This fits her character perfectly. When hermoine claims that the carriage is pulling itself, Luna lets her believe it. To some degree, she’s always been in on the joke and was comfortable letting others believe she was crazy. She has nothing to prove. Great theory.
I always assumed she was right about everything. I always thought it was a hilarious joke that people living in a world of magic thought her claims were too outlandish.
@@erikhermansen3431 It's like when characters in a clearly magical setting don't believe in Santa or whatnot. Or, as has been pointed out before, people in Harry Potter not believing in fortune-telling. You tell me why it makes any sense that Divination is less believable than turning a desk into a pig.
@@erikhermansen3431exactly! You live in a world were your teacher turned himself into a couch and you yourself made a bag with infinite space,how is the existence of 1 or 2 more magical creatures (again in a world were unicorns and giants exist right next door to your school) is so weird?
I always though that "nargles" were mean, crazy, or annoying girls in Luna's language. She mentioned how mistletoe was filled with nargles and some girls during Christmas were always under mistletoe, she said that nargles took her things and we know that were the girls from her room that were being mean to her. So when I read the book I always thought that nargles were girls that Luna didn't like
Fun fact about narwhals their horns was sold as unicorn horns in Victorian England, they were caught in Norway brought to Scotland (whose national animal is a unicorn) and sold as medicine good luck ect to wealthy English people
@@JasperPeters I can't seem to find it for the life of me but I promise I didn't hallucinate it. And I don't watch any other HP creators than SuperCarlin so definitely not remembering somebody else - they covered things like Ron joking that Voldemort killed Myrtle (he did) or that Harry will come into unexpected money (he then did)
The way he phrased "adding milk to cereal" or "adding cereal to milk" made me immediately imagine pouring milk into the cereal box and pouring cereal into the milk jug.
I believe for the Harry Potter Universe, those beasts that nobody knows whether or not they exist could just be the wizarding world equivalent of the cryptids like Bigfoot or the Loch Ness Monster many people believe exist and some claim to have seen.
About Newt's deceptive book - there's a beach in the Falkland Islands that has a sign banning people from that beach due to the landmines that are still there from the Falklands War. There are, in fact, no landmines on that beach, it's just a way of keeping that spot solely for penguins to chill!
I'll watch this video later when I have more time! I'm reading Harry Potter for the first time (age 19) after watching a ton of your theories on it, and watching the movies. It's a delight so far! I especially love the beginning. I'm on the Philosopher's Stone, and I just reached chapter 11!
@@ashleysherlock5705 nah! I've seen wayy to many spoilers by this point! I saw spoliers before I watched the movies. These theory videos and spoliers is what got me into it! I would be concerned if I hadn't seen an extreme amount of spoilers and videos that I happily watched since they're entertaining!
I always loved Luna as a character, this just shows how awesome she is! Also, question for all my Harry Potter fanatics, if a blind person used a Pensieve, would they be able to see the memories? Or would they just be able to hear what was happening? My friends and I can can’t decide on what the answer would be and would love more feedback, thanks!
She is my favourite Ravenclaw And by the way Narwhals are real, look it up! And I have been part of this channel since I don’t know for how long but I believe a few years, oh yeah I have been watching all the Encanto videos
They know about narwhals, I promise. They don't need to look it up. It's a long-running joke from the early days of the channel, going back to the Grizzly Eagle Shark and "These Socks Are Amazing!" days.
8:34 I had two versions of Arthur in my mind. One, "What exactly is the purpose of a rubber duck" Two, "I tHfiNk i GoT iT" from AVPS "He doesn't know what a moogle is"
Can we all just agree that of all the Hogwarts textbooks we needed Hogwarts a history is like top of the list!! Don’t get me wrong I enjoy fantastic beasts and where to find them and Quidditch through the ages, but what I really wanted was Hogwarts a history
Wait, what do you do when you have finished your bowl of cereal and are still hungry and have milk at the bottom? Do you drink or pour out the milk and then do cereal + milk, or do you add more cereal to the remaining milk to keep eating?
