At 80, Roger Waters Finally Reveals How Pink Floyd Came To An End. The Truth Will Shock You
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ส.ค. 2024
- The music was groundbreaking, the concerts were legendary, but behind the scenes, a war was brewing at Pink Floyd. Roger Waters, the driving force behind the band, has finally opened up about the toxic power struggles, creative clashes, and bitter betrayals that tore them apart. The truth will leave you questioning everything you thought you knew about one of the greatest bands in history.
![พบรัก - INK WARUNTORN x FELLOW FELLOW [LIVE SESSION]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1VonHhP6_Y8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W3D1 | Fall | สัปดาห์ตัดสิน ทีมไปไฟนอล](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZBU3GyzqErI/mqdefault.jpg)
Why do you keep showing U2 when talking aboutPink Floyd?
...and the Sex Pistols ?
because "The Unseen" are amateurs!
It's propagandistic trick, in any other many things the propagandistic machine force to expose british royal family members and so on
And punk clips 😮
עם ישראל🇦🇷חי!!!
Most of the pictures are totally irrelevant to the story, the entire saga is covered much better on other channels.
i know he can't even spell Gilmour and why punks and U2 , ridiculous video 😂😂
Why does TH-cam allow videos,depicting a certain subject, interject visuals that have absolutely nothing to do with the subject.
Doesn't that get old? A buddy of mine and I will watch one and guess which incorrect band photo is coming next, but we make selections that would be even more absurd so at least we get a laugh out of this otherwise worthless waste of time
It's a little irritating.
Pink floyd didn't end, Water's collaboration with PF ended. :PF did fine without him for years after he left.
In all those years they managed a piddly two albums with Dave needing his Mrs to write lyrics.
@@absinthedream9668 I'll take quality over quantity any time.
@@jordangouveia1863 Two of the worst Pink Floyd albums in the entire catalogue lol
album sales proof this wrong
@@frankiefourfingers6717 Dumbest metric ever, Taylor Swift has sold a ton more albums it's meaningless.
For those of us who live and loved the music of Pink Floyd it is inappropriate to get into the internal conflict of the band. Personally I wish them all well and RIP to those who have passed on, Nothing absolutely nothing in my mind would detract from the absolute greatness of Roger Waters, His music apart, he is a compassionate complete human being . Let's face it, there aren't many who can match him,
As an inflated dildo.................absolutely.
entlich einmal jemand der die wahren werte von roger erkennt. danke für ihren kommentar. diese dummen hassparolen gegen waters kann man einfach nicht mehr hören. muss echt schlimm sein so von hass zerfressen zu sein, ich denke solche menschen hassen sich selbst.
@@socialmeaslesinpartnership1252 guck mal in den spiegel
So U2 is the reason Pink Floyd couldn't get along?🤔 Makes sense in a way
That's Funny!
😂😂🎉❤
The Bono effect.
I never knew Bono was a spitting image of Syd, incredible!
Roger seems like an easy man for 99.99% of people to be unable to stand.
I'VE SAID IT BEFORE AND I WILL SAY IT AGAIN DAVID GILMORE IS THE LIGHT OF PINK-FLOYD AND ROGER WATERS IS THE DARKNESS.
and we need both... As per comments, this page should not add to my knowledge of Floyd's psyche.
pffft....roger waters is pink floyd....when roger left the band started sounding like top 40 radio group
That's why on tours they play old Pink Floyd stuff that Roger wrote😂
can you say it again? it didn't stick... you need to tell a lie 1000 times for it to become true... 🤭
@@ortizroided7587 Correct!
I don't like U2 so if you want me to subscribe you better keep to subject on what your talking about if not good bye.
Same here 😂
U2 sucks....always did, always will
The man has a huge ego problem unfortunately.
I don´t think so. He´s telling the truth. He has his own opinion. He is a fighter for peace.
You are confusing big ego with integrity. He's one of very, very few in this world who sees a big picture and is so noble and daring to speak about it. He does it for humanity, not for himself! He's a hero from my poit of wiev. Never he hid his head in the sand like most of the rest of well known people.
@@valenteenaesintegrity and egotism go hand in hand, look up Erik Eriksson.
Even if he has a huge ego, it's not about music. And not politics either. So you should talk about some matters that really bother you as it seems, but not Roger's personality. Come on, speak up, what are your problems really?
@@stuartlast8156 Can't make music without an ego.
It's seems Waters is the problem. He is a hateful person, has a problem with all the others in the band. Just listen to interviews of David and Waters. Speaks volumes. Just an FYI there is no Pink Floyd without the voice and guitar of David Gilmour.
