What you would expect from the universities in Pakistan where basic thing's are not available. It's very easy to say that local PhDs are incompetent but please spend sometime and see what kind of problems they face.
What about quality of schooling being provided in higher educational institutions? Then what would be the output of those institutes?? So, PhD are degree holders from HEIs of Pakistan.
Every word is fact rather bitter reality. I was serving in PU and I exposed one of my colleague's plagiarized paper which was published by Dean Mr. Chawla at PU's HEC recognized Journal of History dept. As a result She was first promoted as professor from Assistant Professor and now she is sitting on Principal's seat and I am kicked out though I completed my PhD in exceptional time in.the field of Art and Design. So this is level of Vice Chancellor Dr. Niaz Akhter who knowingly all facts made her principal with that plagiarized paper. Paper is deposited in HEC's repository.
What is being done in our beloved country specially in education sector. Hoodby is requested to invite Dr Atta ur Rehman to also listen his point of view. Nation should know that what is going on
Iss Tariq Banauri ka tau mind bhi corrupt ho chuka hai, public private partner-ship ko corruption keh raha hai lol. Aisay logon ki wajah se hee saara education system baith chuka hai hehe. Good job PTI
@@aarifboy bro I voted for PTI but unfortunately you did not understand what he really meant. Universities have a lot of land and this plan of public- private partnership was a scheme to grab that land. It is reality that many people have eyes on universities land in big cities like Islamabad and Lahore. He said that he is not against the public-private partnership but strict check and balance and regulatory frameworks should be implemented. Bro its a matter of national importance and above party lines.
@@aarifboy You sound like educated illiterate, not even a common sense what this gentleman is talking about. Kind of leader ship and atmosphere we have in Pakistan is definitely destined to be doomed.
Every single day we hear this.. education is very important for the progress of society but OUR EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM is flawed... I never knew a person as high as chairman of HEC could face such problems. Thank you professor for bearing down on the actual issues and bloody parasites of educational system. MORE POWER TO YOU
I listen Dr. Hood with eager and thrust since my high school. I still remember your lectures of physics on live channel. Sir the points which you have highlighted are very shocking and eye opening. RIEP Science in pakistan.
@SultanM85533133 اسلامی جمہوریہ پاکستان ایک دھوکہ اور شرک ہے# دارالاسلام پاکستان شرک سےعلیحدگی کا تصور 1940ء جناح اورمسلمانوں نے فیصلہ کیا کہ اللہ کی مدد سے طلب کریں گےاورمسلمان شرک سے علیحدگی اختیار کرے گا, اللہ نے دعا کی وجہ سے مشرک_جمہوری ہندوستان کو تقسیم کر کے مسلمانوں کو اعتماد میں پاکستان دیا # ڈاکٹر پرویز ہوڈبائے/حسن نثار/ طحہ صدیقی ، آرزو کاظمی ، طاہر گورا اور طارق فتاح مسٹرجاوید غامدی 1956 کے سیکولرسٹوں کے زبردست گروپ میں شامل ہیں جیسے چیف جسٹس منیر ٹائپ لوگوں نے اللہ کےساتھ غداری کی,جواسلامی پاکستان کو ریپبلیکن ازم کے ساتھ تشکیل دے کرکے پاکستان کو شرک کی راہ میں[1956] سے لے کرگامزن کیا ہوہے ہیں۔ ان سیکولروں لوگوں نے اللہ کے ساتھ دھوکہ کیا ہے, اور, دارالاسلام کو دوبارہ جمہوری # بےدین# ہستی کے نام کے ساتھ پاکستان کومنسلک کر کے اسلامی ریاست کو شرک میں شا مل کرکے, انہیں خوشی ہے کہ ہم کئی دہائیوں سے پاکستانیوں کو بے وقوف بنا رہے ہیں سیکولر مذہب میڈیا غلط بیانیے کو فروغ دینا چاہتآ ہے، جس سے قرآن مجید روکتا ہے. پاکستان کے کچھ ناظرین بھی اللہ/محمد صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کی شریعت کی پرواہ نہیں کرتے. سیکولرازم صرف ایک اور مذہب ہے, یہ اسلام کو دبا کر اپنےغلط جذبات پر مبنی مذہب کی تصدیق کو سننا/فروغ دینا چاہتے ہیں English Urdu Quran 15;26 We created man of dried clay, of black mud, formed into shape: (27) and we had before created the devil of subtle fire. (28) And remember when thy Lord said unto the angels, Verily I am about to create man of dried clay, of black mud, wrought into shape; (29) when, therefore, I shall have completely formed him, and shall have breathed of My spirit into him, do ye fall down and worship him. (30) And all the angels worshipped Adam together, (31) except Iblís, who refused to be with those who worshipped him. (32) And God said unto him, O Iblís, what hindered thee from being with those who worshipped Adam? (33) He answered, It is not fit that I should worship man, whom thou hast created of dried clay, of black mud, wrought into shape. (34) God said, Get thee therefore hence: for thou shalt be driven away with stones: (35) and a curse shall be on thee, until the day of judgment. (36) The devil said, O Lord, Give me respite until the day of resurrection. (37) God answered, Verily thou shalt be one of those who are respited (38) until the day of the appointed time. (39) The Iblís replied, O Lord, because thou hast seduced me, I will surely tempt them to disobedience in the earth; (40) and I will seduce such of them as shall be thy chosen servants. (41) God said This is the right way with me. (42) Verily as to my servants, thou shalt have no power over them; but over those only who shall be seduced, and who shall follow thee. (43) And hell is surely denounced unto them all: (44) it hath seven gates; unto every gate, a distinct company of them shall be assigned.قرآن ;15 26. ہم نے انسان کو خشک مٹی سے ، کالی مٹی سے بنا دیا ، شکل میں بنا: (27) اور اس سے پہلے ہم نے لطیف آگ کا جن ی پیدا کیا تھا۔ () 28) اور یاد کرو جب تمہارے پروردگار نے فرشتوں سے کہا بے شک میں انسان کو خشک مٹی سے، کالی مٹی سے پیدا کرنے والا ہوں، () 29) جب، میں اس کو مکمل طور پر تشکیل دوں گا ، اور اس میں میری روح پھونک دوں گا ، تو کیا تم اس کے نیچے گر پڑو اور سجدہ کرو؟ () 30) اور تمام فرشتوں نے مل کر آدم کو سجدہ کیا، () 31) سوائے ابلیس کے، جس نے اس کی عبادت کرنے والوں کے ساتھ رہنے سے انکار کردیا۔ () 32) اور اللہ نے اس سے کہا، اے ابلیس ، کس چیز نے تمہیں آدمیوں کے ساتھ رہنے سے روک دیا؟ () 33) اس نے جواب دیا ، یہ مناسب نہیں ہے کہ میں اس آدمی کی عبادت کروں جس کو تو نے خشک مٹی سے ، کالی مٹی سے پیدا کیا ہے ، جس کی شکل آپ نے بنائی ہے۔ () 34) خدا نے کہا اس لئے یہاں سے چلی جا کیونکہ تمہیں پتھروں سے بھگا دیا جائے گا۔ () 35) اور قیامت تک تم پر لعنت ہوگی۔ () 36) شیطان نے کہا ، اے خداوند ، مجھے قیامت کے دن تک مہلت دو۔ () 37) اللہ نے جواب دیا، بیشک تو مہلت پانے والوں میں سے ہو گا (38) مقررہ وقت تک () 39) شیطان نے جواب دیا، اے خداوند ، اس لئے کہ تو نے مجھے بہکایا، میں ان کو زمین میں نافرمانی کا لالچ دوں گا۔ () 40) اور میں ان میں سے ایسے لوگوں کو بہکا دوں گا جو تیرے منتخب بندے ہوں گے۔ (41) اللہ نے کہا ، یہ میرے ساتھ صحیح طریقہ ہے۔ ((( یہ صحیح طریقہ ہے ، جیسے ، "میرے ابدی فرمان کے مطابق ، منتخب لوگوں کی بچت اور شریروں کی سراسر بدعنوانی۔))) () 42) بے شک میرے بندوں کے بارے میں ، تم پر ان کا اختیار نہیں ہے۔ لیکن صرف ان لوگوں کے لئے جو بہکاوے میں ہوں گے ، اور جو آپ کے پیچھے چلیں گے۔ () 43) اور یقینا ان سب کے لئے جہنم کی مذمت کی جائے گی (44 44) اس کے سات دروازے ہیں۔ ہر ایک دروازے پر ان کی ایک الگ کمپنی تفویض کی جائے گی۔ Commented on France Reaction to TLP Protests & Pakistan's Image? Taha Siddiqui & Arzoo Kazmi wTahir Gora @TAG TV