I thought that maybe she was referring to things by the names her family called them and not what they were actually called like how in America we call some breeds of dog one way but called other names in different Countries
The one thing you’re certain of is one I find very interesting actually, because I agree that’s generally the way to do it, but there do exist exceptions to that rule, namely: you’ve just finished your first bowl of cereal, and realize you put more milk than the amount of cereal required, you’re not going to just throw the extra milk away, at least not after your first bowl, and while you could drink it, it simply makes more sense to use it for what you intended when you poured it in the first place: a bowl of cereal.
I think Luna is kinda a commentary on wizard of stuff from the perspective of muggles. Wizards would seem like crazy people to muggles. Luna seems like that to wizards.
My headcanon is her father heard of a rare species of magical beast, but it was in a foreign language, so he may have heard the name (or part of a sentence) but could pronounce it well enough, leading to the odder names and why no one else understands.
I thought it was sweet that she says she doesnt like to dance so she wouldnt have minded if shed gone to the ball with Ron but then at the wedding she dances with her dad. Not for her but prob for him.
Hedwig: Oh, I love nargles. I have them for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Harry: *confused* What do you mean? Hedwig: I'm a bird. Nargles are a type of insect, Harry. And birds eat insects, and worms too.
7:35 Well played Sir Well played. Honestly I thought this was a American thing..... TBH Candians have some weird things that a lot of swear are real too such as Big Foot (although thats shared with America) and Okopogo which is often called the "Canadian cousin to Nessie" which is said to live in Lake Okopogo in British Columbia (for our American friends who may not know where that is its where Vancouver is)
I always thought that everything Luna says is actually true, since she seems the kind of mysterious that would know things noone else knows and would be always right
I once, in a half asleep stupor, poured my milk first. Thinking it was no big deal, I went to pour my cereal. Instead of cereal, however, a roach that had fallen in the box came scurrying out. The image of that cockroach floundering about in the milk in my bowl haunts me to this day. NEVER ADD THE MILK FIRST! It can only lead to pain and suffering. (Also, Luna's awesome) (Also, also, How long has it been since you brought up narwhals? That was awesome.)
Personally love that J left in the backwards turned book. If anything, further drives home the point that some things from the Fantastic Beasts movies have such hope and promise, but things just kind of turn up backwards or not following the wizarding world lore.
Regarding "Loser's Lurgy", we know that Luck is something that exists in the wizarding world and can be manipulated using felix felicis. I don't think it's too farfetched to believe there might be some ways other than one specific potion to gain good or bad luck.
The funny thing is apparently Luna during her career as a magical zoologist basically proved that EVERYTHING she believed in existed, EXCEPT for the Crumple Horned Snorkhack.
Ron is the one that says he can’t see the Thestrals and while Hermione also can’t see them in the book she doesn’t say that nothing is pulling the carriages. In Hagrid’s first class of the year in chapter 21 The Eye of the Snake Hermione does say that they are Thestrals meaning she knows what they are even if she can’t see them.
You guys insisting on using AI thumbnails is really making it clear that you don’t value artists at all, and it genuinely makes the entire premise of your channel (talking about somebody else’s work that you had no hand in making, and making a profit from it) really gross. I hope eventually you see AI art for what it is, but for now it’s really sad to see.
My head cannon about luna and her father is that the quibbler is well-disguised satire satire and the allegedly fictional animals are called by the wrong names
YES!!! Luna is the best!! Way to use supreme detail to totally redeem her!! Also...hilarious use of The Incredibles "coincidence" 😂 One more that I thought of while watching is simply her last name being Lovegood...with the whole series being Rowling's message of the importance of Love. 200% agree with you Luna was right about everything!!
I have a question about the deathly hallows, so Death from tale, is quite cunning, do you think he'd go so far as to make the hallows only work properly when in the hands of the Peverell family? Which is maybe why Harry had to be the chosen one and not Neville, because the hallows would respond "correctly" to Harry's intentions, and therefore being the only one who could stop Voldemort but only as long as everything came together???
