The Scientist Who Saved Three BILLION Yet Is Hated
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 เม.ย. 2023
- Fritz Haber saved half of humanity, then committed pure evil. Try brilliant.org/Newsthink/ for FREE for 30 days, and the first 200 people will get 20% off their annual premium subscription
Newsthink is produced and presented by Cindy Pom
/ cindypom
Grab your Newsthink merch here: newsthink.creator-spring.com
Thank you to our Patrons, including Igli Laci
Support us on Patreon: / newsthink
Special thanks to the following for permission to use their material:
Karlsruhe Institute of Technology www.kit.edu/english/
Select images supplied by Alamy.
Sources:
0:30 Jason M Ramos, CC BY 2.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
2:28 Dietmar Rabich / Wikimedia Commons / “Karlsruhe, Elektrotechnisches Institut -- 2013 -- 5260” / CC BY-SA 4.0
2:45 The original uploader was AlterVista at German Wikipedia., CC BY-SA 3.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/b... via Wikimedia Commons
2:50 Wellcome Images, CC BY 4.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
3:37 Jar.ciurus, CC BY-SA 3.0 PL creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
4:30 stavros1, CC BY 3.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
6:02 Norbert Nagel, CC BY-SA 4.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
6:32 Johannes Robalotoff, CC BY-SA 3.0 DE creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
6:38 Bundesarchiv, DH 2 Bild-F-01930 / CC-BY-SA 3.0, CC BY-SA 3.0 DE creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
9:07 Bundesarchiv, Bild 146-1969-024-67 / CC-BY-SA 3.0, CC BY-SA 3.0 DE creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
13:42 Adam Jones, Ph.D., CC BY-SA 3.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
13:59 Goku122, CC BY-SA 3.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/b... via Wikimedia Commons
14:04 Bundesarchiv, Bild 183-N0827-318 / CC-BY-SA 3.0, CC BY-SA 3.0 DE creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
14:10 Paul Arps from The Netherlands, CC BY 2.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
14:14 Bundesarchiv, Bild 146-1972-062-01 / CC-BY-SA 3.0, CC BY-SA 3.0 DE creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
14:42 Fridolin freudenfett (Peter Kuley), CC BY-SA 3.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
14:50 Fridolin freudenfett (Peter Kuley), CC BY-SA 3.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
17:28 MichaelLeukert, CC BY-SA 3.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
17:58 I, Seglea, CC BY-SA 3.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/b... via Wikimedia Commons
18:13 EvaK, CC BY-SA 2.5 creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons
18:18 Benutzer:Sansculotte. Bild ist unter der GNU FDL zur weiteren Verwendung freigegeben. Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported Photographiert 02/2003
18:32 Chaim Weizmann image: Government Press Office (Israel), CC BY-SA 3.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/... via Wikimedia Commons - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
*What other biographies would you like to see?*
Try brilliant.org/Newsthink/ for FREE for 30 days, and the first 200 people will get 20% off their annual premium subscription.
hey
Max plank
max planck
Dr vashisht Narayan Singh
Max planck please
A tragic story beautifully told
Love your presentation and narration. Very simple and straightforward with no drama. It's refreshing to have a newer creator who does not use clickbait titles or overdramatic tones.
Not nitpicking but the final straw that drew the US into WWI, on top of unrestricted sub attacks, was the Zimmerman telegram where Germany offered Mexico an alliance if they went to war with the US.
Overall A+ quality. I hope you continue to put out more stuff like this and that your channel continues to grow. Subscribed!!!
Why would his war time contributions to be any different from those who worked on the Manhattan Project? Only difference is that the side he worked for lost the war!
Artillery still caused the most death and injuries over poisonous gas in WWI and WWII. Should the scientist who invented guns be considered evil? Guns can be used to protect or it can be used for evil.
Don't be discouraged that videos like these do not get explosive views. It's not a flashy clickbaity topic. But you did make the best coverage on the topic. People will watch this video for years to come.
However, you might consider releasing your videos in the style of TechAltar and LMG. Behind a subscription paywall first, then release for free with ads on YT later. Don't ever stop.
Wow! I knew abt the ammonia process in my High school..but his name is not mention unlike other scientist for their respective discoveries..😢 thanks for this..
Cindy is brilliant
Clara fired two shots in the garden that night. The first at God in heaven, she missed, the second at herself.
Fritz's story is absolutely heartbreaking.