There has never been a Pink Floyd feud. What there has been is Roger Waters insulting and abusing David Gilmour for the past 40 years. That’s not the definition of a feud. It’s just obsession on Waters’s part.
@@c.7610 picture this, you are hard at work trying to create songs and an album, and somebody strumming a guitar is just sitting there making derogatory comments about those songs/sounds. That same person refuses to bring anything new to the table as they fear that their new stuff will be reworked to fit better. The same person being unhappy creating more music for the band and just wanting to tour for the girls and drugs. I give you Gilmour.
He is no saint in this, don't be fooled by weasel words.
@@doscwolny2221ok Roger 👍 👌
@@hiawatha6037 there are two sides to every coin.
You won't see anything if you keep your head in the sand.
@@doscwolny2221 Ok, so i won´t read your words again.
This is a snoozer. And what everyone else has said, the pictures are not accurate.
Bono is NOT Sid Barrett
Images don't correspond to narrative.
The narrative is shit
According to this, The Wall, Dark Side of the Moon, etc... would have been as great without Gilmour?? I think not.
have you ever been to a pink floyd concert with both waters and gilmour?
have you ever been to a pink floyd concert without roger waters
have you ever been to a roger waters concert without gilmour?
ich denke auf jeden fall
With all this technology, all they can come up with is a video with pictures and things that have nothing to do with the subject matter.
david gilmore doesnt think genocide is bad.
War sucks man, people die
I see Sid Vicious ❤
From the perspective of this video, you would think that Roger Waters was Pink Floyd. You Don't even mention the fact that David Gilmour's "A Momentary Lapse of Reason" outsold anything Waters did outside of the band. Pink Floyd's popularity isn't encapsulated solely on Waters lyrics. You don't mention the extreme talent that is David Gilmour and the rest of the band. David Gilmour is a legendary Guitarist. Probably the best song on the Wall "Comfortably Numb" was written by both Water's and Gilmour. This Video is basically a fluff piece for Water's.
Well if you had to do an exact pie on percentage of contributions and who did what and narrow it down to an exact percentage, Roger would be the hands down winner, noone doubts Gilmours importance in Floyd, but with out Roger there is no Darkside of the Moon , no Wish you were Here , no Animals and no The Wall. Now let's take those albums out of existence, lets look at what we have , we have Pink Floyd being a late 60s one hit wonder Syd Barret band and a non existence in Rock n Roll cause without the Darside Floyd doesn't have the best album of all time and on a grand scale noone knew Pink Floyd before Darkside and the other three huge ones after ,
noone gave a shit about PinkFloyd and guess who's brain they came out of .
Yep Roger Waters . Case closed.
@@micjoseph6250 Why does that not translate into his solo work. "A Momentary Lapse of Reason" outsold everything Waters did solo. Writing the lyrics of the majority of albums is not the be all end all of a band. Would you have me believe the real talent of Van Halen was in its various front men? How about Led Zeppelin. Pink Floyd didn't really take off until David Gilmour joined the band.
@stephenkennedy6358 im pretty sure you know the reason why M L O R did those numbers, now I do enjoy 3 or 4 songs on that album and I do enjoy David Gimour alot but the writing of those songs are weak and written by who? Not Dave or atleast many not Dave , Roger's albums such as Pros and Cons , Radio Kaios , Amused to Death are fantastic albums , you should listen to them and take in what's being written, it's deep.
@@micjoseph6250 I own both Pro's and Cons and Radio Kaos, I'm not trying to bash Water's. I love Pink Floyd, therefore I love Waters. Not just Waters, but Pink Floyd. I just get tired when some people believe that Waters is the Alpha and Omega, please. He wrote most of the Wall and all of the Final Cut but only because at that time he was no longer a team player he was a bully. Dark Side and Wish you were here was a group effort. Making a song isn't just about lyrics you still have to write the music. In 88 I saw Pink Floyd for the first time, did I wish that Waters was there sure, but if given a choice between seeing three members of the band or just Waters, I would still choose the three members.
Talk of perspective then compare a new record by "PINK FLOYD" a well established and worshiped band to a relatively unknown (who is Roger Waters unless you are already a Pink Floyd fan) and maybe you would have an answer. It could be argued that A Momentary Lapse of Reason without the Pink Floyd banner and without the Pink Floyd marketing would have disappeared into obscurity. Do not get me wrong I am a huge fan of Pink Floyd but will state for the record I was very upset when Roger left but soon realised that instead of one amazing band it gave two separate but equally talented entities both providing music for my soul. What I cannot stand are the so called fans who have to try and divide the talents and provide their expert opinions as to who is better than who. The only people who know the true facts are the ones who were present at the time. Other than that it is all hearsay and opinions which in general should be kept to yourself unless asked for.
