Tap to unmute
Jallianwala Bagh massacre (movie gandhi)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.ค. 2025
- I GIVE CREDITS TO MAKERS OF (GANDHI) MOVIE;
i talked with them.https:
amzn.to/2GwIHAF
amzn.to/2gf7Kk3
The Jallianwala Bagh massacre, also known as the Amritsar massacre, took place on 13 April 1919 when a crowd of nonviolent protesters, along with Baishakhi pilgrims, who had gathered in Jallianwala Bagh, Amritsar, Punjab, were fired upon by troops of the British Indian Army under the command of Colonel Reginald Dyer...
affiliate involved
I am a History Professor at a college and I teach my students using this scene (thank you Dhritesh). I tell my students every time that whatever credibility the British government had before the "Amritsar Massacre" quickly evaporated due to this tragedy. After this horrific even, India's independence was assured. Although I am not Indian, I love the country and plan on continuing to teach its wonderful history!
Thanks a lot Sir I also love a lot of things that Britain did like rule of law, Democratic institutions in India and a lot of other advancements but this act was totally 'Not British' a act like Stalin,Mao or Hitler would have done. However it was in the past we should forget and forgive like Gandhi would have done. Lots of respect from India.
Makes me ashamed to be British.
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳love from India sir
We respect to the people like you sir who stick with the truth.
@@chintanvyas9074 i hope you are not an Indian
With this mindless massacre, the UK lost all moral authority. This was the beginning of the end of the British Empire.
And they try to make themselves look like heroes by overplaying how Churchill fought against Hitler.
And even then, Churchill was losing badly and only succeeded holing up in Britain to defend its skies.
All this despite getting 5 times more material and monetary support from Americans than the Soviets, who successfully pushed right into Berlin, unlike the Brits.
Yeah I guess it's better than Axis Japan playing nuclear victim try to hide how they *invaded, raped, conscripted, eaten (even George HW Bush almost got eaten in Chichijima, its why he threw up on their Prime Minister in 1992 when they were eating sushi because 8 of his wingmen were chopped up and eaten like that), killed, experimented, gassed all those people in Vietnam, Singapore, Malaysia, China, Indonesia, Australia, Korea, Philippines, and Micronesia (the natives were so glad the Americans saved them from Japan, they hold cargo cults in their honor to this day).* Even hide how they too, like Nazis, were developing nuclear weapons, but were too slow compared to the Manhattan Project. And how they got flyers warning them specific cities and dates of bombing but the government told them to get back to making weapons and ignore American lies. Or how Japan bombed civilians as early 1938 in China, in Chongqing.
The British Empire did not have any morality in the very first place.
India too did to the same sikhs in 1984 and Kashmir now
@@CrabTastingMan ever heard of history fabrication
@@waverider1674 no they didn't. Atleast not un Kashmir. If govt was hard it would have broken them by now
In 1984 govt didn't directly game orders. Some pissed off leaders conspired and let the public had it
Today its 100 years of this tragedy. Salute to the martyred...🇮🇳
Salute From Angola ..
Yes brother.
Anonymous Creature th-cam.com/video/YW8BhH-PC5k/w-d-xo.html
Jai ho Jai hind Jai Bharat
Noscoped
This is a rare instance of a film reenactment of a historical violent event where there is no exaggeration. If anything, the real life event was even worse. It's absolutely insane.
All history aside, this sequence is so amazingly shot and directed. The acting, the set pieces, the costumes, the cinematography. It doesn’t feel like a movie at all. It genuinely feels like you’re watching a piece of history.
Yess
watch the movie Sardar Udham if you can handle it. Far better and more impactful depiction of this massacre in the final 45 min. So Gut-wrenching.
this line "ALL HISTORY BESIDE"
@@iamlalisasstylist1796 aside. Not beside. Aside means disregard. Beside means in the general left or right of something.
@@kookookachu26 oh okk
"General, how does a child, shot with a .303 Lee Enfield, apply for help?"
That line has stuck with me since I first saw this movie in school.
Agree. That Line has some impact.
Few lines in cinematic history compare to that.
Strange that this is a British made movie how many countries make movies portraying themselves as the bad guys.
That is the one huge difference between a democratic society and the authoritarian regimes.
It leaves a vent.
@@harding10B its not really portraying themselves, its portraying the people who allowed this to happen referring, the general British public were outraged, Winston Churchill called it 'unutterably monstrous.'
1 minutes peace for those who have died.
Yeah, Sangita
yes we have to do
They Will never die, they will always live in our mind and heart ❤
Jai Hind🇮🇳🇮🇳
@Iraj Pandey why 100 years pagal ho kya🙄
@@Nelson_Muntz-i7s wt other work do u guys have other than drinking, smoking and spreading hate!?
Dyer, the man in command, Rudyard Kipling called, the man who saved the British Empire. He also started a benevolent fund for Dyer, which he later tried to distance himself from after all the facts came out and Britain was in outrage. Even ultra imperialist Churchill and Minster of War at the time, stated it was "an episode without precedent or parallel in the modern history of the British Empire… an extraordinary event, a monstrous event, an event which stands in singular and sinister isolation... the crowd was neither armed nor attacking".
So much for being a civilized country -
@@AllanMogensen. Winston would later say Himself “That It Was the Indians Fault for Breeding like Rabbits” During the Bengal Famine🤦🏿🤦🏿🤦🏿🤦🏿🗑️🗑️🗑️🗑️
@@AllanMogensenThe majority of India is in poverty. More civilised than they will ever be.
@@averagejoe8358 Which must be why the Indian economy is now larger than ours. Average by name, average by intellect it seems.....
@Saj-cz8io Yeah, through cheap labour from people living in squalor. I've been to Mumbai, the conditions honestly apalled me. Never again.
I visited this place last year and to my surprise the bullets holes are still there on the wall.. Shocking and sad😢
Yes me too, when I visited Amritsar a few years ago, I too saw the bullet holes and the well where people jumped to save themselves.
Goes to show how far these idiots have come. lol. They cannot even clean up after.
MOOSEDOWNUNDER oh look a British sympathizer, they didn’t clean the bullet holes to remember the history of this massacre.
sad😢😢😢😢
@@MOOSEDOWNUNDER shutup
The only punishment Dyer ever got was being removed from command
He got full pension till his death. House of Lords and many British subjects supported Dyre's actions and even raised 30,000 pounds to help him financially. He is termed a 'Hero' in British history. Stangely, Winston Churchill who is considered anti-India condemned his actions and demanded action against him, but the Parliamentarians refused.
