Bruckner Symphony No 7 Celibidache Münchner Philharmoniker Live Tokyo 18 Oct 1990
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 เม.ย. 2013
- Anton Bruckner - Symphony No. 7 in E Major
Münchner Philharmoniker conducted by Sergiu Celibidache
Live Suntory Hall, Tokyo 18 October 1990
1. Allegro moderato
2. Adagio. Sehr feierlich und sehr langsam
3. Scherzo. Sehr schnell - Trio. Etwas langsamer
4. Finale. Bewegt, doch nicht schnell - เพลง
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W1D5 | Summer | เก็บคะแนนสู่รอบไฟนอล สัปดาห์แรก](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jSlV6eB1f9k/mqdefault.jpg)
I listened to this performance of Bruckner's Symphony No. 7 by Sergiu Celibidache and the Munich Philharmonic on that very day at Suntory Hall. It ’s a good memory of life...☺
how I envy you!
I am curious… do Japanese have a particular affinity for Bruckner?
You called this a "Peasant Orchestra" Mr Karajan.....Look what they are doing now under Celibidache...
The Karajan Celibidache rivalry was in part an intra-Vlach issue. HvK was 1/4 Vlach.
@@ilirllukaci5345Celibidache had rivalry, not Karajan
@@nicolapascoli4580 As Generalmusikdirektor of Europe, Karajan had a rivalry with everyone, e.g. Günter Wand. I suspect it was personal with Celibidache, who was referred to as "that filthy Romanian" upon consideration as a successor to Furtwängler in Berlin. Obviously Furtwängler hated Karajan. And Karajan was not Greek nor Serbian but a quarter Aromanian himself. And Karajan specifically preferred voices like Cebotari (another Romanian/Moldovan) and Lubin and Dernesch and Janowitz, saying that he wanted Wagner(?) playing removed from the (Munich?) "beer gardens".
What don't you get? Oh, and btw. Karajan lost his beloved BPO over his failed attempt to hire Sabina Meyer, a genius clarinetist and artist who happened to be female. Conversely Celibidache notoriously was quoted as saying that an orchestra with a female (brass) player sounds like a Woman's Orchestra. I say this despite being a lifelong chauvinist myself.
And some of Hvk's best recordings with Walter Legge were with Dinu Lipati, whose playing he adored.
Thud I’d. Duoetuorcti geeking uh ecertcsextion edcrotvcontrevsss
Die Bruckner Symphonien, gespielt von den Münchnern mit Celi...immer wieder wenn ich darauf stoße kann ich nur sagen: Unübertroffen. Soo viele phantastische Wiedergeben gibt es, zum Beispiel mein vergötterter Claudio Abbado mit den fantastischen Luzern Festival Strings, und immer wieder komme ich auf den Tyrannen Celi mit den Münchnern zurück.
Erdenweit allen göttliche Musik spielenden Menschen sage ich Dank, Herzensdank. Ihr tut Gutes, Ihr tut sehr sehr Gutes.
The ending of the 1st movement is not of this world. Absolutely divine.
I've always thought so. to me it's a view of the Alps opening up in the clouds. And no one has to be seeing it. Except for God who created it all.
@@johnlorenzen4633 Well said friend.
1. Allegro moderato - 1:10
2. Adagio. Sehr feierlich und sehr langsam - 25:57
3. Scherzo. Sehr schnell - Trio. Etwas langsamer - 53:46
4. Finale. Bewegt, doch nicht schnell - 1:05:53
Gustavo Sousaj
Thank you for expending the effort to provide those exact timings...