@@nadermazari3334 Thank you for your dim view, You can't be a serious believer if you start asserting that religion has destroyed everything in society, My whole point above was about the people who give priority to [Aql] reason, who take reason as a legislator, they are the ones who have destroyed humanity by adopting the wrong god, the reason is a mere calculator it can not explain reality without religion., this is where secular centric gods have been misled through unqualified conjectures. It is a breathless folly to follow science alone to find reality. Without religion, man is no better than cattle. آپ کے دھیمے خیال کے لئے آپ کا شکریہ ، آپ سنجیدہ مومن نہیں ہو سکتے اگر آپ یہ دعوی کرنا شروع کردیں کہ مذہب معاشرے میں ہر چیز کو تباہ کر رہا ہے تو ، میرا پورا نکتہ ان لوگوں کے بارے میں تھا جو [عقل] کو ترجیح دیتے ہیں ، جو عقل کو قانون ساز کی حیثیت د یتے ہیں ، وہی لوگ ہیں جنہوں نے غلط خدا کو اپناتے ہوئے انسانیت کو تباہ کر دیا ، عقل محض کیلکولیٹر ہے جو مذہب کے بغیر حقیقت کی وضاحت نہیں کرسکتا۔ ، یہی وہ جگہ ہے جہاں سیکولر مرکز پرست خداؤں کو نااہل قیاسوں کے ذریعے گمراہ کیا گیا ہے۔ حقیقت ڈھونڈنے کے لئے تنہا سائنس پرعمل کرنا ایک دم گھٹیا حماقت ہے۔ اسلامی(قرآن) مذہب کےانکشاف بغیرانسان مویشیوں سے بہتر نہیں۔
@@sultanmahmood6396 And please refrain from using idiotic terms like "dim view." I can return the favor in kind. We can all agree to disagree. But as I have always seen, the religious will resort to name-calling instantly.
@@nadermazari3334 I acknowledge your concerns, about strainful terms, but you must appreciate your initial irresponsible slandering religion, someone has to correct misguided perceptions of people, by Amr-Bil-Maroof) of encouraging people to do or to say what is good. Maruf is anything that has been approved in divine law. Nahi Anil Munkar means forbidding evil by discouraging people from doing or initially stating what is wrong.
More respect to you sir. You are a gem sort of a person don't compromise on your integrity. Please bring forward all the prevailing flaws in our higher education in every forum.Kudos
Thanks Dr sahib for conducting interview with Dr Tariq. Firstly I got chance to listen the person who know his work vision and really trying for the betterment in education sector. I highly appriciate Dr Tariq for his bold interview which is based on solid facts. An honest person can spoke not number two like Dr atta. Dr Tariq for us u the Chairman HEC we need people like u. So Pl fight ur case our prayers are with u. People like u should be on such positions for the future of Pakistan. Dr Tariq stay blessed and thanks Dr bahi for conducting interview and bring real picture in front of public without any fear.
Sir, thank you for supporting Dr. Tariq Banuri. To be honest, it didn't surprise me at all. Corruption in HEJ and other research centers, the level of PhDs, local journal fraud, and poor teaching standards, are all obvious issues.
This whole open discussion is actually healthy- may this invite closer introspection from the government on HEJ and may Rahman and his corruption be exposed
Dr atta is the man who destroyed the college education totally It's the college which feed the university College is bridge between the school n university.......it takes input from school process it n gives it to the university
Great video and thanks for uploading Dr. Hoodbhoy. I am glad that I found your channel. Pakistan is such a corrupt place. Shocking to see that the space of higher education is also not safe from it.
37:20 I completely agree. I know this as I was refused my right to keep copyrights and my teachers and institute instead of accepting my case study and publish it instead blacklisted me on this issue
First of all thank you Mr. Pervez Hoodbhoy for bringing Mr. Tariq Banuri for an interview. Hats off to you sir, Mr. Tariq Banuri, for believing and having the courage to fix things in such a country like Pakistan. Going face to face with the dilemma of corruption that has engulfed our beautiful country. If I had the power, instead of taking a year away from you, I would have given you twenty more. I wish we had more and more people like you, if not that, at least and I hope from the bottom of my heart that they wake up. My prayers are with you in you endeavours, stay strong.
There is a lot more to it than meets the eye. Dr. Banuri was one of the architects of University Reform Act which started piling up already full Pandora Box he is talking about in this interview. Higher education, unfortunately, is enslaving the recipients rather than freeing them. This has become true universally, though more so in countries like ours. The 🐀 race of publications in our higher education system has contaminated the very soul of scholarship. The useless research output which Dr. Rahman boasts of has not even remotely contributed to the technological capability of our country. This interview was very important in terms of contribution made by Dr. Hoodbhoy. As always, he exposes courageously and prudently what ought to be exposed.
knowing the truth from an incumbent chairman about the previous discrepancies through HEC is really painful. Well, not just hope we need to work on the current issues at both education, research, and administrative level.
So true. I have studied software engg but none of the teachers in my dept were a true software engr and most were not eveb software engrs. As per the professors, I can tell you they had not written or executed a single line of code in the past decade...
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person. The true facts what’s said about Tariq Banuri. “HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan. 1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded. 2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC. 3) Another important programme “ Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years. 4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far! 5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work. Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
I agree with you. I had done the same thing software engineering. Our teachers even itself don't know the coding. Simple atm code is considered as mind blowing in pakistani universities
The last sigh by Hoodbhoy said it all. Intellectual dishonesty is much more harmful in the long term for the nation than corruption like commissions, money laundering etc. In the first case, one cheat others or a system which can be mended or reversed but what can you do when one is dishonest with his own self. This is called self delusion and when it becomes a national phenomenon, it is difficult to get out of it for centuries. After the sack of Baghdad Islamic civilization never recovered. The last sigh of Hoodbhoy was a sigh of resignation. As far as Banuri is concerned, this interview has destroyed Ata Ur Rehman reputation even if he is able to remain in the good books of IK. It is said that that PM IK is 'Katcha of Kan' and this seems to be a case here. I am surprised that Banuri was not given an opportunity to explain himself or his policies as a chief regulator of higher education..
The main problem is teaching. I am doing bachelors in engineering from a reputed university of Pakistan but the teachers here don't know the basics of their subject. So what will be the output? 0. And the cycle will continue itself. We rely on TH-cam to pass the semester courses. Unfortunately if someone complain about the teacher then get ready for worst.
