I’m a Christian. But this wonderful man speaks a lot of sense. A wonderful advocate for Muslims and Christian’s alike. We need more men like him, in this torrid world we live in.
This is an injustice being attributed to Allah ﷻ similar to how christians believe that people were born with the original sin. Nay, we say just like Rasulullah ﷺ and the Salaf said, that every child is born upon the Fitrah, then it is the parents that turn him into a jew, christian or majoos (zoroastrian). Meaning, it is their parents or environment that corrupts their Fitrah. Otherwise this Ayah Ar-Rum 30:30 - would have no meaning to a person born in a such a state of major sin. Because what he said could be used as a justification by the people of shirk (polytheism and atheism) too, claiming that they were born that way? Just because you want to mold into the american society and seem tolerant, doesn't mean that you should quote what some misguided person said 200 years ago and make it look as if that's what Islam teaches. Allah سبحانه وتعالى said, فِطْرَتَ اللَّهِ الَّتِي فَطَرَ النَّاسَ عَلَيْهَا ۚ لَا تَبْدِيلَ لِخَلْقِ اللَّهِ ۚ ذَٰلِكَ الدِّينُ الْقَيِّمُ وَلَـٰكِنَّ أَكْثَرَ النَّاسِ لَا يَعْلَمُونَ Allah's Fitrah with which He has created mankind. No change let there be in Khalq-illah (i.e. the creation of Allah i.e. the Fitrah - Islamic Monotheism): that is the straight religion, but most of the mankind know not. [Ar-Rum (the Romans) 30:33] The Khalq-illah (i.e. the Fitrah) is the original state, and then that original state is changed by something else, and that's what the Ayah is stating. And that refutes the notion that the original state could be anything other than the Fitrah. There were early Muslims that hinted at evolution - way before the west swallowed it. Now, does that make evolution true? No! Kadhalika (then likewise), just because someone said something a long time ago that people agree with today, doesn't render that old statement into a Hujjah (proof). He knows this. But still he's doing Qiyas by turning the opinion of fulan from 200 years ago into the Asl, then applying it to the Far' (opinion of westerners today), and the 'illah (effective cause) is "tolerance", and then he comes up with a Hukm. Yet he claims to be a person of Usul Al-Fiqh, babbling about the Usuliyeen this and the Usuliyeen that. Nay, we follow the Qur'an and Sunnah in accordance with the understanding of the Salaf (pious predecessors) of this Ummah. And not what fulan or fulan said. That's pure opinion (Ray'). And Ray' is not a source in the Sharee'ah. But let's say that one of the people that engages in the acts of the people of Lut عليه السلام hears this talk, and then thinks to himself that he was born that way, and then he reads the above Ayah. Now, wouldn't he dismiss the Ayah due to your mention of what fulan said 200 years ago? Where's the cautiousness against ignorantly misleading people into erroneous conclusions? No responsibility whatsoever. Rather the Ayah is negating that anyone is born except upon the Fitrah. And the Sunnah emphasize this too. That's because the Ahlul Bid'ah follow the 'Aql and not the Naql. Because if people were born that way, then sending Messengers wouldn't be needed. Are you saying that the people of Lut عليه السلام were dealt with injustice. So they will come up on the Day of Judgement and plead: _"O Allah, we didn't do anything other than the major sin that You created us with, how can it be our fault?"_ Allah سبحانه وتعالى said, رُّسُلًا مُّبَشِّرِينَ وَمُنذِرِينَ لِئَلَّا يَكُونَ لِلنَّاسِ عَلَى اللَّهِ حُجَّةٌ بَعْدَ الرُّسُلِ ۚ وَكَانَ اللَّهُ عَزِيزًا حَكِيمًا Messengers as bearers of good news as well as of warning _in order that mankind should have no plea against Allah after the (coming of) Messengers._ And Allah is Ever All-Powerful, All-Wise. [An-Nisaa' 4:165]
You see the injustice it ascribes to Allah ﷻ? Not only does it ascribe shortcomings like injustice to Allah ﷻ, it renders the Hudud unjust, and renders Risalah (Messengership) and Wahy (Revelation) irrelevant. And it creates determinism (Jabr). Meaning, that people are forced into sinful ways and that they have no free will just like shaytan who was the first determinist and founder of the Jabariyyah doctrine (determinism), ended up blaming his disobedience on Allah ﷻ. Allah سبحانه وتعالى said, قَالَ رَبِّ فَأَنظِرْنِي إِلَىٰ يَوْمِ يُبْعَثُونَ [Iblis (Shaytan - Satan)] said: "O my Lord! Give me then respite till the Day they (the dead) will be resurrected." قَالَ فَإِنَّكَ مِنَ الْمُنظَرِينَ Allah said: "Then, verily, you are of those reprieved." إِلَىٰ يَوْمِ الْوَقْتِ الْمَعْلُومِ "Till the Day of the time appointed." قَالَ رَبِّ بِمَا أَغْوَيْتَنِي لَأُزَيِّنَنَّ لَهُمْ فِي الْأَرْضِ وَلَأُغْوِيَنَّهُمْ أَجْمَعِينَ [Iblis (Shaytan - Satan)] said: _"O my Lord! Because You misled me,_ I shall indeed adorn the path of error for them on the earth, and I shall mislead them all." إِلَّا عِبَادَكَ مِنْهُمُ الْمُخْلَصِينَ "Except Your servants among them Mukhlaseen (sincere who worship You exclusively)." [Al-Hijr 15:36:40] Iblis is saying: _"O Allah, You already knew that I would disobey You, yet You did not prevent it from happening, so You misled me. It was Your fault and not mine."_ Iblis is robbing free will and choice from himself, he is blaming his sin on the Foreknowledge of Allah ﷻ. But he refutes himself, because why didn't he ask for forgiveness? Instead he asked for respite. So did Allah ﷻ force him to ask for respite too? Because Iblis is acknowledging his sin and admitting that what he did was wrong by ascribing misguidance to what he did, yet he asks for respite instead of forgiveness? So did Allah ﷻ prevent him from turning back to Him with Tawbah (repentance)? No, he chose kibr (arrogance), fisq (rebelliousness) and asked for respite until he was given it. See why he asked for respite in Al-Israa' 17:62. Whereas Adam and Hawwa' عليهما السلام also disobeyed their Lord. But instead of robbing themselves of free will and blaming their disobedience and sin on Allah's ﷻ Foreknowledge for not preventing it, nor becoming deluded determinists that ascribe injustice to Allah ﷻ - they blamed it on themselves, on their own shortcomings, thus acknowledging responsibility and free will, and then repenting by asking for forgiveness until they were forgiven. See Al-Baqarah 2:37. Allah ﷻ forgave our parents, and there's no such thing as "the original sin". They are of the people of Jannah who will return to their Home that they were expelled from for this world of toiling and testing and the abode of deeds, reaching truth and reaching realization. So both Iblis vs Adam and Hawwa' عليهما السلام were given what they asked for. Respite vs Forgiveness. Allah سبحانه وتعالى said, وَنَادَاهُمَا رَبُّهُمَا أَلَمْ أَنْهَكُمَا عَن تِلْكُمَا الشَّجَرَةِ وَأَقُل لَّكُمَا إِنَّ الشَّيْطَانَ لَكُمَا عَدُوٌّ مُّبِينٌ And their Lord called out to them (saying): "Did I not forbid you that tree and tell you (aforetime): 'Verily, Shaytan (i.e. Iblis) is an open enemy unto you?' " قَالَا رَبَّنَا ظَلَمْنَا أَنفُسَنَا وَإِن لَّمْ تَغْفِرْ لَنَا وَتَرْحَمْنَا لَنَكُونَنَّ مِنَ الْخَاسِرِينَ They [Adam and Hawwa' عليهما السلام] said: _"Our Lord! We have wronged ourselves. If You forgive us not, and bestow not upon us Your Mercy, we shall certainly be of the losers."_ [Al-A'raaf 7:22-23] And from this we learn that Allah ﷻ gives respite and time to wrong-doers to come back to Him with repentance. And that He is Oft-Forgiving and Most Merciful to those who do that. And also that people have free will while Allah ﷻ is the Creator of their deeds at the same time because He has no partner creator alongside Him like the dualist polytheists (majoos, horus vs seth, dark vs light, yin vs yang) believe. Meaning that both the Qadariyyah and Jabariyyah are misguided, and that the truth is in the middle path when understanding Al-Qadr (Predestination). And that is the Salafi 'Aqidah. O Muslims, becareful, because you are living in the west and are heavily being affected by their values just like the Bani Israa'il (Children of Israel) who grew up in Egypt were, until they worshipped the calf when Musa عليه السلام was away for 40 days worshipping Allah ﷻ. Think about it, they worshipped the calf even after seeing all the Ayat (Signs) and miracles. Why? Because the society that they grew up in had huge scars on them. The generation that grew up in Egypt had to be rid of, and that could be one of the 'illah (reasons) or hikmah (wisdoms) behind not allowing them the Holy Land for 40 years. It was those that grew up under the Tasfiyah wa Tarbiyyah (purification and education) of Musa and Harun عليهما السلام, those who were free from egyptian values, like Yusha who is the boy that follows Musa عليه السلام to meet Al-Khidr in Surah Al-Kahf. It was under his leadership that the Bani Israa'il conquered Palestine and not under those that grew up in Egypt. Very important to grasp this. Because living in the west has similar effects. And it seems that you're becoming like those who were scarred in Egypt. Are you those scarred by the west? And these sufis, will turn you into those that grew up in Egypt if you do not follow the understanding of the Salaf of this Ummah. Allah سبحانه وتعالى said, أَمْ لَكُمْ كِتَابٌ فِيهِ تَدْرُسُونَ Or have you a Book wherein you learn, إِنَّ لَكُمْ فِيهِ لَمَا تَخَيَّرُونَ That you shall therein have all that you choose? [Al-Qalam 68:37-38]
You find it comforting because it resonates with your natural inclination (fitra) and your soul. If you read about Islam/ read the Quran (with impartiality) your intellect and reasoning will also find comfort.