If i may make a comment: it seems, if i understand their "harrrumphs" correctly, that many commentators have criticized the Finale of this symphony as being somewhat out of character with the rest of the work. Celi and the band show that with judicious choices of tempi, this need not be the case at all---- conductor and and orchestra merely need the courage of their convictions to play the slower material as slowly as necessary to make the appropriate contrast with the rather jaunty initial thematic material. To incorporate some of the perceptive commentary of analyst Robert Simpson, it is more vital to uncover the natural tensions inherit in the music, rather than inflaming them say in the manner of a Tschaikovsky symphony finale. It seems it takes the wisdom of a veteran like Celi to boldly do this, and the corporate genius of a fine ensemble like the MPO to trust in the conductor's instinct in that regard. In simpler terms, Celi and his gang show that Bruckner knew what he was doing, and the aural result shows that it does indeed work. Well done, all around, and the Suntory audience, appreciative almost to a fault by nature in any case, show that they heartily approve (as do i, and obviously many others who have posted their sincere appreciation above / below).
Thx! Why is this so low
A very distinct possibility that the Munich Philharmonic, while under the baton of Sergiu Celibidache, became the
finest orchestra in the world.
Especially as in Bruckner's music he set the gold standard of interpretation.
Especially as in Bruckner's music he set the gold standard of interpretation.
La musique d'Anton Bruckner, toutes ses symphonies, touchent les fibres de mon être avec une douloureuse mélancolie et tristesse. Toutes ces idées musicales blessent et au même temps caressent mon âme avec le chagrin de contempler un soleil automnal se couchant derrière un chemin entouré d'arbres déjà éffeuillés, lointain, très lointain. La magie du talent du Maestro Celibidache et tous les musiciens sous son bâton font ce rêve une réalité. Bravo Maestro Bruckner et Maestro Celibidache !
Les violons d'automne blessent mon coeur d'un langueur . . . Verlaine
My favourite conductor playing my favourite symphony! HEAVENLY.....
...when he is smiling like that, he is delighted with the way the Orchestra is realising his vision! He is having a Religious Experience!...ME TOO!
Mahler and Bernstein my favorites.
Mick Dunn first time see him
We 💓 you Sergiu, oh yes we do-oo...
We 💓 you Sergiu, oh yes
we do-oo
Since you're not wi-ith us,
we're 👥 blue,
Oh maestro,
we
💗💗💗
you
@@medievalmusiclover I'm mad about Mahler 4. The rest not so much and only parts of.
Listening to the sublime Bruckner under the baton of the sublime Celibidache, I'm sitting out in the garden at dusk in autumn watching the flocks of cockatoos pass by and ah! My heart is stolen away...
The music played in this tempo reveals the true musicality of the symphony. Conductors know that if they adopt this tempo, those mistakes are revealed. So-called great conductors hide those imperfections with an accelerated tempo, thinking that the audience won't notice. Celibidache through this LARGO tempo showed everyone that he is the most refined listener and creator of truth
You are so right!
best comment ever
Wow... the end of the first movement... much slower than I'm used to, but... just wow... rich and so much power. Tears of joy.
Playing this again for the umpteenth time! I will NEVER tire of it! Love watching Celibedache at work and hearing this orchestra performing the Bruckner Symphonies! Heavenly!
Me too and I so heartily agree.
Every 10th comment is by you i am so very happy that you enjoy this work so much! :D
Local Finnish born Violinist, Satu Vanska, who played under him with the Munich 'City Band' claimed that they could still play all the Bruchner Symphonies without the music in front of them now!
I respect and admire your dedication for the true master of Bruckner's Symphonies!
Greatest interpretation of Bruckner 7th and it just does not get better than this...Celi one of a kind ( the like of which we will never see again )
Anton, if only you could see this! Those who didn't love you are dead and forgotten but you are alive and eternal in our hearts.
In some moments I believe, that with the passing of Celibidache a part of me died too. You will understand me recognizing: it is hardly to tolerate in a philharmonic concert listening to operas like this realized in a very different way. I myself was allowed to listen to Celi & MPO with 7th of Anton Bruckner in autumn 1989 in the Philharmonic hall of Berlin. Unforgettable.....
wow..
I can certainly relate to your feelings, some loss is irreplaceable.
Celibidache is really enjoying this event! He IS a hard man to please...but he obviously loves the music and the composer! He is loving this performance immensely...(orchestra too!) > A comment from a violinist who was there..."The orchestra doesn't need the music in front of them anymore! They are so well schooled by the conductor they can perform the whole thing without it!")