Bono is not Syd Barrett..
Is Paul Billy Shears?
Who made this ? All the U2 videos WTF ?
Talk about Syd Barret and show Bono
Fire the guy who did the visuals.
His musical talents are mediocre at best. He knows how to play four chords on the acoustic guitar. His voice is horrendous. His lyrics many times unnecessarily rhyme. Without the other members of Pink Floyd this guy would be a nobody.
And without him, you would have 2 architects and a homeless druggie
Have you heard amused to death. Its a masterpiece with a top quality sound recording. Better than most of Floyd's recordings and Better content lyrically than many of Floyd's stuff without waters.
And he's a brilliant bass player...you ain't no floyd fan 😂
David Gilmour and Rick Wright and Mason made the music. Waters wrote words, mediocre bass player till Gilmour taught him how to play it! Waters is a little to full of himself, always has been!
lol.....give your head a shak...
@@ortizroided7587 Stay off the '..roids' darling, they're messing with your ability to write something sensible!
Water' s departure was a blessing for Pink Floyd. This Guy is difficult.
Definitely! I actually think you are being far to generous toward Waters, a vile little excuse of a man.
What makes you say that@@jo.s7993
Do you know what was a blessing for Pink Floyd? Roger Waters. That's why during The Division Bell Tour half the setlist was made up of songs written by him.
A couple of good songs Dave wrote without Roger. And that was it.
ha ha not a word about LPs created
Band is to create and play music, not to make feel good members
My Father suffered from Alzheimers for many years, which is why I find it easy to recognise the symptoms. There is no doubt in my mind, after observing Roger Waters interacting with interviewers and after listening to his painfully deficient monologues, that he is currently on the verge of advanced level Alzheimers! Which explains his rage attacks and depression, which are both classic symptoms and which Roger is blaming on Israels actions. Those who care about him should send him.asap to a specialist neurologist in this dementia disease!
There are so many inaccuracies here. FIrst, it was no "Barret's out and Gilmour's in". For several months, PF became a 5-piece band, woth both Barret and Gilmout on board, and they even recorded a single with that 5-piece band setup (I think it was "Apples and Oranges", but I am not totally sure).
According to RW, and later confirmed by Mason and Gilmour, the decision to remove Barret from the band was not made in a "meeting with his managers", but rather spontaneously by the band members. They were going to the rehearsal studios when someone (no one was identified) said samothing like "what if we don't go for Syd?". And that was it. By then, Barret was almost completely inoperative.
:) thank you for injecting some truth into this otherwise terrible poorly constructed video - zero effort went into this and if I created this I would or SHOULD be embarrassed
@@paulA-xq5fi 🙂👍
I don't think I have ever said this about someone's work on TH-cam but in this sad instance it has to be said. This is TERRIBLE, beyond terrible... Nuff said
When Roger Waters redid his “Spoken Version” of DSOTM, and made that “Let's get rid of all this 'we' crap” statement, this let us all know that his cheese had slid off his cracker. First, he got rid of Richard Wright during The Wall and then got rid of David Gilmour and Nick Mason when he did his spoken version of DSOTM. He finally got what he wanted by destroying an absolutely perfect piece of wonderfulness. It took all 4 of them to do what had been done with Meddle, DSOTM, WYWH, Animals, and parts of The Wall. And completely derailed the train with The Final Cut. I like Pro’s & Cons and Amused To Death. I like David Gilmour’s solo work as well. The first 2 solo albums are good. His 3rd, On An Island is almost perfect. At that time, David Gilmour is like a bottle of wine… it got better with age. In 1994, I saw Pink Floyd 14 times. 12 in the USA and twice in London. In 2006, I went to see David Gilmour in Chicago. Once in London and the third in Gdańsk. Having David Crosby and Graham Nash on the album and tour was a real stroke of genius. I saw Roger Waters The Wall live. Only once in Cleveland in 2010. As my wife were going in, someone approached us and handed us literature to support Palestine and anti Israel literature. When I told him that we were not interested. He started yelling at us and forced the paper work into my wife’s hand. A police officer was near by and saw what happened and arrested him. I noticed many others handing out this paperwork and asked the officer what was going on and he said that they were hired by the tour to distribute this stuff. This incident really left a bad taste in our mouths and affected our whole experience. We sold our future Roger Waters The Wall live tickets for Columbus and Philly. My favorite song of all time is Echoes. This song helped me as I was going through some really rough times when I was growing up. This album, Meddle, was the springboard they needed and helped launched them all. It was a collaboration that needed all 4 of them. But Roger Waters has lied to himself for so long, he actually believes that is was either all him or most of him and now wants all the credit and is now trying to rewrite history by lying to all of us. In 2008, my mom called me to tell me Richard Wright had passed away. Right then I knew I would never hear Echoes live again. I was blessed that I saw their last performance of Echoes in Gdańsk. I hope you all have a great day. Thank you.
