I am so glad Geoffrey Rush played the role of David Helfgott. I found it very moving, sad, funny, so many...he was brilliant and deserved that award. No one else could have done it other than him. He was sensitive, passionate and brought out David's character so it made you rivoted to the screen. I loved it so much I didn't want the movie to end. I love classical music and the people talented enough to compose and play such works of art. Although, I wish David hadn't experienced his troubles, I appreciate him for the 'true' human being inside and his beautiful heart. He is God's gift in so many ways. Thank you Mr. Helfgott and Mr. Rush for being the true life story and the other; on-screen story=brilliance!!!
I met him some years ago - came over to have a chat in a small town - talked but also muttered confirmations the whole time - one of this world's oddities!
@@guitaroso this is the third time I've heard of someone having met him in a small town & the muttering. Sounds to me like he wasn't really acting in the movie, just turned up and muttered. Oh well, I'm not going to wish bad on the phony.
I saw this movie when I was eleven. I loved every single minute of it and, till these days, it still makes me feel incredibly emotional. Talent is sometimes hidden in the most unexpected people, and I just love that. Jeffrey's performance is something else, another true talent there.
Having watched the film and been quite moved by the performance and story, it's quite emotional to see the subject of the film perform so well, receive adulation and yet bare the scars quite publicly of what still remains of his dark past.
I live near David and had the privilege of seeing him perform a few years ago. Ironically, about 10 years or so ago, I saw Geoffrey Rush back in Melbourne. He's a cool dude.
This moves you to tears seeing Tom Cruise, Nicholas Cage, Mel Gibson ( all of whom seem lovely people)and other stars in complete awe and wonder at such musical talent.
There's a - Japanese? - pianist, who is blind. Blind, folks! BLIND! He can't bloody SEE! "Oh, he can't play. I give him a thumb down." People should try playing the piano themselves, and see if they can do it better.
@@Aegisth There's a French pianist who is blind too, and not only could he play, he was actually one of THE best if not THE best in the world in his prime Bernhard D'Ascoli.
Unlike today. Did you hear about the new “diversity” standards? Awful🤦🏻♂️ Look, I’m not against diversity, but only in the context of the story. If you’re making a movie about medieval Europe, you don’t expect to see an African American. If you’re making a survival movie, you don’t expect to see an actor in a wheelchair. They’re literally oppressing the artists that make the movies.
@@TheCryptKeeper8 If you knew the Helfgott family you would know Margaret is not a full quid. And she didn’t have ECT. SHINE is pretty accurate, the bath tub scene with Davids father may be guilty of Artistic licence but the reality guarded.
I like viewing and listening to the tune of "flight of the bumble bee" in trumpet, in tuba and trombone...I love the Canadian Brass played it. I love the story of this film, and I was thinking to myself if who wrote the piece-actually it was the tittle of the song I was trying to recall. And it was your comment here that reminded me it was the "flight of the bumble be." Probably because it was played on string instrument that is why I forget. Your comment helps me recall. I love Leslie Dye.
Anyone who's had a handful of years with a good piano teacher can play it. It's little more than a lot of chromatic scales played at a fast speed. It looks and sounds a lot more impressive than it is.
@@NicholasOfAutrecourtyeah try doing it in front of hundreds of people, on a televised event, with a neurological problem and right after you became instantly famous. Anyone can play it? Pff please get real
@@silvia.r.2024 Professional and concert pianists play in front of hundreds of people and in front of cameras all the time. If anything, that would likely make many of them feel more comfortable, not less.
@@NicholasOfAutrecourt that is NOT the circumstance of this particular pianist, and you know it. So it's pointless to compare his ability unless you make the rest of the pianists suffer eleven years of electroshock ;)
@@MLMLW Oh come on, man is asking you to be specific. You know there are thousands of gods in this world right? Even Hinduism alone has so many varieties of them. So, which particular diety is believed to have delivered this parcel or package or whatever? Must be Hermes, don't you think? I have seen the movie series and read the book series of the Persy Jackson and the Olympians. That Hermes guy runs a massive company solely dedicated to delivering parcels, messages, packages and other things all around.
