ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ก.ย. 2024
- I have used both the ResMed Airsense 10 and the Philips Respironics DreamStation auto CPAP machines and this is a comparison between the two. I forgot to say that the Philips is the DreamStation, but it is. If you are considering buying one of these machines, some of these small details may help you decide. They are BOTH great machines and are super quiet. Feel free to ask any questions, I will try to answer as best as I can.
I like the Resmed because it doesn’t poison me.
Despite what Phillips says, I would not put the water chamber in the dishwasher - especially the drying cycle. That metal plate when it is heated in the dishwasher is probably cracking the plastic.
thanks for the video , i will buy the res Med because some problems with the Dreamstation isolation
Coming up on my 2-year anniversary with my ResMed AirSense 10, and have been very happy with it! Great video for people to compare the top dogs of CPAP!
Appreciate the comparison. Thank you, going with the resmed for the smaller foot print
Cheers mate. My partner was just diagnosed with severe sleep apnea and these are the two machines we've been tossing up between! This video will help him decide what's best. Thanks for taking the time!
Thanks for the kind words. Glad it helped!
This is a good comparison. I used a Dream station for 18 months, changed to a Resmed for the last two months. To me, the resmed is eons ahead of the dream station for doing what it is supposed to, which is help me sleep at night. I personally sleep better and feel so much better overall using the resmed. Your mileage may vary.
Very helpful. I've just trialled the Resmed for two months and am going in to buy one today, but wanted to look at the Dreamstation as well. After watching this, I'm definitely sticking with the Resmed. Smaller, quieter (if only just!), less finicky to get started and a more durable tank. That's a big win for Resmed.
Thanks so much for putting this on, great comparison, very helpful. I was torn between the two machines because I wanted to get a very quiet machine, I currently have the philips resprionics system one bipap been using it for 5 years and in the past few months its been having issues with the machine whistling, not holding pressure and its just loud. After seeing this video though I'm now leaning more towards the resmed. Again thanks for posting.
Thank you for your comment. I'm glad it helped :D
The cracking on the heating plate on the dreamstation is a no-go for me. Thank you for the review!
Airsense10 humidifiers are notorious for developing leaks so I'd say it's a wash.
Thank you so much for this video! I was recently diagnosed with severe apnea and I couldn't decide which machine to get. This is very helpful. 😺
Thanks for your nice comments! Glad this helped.
Great video and the best comparison I have seen so far.
Always wondered how the two compare, so thanks for the video.
Great reviews!!! The sound comparison is hard to find in reviews do much appreciated
I'm glad it helped!
thank you - I don't have anything yet. just trying it out from cpap. First night tonight -
They have given me the Philips one and after hearing this - I think that I would prefer the resmed. if I end up purchasing one. Thank you for the info. Keep up the good job.
I'm so lucky to have the NHS I've got both machines. the resmed 10 only two days ..and it wins hands down
I used the DS1 for 2-3 years until Foamgate hit. It was great to use, until the recall. Now I’m using an AirSense 10, and can’t imagine going back to Phillips. They each have strengths and quirks, but the AS10 - to me - is just a better machine. Plus, it won’t make me sick.
I think the cracks to the water container is probably being caused by your dishwasher.
That is a good point. Something to consider.
Over time the cracks around the plate happen with hand washing too. I don’t own a dishwasher but I have seen the little cracks over time. I suspect it’s the heating element beneath the water chamber, but a dishwasher intuitively seems like it would speed this process up … just my opinion
I agree with the comments below, ResMed is better overall...smaller footprint, auto on when mask is placed and the hose quality is far superior. I used the PR DS for a couple of weeks and the hoses are crap. They tore at the slightest tugs. Also to turn off the machine, you need to hold the button down for several seconds before it shuts off. Otherwise, it’ll keep running. Now I’m forced to go with the DS, because ResMed machines don’t give the high pressure I need on my new ASV. ☹️
You tug on your hose haha
@@cebruthius
who doesn't tug their own hose??
