I've been playing golf for over 25 years this is the best explanation that I have seen on TH-cam or by any instructor explaining the left arm. I have fought for this issue for years and years and I appreciate the time and effort you put into the full explanation of this in your video. it is greatly appreciated by this old hack golfer!
I've been playing golf for ten years. About six years ago I was out at the range. The guy on the next tee had a swing right out of the picture books. We got to chatting and he told me he had played in college and now worked for a big company where his job was to take people out golfing. He very politely asked me if he could make a suggestion. "Sure," I said, "suggest away." He said that I should try to keep my left arm straight on the backswing. Okay. I put a ball down, set up and took the club back with a straight left arm. The ball shot from my clubhead on a high, rising arc straight down the middle. It had only taken me one swing to prove the efficacy of his tip. Of course, I still had a lot to learn, but that was, without question, the best tip I've ever gotten.
Hi Everything explained is correct IMHO. The three main things to take note off is: 1: the distance the lead shoulder travels (approx 6 inches) v the left wrist to IMPACT (approx 6 feet). So logics is that the left wrist must accelerate faster that the lead shoulder to both get to impact as explained. 2: the shoulders MUST stay CLOSED and QUIET until the lead arm is approx 45 deg down. DO not fire the upper body first. 3: The longer you hold off on the shot (EXCESSIVE FORCED LAG) will cause big problems. I think it’s time to go play.
This is a very interesting detail about the left arm, it's a funny feeling to try and separate the two ways of rotating the arm. My mind wants to rotate the arm when I try to just rotate the wrist. Thanks for sharing another great video.
Still the best full swing instruction on the platform. This part of the game is "solved" by Chuck imo. If only he knew the secrets of putting (like me😉) and could put up a similar quality of putting instruction to solve that too? Putting well is so easy once you realise it's a totally an instinct/feel thing and NOT an athletic/analytic thing. Your Grandma can put well with almost no athletic prowess. A mind empty of technical thinking is a must. You don't toss a piece of screwed up paper successfully into a waste bin by using a reductionist approach. Just a thought to put here at "the oracle" of golf instruction....
Hey Chuck….in this video you comment that you pull the left arm down. But in all (at least all I’ve seen), you say there is now conscious movement of the arms….they are moved but the weight shift, left hip rotation, and the post up. Can you please clarify. Thanks.
Just to be clear, rotation by the wrist itself is minimal (a few degrees only). The two types of rotation are at the elbow or the shoulder, right? So, the way I understand it is that we want to keep shoulder rotation at a minimum and control the clubface at the elbow.
I agree a bit long winded but he does do a good job of explaining things it would help if he could give some other drills that could be done at the range
Roxy sounds like a hack yes your left arm should always be straight it has nothing to do with hitting up on the driver for every shot keep the left arm straight on the way back it’s called consistency
kathleen smith you’ve clearly not given many lessons to high handicaps! I asked a student to throw a ball down at the ball sitting on the ground and he hit himself in the foot. Just because it’s natural for u don’t assume it’s natural for everyone! After 10k in person lessons I never assume anything is “natural” for anyone!
If your trying to lift the ball up (like Tiger's pic) then get the left shoulder up, but bad. Left should needs to be level to take a divot. Watch more than Tiger's swing. Especially on par threes. Tigers pic should have the driver in hand perhaps.
The issues you speak of Moe Norman eliminated . Everything stays in front of your chest and hip line ! Not easy to learn but you will never go back to the rotary swing once you understand the concept !!
So - you rotate the entire left arm going back …. But only rotate the wrists on the way down ? Why not just rotate the club with wrists going back? What’s the point of rotating the entire arm on the backswing if you don’t “use” it in the downswing?
@@Rotaryswing Hmmm. I think I have a misunderstanding of what swing plane is. I’ve been equating shaft plane with swing plane. So I may be have been thinking I’m on the proper swing plane - when in actuality I’m swing too steeply. Thanks for the response.
@@sandylake304 because golf is not a 1 handed game. You can make a case for any swing theory and seemingly prove it with just 1 hand on the club. In this case he's demonstration left hand and arm rotation holding the club in his left hand. But as soon as the right hand is applied, and the swing speed is multiplied exponentially, left hand and left arm rotation changes dramatically. That part was "total nonsense". Sorry but Ican't comment on the entire video.
enlightened It’s helpful to me because previously opened the face strictly by rotating my wrist. I was not even aware of the importance of rotating the arm as well. It is now much easier for me to get in a better position at the top and letting me make a better transition to the downswing. Very helpful to me, and I’ve been playing for nearly 60 years!
I've been playing golf for over 25 years this is the best explanation that I have seen on TH-cam or by any instructor explaining the left arm. I have fought for this issue for years and years and I appreciate the time and effort you put into the full explanation of this in your video. it is greatly appreciated by this old hack golfer!
Definitely one of the best golf video's I've seen...….BEEN PLAYING THIS GAME FOR 45 YEARS … So glad I found you!!!!! Well done!!!
Wow, thanks!
Fabulous explanation! Clear and descriptive - Thank you!
I've been playing golf for ten years. About six years ago I was out at the range. The guy on the next tee had a swing right out of the picture books. We got to chatting and he told me he had played in college and now worked for a big company where his job was to take people out golfing. He very politely asked me if he could make a suggestion. "Sure," I said, "suggest away." He said that I should try to keep my left arm straight on the backswing. Okay. I put a ball down, set up and took the club back with a straight left arm. The ball shot from my clubhead on a high, rising arc straight down the middle. It had only taken me one swing to prove the efficacy of his tip. Of course, I still had a lot to learn, but that was, without question, the best tip I've ever gotten.
Some of the most clear and concise teaching I've seen and heard.