It's deep and bitter truth of our state education system. Ruling elites & civil and military beruocratics has been educated abroad and shifted their families over there but no space for us ( middle ,lower class of this country). In this situation will state( Islamic Republic Of Pakistan) educate the people like us with standard education? answer would be no ,but divide and rule over them. Kise Parcham K sayie Taleh Hum Ek Hain. Same here 🤗.
Sorry state of every education imparting institution. Be it a business institute or humanities or natural sciences. Been through the same situation throughout my bachelors
Iss bunday ka tau mind bhi corrupt ho chuka hai, public private partner-ship ko corruption keh raha hai lol. Aisay logon ki wajah se hee saara education system baith chuka hai hehe. Good job PTI
A very informative and insightful talk. Dr Banuri followed the correct path and rightly went to the court. All academic institutions and authorities must follow the rules set by the regulator, otherwise what's the point of having a regulator.
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person. The true facts what’s said about Tariq Banuri. “HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan. 1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded. 2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC. 3) Another important programme “ Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years. 4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far! 5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work. Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
Being the student of university I endorsed Dr Buniri that the capacity of teachers in universities is zero, they have not the skill to train or incalcute the exat knowledge of what is the need of time. I have studied half of the degree but even I don't know that how to link the knowledge which I have gained from university to the current market.
Iss bunday ka tau mind bhi corrupt ho chuka hai, public private partner-ship ko corruption keh raha hai lol. Aisay logon ki wajah se hee saara education system baith chuka hai hehe. Good job PTI
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person. The true facts what’s said about Tariq Banuri. “HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan. 1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded. 2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC. 3) Another important programme “ Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years. 4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far! 5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work. Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person. The true facts what’s said about Tariq Banuri. “HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan. 1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded. 2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC. 3) Another important programme “ Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years. 4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far! 5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work. Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
Dr. Hoodbhoy should understand that at the time of COVID-19 pandemic only established virology institute could come up with some solutions. Nations has to build the capacity in advance to fight against such pandemic. However, in response to the national emergency caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, the ICCBS (PCMD) took an initiative to work together with the government for the diagnostics of COVID-19 in Karachi and carried out more than 0.135 million Real-time PCR based tests from various districts of Karachi. The institute has also done identification and mutational analysis of SARS-CoV-2 genome in Pakistani population and also working on the identification of variant strains of SARS-CoV-2.
I watched this program today and so happy that Dr. Banuri is reinstated as chairman HEC. Thank-you Pakistan high court and best of luck Dr. sahab. Please help our country to get rid of these parasites.
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person. The true facts what’s said about Tariq Banuri. “HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan. 1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded. 2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC. 3) Another important programme “ Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years. 4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far! 5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work. Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
Pervaze Sahib thank you for inviting Banuri Sahib for this edifying discussion, I am in sympathy with him. I hope he is reinstated to his position before long. I would like for someone to explain to me why it's the voice of reason that is always silenced in Pakistan. Pervaze Sahib to paraphrase the poet " While kites and buzzards prey at liberty. It's a shame that we eagles are caged up while the vultures are free to do whatever they please". Enjoyed the conversation very much.
Iss Tariq Banuri ka tau mind bhi corrupt ho chuka hai, public private partner-ship ko corruption keh raha hai lol. Aisay logon ki wajah se hee saara education system baith chuka hai hehe. Good job PTI
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person. The true facts what’s said about Tariq Banuri. “HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan. 1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded. 2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC. 3) Another important programme “ Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years. 4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far! 5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work. Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
Very sad and confusing situation after seeing this episode. Not possible to rectify the situation. As all spoiled children of high ups are working in such organisations.
these are serious points, detailed investigation is required in the matter. I believe Dr atta is a man of honour, he should himself ask PM to have a judicial inquiry of these allegations. Not having detailed inquiry will leave stains on Dr. Aata whole life and particularly his research work and will severely hamper the careers of students/scholars studying in those departments,
Dr Banuri's proposal for grants to be linked to performance, and the Government's or rather, the Bureaucracy's knee-jerk, almost alarmist reaction to it reminds me of 'Yes Minister', Dr Richard Cartwright's concept of Performance as a basis of funding for local government bodies, and the reaction of the heads of bureaucracy...
After serving almost 3 years, if you are saying that journals in Pakistan are Scam and they way you are highlighting other issues in the University governance and in quality of faculty/PhD without mentioning any of your actions to improve the system, then actually, you have made your own charge sheet. thank you.
Has there been a formal study undertaken into the Quality of the written PhD thesis and the correlation between the presented work and the written submission? And on the Quality and supervision of PhD candidates in Public sector Universities?
Dr. Atta Ur Rehman to mess up with research --- he started publications MAFIA in universities. In academia, a race for publication to get promotions, just hurt the quality of our research. Every other person is PhD in Pakistan, to get a PhD was made very easy ---- which made the degree worthless. I wish we could more learned, honest and true academician like Pervez Hoodbhoy.
Hello sir Sir I want to meet you just for 15 minutes Because I have a series question regarding relations , and it disturb me a lot I have discussed with various scholars but nobody gives me an appreciated answer . I hope that you will reply me.
At least many universities are opened in atta ur Rehman time and lot of Students are able to get degree at that time. Now if those students doesn't produce any international level thing then these people also didn't.
I am reading a book called Big Ideas Simply Explained in Economics. Just the kind of person with whom I would love to discuss the book..he is Harvard-educated in economics.:):) Pakistan need not suffer so much,seems to have very competent people,but horrible politics and politicians.:):)
And I'm reading a book, Why Nations Fail. Though it doesn't say anything about our country, but our country is the same as failed nation, soon it will come to the last position because of such puppet parties and man, Imran Khan
@@amirlateef1934 India is a failed country too. India breathed a bit under a Sikh scholar Dr Manmohan Singh but hindus have pulled it back into poverty of Hindu rate of growth
Dr. Tariq Banuri did his Best in Destruction of Technology Education of PAK. He didn't forwarded the National Technology Council NTC Act that was lying unattended in HEC for 4 years. Due to his lack of interest and support for PEC, future of Technology Graduates is undecided for Decades. Solid proofs are available ⚠️
Dr. Tariq Banuri did his better in destruction of Technology Education of Pakistan . He didn't forwarded the National Technology Council Act which is laying unintended in HEC for 4 year .
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person. The true facts what’s said about Tariq Banuri. “HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan. 1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded. 2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC. 3) Another important programme “ Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years. 4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far! 5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work. Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
What you would expect from the universities in Pakistan where basic thing's are not available. It's very easy to say that local PhDs are incompetent but please spend sometime and see what kind of problems they face. Research can only be done with full peace of mind.
بے بنیاد عمارت ہے کسی وقت بھی زمیں بوس ہوسکتی ہے ۔ بے صلاحیت لوگوں کے یہی کام ہوتے ہیں کہ با صلاحیت لوگوں پر الزام لگا کر ہی کچھ سستی شہرت حاصل کر لی جائے۔
Dr Atta-Ur-Rehman should also be invited and allowed to defend himself. His point of view should also be taken into account. One sided point of view may NOT reveal the entire truth.
Us interview mein 3 sawal yeh honay chahay 1. Are you and your British National? 2. What is your roll in Bentham sceince? 3. Why more than 50% HEJ faculty belongs to you or your loved Child Iqbal ch...