Islam is a beautiful way of life. I made the decision to submit to Allah's laws and follow Islam 18 years ago. It is the best decision I made and it is a complete way of life full of guidance for mankind
"The people of Lut rejected (his) warning. We sent against them a violent Tornado with showers of stones, (which destroyed them), except Lut's household: them We delivered by early Dawn,- As a Grace from Us: thus do We reward those who give thanks. And (Lut) did warn them of Our Punishment, but they disputed about the Warning." (Surat al-Qamar:, 33-36)
so why does what happened back then to Lut, not happen again? Genuinly curious about this. Maybe it was a situational/ time thing for back in the day that we have to hold into account that we can't use to judge on current day as He is not raining His judgement the way he did with Lut.
@@casualfungaming4356 It did happen in a different form in that the culprits got AIDS which led to death. HIV is not an easy virus to defeat. Nearly a million people still die every year from the virus because they don't know they have HIV and are not on treatment, or they start treatment late.
@@baqirhemraj7639 AIDS and HIV are not virusses caused by homosexuality nor are they targeted in a selective way. Do not confuse correlations with causation as the spread of homosexuality and LGBTQ+ has only been bigger than ever before. If these virusses were His new judgement, than His methods are flawed as it only grew bigger. As such that He can NOT be flawed, that only means that AIDS and HIV have NOTHING to do as signs as a result. HIV and AIDS kill people with no discrimination of religion, sex, poverty or anything else. There are many papers and document about these viruses and trying to see in them Divine Judgement or Punishment is just a bias trying to find reason for your own subjective narrative.
@@casualfungaming4356 What happened to soddomo and goddomo as Quran says that in chapter 11 verse 83 ( and not far from wrongdoers ) if you stay for other couple years you will see live on the tv
But he said that the scholar said some people are born homosexual. This contradicts the Quran in which Allah swt says to the people of Soddom..."Will you do a practice that had not been done by anyone before you?" So it means this act began with the Soddomites and was not something natural from birth otherwise Allah swt wouldn't have made that statement.
@@1dunceheadyou do know that they were heterosexual men who raped other men for power and dominance, they tried to rape angels, they robbed travelers, and they rejected Allah’s messenger. Some men are born homosexual but it’s rare, I personally don’t think it’s as common as the world makes it seem it is. And being transgender is a real medical condition and that is even rarer.
No, this is not "a fact" First of it: nobody was ever created. Species developed. What you are talking about, is the (lack of) knowledge of some 600 yrs mimimum ago. Secondly: Yes, there are mainly two sexes - which are more or less pronounced. This depends on the hormonal household mostly but on other factors as well. There are men, with a lot of female characteristics and vice versa. Obviously you don´t even know the meaning of the term "fact". But what is even more despisable, that the world seems to be full of people, who feel the strong need to restrict, harrass and oppress others. Those people, who don´t feel neither like the one nor like the other sex, usually do not do anyone harm. You and the likes are simply to weak to let others live like they prefer, like they feel and whom they find attracting. Without given Norms, you are naked- and therefore others must be oppressed. People with a mind, a soul, a heart- just like you. You´d better critisize those vast numbers of violent, criminal self-acclaimed "well-guided" muslims, that are responsible for the highest rates of violence related crime in Europe: people with muslim background. And the world knows, that msulims tend to be violent, to rape, to slaughter (they often use the term when they think of Kuffars...) to stone or simply to kill each other driven by their eagerness and zeal. Or the widespread corruption in muslim countries. They are world champions. But a Muslim prefers to attack his indoctrinated "enemies" in the west, before hinting on the desasters in Libya, Turkey and Pakistan - which cost hundreds of thousands of lives through corrupt clerks. Without this dirty bakshish you are a second class person in most of the muslim coutries. Where there is Islam, there is backwardedness, violence and injustice. @@adilshekh8879
May Allah bless Sheikh Hamza for standing for truth despite what some (liberals)muslims in the west are trying to change the religion to "whatever I want" type.
@@samjon6403 bro shut up. Liberal Muslims aren't women alone. There are liberal men who're preaching wrong thing about Islam. But you just jumped into the opportunity to harp on women. Check your dichotomy.
"What are you submitting to if you get to decide what it is?" An absolutely profound thought by Sh. Hamza. Hopefully upon deeper reflection, people will understand that if the individual gets to decide everything, then the hard reality is: that he is submitting to nothing except his own ego / mind.
Why not simply follow developed moral and ethics - and the law, which is based upon those two subjects??! The world, where people "do and don´t" because of the religious rules never worked without- a moralic and selfrighteous elites! If people learn by themselves, what is right and what is wrong- they are well guided. If not, they will pray in the mosques and once they are out, they will take bakshish, steal, kill and envy, like they do especially in backwarded religious countries.
@@jameschoice3983 Because the "law" in most countries is being developed by flawed sinful human beings with motives that don't necessarily align with what the Creator had intended for human beings.
@@jackfroste i am not answering to such a nonsense. Sorry. "Creator" hohoho! Go to school before you post such embarrasing nonsense. It hurts, you know?
@@jackfroste PS: I hope you are living in Iran or Arabia! If not: go there as soon as possible! Nobody will force you to stay in a country with such sinful law! Have a nice trip!
The Prophet (ﷺ)said :" He who conceals (the faults) of a Muslim, Allah would conceal his faults in the world and in the Hereafter. Allah is at the back of a servant so long as the servant is at the back of his brother." [ Sahih Muslim ] He (ﷺ) also said :" The believer will be brought close to his Lord until He conceals him and makes him confess hin sin. Allah will say, 'Do you remember such and such a sin?' The man will say, 'Yes, I admit it.' The Lord will say, 'I concealed it for you in the world and I forgave you for it today." [ Bukhari ]
Brother Shaykh Hamza, I seek your forgiveness because once I associated with you that you are pro lgbt in Islam. Basically while talking to a friend once I said Shaykh Hamza is pro lgbt. After listening to you I realize I was totally wrong. Again I seek your forgiveness.
