g4 and g5. the mane six got their names, designs, and personalities from older ponies. mlp meant a lot to many children everywhere since the 80s, and i bet that they would love their childhood pony become their child's favorite as well. g5 did turn some older ponies into background characters, but it would be very cool to see some return in a major role.
3:23 so they’re COMPLETELY rewriting G4???? There WAS no “camp cutie mark” in G4 and that’s NOT how any of these ponies discovered their cutie marks! I hope this isn’t real.
I don't think they're going to reuse the characters. The collection of 'favourites' suggests to me that this was a test story using character personalities that work. Theyre placeholder for the moment
It would be a reboot. It's no different from Rainbow Dash completely changing her species and personality between G3 and G4. Or Applejack getting a southern accent, which she didn't have in G1.
i hope it has better writing, more like g4, and kind of the 2d looks of g4. As someone else said, g5 was a disaster and NOT thought through !!!! also early :3
I hope that these leaks are going to have the same story as the initial G5 leaks about the redesigned G4 characters in other universe, and we are actually getting continuation of G5 but now with greater connection to G4
someone named "Richel" on youtube actually has a video showing the leaks (probably not for long tho) personally i love the art style, since this is only a pitch changes are possibily going to be made but the art style is absolutely adorable. now the idea seems simple-- most popular mlp characters go to a camp and discover their cutie marks and friendship blah blah, its a simple idea but hey it works. a lot of people will have the problem of re-using the G4 and G5 ponies but people will complain even IF it was new ponies. my only complaint would be that in G5, the mane 6 got their cutie marks in such a specific and unique way, its going to be thrown out the window in this new series but im sure but i think i can get past it. i believe this would be a cute short series featuring everyones favorite characters, nothing too deep, just fun colorful ponies :3
They might get ther marks at the same time here also im guessing at the season one ending there fighting the bad guy learn there destiny and all get there marks right on the spot and beat them with harmony magic,
More disability representation, in this camp would be good have derpy have am actual visual and mental disability and make Fluttershy bad at flying not just because she is scard of heights but she physical can't. The pony show seemed afraid to have a character with a permanent injury or disability, they would imply it never say it directly. I don't see what is so wrong when people are born with them
I said it just now on one of your previous videos, that it would be interesting to see the Main 6 of G4 and the Main 6 of G5 actually interact with one another. And have them interact in a full series, would make it better.
It's insane how people are making fun of you or dissing your ideas and effort. You're not doing anything wrong AND you're putting in more effort than all the little haters combined. I'm guessing they're just jobless kids that have never been told you can be anything you want. Their loss, your gain.🎉
to be fair I think the idea of this could work. g5 was started WAY too soon and people were still connected and had childhood or just general nostalgia from the characters. with g5 people still like the characters and its still relatively new. so having a generation with all of them would be there best pet
Is this a SpongeBob Camp Coral situation where it's an alt universe where all the characters meet for the first time as kids, despite the original show contradicting it?
Nope it's completely new timeline not the same like SpongeBob or Angry Bird this is completely new time line but it looks interesting we already saw a camping episode in MLP Camp Everfree and marks and recreation both of them are really good so it will follow the same type of formula but with some sort of asshole pony trying to bully our main characters similar too Summer Madness but with a lot of Diamond Tiara spice
@@Godzilla5675 Come to think of it, I'm not sure what the difference between an alternate universe versus an alternate timeline. Could be that it's nearly 1 AM for me.
@@Amanda-zn7ox ok let me explain an Alternate timeline is a rewritten part of the same timeline and that's what Summer Madness and Kamp Koral fell into they are both in the same Timeline as their shows but since the main shows are already written very early on some parts make less sense for example Sandy met Spongebob in season 1 but in Kamp Koral they met way earlier as kids but an alternate universe is a completely new timeline completely disconnected from the OG show so this gives the writers more freedom to write a new story instead of following the same Timeline over and over and over again That's what Camp Cutie mark is a brand new universe with the characters we all know and love
New timeline and likely new characters. The characters in the short are most likely placeholder and used to test if their personalities would go well together.
Y'all ever heard of Wild Manes? It's a TH-cam cartoon with horses, similar to MLP. It's like MLP, but with normal horses. I think it's got a similar vibe to MLP too, it's got potential but it's not very popular atm. Since MLP is kinda dying... I figured why not talk about something new lol. I still LOVE MLP though, hoping it makes a strong comeback soon!
i need a 1 hour video of cxcd just saying "i don't know" im so excited for new updates from hasbro or anyone at this point- good or bad, i just want the community to be more alive again haha
I’m tired of waiting and seeing when I’m usually right when it comes to corporations. I would rather them never touch G4 again and instead, give me more new things to love without having to rely on a Gen that ended and has no reason to be continued.
@@tiglishnobody8750 not exactly because it wasn’t Hasbro that wrote the script and the story, it was Faust. Hasbro just owns it. G4 was finished in the way where everything fully ended . So Hasbro was just bringing it back because it’s popular, not because it has unfinished business.
@@BlackRaveBow Well Faust haven't been part of G4 since S1 so she may established project but it Hasbro who decide for G4 and also Twilight become alicorn is what Hasbro wanted to, without Hasbro you wouldn't have Twilight as Alicorn anyway
@@tiglishnobody8750 I mean, I’m not really here to get in a conversation and debate you. G4 ended in a conclusive way so it doesn’t make any sense bringing it back.
I actually desperately want a show with all the G4 and G5 ponies. I have fallen in love with the personalities of the G5 ponies and really want them to interact with G4 ponies, I think there would be a lot of cool friendship, rivalry etc; so honestly whatever this pony camp was going to be/may be, I’d actually enjoy it. For me, I just love the cute wholesome storylines when real life gets rough and I need a reminder of kindness. I enjoyed g5 unlike many fans. I think it’s cool that the world is expanding; I was a very little gal when I started to watch my little pony and played with toys (Gen 2/3) and grew up hardcore on Gen 3-4. I kind of want Starcatcher to come back. It’s the one pony toy I kept from all of my childhood; she was my very favourite pony in the world and I was absolutely mesmerised by her.
i dont like that it looked like even though it was G4 world with G5 characters coming in. The "Adult" poinies that already have their cutie marks only have them on 1 side o3o . i really hate if thats the direction cutie marks are going
I really don’t this leak. Removing g5 characters and only have misty and only have twilight pinkie and rainbow makes no sense to me like why remove characters like why? Just let g4 rest it’s over I know a lot of fans miss g4 but this isn’t how you do it
I dont think these characters will make a comeback. I think the idea was to use them as placeholders as a test story for a group with similar personalities
Gen 5 could have been so good if they took the positives from Gen 4 and mixed them with the Gen 4 improvement suggestions from so many fans. Personally that’s what I find saddest about Gen 5, they didn’t understand what made Gen 4 so popular and loved instead making it for kids and non loyal to the past (also they used the ponies not trusting the other pony species AGAIN😭 it hardly made sense in the Gen 4 finally why go the same route)
If Generation 5 of My Little Pony is enough to piss off Chris Chan then I can’t imagine how he would react to Generation 6 knowing that he’ll never get those last five seasons of MLP:FiM he’s been belly aching for.
Looking at the leaks, if I'm honest, the pony designs are more adorable and they do look like real ponies instead of the Tell Your Tale designs. Cancelled or not, I at least hope they fit Better to the ponies design
Its not what people want to hear, but G4 needs to end once and for all. I love G4 but Hasbro needs to start a new series like they've done with every other generation instead of clinging onto the past. Not a spin off or crossover with G4, something entirely new.