I am quite shocked and saddened to know what is being revealed by these two able professors. However, listening and believing in one sided stories may not reveal the whole truth. Although personal programs through TH-cam are not that credible and impartial in my opinion but in order to take this discussion to a reasonable conclusion Mr. Hood Bhoy should invite Dr Ata-ur-Rehman in his program in the presence of Dr. Banuri in order to find what is right or wrong. However, such national issues can only be explored and exposed honestly when they are debated in independent public forums where academicians, observers and huge number of educated people are invited and asked to participate in the discussion. That is the only way to find the truth and way forward.
National Technology Council is six year old & have started registration of graduate Engineering technologists from 3 years but until now there is no service structure for graduate Engineering technologists
Please ask him why he not forwarded the National Technology Council Act and Service Structure of Engineering Technologists of Pakistan registered with National Technology Council Pakistan since 2018. Why he appoint non Engineering Technologist as a Chairperson of National Technology Council Pakistan against by its bylaws. Why and how he converted National University of Technology Islambad into Engineering University without adopting the bylaws
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person. The true facts what’s said about Tariq Banuri. “HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan. 1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded. 2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC. 3) Another important programme “ Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years. 4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far! 5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work. Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
The most interesting report, I have ever watched. I didn’t know that even our education system would be so much damaged with some poor policies and someones's own benefits. And this is very true that a single piece of paper isn’t sufficient to make you an expert of the subject. One should know what he/she is doing and what has he/she done already? and I should think about myself first. Honestly for a very long time I was not buying what Hoodbhoy was selling (I had my own reasons, and it doesn’t even matter whether I agree with someone or not) but I should say, there must be some people brave enough to highlight such things. We have a saying in Pashto, which means (اگر خود نہیں جانتے تو کسی سے سیکھ لو یا کسی کو دیکھ لو کہ وہ کسطرح کرہا ہے), You have to look at the other nations how they changed themselves. Allah hi hamara haami aur madad gaar ho,, Naaro say kuch nahi badlega simple is that.
this is explosive and shocking to see corruption exposed. Pakistan needs to act against this or it will lose all credibility in the academic world. All academics need to prove themselves and funding must be competitvely awarded based on merit otherwise you will demoralise academic community.
There is highly discouraging atmosphere for research in our universities. Most of professors discourage students who take interest in any research activity. Furthermore, there is no proper research facility in most of our universities, especially they don't take it serious to provide licensed software to students and faculty members. For example, the students of social sciences don't know how to use quantitative and qualitative data analysis software such as SPSS, R, NVivo, MaxQDA etc. This is because we don't teach them. They also don't have access to data collection tools. Our computer labs are pathetic, they have latest computers but they don't have data analysis software installed on them, OR if they have installed these software, most of them are pirated.
Pak education standards have been going downwards for decades and nobody cares. The children of rich/ powerful/ elite go abroad for higher education so why would they care for Pak education standards. If possible, establishment should look into the matters of HEC. Atta ur Rehman is fooling around for too long without any results but only with sweet talk. Allah rehem karay or haram khaane say bachaye. Ameen
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person. The true facts what’s said about Tariq Banuri. “HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan. 1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded. 2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC. 3) Another important programme “ Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years. 4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far! 5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work. Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person. The true facts what’s said about Tariq Banuri. “HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan. 1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded. 2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC. 3) Another important programme “ Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years. 4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far! 5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work. Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
He is so right regarding the PhDs competencies, teaching capabilities of university faculty and the fraud of journals.
Sari Duniya ka yahi hal hai India dekh lein
What you would expect from the universities in Pakistan where basic thing's are not available. It's very easy to say that local PhDs are incompetent but please spend sometime and see what kind of problems they face.
@@AliKhan-mc7bd Khan sb Desi Pardesi 😋 aik hi saff mein Illa MashAllah wicho koi Mehnati laiq bacha niqal aye
What about quality of schooling being provided in higher educational institutions? Then what would be the output of those institutes??
So, PhD are degree holders from HEIs of Pakistan.
100%, people some how get a degree, it could be bachelors, masters, engineering or PhD etc....!
Every word is fact rather bitter reality. I was serving in PU and I exposed one of my colleague's plagiarized paper which was published by Dean Mr. Chawla at PU's HEC recognized Journal of History dept. As a result She was first promoted as professor from Assistant Professor and now she is sitting on Principal's seat and I am kicked out though I completed my PhD in exceptional time in.the field of Art and Design.
So this is level of Vice Chancellor Dr. Niaz Akhter who knowingly all facts made her principal with that plagiarized paper. Paper is deposited in HEC's repository.
Your hardwork will pay off sister
He is a very brave man. He wants to change the structure of old syllabus and come up with new education structure. Thats why government let him to go.
What is being done in our beloved country specially in education sector. Hoodby is requested to invite Dr Atta ur Rehman to also listen his point of view. Nation should know that what is going on
I second.
Iss Tariq Banauri ka tau mind bhi corrupt ho chuka hai, public private partner-ship ko corruption keh raha hai lol. Aisay logon ki wajah se hee saara education system baith chuka hai hehe. Good job PTI
@@aarifboy bro I voted for PTI but unfortunately you did not understand what he really meant. Universities have a lot of land and this plan of public- private partnership was a scheme to grab that land. It is reality that many people have eyes on universities land in big cities like Islamabad and Lahore. He said that he is not against the public-private partnership but strict check and balance and regulatory frameworks should be implemented. Bro its a matter of national importance and above party lines.
@@roselover6784 I do agree with your point
@@aarifboy You sound like educated illiterate, not even a common sense what this gentleman is talking about. Kind of leader ship and atmosphere we have in Pakistan is definitely destined to be doomed.
Every single day we hear this.. education is very important for the progress of society but OUR EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM is flawed... I never knew a person as high as chairman of HEC could face such problems. Thank you professor for bearing down on the actual issues and bloody parasites of educational system.
MORE POWER TO YOU
I listen Dr. Hood with eager and thrust since my high school. I still remember your lectures of physics on live channel. Sir the points which you have highlighted are very shocking and eye opening. RIEP Science in pakistan.