It makes me sad that I can no longer experience Bruckner performances like this. Everyone is doing Bruckner nowadays, but none are truly exceptional. Symphonies like these demand a superlative understanding, one that only the conductors of the past had. I can only experience this performance through a pair of headphones... Maybe rather than investing in concert tickets, I need to invest in a good pair of headphones! Still, Maestro Celi can make me cry on that climax - without fail - even through my cheap headset.
But we have Herbert Blomstedt, he can conduct Bruckner…
well, I could tell you someone who truly understands this music and tries to bring out the soul of Bruckner..
I've been round most of the other Bruckner's with Celi and Paavo and the rest, but I am drawn inexorably back to this. Since it's beyond words, I'll use no more.
It's above and beyond Elegance he's amazing everything he's brought to us has been a gift from God.
seeing this man conduct allows to understand what a conductor is for
Extraordinarily true
masterly! at 25:01 you can distinctly hear him yell :)
These japanese audiences are much quieter than us.
And again at 25:31!
Yes, Bose headphones and Bruckner. That is all I need this Sunday afternoon !!!
Maestro Celibidache is a master Brucknerian conductor. If our ears could taste, he manages to squeeze out every precious drop of nectar of this magnificent symphony for our ears to savor thereby nourishing our very soul so completely that we are transported to a place of sheer sublimity and then we are able to experience the divine. Thank you so much for posting. After listening to such an intense and passionate interpretation I really don't want to come back to earth.
Couldn't have said it better myself!
🌷
You prolly dont give a shit but does any of you know a method to log back into an Instagram account..?
I was stupid lost the login password. I appreciate any help you can give me
@Hugh Ace Instablaster =)
@Mathew Frank i really appreciate your reply. I found the site on google and Im trying it out now.
Looks like it's gonna take quite some time so I will get back to you later with my results.
Celibidache, such a truly charismatic conductor. Nowadays, it is so difficult to find conductors who have the courage to go against the comfortable zone and against what it is considered "the right way". I cannot find a better interpretation of this wonderful symphony, particularly as regards the first movement.
Listening to Bruckner is getting closer to the realm of God .
Bruckner is always in my mind .
From Tokyo of theLand of the Rising Sun .
What a very odd comment. Perhaps induced by lockdown and self isolation.
He was a mystic that adored God using his ability for creating music, great, celestial music. From Chile, on the occidental border of South America, where sun rises from behind the mountains and dies sinking in the sea.
no question this is the finest bruckner 7 on record!
ABSOLUTELY!!!
Fully agree! Celibidache "knows" Bruckner, like no one else
You can say that million times!!!!
yep!!!
I completely agree !!
Ich habe mich langsam
an Bruckners Symphonie n her ran gewagt aber
jetzt bin ❤️🔥
No other conductor can get tempos like Celibidache, every interpretation is a masterpiece of conducting, in this case especially is almost so important like the composer work.
I love Brucker because of its solen and delicate melody. It sounds describing something noble and glorious ideal. And Celibidache's clarification is the best among the masters.
...must be the 20th time I have played this video...sounds better every time!
I've been following you for many years now, impressed by your unflinching love of Celi's artful mastery.
incredible! wonderful! the greatest conductor ever!!
I don't know if Bruckner would approve such a slow tempo but, as far as I'm concerned, this is the real Bruckner. This man was born to conduct Bruckner music. Other composers's I'm not so sure.
Great conductors and performers of genius like Celibidache can bring even more depth and meaning to music of which their very own composers were not aware when the piece was written. Case in point: Rachmaninoff said that Horowitz plays his music better than Rachmaninoff himself. Celibidache takes Bruckner into a space unknown even to Bruckner himself. Once a composer releases a piece of music it is no longer his!
I personally miss here insanity in the 3rd movement - feeling u r on the edge , smth. you feel listening to Mahler. I also think 4th could've been more impetous ( after all it's very Wagner-like music), here it's too "gentle" .And in general -not enough contrast between divinity of first two and insanity of last two movements.