And there were people that called him "the man that saved Punjab"!!
@@nakulsharma7725 It was a Propaganda started by Dyre himself by colluding with the Sikh religious leaders. The leaders declared Dyre a sikh. That's why the other sikhs started the Gurudwara reform movement to get rid of these corrupt religious leaders.
@@roshansingh1623 just came here after watching the movie
@@samiulislam1791 me too
One thing this movie omits is the sheer outrage the massacre caused back in England, the officer was subsequently court martialed
I do not think he was court martialed, he was allowed to resigned.
@@stevenmarler5154 he was court martialed and forced to resign its just court martialing worked differently back then
@@kekistaniempire8910 I have checked four different sources and they all support what I said. I stand by what I said.
@@stevenmarler5154 well he was and it may not of been called court martialing but he did face legal consequences
@kekistaniempire8910 A court martial is a more respectable legal process I think where actual punishments are rendered to the accused.
the portrayal of Dyer as remorseless, numb, and intense is impactful acting in the film. Dyer was described as unfeeling to their suffering, and pretty much hated the thought of being seen a coward before the crowd. Their is so much division by historians by such a heartless man who very well landed on the wrong side on history, especially when remembering the courage of Gandhi and his people.
Based
The curfew imposed by Dyer after the massacre, enforced by the threat of death by shooting, prevented wounded from being collected; thus many died of their wounds that night. Dyer was compelled to resign and retire from military service, and moved to Britain (he was born in Punjab, educated in Ireland) a broken and unhappy man. Historians have written that he carried the weight of the massacre on his soul, even as he had convinced himself he was right in ordering it. He died in 1927, sick, stroke-stricken, and haemorrhagic. Michael O'Dwyer, the Lieutenant Governor of Punjab in 1919, and just as lethally convinced as Dyer of a non-existent rebellion at Jallianwala Bagh, was a racist who believed in freedom for whites, but not for Indians; he fared little better than Dyer. Recalled to Britain in 1920, O'Dwyer spent the next twenty years seeking to sanitize himself and his legacy in supporting the massacre; he had numerous supporters, who styled both O'Dwyer and Dyer as 'Saviour Of The Punjab', including a former Viceroy, Lord Curzon, whose own career as a statesman was in steep decline. While transitioning from White Nationalism to Pro-Naziism in 1940, O'Dwyer was shot to death by a witness and survivor of the massacre, Udham Singh. Singh, involved in revolutionary politics since 1924, had come to the notice of British Intelligence as early as 1934, having escaped Punjab to England via Germany. Singh was tried, convicted, and hanged in 1940, and is today revered as a martyr and hero of Indian Independence; his statement to the court, following his conviction, was finally published in 1996. The massacre helped mainstream Indian Nationalism and the independence movement, which was achieved in 1948. Recent renovations to Jallianwala Bagh have caused some controversy, though it remains a popular tourist site, memorial, and pilgrimage, as well as a nice place to rest, either before, or after, visiting the Golden Temple of Amritsar, itself the site of a violent crackdown on Sikh militants by the government of India in 1984, resulting in hundreds of deaths, and ultimately resulting in the death, by shooting, of Indira Gandhi, Prime Minister of India, daughter of Jawaharlal Nehru, one of the architects of Indian independence. Today Hindu nationalism is on the rise in India, encouraged by Hindu-centric politicians intent on repeating the mistakes of India's troubled past. And so it goes.
He was an evil Pshycopath.
What courage? Why the fuck should I care about "ghandi", let alone any Brit or White person?
The division among historians is a jewish one, jews hate this, normal White people who get the context love this
May God bless Udam Singh!
James Garcia .anand.pal
@@deependradeependra2712 Thank you. I have been to Jalian Wala Bagh. Though I am not Indian, the place brought years to my eyes to think of the the massacre. After that day in 1919, the British lost any semblance of moral standing they might have had. When Udam Singh was executed he immediately ascended into the pastures of heaven. When Singh killed Gen. O'Dywer, the General went immediately to Hell.
@@jamesgarcia2040 This was justified.
@@jamesgarcia2040 Lieutenant-Governor Michael O'Dwyer was assassinated by Udham Singh. Colonel (temporary rank of brigadier-general at the time of the massacre) Reginald Dyer, who is depicted in this clip, had already passed by the time Udham Singh made his way to the UK.
Yes.
I really feel very sad on the ppl who sacrificed their life for our freedom. Big salute
Anil Kumar sad thing is that they were not knowing this would happen because it was nonviolence protest and British given answer with violent act !
We have to give blood to be free !! Not by nonviolence move ! In this way Bagath Singh and Subash Chandra Bose and others are great !!
They didn't sacrifice their lives voluntarily. This isn't something to feel proud about. I can only sense dread and despair in this.
@@maheshbengarkar1354 right sir …!
@sreelekha k.r Care to elaborate?
@@cheems2633 just shut you mouth you sh*t
My grandfather's kinsman was also there but he was saved then. My grandfather told this whole story to us.
I am from Punjab, 🇵🇰.
same here, thank lord my grandma escaped into Britain at that time and didn't have a single chance of being there
@@PG-hc7nb nah nah we were richer than Britain all u did was steal our shit and run like cowards
@@PG-hc7nb india contributed 25 percent to the world economy before british came....atleast this was more the 2 percent contributed by britain
@@punjabiman596 she went to Britian or she left Britian?
@@mrcool2107 she went into britain with her husband for work that had an ok pay
I wonder if someone said to him “Congratulations, you have lost us India” if that would have provoked a reaction of any regret.
He basically was told this during the inquiry and he held no remorse. He was discharged from the military over it and it caused a lot of backlash in England.
If i'm not mistaken, the script for the questioning of General Dyer is lifted directly from the real hearing's transcripts.
It is. And even as someone who would be considered a "hard-right conservative" by modern standards, my immediate reaction is to stand up and scream "WHAT THE ABSOLUTE F-CK WERE YOU *THINKING?!*"
The Irish man Dyer friend of de Valera
@@edcarson3113 Stop lying Edward, he was born in india and went to university in ireland.