@SultanM85533133 اسلامی جمہوریہ پاکستان ایک دھوکہ اور شرک ہے# دارالاسلام پاکستان شرک سےعلیحدگی کا تصور 1940ء جناح اورمسلمانوں نے فیصلہ کیا کہ اللہ کی مدد سے طلب کریں گےاورمسلمان شرک سے علیحدگی اختیار کرے گا, اللہ نے دعا کی وجہ سے مشرک_جمہوری ہندوستان کو تقسیم کر کے مسلمانوں کو اعتماد میں پاکستان دیا # ڈاکٹر پرویز ہوڈبائے/حسن نثار/ طحہ صدیقی ، آرزو کاظمی ، طاہر گورا اور طارق فتاح مسٹرجاوید غامدی 1956 کے سیکولرسٹوں کے زبردست گروپ میں شامل ہیں جیسے چیف جسٹس منیر ٹائپ لوگوں نے اللہ کےساتھ غداری کی,جواسلامی پاکستان کو ریپبلیکن ازم کے ساتھ تشکیل دے کرکے پاکستان کو شرک کی راہ میں[1956] سے لے کرگامزن کیا ہوہے ہیں۔ ان سیکولروں لوگوں نے اللہ کے ساتھ دھوکہ کیا ہے, اور, دارالاسلام کو دوبارہ جمہوری # بےدین# ہستی کے نام کے ساتھ پاکستان کومنسلک کر کے اسلامی ریاست کو شرک میں شا مل کرکے, انہیں خوشی ہے کہ ہم کئی دہائیوں سے پاکستانیوں کو بے وقوف بنا رہے ہیں سیکولر مذہب میڈیا غلط بیانیے کو فروغ دینا چاہتآ ہے، جس سے قرآن مجید روکتا ہے. پاکستان کے کچھ ناظرین بھی اللہ/محمد صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کی شریعت کی پرواہ نہیں کرتے. سیکولرازم صرف ایک اور مذہب ہے, یہ اسلام کو دبا کر اپنےغلط جذبات پر مبنی مذہب کی تصدیق کو سننا/فروغ دینا چاہتے ہیں English Urdu Quran 15;26 We created man of dried clay, of black mud, formed into shape: (27) and we had before created the devil of subtle fire. (28) And remember when thy Lord said unto the angels, Verily I am about to create man of dried clay, of black mud, wrought into shape; (29) when, therefore, I shall have completely formed him, and shall have breathed of My spirit into him, do ye fall down and worship him. (30) And all the angels worshipped Adam together, (31) except Iblís, who refused to be with those who worshipped him. (32) And God said unto him, O Iblís, what hindered thee from being with those who worshipped Adam? (33) He answered, It is not fit that I should worship man, whom thou hast created of dried clay, of black mud, wrought into shape. (34) God said, Get thee therefore hence: for thou shalt be driven away with stones: (35) and a curse shall be on thee, until the day of judgment. (36) The devil said, O Lord, Give me respite until the day of resurrection. (37) God answered, Verily thou shalt be one of those who are respited (38) until the day of the appointed time. (39) The Iblís replied, O Lord, because thou hast seduced me, I will surely tempt them to disobedience in the earth; (40) and I will seduce such of them as shall be thy chosen servants. (41) God said This is the right way with me. (42) Verily as to my servants, thou shalt have no power over them; but over those only who shall be seduced, and who shall follow thee. (43) And hell is surely denounced unto them all: (44) it hath seven gates; unto every gate, a distinct company of them shall be assigned.قرآن ;15 26. ہم نے انسان کو خشک مٹی سے ، کالی مٹی سے بنا دیا ، شکل میں بنا: (27) اور اس سے پہلے ہم نے لطیف آگ کا جن ی پیدا کیا تھا۔ () 28) اور یاد کرو جب تمہارے پروردگار نے فرشتوں سے کہا بے شک میں انسان کو خشک مٹی سے، کالی مٹی سے پیدا کرنے والا ہوں، () 29) جب، میں اس کو مکمل طور پر تشکیل دوں گا ، اور اس میں میری روح پھونک دوں گا ، تو کیا تم اس کے نیچے گر پڑو اور سجدہ کرو؟ () 30) اور تمام فرشتوں نے مل کر آدم کو سجدہ کیا، () 31) سوائے ابلیس کے، جس نے اس کی عبادت کرنے والوں کے ساتھ رہنے سے انکار کردیا۔ () 32) اور اللہ نے اس سے کہا، اے ابلیس ، کس چیز نے تمہیں آدمیوں کے ساتھ رہنے سے روک دیا؟ () 33) اس نے جواب دیا ، یہ مناسب نہیں ہے کہ میں اس آدمی کی عبادت کروں جس کو تو نے خشک مٹی سے ، کالی مٹی سے پیدا کیا ہے ، جس کی شکل آپ نے بنائی ہے۔ () 34) خدا نے کہا اس لئے یہاں سے چلی جا کیونکہ تمہیں پتھروں سے بھگا دیا جائے گا۔ () 35) اور قیامت تک تم پر لعنت ہوگی۔ () 36) شیطان نے کہا ، اے خداوند ، مجھے قیامت کے دن تک مہلت دو۔ () 37) اللہ نے جواب دیا، بیشک تو مہلت پانے والوں میں سے ہو گا (38) مقررہ وقت تک () 39) شیطان نے جواب دیا، اے خداوند ، اس لئے کہ تو نے مجھے بہکایا، میں ان کو زمین میں نافرمانی کا لالچ دوں گا۔ () 40) اور میں ان میں سے ایسے لوگوں کو بہکا دوں گا جو تیرے منتخب بندے ہوں گے۔ (41) اللہ نے کہا ، یہ میرے ساتھ صحیح طریقہ ہے۔ ((( یہ صحیح طریقہ ہے ، جیسے ، "میرے ابدی فرمان کے مطابق ، منتخب لوگوں کی بچت اور شریروں کی سراسر بدعنوانی۔))) () 42) بے شک میرے بندوں کے بارے میں ، تم پر ان کا اختیار نہیں ہے۔ لیکن صرف ان لوگوں کے لئے جو بہکاوے میں ہوں گے ، اور جو آپ کے پیچھے چلیں گے۔ () 43) اور یقینا ان سب کے لئے جہنم کی مذمت کی جائے گی (44 44) اس کے سات دروازے ہیں۔ ہر ایک دروازے پر ان کی ایک الگ کمپنی تفویض کی جائے گی۔
Commented on France Reaction to TLP Protests & Pakistan's Image? Taha Siddiqui & Arzoo Kazmi wTahir Gora @TAG TV
@@sultanmahmood6396 Please leave religion out of this. It has already destroyed everything.
@@nadermazari3334 Thank you for your dim view, You can't be a serious believer if you start asserting that religion has destroyed everything in society, My whole point above was about the people who give priority to [Aql] reason, who take reason as a legislator, they are the ones who have destroyed humanity by adopting the wrong god, the reason is a mere calculator it can not explain reality without religion., this is where secular centric gods have been misled through unqualified conjectures. It is a breathless folly to follow science alone to find reality. Without religion, man is no better than cattle.
آپ کے دھیمے خیال کے لئے آپ کا شکریہ ،
آپ سنجیدہ مومن نہیں ہو سکتے اگر آپ یہ دعوی کرنا شروع کردیں
کہ مذہب معاشرے میں ہر چیز کو تباہ کر رہا ہے تو ، میرا پورا نکتہ
ان لوگوں کے بارے میں تھا جو [عقل] کو ترجیح دیتے ہیں ،
جو عقل کو قانون ساز کی حیثیت د یتے ہیں ،
وہی لوگ ہیں جنہوں نے غلط خدا کو اپناتے ہوئے انسانیت کو تباہ کر دیا ،
عقل محض کیلکولیٹر ہے جو مذہب کے بغیر حقیقت کی وضاحت نہیں کرسکتا۔
، یہی وہ جگہ ہے جہاں سیکولر مرکز پرست خداؤں کو نااہل قیاسوں کے ذریعے گمراہ کیا گیا ہے۔
حقیقت ڈھونڈنے کے لئے تنہا سائنس پرعمل کرنا ایک دم گھٹیا حماقت ہے۔
اسلامی(قرآن) مذہب کےانکشاف بغیرانسان مویشیوں سے بہتر نہیں۔
@@sultanmahmood6396 And please refrain from using idiotic terms like "dim view." I can return the favor in kind. We can all agree to disagree. But as I have always seen, the religious will resort to name-calling instantly.
@@nadermazari3334 I acknowledge your concerns, about strainful terms, but you must appreciate your initial irresponsible slandering religion, someone has to correct misguided perceptions of people, by Amr-Bil-Maroof) of encouraging people to do or to say what is good. Maruf is anything that has been approved in divine law. Nahi Anil Munkar means forbidding evil by discouraging people from doing or initially stating what is wrong.
Not heard such a thought provoking interview regarding eduction and higher education in our country...
More respect to you sir. You are a gem sort of a person don't compromise on your integrity. Please bring forward all the prevailing flaws in our higher education in every forum.Kudos
corrupt system. At least you took stand against it. Great sir.
Who took what stand?
I am totally shocked after this interview ....