Celi's slow tempi work very well with most Bruckner material as it surely does here, but there are a few exceptions.
@@robert72744 With your last statement I totally agree. But Celibidache, always trying to be as close as possible to what he thought to be the composers intention, didn't think that way, and how much the "spaces" or "depths" of Bruckner and Celibidache converged you can't possibly know. Rachmaninoffs statement, I think, rather referred to the fact that only perfect mastery of the instrument (although Rachmaninoff himself was a virtuoso) opens up all possibilities of interpretation. And as far as I know, it was Horowitz who told this story.
I think Anton Bruckner would agree Celibidache, he was always willing to modify his scores. A slower tempo it's just a minor change and contributes to get a better work.
So magnificent is the end of the first movement, that iif the Symphony had ended there, I wouldn't have felt cheated. I have never heard Bruckner played like this before.
The true test of artistic genius comes with repeated exposure - and thanks to these great postings on TH-cam - we are able to savor the brilliance of Sergiu Celibidache's Bruckner interpretations as often as we like! With every listening (and watching) I find myself savoring every single nuance of this gorgeous musical experience. Over time, I have become hopelessly addicted these Celibidache Bruckner performances - like no other I have ever heard. For those who think Celi moves forward too slowly - you need to take the time to truly absorb the unfolding supreme beauty that literally makes time "stand still"!
Such an appropriate comment as I listen 12 hours from the Winter Solstice. True understanding!!!
@@johnvaughan7096 Your comment brought me back to this special performance in Japan during the last years of Celibidache's life. Perfect for this time of greater isolation. Thank you and happy holidays!
Once you sink into his slow tempi it's really quite wonderful.
Words fail me! I just LOVE this man's work!...He knows Bruckner very well too!
I am sure he would have loved to meet you, you would be fully deserving!
감사! 감사! 감사! & 감동! 감동! 감동~~~
Thanks! Thanks! Thanks!!!!!
O, the pleasure of the underexposed listener, whose untutored musical mind finds wonder in each new discovery! As first setting eyes on a Passion Flower, or a regal Indian peacock to a newly arrived explorer. What celestial pleasure, this Bruckner. Thank you.
you nuts
I'm gonna puke now
THESE NUTS
Amazing phrasing and textures. I thought I'd heard the best with Barenboim, but this is wondrous. Something interesting and arresting happens in every measure.
That was the best Times of MPO
Spectacular! Thank you Bruckner!
E' una gioia ascoltare questa sinfonia e questi esecutori. E questo direttore!
30:10 PASSION! PASSION! 38:05 Violas and chelos sublime! sublime!
It does not get better than that!
Thank you for this treat !
Delighted at the excellent people I have met in here! There's certainly something wonderful about Celibedache directing Bruckner....with such a highly talented Orchestra!
Remarkable performance by a stunning conductor: fascinating to watch Celibidache's facial expressions. He has an eye on each and every musician and he follows the score (by heart) with luscious pleasure and insight. His command of the music is unique, drawing the listener with a soft hand towards another universe. Bravo Maestro.
My favorite passage starts about 44:29 to 48:00. Never fails to raise goosebumps...
me too...
As a kind of "booster", I also listen carefully to a piano transcription of this passage by Fumiko Shiraga.
It has an amplification effect on the subsequent re-listening of the symphonic version.
th-cam.com/video/g_iWk19i9Zo/w-d-xo.html
It is also my favorite passage!! I love Bruckner. Just 1 year ago I started listening to him and getting to know him. The Celibidache versions for now are the ones I like the most. Greetings from Argentina and thank you for sharing that passage from the symphony!
As verdadeiras músicas Clássicas que nos enlevam . Anton Bruckner , compositor Austriaco , sendo seu compositor favorito o Alemão , grande Richard Wagner da linda música ( Cavalgada das Walkirias ) e me encantei com a calmaria de suas músicas que adentram nossa Alma , plantando Paz em nosso " Eu Interior " . Gratidão a Filarmonica Munchiner , Condutor Celibidache , e ao 1 Furtwangler pela postagem . Paz e Luz , Esperanças e Fé no Criador Nosso . São Paulo , 17-01-2021 - Pátria Amada Brasil !!!
