Jallianwala Bagh massacre (movie gandhi)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ม.ค. 2017
- I GIVE CREDITS TO MAKERS OF (GANDHI) MOVIE;
i talked with them.https:
amzn.to/2GwIHAF
amzn.to/2gf7Kk3
The Jallianwala Bagh massacre, also known as the Amritsar massacre, took place on 13 April 1919 when a crowd of nonviolent protesters, along with Baishakhi pilgrims, who had gathered in Jallianwala Bagh, Amritsar, Punjab, were fired upon by troops of the British Indian Army under the command of Colonel Reginald Dyer...
affiliate involved
With this mindless massacre, the UK lost all moral authority. This was the beginning of the end of the British Empire.
And they try to make themselves look like heroes by overplaying how Churchill fought against Hitler.
And even then, Churchill was losing badly and only succeeded holing up in Britain to defend its skies.
All this despite getting 5 times more material and monetary support from Americans than the Soviets, who successfully pushed right into Berlin, unlike the Brits.
Yeah I guess it's better than Axis Japan playing nuclear victim try to hide how they *invaded, raped, conscripted, eaten (even George HW Bush almost got eaten in Chichijima, its why he threw up on their Prime Minister in 1992 when they were eating sushi because 8 of his wingmen were chopped up and eaten like that), killed, experimented, gassed all those people in Vietnam, Singapore, Malaysia, China, Indonesia, Australia, Korea, Philippines, and Micronesia (the natives were so glad the Americans saved them from Japan, they hold cargo cults in their honor to this day).* Even hide how they too, like Nazis, were developing nuclear weapons, but were too slow compared to the Manhattan Project. And how they got flyers warning them specific cities and dates of bombing but the government told them to get back to making weapons and ignore American lies. Or how Japan bombed civilians as early 1938 in China, in Chongqing.
The British Empire did not have any morality in the very first place.
India too did to the same sikhs in 1984 and Kashmir now
@@CrabTastingMan ever heard of history fabrication
@@waverider1674 no they didn't. Atleast not un Kashmir. If govt was hard it would have broken them by now
In 1984 govt didn't directly game orders. Some pissed off leaders conspired and let the public had it
I am a History Professor at a college and I teach my students using this scene (thank you Dhritesh). I tell my students every time that whatever credibility the British government had before the "Amritsar Massacre" quickly evaporated due to this tragedy. After this horrific even, India's independence was assured. Although I am not Indian, I love the country and plan on continuing to teach its wonderful history!
Makes me ashamed to be British.
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳love from India sir
We respect to the people like you sir who stick with the truth.
@@chintanvyas9074 i hope you are not an Indian
I love my India
'If Hitler does it, it's called fascism
If we do it, it's called modernization'-British Empire
I think it’s cause they removed this guy from command while hitler encouraged his generals to do this resulting in the genocide of 11 million people.
Well it was done by one unit, not the leader of a country, Winston Churchill found the incident "unutterably monstrous."
@@enterchannelname154 And later in 1943, he caused the infamous bengal famine, killing millions of my ancestors.
@@kushagrasrivastava8432Bengal famine is holocaust of india
@@Azahar-cp1vb Yes it is
Btw, where r u from? ?
And Speaking English in India is still considered Superior...
It's not about hate.. it's about dignity..
I am a foreigner from Mauritius..
My ancestors came from India ...
I visit India regularly..
I always try to speak Hindi I've learned from Hindi movies...
I feel pride in there ..
Pueden hablar los dos idiomas y la herencia del Reinó unido quedo para siempre.
The colonial history of the English language does leave a sour taste in the mouth of a lot of people but you really can't blame them, English is the language of international commerce and most scientific research. In a country with massive linguistic diversity like India they gain much more benefit from everyone learning English than everyone learning Malayalam or Telugu. Props to you though for paying respect to your ancestors and the local culture
That's because for half of Indians Hindi is as foreign as English.
Today its 100 years of this tragedy. Salute to the martyred...🇮🇳
Salute From Angola ..
Yes brother.
Anonymous Creature th-cam.com/video/YW8BhH-PC5k/w-d-xo.html
Jai ho Jai hind Jai Bharat
Noscoped
I visited this place last year and to my surprise the bullets holes are still there on the wall.. Shocking and sad😢
Yes me too, when I visited Amritsar a few years ago, I too saw the bullet holes and the well where people jumped to save themselves.
Goes to show how far these idiots have come. lol. They cannot even clean up after.
MOOSEDOWNUNDER oh look a British sympathizer, they didn’t clean the bullet holes to remember the history of this massacre.
sad😢😢😢😢
@@MOOSEDOWNUNDER shutup
It's a pity that Sir Reginald Dyer didn't serve on the Western Front in WWI, with little luck a Mauser bullet or a Krupp shell would cut his career short. On a happier note, it's a brilliant performance by Edward Fox, as always.
If i'm not mistaken, the script for the questioning of General Dyer is lifted directly from the real hearing's transcripts.