But Applejack, Pinkie Pie, and Twilight are from previous generations (and Fluttershy is based on Posey, while Rainbow Dash is based on Firefly). MLP is like Transformers. Do you expect them to get rid of Optimus Prime and Megatron in the next generation of Transformers? No, that's silly. Hasbro has never made a fully original generation (except for G1 obviously) and they never will.
@@snowblind9551 Unlike the main 6 we see in G5, the ponies from lets say, G1, are from a separate universe. The main 6 from G4 appear in G5 as the same characters, but in G1 they are a different version of those characters in a different universe. Hasbro just needs to let go of the versions of the characters that were introduced in G4, and move onto a new version for G6. The G4 Twilight, Pinkie, and Applejack need to go, they've had their time.
@@charlotte_poppy Oh yes, I agree, they need to be different universe. But G6 IS a different universe. But yeah, they could've used a redesign instead of recycling the exact same design from G4.
5:00 Back it up my dude, you had it right earlier- at least for a lot of detractors. Hasbro execs are being absolute assholes to a lot of beloved IPs lately. That's my only hesitation here. If Hasbro was acting like they were circa ~2008-9, trying to make The Hub a thing and all that, then sure, I (and I think a lot of the Camp Cutie Mark detractors) would be all for this. But looking at what G5 could have been, with the concept art, learning more about fhe scrapped storylines, learning more about CG animation (and how MYM looks like its rushed and not just incompetent) and rewatching the movie? Its soooo painful. A New Generation is GOOD. TYT is actually even generally hitting its stride, even in its now clandestine state. It would just hurt to see Hasbro hire more great creatives, give them existing great characters, and force them and these ponies to slowly drown due to corporate bullshit beyond their control. Maybe, given some time and with a bit more creative freedom, Hasbro can get their collective corporate heads out of their asses and we can see something better. This felt like a pretty half baked, Kamp Koral level plan, (So limited in scope, character age, time of year, etc) and I'm really hoping they're working on new pony concept that gives a creative team more to work with. But its not about "being caught up in the G4 characters," so much as the fact that tying a new IP to the old is YET ANOTHER stumbling block for a creative team to trip over while having to maneuver around these bullshit demands. The subtle incongrueties have been a thorn in the side of anyone who cared enough about the link between G4 and G5 to invalidate the shows' relationship in the first place. And we all have decent enough reason to believe now that the continuity issues were primarily due to business issues entirely out of the creative team's control. (I hold strongly that, for G5, they should have canonized Starlight Glimmer's presence when the Mane 6 got their cutie marks, made said Mane 6 slightly different, and the old fans ((both bronies and grown target G4 demo fans)) could have written off most retcons and embraced a new mystery.) Even if its a separate continuity, they were clearly angling it on being about "Iconic" (ie existing) characters, painting the creative team into a corner. They ain't exactly being allowed to eimagine characters like G4 did with Applejack or Moondancer from the looks of it. ...But it still could have been okay, if a strong team were allowed to cook. I'll grant you that, AND its basically the cornerstone of brony culture. We know how good things can get. I'm plenty willing to give up the girls in the name of a good, meaningful story- especially one that can provide meaningful lessons that can help real people. (MLP as something that helps people emotionally grow and learn is something I do value) Really, I even have a great deal of faith in writers and animators in the industry right now, and Hasbro can generally pick em really well. I just don't think they'd get to cook. Ultimately, we're on the same page here, so please don't pidgeonhole everyone with a less positive view in the same vein? Pony is far from the only IP Hasbro is fucking around with at the moment, after all. I'm so tired of them yanking around so much of the media I like
Tbh, I wish G6 had its own characters, world building, and concepts like g4. At the same time, it should have the same 2D style as the other generations. The problem with G5 was although it has its own story, most of it is pretty much dependent on G4. At the same time, they tried to attempt 3D animation which turned out kind of wonky and a little off. The reason G4 was successful was because its story was independent and just reused and revamped some characters from the former generations. At the same time, the show was appealing not only to children but also older audiences. I just hope G6 has the same charm as G4 while not being dependent on another generation.
I like the cutie mark camp idea its cute, Here is how I would make the show Twilight loves books and has no friends but her brother who left to go join the army, her parents decided to sent her to the camp, Pinkie pie and Rainbowdash just wants to go to the camp. The camp is near the everfree forest a dangerous and scary place. I want misty to be a changeling and her story is she is scared to tell the other ponys her secret,. Okey First episode The kids are told about a dangerous monster in the forest Rainbow goes out to see it and gets lost so Twilight and the other go look for her and Rainbow learns not to make reckless decisions
Yeah, the origin mane six of Friendship is magic might be in this G6 series, but I'm also notes that Misty going to be in it too, and writing this just remind me of the petition for another chapter of Make your Mark
Yeah I wouldn't really call a mish-mash of the three most popular characters of FIM and Misty a new generation. That really just feels like a G4 reboot with some G5 sprinkled in. Wasn't there an official comic or something a long time ago that had Minty, G1 Twilight and a couple other past gen ponies hanging out with the mane six? I would rather have that as a ponyverse than just the two generations. Heck, they could put G2 characters in there which don't have a lot of representation. I'd really like G1-G3 to be more present than just beyond the brand reusing names, I've been growing really attached to those incarnations over the past few years.
Before Hasbro asked everyone to take down the images. The replies to the tweet were so much crazy speculation about "This is made by AI" but like you said that would mean someone has made the world's greatest AI ever that no one has yet... I do agree it might be a new thing that is coming soon but base on the first video it might be a short series of shorts?
I use AI detector on image I saved and it have very least to be made by AI which is error as AI detector isn't prefect but it very accurate at least Beside it Concept Art so it not like this would came out like this
Welcome to the MLP fandom bud A show all about friendship and learning how to be a good person but 99% of the fandom know absolutely jack about friendship it’s kinda wild
I got a lot of comments on my Twitter post about this being “ai generated voices” but I made the argument that it really didn’t seem like it. Because if it were, they’d be carbon copies of what the characters sound like, and we didn’t get that, we got someone’s take on the characters voices in a narrative form. “Robotic” is crazy.
5:24 Personally I’m glad this show wasn’t made because it just felt too wrong. The mane six and old equestria’s story is over, gen 5 is definitely over, if they want to do a gen 6 I would either do a complete reboot of the universe or set it after g5 with new characters. I wouldn’t necessarily be afraid they’d “ruin” the old characters by bringing them to a new story, I just feel like their story is officially over and they got their ending
Having watched the leaked video, my biggest concern with it is the inclusion of the stereotypical 'mean girl' pony. FiM *mostly* avoided this outside of the CMC episodes, which weren't too frequent in the grand scheme of things. It makes me worry it'll feel, for lack of a better descriptor, like any other generic kids show. I also find this to be a weird mix of ponies for a potential 'mane 4'. Dunno, Im open, and its not like I expect anything after G4 to hit its heights of greatness or popularity, but G5 was still such a let down. this isn't necesarily a difficult premise to mess up imo.
