I cried just as much if not more to this episode as you Achara. I lost my mom far too soon so when they looked at the stars and saw their mother I just broke.
Wtf, you write this under every reaction, do you want attention or something or is it straight a lie??? (to bring something up here, you wrote this only under reactions with women, wtttfffff?
Very emotional episode and it's part of the core of SW that George started over 45 years ago but the technology wasn't there yet for him to tell the story he wanted to tell. I couldn't believe this episode was stop motion and I am so glad the technology has improved so much that story tellers all over the world can finally tell their stories.
While the first 2 episodes were thought provoking visual spectacles....this one was all heart! Add in the Claymation for the nostalgia and its was *chef's kiss*. Great reaction from you both.
In Disney+ when you select Visions one of the options is Extras. Their is a video for each season 2 episode that gives information about the animation studio and the inspiration for each episode. This episode is from a studio in Chile and is inspired by Spanish colonialism and the native people.
Damn these Europeans, they haven't left one good corner in the world. Australia,Americas, Asia, Africa. But I think Australia and north America were the worst cases.
@@kesardogra5529 well the other problem is the descendants of the colonists often don't see themselves as part of the European cultures they came from anymore. Especially in Africa, South America, and parts of the USA, this is sometimes because they were trying to get away from something in Europe or elsewhere. Some of the African peoples that were moved to the Americas can't go back to Africa because their original culture was destroyed by those that sold them to Europeans and colonies. The European Empires left their marks across the world and it can't really be undone in any neat and tidy fashion. I'm hoping people can find peaceful ways of resolving the problems caused, but many are already resorting to violence and have been for centuries.
Aparte también en la animación ponen temas de actualidad en Chile como la contaminación del agua por parte de empresas privadas o públicas o que el agua no es 100% pública
no, fue el propio gobierno de Chile que financio y aprobo el genocidio masivo de los selknam, ironicamente fueron judios quienes ejecutaron el genocidio pero todo aprobado y financiado por el gobierno de Chile. Cuidado con el tema del colonianismo espanol porque esto fue mucho despues de la independencia de Chile
@@freire_gtr igual ahí que recordar desde 1900 en chile así abajo los pueblos indígenas igual recibían discriminación, por parte de los milicos (si no me equivoco de lo que estás hablando de que el propio gobierno financio eso fue en un gobierno del milico Jorge Montt Álvarez y el gobernado de magallanes)
How exactly since they woke up and started talking. So some people over looked that because they wanted them dead in their ending interpretation to make the story even sadder? 🤔
@@kazehazeeeActually those other stars was the rest of their family. It was not just mom that got killed.. but we like to make things ten times more sadder than it is.
This short literary broke my heart. I fell in love with Tichina from the start. She was so brave & fearless & had so much faith. As sad as the ending was, it was equally beautiful & joyous.
good day i am from chile, studying my first year of digital animation and just yesterday i got invited to a conference by Chilemonos about the production of this short, it was heavily inspired by natives tribes from the south of Chile called the "kawésqar" or "alacalufes" and how they lost their lands and all their tribes by the colonizers, their cultures also had a culture centered around the stars, punkrobot also drew inspiration from many documentary about these tribes.
i also thought it was in stop motion the first time i saw the short, it is not, they intended to look like it was but it's purely made in CG, But that stone split in two was a real set made in real life with styrofoam, other props and scenery objets were also made in real life to then be scanned into frame
At the end….when the two stars appeared under the ‘mom’ star is symbolic off the sisters eventually dying. Think about it their entire village was killed and there was no way off planet. They most likely died on the planet of old age and their species is extinct after that.