Thank you professor hoodbhoy for this discussion, it's an eye opener
It is a fake story by a sacked HEC chairman. Dont take it serious.
Thanks Dr sahib for conducting interview with Dr Tariq. Firstly I got chance to listen the person who know his work vision and really trying for the betterment in education sector. I highly appriciate Dr Tariq for his bold interview which is based on solid facts. An honest person can spoke not number two like Dr atta. Dr Tariq for us u the Chairman HEC we need people like u. So Pl fight ur case our prayers are with u. People like u should be on such positions for the future of Pakistan.
Dr Tariq stay blessed and thanks Dr bahi for conducting interview and bring real picture in front of public without any fear.
This corrupt system doesn't deserve true leaders like you sir. More power to you👍🏻
Really sad to hear about our corrupt system
I am doing my bachelor's from one of the top universities in the country and I can assure you that what ever he's saying is absolutely true.
So unfortunate!!!!! May Banuri come back INSHALLAH
😔
Agree
Sir, thank you for supporting Dr. Tariq Banuri. To be honest, it didn't surprise me at all. Corruption in HEJ and other research centers, the level of PhDs, local journal fraud, and poor teaching standards, are all obvious issues.
This whole open discussion is actually healthy- may this invite closer introspection from the government on HEJ and may Rahman and his corruption be exposed
Dr atta is the man who destroyed the college education totally
It's the college which feed the university
College is bridge between the school n university.......it takes input from school process it n gives it to the university
Great video and thanks for uploading Dr. Hoodbhoy. I am glad that I found your channel. Pakistan is such a corrupt place. Shocking to see that the space of higher education is also not safe from it.
37:20 I completely agree. I know this as I was refused my right to keep copyrights and my teachers and institute instead of accepting my case study and publish it instead blacklisted me on this issue
First of all thank you Mr. Pervez Hoodbhoy for bringing Mr. Tariq Banuri for an interview. Hats off to you sir, Mr. Tariq Banuri, for believing and having the courage to fix things in such a country like Pakistan. Going face to face with the dilemma of corruption that has engulfed our beautiful country. If I had the power, instead of taking a year away from you, I would have given you twenty more. I wish we had more and more people like you, if not that, at least and I hope from the bottom of my heart that they wake up. My prayers are with you in you endeavours, stay strong.
One sided story.
May he brought back INSHALLAH
Most important interview/discussion of 2021 on where Pakistan is headed.
Excellent critique by both.
A very versatile personalities of Pakistan 💚. On such pillars we are still standing.
There is a lot more to it than meets the eye. Dr. Banuri was one of the architects of University Reform Act which started piling up already full Pandora Box he is talking about in this interview. Higher education, unfortunately, is enslaving the recipients rather than freeing them. This has become true universally, though more so in countries like ours. The 🐀 race of publications in our higher education system has contaminated the very soul of scholarship. The useless research output which Dr. Rahman boasts of has not even remotely contributed to the technological capability of our country. This interview was very important in terms of contribution made by Dr. Hoodbhoy. As always, he exposes courageously and prudently what ought to be exposed.
knowing the truth from an incumbent chairman about the previous discrepancies through HEC is really painful. Well, not just hope we need to work on the current issues at both education, research, and administrative level.
Sir how we contact you regarding guidelines about studies
A great interview. I salute both Banuri and Hoodbhoy!
Excellent discussion.
Dr pervaiz hoodbhoi thanks jazakAllah for ur endeavours... Who will sort out this matter ?? ..this is extremely serious
So sad to know about the realities about HEJ, PhDs, local Journals and teaching standards in Pakistan. May Allah help this nation.
Mr. Irfan Saleem I invite you to kindly visit www.iccs.edu. You cant reply on such fake things mentioned by a person only to safe his position.
This interview seem to be against HEJ. Being physicist and economist Dr. Hoodbhoy and Dr. Banuri, respectively, what are your achievements?
Samer yousaf i have seen ur teaching you don't know any thing and i challenge you to give us x ray lecture online
Dr khalid what is your achievement? You are the most disrespect person oh hej
Mr. Toor Lala, kindly put off your fake id and come on with your real name otherwise you are coward person. Put off your fake curtains.
So true. I have studied software engg but none of the teachers in my dept were a true software engr and most were not eveb software engrs. As per the professors, I can tell you they had not written or executed a single line of code in the past decade...
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person.
The true facts what’s
said about Tariq Banuri.
“HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan.
1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded.
2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC.
3) Another important programme “
Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years.
4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far!
5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work.
Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
I agree with you.
I had done the same thing software engineering.
Our teachers even itself don't know the coding.
Simple atm code is considered as mind blowing in pakistani universities
@@mkansari007 all of these seem to be money grabbing scams.
The last sigh by Hoodbhoy said it all.
Intellectual dishonesty is much more harmful in the long term for the nation than corruption like commissions, money laundering etc.
In the first case, one cheat others or a system which can be mended or reversed but what can you do when one is dishonest with his own self.
This is called self delusion and when it becomes a national phenomenon, it is difficult to get out of it for centuries. After the sack of Baghdad Islamic civilization never recovered.
The last sigh of Hoodbhoy was a sigh of resignation.
As far as Banuri is concerned, this interview has destroyed Ata Ur Rehman reputation even if he is able to remain in the good books of IK.
It is said that that PM IK is 'Katcha of Kan' and this seems to be a case here.
I am surprised that Banuri was not given an opportunity to explain himself or his policies as a chief regulator of higher education..
Very sad.
As educationist/researcher i feel demoralised
The main problem is teaching. I am doing bachelors in engineering from a reputed university of Pakistan but the teachers here don't know the basics of their subject. So what will be the output? 0. And the cycle will continue itself. We rely on TH-cam to pass the semester courses. Unfortunately if someone complain about the teacher then get ready for worst.
Name of the university?
It's deep and bitter truth of our state education system.
Ruling elites & civil and military beruocratics has been educated abroad and shifted their families over there but no space for us ( middle ,lower class of this country).
In this situation will state( Islamic Republic Of Pakistan) educate the people like us with standard education?
answer would be no ,but divide and rule over them.
Kise Parcham K sayie Taleh Hum Ek Hain.
Same here 🤗.
Can't agree more.
Sorry state of every education imparting institution. Be it a business institute or humanities or natural sciences. Been through the same situation throughout my bachelors
Iss bunday ka tau mind bhi corrupt ho chuka hai, public private partner-ship ko corruption keh raha hai lol. Aisay logon ki wajah se hee saara education system baith chuka hai hehe. Good job PTI
This man speaks sense and wisdom. The day Dr Pervez Hoodbhai will have 1 million subscribers Pakistan will change!
Sir how to improve writing expression essay writing and columns
Good job sir keep exposing our education system
A very informative and insightful talk. Dr Banuri followed the correct path and rightly went to the court. All academic institutions and authorities must follow the rules set by the regulator, otherwise what's the point of having a regulator.
Thank you Dr Hoodbhoy and Dr Banuri, I wish there are more people like you who can fearlessly expose the selectors and selected.
The problem is bigger than that
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person.
The true facts what’s
said about Tariq Banuri.
“HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan.
1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded.
2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC.
3) Another important programme “
Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years.
4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far!
5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work.
Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
very informative to me about phds
Being the student of university I endorsed Dr Buniri that the capacity of teachers in universities is zero, they have not the skill to train or incalcute the exat knowledge of what is the need of time. I have studied half of the degree but even I don't know that how to link the knowledge which I have gained from university to the current market.
Higher education is based on andragogy, adults must learn own their own with directions from the faculty.