"General, how does a child, shot with a .303 Lee Enfield, apply for help?"
That line has stuck with me since I first saw this movie in school.
Agree. That Line has some impact.
Few lines in cinematic history compare to that.
Strange that this is a British made movie how many countries make movies portraying themselves as the bad guys.
That is the one huge difference between a democratic society and the authoritarian regimes.
It leaves a vent.
@@harding10B its not really portraying themselves, its portraying the people who allowed this to happen referring, the general British public were outraged, Winston Churchill called it 'unutterably monstrous.'
1 minutes peace for those who have died.
Yeah, Sangita
yes we have to do
They Will never die, they will always live in our mind and heart ❤
Jai Hind🇮🇳🇮🇳
@Iraj Pandey why 100 years pagal ho kya🙄
@@PatrickFitzgerald.. wt other work do u guys have other than drinking, smoking and spreading hate!?
Now Rishi Sunak an Indian is the Prime Minister of the UK. Just imagine if Mahatma Gandhi was here to see this today.
Mahatma the Charlatan
Well that just shows the superiority of British Society that today a British citizen of foreign origin can rise to the highest office. It's not likely will see the reverse in another hundred years.
Yeah made an Indian the PM of England and the Indians still bang the drum on racism and reparations. Would India ever elect a Westerner as PM in its own country? NO WAY....Even though it is badly needed to address the failures of modern India....
@@billprendgergast8976Modern India and Pakistan were destined to be failstates since their independence though. One is still filled with poverty, with it's prime main holy river of Ganges being polluted to the point it's toxic to be near it in kilometers, with a unhealable divide between Hindi North and the Dravidan South. The second is a islamic theocracy, with life even worse than in, say, Varanasi, Shanghai, Detroit, Norilsk, or Mogadishu, as it still has medieval laws, like execution for crimes and stoning people to death. Here it needs to just be legit carved up because the countries cannot maintain themselves at this rate - India recently surpassed China in population it cannot maintain - often hunger and diseases are main occurrence in places like Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal.
@@OkojoMizuri Exactly....India and Pakistan have been on the cusp of failed states since the British left. The jingoism that comes out of these two nations is delusional. If the West went for closed doors on immigration and wound back aid and free trade agreements most of the third world.wojrd collapse. We have inadvertently brought down the West and particularly USA and England to a shell of its former self all for then same of saying "we are not racist". The multicultural utopia that many envisioned is a failed experiment but nobody has the courage to bring an end to it. And I am trying to state it in as politically way as possible...
I am Irish. the British did similar things to us. long live India and long live Ireland
The British government you mean? The public didn’t come over and start starving the irish, the monarchs and governments did over the years. Hate the right people
The governor of that province was named michael o dwyer a tipperary man. He was assinated in revenge in London almost 20 years later by one of the survivors..general dyer had been educated in midleton co cork.
And in every other country they enslaved.
@@seanmccann8368The English committed the worst atrocities in Africa and India and launched the black legend against Spain
@@RaulGonzalez-xt1kx I agree.
The saddest thing is that the soldiers firing upon our brothers in Jallianwala Bagh were Indians themselves.
I think they were Gurkhas from Nepal.
They were Gurkhas from Nepal... not indian
He recruited Gurkhas and ppl from Baloch for this to ensure the soldiers firing had no sympathy for those being fired
@@aaheliroy7769 Who is "he?"
@@Tarnatos14 General Reginald Dyer
My grandfather's kinsman was also there but he was saved then. My grandfather told this whole story to us.
I am from Punjab, 🇵🇰.
same here, thank lord my grandma escaped into Britain at that time and didn't have a single chance of being there
@@PG-hc7nb nah nah we were richer than Britain all u did was steal our shit and run like cowards
@@PG-hc7nb india contributed 25 percent to the world economy before british came....atleast this was more the 2 percent contributed by britain
@@punjabiman596 she went to Britian or she left Britian?
@@mrcool2107 she went into britain with her husband for work that had an ok pay
RIP
To the 1,500-2,000 Indian civilians and Baisakhi pilgrims who were murdered by the British Indian Army under R.E.H. Dyer in the Jallianwala Bagh massacre
The numbers were around 350 civilians dead, but a great tragedy nonetheless.
Another Amercan! This is over a hundred years ago. You lot are still carrying out this type of stuff.
How many died at Horroshima and Nagasaki? Anything else is insignificant compared to that.
I mean it was kinda their fault , why did they just stand there
The armored car not being able to fit through was the best part😂
pagol
The only punishment Dyer ever got was being removed from command
He got full pension till his death. House of Lords and many British subjects supported Dyre's actions and even raised 30,000 pounds to help him financially. He is termed a 'Hero' in British history. Stangely, Winston Churchill who is considered anti-India condemned his actions and demanded action against him, but the Parliamentarians refused.
And there were people that called him "the man that saved Punjab"!!
@@nakulsharma7725 It was a Propaganda started by Dyre himself by colluding with the Sikh religious leaders. The leaders declared Dyre a sikh. That's why the other sikhs started the Gurudwara reform movement to get rid of these corrupt religious leaders.