These are the best lessons I have ever seen.
awesome teacher!!!
Thank you! 😃
Very informative for a golfer who does not hit with a flat left wrist. Thank you.
Hi
Everything explained is correct IMHO.
The three main things to take note off is:
1: the distance the lead shoulder travels (approx 6 inches) v the left wrist to IMPACT (approx 6 feet). So logics is that the left wrist must accelerate faster that the lead shoulder to both get to impact as explained.
2: the shoulders MUST stay CLOSED and QUIET until the lead arm is approx 45 deg down. DO not fire the upper body first.
3: The longer you hold off on the shot (EXCESSIVE FORCED LAG) will cause big problems.
I think it’s time to go play.
Thanks. First time viewer. This is some seriously good stuff!
Glad you enjoyed it!
This is a very interesting detail about the left arm, it's a funny feeling to try and separate the two ways of rotating the arm. My mind wants to rotate the arm when I try to just rotate the wrist.
Thanks for sharing another great video.
I'M OF
How
Charles Baughan
great instruction!!!!....thank you!!
First half is slow, but second half makes the wait all worth the time---very nice---Thanks
great stuff ... much admiration for your knowledge of the golf swing ..thanks for posting
Great
Still the best full swing instruction on the platform. This part of the game is "solved" by Chuck imo. If only he knew the secrets of putting (like me😉) and could put up a similar quality of putting instruction to solve that too? Putting well is so easy once you realise it's a totally an instinct/feel thing and NOT an athletic/analytic thing. Your Grandma can put well with almost no athletic prowess.
A mind empty of technical thinking is a must. You don't toss a piece of screwed up paper successfully into a waste bin by using a reductionist approach. Just a thought to put here at "the oracle" of golf instruction....
Hey Chuck….in this video you comment that you pull the left arm down. But in all (at least all I’ve seen), you say there is now conscious movement of the arms….they are moved but the weight shift, left hip rotation, and the post up.
Can you please clarify. Thanks.
Excellent Information. I truly believe
Just to be clear, rotation by the wrist itself is minimal (a few degrees only). The two types of rotation are at the elbow or the shoulder, right? So, the way I understand it is that we want to keep shoulder rotation at a minimum and control the clubface at the elbow.
Thanks for the information I will check it out
Thank you very much ,this information could get me into single figures.
I agree a bit long winded but he does do a good job of explaining things it would help if he could give some other drills that could be done at the range
Steven Diraimo there are dozens on the website rotaryswing.com
A good way to feel what he is saying( current tiger move) get those hands in front of your body on the way down
Woods is tilted behind you at 15:00 mark. As you are covering the topic of tilting.
Nova Time he’s always there
great explanations
Awesome video!!!!
Thanks Cody!
great video
Thanks a lot
You're welcome! Please check out my latest video on Tour Pro Consistency Secrets th-cam.com/video/Bl9DSthiUiM/w-d-xo.html
The only issue I have is the straight left arm seems to limit my mobility I use to do this but now I am post back injury
does this apply to the driver too.
you are supposed to hit up, so it cant be.
Roxy sounds like a hack yes your left arm should always be straight it has nothing to do with hitting up on the driver for every shot keep the left arm straight on the way back it’s called consistency
Roxy is a wrist flippy hack and I’m a scratch with a bad back ignore him
It is a natural feeling -- dont over think it, it is like throwing a ball --- when u throw a ball you don't thing technical.
kathleen smith you’ve clearly not given many lessons to high handicaps! I asked a student to throw a ball down at the ball sitting on the ground and he hit himself in the foot. Just because it’s natural for u don’t assume it’s natural for everyone! After 10k in person lessons I never assume anything is “natural” for anyone!
You can clearly see Tigers left shoulder is moving up at impact.
yep.
Mike Bailey , p ,
B
If your trying to lift the ball up (like Tiger's pic) then get the left shoulder up, but bad. Left should needs to be level to take a divot. Watch more than Tiger's swing. Especially on par threes. Tigers pic should have the driver in hand perhaps.
body squares the club
The issues you speak of Moe Norman eliminated . Everything stays in front of your chest and hip line ! Not easy to learn but you will never go back to the rotary swing once you understand the concept !!
Thank you Ben Affleck!
K
Everything was good until he started talking about releasing the arms early at 10:15.
Lmao "thousands of degrees of rotation".
Data doesn’t lie
Who actually impacts in the position in which they address the ball?....besides me.
So - you rotate the entire left arm going back …. But only rotate the wrists on the way down ?
Why not just rotate the club with wrists going back? What’s the point of rotating the entire arm on the backswing if you don’t “use” it in the downswing?
Because the swing plane would be too upright
@@Rotaryswing Hmmm. I think I have a misunderstanding of what swing plane is. I’ve been equating shaft plane with swing plane. So I may be have been thinking I’m on the proper swing plane - when in actuality I’m swing too steeply. Thanks for the response.
total nonsense
enlightened why? What do you recommend?
@@sandylake304 because golf is not a 1 handed game. You can make a case for any swing theory and seemingly prove it with just 1 hand on the club.
In this case he's demonstration left hand and arm rotation holding the club in his left hand. But as soon as the right hand is applied, and the swing speed is multiplied exponentially, left hand and left arm rotation changes dramatically. That part was "total nonsense". Sorry but Ican't comment on the entire video.
enlightened It’s helpful to me because previously opened the face strictly by rotating my wrist. I was not even aware of the importance of rotating the arm as well. It is now much easier for me to get in a better position at the top and letting me make a better transition to the downswing. Very helpful to me, and I’ve been playing for nearly 60 years!
Yes I agree about rotation on the backswing not getting in the correct position to deliver the clubhead.