7:26 - Note that the current global population is 8 billion, not 7 billion.
It is very sad to see. He fought his whole life to become a German. He always wanted to be a part of something Bigger. He was so brilliant that he did not need it.
"Life is really simple, but we insist on making it complicated." -Confucius
And deadly!😢yes.. deadly to kill anyone for power and
$££ and sex😢
That’s confusing 😅
There was a vast difference between the thinking of Albert Einstein and Fritz Haber as members of the German heritage. Haber was a conventional German patriot who supported the Kaiser during WW1. Einstein was a German proud of the German cultural heritage, its music, literature, and other positive contributions to the human race. There were other major differences in their lives, though both found great difficulty being accepted as scientists. Einstein had to work as a patent examiner after university. Haber could not find a position as a chemist. I have read that Einstein, once he had gained recognition for relativity, assisted Haber to obtain an appointment in chemistry. They were very different people in their political outlooks.
Your documentaries are so good I don't know why you aren't getting enough views.... Go on you are awesome 😎
Dude she gets lots of views.
If this video doesn't, veritasium already made a video on this with over 14 mil. Still this was a good video
People seem to like dumbass videos instead of things like this
Excellent ma'am. Everyone in this world has a finite time the way you choose to use it is in your hands. Some day we will all leave this place but before that let's do something which the future generations will cherish.
Excellent video! Thanks!
How about we say "He invented things, people miss using them."
"science can be used as a tool for good ,and also as a tool for evil".
In his deep desire to identify with his enemy, he gave his enemy its most exacting weapon.
He didn't invented it but refine the process with appropriate technology
That is an abject lesson that the only success that is worthwhile is success in the benefit of humanity.
Thanks for sharing this.
Flashbacks of veritasium flashing by
Same!
Despite his notorious invention used in war, which he willingly or not participate, I personally support the Nobel prize committee awarded him due to his Nitrogen-to-Ammonia invention. Fact is the invention still being used today whether we like it or not.
Your best ever Cindy!
I learned a surprising amount of things I didn't know from this video.
If karma was real, this would make a perfect example
Karma is not real
Thank you for this beautifully narrated video!😊
Damn I love that type of videos!
"Go confidently in the direction of your dreams! Live the life you've imagined." -Henry David Thoreau
Yeah, sure, in some shack, living like a hermit... That is all that I dreamed of...
@@ozymandiasultor9480That is literally what I have dreamed of since childhood.
@@sg-vp2qg Oh... Living like a hermit? Well, there were such in history...some were even living in rooms with no doors after their entering doors were closed...and they were receiving a couple of times in the day their food, and giving to people their "waste" that should be disposed of... You had something of that nature on your mind, or just living in some shack without internet, TV, electricity, running water, toilet... Like Ted Kazunsky??
That is your ideal way of living?
Why bother living, if you hate society? It is totally unnatural, human beings are, as Aristotle said, zoon politicon, social animals, we live in societies...but you want to be an aberration because I bet you are a misanthrope... Then, I ask again, why bother living?
You wanted that since childhood? And what is preventing you to go and live like some wild Robinson Crusoe somewhere totally alone?
@@sg-vp2qg You have a lot here about fibromyalgia... interesting...
this is well story telling. i can feel it from begining to the end. please keep posting video like this. good show. 😊
Everyone should definitely go read the Alchemy of Air.
An interesting story consisting of historically poignant twists
We are torn between virtues
Seems a pattern. Brilliant minds are outliers. Without ethics, there is no compass.
He wanted oat of his father's hose? Is that where wild oats come from?
That is a man that killed hundreds of thousands, but also saved billions. That is a very complex life.
Same as Oppenheimer et al
@@zweisteinya 2/3 of the world's population lives because of Haber. I can't see the resemblance to Oppenheimer unfortunately.
And Enrico Fermi was responsible for the biggest job behind the atomic bomb. And how Oppenheimer has saved billions of people? over a hundred thousand for sure, but not billions.
No offense👍
@@erikaskeroth9720 Yes. The guy was referring to the atom bomb, and I couldn't agree more. Be it Oppenheimer or Fermi, it doesn't matter, every scientist at Los Alamos played a part in the construction of the bomb. Although frowned upon, the atomic bomb was unfortunatelly the lesser evil at the point of the Pacific conflict. I think that Haber's justification of using the gas was not correct and generally not comparable to the atom bomb. Haber said that the gas would end war faster, but I think that idea was flawed because Germany was not close to winning in the slightest. On the other hand the US was definitelly on the verge of winning, but the Japan, which was using dirty methods of warfare at the end of the conflict I might add, just wouldn't give up, thus in my opinion America was justified in using the bomb, and although it killed or injured in any capacity 200 000 people, it is less than the amount of people that would have been killed (on both sides) had the conflict continued.