He was assisinated by Udham Singh in a conference , because Udham Singh wanted to take revenge , if you all don't know
@@roshansingh1623 just came here after watching the movie
All history aside, this sequence is so amazingly shot and directed. The acting, the set pieces, the costumes, the cinematography. It doesn’t feel like a movie at all. It genuinely feels like you’re watching a piece of history.
Yess
watch the movie Sardar Udham if you can handle it. Far better and more impactful depiction of this massacre in the final 45 min. So Gut-wrenching.
this line "ALL HISTORY BESIDE"
@@iamlalisasstylist1796 aside. Not beside. Aside means disregard. Beside means in the general left or right of something.
@@kookookachu26 oh okk
I went to Amritsar on a tour of India and visited this place , the 303 bullets holes are still there to this day as a reminder of what a World Leader the UK was and is today
I felt ashamed to admit i was from the UK while i was there and couldnt believe our armed forces did that to those people
Times have changed
@@thecamocampaindude5167 Not for the British elites that still think they are superior, only now the British do their covert operations and stay silent, Ukraine war and their puppet Zelensky.
@@thecamocampaindude5167nothing change, now UK supplying weapon to Israel.
Oh for god's sake shut up. The two things aren't comparable@@kamaruddin9172
@@kamaruddin9172as it should be
They won the war without firing a single shot.
May God bless Udam Singh!
James Garcia .anand.pal
@@deependradeependra2712 Thank you. I have been to Jalian Wala Bagh. Though I am not Indian, the place brought years to my eyes to think of the the massacre. After that day in 1919, the British lost any semblance of moral standing they might have had. When Udam Singh was executed he immediately ascended into the pastures of heaven. When Singh killed Gen. O'Dywer, the General went immediately to Hell.
@@jamesgarcia2040 This was justified.
@@jamesgarcia2040 Lieutenant-Governor Michael O'Dwyer was assassinated by Udham Singh. Colonel (temporary rank of brigadier-general at the time of the massacre) Reginald Dyer, who is depicted in this clip, had already passed by the time Udham Singh made his way to the UK.
Yes.
"Civilized" British in action
True
I see a single British commander and hordes of loyal brown skinned soldiers obeying his orders.
@@prasanthalpha thise are gorkhos Nepalese
Not punjabi
Brits have a property of dividing people first Scots with Catholics then Arab with Israel
@Indian Atheist No. Hitler was not innocent. The people who collaborate with him are equally guilty.
@Indian Atheist The blame cannot be on the British alone. Indians are equally responsible.
God this is shot so well, I feel choked up watching all the people run. Great work to the director, crew, hundreds of actors/extras for giving light to this horrible tragedy. I hope those people may rest in peace.
The irony is that the Sikhs were the biggest losers with the end of the British Raj. Their home land was cut in a half and their special place in the British hierarchy was lost.
After this incident, dyer returned to England where he got prizes for this bravery. This makes you wonder how shameless are these Brits..... Really.
@British National Conservative when dyer return to England a benefit fund was started in his name which collected 26000 pounds in that time of money, and should people feel happy that his action got criticism? when a sport person doesn't perform good then even he gets criticized for his performance, but dyer deserved the capital punishment which was too common to be given to the Indians but instead he gets rewarded by money for his action.
@British National Conservative Tell Elizabeth to return the wealth looted by her forefathers . Tell Elizabeth to apologize in public for all the atrocities and murders committed by her empire.
I guess you’ll be wanting that great big diamond from the queen’s crown!! What will India do with it?
@@timsplanet2 nothing..... We might just throw that in garbage..... but you don't have to be concerned about how we gonna use our things, if someone stole something from your home and when you ask that thing back from him then does he has right to ask you that what would you use it for?
@@parasmehra2479 As an English person I fully agree. Britain today stands on the looted and stolen wealth from countries like India and shamelessly refuses to acknowledge that fact. The fact that we have our monarchy etc sickens me.
As a specific example for the diamond from the queens crown; yeah, give it back. It doesn't matter what happens to it after that, the point is simply that it's not hers to keep.
I really feel very sad on the ppl who sacrificed their life for our freedom. Big salute
Anil Kumar sad thing is that they were not knowing this would happen because it was nonviolence protest and British given answer with violent act !
We have to give blood to be free !! Not by nonviolence move ! In this way Bagath Singh and Subash Chandra Bose and others are great !!
They didn't sacrifice their lives voluntarily. This isn't something to feel proud about. I can only sense dread and despair in this.
@@maheshbengarkar1354 right sir …!
@sreelekha k.r Care to elaborate?
@@cheems2633 just shut you mouth you sh*t
इसे देखने के बाद मेरा रूह कांप उठा
ऐसे वीर साहिद के लिए सत सत नमन
😢😢
The thing I like about this movie is doesn't bias any side, potrays history in it's raw form
Knowing the fact that it’s 102 yrs old still breaks my heart even today 😭😭😭😭
Knowing the fact that Britain built railroads in India still warms my heart.
