How Fred and George Solved The Marauders Map | Harry Potter Film Theory
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp - go to betterhelp.com/... to get started today.
Head on over to uncommongoods.c... to get 15% off!
Today J dives into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to discover how Fred and George Weasley figured out how to use the Marauders Map! Did they just guess, “I Solomnley Swear I am up to no good? Did the map test them? And How did the marauders lose the map to begin with?
Through The Griffin Door
TH-cam :: / @throughthegriffindoor
Apple :: podcasts.apple...
Spotify :: open.spotify.c...
#supercarlinbrothers #HarryPotter
Edited by :: Ethan Edghill
Carlin Brothers Coffee & Merch ►► carlinbrothers...
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)
I can only imagine Lupin realizing that Harry has the Map, then biting his knuckles trying not to laugh when it starts insulting Snape and he FINALLY gets to see this ~20 year old prank come to fruition.
I never realized until reading this that they would have specifically added that for snape when they created the map vs using an enchantment that just insults whomever is trying to use it that shouldn't be like i thought is was.
@@sonorangaming449 I always thought it was enchanted to insult anyone who reads it, but I came upon a wiki entry about the "Charm to insult Severus Snape" one day.
@@jagnestormskull3178 It's so much better. Lupins face was amazing when he realized what happened.
@@jagnestormskull3178 some guy a million years ago created it just for snape.
@@PlaceHolder007YTlol
So basically it’s the Jumanji board game asking the Jigsaw question “do you wanna play a game?”
Hey guys loving your podcast...... Spotify doesn't have a comment section so here I am .......my theory is that Hagrid came to the island via a (single travel) portkey..
..... teleportation magic as you point out is extremely uncomfortable to him....he is not supposed to use magic because the ministry might trace it......he is supposed to go to leaky couldron with Harry Potter where everybody spots them (this serves as an aliby as Hagrid can say he only went to Gringots to fetch Harry some money from his vault thus not alerting Voldemort who Dumbledore suspects is lurking around and wants the stone) and finally when he leaves Harry to get a "pick me up" he goes and gets another portkey cleverly planted somewhere in the diagon alley by Dumbledore which he uses to vanish before Harry turns around to look.....
It could also be magic close to what Tom Riddle did with his diary, minus the horcrux obviously 😅😅😅
7:19 *Witherspoon* 🦹
Here is a what if for you what if Snape became a Marauder with James Sirius Lupine and Peter
How do you guy do it?
Fred and George are such a delight in the books, they are goofing off but still manage to do so much good.
I really like in the second book when Harry is suspected being the heir of slytherin, they act like his heralds "making way for the heir of slytherin" And it makes Harry feel better since the rest of the students know the Twins are always goofing, it kinda removes suspicion on Harry. And the books are just full of moments like that.
Fff guy guy guy get guy hi hi ft Ccc xo
Reading Order of the Pheonix for the first time and I just got past the bit where Fred, George, and Ginny are all chanting "he got off!" After Harry's trial, it really shows how much they value Harry's brotherhood
@@a.ychristian3562 hey
This part made me choke on a bagel I was eating at the time. I came this close to blasting off this planet and I wouldn’t have cared in the slightest cause I went happy.
@@a.ychristian3562They really did include him into the family the second they met him. Fred and George like all other Weasleys saw him like real Family and loved him. Harry marrying into their family so they are now actually Family in title as well is just the best thing that could happen, same goes for Hermione being in as well.
Fred and George are the type of jokers who really want everyone to relax and have a good time. They usually want their "victims" to laugh along. Do they sometimes go too far? Yes, but it normally with good intentions. In their mind, someone like Percy could use a good laugh to relax. It's only malicious when their target is particularly vile, like Umbridge.
Yup, especially since they test their products on themselves to make sure they aren't actually dangerous
Yeah, that's so true for Percy. He was a real stick in the mud for a lot of the series. He was always a bit too uptight for me.
Edit: Can we just talk about how cute J's twins in their Mario Bros Halloween outfits.
Agreed!
George usually keeps Fred in check I say this cause as revenge wjen ron was lile 3 Fred turned something of Ron's into spider and sometimes Fred is really mean to Ron it's def malice aimed at Ron from Fred all cause Ron broke Fred broom
The only time I think they went a bit too far was trapping Montague in the vanishing cabinet… he seriously almost died. Over house points.
I’ll never get over Fred’s death. The fact that George was never able to make a patronus again is just salt in the wound 😭
I take solace in the fact he probably never needed to cast one again.
that just makes it worse
I'm still convinced that Peeves helped Fred and George figure out the map
Very possible.
It's likely.
Fred and George were definitely the only students that Peeves respected
That’s a really good theory actually!!
Wouldn't be surprised if the maraurders gave the map to Peeves with the intend of filtch getting it from him
When anyone brings up the "only Marauders can see other Marauders" theory about the map, they seem to forget that Snape only shows up because he sees Lupin on the map going into the passage.
I just reread that line. You're 100% right. How have we all missed that?