@@ampagetech2624 Apologizing is one thing, seeking forgiveness is another, I am not saying it's straight out haram, do not take my words too literally, but I just feel like it's better to seek forgiveness through the source itself, instead of a creation of Allah azzawajal. I may be wrong, but believe me, I didn't come here with ill intentions, and I apologize if I did, may Allah forgive me insha'allah
@@youmademecringe3225 You are wrong brother despite your good intentions. There is nothing wrong with seeking forgiveness from someone you feel that you have wronged. In fact, it's the right thing to do. With love,
Homosexuality can lead to the end of humanity. Put all the lesbians and gays on separate islands and after a hundred years or so you will find no inhabitants in either of the islands. There will be no two daddys or two mothers as there will be no children to face this disgusting and unnatural choice.
Im a Muslim but im atracted to men too .I need to stop being atracted .I pray , i fast but i need to cut off this behavior. The belief is more important then my own desires. The city that i live has discovered me secret videos they hate me and dont talk to my anymore even Selam dont say to me . They dont know my struggle but i never lose my Hope on GOD mercy . 😭 Never
I hope you repent and delete those videos if you haven't already done so. Whatever feelings are only that and do not act upon them and expose what Allah has hidden them from the people. Allah has given you this test because he knows you can succeed as a muslim. You say about behaviors as I assume they are habits. One way to stop them is to replace them with good habits. Learn and work on projects that you like and be productive. Another is remove and plan to avoid triggers and you'll gradually forget the bad ones. Dont worry about the bad and judging company and leave them. Once you occupy yourself with doing good and seek knowledge, actual good friends will come insha Allah. I speak from experience and do have similar tendencies myself. You are not alone and there are many with similar tests.
Who is the scholar and his book he speaks of starting @ 0:50? Imam "Tahanawee" (???) and his book on the "Mustahad" (???). Can someone give me a better English rendering of those names so I may seek them out? Jazakmullah Salaamalaykum.
It is such a huge challenge for an individual to bear. Only once one is faced with this challenge, then one understands the magnitude thereof. It seems that there is a definite incline in members of this community as well. May Allah protect all and give all ghidayah in the manner we deal with this challenge, Ameen.
It can be eased by remembrance of the Akhira. Everyone has their own desires, but this is a temporary life and so one must submit to resisting temptation for an eternal reward. It increases in difficulty with the self conditioning the soul towards impurity and weakening your own Taqwa. Consciousness of Allah and Remembrance of the Hereafter will always keep you safe from evil.
Some men love women too much, some married women fall in love with other than their husband, some people are attracted to the same gender, some people lose their loved ones. These are all huge tests and if they strive to be patient and follow what Allah commanded them they will have a great reward in the Hereafter in sha Allah.
You can submit to whoever or whatever you want. If you need it, well, be it. But it is none of your business to judge on others, be it homosexuals, "infidels" as you kindly call them. Homosexuals get perscuted and even killed by Muslims all over the world! Btw: Homosexuality exists amongst some animal species too - so who "created" (following the Muslims ridiculous claim)-- those animals then?! Islam is a disgusting, violent, backwarded sect, nothing else!
Just for those who are wondering, the Shaykh clarified what he meant by some people are born gay at 1:30 where he said that's because of the practices of the parents or the surroundings he born into which might incline the person to bring gay.
Im straight that explanation is stupid. Trust me Ive been around gays my whole life and I love women sexually and you would have to put a gun to mu head to be with a man. They just dont have explanation other than some are born that way and thats it
Thk u.The answer is not accepted not based on Quran and hadith and illogical and irrational.Contradicting what he said earlier and later...Hamzah tried to appease everyone not truly to Allah alone...
@heylola what the hell do you say!!!!! we can love every one it is our creation our lord created us this way !!| I will love everything that Allah جل جلاله want us to love. do preach others preach yourselves
Why is he even talking about the sheikh and making reference to his comments about lgbt? His first point from surah yasin suffice all. Why contradicting Allah's words? I do not understand these sheikhs
He is quoting an Imam who is not really known or not famous and may be I'm wrong. Where are the opinions of the Mainstream Scholars who are Authorities? Why quote a Scholar not known and leave out well Known Authorities?
@@eesaabdurrahman1569 Imam Tahawi is not Imam Thanavi. Imam Tahawi passed away 239AH and was from amongst the major hanafi muhadditheen and fuqaha. Imam Thanavi is a later Indian scholar who passed away 1158AH.
@@J48IR sorry, I’ll admit ignorance on this one. My Arabic is terrible and I seem to have misunderstood the name. I’m sure you know better than me. May Allah forgive me for misrepresenting a scholar. I should have known better. Although I haven’t read any of his writings, I am aware of Imam Tahawi. Astaghfirallah.
The Sheikh is NOT saying that the Quran or the hadith say something they don't. Just that Muslim scholars have historically dealt with and categorized the lgbtqia people under the title Mushkeel. If you pay attention he clearly explains Quran and hadith and then he also gives a history lesson. Please stop twisting his words.
@@WillScarlet1991 true. Sometimes folks hide their opinions by quoting someone else’s. I hope that isn’t the case here. But with all of the problematic talk coming from a certain American institute, I actually found Hamza Yusuf’s comments to be somewhat refreshing. Still, this is why I generally stick to other speakers, and avoid American institutes that claim to speak for Islam.
One of a great way and Litmus Test to identify Ulama e Haqq (Scholars on Truth) in this day and age is to see where they stand on these woke liberal ideologies. God bless Shaykh Hamza Yusuf.
There's nothing woke or liberal about acknowledging facts and accepting LGBT people exist and should have the same rights as everyone else. Look around, the Islamic world is an abject failure because of backward and primitive thinking and each day that passes you fall even further behind.
I love dudes logic never ceases to amaze me, ma shaa Allah I never looked at it that way. I never believed in more then 2 gender in humans but I didn’t think that calling one self non binary is trying to imitate Allah. The devil is truly in the detail
Islam teaches us tolerance,that is an important fact,tolerating human beings and living creatures,not their wrongs that Allah the Almighty frowns upon.The dead sea is left as an example so there's no contesting this issue.The Quran the speech of Allah mentions this so,it does not allow for us to condone these practices ,or to normalise them in any way.
Scholars of Islam very funny. What has islam given the world. Nothing. 99% of all the worlds advances have come from CHRISTIAN Countries, and generally NEVER MUSLIM COUNTRIES, IslamIC Countries are always backwards. They owe everything to Christian Countries. You should worship Christian’s for dragging you out from being gator herders.
I sincerely wish to learn more from him. This is a sincere question. But there’s a non-binary animal such as snail, most of them are hermaphrodites which means they are both male and female. What about that?
Where is the daleel from the scholar that he referred to who is saying that someone can be born as lgbt? Again, one should avoid any speaker in Islam who is failing to provide an evidence from the books of Hadith and Quran. Stop sugar coating Islam to please the people! It is beautiful as it is, but the ones who don’t see it or have doubts are blind.
He is suggesting that people may get "a set of sexual propensities and inclinations they are born with" and fighting these propensities and inclinations and remaining normal is their test. Like someone is born with defected limb, less intelligence, six fingers, etc.
The reality is that every society in the history had a certain percentage of homosexuell persons. And the majority of them is born this way. Whether you like it or not- that is a fact. Allah alone knows why he created people this way and it's on him to judge not on you!
„Don’t question, just believe“ I just can’t. I could never get religious. My mind is telling me exactly this since I can think and my grandparents tried to get me to „god“. Does it make me a worse person?
Ellhamdullilah for being a Moslim! Its clear about many many things in life and therefore its a vangrail. It protect me from moral ethical perspective to going off the rails. Like interest, alcohol, drugs , sexual relationship outside marriage, many other things. Within this many other things is also LGBT what never will be acceptable, its not interpretation, its just (ellhamdullilah) HARAM!