Other echoes: I've seen PF live with and without Waters: The Wall in Germany (oustanding) and some years later in Rotterdam (disappointing). About the solo work: I have all albums of Gilmour and Waters. The stand out for me is Amused to death (especially on vinyl sounded much better than CD). And On an Island? I haven't played in years. Maybe like old wine another try?
Dark side was a single album not a double. PPICK !!!
It is Gilmour, not Gilmore !!
This video is the best example of how anyone who doesn't know anything about anything can spout nonsense. We should show it in schools so that children learn to recognise fake news.
I've never heard anyone say that Dave, Rick, or Nick were jerks are hard to deal with.
As for Roger.....All the time.
WATERS 👍👍
Waters for PRIME MINISTER
Pictures of Johnny Rotten and The Sex Pistols with Pink Floyd? Ironically, Rotten used to wear a t-shirt that said, "I hate Pink Floyd." lol
Although I love all of the photos of Syd Barrett, they don’t belong here. Same with the David Gilmour photos. I can’t imagine that Roger had any involvement with the photos chosen to accompany this music. They’re very incongruous with the lyrics.
Roger is Roger. He's NOT PF although he was the "leader" up thru THE FINAL CUT. What an appropriate name for the last album together. Pink Floyd did fine after Roger left. Roger has done fine on his own and so has Nick and David. Sorry Roger, we can't always have the things we want and have them go our way. All the guys have made good music so let bygones be bygones!! Pink Floyd has made awesome music......no matter what incarnation of the band it was.
Waters left Pink Floyd and tried to destroy it and stop letting other band members carrying it on. Roger you are a founder member and get credit as a great songwriter and receive royalties for this endeavour. But the courts ruled that you don’t own Pink Floyd. You wanted freedom away from Pink Floyd and you got your wish. Stop being such a muppet
unseen never to be seen by me again
What a way to end😎you should've brought it up to current days, with Waters massively successful tours of The Wall and Us+Them😎 just a little constructive criticism, you really ended quite abruptly 😎
GILMORE IS PINK FLOYD...THEY CAN DO WITHOUT WATERS BUT NOT WITH OUT DAVE!!
so ein blödsinn was du da von dir gibst
Pink Floyd didn't end, just waters stupidity
David was always a cut above in regards to coolness and Roger was a cut above with angst!
Gilmour “FILLED THE VOID” alright!!🙄
Introduced GREATNESS to Pink Floyd!!!!
I'm nowhere near as left wing as roger but like him I just want wars to stop. It's sad man. So sad.
Why does this begin with "Dark Side Of The Moon" and doesn't mention Pink Floyd's earlier work?
Pink Floyd post Waters is like Wings post Beatles, rubbish! As John Lennon said there is Paul making his granny music!
Does this video have a concept and what about the background -detective-soundtrack is it related with the pictures ?
Why the U2 footage?..waters can't stand Bono's falsehood.
When the band was together they were one of the best musical teams ever. So, so you think you can tell. Heaven from Hell, Blues skies from pain.
Roger was the brains and the musical genius of pink floyd and thanks to him he's still kicking ass ...Roger Rules O.K?
Finally, the other 0.01 %
Bless you sweetie! I do feel bad for you. Waters the musical "genius", who couldn't actually play bass, until Dave Gilmour taught him how too!
Thanks Roger 👍 😊 your my hero so you haters you can do one
da hast du völlig recht. roger ist nicht so ein schleimer wie gilmour. roger vertritt mutig seine meinung ohne wenn und aber und dafür gebührt ihm anerkennung. gilmour ist für mich lediglich eine marionette und ein schleimer der lediglich seinen "erfolg" vor augen hat. ohne roger wäre pink floyd nie so weit gekommen da er massgeblich dazu beigetragen hat zu dem erfolg.
The Bite was gone from PF when Roger left their subsequent albums were like wings without PMcA, and mostly unremarkable
I'm a huge Roger Waters fan but this is pure one sided Roger Waters propaganda!
Why is U2 here?