May Allah Kareem help our country and give our leadership the sense to know what’s really good for country.
Great minds discuss ideas
Average minds discuss events
Small minds discuss people
Eleanor Roosevelt
Both greats here👍🏽
Iss bunday ka tau mind bhi corrupt ho chuka hai, public private partner-ship ko corruption keh raha hai lol. Aisay logon ki wajah se hee saara education system baith chuka hai hehe. Good job PTI
@@aarifboy can you elaborate a bit about it
@@aarifboy k and your pti
Your quote does not fit in this situation.
Eye opening video...
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person.
The true facts what’s
said about Tariq Banuri.
“HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan.
1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded.
2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC.
3) Another important programme “
Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years.
4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far!
5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work.
Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
The entire episode is due to his refusal to recruit maryam wattoo (sister pinky peerni)
Is it true ????
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person.
The true facts what’s
said about Tariq Banuri.
“HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan.
1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded.
2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC.
3) Another important programme “
Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years.
4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far!
5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work.
Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
Thankyou for such an intelligent talk. Sad to know the facts though
Dr. Hoodbhoy should understand that at the time of COVID-19 pandemic only established virology institute could come up with some solutions. Nations has to build the capacity in advance to fight against such pandemic. However, in response to the national emergency caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, the ICCBS (PCMD) took an initiative to work together with the government for the diagnostics of COVID-19 in Karachi and carried out more than 0.135 million Real-time PCR based tests from various districts of Karachi. The institute has also done identification and mutational analysis of SARS-CoV-2 genome in Pakistani population and also working on the identification of variant strains of SARS-CoV-2.
I know that you people forcefully call student for that and when some refuse you people delay their mphil, phd
Dr zaheer is more productive but not promoted as fast as Dr musharaf, why?
Because you people make good coffee for director, and Dr zaheer not
@@toorlala9765 Totally fake I am already enrolled 2nd semester student
You know the phrase "lot of movement of the arm and nothing moves forward" that is HEJ.
Great discussion..... Loved it.
I watched this program today and so happy that Dr. Banuri is reinstated as chairman HEC. Thank-you Pakistan high court and best of luck Dr. sahab. Please help our country to get rid of these parasites.
We all should ask for accountability. Send emails to HEJ and all other universities and start start citizen accountability.
No doubt Dr. Atta play vital role to develope scientific innovations in Pakistan but cannot ingonre the facts which Dr. Hood discussed.
Oh my God! We are at your mercy. Help us.
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person.
The true facts what’s
said about Tariq Banuri.
“HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan.
1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded.
2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC.
3) Another important programme “
Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years.
4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far!
5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work.
Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
uff sir..........................................!
Sir i have a question for Chairman sab how many did u hired consultants and what was their efficiency and performance?
Pervaze Sahib thank you for inviting Banuri Sahib for this edifying discussion, I am in sympathy with him. I hope he is reinstated to his position before long. I would like for someone to explain to me why it's the voice of reason that is always silenced in Pakistan. Pervaze Sahib to paraphrase the poet " While kites and buzzards prey at liberty. It's a shame that we eagles are caged up while the vultures are free to do whatever they please". Enjoyed the conversation very much.
Being alive can be construed as a felony in a vulture's world.
Iss Tariq Banuri ka tau mind bhi corrupt ho chuka hai, public private partner-ship ko corruption keh raha hai lol. Aisay logon ki wajah se hee saara education system baith chuka hai hehe. Good job PTI
❤️❤️❤️❤️
Wonderful and very much eye opening talk❤️👏
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person.
The true facts what’s
said about Tariq Banuri.
“HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan.
1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded.
2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC.
3) Another important programme “
Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years.
4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far!
5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work.
Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
I fail to understand how can one (IK) be so brazen to self claim to be Sadeeq aur ameen?
Wonderful sir. Keep educating us. Love you.
Very sad and confusing situation after seeing this episode. Not possible to rectify the situation. As all spoiled children of high ups are working in such organisations.
💓
May Allah bless Pakistan and long live both of you.
If the so-called leader is imran khan, who never remembers what he said before being the PM, Pakistan will never have a good future.
these are serious points, detailed investigation is required in the matter. I believe Dr atta is a man of honour, he should himself ask PM to have a judicial inquiry of these allegations. Not having detailed inquiry will leave stains on Dr. Aata whole life and particularly his research work and will severely hamper the careers of students/scholars studying in those departments,
He's a fraud and he will never ask for that because he will get exposed. But may Allah expose his crimes.
Dr Banuri's proposal for grants to be linked to performance, and the Government's or rather, the Bureaucracy's knee-jerk, almost alarmist reaction to it reminds me of 'Yes Minister', Dr Richard Cartwright's concept of Performance as a basis of funding for local government bodies, and the reaction of the heads of bureaucracy...
After serving almost 3 years, if you are saying that journals in Pakistan are Scam and they way you are highlighting other issues in the University governance and in quality of faculty/PhD without mentioning any of your actions to improve the system, then actually, you have made your own charge sheet. thank you.
آپ نے pm کے ساتھ میٹنگ میں کس کو عمران خان کے ساتھ بیٹے دیکھا۔ آپ اس سے اندازہ لگا سکتے ہیں کے صورت حال کیا ہے
Listen to his other interviews. He mentions this in detail. He also mentioned some here, clean your ears and listen again
A true talk.
Has there been a formal study undertaken into the Quality of the written PhD thesis and the correlation between the presented work and the written submission? And on the Quality and supervision of PhD candidates in Public sector Universities?
Dr. Atta Ur Rehman to mess up with research --- he started publications MAFIA in universities. In academia, a race for publication to get promotions, just hurt the quality of our research. Every other person is PhD in Pakistan, to get a PhD was made very easy ---- which made the degree worthless. I wish we could more learned, honest and true academician like Pervez Hoodbhoy.
It's Imran Khan era. Right and wrong does not matter. What matter is his personal will and if u don't fall in line they will push u out of line.
People that bend down for his nonsense get pushed out of line -this Imran Khan needs to get out
Excellent interview.
there are no videos on astrophysics in urdu sir
"What ever you do give islamic touch", so touchy😀 99% pakistani agree with it
Hello sir
Sir I want to meet you just for 15 minutes
Because I have a series question regarding relations , and it disturb me a lot
I have discussed with various scholars but nobody gives me an appreciated answer .
I hope that you will reply me.
Sorry not relations but religion
At least many universities are opened in atta ur Rehman time and lot of Students are able to get degree at that time. Now if those students doesn't produce any international level thing then these people also didn't.
Pathetic
This country doesn't deserve Dr Buneri
Here it is impossible to work honestly
He was very Honest...... With his all relatives.
sir ye 2nd class bachlor degree 2.5 CGPA ko kehte hai ye 3 CGPA ko?
I am reading a book called Big Ideas Simply Explained in Economics. Just the kind of person with whom I would love to discuss the book..he is Harvard-educated in economics.:):)
Pakistan need not suffer so much,seems to have very competent people,but horrible politics and politicians.:):)
And I'm reading a book, Why Nations Fail. Though it doesn't say anything about our country, but our country is the same as failed nation, soon it will come to the last position because of such puppet parties and man, Imran Khan
@@amirlateef1934 India is a failed country too. India breathed a bit under a Sikh scholar Dr Manmohan Singh but hindus have pulled it back into poverty of Hindu rate of growth
Good analysis
Sir Bzu university Multan teacher has very bad condition
Dr. Tariq Banuri did his Best in Destruction of Technology Education of PAK.
He didn't forwarded the National Technology Council NTC Act that was lying unattended in HEC for 4 years.