Ameen, this is my Shaykh of well over two decades. I've yet to hear anyone deal with this subject matter in as an intelligent and responsible non prejudiced bias way as Shaykh Hamza Yusuf. May Allah preserve him ameen.
Exceptional explaination, which leads me to a question: When people are born with a weak link, what's the ruling on that in regards to how are they supposed to live their lives, in regards to a relationship...
On one hand he gave historical evidence from a cleric 250 years ago who was talking about people born as non binary and on other hand he’s giving lectures about you can’t be non binary, if you can’t be non binary then why did he has to talk about the input of that cleric ? Isn’t he being hypocrite
Whenever you think: ,,I don’t practice lgbtq stuff but I will support the people“. - just remember that the wife of Prophet Lut a.s. was called a Kafir for supporting lgbtq of their time
Did Rasulilahi saaws tolerate homosexuality in his community? Did he saaws divide them into sections and groups and classifications. We follow what he said of them. And more importantly what did ALLAH ta ala dictate the outcome in his infallible book AL-QUR'AN of the people that practiced such acts?
Hamza Yusuf, how can you accept people are born gay? When Allah (swt) says we've been created on the Fitrah? On the original disposition and natural order?
Sure nature? See lady imam s videos she is Fallacy. Nature is not of born will it is the agreement between two parties. It is a consensual agreement. So it is upon the murders 'nature' to kill? Nobody will say yes. So masculinity is the origin of murder? Homosexuality is the Envy of the opposite sex. A choice is pedophilla? No they say it's a born in-nature. Lsban pedophilla comics are accepted world wide. And many show coercion. There are no straight ones or g,8Y accepted anywhere. I have recorded the behaviour and scholarly answers from LGHDTV Muslims and alike and that of T√ans. Do Transwomen call all women ugly and be misogntsic 24/7.
Classic hamza!!! beating around the bush, going on different tangents, citing stuff he reads in books to sound legit, trying to please both sides, appealing to emotions rather than clearly articulating his position. so sad, where is the hamza Yusuf prior to 9/11??
Confused much? What he said is so clear. Acknowledging the issues these people have is just stating facts. He is not saying it is halal quite the contrary. Again his stance is very clear.
Agree w u vehemently though this time Hamzah exert a bit strongly agst LGBT but must add some confusion of that Imams book since 250 years ago...yes classic Hamzah Sufi....
Islam is a religion where we should constantly be studying the universe and develop the religion around principles. The way we have defined "binary" is based on sexual organs when we could be classifying it all wrong - binary could be a state of mind, something that Allah has given us in our experience and not our genitals. We have selected a simple answer to an obviously complicated question - we then praise simple people for forcing these simple answers and some even kill in the name of these simple answers. We're not worthy of Allah.
Islam most importantly is a way of life .A way of life to be lived in submission to OUR CREATOR.Medical science admits and proves through research that people are not BORN homosexual.Yes there are people that are born HAEMOPHRODITE,and that is what the sh.he quoted early in his vid.means.The fact that people choose to live the life of homosexuals ( and many amongst them that do it ,do not want to but don't know how to navigate themselves out of the situation)is because a very deep rooted psychological component stemming from their upbringing in childhood.Living arrangement environments,Sexual abuse,Emotional abuse,the absence of a father figure in males and a mother figure( femininity,) in females are just some factors.
May Allah bless the Shykh and the brother in islam who is sharing. Can anyone please provide the book / name of the imam who talked about homosexuality? Almustalihat by Imam At tawanhi?
Hadith of Prophet sallahu alayhi wa salam “Do not have ill-will towards one another, do not be envious of one another, do not turn your back on one another; O, servants of Allah, be brothers (and sisters). It is not permissible for Muslims to remain angry with their brother [in religion] for more than three days.[Bukhari, Al-Adab (Good Manners); 57-58]"
He’s talking about the eunuches who dress up as women and go to weddings dance and collect money, we have these people in most of the cultures. The problem with modern day gender movements is that they are pushed on our faces with a certain evil agenda.
I think you missed the point, he does say that but he says “some” people think they are otherwise which doesn’t mean they necessarily are. He’s quoting a scholar from 250 years ago, who made profound predictions of the predicament of the modern age regarding these people.
I can't believe people still don't understand what he's saying and going at him like🔪🔪🔪. He is pretty clear in acknowledging the predicament yet defining the limitations set within Islam, which is 👌.
It is nice to see that the author of the book is acknowledging that homosexuality is a genetical thing. So no need to be ashamed of how you are born. Allah has made you this way. So its okay.
Man it's hard being a public figure, he can't confidently say we should be tolerant towards transgender, he had to quickly resort to non-binary being haram. But I'm not afflicted with fame so I'll say it. Even if God has intended us to be in a certain orientation, there are people who are internally different then their physical form without their choice. We need to be tolerant and understanding, because I think mercy and compassion is the truest marker of a believer, not how straight or manly you are.
I think we should respect them as human beings but not accept their act or beliefs as true or right. We shouldn't prosecute or harm them but still disagree with them
God says "no non-binery" but again you want tell us a certain sheikh says there are. God says full stop. No body's claims are considered relevant against God's commands.
The quoted sheikh is not necessarily saying there are non-binary people, it was said that there are people who grow to think they feel that way. It’s just one of the many perverse directions a person can take when they abandon their fitrah. More and more common in this terrible society as it wanders further and further astray from the Straight Path.
So far as I understand, as a Muslim who spent 8 years in a Quranic study forum, the primary issue is of avoiding extramarital relationships. So as long as two are wedded, any romantic interaction is acceptable to Allah. In fact, in the Quran, Allah writes that husbands and wives are like each other's clothing! So not much analysis needed there.
I’m not sure if ur already aware but obviously only Men and Women can get married to each other like the only correct way to be in a relationship in Islam is for the ppl of opposite sex to get married for the purpose of procreation, that’s all
@@user-zv5dy8ye1s Why? Who said? Tradition? What is traditio? Did Allah establish tradition? When the Allah writes about Lut in the Qur'an, what sins does He refer to ? What ayat and sura does Allah present in the Qur'an that same gendered people are not allowed to wed?
Why Hamza Yusuf always says so and so imam said that? Firstly, who are this imams he always quotes and secondly, are these imams opinion more important than the Qur"an and Sunnah. I wish Hamza stops saying or quoting that particular Imam or philosopher say so and so
The reason is to sounds righteous . And knowledgeable 😁😁The Quran is clear in this matter, so the opinion of those scholars is NOT needed at all, especially if it contradicts the Quran and the Sunnah.
@@RJ-sv7tr I agree with you brother, we should take knowledge from unknow sheikhs and those who contradicts against the qur"an and Sunnah. Brother Hamza should only concentrate quoting from the qur"an and Sunnah, and those well known and reliable scholars
most people identify as non binary because they dont like the stereotypes given to men and women, you know, men are manly and muscular and protective and stuff, women are shy and petite and always need help or something, these gender roles have become so sexual in nature that people have started to go against them completely, not by changing the norm, but by denying the norm even exists, acting as if these problems are not real as long as we dont pay attention to them. In my opinion we need to start accepting that some men are weak and shy, and some women are assertive and strong, that doesnt mean their no longer their assigned gender, it means that gender roles and expectations like these should not exist.
link to the full lecture:
th-cam.com/video/gh_as4dNRAM/w-d-xo.html
Love you bro
Thanks
JazakAllah khair for the link to Sheikhs beautiful, clear, easy to understand lecture
En français...🙏
@@sanfooras5799 definitely, not good for YOU. BYE
I’m a Christian. But this wonderful man speaks a lot of sense. A wonderful advocate for Muslims and Christian’s alike. We need more men like him, in this torrid world we live in.
Not only islam makes sense and lacks any hypocrisy and contradictions, it amazes me how strong the believers are.
May God bless you, Michael.
This is an injustice being attributed to Allah ﷻ similar to how christians believe that people were born with the original sin.