@@PG-hc7nb don't u feel shame oh ofc u don't coz u Britishers will never be kind to us, right?
@@iamlalisasstylist1796 Yes we civilized you otherwise yall wouldve been as poor as africa eejit
@@PG-hc7nb oh wow what a big pleasure right? damn it, we dint's have any technology in India before ur general and blah blah blah's rule but we became INDEPENDENT after 1947 as u know what happened that year so anyways, we have many gadgets in India, why? coz u guys are not still telling us that what are do's and don't's, so accept it as your queen eliza eliza accepted it!!!
@@iamlalisasstylist1796 Accepted what, that we developed India?
143 years later and the imperial British still hadn't learned a thing.
Their karma has caught up with them.
And it's only been a hundred years since this took place
101 years
@@charlesottowilliamwade5328 and what did the British do to a island 4000 miles away from their island. idk a full millitary invasion?
Shut the fuck up with your Stone Age country what do you mean we haven’t learned a thing you dickhead
The fact that they honored him, shows the extent of their moral debauchery.
How sad we as a nation sank to such levels of violence against an unharmed crowd 😢
If it makes you feel any better, India and Pakistan committed far worse to one another during the Partition. Let not your heart not be troubled.
@@smellincoffee
Yes and that had nothing to do with British policy of "divide and rule".. anyway nice try to whitewash your country's criminal past
@@nitlover8319 One little island dominated the damn world. I'm not in the least ashamed.
The British public was horrified by this event and the perpetrators vilified. Not that this matters to Indians.
@@smellincoffeeoh yeah that speaks volumes about your character.
that kid's face gave me tears 😭😢😩
You tell us widows had childrens too how ruthlessly your culture had been throwing widows into fire.
th-cam.com/video/XAc2KiDusQc/w-d-xo.html
How did you ruthlessly killed lower caste peoples for entering in temples and you'd been killing millions of millions widows since the beginning killed a lot of peoples alive and killed a lot of girls by ur dangerous culture
In same way everything happened with all bymut just thousands of people died
*God see everything*
Get happy if General Diar didn't shooted peoples so India would never be independent none's eye would open
Ur Freedom fighters like Gandhi ji etc worked for Britian first.
Watch in to video how britishers saved ur millions of millions girls
Somehow God made happened what God wants to be happened and India's whole money was taken away and was made apoor country
@@pokemonhunter8418 wth
@Indian Atheist Our religion hasn't any caste system and we don't believe in any kinda blackfaith therefore we are christans.
✝️✝️✝️✝️✝️✝️
@Indian Atheist lool
*You are more stupid than you look*
As I said we don't believe in any blackfaith.
So we just feel ashamed for our commited sins, What we have never commited.
Improve your mentality.
What can be expected you to say .😂.
@Indian Atheist You all carry on crying for the past
I guess the saddest line uttered was, "General, how does a child shot with a 303 Lee Enfield apply for help?" 😢
कौन कौन ये विडिओ 13 अप्रेल को देख रहे है
😢😢😢
All of Kashmir, Aksai Chin, Nepal, Bhutan, Sri Lanka, the Maldives, Siachen Glacier, the Trans-Karakoram Tract and even South Tibet all rightfully belong to India and will inevitably be returned to India.
Long live to India and regards to all Indian patriots from Mexico! 🇮🇳🇲🇽❤🫡
Long Live CHRIST The King
"We must have the courage to take their anger"
Maybe if the British had taken that approach - if they’d just kept administering justice fairly whenever the radicals attacked them - then maybe they wouldn’t have lost India.
@@TheWchurchill4pm So kind of you to refer to Freedom Fighters of my nation as "radicals".
Today, it serves no purpose to hate. The purpose is education by all involved so that such a thing does not happen again. The number 1 take away is that under no circumstances should anyone kill unarmed innocent people especially your own countrymen. India as well as many other countries have this shame in their past. So look forward not backwards and heal yourself.
Salute to bhagat Singh and his friends.
Udham singh
@@PG-hc7nb who kicked out indians out of the train and used railway to transport free goods from india to britain.....still salute???
Human beings have short memories. Therefore it is educational to screen this short episode on National TV + broadcast to mobile phones within the whole of India - on 15 August every year. It is to remind India citizens what nationhood means.
I remember being in India in 1977-78, there were mass shootings of civilians by police. Usually low caste or untouchables, I’d read about it in local Indian papers but it was never picked up internationally. You see it was brown on brown and not white on brown. All the difference in the world.
Yes I am a cynic !
SAINT MICHAEL THE ARCHANGEL
The Patron Saint Of Police Officers
Dyer suffered numerous strokes in the last few years of his life, which resulted in paralysis and speech impairment. He died in 1927 from a cerebral haemorrhage. Perhaps it was divine punishment.
Ironic how the British condemned Hitler's 3rd Reich when there were officers in their own army as bad as him... he was willing to kill unarmed civilians as mercilessly as the SS were unarmed Jews.