@@antoniogomriver He has the same amount of evidence to prove the inexistence of 'God' or 'Gods' that you have to prove the inexistence of the giant spaghetti monster in the sky.
Jim Carrey commented " the live of a piano wire constitutes the real essence of vibrations in the cosmos, the player is not a player but a thought...it is you"
This was admittedly a relatively underwhelming performance but if you watch the documentary, Hello I Am David, you can tell he plays much better than this and for sure he plays with emotion.
I would hazard a guess and say that David as a young man probably played this piece much better. Most of us judge his position in life according to what we saw in the movie, 'Shine'. Unfortunately, that movie was mostly bullshit. What wasn't bullshit was the breakdown David had and the horrors he had to put up with before he was released from the institution. My father a;so went through shock treatment, and today, shock treatment is usually the last line treatment for certain mental disorders. "ECT (Electroconvulsive therapy), is often used with informed consent, as a last line of intervention for major depressive disorder, mania, and catatonia. ECT machines have been placed in the Class III category (high risk)." For major depressive disorder, ECT is generally used only when other treatments have failed, or in emergencies, such as imminent suicide. Having said that, it is remarkable that David Helfgott has improved to such an extent, but this rendition of the Bumble Bee, sounded like his own version, not the original. I have deep admiration for David Helfgott, especially with those struggles he has surpassed.
Knowing full well that you DON'T do research, I include a part of my research here. It is from the perspective of David Helfgott's sister, Margaret. One of her telling quotes was, "How far can a director (Scott Hicks) go from the truth? Is it morally right?" what bothers me is that there are quite a lot of people just like you who think whatever they see on the silver screen, is the truth. Geoffrey Rush IS a brilliant actor, but then he is only interpreting what the director tells him to do. I will leave it up to the readers here to decide. lasvegassun.com/news/1997/mar/24/where-i-stand-david-helfgotts-sister-shines-some-l/
I am so glad Geoffrey Rush played the role of David Helfgott. I found it very moving, sad, funny, so many...he was brilliant and deserved that award. No one else could have done it other than him. He was sensitive, passionate and brought out David's character so it made you rivoted to the screen. I loved it so much I didn't want the movie to end. I love classical music and the people talented enough to compose and play such works of art. Although, I wish David hadn't experienced his troubles, I appreciate him for the 'true' human being inside and his beautiful heart. He is God's gift in so many ways. Thank you Mr. Helfgott and Mr. Rush for being the true life story and the other; on-screen story=brilliance!!!
Long retort short, ditto!
They have a similar resemblance, a little, and it was portrayed nicely.
I met him some years ago - came over to have a chat in a small town - talked but also muttered confirmations the whole time - one of this world's oddities!
"rivoted to the screen" - that means what exactly? Is that like "gluud to being thrilled", or "exited to my nails"?
@@guitaroso this is the third time I've heard of someone having met him in a small town & the muttering. Sounds to me like he wasn't really acting in the movie, just turned up and muttered. Oh well, I'm not going to wish bad on the phony.
I saw the movie today in quarantine for tenth time. I cried like always. Love you David, for the human being that you are. Thank you for exist.
They really nailed his look in the film.
It's a great movie
They sure did! What a great movie!
I saw this movie when I was eleven. I loved every single minute of it and, till these days, it still makes me feel incredibly emotional. Talent is sometimes hidden in the most unexpected people, and I just love that. Jeffrey's performance is something else, another true talent there.
Having watched the film and been quite moved by the performance and story, it's quite emotional to see the subject of the film perform so well, receive adulation and yet bare the scars quite publicly of what still remains of his dark past.