..better than tugging on someone else's, i suppose.
Well, that question has been finally and fefinitely answered by a Philips recall. Never again Philips, ever!
Have tried them both and the RESMED Airsense turned out to be my preferred choice because it did not give me the "darth vadar" breathing noise that you get at higher pressures when using the dreamstation. Thanks for pointing that out!
Thanks a lot Gar for the review!
You're welcome! Hope it helped.
I recently purchased a Resmed Airsense 10 autoset after using a Resmed S9 Elite for 10 years (that still works). I have been a little disappointed with the Resmed Airsense 10 autoset.
The S9 is a better overall design and the humidifier reservoir is easier to clean. The position of the screen on the 10 is silly and it is at a bad angle to read. I could go on.
This is very interesting about the Airsense 10 as I'm just about to upgrade from a S9 to one of these two machines. (Nothing wrong with the S9 at all - it's just 6 years old.) Looking forward to _either_ of these machines as they both seem much quieter than the S9 (which wasn't bad at all compared to the machines I was using before that!). I'm leaning towards the Dreamstation though because I have a Dreamstation Go for travel/airplanes and that's just wonderful ...
Has there been investigation on Remed FOAM and it's safety? In light of the Phillips carcegenec foam recall can Resmed company verify their products safety? Anyone????
@@michellelippincott6097 I saw on CPAP Reviews channel that he had a statement from ResMed that they don't use the same foam and there is no issue with their foam.
@@MickSkitz I think after ALL this I don't trust ANY of the companies.
Main thing about all those machine is amount of noise they produce. They are making noise when its quiet home at night time. You can here specific nose every time you exhale. Second later after exhale, machine produce some kind of wiared noise. Its not loud, but when you keep notice it - it keeps you awake. I had 2 machine previous generation. Older machine - is super quiet. I took it apart and noticed big fat foam insulation inside machine. Old machine was heavy but absolutely quiet. System one machine not as quiet, but still much better then new one, which i assume does not have sufficient insulation inside (cost reduction). I bought new machine and end up using old one, because that tiny noise keeping me awake.
So since you were a previous Dreamstatiion user and I am a new Dreamstation user coming from 5 years' use of ResMed Airsense 10 Autoset have you seen different data coming from the change in machines? I have been using the Dreamstation now for 5 days and have seen Periodic Breathing, Increased Snore, and RERA, which I never saw while using the Airsense10. I have noticed as well that the Dreamstation does not raise the pressure as the Airsense10 did during use. I am just wondering if you have seen better therapy from Resmed Airsense than from the Dreamstation. I got the Dreamstation because insurance was paying for a new machine and I thought I would give it a try to see what it would be like. I would appreciate you thoughts.
Hi Brad, any new info by comparison??
I like my Philips and my gf using the resmed. Water tank is so much better and although the footprint looks bigger its also a flat top so if you put stuff on your nightstand you will still have the space to do so just put it on top of the unit. I don't know how you manage with the full mask. I use the under nose and it works perfect even with full pressure being used.
What is the model number for the mask you are using? I have the AirFit N30 & N30i and it seems to slide off a little when sleeping because I am a side sleeper.
If I am correct that's F20 mask
Good morning Mr, I have question about energy electrical with equipment working, i live in argentina, here the voltage is around 220, with the frequency is 50 Hz, thats equipments are adapted for this zone south american. thanks for your explication of both medical equipment.
Awesome video! Just letting you know, you will have to change the ResMed humidifier, the same thing will happen, and will need to be changed. ResMed recommend changing it every 6 months, but if it's looked after, you should get 12 months or more. I used to soak my humidifier in a disinfectant/antibacterial solution, but it breaks down the glue that's used. I've learnt that it's much better to just wash the humidifier with warm soapy water...not hot. How have you found using it so far?
It's held up pretty well so far. It's a little creaky now at the hinges, but still works well. I know I'll have to get another one at some point.