Huge respect to the conductor he is The Godfather of conducting
YES! YES! YES! God's Conductor playing the music of God's Composer!
love those woodwinds... like a chorus of birds in the early hours of the morning.
CELIBIDACHE E SUPERB ,ca întotdeauna, un geniu,un virtuoz!!O minune de OM!
Never pass up an opportunity to listen to Celibidache's recordings. They're all quite special.
Bruckner must have known Celibidache would come along; just made for each other!
If he did, it makes you wonder why he marked two of the movements to be played fast.
@@ardentspy Knew Celli would improve on that.
Celibidache must be a rebirth of Bruchner. He conducted his most splended melody with heavenly tempo.
Grazie per averci regalato momenti di sublime, Maestro
MAESTRO!!!!! dear Master!!!!!!
Warm fully tears of
great joy!!!
Bravo maestro..you created a little heaven....
If this does not move you, nothing will.
Mahler symphony no. 3 will move you
Sometimes, I wake up during the night and I have this music in my head
@@ohraider no bruckner symphony without a guy comparing it to mahler..
this symphony's Third movement is as bold and direct as the composer has even written- Bravo !!
Une 7ème flamboyante magistralement interprétée par des musiciens qui ''collent'' à un chef sans égal pour diriger Bruckner ! Fabuleux !
he is and was the greatest conductor ever.
ABSOLUTELY ALEC!!!
The God of Music conducts the Music of God! - And now he conducts the Angels in Heaven!
Da, a fost si este marele dirijor si filozof al muzicii! Suntem mandri ca a fost roman!
NO DOUBT AT ALL alec!
apart from the shouting
@@mickdunn8423 ...and shouts at them, düüüü! düüüü! düü!!!
Sergiu Celibidache is no longer with us but he has left us memories to cherish. That was the humility and greatness of this remarkable Maestro! Anyway this is a wonderful presentation to honour the master Bruckner!!
12:20 Viola!!!
LOL true that!
viola~! vioooola!!
Poor violists! My heart always goes out to them. :)
Zwaiteeeeeeee.
Zwaiteeeeeeee.
Let's not forget the brilliant production team! WELL DONE!!
watch him conduct. pretend you're in the orchestra. use your headphones, let the music flow. WARNING: Bruckner is addictive.
Totally agree. One thing to be cautious about though is the sharp dynamic changes. If you have your volume all the way up for a pianissimo passage, beware the sudden onset of fortissimo!
Very addictive
@@BrucknerMotet That's why I suggest headphones (the best way to listen to symphonic music): don't tamper with the volume. You should just hear the pianissimo, and the fortissimi will not break your eardrums (or heart).
Jiva Das very good advice! As the classical music is always performed in big concert halls, churches..etc, there is a lot of colorful reverb that gets mixed with the room/reverb of your own environment..or it just doesn’t translate it’s grandiosity; And 2) this is a pleasure that you can rarely share with someone..So headphones are the right solution😅🙏🏼.. my two pennies
No words can express how lucky we are to be able to enjoy the divine encounter of these two men. Sublime.
47:54 THE clash of cymbals
31:35 ...Uno de los momentos más sublimes que he escuchado, es música traida desde el mismo cielo, alimento puro para el alma. Qué serenidad, belleza, pureza, elevación! Gracias...
Vale.
Sin duda
Si escuchas bien la flauta el tema es de una sensación bucólica similar a la Sexta de Beethoven.
Ricardo...É música que alimenta a Alma . Asserena o " Eu Interior .Emocionei-me , conheci hoje ...Paz e Luz! São Paulo , janeiro , 17 , 2021- Brasil
Completamente de acuerdo
Direttore mitico e orchestra straordinaria.Cosa si può volere di più? Veramente eccelsi e si capisce perfettamente cosa ha composto il genio di Anton Bruckner la forma sonata dilatata appare in tutta la sua magnificenza e con grande chiarezza i passaggi dal primo tema e a i successivi sono proposti con grande chiarezza e così le transizioni e lo sviluppo.Si potrebbe andare avanti ancora ma la musica si spiega da sola.