5:14 - Considering how bad G5 was, yeah totally warranted response, Hasbro shouldn't touch G4 characters, not without Lauren Faust and Megan McCarthy involved 7:20 - it would be an utter tragedy if it wasn't cancelled yes, and knowing my luck theyll be ruining this next series 10:00 - If Fluttershy is in this Ill give it a chance, if they dont include her then the sin is too great and I wont. if the art style is a cal-arts garbage fest, Ill immediately turn away from it and refuse to give it a shot. I'm tired of the lowest quality garbage getting greenlit, I'm tired of the stupid decisions, Hasbro has not been treating MLP like the success it was, and that's why they keep failing, and if they decide to continue going down that path I wish them nothing but the worst possible failure, comparable to Concords failure, if they rectify their mistakes, then I wish them luck, but I am very black-pilled when it comes to the idea that Hasbro can learn from their mistakes, most companies are failing to do that, why should I believe Hasbro will be any different? want to be proven wrong, i dont like hating any MLP series, that's why I'm so damn harsh with this, because i dont want to hate anything else I dont want Hasbro to fail MLP again
The amount of comments on this video that very obviously didn't watch it all the way through is ASTOUNDING. GUYS. I was GASLIGHTING you. Do you think the fandom has any say in whether or not CCM would come out at all? The entire first half of the video is me playing it up and acting angry at the fandom, before revealing that it probably isn't cancelled. There are a STAGGERING amount of comments down here that very obviously paused the video halfway through just to get angry. Jeez.
@@Cxcdmade a comment here 2 months ago when the video came out, frankly you should know your audience (me) is extremely gullible (me)
this comment has strange vibes
A friend of mine described G5 as Cocomelon Horses.
I... fear G6 is shaping up to be Skibidi Horses
G4.1 might as well bite the bullet & turn it into kingdom hearts ...😅😅🤣🤣 confuse people more
Its a pub named scooby doo with horses,
this implies that g6 is gonna be animated with sfm 😭
that's weirdly... accurate description of G5... I'm shocked xD
THIS IS SENDING ME HAHA
All Hasbro has to do is animate the comic books and call it gen 4.5. There, everyone is happy
Na I think the comics are to adult, The changlings killed some cute animals in one comic, and they contradtic the show anyway. Do the camp cutie mark idea that looks cute,
omg fr
it would make a perfect Teen series.
Yeah, comic book adaptation is a great idea, I've been thinking about it for a long time.
But Hasbro is afraid of success
Fr I really wish we got some of the comics like stories in the show
The fact that Hasbro is trying so hard to scrub the internet of these leaks means there probably is something going on behind the scenes, but at this point there’s so much disinformation circulating that the truth has been lost.
>something going on behind the scenes
>not knowing that any company will send you cease and desist for a leak
??? are you dumb
I would 100% be down for this in all honesty. My biggest issue with G5 was how they completely ruined G4's world just by having the two of them be connected. But having everyone share the same space at the same time could really help the G5 characters.
you still think this was the problem, everything is horrible in g5, there nothing in it
IMHO G4's finale(s) kinda drove a stake into its heart to start with. G5 twisted the knife.
...It's a stake that turns into a knife, ok?
Yep
I hope it’s 2D again
Fr
Isn't it already in 2D as TYT
I hope it's 2D and the animation is better than g4 and doesn't look like g5 2d animation.
I love how they forget of TYT
Also what the problem of 3D?
@@tiglishnobody8750 3D animated shows are always just so idk mid
3:26 i like how this image looks like the popular kids (twilight, pinkie and rainbow) invited the new kid (misty) to sit with them on lunchtime 😭
Aww! 😄
Yo who cares what Hasbro wants I'm tired of all these companies being jerks to each other just aur a pony show of any type I do not care 💅😘 at all if they rebrand the characters so long as I can read butt loads of fanfiction pony. 🐴 🐎 nonsense just give me horses and poneys or I will go play ⏯️▶️ star ⭐✨ stable instead lol 😂 XD oveisly there's more than one pony 🐴🐎 show game 🎮🎯 toys and apps lol 😂 XD 🪀🧸 horses are cool 🆒 and I love all poneys and horses everywhere lol 😂 XD
@@randomshorts6862what the fuck
@@randomshorts6862 who uses emojis like that 😭
@@randomshorts6862 I also love horses and ponies so i definitely LOVE what this leaked My Little Pony "Ponyverse" series could be!
Hasbro Executive: "Oh NO! Our G5 toy sales have plummeted! Quick add more G4 member berries! Hell add ALL the G4 member berries!"
Marketing Team: "You realize that 30% of the target audience wasn't born until after Friendship is Magic ended right?"
Hasbro Executive: "You realize thinking is my job not yours?"
That doesn't really matter considering Hasbro is still posting G4 videos and episodes to their official channels, and they get many more views than G5 to boot. In shops I only see G4 merchandise. G4 notebooks, G4 backpacks, G4 yoghurt. G5 is absent. G4 is, ironically, much more present in a very young girl's life than the newer series.
@@TheGielnik in my country there are NOT A SINGLE thing from G4. EVERYTHING is G5....
@@TheGielnik I for one never saw any G4 toys, merchandise, etc. in any of the stores where I lived when I was growing up.
G5 was a total disaster. I miss the vibe G4 had, I hate modernized mlp
Really hope so. I lost nearly all interest in MLP due to G5 lol
I wouldn't say a disaster or a train-wreck it's just painfully mid..
I don't want to be that guy guys but you guys are literally the reason why we can't have good things lol dude in the video literally just said give it a chance instead of just hating it off the bat. I understand not liking G5 but if that's the direction has been wants to go with don't try to clamor on to the past
G4.1 might as well bite the bullet & turn it into kingdom hearts ... 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@rinnabinna lmao i gave it my full chances, it just wasn't for me
No...they're not doing a spongebob and making a camp series...right?
THAT WAS MY EXACT THOUGHTS OML qmq
At the end of the pilot, they set out to explore equestria searching for stuff, so it's not going to mostly take place at the camp, it's still going to take place all around equestria.
Would Pony Life be considered the camp spin off? Or more of a Patrick Star Show 🤔
G5 was going to be like A New Wish at one point but G5 took a turn
Don't compare them. MLP isn't gonna be like Spongebob
I really wish g4 would be allowed to rest and that G6 would have its own identity
They won't, they're gonna drag its corpse around forever to keep the bronies. Wish they'd been this vigilant about G1.
I agree. G4 is amazing, but its had its time, and Hasbro needs to let it rest in peace and create a new story.
Oh Thank Celestia, We didnt need a MLP Version of Camp Koral. I'm sorry, i feel like might've end up another Camp Koral.
Agreed, even though I don’t really know what show you’re talking about.
@@Pearl.Is.Autistic.SU.900 that spongebob spinoff show.
@@Pearl.Is.Autistic.SU.900 the GOD AWFUL spongebob Spinoff series. If you were a spongebob veteran, You'd know how spongebob and sandy originally met. Not in Kamp Koral.
@@Pearl.Is.Autistic.SU.900 spongebob. I'm talking about a spongebob copy.
@@Pearl.Is.Autistic.SU.900 camp koral is a spongebob spinoff
MLP is changing, but the Christmas tree is still next to him, lol
The reason why so many are against this idea is because by this point nobody trusts big corpos to write a story, the only things they do in recent years is easy to produce slop with nostalgia bait. People are turning towards creator driven stories made by independent indie studios with unique visuals and attention to details, beacuse people who work on these shows usually personally connected to them in one way or another.
This cutie mark camp thing is the most toothless idea imaginable, the nasty popular girl and her annoying friends, main 4 consisting of the marketable 3 and Misty, the most recognizable pony of gen5, the characterization is confusing...
those are the reasons why people are so sceptical of the new pony cartoon.