Actually heard this short didn’t utilize stop-motion. Punkrobot studios used computer animated graphics that replicate a stop-motion style. Similar to what the Lego movies did
Ohhh I hadn't seen the short. I am from Chile and the story of this short film has to do with the extinction of the people of Chilean Patagonia. The Selk'nam. they had that particular style of putting on those horns and paints. And also the looting of water for sale to private industries... that is, the story has a part of the truth! Greetings from the south of the world
The only issue I have with this episode is that I feel the exposition at the start could've been done entirely through visuals, it didn't need the dialogue. Not one of my favourites, but definitely not a bad one either.
this ep was good, but i hate so much the trope of: kid wants to do something even if everyone tell them they shouldn't, does it, ruins everything, then the others have to fix it, and at the end the child is like "see!, i was right."
Then a week later, The Empire sends an Inquisitor, or Vader arrives. I’m sorry, I know I’m ruining it, but that’s probably what will happen, The Empire doesn’t give up.
The entire short film serves as a poignant euphemism for the plight of the native peoples in Chile, particularly in the face of exploitation by European, American, and Canadian corporations. These corporations ravage the delicate and isolated Chilean ecosystem, upon which these indigenous communities critically depend for their survival and cultural heritage, thits also true for the Average mixed and euro desendant chilean. The two sisters in the film symbolize the Selknam and partially the Tehuelche peoples, embodying their rich cultural legacy and profound connection to their land. The Selknam people, in particular, are on the brink of extinction, their numbers dwindling to near obliteration due to historical and ongoing pressures. Through the sisters' narrative, the film illustrates the cultural erasure and environmental destruction wrought by external forces. It highlights the fragile interplay between indigenous communities and their natural environment, showcasing the devastating impact of corporate intrusion on both. The sisters' struggles and resilience mirror the broader fight of the Selknam and Tehuelche against cultural genocide and ecological devastation, urging viewers to reflect on the urgent need for preservation and respect for indigenous rights and their ancestral lands.
If you're pissed that the previous vids didn't have much traction, I'm quite pissed that my comment on your previous vid hasn't been saved or something... TH-cam keeps doing this to me pretty regularly, recently, I have no idea what happened... So I just had to rewrite a crappier paraphrasing version of it, and be done with it... But to come back to the lack of popularity, I think it's more because of the lack of Interest Visions is pulling from the broad Star Wars fandom. Most of them are not interested in animation projects, and if the first volume could ride on the popularity of Japanese anime, this second volume is riding on the pure talent of worldwide animation studios... which has near zero audience (trust me, I'm an indie animation film director raised in Belgium, so I'm PAINFULLY aware that some of the most talented storytellers of all times are hiding in our ranks, completely overshadowed by Japanese anime and the Pixar/Dreamworks/Disney.Hollywood schools) ! Anyway, glad you got to discover this banger of a season ! Glad that for a limited time, some light can be shining onto worldwide animation studios through such a massive platform as Star Wars. It's still not big numbers by any means, but it's already MUCH MUCH larger than anything we could manage to attract just on our own, so we're grateful. And if big time reactors like you guys can actually see what indies worldwide animations are doing, and make you discover our previous works in retrospect, that fills us with (dare I say)... A new Hope !) There's a case for animation to be a natural fit for a universe such as Star Wars, as Visions vol.1 already showcased, and I'm really hoping that the success of this season will spearhead many more spinoff projects from it. It's kinda sad that the only truly great quality Star Wars content we're getting now (with the exception of Andor) are from studios outside of Lucasfilm, but hey, I guess that's specifically what makes them so good : they know they're on a MISSION ! I mean, Star Wars, dude ! They still remember it's a privilege, so they're all gonna bring their A-game to it ! Just these 3 opening episodes have been banger after banger ! (I mean, I was not surprised from Cartoon Saloon, it was one of my most anticipated of the season, but the other 2 were really fantastic surprises) I had no idea what studio Punkrobot is (I'm much more familiar with Aardman, Cartoon Saloon, Studio Mir and Studio La Cachette, 4 of the absolute best animation studios in the world of this current generation), but this episode reminded me of a Laika movie, like Kubo and the 2 strings. That was really impressive ! Very much looking forward to know what they're gonna come up with in the future ! Btw, if you weren't crying enough at the end of the episode, the 2 stars that light up besides their mother's is most likely their own, once they die somewhere in the future (since they're the only 2 souls left alive on the planet, so they couldn't reproduce, and eventually their whole tribe went extinct). Here, enjoy your afternoon ^^ !