I live near David and had the privilege of seeing him perform a few years ago. Ironically, about 10 years or so ago, I saw Geoffrey Rush back in Melbourne. He's a cool dude.
all i can say is look at the joy and surprise on James Woods face. he was happy and very surprised to see David there, I personally like that
ashdhuk It's Geoffrey Rush. But yeah, the joy is delightful.
They show both of them.....Geoffrey Rush is smiling and applauding, but James Woods looks way more excited than he does.
Years of electric shock treatment... I’m happy he can play at all
He had the gift of imagination and play with all the suffering he went through in his life and his health !! Legend
Brilliantly played and brilliantly played. 👏 👏
In the film "Shine" his play was wonderful、I felt some quake of my Heart!
This moves you to tears seeing Tom Cruise, Nicholas Cage, Mel Gibson ( all of whom seem lovely people)and other stars in complete awe and wonder at such musical talent.
I can see Mel Gibson having other kind of thoughts entirely, knowing him as we do.
painfully beautiful
I don't know if it's just me but I couldn't stop thinking about the Puffy Shirt episode of Seinfeld when watching this clip.
69 likes MY MAN
I have waited decades to review this moment. Man...finaly i found the vídeo
2:46 the way he applauds with total admiration. captivates me
I watched him live on stage here in Denmark many years ago. A weird creature but very kind person with a lovely smile.
Liar.
Why thumbs down - give me a break - so what if it’s not perfect technically - it would be if had not endured his health probs and childhood
There's a - Japanese? - pianist, who is blind. Blind, folks! BLIND! He can't bloody SEE! "Oh, he can't play. I give him a thumb down."
People should try playing the piano themselves, and see if they can do it better.
@@Aegisth There's a French pianist who is blind too, and not only could he play, he was actually one of THE best if not THE best in the world in his prime Bernhard D'Ascoli.
Just saw this!!!! My heart is pounding!!!! Well done!!!! 🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽
“If You Can Play Something Slowly, You Can Play It Quickly.”
Painful yet beautiful story! I just love the movie and David’s interpretation. Magnificent!
I remember watching that Oscars show on TV. This was the only thing that I remember.
I remember this particulary moment since then. Shine was probably the movie that marked me the most
Shine is amazing 👏
Back when the Oscars were real and actually meant something...
Unlike today. Did you hear about the new “diversity” standards? Awful🤦🏻♂️ Look, I’m not against diversity, but only in the context of the story. If you’re making a movie about medieval Europe, you don’t expect to see an African American. If you’re making a survival movie, you don’t expect to see an actor in a wheelchair. They’re literally oppressing the artists that make the movies.
yeah now it's all about lgbt and sex
He looks so pure.
2:46 the cute Geoffrey’s face!
That's the face Nicolas Cages makes when he knows he has been out-crazied.
Minutes later he jumped on his seat and started yelling YEAH BABY!
The difference is David actually has talent.
Convenient they showed the three crazies in a row. Mel Gibson, Nic Cage, and Tom Cruise.
Bravo, bravo, bravo David 🎼🎹🎹🎹🎹
How beautiful
What a gift to the World. Mazel Tov.
Tom Cruise, Mel Gibson, James Woods. Three people we now know are crazier than David Helfgott. Is life too weird or what...
In their heads they are thinking: Tom Cruise: "He needs an audit", James Woods: "I wonder if he has a daughter", Mel Gibson: "He's a Jew".
They are thinking?
You can add Nicolas Cage to that list
Never sign a long contract with Disney you may get Eddie Murphy syndrome
Nicholas Cage is in a whole other league of crazy. The RC Psych had to rewrite the definition of "crazy" thanks to Cage.
Amazing courageous story 👏 😍
Una creatura meravigliosa!!❤
He is amazing ❤
Beautiful man, so full of joy.
He was ahead of his time, before electric keyboards
God Speed with u, thx for all your passion!!
Genialny muzyk .
I got nervous when the woman started running in her high heels at the beginning, the risk of falling in those things is too damn high already!
Hermoso!!!!,lo amo!!,
Godfrey rush realy is amazing actor ..portrayed David helfgot perfectly in movie shine....