Humans are more vicious than dangerous.. 15:08 He says that man is what newt considers "the most dangerous beast on the planet." The clip then shows Newt describing humans as "The most vicious creatures on the planet" According to the Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them book that he's holding, Newt says nundu may be the most dangerous creature alive. I only know this cause Ben read it in their last video at 41:50 in J vs Ben: HARDEST Harry Potter MONSTER Trivia Quiz.
What about in the half blood prince movie when luna finds Harry on the train even though he is under the invisibility cloak? We see that she was able to find him because she could see the rackspurts floating in his head. Almost nobody can see through that cloak but luna still found him solely because of the rackspurts. What about that?
Well the only two outcomes are She found them and thus knows they're real but continues the lie to protect them OR She searched the whole world for every beast and didn't find them which proves they don't exist. Sort of like the conjecture Hermione put to Xeno lovegood about the resurrection stone when he counters with prove that it doesn't "You could claim that anything's real if the only basis for believing in it is that nobody's proved it doesn't exist."
Luna is very open minded and more willing to believe what others consider impossible. This allows her to think outside the box and consider a wider range of possibilities.
Really wish Luna had have talked about the Hallows. To get her take on it, ooo. Xeno is interesting, but he's a lot more grounded than Luna, the interpretation of the Hallows would be very different. Would Luna be most interested in the Cloak or the Stone? .... that could have been a really interesting connection between Harry and Luna: both wanting to see their moms.
i actually get the "yips" when shooting (gun) if there is an error that i myself caused unknowingly, it will completely mess me up, i will clear it just fine no problem ezpz BUT, after the clear and i start shooting again, i will proceed to miss my intended target with the remaining rounds in the mag. this is something that RARELY happens but, it does. and its extremely dumb when it happens because im actually a highly skilled shooter who should NEVER and generally NEVER misses my intended target. (i was a 0311 and i did armed security) its so dumb when it happens too because no joke, EVERYONE around just stops and stares in confusion. ((what i mean by "error caused by myself" i mean when using like an M4 for example and accidentally covering the ejection port while firing which will cause a jam.))
I mostly agree. Personally I've always felt that her peculiarity stems from 2 possible points. Either or both being valid. My one point is that i think wizards are born with various 'depth' to their magical abilities. We don't get told how magic actually works, but we know there is a blood factor. We know some have such low levels of power that they're called squibs. Having more magic than a muggle. So if someone can have less magic, then more magic is possible. Unlike Hermione, who has to focus on study, we do know that 'talent' exists and runs in blood. From obvious talents like speaking to snakes or shape shifting, to Harry's weird natural affinity to flying a broom. Voldemort himself may be one such natural talent. And so i believe that the main reason Luna got into Ravenclaw was some rare ability the hat could sense. An ability that allows her to perhaps detect very ethereal or cloaked creatures. I also suspect that her mother had a similar ability, and perhaps discovering something that didn't want to be discovered may have been the cause of her death. Thus maybe some of the strange names and such was loaned from wizard stories, but referred to real creatures yet undiscovered. Secondly, i lean more to these creatures being undiscovered. True, they could have been discovered by Newt before. And it's possible that his Grandson knew that some of these creatures exists. But i get the feeling that Newt didn't just go catalogue creatures that was already known. I believe most of those he wrote about was ones that was unknown up to that time. Perhaps much like those looking for the yeti or nessie. Perhaps hearing legends and then seeking to prove them real. And in that way Luna's talents could allow her to find creatures even Newt couldn't find. Creatures more magical than those currently seen, can logically not be found except by a rare individual with equally high magical talents. I wouldn't be surprised if Luna's mother had been a pupil of Newt, or at least a friend. And perhaps the desire for the diadem of ravenclaw was tied into their quest to explore this world.
I think Luna knows exactly what’s going on, she just takes a step back, flip it with a different point of view. I think Luna is the smartest wizard, and knows way more than what she’s tells people.