This symphony is well represented on video. This one, Jochum, and Abbado with Lucerne ( the last time he conducted I believe ) I love them all! They are all great for similar and different reasons. If I had to pick one it would be Abbado. There is a real sense of occasion, and watching the music play over the maestros face is beautiful and poignant. Celebidache is probably the most complete realization of both the composers and conductors wishes.
SERÍA UNA NECEDAD,NEGAR LA CALIDAD Y FAMA DE LA FILARMÓNICA DE BERLÍN PERO,EN LA ÉPOCA DE CELIBIDACHE,LA FILARMÓNICA DE MUNICH SE ESCUCHABA SUPERIOR,EL MAESTRO RUMANO HA SIDO UNO DE LOS MEJORES DIRECTORES DE LA HISTORIA,UN GENIO.
Asi es
Totally agree!
Sublime!Sublime!Sublime!!🎼👏👏👏
That crescendo from 21:40! Magnificent. What a deep and large phrase
+Giovanni Godio yes but Celibidache just scream at the end , around 24:40
And he sreams again around 1:17:04... What a shame...
Who cares about that? this is a ridicoulous thing compared to his ability to conduct the orchestra in the final part of the first movement
I am sorry, Giovanni Godio, but I do care about that, because when I am listening to the music, I like to listen ONLY to the music...
jesus, you're a moron! he's probably shouting because he cannot be as bodily active as he was when he was younger...
Excepcional interpretación de Celibidache y la Filarmónica de München de esta gigantesca sinfonía. En 1990 Celibidache estaba ya anciano, con alguna dificultad de movimiento. Pero su concentración y absoluto control de la enorme orquesta son impresionantes. La calidad de la grabación en vivo es notable.
Estoy de acuerdo, don Jorge. Sus opiniones me parecen siempre ponderadas, atentas y de buen gusto
@@luisdiazlopez3712 Muy agradecido por su atenta respuesta.
Es un genio
どうしてこんなに素晴らしいのか・・・・
芸術という言葉では表せない凄さと偉大さを感じる。
賛成です
Fantastic. Just listened to Haitink and European Youth orchestra but this is another universe
Maestre îți mulțumim pentru aceste momente sublime Celibidache un vrăjitor al acestei orchestre și al acestui mare compozitor
Vraiment une excellente interprétation. Je reste pantois devant un scherzo joué avec une telle maîtrise qui provoque un véritable effet.
Unbeleivable!
I had forgotten how much i like this music, and this performance. My imagination is boarding a train for a journey through spectacular meadows, hills, and mountains
Absolute magnificence and grandiosity.
Buen sonido , interpretación MAGISTRAL , gracias 1Furtwangler por subirla.
Maestrul Sergiu Celibidache a fost si va ramane dirijorul de referinta al lucrarilor lui Bruckner. Un mare dirijor si filozof al muzicii! Suntem mandri ca e din Romania.
...DIRIGERE È UN ARTE ,NON UNO SFOGGIO DI VANITÀ.MI DISPIACE PER ALTRI DIRETTORI,MA DI CELIBIDACHE NE È ESISTITO SOLO UNO. LA SUA CIFRA COSMOGONICA DI PENETRAZIONE NELL' ATTO CREATIVO SUBLIME IMMANENTE TRASCENDENTE ,È UN RAPIMENTO ,UN VOLO CHE PORTA ALL' ESTASI.
Great!! And that brass.... wow!
The passage starting at 29:40 is one of the most ethereal things I have ever heard
to hear it again in our days is unbelievable! that was conducting…..he went so deep inside the score 🙏🙏💐
Intensa, profunda, ritmo interno inquebrantable. Belleza en el más alto estado de gracia.