Just to add mate punkrobot got to be more known after their short story got to win the Oscar for animation a few years back with the very emotional bear story and its analogy to the history of the coup de etat of 73
The Chilean studio did an incredible job 👏👏👏
FACTS 🗣🗣🗣
This season might as well be called Visions 2: Emotional Damage!
I cried just as much if not more to this episode as you Achara. I lost my mom far too soon so when they looked at the stars and saw their mother I just broke.
Wtf, you write this under every reaction, do you want attention or something or is it straight a lie??? (to bring something up here, you wrote this only under reactions with women, wtttfffff?
Wish you the best💕🙏🏻
Very emotional episode and it's part of the core of SW that George started over 45 years ago but the technology wasn't there yet for him to tell the story he wanted to tell. I couldn't believe this episode was stop motion and I am so glad the technology has improved so much that story tellers all over the world can finally tell their stories.
i cried too ❤great job with this one. can this be canon please, i need more of them 🥲
While the first 2 episodes were thought provoking visual spectacles....this one was all heart! Add in the Claymation for the nostalgia and its was *chef's kiss*. Great reaction from you both.
The Story + Animation Style = Awesome !!
That flute...right in the feels.
In Disney+ when you select Visions one of the options is Extras. Their is a video for each season 2 episode that gives information about the animation studio and the inspiration for each episode. This episode is from a studio in Chile and is inspired by Spanish colonialism and the native people.
Damn these Europeans, they haven't left one good corner in the world. Australia,Americas, Asia, Africa. But I think Australia and north America were the worst cases.
@@kesardogra5529 well the other problem is the descendants of the colonists often don't see themselves as part of the European cultures they came from anymore. Especially in Africa, South America, and parts of the USA, this is sometimes because they were trying to get away from something in Europe or elsewhere. Some of the African peoples that were moved to the Americas can't go back to Africa because their original culture was destroyed by those that sold them to Europeans and colonies. The European Empires left their marks across the world and it can't really be undone in any neat and tidy fashion. I'm hoping people can find peaceful ways of resolving the problems caused, but many are already resorting to violence and have been for centuries.
Aparte también en la animación ponen temas de actualidad en Chile como la contaminación del agua por parte de empresas privadas o públicas o que el agua no es 100% pública
no, fue el propio gobierno de Chile que financio y aprobo el genocidio masivo de los selknam, ironicamente fueron judios quienes ejecutaron el genocidio pero todo aprobado y financiado por el gobierno de Chile. Cuidado con el tema del colonianismo espanol porque esto fue mucho despues de la independencia de Chile
@@freire_gtr igual ahí que recordar desde 1900 en chile así abajo los pueblos indígenas igual recibían discriminación, por parte de los milicos (si no me equivoco de lo que estás hablando de que el propio gobierno financio eso fue en un gobierno del milico Jorge Montt Álvarez y el gobernado de magallanes)
People are saying that the girls actually died and became stars like the mother.
omg yeah, just noticed the two stars twinkling at the end 💔
Open for interpretation
It's likely an Inquisitor was sent to wipe them out.
How exactly since they woke up and started talking. So some people over looked that because they wanted them dead in their ending interpretation to make the story even sadder? 🤔
@@kazehazeeeActually those other stars was the rest of their family. It was not just mom that got killed.. but we like to make things ten times more sadder than it is.
This is the most 90s era Disney Star Wars episode.
Achara looks like Tichina Ithink... loved her tears.... i cried too. :)
So far, this episode is my favorite. Not bad for stop-motion.