@@JCarey1988You still have time to change and realise the conservatives and their values have destroyed our country.
@@GivemetheGravy some day youll grow up and realize being a Reddit liberal was just an embarassing part of being young.
Fun fact: The British soldiers in this scene were Gurkha Riflemen from Nepal. So massacring Indians as ordered would be indifferent to them.
They look like Chindits.
They weren't all Gurkhas, there were also Indian soldiers there. Sadly my knowledge of the Indian Army is not deep enough for me to identify their regiment.
Police forces and armies, around the world, have a track record of 'following orders'. We see it under fascism, communism, colonialism, no matter the regime, going right back into antiquity.
Yep ..no native brits were involved ...the soilders gurkhas , the govener of the province was an irishman ...the officer who gave the order to fire was born in india ....
He was no Irishman, he was a Brit born in Ireland.@@martinmanifold2241
This massacre is embedded in every Indians memories,we shall never ever forget and forgive....Jai Hind.
I will why can’t we stop seeing them as enemies they can’t be blamed for something other people did
@@Mylifesuckslol Who is blaming people living there today? We hate the British empire, get lost, sepoy.
@@doctorgamez2410 I hate the empire too the person said never forget which is fair but never forgive is too far
@@Mylifesuckslol No, they shouldn’t be forgiven for this, because it was done and they have barely made a half assed apology. Doesn’t mean we can’t have good relations with them. We can work together and recognize past wrongdoings.
@@doctorgamez2410 He probably means never forgive the brits even in their current state with the empire all but gone
As an Australian in the trucking industry, I work with and cross paths with a lot of Indians, and I have to say, of all the demographics of migrants I have known over the years, it'd be hard to find any group of people as hard-working and immediately friendly as they are. Given the opportunity or special occasion, they'll gladly share their lunch with you, and having grown up on the wrong side of the tracks among my own people who were violent and abusive, I value the kindness and contribution of the Indians even more. So you can well imagine how watching a group of British Imperialists gunning these unarmed people down would make me feel. It's incomprehensible.
Thank you very much for your kind gesture Sir.
"We must have the courage to take their anger"
Maybe if the British had taken that approach - if they’d just kept administering justice fairly whenever the radicals attacked them - then maybe they wouldn’t have lost India.
@@TheWchurchill4pm So kind of you to refer to Freedom Fighters of my nation as "radicals".
Today, it serves no purpose to hate. The purpose is education by all involved so that such a thing does not happen again. The number 1 take away is that under no circumstances should anyone kill unarmed innocent people especially your own countrymen. India as well as many other countries have this shame in their past. So look forward not backwards and heal yourself.
Shikh dhurm k logo ne bahut kurbaniyan di hai is Desh k liye
Shikh dhurm jindabad
But hey, Sikhs don't believe in a caste system. The Indian Armed Forces commanders have far too many Sikhs compared to other groups. In armed forces only the military success should count. Meritocracy, Sir!
Ha brother salute
@@cintulator2 fuck- fc = UK
Shikh ko mai dil se salam karta hu
@Home Lander Muslim ne Kuch Nahi kiya
Salute to bhagat Singh and his friends.
Udham singh
@@PG-hc7nb who kicked out indians out of the train and used railway to transport free goods from india to britain.....still salute???
Inquilab Zindabad
I'm an Englishman. I was a soldier.
This was not soldiering. It was brutal, cowardly slaughter and shall forever be a stain upon my nation and although I wasn't born when it took place, I am profoundly sorry.
The Public school system in England, at that time, and to a slightly lesser extent now, was a factory producing a class of barbarous individuals, who believed it was their right to take and control by force anything they wished for their own benefit, and to hold anyone not of that group in distain and as worthless.
I met a scottish guy in Canada and he still beleives Britishers came to civilize Indians :)
You can't spell Gary without " G A Y "
@theimmortalgrenadier3851 and you evidently can't have a thought without turning to homosexuality.
I guarantee you receive sugar britches, and can't give because you lack potency.
Just take care of your entrance and use plenty of lube.
@jamesbarlow4474 I'm erudite, but all I need say is that you're an idiot.
If you haven't already bred, I'll pay for your vasectomy.
Sadly not all soldiers think this way, but they exist in every country - soldiers willing to commit war crimes. American soldiers, Russian soldiers, British soldiers, german soldiers... of course, there are good soldiers out there as well, like yourself. But, still sad it happens.
We watched this movie in my global studies class and this scene almost made me cry. The little girl crying next to her dead mother especially hit me. It's so disgusting and heartbreaking that violence like this exists and that this whole event even happened
Life is cruel you know 😢
Have u seen... Sardar udham.... Movie???
Its highly unlikely that the soldiers fired without first being attacked by the mob, and its also not likely that they kept firing after the mob dispersed, nor likely that women and children were in the mob too. Don't confused a Hollywood anti-imperialist movie for a real camera on the scene telling the whole truth. This defies common sense and human nature. That little girl you are emotionally struck by likely never existed.
"Иди и смотри" не смотрели!?
Watch this Scene in the "Udham Singh " movie.
Just knowing this was done to my own people hurts me. Some of the people who were killed that tried to run away were not cowards. Some were people who tried to be home with their family, others were moms seeking safety for their kids, and some were loyal husbands to their wifes and loyal wifes to their husbands.
You are not a coward if you try to escape from dying foolishly
@@doubleOsable isn't British word is a stain itself
@@doubleOsable Yet I see a lot of your people being Racist and celebrating the massacre.
Not learned a lot haven't they??
We will take revenge
@@doubleOsable easy for you to say when you come from the side of the oppressor.
The way this scene has been captured in Sardar Udham movie, watching that will surely bring tears in one's eyes
How much the Britain contributed to India laws railroads brings tears to ones eyes
Don't want such Roads, rails in terms of oppression. #FckU #FckBritain
@@PG-hc7nb ofcourse, this brings tear to eyes that they build those roads and railways to transport jewels to port
@@PG-hc7nb what contribution they make railway for their own benefit you people brainwashed by white india was a rich country after china britishers came here looted our wealth and destroy our economy and take heavy tax from poor people
@@PG-hc7nb lmao yeah right... They contributed... More like we did... They charged 2x the money required to build normal railroads... Putting millions of dollars into the project from the pockets of poverty stricken indians... Some contribution tht was... Using private contractors from Britain.. Instead of the indians to purposely increasing cost and dont even get me started on trying to match consumer demand cause they didn't even try.. You got nothing to defend your glorified empire with... Just gtfo and stop embarrassing yourself
This Jalianwala Bagh scene was shot in the playground of the then Delhi College/ Anglo Arabic School on Ajmeri Gate Delhi. I have been a student here from 1971 to 74.