Take me back here. Please.
Must warch the movie
Great
If you like Silverchair, he plays the piano in ‘Emotion sickness’
Grande grande grande....David.
If you didn't know his past, and what he endured, this would be a pretty average performance. Props to Helfgott for pushing through it all.
www.thriftbooks.com/w/out-of-tune-david-helfgott-and-the-myth-of-shine_tom-gross_margaret-helfgott/677722/item/7443089/?mkwid=CvOFukeb%7cdc&pcrid=70112890512&product=7443089&plc=&pgrid=21326630352&ptaid=pla-485630668032&CvOFukeb%7cdc%7cpcrid%7c70112890512%7cpkw%7c%7cpmt%7c%7cproduct%7c7443089%7cslid%7c%7cpgrid%7c21326630352%7cptaid%7cpla-485630668032%7c&gclid=EAIaIQobChMI_MTuv6-56AIVTEHTCh0QqQ0VEAQYAiABEgLmgPD_BwE#isbn=0446523836&idiq=7443089
@@TheCryptKeeper8 If you knew the Helfgott family you would know Margaret is not a full quid.
And she didn’t have ECT.
SHINE is pretty accurate, the bath tub scene with Davids father may be guilty of Artistic licence but the reality guarded.
Que ser tan extraordinario y maravilloso... Bravo...!
Admirable !!!
one word:awesome
Best film ever
BEAUTIFUL.¨!!!!!!!!!!!!
He's a gift of God!!!
Wonderful♥Wonderful
Thank you
Well done
Next time I see a homeless person talking to him/herself, I'll try to remember this.
Amazing!
I had never really thought "Flight of the Bumblebees" created much imagery or sounded like an actual flight of bumblebees til hearing this.
I like viewing and listening to the tune of "flight of the bumble bee" in trumpet, in tuba and trombone...I love the Canadian Brass played it. I love the story of this film, and I was thinking to myself if who wrote the piece-actually it was the tittle of the song I was trying to recall. And it was your comment here that reminded me it was the "flight of the bumble be." Probably because it was played on string instrument that is why I forget. Your comment helps me recall. I love Leslie Dye.
This is so moving!
un dieu vivant de la musique ...merci
Only a top notch pianist couple perform that piece!
Anyone who's had a handful of years with a good piano teacher can play it. It's little more than a lot of chromatic scales played at a fast speed. It looks and sounds a lot more impressive than it is.
@@NicholasOfAutrecourtyeah try doing it in front of hundreds of people, on a televised event, with a neurological problem and right after you became instantly famous. Anyone can play it? Pff please get real
@@silvia.r.2024 Professional and concert pianists play in front of hundreds of people and in front of cameras all the time. If anything, that would likely make many of them feel more comfortable, not less.
@@NicholasOfAutrecourt that is NOT the circumstance of this particular pianist, and you know it. So it's pointless to compare his ability unless you make the rest of the pianists suffer eleven years of electroshock ;)
@@silvia.r.2024 Someone is triggered. 😂
BELLISIMO MOMENTO!!
Thank you
God puts talent in some of the strangest packages. This man is a genius.
Which God and what evidence do you have that it exists?
@@TheKingkeano What evidence do you have that He doesn't exist?
@@TheKingkeano - I'm just now seeing this comment and I agree with the other response from @Hillbilly - What evidence do you have that He doesn't? 🙄
@@MLMLW Oh come on, man is asking you to be specific. You know there are thousands of gods in this world right? Even Hinduism alone has so many varieties of them. So, which particular diety is believed to have delivered this parcel or package or whatever? Must be Hermes, don't you think? I have seen the movie series and read the book series of the Persy Jackson and the Olympians. That Hermes guy runs a massive company solely dedicated to delivering parcels, messages, packages and other things all around.
@@antoniogomriver He has the same amount of evidence to prove the inexistence of 'God' or 'Gods' that you have to prove the inexistence of the giant spaghetti monster in the sky.