I agree mostly. But I don't think the intention was to reuse these characters. Probably just reusing their personalities as placeholder. But again, the concept itself does feel like a hasbro exec using chatgpt to create a 'trendy' reboot for mlp.
Companies don't write a story the creative team behind the scenes and the shows write the story not the corporations themselves they just making their money and control the projects they either high budget the projects to make sure the best it can be or completely screw it over
Yeah your right I’m so tired of animation studios that I’ve given up hope, I’m just watching their old shows because those ones were the only good things they made (and I have no respect for Disney or Netflix those two are the most horrible studios in the whole world in my opinion) this is why I watch indie shows like TADC or BFDI or anything that is indie because those creators are the only ones who care now
One thing id like to add is please don't bring back social media/advanced technology, it really kills a show when you need cellphones or tablets to push it forward even if its just for one small episode that doesn't mean much to the plot
THIS! this is what completely ruined gen5 for me
Has someone noticed that the background ponies in G5 do nothing but stare at each other or something
The disaster of G5 also makes me feel bad for some of the amazing artists who worked on it as one of them known as Imalu started as one of the most famous and talented artists in the fandom before being hired to work on MLP G5 in 2017 as a lead concept illustrator and character designer so the visual style of the characters was pretty much based on her iconic art style that she had established after a few years of doing commissions full time for members of the fandom! :)
can you send her/his deviantart or anything to see arts?
@
Imalu is also the DeviantArt username of the artist! :)
I've come to the conclusion that whenever a "leaker" tells us something is "dead" we just have to wait to find out what they REALLY MEAN cause they're absolutely just giving us a red herring rather than giving the whole answer 😂
Absolutely. IMO that guy was just playing with us and lying to get attention. People do that all the time, why would this random ass guy be any different lol.
The idea seems rather cringey... Well, and the fact that only half of the original six remains sounds rather depressing. However, given that the pony-verse has been cancelled, there is less reason to worry
UPD
By the way, I'm interested in these accusations that we, the MLP fandom, killed the ponyverse, considering that it was canceled before we even knew about it. Like, what? I would understand this discontent if the project was canceled after Hasbro saw our reaction, but no, as far as I understand, it was canceled long before the leak happened
Personally, I would give a ponyverse a chance, even if my first impression of it is negative, just to either make sure I was right or to learn that I was wrong. Low expectations do not equal hatred and refusal to watch the show, they are just low expectations.
It isn"t that hasbro cancelled because of the fans, it is the fact that the Mlp fandom don"t seem to give the project a chance, it was the same thing when the first G5 leakers happened.
Alsp, it is supossed to be a new generation, so i don't see why it is such a problem to be just three of the mane 6, you don't see G3 fans complaining about Starsong not being in G4 or Scootaloo, Cherille and Sweetie Belle not being part of the main cast for example.
@@flowerdaisystar9593 I can't say anything about Scootaloo, Cheerilee and Sweetie Belle, because I don't know what role they played in the plot of G3, but I see a complete transfer of characters from G4 to the new cartoon. This is of course a personal opinion, but for me the new cast of main characters will always seem incomplete in this case, even if the plot turns out to be good, I can't help myself
@@flowerdaisystar9593 Actually, I thought about the plot a bit and now it doesn't seem so bad to me... This idea that the main characters of the cartoon live together in some educational institution, search for some artifacts and simultaneously confront bullies from another group, it sounds like fucking Harry Potter, and I love Harry Potter, haha! The only confusing factor is the attempt to combine the characters of G4 and G5. I think many will agree with me that if these characters are to be divided, making only half of the old characters part of the new cast of main characters, then at least it would be nice to have the old characters at least as secondary ones (like the residents of another house in the camp). Well, in fact, I feel sorry for the fans of G5 despite my dislike for the new generation. They probably loved all the characters from there, and seeing only Misty from them is even more depressing than seeing only Twilight, Pinkie and Rainbow from M6. In short, I am all for the new project, but I hope that all the other characters from G4 and G5 will also be in the plot at least occasionally.
The trailer almost feels like the set-up or intro for a mobile game, with the animation and plot - I wouldn't be surprised if this did come out, and what we've seen is the equivalent of the MLP FiM mobile game intro.
I think there is one, because I remember seeing a promo vid about applejacks VA talked about a mobile game while voicing lines for it
I feel like they need to branch out and finally try to market towards the adult/ teen side of the fan base. The reason g4 did so well in my opinion is because it wasn't super childish, and had heavier themes in some episodes; if they leaned into that we could have a pretty cool show. there's clearly a market for a more adult themed magical pony show as crazy as that sounds and i wish we could get it tbh!
Holds up a Monkey Paw high in the air and shout "I want return of G4 and Twilight WITHOUT wings!!!"
I just want there to be a series that just focuses on the massive amount of genuinely interesting lore in G4
You ask why the fandom so quickly lashed out at this concept and not give it a chance... were you not there for the Twilicorn drama? Or the Equestria Girls backlash? The fandom was ready to call these the end of the franchise and the death of the fandom when all we had was leaked promo art! This is pretty par for the course
Heck! I was pretty mad when I saw Gen 4 for the first time! (I was 9 or 10 and super enthused w Gen 3 at the time)
Honestly a new Mlp series using g1 and g4 medieval/fantasy visuals with trying a little of the modern stuff of g5 would be fire, i just wish they focused in 2D animation or at least a 3D animation that looks better than G5, they could take a lot of inspiration from the g4 comics as well.
Also i love the Banjo Kazooie music you use in these videos, they really fit with your narration haha.
Yay! I agree with your idea so very much! I love all horse and pony stuff but i also love fantasy-like stuff more than reality-like stuff.
4:58 "could you at least give this a chance??"
Yeah I'mma stop you here my guy, I saw the actual pitch video and I have some...Things to say...
To try and not have this comment be removed I'll say that while describing the video contents, Cxcd left out a very important character that was also featured in the video...
There's another unicorn who is not a fan of the "main" unicorn in the camp. She is best described as your typical "popular/I'm better than everyone here" type of character. and no, this isn't Trixie or Starlight Glimmer, she's a new character for this series. It's just so wild that the purple unicorn had such a well established personality, was booksmart but also understanding and whatnot to only then have that stripped away and just have her be "lol I'm a quirky lil pony who doesn't know how to make friends"
JUST USE NEW CHARACTERS!! I can genuinely see this series be better suited for a new group of characters. Maybe have the main character still be a unicorn who is really good at magic but not that great at social interaction. Show examples of her (or him! let's get real crazy) following steps from a book on "how to make friends" but always failing because real friendships don't work that way. The other characters can also have some sort of "fault" to them that also makes it difficult to make friends also but whenever they're together, they just somehow "work"
Apologies for the long comment I just honestly can't really suspend my belief on a new show with established character that are just shells of their former selves :/
They probably will use nee characters. Twilight pinkie, Rd and misty are probably placeholder. Their personalities worked before and will probably work again. They'll probably model new characters after them
I binge watched the entirety of G4 for my first time earlier this year & absolutely loved it!
Honestly can't wait for more FIM - really do hope they are able to make it appealing to adults & maturer audiences again...