Dyer suffered numerous strokes in the last few years of his life, which resulted in paralysis and speech impairment. He died in 1927 from a cerebral haemorrhage. Perhaps it was divine punishment.
Ironic how the British condemned Hitler's 3rd Reich when there were officers in their own army as bad as him... he was willing to kill unarmed civilians as mercilessly as the SS were unarmed Jews.
@@nahor88 "History is written by victors"
@@nahor88 It was policy by the German government to deliberately murder a whole race of people.It absolutely was not government policy by the British government to murder the Indian's.Don't try to compare the two.
@@Anglo_Saxon1 First of all indian is not a race but nationality .
Second of all the British is responsible of the deaths of at least a billion people in India. They thought of themselves a "necessity" because they believed indians to be beggars who did not deserve the wealth and resources. They looted . Everything Britain had and has is made from the suffering and pain of others
@@Anglo_Saxon1 the entire South Asian continent suffered over 2.7 Billion deaths under British rule for 200 years...
Wanna elaborate on that???
The saddest thing is that the soldiers firing upon our brothers in Jallianwala Bagh were Indians themselves.
I think they were Gurkhas from Nepal.
They were Gurkhas from Nepal... not indian
He recruited Gurkhas and ppl from Baloch for this to ensure the soldiers firing had no sympathy for those being fired
@@aaheliroy7769 Who is "he?"
@@Tarnatos14 General Reginald Dyer
i am proud of being Punjabi. I love my forefathers for their sacrifice for the country.
Animated Story on partition of India
th-cam.com/video/1okXmLObHRE/w-d-xo.html
U should proud of being bhartiye sir .....state devied us
@@govindkumarraj9426 so why there are states remove all the states why haryana and punjab was divided in 1966
@@HarmanSingh-hm4zt it's just a significant ..don't we just one ...counting only our house ..isn't a option buddy ...think about it ...there r lots of propegenda out there to cut us
I salute them I also love sikhs
A remarkable level of moviemaking. From the correct WW1-period armored car that can't pass the narrow doorway, to the clearly recognizable Sikh and Gurkha soldiers, to the foreshadowing of Martyr's Well at 3:48 and the clever circumvention of the (still unknown, and unknowable) number of dead vs wounded by simply using the word "casualties", this movie is the product of a truly scholarly level of background research.
Knowing the fact that it’s 102 yrs old still breaks my heart even today 😭😭😭😭
Knowing the fact that Britain built railroads in India still warms my heart.
@@PG-hc7nb don't u feel shame oh ofc u don't coz u Britishers will never be kind to us, right?
@@iamlalisasstylist1796 Yes we civilized you otherwise yall wouldve been as poor as africa eejit
@@PG-hc7nb oh wow what a big pleasure right? damn it, we dint's have any technology in India before ur general and blah blah blah's rule but we became INDEPENDENT after 1947 as u know what happened that year so anyways, we have many gadgets in India, why? coz u guys are not still telling us that what are do's and don't's, so accept it as your queen eliza eliza accepted it!!!
@@iamlalisasstylist1796 Accepted what, that we developed India?
Imagine if the armoured car was brought in, equipped with just one Vickers machine gun or if the soldiers were equipped with fully automatic submachine gun, it would be an unimaginable horror.
Oh yes
Even worse, if they had self-loading rifles or bren or Lewis lmg's
Sub machine guns are already fully automatic
The horror is still no less imaginable…even now with 1500+ unarmed casualties who here are shown all unarmed
Oh like it wasn't already
I am a teacher from south India. In the 1980s when I was studying middle class when my History teacher narrated the incident I was moving with pain in my heart for many weeks. Those days no TV or any kind of visual aids to learn about things. But the visualization which I had on those days exactly correlates with the above.
Have u seen.... Sardar udham... Movie...?????
You know this is Hollywood propaganda and not likely historically accurate, right? Its far more likely that several warnings were issued, the crowd rushed to attack believing in superior numbers, and forced the soldiers to defend themselves. That's how it has gone in almost all of these "massacres" around the world in so many different cultures.
Worse things happened in South India babu Palackal. In Vellaloor in Tamil nadu more than 5000 as per official records and 12, 000 as per unofficial records were killed by British captain Rumley for refusing to pay taxes. No one would have heard of it because NCERT books blackout this massacre and make a big issue of 379 people killed. Captain Rumley was imprisoned at Arnee, for this massacre by the East India company. He was then moved to Seringapatam & murdered by poison in 1783 on the orders of Tipu Sultan during the Second Anglo-Mysore War (1780-1784)
Reminds me of a line from one of the greatest sci fi movies of all time. "Soldiers deserve soldiers, sir"
Tears bursted through my eyes after watching this... 😭😭😭
Acha
I’m laughing at the fact that a enfield wouldn’t hold that much rounds being fired without reloading
watch Sardar Udham if you can handle it. Far better and more impactful depiction of this massacre in the final 45 min.
Tears bursted after the Indians aren't thanking us for all the good things we did
😂😂😂
that kid's face gave me tears 😭😢😩
You tell us widows had childrens too how ruthlessly your culture had been throwing widows into fire.
th-cam.com/video/XAc2KiDusQc/w-d-xo.html
How did you ruthlessly killed lower caste peoples for entering in temples and you'd been killing millions of millions widows since the beginning killed a lot of peoples alive and killed a lot of girls by ur dangerous culture
In same way everything happened with all bymut just thousands of people died
*God see everything*
Get happy if General Diar didn't shooted peoples so India would never be independent none's eye would open
Ur Freedom fighters like Gandhi ji etc worked for Britian first.
Watch in to video how britishers saved ur millions of millions girls
Somehow God made happened what God wants to be happened and India's whole money was taken away and was made apoor country
@@pokemonhunter8418 wth
@Indian Atheist Our religion hasn't any caste system and we don't believe in any kinda blackfaith therefore we are christans.
✝️✝️✝️✝️✝️✝️
@Indian Atheist lool
*You are more stupid than you look*
As I said we don't believe in any blackfaith.