Muy acertado👌
Great to see him enjoying the performance!
wow!!!primera vez que escucho a este colosal maestro de la direccion orquestal, que sonido, que texturas, impresionante y el tempo, el tempo es algo sobrenatural parece que se escapara del concepto normal que se tiene el pulso musical
+elkin gomez Celibidache es el" Einstein musical", el tiempo y el espacio son de otra dimension.
Elkin Gomez - Eu também , primeira vez que o escuto . Encantada com sons que Harmonizam Nossa Alma ..., Paz e Luz ! São Paulo, 17-01-2021 - Brasil
Celibidache ist mein Lieblingsdirigent und ich entdecke ihn gerade neu. Mir gefällt seine herangehensweise und man sieht an den proben, dass alles Hand und Fuß und Berechtigung hat. Zur Tempodiskussion kann ich nur sagen: ich weiß nicht wer diese als erster aufgebracht hat. Aus eigener Erfahrung kann ich dazu nur sagen es ist wesentlich schwieriger langsam zu spielen als schnell. und in vielen musikrichtungen wird zu schnell und zu verhaspelt gespielt sodass die Musik und das Werk gar nicht zur blüte kommen kann. Übrigens muss man es differenzieren, denn auch celibidache hat langsame und schnellere tempi. siehe Mozarts Requiem (Gegensatz Introitus sehr langsam und getragen und Kyrie wesentlich anderes Tempo). Auch im Jazz ist dieses Schnellgespiele gang und gebe und oft falsch und reine pseudovirtuosität.
Ich habe Sergiu Celibidache nur einmal live gehört , das war in München bei Mozarts Requiem. Nicht lange vor seinem Tod. Einer der bewegendsten Momente meiner musikalischen Erfahrungen. Ich fühlte damals die Gegenwart eines Alten Meisters.
Live*
Celibidache’s Bruckner is the perfect complement to the production of visual art for me. It’s sustains me like the highest grade protein and the deepest spiritual guidance.
I believe Celibidache to be a pre- Arvo Part tintinabulist of the highest order. He allows the time for the blossoming of tones. I find myself more and more resorting to the timeless heaven of Sergiu’s Bruckner.
Hier begreifen wir die Tiefe unserer Einmaligkeit unseres Seins
Le grand CELIBIDACHE est l'un des rares chefs qui savent interpréter la musique de BRUCKNER.
Sì, insieme a Karajan. Questa esecuzione è in effetti di grande levatura, decisamente migliore di quella coi Berliner del 1992.
Come puoi paragonare Celibidache a Karajan? È un impastatore di suoni, incapace di leggere una partitura!
Marco Biondi Chi è l'impastatore di suoni, Celibidace o Karajan?
Bruckner is the great composer .
This work the genius composer
evoked by the voice of God creates certainly flicks the heartstrings in the inside depth
of human soul .
From that ， impression , lamentation and compassion are born .
@2:37
"Hey, I am the boss!"
PRECIOSA MUSICA
As of the first note, we know we're in for an extraordinary interpretation, or better still, an extraordinary experience. Let me correct myself: not the first note, but the first half of the first note.
Many will take exception at the extreme slowness of the Adagio, but I believe it is as close to perfection as one can get. Would Bruckner himself have taken it so slow and would he approve? Great conductors and performers of genius like Celibidache can bring even more depth and meaning to music of which their very own composers were not aware when the piece was written. Case in point: Rachmaninoff said that Horowitz plays his music better than Rachmaninoff himself. I believe Celibidache takes Bruckner into a space unknown even to Bruckner himself. Once a composer releases a piece of music it is no longer belongs to him!
I am sure that Bruckner would love it Robert! (and I am sure that you are absolutely correct with your closing comment!...Bruckner would also agree!
It no longer belongs to him completely*
almost as slowly as Klemperer
Actually Celibidache is much slower than Klemperer.
@@robertmanno8470 Yes, he is. My poor memory! I think a little to slow in the final movement, an extreme reading of nicht schnell.
La più bella di BRUKNER, CON GRANDE DIRETTORE.
I can't think of any other performance of Bruckner which comes close to Celibidache!