@@nahor88 "History is written by victors"
@@nahor88 It was policy by the German government to deliberately murder a whole race of people.It absolutely was not government policy by the British government to murder the Indian's.Don't try to compare the two.
@@Anglo_Saxon1 First of all indian is not a race but nationality .
Second of all the British is responsible of the deaths of at least a billion people in India. They thought of themselves a "necessity" because they believed indians to be beggars who did not deserve the wealth and resources. They looted . Everything Britain had and has is made from the suffering and pain of others
@@Anglo_Saxon1 the entire South Asian continent suffered over 2.7 Billion deaths under British rule for 200 years...
Wanna elaborate on that???
I love the line “We must have the courage, to take there anger.”
Their anger.
You can almost read his mind, like he was thinking, "These are my final words, I must make them count."
Even now, clear over a 100 years later and when the PRIME MINISTER OF THE UK IS OF INDIAN ORIGIN, The British Government still has not issued an apology for the Amritsar Massacre. For shame.
Yeah bro
Just knowing this was done to my own people hurts me. Some of the people who were killed that tried to run away were not cowards. Some were people who tried to be home with their family, others were moms seeking safety for their kids, and some were loyal husbands to their wifes and loyal wifes to their husbands.
You are not a coward if you try to escape from dying foolishly
@@doubleOsable isn't British word is a stain itself
@@doubleOsable Yet I see a lot of your people being Racist and celebrating the massacre.
Not learned a lot haven't they??
We will take revenge
@@doubleOsable easy for you to say when you come from the side of the oppressor.
This massacre is embedded in every Indians memories,we shall never ever forget and forgive....Jai Hind.
I will why can’t we stop seeing them as enemies they can’t be blamed for something other people did
@@Mylifesuckslol Who is blaming people living there today? We hate the British empire, get lost, sepoy.
@@doctorgamez2410 I hate the empire too the person said never forget which is fair but never forgive is too far
@@Mylifesuckslol No, they shouldn’t be forgiven for this, because it was done and they have barely made a half assed apology. Doesn’t mean we can’t have good relations with them. We can work together and recognize past wrongdoings.
@@doctorgamez2410 He probably means never forgive the brits even in their current state with the empire all but gone
British Empire when finding unarmed civilians: :D
British Empire when a fellow European superpower threatens their interest: D:
My blood is boiling to see all my people's are dying 😭
@@pokemonhunter8418 👍
@@pokemonhunter8418 even the most educated person cant understand this sentence like oml...fix ur grammar
@Indian Atheist not more than u,
You're more stupid AF than you look.
Therefore that's nonsense to u.
@@pokemonhunter8418 MAN, U THINK I AM BLIND? I JUST EDITED IT MORON!
@@pokemonhunter8418 u mean ur entire paragraph was a typo? no shit-sherlcok
Shikh dhurm k logo ne bahut kurbaniyan di hai is Desh k liye
Shikh dhurm jindabad
But hey, Sikhs don't believe in a caste system. The Indian Armed Forces commanders have far too many Sikhs compared to other groups. In armed forces only the military success should count. Meritocracy, Sir!
Ha brother salute
@@cintulator2 fuck- fc = UK
Shikh ko mai dil se salam karta hu
@Home Lander Muslim ne Kuch Nahi kiya
Britishers never apologized for this Massacre and looting
5:21 It's sad just seeing the baby there not knowing what's going on but see her mother injured or dead, kinda dark and still sad.
A heartly and proudly Salute to SARDAAR UDHAM SINGH JI
Who is that ? New shopkeeper?
@@mrcool2107 he was the hero of our country who killed tha lousy general Dyer
@@mrcool2107 he was ur daddy
@@mrcool2107 your mum's sugar daddy
@@myindia4553 dyer wasn't assassinated it was Dwyer bruh cmon get yo facts right
As a brit myself I'm glad our "little" empire fell. We were almost as bad as the Nazis with our idea of supremacy... The boer war for example - We thought we were entitled to South Africa's diamonds just because they had it. It cost 40,000 civilian lives. We pillaged India for all their resources and left them in poverty. We should have to pay reparations for all the damage we've done yet we seem to act like we're perfect. We were almost like Cardassians...
completely agree mate, especially as a british indian
Well it's in the past so I wish we all could move on, yeah loads of Indians r still upset & haven't moved on but let's not try to hurt any of the current lot who r innocent from both sides. It's good that this won't happen in modern times, atleast by outside forces.
there are comments of people 'celebrating' the massacre on this video, are people there still so shameless?
I always say this.
Britishers are worse than Nazis
Return kohinoor
What rifle is that? A Springfield 1903?
What's the song at the first 10 seconds of the clip?
and the irony is that the West look at the colonies and call them Barbarians..
Well who were the ones who opened fire? Westerners or Barbarians?
@@prasanthalpha who were the ones who don't women vote for 100 years
@@johnjacobastoriv688 west. India allowed women vote starting from independence
@@samarpreetsingh1052 thanks India later
@@prasanthalpha , The Barbarians opened fire
5:14 That part made me cry.