So we just feel ashamed for our commited sins, What we have never commited.
Improve your mentality.
What can be expected you to say .😂.
@Indian Atheist You all carry on crying for the past
A heartly and proudly Salute to SARDAAR UDHAM SINGH JI
Who is that ? New shopkeeper?
@@mrcool2107 he was the hero of our country who killed tha lousy general Dyer
@@mrcool2107 he was ur daddy
@@mrcool2107 your mum's sugar daddy
@@myindia4553 dyer wasn't assassinated it was Dwyer bruh cmon get yo facts right
An young 7 year old Bhagat Singh, visited the Jalianwalabagh took some soil and vowed to take revenge. It marked the beginning of the end of the British Empire
I guess the saddest line uttered was, "General, how does a child shot with a 303 Lee Enfield apply for help?" 😢
Something worth remembering is that this massacre horrified Churchill, who did not, to be as diplomatic as possible, advocate a "gentle hand" policy with Britain's colonial subjects. So you can imagine how horrified everyone else was.
You know it says a lot when someone like Churchill thought Dyer had gone too far.
he was so horrified when the Bengal famine started he said" Beastly people with a beastly religion, ihate them" hasn`t Gandhi starved yet ? NO american ships with supplies for them!
@@michaelpielorz9283 never said that last part, thats a lie
@@Mythee. He said it was the Indians fault for Breeding like Rabbits🤦🏿🤦🏿🤦🏿🤦🏿
@Kaltagstar96 says Churchill who sent the black and tans to ireland
Watching this movie in Religion class, this is the moment everybody took the film seriously. It was amazing how the class went from making jokes, to fully engaged for the rest. When the film started, people giggled when Ghandi was shot, at the end, they cried.
Have u ever heard about... Sardar udham..... Movie????
True sir.
Lucky you have Indian religion classes. Even though I’m a Hindu, my school forces me to learn about Catholicism and pray to that religion. Sometimes non Catholics get in big trouble at my school just for being a different religion. I hope that someday my school will correct itself and treat all religions equally.
@@TRGRobloxGodbro it happens in christian convent schools 😂that's their propoganda
I could definitely understand how the transition of emotions could change for the audience.
4:21 this reminds of that one scene in squid game where all the players are just trying to get through the gate in Redlight greenlight but are getting shot by the pink soldiers.
Ur right
and the irony is that the West look at the colonies and call them Barbarians..
Well who were the ones who opened fire? Westerners or Barbarians?
@@okeng71487 who were the ones who don't women vote for 100 years
@@johnjacobastoriv688 west. India allowed women vote starting from independence
@@samarpreetsingh1052 thanks India later
@@okeng71487 , The Barbarians opened fire
"Civilized" British in action
True
I see a single British commander and hordes of loyal brown skinned soldiers obeying his orders.
@@okeng71487 thise are gorkhos Nepalese
Not punjabi
Brits have a property of dividing people first Scots with Catholics then Arab with Israel
@Indian Atheist No. Hitler was not innocent. The people who collaborate with him are equally guilty.
@Indian Atheist The blame cannot be on the British alone. Indians are equally responsible.
143 years later and the imperial British still hadn't learned a thing.
Their karma has caught up with them.
And it's only been a hundred years since this took place
101 years
@@lordcharlesthomas and what did the British do to a island 4000 miles away from their island. idk a full millitary invasion?
Shut the fuck up with your Stone Age country what do you mean we haven’t learned a thing you dickhead
And yet, after this Dyer had no more trouble in the region...
If you haven't watched it, you must watch Gandhi. Directed by Richard Attenborough (brother of David Attenborough, the naturalist) it is truly a masterpiece.
Thank you for the recommendation, I will check it out
Así es. Y con una actuación soberbia de Ben Kingsley como Gandhi 👍👍👍
I was a little concerned that it was their other Attenborough (the naturist)
No it's not . The lead role of "Ghandhi" is played by a white guy? He tanned himself to become brown. They should have cast an Indian actor.
@@chandaniberry9369 Ben Kingsley is of Indian descent lmfao, his real name is Krishna Pandit Bhanji
I was a 4 years old when I saw this movie and this scene had deep imprints on my minds for many years. Many a times this scene terrified me during my sleep for few years. I wonder what these people had gone through when they saw death before them with no way to escape
Animated Story on partition of India
th-cam.com/video/1okXmLObHRE/w-d-xo.html
@@fab5818 By British.
First India was united. But the British partitioned in it and created problems.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partition_of_India
The plan for Indian independence was set in 1934. India would be fully independent by 1950 and would be a federal republic of majority Moslem states and majority Hindu states living side by side. It was Indian politicians whose intolerance caused partition, intolerance that is happening again.
you know theres 6 years old enslaved in India right now by Indians, do you ever think about them.
Love from Pakistan I read full history of Jallianwala bagh and I salute to Ram Muhammad Singh Azad (Udham Singh) for took revenge our people may Allah his soul rest in peace
Britain is cruel bro
@@notyourtypefan7743 mughal also
We are brothers .
@@Wandererofpeace5175 you absolutely cannot state Mughals to be as cruel as the British empire...infact, the empire went far beyond just "cruel"...Mughals (majority of them) were just the same as the Peshwas or Guptas, except they came from a different country...they wanted to rule over India, settle here and flourish its economy...yes, there were some who condemned different religions, but none of them ever came with that intent...all of the Hindu Muslim division bullshit came from the British...also, Bahadur Shah Zafar played a major role in the Revolt of 1857
So don't say that the Mughals were cruel, because they were just the same as most dynasties and empires that were from India and ruled over the nation before the Brits came and all hell broke loose
@@Wandererofpeace5175 the later Mughal, I'd say after Akbars sons were the weakest of the bunch
I've seen this movie three times, and the massacre scene still makes me cry.
Today is 102 anniversary of this masacre 😢😢😢rip to all people who dead in this masacre
Today Its 102 Years Of This Unforgettable And Tragedy Day . Salute To All Martyreds May Their Souls Rest In Peace Jai Hind Jai Bharat .
Meh
Meh
It's a most horrific and heart touching incident that no Indians can never forget in their life.