Well Lupin left the map on his desk open, just like in the case of Moody being able to use the map even though he'd be an unsavory character who doesn't know how to operate it, I feel the contents of the map are based on who opened the map, not who'd currently using it. Thus because Lupin opened the map it's able to see the other marauders, perhaps it's even an additional passphrase which enabled the viewing of the other marauders, which lupin invoked because it would allow him to see Sirius.
@@DreadKyllerOh, that makes more sense.
i think it's because snape is a specials case. he spent years of his life hexing with the 4, make sense not all the defense mechanism would work
How about mauraders can only see mauraders when they in animal form
I’m reading HP to my kids (4 and 7) and their favourite part so far was the Map’s insults to Snape. They absolutely LOST IT as soon as I said “abnormally large nose,” continued to laugh themselves silly through the rest of them, and made me reread them again and again. Gotta love those Marauders!
I remember reading the first book to my siblings and they started laughing over the descriptions of the Dursleys… 😅
Because a lot of people bring up Harry seeing Pettigrew on the map as a counter to only the Marauders being able to see the Marauders, while this is the case in the movies, this scene plays out very differently in the books. In the books it's revealed that Lupin, Sirius, James and Remus are the Marauders, and that Lupin found them in the shack by seeing Pettigrew on the map, going further on to explain that he knows how the map works because he helped create it. In the movies it's never actually revealed who the Marauders are, the movie creates a different way to give Lupin the revelation that Pettigrew is alive, by having Harry tell him. Thus in the movies they combined two scenes, the scene where Harry gets caught with the map, and the scene where Lupin finds out about Pettigrew, into the same scene. In the books Harry is caught with the map after an incident in Hogsmeade, the scene where Harry is messing with Malfoy while using the cloak, in the books the cloak is pulled partway off him revealing his floating head, which Malfoy immediately goes to report. Harry rushes to get back to the school via the secret passage to cover himself, in a rush he leaves the cloak in the passage and leaves with the map where it's almost immediately found by Snape. Snape tries to force the map open, and when he's presented with the named Mooney Wormtail, Padfoot and Prongs, as well as very unique insults the Marauders used to say to him, he knew who was behind the map, and went to Lupin with Harry. In the books Harry never sees Pettigrew on the map.
Doesn’t Harry see lupin on the map at the end of the third book? When he goes down to his office to say goodbye?
Imo Harry can see the marauders for the same reason he's protected from voldemort while at privet drive, the blood of his parents, he has the blood of a marauder
@@slayerking360 Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
@@meleardilOr maybe it's just a plot loop. 🤷🏻♂️😂
I like to think the map was designed with a little of the marauders inside, and reacts to everyone differently. So when it detects Snape in Prisoner of Azkaban it insults him (because the Marauders hated Snape). But when it detected Fred and George, it told them how to solve it because it detected their mischievousness.
I also like to think that Lily once found the Marauders map, and it started flirting with her.
You think too much lol
I would love to see the Map call Harry Prongs too seeing as he's James Potter's son.
@@Red_MOON187Would he need to be an animagus himself?
@@wyattstevens8574 Maybe... harry also has a stag as his patronus charm.
Imagine if the Marauders had lived, gotten normal wizarding jobs like... working at the ministry like 90% of the british wizarding population, and made new maps. Maps of Hogsmeade, maps of Diagon Alley, maps of Nockturn Alley... imagine the utility for Aurors. Being able to immediately see criminal wizards entering any of the maps, regardless of disguise, and being able to apparate directly to their position, ready to stupefy.
They'd turn crime fighting upside down in days, and rush through the ranks.
Imagine if they made bigger maps... entire cities.
They clearly had an amazing invention in their hands. Shame they never got to use it properly.
Terrible thought tbh
Nah they used it properly. The only proper way was done 😂😊
@@bootercup001 sneak around, stalk, and bully people?
Seems a waste imo.
Come to think of it... they could see EVERYONE on the map. And almost all of the school was on the map, bar a few special places... and they were four teenage boys with very loose boundaries. Somehow, the map just started feeling icky.
Me when I find a nice bit of magic so I immediatly create surveilance distopia
@@w0t3rdog sorry I actually have no idea what this comment is regarding. I don’t remember much, but based on my emoji I was making a dumb joke, so best to just disregard 😂
What if Snape was actually nice to Harry? (Crouch Sr survives? Snape masters potions? Maybe even occlumency?)
*Harry masters potions? Maybe even occlumency?
And for the record, I think Harry would be fantastic at potions if Snape mentored him but he was always beyond hope with Occlumency, he's just terrible at it. It requires having control of your emotions and that's pretty much Harry's defining characteristic - that he does not
But I would love to see a full video on it
@@samstromberg5593 Let's be fair to Harry and say that Snape shouldn't have been the one teaching him occlumency (at least, not initially). The history between the two of them was bad enough already, and having Snape openly rummage around in his private memories couldn't have been fun. It was the equivalent of having someone who you believed was one of your worst enemies learning all of your most embarrassing secrets.
If someone Harry trusted taught him how to get the hang of it first (like Lupin or Sirius - they could have easily been snuck into the castle), and THEN they had Snape help Harry master it, it would have worked out much better in the long run.
harry liked knowing what voldemort is up to. harry liked going after his curiosity. harry liked being the hero. harry liked being hot-headed. he was meant to fail occlumency @@drakenstoc4885
I was always surprised that Remus didn't ask the boys how they figured out the pass phrase.