I really like the idea respironics has with the air filter vs resmed. Resmed is very loose and floppy air filter. It's loose fitting vs the right cartridge of the respironics. Thoughts please. I am buying soon. Air filter is super important to keep the machine clean. And covid I don't want covid.. the cracks to your plastic water chamber is likely do to the dishwasher heat is very hot with soap enzymes breaking down the plastic. The water chamber is going to help the sound if you put water in it. Also I have hose covers and it really helps. I got the blue respironics and the grey resmed tube zipper covers. How's the software on the smart phone? Which one allows you to get a better idea of your apnea issue?
DreamMapper and MyAir both suck. Download OSCAR
Do you have any chance to compare Dreamstation 2 vs Resmed
thanks for the video
You're welcome.
Thank you for the video. Would you be able to give me some advice on how do you find your perfect fit mask and what model of mask are you currently using
I think most people have to try several different masks before they find the mask that works best for them (myself included). My advice is to look at CPAP mask reviews and try to make an educated guess. I am wearing a ResMed AirTouch F20. The foam cushion was a real game changer for me.
Thanks so much for your review
I know this question is late in coming, but which machine holds the most water? I have the resperonics and it runs dry by morning in the winter time; so uncomfortable! We heat with wood, so the house is super dry!
The sound of them is much louder on the video than in person.
Great video. How would you compare the air filters. The Philips has a disposable fine filter + washable filter combination. How do they compare with the Resmed filter?
The Resmed is just a disposable square filter that should be changed every month. They are inexpensive.
Great video, thanks!
hi there, thanks for the video, i have to pick between the two, and your video is very helpful. i have a question regarding how they work. i frequently get power cuts, and im concerned that the mask could inhibit my breathing if the machine switches off. would that happen? or would the mask allow me to keep breathing if the machine goes off.
Thank you for making this. I'm trying to decide if I want to try the Dream Station after having the Resmed for 5 years. The face cushion seems to leak pretty quick and need to be replaced. What do you think of the face mask that goes with the Dream Station, any differences?
Face Masks do not come with machine and can work with either. Personally, I am a Full Face Mask user and I have been using Simplus but they have supposedly improved it to the new version Vitera.
Do I need to get a new prescription to buy another CPAP machine? Do you have go through all that test processes again?
It depends on how long it has been since your last test. I got my last cpap machine 10 years ago, so I needed to do another at home test, in order for me to get a prescription.
Im new to all of this. Can you inform me of the name of the mask you are using in the video
Dishwasher is ruining your humidifier tray on the DS1
Can you use the restmend without humidifier
Yes! There is a "side cover". It's basically a plug to put in the side of the machine instead of the humidifier.
@@GrantSorensen I think you have to buy that separately though - or does it come with the machine?
I’ve used a ResMed airsense10 for 11 months now and it has started making a whining noise which makes it annoying
Got a SoClean?
Yes I did but no longer I started getting headaches so stopped using it. Wash all my Cpap stuff now and use a hurricane dryer. Had to get a new Cpap machine
@@flaviamcfatridge592 So you didn't use it for long? ResMed has published a letter saying that they can see damage from SoClean and it voids the warranty.
which one is better ?
They are both great machines. The ResMed is a little quieter and the Dream Station is a better design.
Thanks
Resmed because of philips foamgate
How about Dreamstation 2
@@cantoplar Dreamstadion 1 kullanıyorum. Köpük sorunundan haberim yoktu. 2-3 ay kullamdım. Auto modelini güzel sessiz bir cihaz nefes nefes alıp verme rahat bir çok ayarı var sessiz de Şuan kararsısızım kullanmak zorundayızda Ama sadece ABD de çağrılmış köpük değişikliği için Bizim ülkemizde kayıt alıyorlar internetden cihazları ama çağrılma yok
Can I have your email Id please have to clear some doubts on E30 Ventilator..
Hi Gar, We want to share with you a CPAP cleaner, and give it to you. could I get your email?