Due to his lack of interest and support for PEC, future of Technology Graduates is undecided for Decades.
Solid proofs are available ⚠️
Right
Due to lack of interest for technology education's future this is good decision taken by Federal government.
Dr. Tariq Banuri did his better in destruction of Technology Education of Pakistan . He didn't forwarded the National Technology Council Act which is laying unintended in HEC for 4 year .
Tariq banori is so descent. he has very calm and descent. The way he talks. He is very tolerant
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person.
The true facts what’s
said about Tariq Banuri.
“HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan.
1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded.
2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC.
3) Another important programme “
Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years.
4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far!
5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work.
Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
What you would expect from the universities in Pakistan where basic thing's are not available. It's very easy to say that local PhDs are incompetent but please spend sometime and see what kind of problems they face. Research can only be done with full peace of mind.
Throughout the discussion I was like whaaaattt 😳
Because we enjoy hearing fake stories.😁😂
بے بنیاد عمارت ہے کسی وقت بھی زمیں بوس ہوسکتی ہے ۔ بے صلاحیت لوگوں کے یہی کام ہوتے ہیں کہ با صلاحیت لوگوں پر الزام لگا کر ہی کچھ سستی شہرت حاصل کر لی جائے۔
sir please make videos on astrophysics and cosmology
Dr Atta-Ur-Rehman should also be invited and allowed to defend himself. His point of view should also be taken into account. One sided point of view may NOT reveal the entire truth.
Us interview mein 3 sawal yeh honay chahay
1. Are you and your British National?
2. What is your roll in Bentham sceince?
3. Why more than 50% HEJ faculty belongs to you or your loved Child Iqbal ch...
No one needs to hear his nonsense
I am quite shocked and saddened to know what is being revealed by these two able professors. However, listening and believing in one sided stories may not reveal the whole truth. Although personal programs through TH-cam are not that credible and impartial in my opinion but in order to take this discussion to a reasonable conclusion Mr. Hood Bhoy should invite Dr Ata-ur-Rehman in his program in the presence of Dr. Banuri in order to find what is right or wrong. However, such national issues can only be explored and exposed honestly when they are debated in independent public forums where academicians, observers and huge number of educated people are invited and asked to participate in the discussion. That is the only way to find the truth and way forward.
National Technology Council is six year old & have started registration of graduate Engineering technologists from 3 years but until now there is no service structure for graduate Engineering technologists
Urdu material is not available
Allah kaa shukar hai
A level problems
Eye opener, I am with Banuri sahib, May God bless him long life and to serve Pakistan.
What a monumental loss for Pakistan!
Please ask him why he not forwarded the National Technology Council Act and Service Structure of Engineering Technologists of Pakistan registered with National Technology Council Pakistan since 2018. Why he appoint non Engineering Technologist as a Chairperson of National Technology Council Pakistan against by its bylaws. Why and how he converted National University of Technology Islambad into Engineering University without adopting the bylaws
Good question.
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person.
The true facts what’s
said about Tariq Banuri.
“HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan.
1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded.
2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC.
3) Another important programme “
Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years.
4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far!
5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work.
Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
The most interesting report, I have ever watched. I didn’t know that even our education system would be so much damaged with some poor policies and someones's own benefits. And this is very true that a single piece of paper isn’t sufficient to make you an expert of the subject. One should know what he/she is doing and what has he/she done already? and I should think about myself first. Honestly for a very long time I was not buying what Hoodbhoy was selling (I had my own reasons, and it doesn’t even matter whether I agree with someone or not) but I should say, there must be some people brave enough to highlight such things. We have a saying in Pashto, which means (اگر خود نہیں جانتے تو کسی سے سیکھ لو یا کسی کو دیکھ لو کہ وہ کسطرح کرہا ہے), You have to look at the other nations how they changed themselves. Allah hi hamara haami aur madad gaar ho,, Naaro say kuch nahi badlega simple is that.
this is explosive and shocking to see corruption exposed. Pakistan needs to act against this or it will lose all credibility in the academic world. All academics need to prove themselves and funding must be competitvely awarded based on merit otherwise you will demoralise academic community.
There is highly discouraging atmosphere for research in our universities. Most of professors discourage students who take interest in any research activity. Furthermore, there is no proper research facility in most of our universities, especially they don't take it serious to provide licensed software to students and faculty members. For example, the students of social sciences don't know how to use quantitative and qualitative data analysis software such as SPSS, R, NVivo, MaxQDA etc. This is because we don't teach them. They also don't have access to data collection tools. Our computer labs are pathetic, they have latest computers but they don't have data analysis software installed on them, OR if they have installed these software, most of them are pirated.
Ye kon sa research center ha Jo 3 ka cluster ha?
Pak education standards have been going downwards for decades and nobody cares. The children of rich/ powerful/ elite go abroad for higher education so why would they care for Pak education standards. If possible, establishment should look into the matters of HEC. Atta ur Rehman is fooling around for too long without any results but only with sweet talk.
Allah rehem karay or haram khaane say bachaye. Ameen
محترم ڈاکٹر صاحب _میٹ دی پریس میں کیے جانے والے سوالات کے جوابات ایسے ہی تھے جیسے سوال گندم جواب چنا ۔
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person.
The true facts what’s
said about Tariq Banuri.
“HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan.
1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded.
2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC.
3) Another important programme “
Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years.
4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far!
5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work.
Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
Bht hee acha hwa
Read this about Tariq Banuri, very inefficient person.
The true facts what’s
said about Tariq Banuri.
“HEC has available more than 8,000 scholarship slots (local plus international) worth about 50 billion rupees which were blocked by Tariq Banuri causing huge damage to higher education in Pakistan.
1) The Rs.22 billion “2000 Overseas PhD Scholarships” scheme Phase III was approved in early 2018. Scholars were to be sent for PhD level training to top 200 universities of the world. It was held back as it did not suit our “foreign masters” since it would have strengthened teaching and research in Pakistan. Only 40 scholarships could be awarded.
2) Another important initiative launched with much fanfare was the US-Pakistan Knowledge Corridor under which Rs. 25 billion were available. The programme was approved in 2017 and 1500 Pakistani scholars were to be sent to top ranked universities in USA. Only about 100 scholarships could be awarded, a huge failure of HEC.
3) Another important programme “
Faculty Development Program-PhD Sudies” was approved at a cost of Rs.7 billion to award 2000 scholarships for PhD Studies in Pakistan. and to carry out research for one year in top universities abroad. Only 120 scholarships could be awarded in last 3 years.
4) Yet another faculty training initiative, the “Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme” worth Rs. 3 billion approved in 2017 for training 1000 scholars had the same fate---- only about 40 persons could benefit from this programme so far!
5) Another programme was approved by under the Knowledge Economy Task Force programme by the Ministry of Science and Technology. Worth Rs. 12 billion, it was approved in March 2020, to sent hundreds of scholars to top universities abroad. On the request by HEC, it was transferred from the Ministry of Science to HEC by the Planning Ministry. Again it has been blocked and not a single scholarship awarded so far. To have about Rs. 50 billion available under several schemes for training of our brightest youth and yet blocked by HEC Chairman clearly indicates a foreign agenda at work.
Our brightest students were thus deprived of the chance of availing PhD level training at top institutions abroad. This has been criminal negligence on the part of HEC and huge damage has been caused to higher education as a result of an apparently deliberate plot to damage higher education. It needs to be investigated by national agencies and those responsible severely punished.”
If investigative journalism is done on scientific research related corruption in this country people will be petrified.
One side of story