I suspect that might be either Sirius idea or James or both
Given that he probably helped create the map, it is likely that he knew what the only ways to reveal the map were. That means that he would not have to ask.
Since we the readers only know (for the most part) what Harry knows, it's entirely possible that he asked and we just didn't hear about it
my theory as to how filtch got it is when the marauders graduated they handed it off to someone who lost it
I like to think there is no real pass phrase, the map is just messing with them.
Like, the twins found it and started talking to it like Snape did, and the map was like "I have found my people".
Depressing Fact: Freds death affected George so much he was never able to produce a corporeal Patronas ever again. This implies 2 things: 1, a fundemental part of his joy in life was Fred, and 2, now that hes dead, he will never have the same amount of happiness in his life ever again.
Holy SHI-
Well FU-
Excuse me while I go cry in the corner...
Heard a head cannon that George hates mirrors cause his reflection reminds him of his other half.
Do we ever get to see what animal form Fred or George’s Petronas takes? I think it would be funny if each of them produced the other twin as their Petronas. But I don’t think it is ever mentioned in the books or movies.?🤔?
@@kalebzerger301 A fox? It's the Gemini animal, as in twins, and they definitely fit the personality. It's a shame they never bonded with Seamus over having the same one.
Sirius seems like the Slytherin, Black family, and had the cunning, ambition and resourcfulness to survive and escape askaban.
Peter is the Hufflepuff but in a strange way. He understands loyalty is important but is confused to who he should be loyal to. Has a huge amount of hard work, dedication and patience keeping himself as a rat for 12 years. And a badger is definitely the most rat like out of all the other creatures on house crests.
Agree
What's more, loyalty can be also something of Slytherin - for instance, Bellatrix
Sirius- Slytherin
James - Gryffidor
Lupin - Ravenclaw
Peter - Hufflepuff
I always assumed Fred and George gave the map to Harry because of Sirius. If someone was trying to get to you, what better solution is there than having a map that will show you they are coming
That makes sense, they want Harry to have some fun but want him to stay safe.
Also if you’re looking for it, you can actually see when Harry sees him and Peter on the map, Harry has two feet which move slowly. Peter has four feet at a time that seem to move quickly which shows that the map can possibly tell people who is in animagus and when they are one
I’m surprised you’ve never mentioned how often ‘at once’ is said in the books. Next time you read them, you should try counting and do a short video or yt short about it. (I think it’s 77 in prince and 66 in hallows)
Why do you continue to be sponsored by better help
That’s the economy dude
They bring in good money for BH and probably get some small bonuses as well, for advertising.
What is this question
Yeah BH suuuuuucks, they exist to sell people’s info and masquerade as a therapy alternative. Big yikes
They need therapy beacause they use to much brain power in every theory video
The “only maurauders can see eachother” theory doesn’t work because A) snape see lupin on it and that’s how he knows where to go. And B) Harry see Peter on it in the movie (although maybe we ignore that one cuz it’s kinda dumb) what’s more likely is that the twins stopped using it by the time Ron got to school because they had in memorized already. And they’d only check it for specific reasons, and wouldn’t check the dorms
Yes! People act like the twins would constantly be keeping tabs on Ron and Ginny, but why? If it was Percy yea but the twins? Like they care if their siblings are sneaking out of the dorms?
Why does everyone forget that Peter was already at the school as PERCY'S pet when the twins got the map?
Orrrr...
The marauders can only see each other when they are in animagus form, others can see them only when they are in human form.
Lupin doesn't have an Animagus form so Snape managed to see him, but the twins couldn't see Peter because he was always in animagus form. Harry was able to because Harry is a Marauder's son
@@srujanshukla9696 EXACTLY! Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
I actually really like that idea, and honestly as soon as you started bringing up the personality I was like "I know where this is going"
Honestly I could see a whole situation happen around this theory, I can visualize the whole scenario
The map: Are you up to no good?
Twins: "The parchment talks?" "That explains a lot" "Would you say we're up to no good?" "Most definitely"
The map: Solemnly Swear it
Twins: "Seems tedious" "It can clearly hear us though" "Worth a shot?" "Filch didn't like it for a reason"
Twins (In unison): "I solemnly swear I am up to no good"
And viola, the map's secrets were unlocked.
I’m pretty sure that you made a video about how the map uses The Book and Quill to keep an up to date list of who all can appear on the map, but does anyone have any theories on what would happen if an addition was made to the school or if part of the structure was destroyed by a curse and couldn’t be repaired? Would The Map update itself or would The Map be out of date? We know it shows secret passages out of the school that no longer exist for various reasons and if I remember correctly the passage to The Hogshead isn’t on there (but that may be a Room of Requirement thing).
Thoughts?