OK
Where does all the Sex Pistols pictures come into play with Waters childhood,?
No mention of David's solo albums? The first two were good, everything else after that is for old people
Thank you! ❤
Wow...Syd Barrett looks an awful lot like Bono!😉
Yeah in Lebanon with the band when he said….this is Jew food in disdain
David gilmour will allways be pinkfloyd!!!!
Me, Me, Me, Me. Who paid for this? HaHAHa
It's all pretty irrelevant and overrated in the long run, isn't it?
When the guy first mentions Syd Barrett a clip of Paul Hewson from Finglas East Dublin comes up. He says he comes from Ballymun which was an underclass projects type place. It's like the Queen saying shes a Cockney. This is Blasphemous to Roger Keith Barrett who was actually extremely creative. I saw the diminutive creep many times walking down Ballymun Avenue (Now Glasnevin Avenue because the people from Finglas East voting against the road to Ballymun being associated with them). I liked Actung Baby and one more 80's album. He's a singer with NO connection in anyway to Syd.
Strange video. Strange editing. Strange information about Pink Floyd.
"poor poor Roger" hide the master tapes from all the other members of the band, THEN cried like a baby
Very good insight into the mindset of an obsessive, egotistical, domineering autocrat.....with a little touch of anarchist thrown in to spice things up.
OK, so he was one of the two founding members of the band, so that gave him the right to be a domineering bully to the rest. Yeah, he wrote good lyrics, outstanding lyrics, but without the musical accompaniment to flesh it out its just a bunch of words written down. He took more and more control of the band relegating the other three to mere manekins for his accompaniment. Vocally and musically both David Gilmore and Richard Wright had more talent in their pinky fingers that Waters could ever hope for, talent just was below the others and I believe this knawed away and ate him up inside.
The breakup is his fault
Syd BONO Barrett
🤣🤣🤣
There's not a single thing here we don't already know!😴
This was mediocre at best. They also keep misspelling David GILMOUR wrong. Cmon guys
I stopped watching after the first five minutes... the images didn't coincide with commentary.
The pictures in this video are awesome but have nothing to do with what he's saying.
They are all wealthy and we are poor. So there....
Man, that is f'd up...sex pistols, bono (lower case intended), U2???
David Gilmour... "There was a band called Pink Floyd, there isn't anymore".
One thing about Roger he likes Wedding Cake.
U2????????
Still watching it. The pictures that nothing ro do with what he's saying is distracting. And IHATED everything about the words at the bottom. But the narration was good.
The visuals are totally inaccurate ... how can I believe the words.
Oh I'm shocked! 1. Did anyone else know there is a UK (Rock and Roll) Hall Of Fame? 2. Do we need it? It's irrelevant, the music speaks for itself, always has done in the UK.
I certainly remember the In the flesh tour @ Target Center in Minneapolis, Dark side of the Moon and The Wall @ The Xcel Energy Center in St. Paul MN. All 3 Phenominal! This was before he went off the Woke end.
Yeah, talking about Pink Floyd while showing images of The Sex Pistols at 1:30. What a piece of crap.
Roger would have been much better off keeping things going with Pink Floyd
Great song writer, yes, but he is nothing without the rest of Pink Floyd. He can't sing to save his soul and without David's guitar, everything he's done since just sucks. Just my personal opinion, of course 🤷♀️
Not only irrelevant photos that don't match the narrative, but it's not until the seventh minute in do the photos of Gilmour try to line up in the history. But U2 photos are inexcusable. Get with the program or bow out, please.
Absolutely adore Gilmour❤❤❤❤❤ nice personality
Momentary lapse isn't a patch on amused to death. They had help writing it aswell...even amused to death sounds much better in sound quality. And the pink floyd name gets more exposure in terms of advertising than waters.
Final Cut was awful
Big red flag my dad was a communist
Poor ol’ Roger
Very chaotic video with all these jumbled images. Now about Pink Floyd...it was the decision of Roger Waters to leave the band. Nobody forced him to leave. The rest are empty words...
Why do they always load these videos with the same damn bio for the first 3/4 of it. We don’t need to know how the band formed for the millionth time. Get to the point.
Penny Samson lyrics are awful
An interesting, but very odd film. Confusing footage at many points. Lack of footage, I guess.......but could've chosen better.
Bono wasn’t in Floyd 😂❤🎉
Think bono made this documentary
Why U2 ? 😂 Sex Pistols😂 Van Halen ? 😂😂😂 bye!
Sex Pistols inserted at 1:27
Roger...Is this you? I thought we talked about this. Who doesn't the world revolve around?