6:51 That slow head turn was funny
Regarding that project: Hasbro has a strict policy of NEVER accepting unsolicited scripts or pitches under ANY circumstances. I know people who have looked into similar things before. I didn't personally so I cant' exactly call them out, so if you wanna ignore this, that's fine. I tried. If you submit something to them you will get a form letter in response saying they do not accept unsolicited pitches. If you are lucky they will ignore anything further you put out on it. They are usually pretty chill about fan stuff.
If we are, in fact, getting Camp Cutie Mark as an official show, I hope that it will be good. Great. Amazing, even! I may not like the idea of meshing G4 and G5 together and calling it Friendship is Magic 2.0, but it CAN be done well if the writers know what they're doing, which I'd hope they would.
My main grievance is that G5 got cancelled so soon. Only thing that isn't clear is if we'll see any more of Tell Your Tale Season 2.
If G5 was just the movie then it ended for G6 that would have been good the movie was good the show not so much, there was not enough songs for me
@@daraghokane4236 Agree to disagree on the shows. I absolutely love the movie, but I for one think Make Your Mark is really great, and Tell Your Tale is also of high quality (Albeit it's held back a bit more by more frequent writing issues, its general pacing, and its cancellation).
@@SmokeTheHorsehog I liked the song when they beat opilnce that was a banger, more villains beaten by songs in G6 make the elements of harmony musical instruments
@@daraghokane4236 We Got the Magic really is a great song.
To be fair, I would still give "Camp Cutie Mark" a shot but the concept itself is super disappointing seeing has how it shows they haven't learned from why G5 failed in the first place.
CCM seems like a desperate attempt to follow trends instead of making a show that people would really care about and that would have longevity- the concept itself limits what they can do with the characters and world building super hard.
I went and looked at the tweet. I feel like it would be a super fun and cozy show to watch. I already recognize so many really old characters, to the newer ones, and all new ones. Something that would make this even greater? G3 Minty and her wonderful collection of socks. (Although it seems hasbro loves Minty just as much as me for having her in so much random merch, even with g5)
honestly I think also having even older characters come back would fix my problem with it. I personally am very unhappy with them only seeming to bring back half of the main 6... ill miss fluttershy too bad😭. But having someone like minty would feel like a good enough addition that I think I could put up with it.
@@craftterry9596Imagine this cute scenario: our main cast of characters are going around on their epic adventure. They’re lost, and are hostile to each other by getting upset. They then stumble upon a cottage, where a small pegesi is living, who is Fluttershy! They all become great friends before our main group leaves on their adventure again, having learned the value of kindness towards each other. There’s so much potential with this show. Just because beloved characters aren’t there right now, doesn’t mean we won’t have the chance to see them later down the road on an adventure. This has the potential to be something incredible that brings all the fans together, along with providing wonderful pony content for a new generation.
"look it up" I CAN'T HASBRO KEEPS TAKING EVERYTHING DOWN I WANNA SEE THE COOL SHIT.
I really hope that Hasbro will not abandon the G4 timeline, because as I said it still has potential for growth. That's personally for me the most important thing
A new universe is better I want to see Tirex that is like G1 with a army of dragons, I want unreformed changelings back the black ones are cuter
@@daraghokane4236 and I think that it's too early for new universe, because the potential of the G4 universe is not fully fulfilled. For example, we know less about ancient Equestria, so it's going to be perfect to see a prequel series about Celestia and Luna
Sadly as of now they don’t have full control of the seasons 5-9 because of Discovery. It’s been said that Hasbro will get full control back in 2025. So, a new universe is a better idea for now
@@StarzGecko haven't they got it back already?
@@moisieiev7124 Not yet. Company agreenments usually last for 10 years so pretty soon it should be finished.
Tbh I wish Hasbro would move on from G4. I get it, it was incredibly successful and made Hasbro a ton of money but at this point it feels like they trying to milk it because of said success
G4 appealed to adult fans, in part, because the main characters were adults who did adult stuff - like running a business or attending university - and faced adult problems - like Starlight's dictatorship rule, Chrysalis crashing a wedding, and quite often, literal life-or-death!
The leaked video was very disappointing because it showed the characters as adolescents facing the childish problem of making friends at camp. Making friends at camp might be a big deal to kids, but it seems like a trivial problem to adult viewers who face and conquer far greater challenges in their real lives - like university exams, job hunting, and paying mortgages. Watching adolescent characters make friends just isn't interesting to adults.
G4 was a success because it appealed to adults. But also, Bluey was a success because it appealed to adults! Obviously the show should appeal to kids too, but if it exclusively caters to kids it will get lost in the shuffle of all the other kids media competing for kids' screen time.
Personally, I miss them vibe of G4, but I'm not going to complain if they decide to continue with the style of G5. I'm happy with whatever Hasbro decides to do
Unless it's good.
4:40 thank the lord above
5:22 Hey, sorry but I’m personally glad it was canceled. It’s not that I think that the show would be automatically bad- but at the same time it might’ve had a chance to be.
Gen5 really needs to be left alone, why?, it’s because the series ended off on a really good note. It taught kids, like me who’s now 19 really good things that really built me as a person. And it also had a beautiful story that no longer needs adding to, sure, some characters I would love to know more about them but I don’t want the series to be added and added to..
This causes what used to be good to become bad, you don’t want to add too much to a story // you don’t wanna keep running it in the ground. This is like SpongeBob! I’m not huge into that, never was and probably never will be, I’m unsure if it has lore. But, the company it’s own by still keeps it going, it’s lost the funny in it because it isn’t the same. The humor is bad, to each their own if you enjoy it though. But it’s not the same like the old SpongeBob and that’s from it being continued instead of ended on a good note.
A project looses its spark after kept going for so long.
Gen6 is ASS, frankly, the writing is horrible but the comic, I’ll be honest the comic with discord is awesome, I cried at that comic from how well it was made and because they actually wrote Discord and Fluttershy right.
But the show, it’s very bad, it has plot holes and the models could have more passion put into them. IM ALLOW TO CRITIQUE THAT BTW IM AN ARTIST!!! And a writer, and an aspiring cartoonist with ideas and stories and characters. I can critique all of this all I want.. Anybody creative especially a writer would genuinely understand my ranting and what I’m saying.
And get what I mean when I say Gen6 has a lot of plot holes and things barely touched that needs explaining. Like lore PLEASE touch on Twilight way more, and explain how separation happened after the message Twilight and her friends spent years spreading around just for these new writers to flush it all down the drain, it’s ass writing.
Nothing makes sense, and everything gets rid of a lot of the impact G5 left.
"Why don't we give it a chance?" Have you seen what's been coming out of the entertainment industry lately? It's blatantly clear that media from the higher ups is made in an eco-chamber these days. After being disappointed time after time after time again, people are just sick of it. How about you make a strong first impression or get out? I'm not going to waste my time "giving something a chance" if it doesn't capture my interest to begin with. All people care about these days is formulas to success rather than actually being creative and encouraging people to see it. It is blatantly clear on first impression of this cancelled mlp thing that they clearly only cared about the formula but not the passion. As a result, I am glad that it is cancelled, and I pray Hasbro doesn't even think about touching G4 again unless on the off chance they are willing to actually understand what made G4 good to begin with.