I think of the Wrackspurts as a psychological thing that is viewed as magical, like the Yips. I wonder if Wrackspurts are sort of like a manifestation of anxiety/panic or even an anxiety/panic attack. It is not unrealistic to think she might have trauma that results in such, but also seeing it as a creature is fitting for the Lovegoods, as well as making it easier for her to deal with if she can physically fight them off. The symptoms fit, and it would be fitting for the time when Harry experienced it. I might be reaching.
@SuperCarlinBrothers What's with the changed thumbnail art (with this one as well as the Maledictus and Patronus videos)? Is that someone cast as Luna in the HBO series?
you should do a “what if Voldemort got hold of the philosopher stone”. ik he can’t get it from the mirror so the only way would be to somehow get it from gringods before hagrid 🤷♂️.
I like the idea that she was homeschooled, her mother died so the terms she learned is 'wrong', never transitioned to the real terms. The dad is lost in keeping Luna's childhood, forgetting himself to much. So she is still learning, making terms of her own along with logic of conspiracy theories, writing to her magazine. So no one understands what she is saying, even thou her ideas are well formulated. People even avoid asking what her terms are, because they have not learn how to form logic or they she as loony(but not the Canadian money).
Get your tickets for our LIVE TRIVIA event in Roanoke ::
www.eventbrite.com/e/super-carlin-brothers-go-fest-trivia-night-tickets-694221734897
You guys are amazing 🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤
You guys are amazing. I didn’t hear channel since I was around five.
Personally, I put the bowl last, but you do you brother
It's a sad truth that those who exist outside of socal normalcy often are the most insightful.
Please do a video about connecting Harry Potter to Holy Week (philosopher’s Sunday, hallows sat/Easter, etc.)
This fits her character perfectly. When hermoine claims that the carriage is pulling itself, Luna lets her believe it. To some degree, she’s always been in on the joke and was comfortable letting others believe she was crazy. She has nothing to prove. Great theory.
I always assumed she was right about everything. I always thought it was a hilarious joke that people living in a world of magic thought her claims were too outlandish.
Well said! Huzzah!
@@erikhermansen3431 It's like when characters in a clearly magical setting don't believe in Santa or whatnot. Or, as has been pointed out before, people in Harry Potter not believing in fortune-telling. You tell me why it makes any sense that Divination is less believable than turning a desk into a pig.
Also it was always weird to me that in a world of magic where pretty much everything can and does exist she is still seen as that crazy girl
@@erikhermansen3431exactly! You live in a world were your teacher turned himself into a couch and you yourself made a bag with infinite space,how is the existence of 1 or 2 more magical creatures (again in a world were unicorns and giants exist right next door to your school) is so weird?
I always though that "nargles" were mean, crazy, or annoying girls in Luna's language. She mentioned how mistletoe was filled with nargles and some girls during Christmas were always under mistletoe, she said that nargles took her things and we know that were the girls from her room that were being mean to her. So when I read the book I always thought that nargles were girls that Luna didn't like
Great point!!
Agreed, thats always been my interpretation. That said, I could see theirs as well.
This makes so much sense. Great theory.
What if Nargles are hostile intent, wrachspurts are current or future confusion, etcetera: Luna is seeing what is usually intuitively known.
I'm convinced your theory is correct
Fun fact about narwhals their horns was sold as unicorn horns in Victorian England, they were caught in Norway brought to Scotland (whose national animal is a unicorn) and sold as medicine good luck ect to wealthy English people
The spiritual successor to the "Ron is always right" video. Love it!
Where is that video?
And Trelawny's predictions are always right
@@JasperPeters I can't seem to find it for the life of me but I promise I didn't hallucinate it. And I don't watch any other HP creators than SuperCarlin so definitely not remembering somebody else - they covered things like Ron joking that Voldemort killed Myrtle (he did) or that Harry will come into unexpected money (he then did)
@@kaylabayusik1868I remember this too
@@JasperPeters I don't think it's an SCB one cause I don't remember seeing it either
The way he phrased "adding milk to cereal" or "adding cereal to milk" made me immediately imagine pouring milk into the cereal box and pouring cereal into the milk jug.