Yeah, you had it right. Fred and George warn Harry that one of the passages shown behind a mirror had caved in, which wouldn't be necessary if the map showed it up-to-date. They also don't say anything like "look here" when they say it caved in, further implying the map didn't "know". So presumably it does not update, with the likely exception of the parts that regularly changed when they were at school, like staircases.
you mean like the bridge getting blown up by seamus?! XD
HHarry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
This also explains why Harry could see Peter, being James’ son
Sure, but I don’t think Harry ever saw Peter on the map in the books. I believe that was a movie change.
@@ellie.b.e.yeah, it's just a movie thing
It's only a movie thing lol
That's film canon. Go watch Seamus Gorman's video about the Marauder's Map because he gave a very solid argument that just explains everything.
@@ellie.b.e. Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
Here is a theory for you, why is Snape in Slytherin?? You get sorted based on what you value most, and Snape never really comes across as ambitious. Maybe you could argue that the reason Snape resents James so much is because of all the glory James seemed to get at Hogwarts 🤔 but the story really implies that has dislike of James is due to his feelings for Lilly.
ambition isn't the only thing slytherins value. his self proclaimed nickname was the half blood prince, which admittedly is a double, since his mother's maiden name was prince, iirc, and he was a half blood, but also referring to yourself as royalty is very prideful. he was also a double agent, which requires a lot of cunning.
@@dualcaster That's right. Snape had pride in himself and wanted to prove to people he was better than his muggle father by doing well academically. He basically wanted to prove to the world that he wasn't nothing.
Sometimes I think it’s simpler than a complex series of traits that you value. Sometimes it’s the people you look up to, and the legacies that you value. I don’t know exactly why Snape values Slytherin over Gryffindor, but he believed that Slytherin was the place to be, and so the hat listened. Similarly, Peter saw James, Sirius, and Lupin who all wanted to be in Gryffindor, and wanted to be as well, so the hat obliged and put him in Gryffindor. Ditto Ron, Hermione, Neville, and countless others.
Snape was ambitious, just not in a way acceptable to the school. Sirius said it himself: Snape knew dark magic even seventh graders did not know. And even if Sirius was exaggerating, Snape still was one of the best potions students and created all sorts of dark magic spells while still in school.
Snape should've taken his potions improvements and published a companion to the Advanced Potion Making textbook if he wanted to prove his superiority.
Wasn’t there a different caretaker before filch? I remember Molly saying a different one caught Mr Weasley when they were out of the dorm late when they were in school.
Apollyon Pringle (I looked up the name)
Molly and Arthur are much older than the 1971-78 group. Remember, their oldest son is a few years past Hogwarts by the time Harry gets there.
Also it would probably have been the same office
im pretty sure it was gamekeeper
When is J going to rate more Harry Potter covers? The first one was super fun and it was really cool to see what the covers looked like around the world.
I think the map is tied to Hogwart's main entrance. In Prisoner of Azkaban, Flitwich trains the front oaken door to recognize Sirius in order to not grant him access into the castle. I think the Marauders could have put a spell on the entrance to "scan" and "register" everyone that enters through it, then link them onto their map. This could be how even people who have never been to Hogwarts before or even live in the UK (such as foreign guests) have their name and location appear up on the map.
FYI: Messrs is French abbreviation for MESSIORS (sirs or Misters); plural for Monsier (Sir or Mister)
How did the Twins learn how to activate and use the Marauders Map? Answer: Peeves the Poltergeist told them.
It’s okay Fred now gets to see his entire family forever go through Hogwarts
Not all who die become ghosts. Fred didn't, sadly
@@cayenigma Far as I remember that was characterized as being pathetic excuse of half-life, so is that really sad?
No, I guess you are correct@@tappajaav
Messrs is the abbreviation for the French version of "misters." It also leans into the proper pronunciation of Voldemort.
While its origins are in French, “Messrs.” is also now simply the plural of “Mr.” In English - i.e. “mister” and “misters”. No need to involve the French at all at this point.
4:20 Was 5+ Peter a subtle reference to ATLA?
The Marauders map is the early version of the wait times map for Disney! I'm sure Harry used it to see the wait time at the bathroom, cafeteria, etc. With cell phone technology, I'm sure Disney could put our names on the map if they so desired. =)
I love this idea, but don't think harry would think of it
But The twins and mauraders most definitely did it
2:38 ummm I JUST NOTICED THIS ON THE MAP BUT WHAT THE HECK IS THE 'DOOM ROOM'!?!?!?!?!?
I think the map might prompt someone into the right incantation, but if anyone were to spontaniously come up with the right phrase, it would be the Weasly twins. Also, if the map doesn't reveal the mauraders to non-mauraders, why did it tell Harry where Pettigrew was?
There is never anything to imply worm tail is a less skilled wizard than almost anyone else. We see at Hogwarts. Of course, James, Sirius, Lupin, Hermione, Snape, and a lily are all superb students. But there is nothing to suggest worm tail was any less skilled than Ron… I feel like people always treat worm tail like he is Neville if Neville was a coward and a traitor, but why?? Just because he is unlikable? Doing one horrible thing doesn’t make a person horrible as a whole, it just means they are a person who has done horrible things. But that has no effect on his skill as a wizard. Worm tail was able to frame serious and escape, when we can assume serious was hunting him down with the intention of killing him. You have to be a pretty skilled duelist to beat serious black, especially when he is the one getting the drop on you. And there is no reason to assume Peter lost the map? I would guess it was either James or serious being cocky little f$&@‘s
Read about the procedure to become an Animagus, and realize that Peter did that too. Peter was no slouch, and seemed to genuinely care about being friends with the other Marauders, which makes the betrayal all the more awful.