@@halbarad7932It seems consequatialism can, in some circumstances, justify mass murder. If murder can't be justified, it seems consequentialism is wrong.
A large difference would be that the bombs were dropped on children, the chlorine/mustard gas used on soldiers. Also, a person could, it seems, have known they would be.
Ending the war earlier and saving lives being the sole aim can justify rape if a person thinks it will be effective. If consequentialism leads to this, but rape is always wrong, then consequentilism is wrong as an ethical theory.
@@erikaskeroth9720Finally someone who acknowledged Fermi, sure Oppenheimer was extremely important due to his role in fissionanle material but Fermi literally invented the nuclear fission
Well he used the logic to justify mustard gas that US used to justify the nukes... So...
Fritz Haber, the man who rescued humanity from a sure Malthusian Disaster.
How could the entente powers charge Haber with war crimes when they also used poison gas?
Fed the world by ways of science
Sinner or a saint ?
Father of toxic gas and chemical warfare
-Sabaton
He was neither a sinner or a saint. He wanted to be a patriot.
Like a supervillain origin story, but in real life
During times when there's peace, he belonged to the world, During times when there's war he belonged to his place of birth.
What a sick man using what he knew to hurt people. That cancels out any good in the beginning.
Every invention has had positive and negative consequences.
@@patrickmiano7901 shame there always has to be a negative consequence by abusing the positive because one can.
You must be aware that even as we watch this clip, in practically every country on earth there are many scientists around the clock "using what they know to hurt people". From big projects like rockets, aircraft, submarines, tanks, to cruise missiles, drones and mines... even the ongoing improvement of hand guns. All in the name of helping their country. Fritz Haber was a chemist, and so he thought of a weapon in the chemical field. An especially nasty, condemnable weapon for sure, but isn't that true of the nuclear bombs that fell on Japan, too? And a final thought: The responsibility for using a weapon doesn't solely rest with the inventor, but also with the politicians that authorize or demand its use.
I do think is better to set a heuristic during interactions: Do unto others what you can bear as the last thing you did to others. I know is almost impossible to live by this unbelievably difficult heuristic, but then, we can always, at least, try to live into it.
curious stuff and well crafted videos. Subscribed!
Interesting documentary. One note, you mention a number of times his conversion to Christianity. While this would have help during WW1 it would matter not at all during WW2. The Nazis were not Christians, that were humanist. Some were heavy into things like the occult. They had strange beliefs to say the least and would have done away with all religion’s activities outside their own beliefs if they were successful, including Christianity.
"What? How could a man who saved 3 billion lives be hated?"
"Fritz Haber was...."
"Oh"
Haber belongs with Oppenheimer as the men most deserving of a Nobel Prize. Just as Nobel founded the Nobel academy in an attempt to recover his name from bastardization by those who found him responsible for the missuse of his invention. It should be noted that both Haber and Oppenheimer believed during development that their invention would be so catastrophic that it would bring an end to the current world war with little to no bloodshed, as they would be seen as too horrific to be used more than was absolutely necessary. These 3 men, Nobel, Haber, and Oppenheimer probably have more understanding of what they went through decades apart than any of the men in their company. It would be beautiful if it weren't so tragic
Amazing content, and research. I would request you to make a video on Narinder Singh Kapany, an unsung scientist who invented and coined the term fiber optics, essentially laying the foundation for the information age.
A very good video.
I just knew about Marie Curie’s contribution at WW1 with her mobile field x-ray machines which saved thousands of french troops and I was just glad she help saved lives instead of taking them because she could have just sprayed radium all over germany
Poor planet.
Sad but interesting story. One remark, soldiers are also innocent civilians. They don't choose to go to war, they are forced to.
Love cindy ❤️ ♥️
Good story
He is a character of intelligent villain arc in movies or a grey character who has positives of saving billions of people from starvung at the same time killing the people to serve his country.
A small price of salvation
Does anyone know the background music fpr 5:08?
Discovery to destroy your people, This is insane😢😢
4:29 - Those were guano 'mines'; islands covered to great depths in sea bird poop.