There were WOMEN and CHILDRENS too😭😭😭
Imagine the trauma even if they survived😭😭
At least they were indians, so no mistake in that
My blood is boiling to see all my people's are dying 😭
@@pokemonhunter8418 👍
@@pokemonhunter8418 even the most educated person cant understand this sentence like oml...fix ur grammar
@Indian Atheist not more than u,
You're more stupid AF than you look.
Therefore that's nonsense to u.
@@pokemonhunter8418 MAN, U THINK I AM BLIND? I JUST EDITED IT MORON!
@@pokemonhunter8418 u mean ur entire paragraph was a typo? no shit-sherlcok
A superb film which treats the historical mindlessness of tragic events such as this one with dignity and respect. The questioning of the general, after the incident, and the silence in the film when the general delivers his answers reflects the severity of the tragedy. The final question "General, how does a child, shot with a .303 Lee Enfield, apply for help?" - and the silence which follows - still resonates with me and reminds me of the brilliance of the scriptwriters and editors of the film. The author of the screenplay, John Briley, was a justifiable winner of the Academy Award, one of the eight that the film won (including Best Film, Director and Actor).
Whenever I think about this Jallianwala bagh incident I fell very bad because hundreds of people were killed in this incident😭😭
Ummmm...nobody is reloading. They found the infinite ammo glitch in the matrix.
😂
Dosto,
General dyre ke saath 250 soldiers the jisme se 200 soldiers Indian the aur 50 soldiers British.
Agar in 200 Indian soldiers me se sirf 1soldier bhi smjhdar rhta to WO phla goli kispe chlata-
1. Indian PR ya
2.general dyre PR
Gandu.....soilders r stupid brain washed ppl they r designed to kill
Mei hota woh time pe agar ..gen Dyer par chalata aur 2 gali deta
@@MohsinKhan-yr1rd teri aukaat nahi hai kuch bhi krne ki...yaha bhok mat
@@jayantkumarmishra9861 toh teri bohot hai fir .. MISHRA ...BIHARI tappaiye
@@MohsinKhan-yr1rd ha be chutiy3 chakke..meri to tere se jada hai...par tere jaise bhokne walo me se nahi hu main.
Our history teacher answered a student's question on what was inside the well Gandhi was looking into. I didn't even see the blood the first time we watched this in class. She said anyone who went into the well to escape fell to their death. Gandhi was looking upon a pile of bodies.
Perhaps Ghandi should also have looked into the well at Cawnpore.
Iam from USA.. (America)
After watching this movie, i felt very sad for indians. I proud and respect india. India is not my country. But i love it...
Regresa a Inglaterra
Nope, you are not from the US.
So you are from another country that ignores its responsibility for crimes against mankind: Remember the American Natives and Slavery!
Probably not, actually
Proof?@@omg.mesohungry
"my intention was to inflict a lesson on all India" The pure disgust the other man had in his face upon hearing that speaks volumes.
God this is shot so well, I feel choked up watching all the people run. Great work to the director, crew, hundreds of actors/extras for giving light to this horrible tragedy. I hope those people may rest in peace.
I literally cried watching this scene ,the emotions in it , only a true indian can understand
Well remember the British created all the railroads in India and Pakistan too!...
They created railroads for ther advantage to carry raw materials for business , regarding pakistan u know how extend its affecting people till now , they motive from beginning was Muslim hindu separation
@@PG-hc7nb Ok, doesn’t justify this. Most of the progress India made was after independence.
@@PG-hc7nb so? What are you trying to say?
@@nucleophile994 we developed your country granted railways, law, toilets and yall are hating on us like crazy man
It’s upsetting enough just as a movie scene, but knowing this actually happened and being British myself, absolutely breaks my heart
The dark side of colonisation, which we're taught is nothing but "exploration and civilising people"
Eh don't worry, luckily the world's a better place now
Have u seen...... Sardar udham..... Movie????
@@drvirin actual fact, we never, ever, EVER, hear the fucking end of it.
Well get over yourself then.
I wonder what they would have thought that in 75 years later Rishi Sunak would become a British Prime Minister
4:58 oh look i found a psychopath
Not hard to do, infortunately. You just have to look at some of the comments on here.
He is an actor. Don't hate him. He is doing his role😂😂
@@beenadatta5038 If an actor makes you hate a villainous character so much, then the actor has done his job to play the role to perfection
Udham Singh assasinated the man who ordered him in London
Long live Shaheed Udham Singh
🥺🥺 My heart goes out for those children, women & innocent ppl 😞😞😞
Animated Story on partition of India
th-cam.com/video/1okXmLObHRE/w-d-xo.html
Men's 🤔
@@jaisanatanrashtra7035 Sadly no one cares enough about us men's lives 😭
@@aAverageFan For real, hence the new song by Dax th-cam.com/video/tHxip2x-PLc/w-d-xo.html
😣
"There is not curse on entish, elvish or language of man for this treacherous!"
Having visited the site on one of my many trips to India, I was left in tears at the thought of what the victims went through. The general who was court marshalled got off lightly. It was out and out the mass murder of people who had no way out.
Please read the book "Butcher of Amritsar". Brig. Gen Dyer actually was born and lived most of his young life in British India. His long term stay in UK for the first time was when he joined the Military Academy at Sandhurst.
Read about Huseyn Shaheed Suhrawardy the Butcher of Bengal.
@@qmsarge and he developed a distinct disdain & hatred for the natives of that land.
So he wasn't British but rather an Indian .
@@RashidmButt The native troops that he commanded actually liked him and he respected the Indian officers which makes it more bizarre.
I remember when our teacher told us abt this and I started crying this was so in humane us Indians really went through a lot
Did your teacher teach who enacted laws in India?
@@PG-hc7nb so what Thief ?🐷
@@PG-hc7nb yes, it were britishers, Indians didn't even have the power to move resolutions against budgets forget about making legislation.
@@Deekdock British took away our power dumbass, India was called "golden bird" of the world we were called "Vishwa guru" which means world leaders. British made us suffer for more than 100 years, made Indians lives no less than hell and then took away all our resources, you still think you helped us LMFAO
@@PG-hc7nb The oldest written set of laws known to us is the Code of Hammurabi. He was the king of Babylon between 1792 BC and 1758 BC
We iraqian people invited law at the first time
And we invited writings and most of the sciences and mathematics sciences
You British people are just a bunch of thieves and killers and your black history full of killing and stealing from other countries
5:14 That part made me cry.