Preach, proof that you should always listen to Luna. She may be unapologetically weird, but she's extremely wise. 😍
Dude I feel like I see your comments everywhere😂
@@supersoup4672there is no escape from grand admiral trinaq
Luna is the best,a true Ravenclaw
I believe for the Harry Potter Universe, those beasts that nobody knows whether or not they exist could just be the wizarding world equivalent of the cryptids like Bigfoot or the Loch Ness Monster many people believe exist and some claim to have seen.
Luna: Mission Failed Successfully
Or would it be mission accomplished fail…fully? 🤔😵💫
Why'd the thumbnail change?
About Newt's deceptive book - there's a beach in the Falkland Islands that has a sign banning people from that beach due to the landmines that are still there from the Falklands War. There are, in fact, no landmines on that beach, it's just a way of keeping that spot solely for penguins to chill!
I'll watch this video later when I have more time! I'm reading Harry Potter for the first time (age 19) after watching a ton of your theories on it, and watching the movies. It's a delight so far! I especially love the beginning. I'm on the Philosopher's Stone, and I just reached chapter 11!
@@ashleysherlock5705 nah! I've seen wayy to many spoilers by this point! I saw spoliers before I watched the movies. These theory videos and spoliers is what got me into it! I would be concerned if I hadn't seen an extreme amount of spoilers and videos that I happily watched since they're entertaining!
11:05 you can see the raxspurts in the film if you look closely. It’s little wavy lines around Harry’s head, those ARE the raxspurts
I always loved Luna as a character, this just shows how awesome she is! Also, question for all my Harry Potter fanatics, if a blind person used a Pensieve, would they be able to see the memories? Or would they just be able to hear what was happening? My friends and I can can’t decide on what the answer would be and would love more feedback, thanks!
She is my favourite Ravenclaw
And by the way Narwhals are real, look it up!
And I have been part of this channel since I don’t know for how long but I believe a few years, oh yeah I have been watching all the Encanto videos
They know about narwhals, I promise. They don't need to look it up. It's a long-running joke from the early days of the channel, going back to the Grizzly Eagle Shark and "These Socks Are Amazing!" days.
@Miss_Myth I for one miss the socks 😢
Yeah, when Movie Flame didn't place her high on the IQ scale, I was offended for her 😂
Except when she's Left lolol.
Respect and keep up the epic work.
Nailed it
@@SuperCarlinBrothersYou guys rock 🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤
Absolutely crumpled horn snorkacks are real. Always were. Love your channel!
Narghouls actually LOOK like mistletoe. They're an off shoot of Bowtruckles
8:34 I had two versions of Arthur in my mind. One, "What exactly is the purpose of a rubber duck"
Two,
"I tHfiNk i GoT iT" from AVPS
"He doesn't know what a moogle is"
What gets me is neville does not defend Harry when he is one of the people who can see thestrals (in the book at least.)
When you open up TH-cam and the first video is:
1. SCB video
2. Has Luna in it
3. Uploaded 15 min ago
🔥🔥🔥
Can we all just agree that of all the Hogwarts textbooks we needed Hogwarts a history is like top of the list!! Don’t get me wrong I enjoy fantastic beasts and where to find them and Quidditch through the ages, but what I really wanted was Hogwarts a history
And A History of Magic by Bathilda Bagshot. Maybe even The Life and Lies of Albus Dumbledore by Rita Skeeter
You’re telling me my favorite character was right about everything? I’m on board.
Please do a video about connecting Harry Potter to Holy Week (philosopher’s Sunday, hallows sat/Easter, etc.)
Wait, what do you do when you have finished your bowl of cereal and are still hungry and have milk at the bottom? Do you drink or pour out the milk and then do cereal + milk, or do you add more cereal to the remaining milk to keep eating?
Drink the milk and start over
I've been on this channel long enough... narwhals are definitely mythical creatures
I hadn't thought of adding cereal to milk before. Might try that tomorrow, thanks!
I thought that maybe she was referring to things by the names her family called them and not what they were actually called like how in America we call some breeds of dog one way but called other names in different Countries
Love the pitch meeting quote
Who's the girl on the thumbnail?
Is that supposed to be Luna?