Nay, we say just like Rasulullah ﷺ and the Salaf said, that every child is born upon the Fitrah, then it is the parents that turn him into a jew, christian or majoos (zoroastrian).
Meaning, it is their parents or environment that corrupts their Fitrah. Otherwise this Ayah Ar-Rum 30:30 - would have no meaning to a person born in a such a state of major sin. Because what he said could be used as a justification by the people of shirk (polytheism and atheism) too, claiming that they were born that way?
Just because you want to mold into the american society and seem tolerant, doesn't mean that you should quote what some misguided person said 200 years ago and make it look as if that's what Islam teaches.
Allah سبحانه وتعالى said,
فِطْرَتَ اللَّهِ الَّتِي فَطَرَ النَّاسَ عَلَيْهَا ۚ لَا تَبْدِيلَ لِخَلْقِ اللَّهِ ۚ ذَٰلِكَ الدِّينُ الْقَيِّمُ وَلَـٰكِنَّ أَكْثَرَ النَّاسِ لَا يَعْلَمُونَ
Allah's Fitrah with which He has created mankind. No change let there be in Khalq-illah (i.e. the creation of Allah i.e. the Fitrah - Islamic Monotheism): that is the straight religion, but most of the mankind know not. [Ar-Rum (the Romans) 30:33]
The Khalq-illah (i.e. the Fitrah) is the original state, and then that original state is changed by something else, and that's what the Ayah is stating. And that refutes the notion that the original state could be anything other than the Fitrah.
There were early Muslims that hinted at evolution - way before the west swallowed it. Now, does that make evolution true? No! Kadhalika (then likewise), just because someone said something a long time ago that people agree with today, doesn't render that old statement into a Hujjah (proof). He knows this. But still he's doing Qiyas by turning the opinion of fulan from 200 years ago into the Asl, then applying it to the Far' (opinion of westerners today), and the 'illah (effective cause) is "tolerance", and then he comes up with a Hukm. Yet he claims to be a person of Usul Al-Fiqh, babbling about the Usuliyeen this and the Usuliyeen that.
Nay, we follow the Qur'an and Sunnah in accordance with the understanding of the Salaf (pious predecessors) of this Ummah. And not what fulan or fulan said. That's pure opinion (Ray'). And Ray' is not a source in the Sharee'ah.
But let's say that one of the people that engages in the acts of the people of Lut عليه السلام hears this talk, and then thinks to himself that he was born that way, and then he reads the above Ayah. Now, wouldn't he dismiss the Ayah due to your mention of what fulan said 200 years ago? Where's the cautiousness against ignorantly misleading people into erroneous conclusions? No responsibility whatsoever. Rather the Ayah is negating that anyone is born except upon the Fitrah. And the Sunnah emphasize this too. That's because the Ahlul Bid'ah follow the 'Aql and not the Naql.
Because if people were born that way, then sending Messengers wouldn't be needed. Are you saying that the people of Lut عليه السلام were dealt with injustice. So they will come up on the Day of Judgement and plead: _"O Allah, we didn't do anything other than the major sin that You created us with, how can it be our fault?"_
Allah سبحانه وتعالى said,
رُّسُلًا مُّبَشِّرِينَ وَمُنذِرِينَ لِئَلَّا يَكُونَ لِلنَّاسِ عَلَى اللَّهِ حُجَّةٌ بَعْدَ الرُّسُلِ ۚ وَكَانَ اللَّهُ عَزِيزًا حَكِيمًا
Messengers as bearers of good news as well as of warning _in order that mankind should have no plea against Allah after the (coming of) Messengers._ And Allah is Ever All-Powerful, All-Wise. [An-Nisaa' 4:165]
You see the injustice it ascribes to Allah ﷻ? Not only does it ascribe shortcomings like injustice to Allah ﷻ, it renders the Hudud unjust, and renders Risalah (Messengership) and Wahy (Revelation) irrelevant. And it creates determinism (Jabr). Meaning, that people are forced into sinful ways and that they have no free will just like shaytan who was the first determinist and founder of the Jabariyyah doctrine (determinism), ended up blaming his disobedience on Allah ﷻ.
Allah سبحانه وتعالى said,
قَالَ رَبِّ فَأَنظِرْنِي إِلَىٰ يَوْمِ يُبْعَثُونَ
[Iblis (Shaytan - Satan)] said: "O my Lord! Give me then respite till the Day they (the dead) will be resurrected."
قَالَ فَإِنَّكَ مِنَ الْمُنظَرِينَ
Allah said: "Then, verily, you are of those reprieved."
إِلَىٰ يَوْمِ الْوَقْتِ الْمَعْلُومِ
"Till the Day of the time appointed."
قَالَ رَبِّ بِمَا أَغْوَيْتَنِي لَأُزَيِّنَنَّ لَهُمْ فِي الْأَرْضِ وَلَأُغْوِيَنَّهُمْ أَجْمَعِينَ
[Iblis (Shaytan - Satan)] said: _"O my Lord! Because You misled me,_ I shall indeed adorn the path of error for them on the earth, and I shall mislead them all."
إِلَّا عِبَادَكَ مِنْهُمُ الْمُخْلَصِينَ
"Except Your servants among them Mukhlaseen (sincere who worship You exclusively)." [Al-Hijr 15:36:40]
Iblis is saying: _"O Allah, You already knew that I would disobey You, yet You did not prevent it from happening, so You misled me. It was Your fault and not mine."_
Iblis is robbing free will and choice from himself, he is blaming his sin on the Foreknowledge of Allah ﷻ. But he refutes himself, because why didn't he ask for forgiveness? Instead he asked for respite. So did Allah ﷻ force him to ask for respite too? Because Iblis is acknowledging his sin and admitting that what he did was wrong by ascribing misguidance to what he did, yet he asks for respite instead of forgiveness? So did Allah ﷻ prevent him from turning back to Him with Tawbah (repentance)? No, he chose kibr (arrogance), fisq (rebelliousness) and asked for respite until he was given it. See why he asked for respite in Al-Israa' 17:62.
Whereas Adam and Hawwa' عليهما السلام also disobeyed their Lord. But instead of robbing themselves of free will and blaming their disobedience and sin on Allah's ﷻ Foreknowledge for not preventing it, nor becoming deluded determinists that ascribe injustice to Allah ﷻ - they blamed it on themselves, on their own shortcomings, thus acknowledging responsibility and free will, and then repenting by asking for forgiveness until they were forgiven.
See Al-Baqarah 2:37. Allah ﷻ forgave our parents, and there's no such thing as "the original sin". They are of the people of Jannah who will return to their Home that they were expelled from for this world of toiling and testing and the abode of deeds, reaching truth and reaching realization.
So both Iblis vs Adam and Hawwa' عليهما السلام were given what they asked for. Respite vs Forgiveness.
Allah سبحانه وتعالى said,
وَنَادَاهُمَا رَبُّهُمَا أَلَمْ أَنْهَكُمَا عَن تِلْكُمَا الشَّجَرَةِ وَأَقُل لَّكُمَا إِنَّ الشَّيْطَانَ لَكُمَا عَدُوٌّ مُّبِينٌ
And their Lord called out to them (saying): "Did I not forbid you that tree and tell you (aforetime): 'Verily, Shaytan (i.e. Iblis) is an open enemy unto you?' "
قَالَا رَبَّنَا ظَلَمْنَا أَنفُسَنَا وَإِن لَّمْ تَغْفِرْ لَنَا وَتَرْحَمْنَا لَنَكُونَنَّ مِنَ الْخَاسِرِينَ
They [Adam and Hawwa' عليهما السلام] said: _"Our Lord! We have wronged ourselves. If You forgive us not, and bestow not upon us Your Mercy, we shall certainly be of the losers."_ [Al-A'raaf 7:22-23]
And from this we learn that Allah ﷻ gives respite and time to wrong-doers to come back to Him with repentance. And that He is Oft-Forgiving and Most Merciful to those who do that. And also that people have free will while Allah ﷻ is the Creator of their deeds at the same time because He has no partner creator alongside Him like the dualist polytheists (majoos, horus vs seth, dark vs light, yin vs yang) believe. Meaning that both the Qadariyyah and Jabariyyah are misguided, and that the truth is in the middle path when understanding Al-Qadr (Predestination). And that is the Salafi 'Aqidah.