I'm pretty sure they said he needed plenty of help but eventually got there. Also, remember how bad he was at identifying werewolves despite being with one every month.
3rd book actually goes into a fair bit of detail about how he is a poor wizard most notable are the parts of the professions discussing him as a kid and Sirius talking about becoming an animagus and how he and James had to hard carry him .
@dankmemes7796 There are steps in being able to transform into an animal. You have to do yourself no one else would be able to help or assist you with. Like being able to hold a leaf in your mouth without swallowing for a month.
I can confirm, Jay's twins are adorable.
The only issues with the theory that only marauders can see the other marauders is that in book cannon snaps see them going to the shrieking shake when he is delivering lupin his potion
True, but Lupin unlocked the map and left in such a hurry he left it sitting open on his desk. So technically, from the map’s perspective, it was a marauder using it and they’d have been visible.
@@ellie.b.e.Exactly
Can't remember. Is Harry seeing peter on the map a movie only thing?
( to replace Lupin seeing peter getting dragged away with Ron?)
Yeah, it's only in the movies
It is only in the movies AND it has been confirmed as a mistake.
Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
I have a question that I think might make a good theory. Why didn't voldemort make an unbreakable vow with all of his death eaters? If he did then snape couldn't have gone to dumbledoor and he would have never had to worry if anyone would betray him because they would die if they tried to. Anyways love the video!!!!!❤❤❤❤
The answer is same as with many of his downfalls, he believed in his superiority and obedience and fear of his followers
You should do a video connecting the seven books to the eight days of Holy Week, bc it connects really well (I’m sure you could make the video appealing to everyone, not just Christians)
Honestly I just assumed that the twins never saw Peter sleeping with Ron or Percy because they never bothered to stalk them at night.
This! Exactly! Everyone’s obsessing over this but why would they bother checking on their little brother?! Like they care if he sneaks out?
Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
The map was completely wasted on Harry. In the 6th book he's apparently obsessed with finding out what Malfoy's up to but never bothers to go and check what Crabbe and Goyle are up to when he sees them hanging out in the 7th floor corridor for hours at a time. If he had he'd have realised sooner that they were using polyjuice potion and standing outside the room of requirement
The same with the two ways mirror. Harry is not really good at using all the ridiculously powerful magical artifacts he came into possession one time or another.
1) 5:19 why didn’t Dumbledore make a map for security purposes?
2) 11:23 Snape actually saw Lupin go to the Womphing Willow tho…
Yeah because Lupin opened the map and left it on his desk, that's why Snape saw them.
@@RKIJSITFAHCWGOR Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
@@meleardil Cap. Harry can't see Lupin bc only the Maurauders themselves can see each other on the map. Snape only saw them bc Lupin left the map open on his desk.
And btw it doesn't matter if someone is in his animagus form or not. The map can still see who that person/animal is. The map isn't fooled by animagi, as well as it isn't fooled by ghosts or any other magical creatures like werewolves etc.
While it's great that Harry basically gets the map because he ballooned his aunt, it's even more compelling because the reason he has to deal with Marge and the Dursleys at all is because his own parents are gone, so in a way, Fred and George give Harry the map because James couldn't give it to him himself.....although I guess they did get it from Filch who presumably confiscated it from either a Marauder or someone they passed it on to so really James couldn't give it to Harry so much as just tell him what it was and where to find it, but I digress 👀
Also, do you think Harry ever told the twins that they were so closely tied with the authors of the map and had even been taught defense by one of them, lived under the same roof of another for over a decade, and briefly lived in the house of a third?
I'd imagine they found out during the summer before Harry's 5th year, when they met Sirius Black.
By the way, the actual reason the twins gave Harry the map was because his broom had been destroyed by the Whomping Willow when the Dementors attacked Harry during a Quidditch match, resulting in Harry's first loss in Quidditch.
Veery unfortunately, Snape sees Lupin on the map when he heads to the tunnel on his way to the shreaking shack so even Snape - and therefore everyone, I assume - can see everyone else, even the marauders on the map. I would have loved the theory that they were only visible for other marauders but it sadly is disproven by the books.
Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
Harry isn't a Marauder and was able to see Peter on the Map (or was that only in the movie?). Or maybe, the map reveals Marauders to their the descendants too.
that was ONLY in the movie... Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
If you really think about it, Peter Petigrew mangaged the MOST mischief out of the 4 in the long run. He killed 12 muggles, framed one of his best friends for the murders, had his friend be sent to Azkaban, lived in hiding for years under the Order of the Phoenix's nose, orchestrated the kidnapping of Harry (during the TWT) and brought Voldemort back. I hate to say it... he's one sneaky Niffler! 😅
I always imagined that _The Marauders_ had decided when leaving school The Map would be of little future use to them, so they'd to bequeath _The Map_ to the next set of worthy mischief makers, and had enchanted _It_ with the desire to be used by similar people; much the way the wand chooses the wizard~ let _The Map_ find those future worthy mischievous students; mischievous, but not with dark/evil intent.