Why change the thumbnail?
Is the Platypus a magical creature that muggles have discovered.
We all need a movie where Ralph and Luna meet and have a littlle adventure. Just a magical movie where two odd balls fall in love.
Anyone turn the captions on just to see? They did a really good job!
The one thing you’re certain of is one I find very interesting actually, because I agree that’s generally the way to do it, but there do exist exceptions to that rule, namely: you’ve just finished your first bowl of cereal, and realize you put more milk than the amount of cereal required, you’re not going to just throw the extra milk away, at least not after your first bowl, and while you could drink it, it simply makes more sense to use it for what you intended when you poured it in the first place: a bowl of cereal.
7:08 I actually just watched a Fakemon video where this dynamic was brought up.
I think Luna is kinda a commentary on wizard of stuff from the perspective of muggles.
Wizards would seem like crazy people to muggles. Luna seems like that to wizards.
They never realized that Harry's invisibility cloak is one of the Deathly Hallows until before their return to Hogsmeade.
My headcanon is her father heard of a rare species of magical beast, but it was in a foreign language, so he may have heard the name (or part of a sentence) but could pronounce it well enough, leading to the odder names and why no one else understands.
I thought it was sweet that she says she doesnt like to dance so she wouldnt have minded if shed gone to the ball with Ron but then at the wedding she dances with her dad. Not for her but prob for him.
The purpose of a rubber duck: you'd have to ask Christopher Bowes for the details, but their purpose is to shoot lasers out of their eyes.
Nice Narwals through back 😂
Hedwig: Oh, I love nargles. I have them for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
Harry: *confused* What do you mean?
Hedwig: I'm a bird. Nargles are a type of insect, Harry. And birds eat insects, and worms too.
7:35 Well played Sir Well played. Honestly I thought this was a American thing..... TBH Candians have some weird things that a lot of swear are real too such as Big Foot (although thats shared with America) and Okopogo which is often called the "Canadian cousin to Nessie" which is said to live in Lake Okopogo in British Columbia (for our American friends who may not know where that is its where Vancouver is)
Goblin Pie! Ha!
Everyone in the know, knows that Fudge was using Goblins as part of his favorite Stew. So there, shows what you know!
I always thought that everything Luna says is actually true, since she seems the kind of mysterious that would know things noone else knows and would be always right
I just love Ben laughing in the background 😂😂😂
My brother. You put the milk first? Personally I put the spoon, then the cereal, then the milk and finally the bowl
He said you pour cereal into milk. Not milk into cereal.
At this point, I think J can convince me of anything.
I once, in a half asleep stupor, poured my milk first. Thinking it was no big deal, I went to pour my cereal. Instead of cereal, however, a roach that had fallen in the box came scurrying out. The image of that cockroach floundering about in the milk in my bowl haunts me to this day.
NEVER ADD THE MILK FIRST!
It can only lead to pain and suffering.
(Also, Luna's awesome)
(Also, also, How long has it been since you brought up narwhals? That was awesome.)
Personally love that J left in the backwards turned book. If anything, further drives home the point that some things from the Fantastic Beasts movies have such hope and promise, but things just kind of turn up backwards or not following the wizarding world lore.
Regarding "Loser's Lurgy", we know that Luck is something that exists in the wizarding world and can be manipulated using felix felicis. I don't think it's too farfetched to believe there might be some ways other than one specific potion to gain good or bad luck.
The funny thing is apparently Luna during her career as a magical zoologist basically proved that EVERYTHING she believed in existed, EXCEPT for the Crumple Horned Snorkhack.
Ron is the one that says he can’t see the Thestrals and while Hermione also can’t see them in the book she doesn’t say that nothing is pulling the carriages. In Hagrid’s first class of the year in chapter 21 The Eye of the Snake Hermione does say that they are Thestrals meaning she knows what they are even if she can’t see them.
1:36 I paid the math budget for this one… he’s right.
You guys insisting on using AI thumbnails is really making it clear that you don’t value artists at all, and it genuinely makes the entire premise of your channel (talking about somebody else’s work that you had no hand in making, and making a profit from it) really gross. I hope eventually you see AI art for what it is, but for now it’s really sad to see.