O Muslims, becareful, because you are living in the west and are heavily being affected by their values just like the Bani Israa'il (Children of Israel) who grew up in Egypt were, until they worshipped the calf when Musa عليه السلام was away for 40 days worshipping Allah ﷻ.
Think about it, they worshipped the calf even after seeing all the Ayat (Signs) and miracles. Why? Because the society that they grew up in had huge scars on them.
The generation that grew up in Egypt had to be rid of, and that could be one of the 'illah (reasons) or hikmah (wisdoms) behind not allowing them the Holy Land for 40 years. It was those that grew up under the Tasfiyah wa Tarbiyyah (purification and education) of Musa and Harun عليهما السلام, those who were free from egyptian values, like Yusha who is the boy that follows Musa عليه السلام to meet Al-Khidr in Surah Al-Kahf. It was under his leadership that the Bani Israa'il conquered Palestine and not under those that grew up in Egypt. Very important to grasp this. Because living in the west has similar effects. And it seems that you're becoming like those who were scarred in Egypt. Are you those scarred by the west?
And these sufis, will turn you into those that grew up in Egypt if you do not follow the understanding of the Salaf of this Ummah.
Allah سبحانه وتعالى said,
أَمْ لَكُمْ كِتَابٌ فِيهِ تَدْرُسُونَ
Or have you a Book wherein you learn,
إِنَّ لَكُمْ فِيهِ لَمَا تَخَيَّرُونَ
That you shall therein have all that you choose? [Al-Qalam 68:37-38]
We should try to be like him instead of wishing to have more people like him
beautiful words he said "it's Islam which means submission it's not called whatever I want"
Best quote. And also 'God create you binary, you cannot be nonbinary no matter you try'
Islam means Peace!
@@ping5825 That would be Salam
@@naimmazmi Salam and Islam are similar
@Raabraka65 ????????????
“What are you submitting to if you decide what it is????” What amazing words!
submitting to my whims and desires lmao
@@angcil88 better then submitting to some arabic myth god 🤣🤣🤣
Agree allah is with israel every war proves it.
@@bharathdeva9407 bro you should buy a new deodorant 🤣
@@angcil88 u shld try to bath often n not once a year
I’m not religious but find it very comforting listening to your channel
You find it comforting because it resonates with your natural inclination (fitra) and your soul. If you read about Islam/ read the Quran (with impartiality) your intellect and reasoning will also find comfort.
don't mind . Just think why are u in the earth! Who sent u to this world. Think think think before ur death
that's your soul finally being fed what it's been yearning for: the truth.
Islam is a beautiful way of life. I made the decision to submit to Allah's laws and follow Islam 18 years ago. It is the best decision I made and it is a complete way of life full of guidance for mankind
@@aishaabdikarim1840 Welcome dear sis! SubhanAllah Islam instills utter peace within.
"What are you submitting to if you decide what it is". Absolutely beautiful.
"The people of Lut rejected (his) warning. We sent against them a violent Tornado with showers of stones, (which destroyed them), except Lut's household: them We delivered by early Dawn,- As a Grace from Us: thus do We reward those who give thanks. And (Lut) did warn them of Our Punishment, but they disputed about the Warning." (Surat al-Qamar:, 33-36)
so why does what happened back then to Lut, not happen again? Genuinly curious about this. Maybe it was a situational/ time thing for back in the day that we have to hold into account that we can't use to judge on current day as He is not raining His judgement the way he did with Lut.
@@casualfungaming4356 It did happen in a different form in that the culprits got AIDS which led to death. HIV is not an easy virus to defeat. Nearly a million people still die every year from the virus because they don't know they have HIV and are not on treatment, or they start treatment late.
@@baqirhemraj7639 AIDS and HIV are not virusses caused by homosexuality nor are they targeted in a selective way. Do not confuse correlations with causation as the spread of homosexuality and LGBTQ+ has only been bigger than ever before. If these virusses were His new judgement, than His methods are flawed as it only grew bigger. As such that He can NOT be flawed, that only means that AIDS and HIV have NOTHING to do as signs as a result. HIV and AIDS kill people with no discrimination of religion, sex, poverty or anything else. There are many papers and document about these viruses and trying to see in them Divine Judgement or Punishment is just a bias trying to find reason for your own subjective narrative.
وما ذلك من الظالمين ببعيد ..... Hope soon we shall see that punishment happening live
@@casualfungaming4356 What happened to soddomo and goddomo as Quran says that in chapter 11 verse 83 ( and not far from wrongdoers ) if you stay for other couple years you will see live on the tv
True. The question is what I am submitting to;
My desire or my Creator
To be a Muslim I have to submit to my Creator.
Créator? Girl it’s just a myth wake up
@@viciousv9671 I am very much awake. What about you?
God bless Shaykh Hamza for clarifying so many confusions! Many duas for him !
@@Jonas114_Qc hamza knows exactly what he's doing spreading this misguidance
Have you been confused about it ?
@@sanfooras5799 Already Hamzas first sentences are wrong.
Stupid "lectures" from a stupid rat-catcher for people alike!
I love Shaykh Hamza Yusuf may Allah elevate him. Thank you for helping spread the haq (truth) ❤️
Aameen
He's a caller to shirk.
@@Mozee854 what did he say
@@Ck_olp He promotes Habib Ali Jifri...Habib Ali Jifri calls upon the dead, seeking aid/assistance from them.
This is a great message. Super concise and to the point. He summarized a lot of great points within minutes, he's a great teacher mashallah
Yes, for people with a small brain this might well be as you describe.
Are there some intelligenMuslims too- or do they hide somewhere?!
@@jameschoice3983
You might be the stupid one, just a possibility 🙃
@@jameschoice3983I’m here and I’ve written my comments around the place on here
But he said that the scholar said some people are born homosexual. This contradicts the Quran in which Allah swt says to the people of Soddom..."Will you do a practice that had not been done by anyone before you?" So it means this act began with the Soddomites and was not something natural from birth otherwise Allah swt wouldn't have made that statement.
@@1dunceheadyou do know that they were heterosexual men who raped other men for power and dominance, they tried to rape angels, they robbed travelers, and they rejected Allah’s messenger. Some men are born homosexual but it’s rare, I personally don’t think it’s as common as the world makes it seem it is. And being transgender is a real medical condition and that is even rarer.
Love this man not fearing to speak God words in fear of being labeled. Fact is fact with no fear of society 💪🏾
Which "fact"??! There is no fact.
@@jameschoice3983God created you in a binary. You cannot escape it. That fact
No, this is not "a fact"
First of it: nobody was ever created.
Species developed. What you are talking about, is the (lack of) knowledge of some 600 yrs mimimum ago.
Secondly: Yes, there are mainly two sexes - which are more or less pronounced. This depends on the hormonal household mostly but on other factors as well.
There are men, with a lot of female characteristics and vice versa.
Obviously you don´t even know the meaning of the term "fact".
But what is even more despisable, that the world seems to be full of people, who feel the strong need to restrict, harrass and oppress others.
Those people, who don´t feel neither like the one nor like the other sex, usually do not do anyone harm.
You and the likes are simply to weak to let others live like they prefer, like they feel and whom they find attracting.
Without given Norms, you are naked- and therefore others must be oppressed. People with a mind, a soul, a heart- just like you.
You´d better critisize those vast numbers of violent, criminal self-acclaimed "well-guided" muslims, that are responsible for the highest rates of violence related crime in Europe: people with muslim background.
And the world knows, that msulims tend to be violent, to rape, to slaughter (they often use the term when they think of Kuffars...) to stone or simply to kill each other driven by their eagerness and zeal.