7:16 - There are *NO* choices which do not involve trade-offs.
10:04 - That would be true (and it was regarding the nukes in WWII), but there was nothing keeping Germany's opponents from using the same. Hence the use simply increased the casualties on both sides with no shortening of the war. He turned into a monster. Horrible.
15:18 - 'You petition the Lord with prayer?! You do *not* petition the Lord with prayer!'.
Haber what have you done ?
8:35 the last person i would ever see throwing a grenade is a guy in a suit lol
Now this is a great video and story telling. Please do more of these and less Apple/Tesla.
Considering how he treated his wife alone... Villain. A smart villain to be sure, but a villain none the less...
What about the inventor of the atomical bomb?
I feel like they tried to make his wife reverse aliving herself as this story about external factors driving her to have to do it. Humans even in the toughest situations don’t wish to die, and absolutely never when they have loved ones including children, unless they have neurological problems. Also, we don’t see any evidence or word of her experiencing anything that horrible, becoming worn out by whatever was harming her, or some evidence of growing logical decision making to unalive herself. So it’s okay to talk about her hardships and loneliness and lack of support, but those aren’t what caused her to unalive. It’s medical and neurological problems that caused it, it was the lack of other things that prevented other things from helping her hold on to her life until she could get better and get medical help.
He saved millions of lives and killed too
A LONG AGO IN EASTERN PRUSSIA
YOUNG MEN WITH GREAT AMBITIONS RISE
SO WHO CAN TELL ME WHO CAN SAY FOR SURE
WHICH ONE WILL WIN THE NOBEL PRIZE?
Science and morality dont mix if it can be done it will be done.
Still billions of people live with hunger all over the world.
There is no monument of Karl Marx anywhere in Germany either. Also another jew.
Wow Phd in organic. Chemistry
Those have thrown the stones at him whom created the atomic weapons. That's just funny.
A. Hitler's real surname was Shekelgruber -- sure sounds like a disenfranchised
Yid
Didn't know Anupam Kher was a scientist.
different used to distroy humans 😢
Thr authors of this video project their prejudices when they mention the causes of Clara's death. She was not a millennial feminist. It is their own speculation.
This was horrible
Unfortunately a street on the Campus of the University of Karlsruhe (KIT) is named after Fritz Haber and a technical device for producing amonia (about 15 meters hight) is raised to remember him.
Sounds fortunate to me.
nice use of Erik Satie
Attack on titan vibes
Next , Max Planck
Science has two faces the only thing is that which face you want to see...🎉🎉🎉🎉
15:55, spot the mistake
"Pray for those who despitefully use you and persecute you"....Jesus Christ
Do a video about Adaani and his scam .. btw you guys doing great job
19:20 You might want to check that part up
talk about a bad timed commercial.
Seems very similar to Veritasiums relatively recent video
How so? I haven't watched it so would be interested in hearing your thoughts.
I saw the thumbnail and I was like "oh it's haber"
He should’ve moved to America
Me:Himn his good guy 👍 me after: his bad guy 😮. Me after again: his sad guy 😢. Me: what can human being he is
Heĺl Faber 🌐🐱🎇🎇🎇
hey.
😊
He was nothing but an opportunist. He developed the fertilizer and the poison gases to satisfy his own ego. Humanity owes him nothing.
Again the absolutely terrible "positivism" ideology strikes here, judging the past people with the pseudo-morality of today's people... The only value which prevails is that the critics are alive. No problem, you will be all dead in some time and those coming after... how said the Taliban? "We will erase your trace from history!"... based on "you have watches, we have time..."!
what Anupam Kher doing here
It's fritz Haber not anupam kher 😂
Who h÷
Einsteins contribution to science is nothing compared with Haber
You’re wrong, i think u meant contribution to mankind. Einstein def has more contribution in science than him
Content copied from Veritasium
What are you talking about? Please give examples of what sections were copied. Quite amazing considering I never even watched his video.
@@Newsthink😂😂😂 just stop
@@Xaviergonzalez85 Stop what? Frustrating when someone accuses you of copying from Veritasium when they don't have examples to back up their false claims.
I can see someone who replied to a comment that no one notices, it's just a comment
this video is miss leading and so untrue...Fritz was a monster ... I can't believe these people are making great someone that was very bad. Ask yourself how the population has grown so high...then you will understand all. we are disposable