This short literary broke my heart. I fell in love with Tichina from the start. She was so brave & fearless & had so much faith. As sad as the ending was, it was equally beautiful & joyous.
Viva Chile 🇨🇱🇨🇱
Poor achara dropped the tissues on the floor tears streaming down thw face .... 😢
this episode was amazing
you cried in this episode so i can only imagine whats your reaction will be in episode 8
yeah in ep 8 i didnt even expect that
Episode 8 GUTTED ME!
Tbh I had a much stronger with episode 6 (this episode not withstanding)
good day i am from chile, studying my first year of digital animation and just yesterday i got invited to a conference by Chilemonos about the production of this short, it was heavily inspired by natives tribes from the south of Chile called the "kawésqar" or "alacalufes" and how they lost their lands and all their tribes by the colonizers, their cultures also had a culture centered around the stars, punkrobot also drew inspiration from many documentary about these tribes.
I felt like the world’s biggest pansy crying over this episode and I feel so validated watching this reaction
The main characters are inspired from the indigenous people Selk'Nam from Chile.
i also thought it was in stop motion the first time i saw the short, it is not, they intended to look like it was but it's purely made in CG, But that stone split in two was a real set made in real life with styrofoam, other props and scenery objets were also made in real life to then be scanned into frame
the simplicity of the complex as hell animation...
I need Greg's take on the Halloween story😂
I was hoping to see the Death Star at the end when the clouds parted but there you go🤷♂️
thanks Achara for your sincere sensitivity
I ugly cried during that ending
I for one am glad you're doing these reactions!
At the end….when the two stars appeared under the ‘mom’ star is symbolic off the sisters eventually dying. Think about it their entire village was killed and there was no way off planet. They most likely died on the planet of old age and their species is extinct after that.
Are the sisters dead at the end? I ask this becaue the end scene shows two new stars net to their mother's?
Great Episode!! I was there with you two.
Actually heard this short didn’t utilize stop-motion. Punkrobot studios used computer animated graphics that replicate a stop-motion style. Similar to what the Lego movies did
I cried.
Have to fess, I think they both died: two stars appeared on either side of their mother star.
I'm pretty sure the Empire would've sent an Inquisitor, or Clone Commandos to deal with them eventually.
Ohhh I hadn't seen the short. I am from Chile and the story of this short film has to do with the extinction of the people of Chilean Patagonia. The Selk'nam. they had that particular style of putting on those horns and paints. And also the looting of water for sale to private industries... that is, the story has a part of the truth! Greetings from the south of the world
THANKS for this!!!!
Volume 2 really took me to a dark place it was a beautiful masterpiece but way too painful to watch again.
Great season
Viva chilee 😎❤
Can anyone tell me to feel same emotional, how much and what content i will have to watch from star wars. I haven't watched anything from star wars.
Cant quite understand you But watching starwars it's a long journey specially considering animated series like this one
are they sean paul jedi ?
The only issue I have with this episode is that I feel the exposition at the start could've been done entirely through visuals, it didn't need the dialogue. Not one of my favourites, but definitely not a bad one either.
Crying is the body's natural way of healing psychological trauma
u can see the influence of mapuche people on this also they join their mother so emotional short
this ep was good, but i hate so much the trope of: kid wants to do something even if everyone tell them they shouldn't, does it, ruins everything, then the others have to fix it, and at the end the child is like "see!, i was right."
Accurate representation of a child for you
@@tomasalarconchible9729 better yet acurrate representation of star wars
Then a week later, The Empire sends an Inquisitor, or Vader arrives. I’m sorry, I know I’m ruining it, but that’s probably what will happen, The Empire doesn’t give up.
love these
Hi, you two want to React the breakdown and easter eggs of GotG vol.3? New Rockstars.