Good point
This should be pinned, I’m honestly fine without mlp camp coral. An amazing idea would instead have a series taking place in between G4-5, kinda like rainbot is doing with their story. I’d love a story that explains how we got from point a to point b and any inconsistencies can be properly explained
@@Fluffball778 It should be like A New Wish and not Kamp Koral
Good lord did you just made a reference to Canterlot Boutique? Sassy Saddles was initially all about formulas to success, and look what happened to all the places she was employed at. Hopefully Hasbro can let their Rarity do their job with TLC this time
Bruh why are you so pessimistic? Not everytime things will be Terrible just look at puss in Boots 2 everyone thought it's gonna be garbage but they give it a chance and suprisingly it was a masterpiece! So why not MLP? Maybe they could pull out something suprising too.. :/
You will never know what will happen for sure! Not everything is a lost cause.
MLP to G4/FIM is like how Transformers is to G1
Tbh my first reaction when you talked about this G4+G5 concept was rather repellent aswell. But not because it clench onto G4 and i don't want them to fuck it up. Quite the contrary. In my opinion one of the biggest drawbacks of G5 was how it desperately tried to hold onto G4. G4 would've never been as great if Lauren Faust hadn't come in to try something new. I want that again. I want new colorful horses I can fall in love with all over
I really enjoy the aesthetic of your set up
Its like a bunker where you get to watch mlp stuff
I hope when G6 does come around Hasbro lets creative minds work and get someone who knows what their doing. Its what made G4 so magical (no pun intended) and feel fresh cause it was a world Lauren Faust built on her own and it got a chance to breathe and develop .
This mf took me on an emotional rollercoaster
I'm nervous about the uncertainty in MLP right now, but I'm also a little excited.
And to quote Pinkie Pie...
I actually just watched the leaked pilot last night, and when I watched it, some parts fel fanfic like, but others I really liked. The big thing I don't like, is how they got to camp cutie mark. About them using g4 characters, I have nothing wrong with that. It looks like they're doing a complete reboot, where it doesn't take place in the same universe as g4 and g5, so we will be getting a fresh take on the characters. I love this, because it can make the characters better than they originally were. Heck, they did something similar with g3 and g4, since g4 has some ponies from g3, namely pinkie pie, rainbow dash, scootaloo, sweetie belle, and cheeralee. It can work. What really would make me groan, is if they try to tie in the events of g4 or g5, because I want a fresh take on mlp, not just hasbro latching onto a previous generation.
I don’t understand fans sometimes. If you want more mlp then you to be willing to give a new show a chance or you’ll never get more content. I agree with giving new shows a chance 100%.
Also, while I love g4 I’d also love to see a show take a new direction with characters from g1. I know that’s what g4 did but there are so many other characters and different directions they could go starting from g1 and I would love to see it. Probably just a dream though with what it sounds like Hasbro interested in doing.
tbh it's mainly the fact that..the g4 characters already exist, camp cutie mark could be great! The cmc could run it, putting it in the universe of g4, and get cool cameos or episodes featuring g4 characters like twilight and Rainbow. Maybe there's a rising epidemic of adult ponies not getting their cutie marks as corporate businesses rise. It could also have g4 characters in the camp! Like Flurry heart, or lil cheese if they were REALLY desperate to make a g4 character a more important character.
Hasbro could desperately drag the corpses of their cash horses for a couple more years, and still get a pretty compelling and good story, and the fans would get more of the show they still adore without it just being g4 repackaged or obliterated! Everyone is happy
Could be cool if they made the CMC adults (like a roles reversed story)
This is so cool, thanks for sharing these leaks and theories, confirming this, I appreciate it! :D ❤❤❤
when they said they would bring back iconic characters, i was kinda hoping some from older gens would return as well, such as firefly from g1 and skywishes from g3. i would argue that the other gens (g1 and g3 especially) are just as important to mlp as g4 and g5. the mane six got their names, designs, and personalities from older ponies. mlp meant a lot to many children everywhere since the 80s, and i bet that they would love their childhood pony become their child's favorite as well. g5 did turn some older ponies into background characters, but it would be very cool to see some return in a major role.
3:23 so they’re COMPLETELY rewriting G4???? There WAS no “camp cutie mark” in G4 and that’s NOT how any of these ponies discovered their cutie marks! I hope this isn’t real.
I don't think they're going to reuse the characters. The collection of 'favourites' suggests to me that this was a test story using character personalities that work. Theyre placeholder for the moment
It would be a reboot. It's no different from Rainbow Dash completely changing her species and personality between G3 and G4. Or Applejack getting a southern accent, which she didn't have in G1.
i hope it has better writing, more like g4, and kind of the 2d looks of g4. As someone else said, g5 was a disaster and NOT thought through !!!! also early :3
The G5 animation was like a PlayStation 3 cutscene
Yep
I hope that these leaks are going to have the same story as the initial G5 leaks about the redesigned G4 characters in other universe, and we are actually getting continuation of G5 but now with greater connection to G4
They just had to double down 😂
someone named "Richel" on youtube actually has a video showing the leaks (probably not for long tho)
personally i love the art style, since this is only a pitch changes are possibily going to be made but the art style is absolutely adorable. now the idea seems simple-- most popular mlp characters go to a camp and discover their cutie marks and friendship blah blah, its a simple idea but hey it works. a lot of people will have the problem of re-using the G4 and G5 ponies but people will complain even IF it was new ponies. my only complaint would be that in G5, the mane 6 got their cutie marks in such a specific and unique way, its going to be thrown out the window in this new series but im sure but i think i can get past it. i believe this would be a cute short series featuring everyones favorite characters, nothing too deep, just fun colorful ponies :3
They might get ther marks at the same time here also im guessing at the season one ending there fighting the bad guy learn there destiny and all get there marks right on the spot and beat them with harmony magic,
More disability representation, in this camp would be good have derpy have am actual visual and mental disability and make Fluttershy bad at flying not just because she is scard of heights but she physical can't. The pony show seemed afraid to have a character with a permanent injury or disability, they would imply it never say it directly. I don't see what is so wrong when people are born with them
Easy-peasy Lemon Squeezey to find.
Hide better next time.
It's weird how rainbow dash seems to already be a famous flyer but for some reason hasn't got her cutie mark yet lol
Her make also represents loyalty she probably hadn't learned that yet
I said it just now on one of your previous videos, that it would be interesting to see the Main 6 of G4 and the Main 6 of G5 actually interact with one another. And have them interact in a full series, would make it better.
It's insane how people are making fun of you or dissing your ideas and effort. You're not doing anything wrong AND you're putting in more effort than all the little haters combined. I'm guessing they're just jobless kids that have never been told you can be anything you want. Their loss, your gain.🎉
It would be kinda poetic Hasbro made a MLP crossover like all this G6 announcing stuff was just a coverup for the real Surprise
to be fair I think the idea of this could work. g5 was started WAY too soon and people were still connected and had childhood or just general nostalgia from the characters. with g5 people still like the characters and its still relatively new. so having a generation with all of them would be there best pet
Is this a SpongeBob Camp Coral situation where it's an alt universe where all the characters meet for the first time as kids, despite the original show contradicting it?
Nope it's completely new timeline not the same like SpongeBob or Angry Bird this is completely new time line but it looks interesting we already saw a camping episode in MLP Camp Everfree and marks and recreation both of them are really good so it will follow the same type of formula but with some sort of asshole pony trying to bully our main characters similar too Summer Madness but with a lot of Diamond Tiara spice
@@Godzilla5675 Come to think of it, I'm not sure what the difference between an alternate universe versus an alternate timeline. Could be that it's nearly 1 AM for me.