Same 😭
Aaj bhi isko yaad karne ke baad rooh kaap uthati hai 😢😢
As a Korean, I was glad that the impact of March 1st Movement of our country was seen in this movement in India, especially when it happened the same year. Just like many Indians, many of our compatriots were massacred back in the earlier protest by the Japanese.
And indeed during the Korean War it was Koreans killing Koreans. The British were one of the nations that fought and died for your freedom my friend. They are not the same people as they were 125 years ago.
@@kennethpotts4341 I know, but that does not justify war crimes by Britain though.
We watched this movie in my global studies class and this scene almost made me cry. The little girl crying next to her dead mother especially hit me. It's so disgusting and heartbreaking that violence like this exists and that this whole event even happened
Life is cruel you know 😢
Have u seen... Sardar udham.... Movie???
Its highly unlikely that the soldiers fired without first being attacked by the mob, and its also not likely that they kept firing after the mob dispersed, nor likely that women and children were in the mob too. Don't confused a Hollywood anti-imperialist movie for a real camera on the scene telling the whole truth. This defies common sense and human nature. That little girl you are emotionally struck by likely never existed.
"Иди и смотри" не смотрели!?
The way this scene has been captured in Sardar Udham movie, watching that will surely bring tears in one's eyes
How much the Britain contributed to India laws railroads brings tears to ones eyes
Don't want such Roads, rails in terms of oppression. #FckU #FckBritain
@@PG-hc7nb ofcourse, this brings tear to eyes that they build those roads and railways to transport jewels to port
@@PG-hc7nb what contribution they make railway for their own benefit you people brainwashed by white india was a rich country after china britishers came here looted our wealth and destroy our economy and take heavy tax from poor people
@@PG-hc7nb lmao yeah right... They contributed... More like we did... They charged 2x the money required to build normal railroads... Putting millions of dollars into the project from the pockets of poverty stricken indians... Some contribution tht was... Using private contractors from Britain.. Instead of the indians to purposely increasing cost and dont even get me started on trying to match consumer demand cause they didn't even try.. You got nothing to defend your glorified empire with... Just gtfo and stop embarrassing yourself
Even though this is a movie as you would say a reenactment. I still feel the pity for those people that were involved in such a massacre. 😢
Senseless killing by an incompetent administrator.
Love from Pakistan I read full history of Jallianwala bagh and I salute to Ram Muhammad Singh Azad (Udham Singh) for took revenge our people may Allah his soul rest in peace
Britain is cruel bro
@@notyourtypefan7743 mughal also
We are brothers .
@@whatisthat5175 you absolutely cannot state Mughals to be as cruel as the British empire...infact, the empire went far beyond just "cruel"...Mughals (majority of them) were just the same as the Peshwas or Guptas, except they came from a different country...they wanted to rule over India, settle here and flourish its economy...yes, there were some who condemned different religions, but none of them ever came with that intent...all of the Hindu Muslim division bullshit came from the British...also, Bahadur Shah Zafar played a major role in the Revolt of 1857
So don't say that the Mughals were cruel, because they were just the same as most dynasties and empires that were from India and ruled over the nation before the Brits came and all hell broke loose
@@whatisthat5175 the later Mughal, I'd say after Akbars sons were the weakest of the bunch
Something worth remembering is that this massacre horrified Churchill, who did not, to be as diplomatic as possible, advocate a "gentle hand" policy with Britain's colonial subjects. So you can imagine how horrified everyone else was.
You know it says a lot when someone like Churchill thought Dyer had gone too far.
he was so horrified when the Bengal famine started he said" Beastly people with a beastly religion, ihate them" hasn`t Gandhi starved yet ? NO american ships with supplies for them!
@@michaelpielorz9283 never said that last part, thats a lie
@@Mythee. He said it was the Indians fault for Breeding like Rabbits🤦🏿🤦🏿🤦🏿🤦🏿
@Kaltagstar96 says Churchill who sent the black and tans to ireland
Still amazed by what humans can do to other humans....💔
Throughout the history of man. you are so right. it is totally sad and pathetic.
A superb film which treats the historical mindlessness of tragic events such as this one with dignity and respect. The questioning of the general, after the incident, and the silence in the film when the general delivers his answers reflects the severity of the tragedy. The final question "General, how does a child, shot with a .303 Lee Enfield, apply for help?" - and the silence which follows - still resonates with me and reminds me of the brilliance of the scriptwriters and editors of the film. The author of the screenplay, John Briley, was a justifiable winner of the Academy Award, one of the eight that the film won (including Best Film, Director and Actor).
Tears bursted through my eyes after watching this... 😭😭😭
Acha
I’m laughing at the fact that a enfield wouldn’t hold that much rounds being fired without reloading
watch Sardar Udham if you can handle it. Far better and more impactful depiction of this massacre in the final 45 min.