My head cannon about luna and her father is that the quibbler is well-disguised satire satire and the allegedly fictional animals are called by the wrong names
I REALLY wish they will introduce some of the weird creatures Luna talks about in the next Fantastic Beasts movie
YES!!! Luna is the best!! Way to use supreme detail to totally redeem her!! Also...hilarious use of The Incredibles "coincidence" 😂
One more that I thought of while watching is simply her last name being Lovegood...with the whole series being Rowling's message of the importance of Love. 200% agree with you Luna was right about everything!!
Gotta love J hitting us with another strong opinion about weak things 😂
These AI thumbnails are kinda unsettling
I have a question about the deathly hallows, so Death from tale, is quite cunning, do you think he'd go so far as to make the hallows only work properly when in the hands of the Peverell family?
Which is maybe why Harry had to be the chosen one and not Neville, because the hallows would respond "correctly" to Harry's intentions, and therefore being the only one who could stop Voldemort but only as long as everything came together???
Humans are more vicious than dangerous..
15:08
He says that man is what newt considers "the most dangerous beast on the planet."
The clip then shows Newt describing humans as "The most vicious creatures on the planet"
According to the Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them book that he's holding, Newt says nundu may be the most dangerous creature alive. I only know this cause Ben read it in their last video at 41:50 in J vs Ben: HARDEST Harry Potter MONSTER Trivia Quiz.
Why is no one talking about the pitch meetings reference at the start of the video ?!?!?!
I think it’s highly possible that Fudge was killing off goblins or having them killed off.
Milk left after eating all the cereal in the bowl, just ADD cereal to the MILK. I do it all the time.😊
WAS THAT A RYAN GEORGE REFERENCE AT THE BEGINNING?? ❤️❤️❤️
The wrackspurts proof is actually seen with the spectrespecs in the movie. Notice the little dots floating around Harry's head.
The only time you add cereal to milk is when you are going for round 2
"Banana sandwiches" 😂😂😂
You know? I thought exactly the same thing yesterday!
That`s a really good point.
What about in the half blood prince movie when luna finds Harry on the train even though he is under the invisibility cloak? We see that she was able to find him because she could see the rackspurts floating in his head. Almost nobody can see through that cloak but luna still found him solely because of the rackspurts. What about that?
Well the only two outcomes are
She found them and thus knows they're real but continues the lie to protect them
OR
She searched the whole world for every beast and didn't find them which proves they don't exist.
Sort of like the conjecture Hermione put to Xeno lovegood about the resurrection stone when he counters with prove that it doesn't "You could claim that anything's real if the only basis for believing in it is that nobody's proved it doesn't exist."
I loved this! Luna IS Always Right! Amazing! Thanks!
Luna is very open minded and more willing to believe what others consider impossible. This allows her to think outside the box and consider a wider range of possibilities.
Really wish Luna had have talked about the Hallows. To get her take on it, ooo. Xeno is interesting, but he's a lot more grounded than Luna, the interpretation of the Hallows would be very different.
Would Luna be most interested in the Cloak or the Stone? .... that could have been a really interesting connection between Harry and Luna: both wanting to see their moms.
i actually get the "yips" when shooting (gun) if there is an error that i myself caused unknowingly, it will completely mess me up, i will clear it just fine no problem ezpz BUT, after the clear and i start shooting again, i will proceed to miss my intended target with the remaining rounds in the mag.
this is something that RARELY happens but, it does. and its extremely dumb when it happens because im actually a highly skilled shooter who should NEVER and generally NEVER misses my intended target. (i was a 0311 and i did armed security) its so dumb when it happens too because no joke, EVERYONE around just stops and stares in confusion.
((what i mean by "error caused by myself" i mean when using like an M4 for example and accidentally covering the ejection port while firing which will cause a jam.))
I mostly agree. Personally I've always felt that her peculiarity stems from 2 possible points. Either or both being valid.