Where else better than Filch's office? Filch would never be able to use it, _The Map_ would never allow him to, probably only insulting remarks much as _It_ did with Snape. but Filch's office is where _"Trouble Makers"_ of the sort _The Marauders_ would have respected, were sure to be taken at one time or another.
Then, after _The Map_ found _The Twins,_ IT accepted _THEM,_ Much the way a wand may shift alliances, It Chose Them then They choose a new suitable {enchantment/password} to open _The Map,_ as one may present a computer with a new PIN or Password when personalizing it for the first time...
Just a few days ago, the channel The Uncanny JMen (just shy of 300 subscribers as of the time of writing) uploaded a video on this very topic. Their conclusion is also very similar to yours (the map itself "talks" to Fred and George and eventually guides them to the correct solution). It's not my intention to throw any shade on you, a channel that I've been following for years and that I deeply love, but the timing of this video is weird...
SINGULAR POSSESSIVE!! It's a map for someone who marauds. It is NOT a proper noun. James and his friends did NOT refer to themselves as THE marauders. Not once.
what you missed is that Lilly was probably instrumental in creating the map. As noted by nearly everyone who talks about her, she was the most talented with charms.
Hmm… not convinced at all on the pun with messrs. I don’t think that is what JK is going for at all, it is not clever or subtle enough. But it is quite “schoolboy” English humour to playfully overly formalise and aggrandise a group of young men (either in a positive or negative light).
I always felt it played into the sense of “schoolboy” arrogance we get from the Marauders, it is difficult to explain to an American other than to say it is quite niche “schoolboy” humour - which is not to say that it is limited to those of school age, it is an impertinence and boyish nature which exists in many English men and in particular those who have had a certain sort of education. Such groups often include young men who, like Sirius and James, come from old families but who equally do not take themselves too seriously.
I subscribe more to the idea that it's an artifact of the school like the room of requirement, maybe even created by the room itself. And if anything its probably not a Griff item. They are too courage to stop and create a map, risking it all. It's slytherin in nature, answering they are up to no good. Maybe it was a ravenclaw item, knowledge without purpose, and it was on 100% of the time. Then our favorite 4 trouble makers added a lock to it. My favorite part of your video is how Fred and George figured it out. I assume the key was given with it by the room itself. I like yours much better
5:00 was Filch around when the Marauders were? It's easy to think so since he's a really old squib, so what else would he be doing, but Mrs Weasly is younger than Filch (in the movie, I don't remember if Filch's age was revealed in the books as "greasy" doesn't really convey age) and she directly mentioned having not only a different groundskeeper but one that was a wizard. It would make sense that the office of the groundskeeper would be the same despite the owner, so the map probably got taken by a wizard groundskeeper.
Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
I feel like either the Marauders told peeves how to do it when they left for them to tell some mischievous Gryffindors Cuz fun fact peeves the poltergeist exists in the books. That's always been how it's been in my head at least
additionally in order to work within Hogwarts it must be made OF Hogwarts... and its actually piggybacking on the headmaster's access.
I really think the "Why do Fred And George not notice Peter" question is overplayed. The much easier explanation is that they aren't interested in Ron's whereabouts or the goings on in the Gryffindor dormitories.
Just a theory, but what if the Marauders simply gave the map to younger students when they graduated, who then lost it to Filch. Idk, seems more likely to me than them just giving it to Filch or getting caught.
Gred and Feorge video!!!!!
The twins are shooting up so fast. Also wanted to say Happy Birthday to Luke who turns 6 this month (Nov 2023)
Except Harry saw Peter Pettigrew. He told Lupin he saw someone he knew to be dead. That was why he was out in the first place! And that’s why Lupin was looking for him too…
I sat through the whole video and still don't know how Fred and George figured out the marauders map. You talked about them but if you slipped the answer in it was not apparent to me.
So if anybody could tell me in like a sentence or two I would appreciate it. Thanks
Quick question, does the map lose its magic, after lupin dies ? I mean, it happens after dumbledore dies for the secret keeper on the headquarters and a few other senerios I'm pretty sure
The problem with the theory about the Marauders being hidden on the map from anyone but other Marauders is that Snape saw Lupin on the map in PoA
Lupin had previously opened the map and left it open on his desk. The map cannot detect who is using it, only who opened it.
Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
Slight error, I believe Snape says the reason he comes down to the Shrieking Shack is because he sees Lupin, Peter and Sirius there on the map.
Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
Uncanny J Men had a video last week about this, though they thought that it wasn’t actually a password but the phrase endeared the twins to the map.
according to Seamus' theory, was harry able to see peter because he is james son and some kind of magic that makes him now a marauder like an heir?