Waiting for ur reaction on the bandits of golak...c'mon man speed up
I also quite liked that episode greetings from chile
The entire short film serves as a poignant euphemism for the plight of the native peoples in Chile, particularly in the face of exploitation by European, American, and Canadian corporations. These corporations ravage the delicate and isolated Chilean ecosystem, upon which these indigenous communities critically depend for their survival and cultural heritage, thits also true for the Average mixed and euro desendant chilean.
The two sisters in the film symbolize the Selknam and partially the Tehuelche peoples, embodying their rich cultural legacy and profound connection to their land. The Selknam people, in particular, are on the brink of extinction, their numbers dwindling to near obliteration due to historical and ongoing pressures.
Through the sisters' narrative, the film illustrates the cultural erasure and environmental destruction wrought by external forces. It highlights the fragile interplay between indigenous communities and their natural environment, showcasing the devastating impact of corporate intrusion on both. The sisters' struggles and resilience mirror the broader fight of the Selknam and Tehuelche against cultural genocide and ecological devastation, urging viewers to reflect on the urgent need for preservation and respect for indigenous rights and their ancestral lands.
If you're pissed that the previous vids didn't have much traction, I'm quite pissed that my comment on your previous vid hasn't been saved or something... TH-cam keeps doing this to me pretty regularly, recently, I have no idea what happened... So I just had to rewrite a crappier paraphrasing version of it, and be done with it...
But to come back to the lack of popularity, I think it's more because of the lack of Interest Visions is pulling from the broad Star Wars fandom. Most of them are not interested in animation projects, and if the first volume could ride on the popularity of Japanese anime, this second volume is riding on the pure talent of worldwide animation studios... which has near zero audience (trust me, I'm an indie animation film director raised in Belgium, so I'm PAINFULLY aware that some of the most talented storytellers of all times are hiding in our ranks, completely overshadowed by Japanese anime and the Pixar/Dreamworks/Disney.Hollywood schools) !
Anyway, glad you got to discover this banger of a season ! Glad that for a limited time, some light can be shining onto worldwide animation studios through such a massive platform as Star Wars. It's still not big numbers by any means, but it's already MUCH MUCH larger than anything we could manage to attract just on our own, so we're grateful.
And if big time reactors like you guys can actually see what indies worldwide animations are doing, and make you discover our previous works in retrospect, that fills us with (dare I say)... A new Hope !)
There's a case for animation to be a natural fit for a universe such as Star Wars, as Visions vol.1 already showcased, and I'm really hoping that the success of this season will spearhead many more spinoff projects from it. It's kinda sad that the only truly great quality Star Wars content we're getting now (with the exception of Andor) are from studios outside of Lucasfilm, but hey, I guess that's specifically what makes them so good : they know they're on a MISSION ! I mean, Star Wars, dude ! They still remember it's a privilege, so they're all gonna bring their A-game to it !
Just these 3 opening episodes have been banger after banger ! (I mean, I was not surprised from Cartoon Saloon, it was one of my most anticipated of the season, but the other 2 were really fantastic surprises)
I had no idea what studio Punkrobot is (I'm much more familiar with Aardman, Cartoon Saloon, Studio Mir and Studio La Cachette, 4 of the absolute best animation studios in the world of this current generation), but this episode reminded me of a Laika movie, like Kubo and the 2 strings. That was really impressive ! Very much looking forward to know what they're gonna come up with in the future !
Btw, if you weren't crying enough at the end of the episode, the 2 stars that light up besides their mother's is most likely their own, once they die somewhere in the future (since they're the only 2 souls left alive on the planet, so they couldn't reproduce, and eventually their whole tribe went extinct).
Here, enjoy your afternoon ^^ !
Just to add mate punkrobot got to be more known after their short story got to win the Oscar for animation a few years back with the very emotional bear story and its analogy to the history of the coup de etat of 73
This story is real 😢 and the episode has a good ending.
But the real story is not a good ending😶🌫️...
The emotional gut punches were too much to handle......,
Might be my least favorite episode of the series
Тупее реакции не придумаешь 🤦🏼♂️
?