Tears bursted after the Indians aren't thanking us for all the good things we did
😂😂😂
Iam from USA.. (America)
After watching this movie, i felt very sad for indians. I proud and respect india. India is not my country. But i love it...
Regresa a Inglaterra
Nope, you are not from the US.
So you are from another country that ignores its responsibility for crimes against mankind: Remember the American Natives and Slavery!
Condolence 😢🤍❤️ from the Philippines 🇵🇭⛩️🇮🇳to India
Bit ironic the current British PM is Indian who has about the same humanity as this General
i am proud of being Punjabi. I love my forefathers for their sacrifice for the country.
Animated Story on partition of India
th-cam.com/video/1okXmLObHRE/w-d-xo.html
U should proud of being bhartiye sir .....state devied us
@@govindkumarraj9426 so why there are states remove all the states why haryana and punjab was divided in 1966
@@HarmanSingh-hm4zt it's just a significant ..don't we just one ...counting only our house ..isn't a option buddy ...think about it ...there r lots of propegenda out there to cut us
I salute them I also love sikhs
Watching this movie in Religion class, this is the moment everybody took the film seriously. It was amazing how the class went from making jokes, to fully engaged for the rest. When the film started, people giggled when Ghandi was shot, at the end, they cried.
Have u ever heard about... Sardar udham..... Movie????
True sir.
Lucky you have Indian religion classes. Even though I’m a Hindu, my school forces me to learn about Catholicism and pray to that religion. Sometimes non Catholics get in big trouble at my school just for being a different religion. I hope that someday my school will correct itself and treat all religions equally.
@@TRGRobloxGodbro it happens in christian convent schools 😂that's their propoganda
I could definitely understand how the transition of emotions could change for the audience.
This is nothing compared to the tens of millions of indians who starved to death in India while the british were shipping food out .
This is the reason i never went to the ARMY you become a minion a slave to kill from the gods.
General Dwyre isn't some rogue soldier. He's exactly what the British Empire represented
No, he wasn’t. pick up a history book and you will see he wasn’t and doesn’t represent us at all. truth is all you colonial subjects want someone to blame for your own failures. cry me a river. the empire has been dead for essentially 50 years.
@@thatonelocalauthority2809 go fuck yourself Tan.
@Caleb Reichenbach that's what the Britsh Empire is. A giant pompus jackass with a gun.
@@thatonelocalauthority2809 It was probably the British who wrote the history book.
@@thatonelocalauthority2809 why would the British House of Lord endorsed hia actions.. He wasn't even jailed .. He returned to England get pension and led a luxurious live
Today is 102 anniversary of this masacre 😢😢😢rip to all people who dead in this masacre
Those British troops don't look like local militia. I think they are Gurkhas.
Whenever I think about this Jallianwala bagh incident I fell very bad because hundreds of people were killed in this incident😭😭
Imagine if the armoured car was brought in, equipped with just one Vickers machine gun or if the soldiers were equipped with fully automatic submachine gun, it would be an unimaginable horror.
Oh yes
Even worse, if they had self-loading rifles or bren or Lewis lmg's
Sub machine guns are already fully automatic
The horror is still no less imaginable…even now with 1500+ unarmed casualties who here are shown all unarmed
Oh like it wasn't already
I remember watching Grandi in the Odeon Cinema in Leicester Square London with my late Goan wife. When this scene came on the audience went absolutely quiet. You could have heard the proverbial pin drop on the plush carpet. They could not believe the British Army would have been capable of such horror. But it was. You can't wash blood like this off, it's a stain on our then character. I'd like to think that we are now rather better. Yes, things are still done wrong, but also things have also been done right. It used to be said that there were only two species on this planet that made war on themselves. Ants being the other one. We did great wrong here, and so, very sadly, have very many others. That is no excuse. Not for any of us. We remember our great sins but we should also try and improve.
All of you crying about how brutal the British were......YET....YOU COME HERE IN YOUR HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS.....SINCE this event !!!
So you condone mass murder
इसका हिसाब हम भारतवासी एक दिन जरूर लेंगे कर्म घूम के वापस आता है तैयार रहना भविष्य में ।
I am a teacher from south India. In the 1980s when I was studying middle class when my History teacher narrated the incident I was moving with pain in my heart for many weeks. Those days no TV or any kind of visual aids to learn about things. But the visualization which I had on those days exactly correlates with the above.
Have u seen.... Sardar udham... Movie...?????
You know this is Hollywood propaganda and not likely historically accurate, right? Its far more likely that several warnings were issued, the crowd rushed to attack believing in superior numbers, and forced the soldiers to defend themselves. That's how it has gone in almost all of these "massacres" around the world in so many different cultures.
If you haven't watched it, you must watch Gandhi. Directed by Richard Attenborough (brother of David Attenborough, the naturalist) it is truly a masterpiece.
lee enfield is indeed one of the best rifle at its time
British got the karma when Hitler bombarded UK straight for 8 months in a row. Hitler failed the war but he also assured he bankrupted Britain which led to the fall of British Empire and ultimately resulted in India independence. Even other colonies also gained independence. Brexit is another karma.