Or the widespread corruption in muslim countries. They are world champions.
But a Muslim prefers to attack his indoctrinated "enemies" in the west, before hinting on the desasters in Libya, Turkey and Pakistan - which cost hundreds of thousands of lives through corrupt clerks.
Without this dirty bakshish you are a second class person in most of the muslim coutries.
Where there is Islam, there is backwardedness, violence and injustice.
@@adilshekh8879
I am surprised that we had an Islamic scholar who had researched about sexuality and had come to this conclusion which is so true
Ahhh shaykh hamza yousuf never fails with his lectures. May Allah protect him from the fitnah and show your infinite blessings upon him. Ameen❤🤲🏽
May Allah bless Sheikh Hamza for standing for truth despite what some (liberals)muslims in the west are trying to change the religion to "whatever I want" type.
Alhamdulillah he didn’t give a pass for that behavior. He still got my respect
@@samjon6403 bro shut up. Liberal Muslims aren't women alone. There are liberal men who're preaching wrong thing about Islam. But you just jumped into the opportunity to harp on women. Check your dichotomy.
"What are you submitting to if you get to decide what it is?" An absolutely profound thought by Sh. Hamza. Hopefully upon deeper reflection, people will understand that if the individual gets to decide everything, then the hard reality is: that he is submitting to nothing except his own ego / mind.
Makes sense 🙏
Why not simply follow developed moral and ethics - and the law, which is based upon those two subjects??!
The world, where people "do and don´t" because of the religious rules never worked without- a moralic and selfrighteous elites!
If people learn by themselves, what is right and what is wrong- they are well guided.
If not, they will pray in the mosques and once they are out, they will take bakshish, steal, kill and envy, like they do especially in backwarded religious countries.
@@jameschoice3983 Because the "law" in most countries is being developed by flawed sinful human beings with motives that don't necessarily align with what the Creator had intended for human beings.
@@jackfroste i am not answering to such a nonsense. Sorry.
"Creator" hohoho!
Go to school before you post such embarrasing nonsense.
It hurts, you know?
@@jackfroste PS: I hope you are living in Iran or Arabia!
If not: go there as soon as possible!
Nobody will force you to stay in a country with such sinful law!
Have a nice trip!
Can we please get the full link.? May Allah reward you and Sheikh Hamza Yusuf for spreading his knowledge.
Yes please share the full link
th-cam.com/video/BfgFe1VtPLs/w-d-xo.html
Cafe again with the wrong link
@@cafeihsan6529 ارجو ترجمه الفيديوهات الي العربية والالمانيه جزاكم الله خيراً
The Prophet (ﷺ)said :" He who conceals (the faults) of a Muslim, Allah would conceal his faults in the world and in the Hereafter. Allah is at the back of a servant so long as the servant is at the back of his brother." [ Sahih Muslim ] He (ﷺ) also said :" The believer will be brought close to his Lord until He conceals him and makes him confess hin sin. Allah will say, 'Do you remember such and such a sin?' The man will say, 'Yes, I admit it.' The Lord will say, 'I concealed it for you in the world and I forgave you for it today." [ Bukhari ]
Alhamdulillah Islam is complete
And Ya Allah grant you Jannah
There is no He or God ... Just wake up man and grow up
(يَا أَيُّهَا النَّاسُ إِنَّا خَلَقْنَاكُمْ مِنْ ذَكَرٍ وَأُنْثَى وَجَعَلْنَاكُمْ شُعُوبًا وَقَبَائِلَ لِتَعَارَفُوا إِنَّ أَكْرَمَكُمْ عِنْدَ اللَّهِ أَتْقَاكُمْ إِنَّ اللَّهَ عَلِيمٌ خَبِيرٌ).
سورة الحجرات:13
Brother Shaykh Hamza, I seek your forgiveness because once I associated with you that you are pro lgbt in Islam. Basically while talking to a friend once I said Shaykh Hamza is pro lgbt. After listening to you I realize I was totally wrong. Again I seek your forgiveness.
Do not seek the forgiveness of Sheikh Hamza, seek forgiveness from Allah swt, He is the one who grants mercy, not our respected sheikh
@@youmademecringe3225 Nothing wrong in seeking forgiveness from some one you have wronged or backbited!!
@@ampagetech2624 Apologizing is one thing, seeking forgiveness is another, I am not saying it's straight out haram, do not take my words too literally, but I just feel like it's better to seek forgiveness through the source itself, instead of a creation of Allah azzawajal. I may be wrong, but believe me, I didn't come here with ill intentions, and I apologize if I did, may Allah forgive me insha'allah
@@youmademecringe3225 You are wrong brother despite your good intentions. There is nothing wrong with seeking forgiveness from someone you feel that you have wronged. In fact, it's the right thing to do. With love,
@@Awab_Hamid there is no Allah. It's all made up. No one know how the universe came to be. There was not qawme lut. Stop hating.
Homosexuality can lead to the end of humanity. Put all the lesbians and gays on separate islands and after a hundred years or so you will find no inhabitants in either of the islands. There will be no two daddys or two mothers as there will be no children to face this disgusting and unnatural choice.
Literally
Ustaz Hamza Yusif a gift from Allah to us May Allah bless you and reward you ..Respect🙏
Im a Muslim but im atracted to men too .I need to stop being atracted .I pray , i fast but i need to cut off this behavior. The belief is more important then my own desires. The city that i live has discovered me secret videos they hate me and dont talk to my anymore even Selam dont say to me . They dont know my struggle but i never lose my Hope on GOD mercy . 😭 Never
May Allah All Mighty help you brother Insha’Allah. Don’t give up
Don't give up brother, everyone has their own struggle, this life was never meant for comfort.
I hope you repent and delete those videos if you haven't already done so. Whatever feelings are only that and do not act upon them and expose what Allah has hidden them from the people.
Allah has given you this test because he knows you can succeed as a muslim.
You say about behaviors as I assume they are habits. One way to stop them is to replace them with good habits. Learn and work on projects that you like and be productive. Another is remove and plan to avoid triggers and you'll gradually forget the bad ones.
Dont worry about the bad and judging company and leave them. Once you occupy yourself with doing good and seek knowledge, actual good friends will come insha Allah.
I speak from experience and do have similar tendencies myself. You are not alone and there are many with similar tests.
live your truth lmfao
May Allah grant you patience and understanding, brother. May Allah safeguard you from troubles and grant you peace and submission.
Who is the scholar and his book he speaks of starting @ 0:50? Imam "Tahanawee" (???) and his book on the "Mustahad" (???). Can someone give me a better English rendering of those names so I may seek them out? Jazakmullah Salaamalaykum.
Agreed on the making of your own choices for our religion. It’s supposed to be followed in a certain manner, certain way. No wavering insha Allah.
Atleast now I know what binary and non binary means
It is such a huge challenge for an individual to bear. Only once one is faced with this challenge, then one understands the magnitude thereof.
It seems that there is a definite incline in members of this community as well. May Allah protect all and give all ghidayah in the manner we deal with this challenge, Ameen.
It can be eased by remembrance of the Akhira. Everyone has their own desires, but this is a temporary life and so one must submit to resisting temptation for an eternal reward. It increases in difficulty with the self conditioning the soul towards impurity and weakening your own Taqwa. Consciousness of Allah and Remembrance of the Hereafter will always keep you safe from evil.
@@whostherehuhk
You are 💯 right! 👍
Ameen. I think lgbtq Muslims have a great internal Jihad. It can't be easy for them at all.
Ameen
Some men love women too much, some married women fall in love with other than their husband, some people are attracted to the same gender, some people lose their loved ones. These are all huge tests and if they strive to be patient and follow what Allah commanded them they will have a great reward in the Hereafter in sha Allah.
You can't just make up the religion and say what you think it is
Islam is submitting to what it is
That's got to be written in gold👌
SubhanaAllah !words of wisdom
@Raabraka65 Within the Quran, there is no consequential sequence to the 6 days in which God created the Heavens and Earth.