Same 😭
Lord forgive them...
Более 100 лет Британия грабила Индию. Все нынешние ее богатства - на 70 % оттуда. Насилием подавлялись любые , даже мирные формы протеста , против английских колонизаторов . Народ Индии , до сих пор это помнит и не забыл.....
I'm happy to say that this is currently being taught in Canadian schools for history classes
i wish it were taught in my school, we only learn about the british empire, its getting racist at this point.
How do u know?
What does canada have to do with this? Also why should I care about the enemy 🇮🇳
Sure .. when you have so many khalistani mob running wild all over Canada now !!
In Australia, they're teaching us about the CANADIAN TRUCKERS.
Freedom WILL PREVAIL, it's just going to take a few more sheeple to pull the wool out of their eyes.
We Filipinos, almost all of our grudges against our colonizers especially Spain have disappeared or almost faded away. However, I cannot expect the same thing to Indians for this is extremely brutal. Hope the wound will heal, and British also must understand how hard it is for Indians to accept this painful past.
The racist mind set here is unbelievable. The British press raised forty thousand pounds for this guy when he was sent home after the investigation. So his views were shared by many.
Specially Spain??? HUH??? why mention only Spain? When compared with Amerika, Amerika did far worse than what Spain did, Amerika committed massacres and genocides just like what the British did, was racist towards Filipinos, and we got involved in WW2 because of Amerika, and we are still fuc.ked and still a US lapdog. Spain did nothing like that, No massacres and genocides. 🤣 Tapos special mention lang ang Spain??? Lupit mo ha.
So we should all hate the British living today because of something their ancestors did? Don’t be so stupid.
Yeah it was so terrible that thousands of Indians flocked to the UK each month! Stop it.
@@markmower1746The UK, knows better than to further that racist mindset these days. India and Pakistan are both more than capable of reducing the UK, to cinders.
अंग्रेजो नें ही हिंदु और मुसलमानो का आपस में लड़वाया था और हम आज भी लड़ रहें हैं बहुत अफ़सोस हैं
sahi baat leke aya
Amazing Star yes brother you are right
+vicky dadwal Kohinoor ke liye kuch step Lena chahiye
AAAN KH yes why not
Amazing Star no muslims started it frst
I've seen the entire movie, but I forgot about this scene. It's very powerful.
Yes I’m from south India. This massacre made my blood boil. Colonialism has changed the dynamics of the world. There was a freedom fighter from vishakapatnam who made British piss in their pants. Alluri seetha ram raju. Google his name. All the freedom fighters who used violence, I love them. Bhagat sing, subash Chandra Bose etc. hats off.
We came to know about it through RRR
It's a shame we don't know much about so many of our freedom fighters 😭
you know nothing
yes sure mate. Dream on.
@@jamesbarlow4474 ok coomer ( This is coming from a non-Indian )
Chandra Bose🤣 The man who supported Japam slaughtering 30 million Chinese......don't give me any lectures when you support a despotic murderer like Bose
We reap what we sow. People might forget but time doesn’t. I believe in time.
What has 6 years done to you since you posted this comment
My eyes went numb ...no tears to fall...As a patriot Indian...i condemn this heinous act against humanity. MY MARTYRED COUNTRYMEN , I BOW DOWN TO THEE WITH TEARY EYES
മലയാളികൾ ഒക്കെ ഇങ് പോരട്ടെ... ✨️✨️✨️👍
Dude uyirr😍😍😍
Onnu poda
The armored car not being able to fit through was the best part😂
pagol
We are the world's 4th largest army now.. Don't you dare Britishers
Mr. Jonathan if u r from the so called great Britain u morons made our life miserable by dividing us by creating chaos and a civil war in our country u r forefathers raped our women took our gold and land shot our people treated us as slaves and made a fucking statement that we r sry for what we did to India .... We were living our life peacefully and didn't know what guns and bombs are ......now if u want the war we will bring it to u
...don't think that we r like the middle eastern nations than u can supress by u r sheer force ......u r wrong mr. Wanna take the fight we will bring it to u and u and u r country will be devastated
Note : am an INDIAN born after Independence but the pain I had seen through my grandfathers eyes made and realised what a brutal regime was u r s.....never ever will we forget what u r forefathers did to us
@@ajayk1432 What was the condition of England , say 700 years ago ? They have nothing. They have no resources. They are fully dependant on looting other countries. This plunder is still continuing under the name of Commonwealth. Their museum consists of artifacts looted or plundered from the colonies. They think themselves as the father of this world. They cannot win a single war in fair means. They are always backstabbers.
Dude. You gotta let it go. Worry about the future
@Jonathan [British Imperialist] you don't know that if we Indians show our living standard than you would be living in Hell
Economy of all western countries are run by us if we started boycotting you people there will be nothing left in west
Ajay K I don’t care mate, the empire was good and I’m proud to be British
無知ですみません。これはなんと言う事件ですか？
It happened in the British Raj around 1914 I believe.
@@ssesssusman9417 ありがとうございます。
You have to give credit to the acting and cinematography.
The reaction, accents and mannerisms are quintessentially British, and thus, they all maintain that stiff upper lip, but all the while, you can just _feel_ the abject horror and disturbance in subtle ways. A swallowing of air before a sentence, the subdued, almost bemused bewilderment at another man's inhumanity.
And, of course, the bureaucratic, almost euphemistic answers.
*The Empire pauses for a moment, aghast at its own deeds... Then carries on. On to newer atrocities.*
This is not mere acting ,it is History .
I bet you haven't seen Sardar Udham....
They need to remake this movie. Jallianwala Bagh was the turning point of the British Empire. Yet very few people around the world know about this incident. It needs to be remade with great emphasis shown of this massacre.
There is a movie called 'Sardar Udham' based on Jallianwala Bagh massacre. Udham Singh was a teenager when this happened and it inspired him to be a freedom fighter. He travelled to England and confronted Michael O'dwyer (the governer who ordered this massacre). When he noticed that the former governor doesn't have a slightest bit of regret and considers this massacre as a righteous one, Singh was devastated. He planned his revenge and executed him. Singh was hanged by British government for this act.
The movie is very carefully crafted and can be a tough watch. But it's a very good movie.