My one point is that i think wizards are born with various 'depth' to their magical abilities. We don't get told how magic actually works, but we know there is a blood factor. We know some have such low levels of power that they're called squibs. Having more magic than a muggle. So if someone can have less magic, then more magic is possible. Unlike Hermione, who has to focus on study, we do know that 'talent' exists and runs in blood. From obvious talents like speaking to snakes or shape shifting, to Harry's weird natural affinity to flying a broom. Voldemort himself may be one such natural talent. And so i believe that the main reason Luna got into Ravenclaw was some rare ability the hat could sense. An ability that allows her to perhaps detect very ethereal or cloaked creatures. I also suspect that her mother had a similar ability, and perhaps discovering something that didn't want to be discovered may have been the cause of her death. Thus maybe some of the strange names and such was loaned from wizard stories, but referred to real creatures yet undiscovered.
Secondly, i lean more to these creatures being undiscovered. True, they could have been discovered by Newt before. And it's possible that his Grandson knew that some of these creatures exists. But i get the feeling that Newt didn't just go catalogue creatures that was already known. I believe most of those he wrote about was ones that was unknown up to that time. Perhaps much like those looking for the yeti or nessie. Perhaps hearing legends and then seeking to prove them real. And in that way Luna's talents could allow her to find creatures even Newt couldn't find. Creatures more magical than those currently seen, can logically not be found except by a rare individual with equally high magical talents.
I wouldn't be surprised if Luna's mother had been a pupil of Newt, or at least a friend. And perhaps the desire for the diadem of ravenclaw was tied into their quest to explore this world.
I think Luna knows exactly what’s going on, she just takes a step back, flip it with a different point of view. I think Luna is the smartest wizard, and knows way more than what she’s tells people.
Wait, it’s only 90° no fair actually kind of cold today. The high is going to be in 100°, so it’s not as hot as it’s been lol
I think of the Wrackspurts as a psychological thing that is viewed as magical, like the Yips. I wonder if Wrackspurts are sort of like a manifestation of anxiety/panic or even an anxiety/panic attack. It is not unrealistic to think she might have trauma that results in such, but also seeing it as a creature is fitting for the Lovegoods, as well as making it easier for her to deal with if she can physically fight them off. The symptoms fit, and it would be fitting for the time when Harry experienced it. I might be reaching.
The cause of "the yips" is gambling debts.
So the truth is that Neville's Slippers have wrackspurts!!
Why isn't the original Luna on your Thumbnail?
Wow! The captioner actually got Crumplehorn Snorkak right!
In regards to the comment about cereal and milk. "Only the Sith deal in absolutes."
Luna is the Alex Jones of the wizarding world, only softer spoken.
"They're making the frogs gay!"
@SuperCarlinBrothers What's with the changed thumbnail art (with this one as well as the Maledictus and Patronus videos)?
Is that someone cast as Luna in the HBO series?
Hi J!
Very cool!
you should do a “what if Voldemort got hold of the philosopher stone”. ik he can’t get it from the mirror so the only way would be to somehow get it from gringods before hagrid 🤷♂️.
I don't know anything about narwhals but I do know that unicorns are in fact one horned rhinoceros
I absolutely love this! And it seems such a Ravenclaw thing too!
is Sirius the lead singer of the magical band, did a witch ride to the moon on a clean sweep 2000
I add cereal to milk. Gets to soggy so I just add little bits at a time.
Idea: Voldemort was taught how to open the chamber of secrets by Salazar slitherin brought back by the ressurection stone. Discuss
WOW WOW WOW WOW.... WOW pitch meetinggggg
Newt really took a page from grindlewald’s book of deception huh
Our Lady Mothra 🥰
I like the idea that she was homeschooled, her mother died so the terms she learned is 'wrong', never transitioned to the real terms. The dad is lost in keeping Luna's childhood, forgetting himself to much. So she is still learning, making terms of her own along with logic of conspiracy theories, writing to her magazine. So no one understands what she is saying, even thou her ideas are well formulated. People even avoid asking what her terms are, because they have not learn how to form logic or they she as loony(but not the Canadian money).