Hey brother i have just a one request for you guys make a quiz with movie flams channel i would love to see you all together you three are the god of Harry Potter
The theory where only marauders can see eachother on the map is easily disproven by a small section from Chapter 19 of Prisoner of Azkaban:
Snape was slightly breathless, but his face was full of suppressed triumph. "You're wondering, perhaps, how I knew you were here?" he said, his eyes glittering. "I've just been to your office, Lupin. You forgot to take your potion tonight, so I took a gobletful along. And very lucky I did... lucky for me, I mean. Lying on your desk was a certain map. One glance at it told me all I needed to know. I saw you running along this passageway and out of sight."
Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
So many people are talking about Harry seeing Peter Pettigrew on the map, but that only happened in the movie.
So you guys mentioned that the marauders could only see each other, but Harry sees Peter on the map, wandering the hallway. Or was that just a movie thing?
Or is it because he is James’s son that he can see the other borders? Like blood relatives can also be considered?
I’m assuming that may be the case. It would make sense considering how intelligent the map is
@@rebeccamills16It is just in the movies, in the books it's Lupin who sees Peter. Snape saw Lupin on it, too, but Lupin left the map open on his desk, so from the perspective of the map, it was still used by Lupin and him alone.
@@luskaneseprinceExactly
Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
The theory of the map not showing it Marauders to people who aren't Marauders themselves, sort of falls apart when you realize that Harry also saw Peter Pettigrew on that map
😜Did I tell you how much I hate Deloris? Yes, Deloris Jane Umbige!
What if Snape heard the full prophecy?
What if Voldemort hid the Diary in Filch's office?
The map is basically like the "Bible" in the American Pie franchise. Maybe actively handing it down to the next generation of chaos-lovers was practiced more often than just from the twins to Harry. Maybe they were even told by older students that they have placed the map into Filch´s office and stealing it is part of the ceremony to become the next "marauders".
While a cool theory, the idea the map hides the Marauders from other's eyes doesn't fly, as Snape himself says he saw Lupin going down the tunnel. And we all know the Marauders would make sure Snape of all people can't use the map, hence the insults. But since Lupin left it on when he went to save Harry, Snape could read it.
"You're wondering, perhaps, how I knew you were here?" he said, his eyes glittering. "I've just been to your office, Lupin. You forgot to take your potion tonight so I took a gobletful along. And very lucky I did... lucky for me, I mean. Lying on your desk was a certain map. One glance at it told me all I needed to know. I saw you running along this passageway and out of sight."
If anything, if you want the theory to still work, it could be that the map doesn't show the Marauders unless a Marauder activates it. That way other people can't use it against them still, but they can use it to find each other while leaving the scenario where Snape uses it available.
I'm pretty sure your last paragraph is precisely how it works, if the map could just change it's content or capabilities based on who's holding it, then it almost certainly would have closed or done something to mess with the fake Moody in GoF. The map doesn't seem to care about who's holding or who's viewing it, but who unlocks it. It wouldn't even surprise me if the Marauders had a second, secret passphrase that unlocks the map with additional capabilities.
@@DreadKyller Yeah, I came to the same conclusion at the end. Its really the only way for Snape to read it with Marauder locations on without the map flipping out and trying to give him a papercut
Maybe the marauders charmed it so that they are invisible on the map, only specifically in animagus or werewolf forms, because then it could explain why the twins never mentioned NOT seeing lupin on the map but also don’t know Peter is here, because Peter is perpetually in rat form. From the marauders pov, I think the map getting discovered and them using it to break rules won’t be too big a deal even if they lost it and get punished but being animagus is the biggest secret they have and they cannot have that be known, so even if they lost it and someone else uses it, they would see the name of Sirius black where a black dog is for example. Also that way they can safely pass the map on without the risk of the successor knowing the animagus secret.
@@ForkJuuga EXACTLY. Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes more sense.
I could have sworn you covered this before...🤔
Yup, two years ago.
th-cam.com/video/Eqiw_ZEIhIg/w-d-xo.htmlsi=w-k0FBHTY8zbngd9
I would love to see J vs Ben vs The Phillip twins (the actors who played gred & feorge)
Fun fact Aunt Marge is not his aunt. She's Vernon's sister so she is Dudley's aunt.
Which begs the question: What do you call a woman that is your cousin's aunt but not your mother? An in-law?
your argument is basically saying that vernon isn't his uncle. just because they're family through marriage doesn't mean they're not family.
@@dualcaster No I said Vernon is his uncle through marriage but his sister is not related to Harry Vernon's siblings do not count as anything to Harry because they are not related to him. Vernon is only related through marriage. His siblings are not Believe me, I have a lot of people I shop for cuz they are related through marriage but that has never included all of their siblings. That includes just the person who married into the family, not everyone they're related to though I will say on my dad's side I don't really have cousins. The closest thing I've got is we share and Aunt and uncle through marriage. Like my dad's sister married her mom's dad and we would hang out basically on Thanksgiving every couple of years and we're friends on Facebook. That's basically the" cousin on that side of the family but we're not actually related I have actual cousins on the other side of the family cuz all my mom's siblings have kids none of my dad's siblings have kids and on my dad's only kids so the only grandkid on that side of the family mom's side everyone has kids
She’s still technically his aunt through marriage, that’s like saying Vernon isn’t his uncle.