Estimates vary but the death toll exceeded 1400 unarmed civilians comprised of men , women and children . This act of barbarism , brutality and racism matches the German atrocities perpetrated on the Jewish people during WW2 . The man who took revenge for this heinous act and paid the ultimate price was then condemned by his own ruling politicians .. Gandhi , Nehru et all . Now , he is a martyr and remembered for his sacrifice and daring to enter the seat of the empire and kill the beast O'Dwyer . RIP Udham Singh
I am Pakistani and I have to say this when this massacre occurred. It was very tragic and the British Empire was going to begin its end. He's probably not in the film but a young Child named Bhagat Singh was there and a witnessed it first hand. Therefore he grew up to be a Revolutionary and he became a Rebel against the British Empire.
I have never not loved seeing Edward Fox on the screen. Even in such a bittersweet scene as this. By "bittersweet" I mean the balanced between the beauty of his acting and the horror of its basis.
I salute that junior officer who requested to issue a warning but was quickly rebuffed... He definitely had some humanity in him... Respect for him...
The junior officer should have relieved the general of command and had him placed under arrest.
@@946towguy2 He didn't dare to...
Even though he knew that he could've taken action himself, he just couldn't...
@@darryldouglasmarbaniang7162to disobey orders means death by firing squad.
that makes him as guilty as the General.@@darryldouglasmarbaniang7162
100 years complete on 13 april 2019 british should apologies #Jaliyawalabaghmassacre
British Prime Minister Theresa May apologized for the Massacre yesterday!
Small but a sure victory for India
@@tanaymehta7212 "REGRET" isn't "Apologize" !!
And words are cheap , blood isn't .
Not defending Theresa May or the people involved in this terrible event 100 years ago, what happened was barbaric, but I agree Britain can't apologise for the events in Amritsar in 1919, otherwise, other countries will demand apologies for past events linked to Britain, in any case don't see other countries like USA apologising to other countries for their roles in terrible events in the past.
Also kohinoor
I am not Fond of what happened 100 years ago, but who should begin with apologies and where does it end? Learning from the past is more important but the harder way. A way that nobody is willing to go.
So what next? The today living English paying compensation? And where does that end? And a good victim always finds a way to be a better victim. Maybe request compensation because the country did not develop because of the English?
Then compensation for amerikas slaves, for the victims of the vikings, the Germans, the Spanish and so on.
This will end up in a never ending story.
At the end of the day, this is just another example of Man's inhumanity to Man. An old story to, unfortunately, be endlessly repeated.
Today we should not blame to Britain or Britain's people becoz they are also feeling shame to that... That was not their mistake... The big mistake was done by their boss in that century... Salute that peoples who sacrifice their lives.. We Love Our INDIA 🇮🇳 🇮🇳🇮🇳💖 Actually their boss was stone hearted 🖤
Ikr I finally found someone with sense they themselves didn’t do it was a dark day for both nations and it was 101 years ago
@Manoj Kumar their national pride was ruined and I never mentioned slavery you dingle
@Manoj Kumar 1 more thing I'm not white cuz I'm Indian
@Manoj Kumar I have Indian parents and citizenship your point?
@Manoj Kumar I don’t need to be born in that hellhole to be Indian I was born somewhere which isn’t hell on earth and explain how I’m not Indian if I (reluctantly) can speak some Hindi, have citizenship and have Indian parents who were born there?
13/04/1919 - Today it marks the 104th anniversary of this Barbaric & inhuman brutality!!
The Bright Day which was turned into a Black Day by Britishers, continues to haunt and boil Indians blood..
This massacre will still remain one of the most brutal act done by colonials.
Salute & tribute to the martyrs of Jallianwala Bagh🙏
And millions of thanks to Sardar Udham Singh Ji that he made sure the culprit to remember what they've done to India.🙌
Your bright day was the beginning of an attack on the Sikh's Holy of Holies, a determined attempt by a mob of 15,000 - yes, including women and children - to destroy the temple because (they said) it was built on the site of a Hindu temple. If the troops had not fired on the mob then the temple might have been destroyed leading to a civil war as the Sikhs took revenge. That is why the general is regarded as a saint by the Sikhs. And leave off the insults - I am Irish and we had our own beef with the British Empire.
Yes, this was a brutal and unnecessary act but to say this one incident stopped the huge benefits that India gained through colonialism is absurd. Have you actually looked into what Indians were doing to other Indians at the time? How about when a husband dies their wife was burnt alive - 'sati' I believe it's called, is that not barbaric and inhuman? This practice was stopped by 'colonials'. Would you still like to see that happen today? And this is just one instance of humanity that colonialism brought. Strange how modern society always just wants to remember the bad things of colonialism and not the much bigger benefits...
@@Mk1Male I would like to add that the soldiers that actually fired their weapons at these poor people look to be Indian/Gurka troops
that is not being mentioned in the comments
Uddham Singh killed O Dwyer not Dyer who died of brain hemorrhage
@@Mk1Male
Can't believe even today's Brits believe they colonised India and other colonies to help them😂
From what I read, the general here who commanded the attack was force to resign yet the British empire awarded him a huge retirement cheque to live out his life. And till he died he showed absolutely no remorse.
And bhagat singh shot only one British they gave him dealth penalty . Hypocrite.
Reginald Dyer was presented with a cheque from a British newspaper for £26,000 which was raised by pro imperialist supporters.
Churchill (then War Minister) wanted Dyer punished but was prevented as the army allowed Dyer to retire quietly.
Churchill himself referred to the massacre as “monstrous”. The Prime Minister, Asquith called it “one of the worst outrages in the whole of our history”.
However, the fact that the man who oversaw it was never punished, adds to the outrage. But unfortunately this is repeated several times in our history.
This is what happens when the state has guns and the people don't. vote carefully.
I never heard of this tragic incident, as a Canadian citizen it sickens me of the terrible crime against humanity.
The British eletes/leaders at their finest....anything to retain control.
@wahhwahhbunchababies Yes of course. they were warned about speaking. how dare they speak! it's best in such situations to kill everyone including children. you are an actually monster. you would have shot those children down as well. How dare you defend the Brits for this crime?
@wahhwahhbunchababies Now replace the Indians with Jews & the British with Desutchland & see how the hypocrisy settles in.
Similarly replace the Indians with Ukranians & the British with Russians/Soviets committing cleansing.
Who cares
@@Leviathan762-zh4lq It seems you cared enough to reply. Also love your pfp :>