Nic Cage looks a bit jealous there haha. He’s like, “I wanna chop his fingers off and wear them as my own!”
No, he doesn't. What on earth is going on in that head of yours? 😂
BRAVO!!!!!!!
Geofrei Rash ! Beautiful !
Amazing 👏
Amazing flight of the bumblebee
HUmmm.. Im just going to go in there and play "Flight of the Bumblebee" Rachmaninoff interpretation... ok.. no big deal.. sheesh! what a legend!
After 11 years in mental institution without a piano, it's unbelievable that he can play again
Bravo👏👏👏👏👏
i really liked the movie Shine. a very touching true story
All of those movie stars are thinking to themselves, "Daymn! I wish I could do that!"
Wow!
Film gigantesco!!! Helfgot e Rush due miti.
Axtraordinary ,love it
Where is Twoset Violin?
The Seinfeld shirt.
Y'know, its really not a bad lookin shirt... *cue spanky bass*
Im here because I read the book of Robert Mckee Story,substance and structure and I have to say, what a ride
Extraordinário!
Back when I used to watch the Oscars.
Astounding
merci, Genial !
The shards of a crystal still give rainbows to the world.
This is what my thought would sound like if they could speak I love flight of the bumblebee
I can't listen to a lot of the great compositions after Shine because I like his interpretation so much better hahaha!
Jim Carrey commented " the live of a piano wire constitutes the real essence of vibrations in the cosmos, the player is not a player but a thought...it is you"
im mocking him btw....for all you amateur "I understand the meaning of life and you don't" people
This was admittedly a relatively underwhelming performance but if you watch the documentary, Hello I Am David, you can tell he plays much better than this and for sure he plays with emotion.
oh! i think i saw that pop up on nflx but I ignored it. Will definitely check it out now!
........I'd like to see you play like that and I'll tell you if it's good...
Well this is just Oscars no one watches it anyway.
Most beautiful film about Musik!
Gênio
感動
I would hazard a guess and say that David as a young man probably played this piece much better.
Most of us judge his position in life according to what we saw in the movie, 'Shine'.
Unfortunately, that movie was mostly bullshit.
What wasn't bullshit was the breakdown David had and the horrors he had to put up with before he was released from the institution.
My father a;so went through shock treatment, and today, shock treatment is usually the last line treatment for certain mental disorders.
"ECT (Electroconvulsive therapy), is often used with informed consent, as a last line of intervention for major depressive disorder, mania, and catatonia. ECT machines have been placed in the Class III category (high risk)."
For major depressive disorder, ECT is generally used only when other
treatments have failed, or in emergencies, such as imminent suicide.
Having said that, it is remarkable that David Helfgott has improved to such an extent, but this rendition of the Bumble Bee, sounded like his own version, not the original.
I have deep admiration for David Helfgott, especially with those struggles he has surpassed.
No it wasnt.. Do some research
Knowing full well that you DON'T do research, I include a part of my research here.
It is from the perspective of David Helfgott's sister, Margaret.
One of her telling quotes was,
"How far can a director (Scott Hicks) go from the truth? Is it morally right?"
what bothers me is that there are quite a lot of people just like you who think whatever they see on the silver screen, is the truth.
Geoffrey Rush IS a brilliant actor, but then he is only interpreting what the director tells him to do.
I will leave it up to the readers here to decide.
lasvegassun.com/news/1997/mar/24/where-i-stand-david-helfgotts-sister-shines-some-l/
...yeah....it's fairly well accepted that Shine, (like most biopics, let's be fair) plays with the truth.
awesome considering his age and health problems.
@twoset needs to respond to this. If you can play it slow, you can play it quickly.
Uncanny resemblance by the way❤
중학교 때 내한 하셨을 때 직접 봤었는데
the best -Perfect -
What is this piece? Does David play it "correctly"? I honestly can't tell, it seems either very complicated or rhythmically improvised?? 😬
Grande!
Define crazy.