@@Amanda-zn7ox ok let me explain an Alternate timeline is a rewritten part of the same timeline and that's what Summer Madness and Kamp Koral fell into they are both in the same Timeline as their shows but since the main shows are already written very early on some parts make less sense for example Sandy met Spongebob in season 1 but in Kamp Koral they met way earlier as kids but an alternate universe is a completely new timeline completely disconnected from the OG show so this gives the writers more freedom to write a new story instead of following the same Timeline over and over and over again
That's what Camp Cutie mark is a brand new universe with the characters we all know and love
@@Godzilla5675 Gotcha.
New timeline and likely new characters. The characters in the short are most likely placeholder and used to test if their personalities would go well together.
Y'all ever heard of Wild Manes? It's a TH-cam cartoon with horses, similar to MLP. It's like MLP, but with normal horses. I think it's got a similar vibe to MLP too, it's got potential but it's not very popular atm. Since MLP is kinda dying... I figured why not talk about something new lol. I still LOVE MLP though, hoping it makes a strong comeback soon!
i need a 1 hour video of cxcd just saying "i don't know"
im so excited for new updates from hasbro or anyone at this point- good or bad, i just want the community to be more alive again haha
the voice did sound a bit off in the leak, so I can understand why people are saying "ai"
I wish they would just move on and create something INSPIRED by g4 and g5 not directly in the same universes.
If they do make it I hope they use good quality animation and don't dumb the characters down
It's a pup named Scooby Doo but with a filly named twilight
Yk g5 did bad when there already wanting to reboot it despite it not being a decade yet
I’m tired of waiting and seeing when I’m usually right when it comes to corporations.
I would rather them never touch G4 again and instead, give me more new things to love without having to rely on a Gen that ended and has no reason to be continued.
But G4 is MLP and it Hasbro right as they one who created MLP, it like ask author to stop touching book they wrote
@@tiglishnobody8750 not exactly because it wasn’t Hasbro that wrote the script and the story, it was Faust. Hasbro just owns it.
G4 was finished in the way where everything fully ended . So Hasbro was just bringing it back because it’s popular, not because it has unfinished business.
@BlackRaveBow I agree. They should just make a whole new thing with similar elements
@@BlackRaveBow Well Faust haven't been part of G4 since S1 so she may established project but it Hasbro who decide for G4 and also Twilight become alicorn is what Hasbro wanted to, without Hasbro you wouldn't have Twilight as Alicorn anyway
@@tiglishnobody8750 I mean, I’m not really here to get in a conversation and debate you. G4 ended in a conclusive way so it doesn’t make any sense bringing it back.
I actually desperately want a show with all the G4 and G5 ponies. I have fallen in love with the personalities of the G5 ponies and really want them to interact with G4 ponies, I think there would be a lot of cool friendship, rivalry etc; so honestly whatever this pony camp was going to be/may be, I’d actually enjoy it. For me, I just love the cute wholesome storylines when real life gets rough and I need a reminder of kindness. I enjoyed g5 unlike many fans. I think it’s cool that the world is expanding; I was a very little gal when I started to watch my little pony and played with toys (Gen 2/3) and grew up hardcore on Gen 3-4.
I kind of want Starcatcher to come back. It’s the one pony toy I kept from all of my childhood; she was my very favourite pony in the world and I was absolutely mesmerised by her.
i dont like that it looked like even though it was G4 world with G5 characters coming in. The "Adult" poinies that already have their cutie marks only have them on 1 side o3o . i really hate if thats the direction cutie marks are going
I really don’t this leak. Removing g5 characters and only have misty and only have twilight pinkie and rainbow makes no sense to me like why remove characters like why? Just let g4 rest it’s over I know a lot of fans miss g4 but this isn’t how you do it
apparently Twilight is gonna be a unicorn when she's suppoes to be an Alicorn
It's good to start the protag as not being an alicorn - assuming they aren't going for the same continuity as G4.
@@alyarin9000 yeah i agree
The ORIGINAL twilight was never an alicorn
@@SavannaW-ww9hj yeah then became an alicorn
@@mlpmidnightsky no she's was never an ailcorn in the original I actually think he was an earth pony in the ORIGINAL ORIGINAL one aka g1
I dont think these characters will make a comeback. I think the idea was to use them as placeholders as a test story for a group with similar personalities
Gen 5 could have been so good if they took the positives from Gen 4 and mixed them with the Gen 4 improvement suggestions from so many fans. Personally that’s what I find saddest about Gen 5, they didn’t understand what made Gen 4 so popular and loved instead making it for kids and non loyal to the past (also they used the ponies not trusting the other pony species AGAIN😭 it hardly made sense in the Gen 4 finally why go the same route)
If Generation 5 of My Little Pony is enough to piss off Chris Chan then I can’t imagine how he would react to Generation 6 knowing that he’ll never get those last five seasons of MLP:FiM he’s been belly aching for.
Even the last five seasons of MLP:FiM if they did get released (Season 10 to Season 14) wouldn't be enough for her, trust me.
I'm scared for this honestly.
same
Looking at the leaks, if I'm honest, the pony designs are more adorable and they do look like real ponies instead of the Tell Your Tale designs. Cancelled or not, I at least hope they fit Better to the ponies design
The ponys as filly is a cute idea,
I’ll give anything a chance, I never really left my pony phase and would love to see what they end up doing with these characters.
Its not what people want to hear, but G4 needs to end once and for all. I love G4 but Hasbro needs to start a new series like they've done with every other generation instead of clinging onto the past. Not a spin off or crossover with G4, something entirely new.
But Applejack, Pinkie Pie, and Twilight are from previous generations (and Fluttershy is based on Posey, while Rainbow Dash is based on Firefly). MLP is like Transformers. Do you expect them to get rid of Optimus Prime and Megatron in the next generation of Transformers? No, that's silly. Hasbro has never made a fully original generation (except for G1 obviously) and they never will.
@@snowblind9551 Unlike the main 6 we see in G5, the ponies from lets say, G1, are from a separate universe. The main 6 from G4 appear in G5 as the same characters, but in G1 they are a different version of those characters in a different universe. Hasbro just needs to let go of the versions of the characters that were introduced in G4, and move onto a new version for G6. The G4 Twilight, Pinkie, and Applejack need to go, they've had their time.
@@charlotte_poppy Oh yes, I agree, they need to be different universe. But G6 IS a different universe. But yeah, they could've used a redesign instead of recycling the exact same design from G4.
5:00
Back it up my dude, you had it right earlier- at least for a lot of detractors.
Hasbro execs are being absolute assholes to a lot of beloved IPs lately. That's my only hesitation here.
If Hasbro was acting like they were circa ~2008-9, trying to make The Hub a thing and all that, then sure, I (and I think a lot of the Camp Cutie Mark detractors) would be all for this.
But looking at what G5 could have been, with the concept art, learning more about fhe scrapped storylines, learning more about CG animation (and how MYM looks like its rushed and not just incompetent) and rewatching the movie? Its soooo painful.
A New Generation is GOOD.
TYT is actually even generally hitting its stride, even in its now clandestine state.
It would just hurt to see Hasbro hire more great creatives, give them existing great characters, and force them and these ponies to slowly drown due to corporate bullshit beyond their control.
Maybe, given some time and with a bit more creative freedom, Hasbro can get their collective corporate heads out of their asses and we can see something better.
This felt like a pretty half baked, Kamp Koral level plan, (So limited in scope, character age, time of year, etc) and I'm really hoping they're working on new pony concept that gives a creative team more to work with.