Hitler a hero of yours then?
4:58 oh look i found a psychopath
Not hard to do, infortunately. You just have to look at some of the comments on here.
He is an actor. Don't hate him. He is doing his role😂😂
@@beenadatta5038 If an actor makes you hate a villainous character so much, then the actor has done his job to play the role to perfection
Udham Singh assasinated the man who ordered him in London
Long live Shaheed Udham Singh
God bless Martyrs of Amritsar, may God have mercy on Mahatma Gandhi and Jawaharlal Nehru. The struggle of Indian brothers in the British also represents a popular struggle. India and Egypt are brothers, not friends ❤️❤️🫂🇮🇳🇪🇬
Lol I like how they missed the part where the mob was running around killing hundreds of innocent people.
Yes I’m from south India. This massacre made my blood boil. Colonialism has changed the dynamics of the world. There was a freedom fighter from vishakapatnam who made British piss in their pants. Alluri seetha ram raju. Google his name. All the freedom fighters who used violence, I love them. Bhagat sing, subash Chandra Bose etc. hats off.
We came to know about it through RRR
It's a shame we don't know much about so many of our freedom fighters 😭
you know nothing
I worked as an investigative assistant at a police station and a few times they brought suspected murderers past the bull pen i worked in. The eyes of a murderer who is unremorseful for their crime is hard to explain. But Edward fox does an incredible job portraying the cold, emotionless eyes of a killer. Probably why he plays the Jackal in day of the jackal as well
True.
But maybe that is not an accurate portrait of Dwyer.
@@HooDatDonDar Also, 'he' didn't kill anyone. Soldiers of the Indian Army did.
@@johnbobson1557 refusing the orders of your superior in the millitary was punishable by death during that time period just take a look at trench warfare in ww1 and soldiers refusing to rush through no mans land shot as they are nothing more than bad product the commander disposes off
@@johnbobson1557 So by your logic the army did'nt kill anyone, their rifles did. Isn't it Mr. Wowaah?
"Dyer devised what even one of his generally supportive superiors, O'Dwyer, described as an "irregular and improper" retaliation for the attack on Marcella Sherwood, designed, it seemed, to fall indiscriminately and humiliatingly on the local population. On the street where the assault occurred, Kucha Kurrichhan, Dyer ordered daytime pickets placed at either end. Anyone wishing to proceed into the street between 6 am and 8 pm was made to crawl the 200 yards (180 m) on all fours, lying flat on their bellies. When questioned at the Hunter inquiry about this, Dyer explained his motivation:
"Some Indians crawl face downwards in front of their gods. I wanted them to know that a British woman is as sacred as a Hindu god and therefore, they have to crawl in front of her too.""
You know that old saying, don't bring a turban to a gun fight.
Our history teacher answered a student's question on what was inside the well Gandhi was looking into. I didn't even see the blood the first time we watched this in class. She said anyone who went into the well to escape fell to their death. Gandhi was looking upon a pile of bodies.
"There is not curse on entish, elvish or language of man for this treacherous!"
The troops doing the shooting were Indian, and now 5.5 million Indians live in the UK
Is this not from Captain Miller ? This scene ?
"We must have the courage to take their anger." (sic)
We Filipinos, almost all of our grudges against our colonizers especially Spain have disappeared or almost faded away. However, I cannot expect the same thing to Indians for this is extremely brutal. Hope the wound will heal, and British also must understand how hard it is for Indians to accept this painful past.
The racist mind set here is unbelievable. The British press raised forty thousand pounds for this guy when he was sent home after the investigation. So his views were shared by many.
Specially Spain??? HUH??? why mention only Spain? When compared with Amerika, Amerika did far worse than what Spain did, Amerika committed massacres and genocides just like what the British did, was racist towards Filipinos, and we got involved in WW2 because of Amerika, and we are still fuc.ked and still a US lapdog. Spain did nothing like that, No massacres and genocides. 🤣 Tapos special mention lang ang Spain??? Lupit mo ha.
So we should all hate the British living today because of something their ancestors did? Don’t be so stupid.
Yeah it was so terrible that thousands of Indians flocked to the UK each month! Stop it.
@@markmower1746The UK, knows better than to further that racist mindset these days. India and Pakistan are both more than capable of reducing the UK, to cinders.
I was a 4 years old when I saw this movie and this scene had deep imprints on my minds for many years. Many a times this scene terrified me during my sleep for few years. I wonder what these people had gone through when they saw death before them with no way to escape
Animated Story on partition of India
th-cam.com/video/1okXmLObHRE/w-d-xo.html
@@fab5818 By British.
First India was united. But the British partitioned in it and created problems.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partition_of_India
The plan for Indian independence was set in 1934. India would be fully independent by 1950 and would be a federal republic of majority Moslem states and majority Hindu states living side by side. It was Indian politicians whose intolerance caused partition, intolerance that is happening again.
you know theres 6 years old enslaved in India right now by Indians, do you ever think about them.