@@brandibastian4193it depends on how close your families are but she’s still considered his aunt even if it is through marriage just like Vernon isn’t related to Harry by blood but is still his uncle through marriage.
but if the marauders only shows to the other marauders then how did harry se peter petegrew?
Can we talk about what Newt Scamander was doing in book 3. Cuz hes on the map 👀
Didn't Harry see Peter Pettigrew on the map? Harry isn't a Marauder
But how did Harry see peter before lupin knew he had the map?
The fact that harry kept the map and watched ginny 😭😭😭
Yeah, I always thought that was a little creepy.
I've always been a bit disappointed there was never a scene were Fred and George reacted to finding out who the Marauders were. Any on else? Maybe the Carlin Brothers could make a video about how they think the twins would have reacted?
Seconded!
Whoooaa... follow-up question--what happens if you break your oath to the map, where you're NOT up to no good? Do you think the map also has been jinxed, like the jinx Hermione put on the DA signup paper, that would bind the user of the map to relatively-harmless mischief only? And what "punishment" do you think the Marauders would have deemed fitting for someone who abuses or misuses the map?
I always thought it was NOT a word by word passphrase. It was a magically binding declaration of intent in ANY form. If you are a mischief maker, the map will aid you. If you are a rulekeeeper, the map will hide or worse, work against you.
*2 points of discussion*
1. In this video, aunt Marge is referred to as "the literal worst". But i thought that role was promised to umbridge for eternity. NEW THEORY: is Harry's aunt Marge possibly related to Umbridge? (They are both terrible people)
2. The map (at least in the movies) shows Filch. If a previous theory is true, can the map show a poltergeist? What about ghosts? Or does the map prove filch is human?
Umbridge is a half-blood, which means there are Muggles in her family. It's possible. Unfortunately, that would make her related to Harry through Vernon's marriage.
Filch and peeves are both referenced in the book on the map im not sure if theres ever a reference to a ghost
@madalynnr9940 so if peeves is mentioned, (regardless of ghosts) it is still possible filch can be a poltergeist. Gotcha
@coolnerdlll6053 maybe that's why Marge is such a miserable person.
Her relative (that she must have some knowledge about) was treated better than she was by adults growing up, and she resents that. {A lot like how petunia was envious of and hated Lily). Maybe she has heard she has a cushy, high ranking (magical) government job.
@@iowa89357NO Filch is a human being, a squib and NOT an agent of chaos. So he can't be a poltergeist lol.
If the only people that could see the marauders on the map are other marauders, then how would Harry have seen Pettigrew? Unless I missed some information, that would imply Harry was a marauder, I would assume by way of inheritance through James?
Which also implies Harry would be the only one of any of the kids able to see lupin or Pettigrew or Sirius.... unless I missed something, I'll just assume that's a loose end that never got situated
Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
The map not showing the Mauraders except to other Mauraders is an interesting theory but has one major flaw in it. In Prisoner of Azkaban Snape only knows where to go to find Lupin because he saw Lupins name on the map going down the passage to the shreaking shack. Shapes not Maurader and is a known enemy of the Mauraders so if there was anyone they would have wanted to have themselves hidden from it would have been him. My reference for this is chapter 19 of Prisoner of Azkaban about 59 seconds into the audible version.
Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
I always assumed that the phrase wasn't a specific passcode, but that anything the map recognises as acceptable would work. But Fred and George "unlocked" the map using that specific phrase (perhaps when they were goofing around with each other) and assumed it was a specific lock and key, passing it down to Harry.
I think if Harry just said anything along the lines of "I'm the son of James Potter" that would have been good enough too, and he'd of course get custom greeting lines from the Messers first :)
Exactly... it is not a word by word passphrase. It is a magically binding declaration of intent. Are you a mischief maker? The map will aid you.
Finally.....someone has explained why Fred and George didn't see Peter on the map with Ron!! Even tho i have read the series twice, my brain tends to combine "book canon" with "movie canon", so I sometimes miss some of the things that only happened in the movie. The exception is the burning of the Burrow. I was very happy to find that incident only happened in the movie. And, since I watched the movies first, I could hear the actor's voices in my head while reading....even if the scene didn't happen in the movie.
Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
But... if Peter doesn't show up on the map to anyone but the the other marauders, how does that explain Harry seeing him on the map before running into Snape in the hall?
Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
But even if the marauders could only see each other by a saftey mechanism, why was it that Harry was able to see Peter Pettigrew? My theory is that he has got James' blood running through him, therefore the safety mechanism would not work on Harry.
Harry can NOT see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
Everyone always seems to conveniently forget that Snape, too, sees Lupin on the map in Prisoner. That's the whole reason he comes down into the Shrieking Shack.
Harry can not see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.
@@meleardil Yes well if you're asking me you're bending over backwards to explain what is simply a plothole. Sure, if you absolutely must have an in-universe explanation - to each their own head canon, right?
I think to add to the theory of The mauraders can only be seen on the map by the mauraders and their kin (CHildren grandchildren etc)
Harry can NOT see Peter, but Harry can see Lupin. Snape was able to see Lupin too. Why? The Marauders are visible on the map in HUMAN form, but dont show up for others in ANIMAL form, only to each other. It also makes sense.