But its not about "being caught up in the G4 characters," so much as the fact that tying a new IP to the old is YET ANOTHER stumbling block for a creative team to trip over while having to maneuver around these bullshit demands.
The subtle incongrueties have been a thorn in the side of anyone who cared enough about the link between G4 and G5 to invalidate the shows' relationship in the first place.
And we all have decent enough reason to believe now that the continuity issues were primarily due to business issues entirely out of the creative team's control.
(I hold strongly that, for G5, they should have canonized Starlight Glimmer's presence when the Mane 6 got their cutie marks, made said Mane 6 slightly different, and the old fans ((both bronies and grown target G4 demo fans)) could have written off most retcons and embraced a new mystery.)
Even if its a separate continuity, they were clearly angling it on being about "Iconic" (ie existing) characters, painting the creative team into a corner. They ain't exactly being allowed to eimagine characters like G4 did with Applejack or Moondancer from the looks of it.
...But it still could have been okay, if a strong team were allowed to cook. I'll grant you that, AND its basically the cornerstone of brony culture. We know how good things can get. I'm plenty willing to give up the girls in the name of a good, meaningful story- especially one that can provide meaningful lessons that can help real people. (MLP as something that helps people emotionally grow and learn is something I do value)
Really, I even have a great deal of faith in writers and animators in the industry right now, and Hasbro can generally pick em really well.
I just don't think they'd get to cook.
Ultimately, we're on the same page here, so please don't pidgeonhole everyone with a less positive view in the same vein?
Pony is far from the only IP Hasbro is fucking around with at the moment, after all. I'm so tired of them yanking around so much of the media I like
Tbh, I wish G6 had its own characters, world building, and concepts like g4. At the same time, it should have the same 2D style as the other generations. The problem with G5 was although it has its own story, most of it is pretty much dependent on G4. At the same time, they tried to attempt 3D animation which turned out kind of wonky and a little off.
The reason G4 was successful was because its story was independent and just reused and revamped some characters from the former generations. At the same time, the show was appealing not only to children but also older audiences. I just hope G6 has the same charm as G4 while not being dependent on another generation.
i had to pause multiple times and just. let it sink in. this sounds so incredibly brainrotted
no way g4 ran for a decade and had 9 seasons and g5 is already over
Because g5 sucks
Until the issues with the production process of G5 are addressed, I'll remain hopefully skeptical of new pony content.
I like the cutie mark camp idea its cute, Here is how I would make the show Twilight loves books and has no friends but her brother who left to go join the army, her parents decided to sent her to the camp, Pinkie pie and Rainbowdash just wants to go to the camp. The camp is near the everfree forest a dangerous and scary place. I want misty to be a changeling and her story is she is scared to tell the other ponys her secret,.
Okey First episode The kids are told about a dangerous monster in the forest Rainbow goes out to see it and gets lost so Twilight and the other go look for her and Rainbow learns not to make reckless decisions
Yeah, the origin mane six of Friendship is magic might be in this G6 series, but I'm also notes that Misty going to be in it too, and writing this just remind me of the petition for another chapter of Make your Mark
Yeah I wouldn't really call a mish-mash of the three most popular characters of FIM and Misty a new generation. That really just feels like a G4 reboot with some G5 sprinkled in.
Wasn't there an official comic or something a long time ago that had Minty, G1 Twilight and a couple other past gen ponies hanging out with the mane six? I would rather have that as a ponyverse than just the two generations. Heck, they could put G2 characters in there which don't have a lot of representation.
I'd really like G1-G3 to be more present than just beyond the brand reusing names, I've been growing really attached to those incarnations over the past few years.
They will reuse G1 villians anyway,
Before Hasbro asked everyone to take down the images. The replies to the tweet were so much crazy speculation about "This is made by AI" but like you said that would mean someone has made the world's greatest AI ever that no one has yet... I do agree it might be a new thing that is coming soon but base on the first video it might be a short series of shorts?
I use AI detector on image I saved and it have very least to be made by AI which is error as AI detector isn't prefect but it very accurate at least
Beside it Concept Art so it not like this would came out like this
@@tiglishnobody8750 If it was really AI someone owns the greatest AI ever made. The 6min video isn't possible for AI to create yet.
@@StarzGecko Is that you in discord?
@@tiglishnobody8750 I have the same username on Discord so it should be me unless it's a changeling
PLEASE LET THIS BE A GOOD SHOW LIKE PLEASE, I WILL EXPLODE 💥💥
Welcome to the MLP fandom bud
A show all about friendship and learning how to be a good person but 99% of the fandom know absolutely jack about friendship it’s kinda wild
I feel ya, they say “love and tolerate” and yet they NEVER do what they say.
Hasbro be on that total dramarama timing 🤡
I got a lot of comments on my Twitter post about this being “ai generated voices” but I made the argument that it really didn’t seem like it. Because if it were, they’d be carbon copies of what the characters sound like, and we didn’t get that, we got someone’s take on the characters voices in a narrative form. “Robotic” is crazy.
Oh CXCD... you always know just what to say....
5:24 Personally I’m glad this show wasn’t made because it just felt too wrong. The mane six and old equestria’s story is over, gen 5 is definitely over, if they want to do a gen 6 I would either do a complete reboot of the universe or set it after g5 with new characters. I wouldn’t necessarily be afraid they’d “ruin” the old characters by bringing them to a new story, I just feel like their story is officially over and they got their ending
Having watched the leaked video, my biggest concern with it is the inclusion of the stereotypical 'mean girl' pony. FiM *mostly* avoided this outside of the CMC episodes, which weren't too frequent in the grand scheme of things. It makes me worry it'll feel, for lack of a better descriptor, like any other generic kids show. I also find this to be a weird mix of ponies for a potential 'mane 4'. Dunno, Im open, and its not like I expect anything after G4 to hit its heights of greatness or popularity, but G5 was still such a let down. this isn't necesarily a difficult premise to mess up imo.
I love when english speakers use the word 'kaputt' as if it means utter annihilation.
G5 could’ve been great if they didn’t drop the ball and completely forget their own story in the end of the opaline arc
Well, let's be glad that G4 is not being abandoned by Hasbro.
OMG YOU FINALLY GOT A MIC CLOSE TO YOU YOUR POOR VOCALS CAN FINALLY REST!!!! (I hope)🎉🎉🎉
5:14 - Considering how bad G5 was, yeah totally warranted response, Hasbro shouldn't touch G4 characters, not without Lauren Faust and Megan McCarthy involved
7:20 - it would be an utter tragedy if it wasn't cancelled yes, and knowing my luck theyll be ruining this next series
10:00 - If Fluttershy is in this Ill give it a chance, if they dont include her then the sin is too great and I wont. if the art style is a cal-arts garbage fest, Ill immediately turn away from it and refuse to give it a shot. I'm tired of the lowest quality garbage getting greenlit, I'm tired of the stupid decisions, Hasbro has not been treating MLP like the success it was, and that's why they keep failing, and if they decide to continue going down that path I wish them nothing but the worst possible failure, comparable to Concords failure, if they rectify their mistakes, then I wish them luck, but I am very black-pilled when it comes to the idea that Hasbro can learn from their mistakes, most companies are failing to do that, why should I believe Hasbro will be any different? want to be proven wrong, i dont like hating any MLP series, that's why I'm so damn harsh with this, because i dont want to hate anything else I dont want Hasbro to fail MLP again