All religions are made up, just to give someone power and control people
You can submit to whoever or whatever you want. If you need it, well, be it.
But it is none of your business to judge on others, be it homosexuals, "infidels" as you kindly call them.
Homosexuals get perscuted and even killed by Muslims all over the world! Btw: Homosexuality exists amongst some animal species too - so who "created" (following the Muslims ridiculous claim)-- those animals then?!
Islam is a disgusting, violent, backwarded sect, nothing else!
Islam is always a matter of interpretation. Don´t you know?!
Just for those who are wondering, the Shaykh clarified what he meant by some people are born gay at 1:30 where he said that's because of the practices of the parents or the surroundings he born into which might incline the person to bring gay.
Im straight that explanation is stupid. Trust me Ive been around gays my whole life and I love women sexually and you would have to put a gun to mu head to be with a man. They just dont have explanation other than some are born that way and thats it
Thk u.The answer is not accepted not based on Quran and hadith and illogical and irrational.Contradicting what he said earlier and later...Hamzah tried to appease everyone not truly to Allah alone...
@@nurhanaibrahim162 agreed.
Something fishy for sure!!!
@@RJ-sv7tr there's nothing fishy. Read the original comment again
@@nurhanaibrahim162 he didn't contradict anything
JazakAllahu khayran
Uhibbuka fillah ya Hamza Yusuf
I wish I can meet him, even time I listen to his lecture I get tears
@heylola I wish I could meet our prophet ﷺ, to hear him recite the blessed Qur’an.
that is really embarrasing, sweatheart. maybe you are not aware of...
Is Allah you want to meet..from that the tears come from...
@heylola
what the hell do you say!!!!!
we can love every one it is our creation our lord created us this way !!| I will love everything that Allah جل جلاله want us to love.
do preach others preach yourselves
@heylola4097who is taking idols for worship when you clearly see they are Muslims ?????? Are you out of your beeswax????
Why is he even talking about the sheikh and making reference to his comments about lgbt? His first point from surah yasin suffice all. Why contradicting Allah's words? I do not understand these sheikhs
Such clarity of thought and amazing teaching qualities in this man
He is quoting an Imam who is not really known or not famous and may be I'm wrong. Where are the opinions of the Mainstream Scholars who are Authorities? Why quote a Scholar not known and leave out well Known Authorities?
Imam Tahawi is well known. He was quoted because perhaps he dealt more in depth with the issue.
@@eesaabdurrahman1569 Imam Tahawi is not Imam Thanavi.
Imam Tahawi passed away 239AH and was from amongst the major hanafi muhadditheen and fuqaha.
Imam Thanavi is a later Indian scholar who passed away 1158AH.
@@J48IR sorry, I’ll admit ignorance on this one. My Arabic is terrible and I seem to have misunderstood the name. I’m sure you know better than me. May Allah forgive me for misrepresenting a scholar. I should have known better. Although I haven’t read any of his writings, I am aware of Imam Tahawi. Astaghfirallah.
The Sheikh is NOT saying that the Quran or the hadith say something they don't. Just that Muslim scholars have historically dealt with and categorized the lgbtqia people under the title Mushkeel. If you pay attention he clearly explains Quran and hadith and then he also gives a history lesson. Please stop twisting his words.
For real, I was thinking the same.
Doesn't he say certain people are born gay?
@@WillScarlet1991 he said that Imam Tahawi said that.
@@eesaabdurrahman1569 Yes, but I didn't hear him disagree with that statement.
@@WillScarlet1991 true. Sometimes folks hide their opinions by quoting someone else’s. I hope that isn’t the case here. But with all of the problematic talk coming from a certain American institute, I actually found Hamza Yusuf’s comments to be somewhat refreshing. Still, this is why I generally stick to other speakers, and avoid American institutes that claim to speak for Islam.
One of a great way and Litmus Test to identify Ulama e Haqq (Scholars on Truth) in this day and age is to see where they stand on these woke liberal ideologies. God bless Shaykh Hamza Yusuf.
There's nothing woke or liberal about acknowledging facts and accepting LGBT people exist and should have the same rights as everyone else. Look around, the Islamic world is an abject failure because of backward and primitive thinking and each day that passes you fall even further behind.
I love dudes logic never ceases to amaze me, ma shaa Allah
I never looked at it that way. I never believed in more then 2 gender in humans but I didn’t think that calling one self non binary is trying to imitate Allah. The devil is truly in the detail
beacause you are a very simple person ..easily led
@@diamondgeezertunes lol
Islam teaches us tolerance,that is an important fact,tolerating human beings and living creatures,not their wrongs that Allah the Almighty frowns upon.The dead sea is left as an example so there's no contesting this issue.The Quran the speech of Allah mentions this so,it does not allow for us to condone these practices ,or to normalise them in any way.
Amen… thank you for this short video and just hitting the hammer on the nail.
His history of what the great learned scholars of Islam left is timeless and phenomenal
Scholars of Islam very funny.
What has islam given the world.
Nothing.
99% of all the worlds advances have come from CHRISTIAN Countries, and generally NEVER MUSLIM COUNTRIES, IslamIC Countries are always backwards. They owe everything to Christian Countries.
You should worship Christian’s for dragging you out from being gator herders.
Masha’Allah! Beautifully explained with superb articulation!
My favorite shaykh is Hamza Yusuf.
Wow found someone with the same first name and thought to comment for no reason 😂
interesting to explore the world of low-level intellectuality... ; )
I sincerely wish to learn more from him. This is a sincere question. But there’s a non-binary animal such as snail, most of them are hermaphrodites which means they are both male and female. What about that?
Humans are a higher creation than animals. But they can debase themselves if they're disobeying the Laws of God.
Where is the daleel from the scholar that he referred to who is saying that someone can be born as lgbt? Again, one should avoid any speaker in Islam who is failing to provide an evidence from the books of Hadith and Quran. Stop sugar coating Islam to please the people! It is beautiful as it is, but the ones who don’t see it or have doubts are blind.
He is suggesting that people may get "a set of sexual propensities and inclinations they are born with" and fighting these propensities and inclinations and remaining normal is their test. Like someone is born with defected limb, less intelligence, six fingers, etc.
The reality is that every society in the history had a certain percentage of homosexuell persons. And the majority of them is born this way. Whether you like it or not- that is a fact. Allah alone knows why he created people this way and it's on him to judge not on you!
@@ahmedalighouri9673 this isn't scientifically proven.
@@jussuj8158
Science cannot "prove" what you may feel.
@@ahmedalighouri9673 heard of psychology?
„Don’t question, just believe“
I just can’t. I could never get religious. My mind is telling me exactly this since I can think and my grandparents tried to get me to „god“. Does it make me a worse person?
Ellhamdullilah for being a Moslim! Its clear about many many things in life and therefore its a vangrail.
It protect me from moral ethical perspective to going off the rails.
Like interest, alcohol, drugs , sexual relationship outside marriage, many other things.
Within this many other things is also LGBT what never will be acceptable, its not interpretation, its just (ellhamdullilah) HARAM!
Ameen, this is my Shaykh of well over two decades. I've yet to hear anyone deal with this subject matter in as an intelligent and responsible non prejudiced bias way as Shaykh Hamza Yusuf. May Allah preserve him ameen.
Clear, concise and empathetic mashallah
Begone Origin of Evil
Exceptional explaination, which leads me to a question: When people are born with a weak link, what's the ruling on that in regards to how are they supposed to live their lives, in regards to a relationship...
Yes !!! What are you submitting to if you decide what it is 👌🏾 so true
you are submitting to what you decide it is
On one hand he gave historical evidence from a cleric 250 years ago who was talking about people born as non binary and on other hand he’s giving lectures about you can’t be non binary, if you can’t be non binary then why did he has to talk about the input of that cleric ? Isn’t he being hypocrite
May Allah give him a longer lifetime
Ameen🤗
Please Pray for MUSLIMS UNITY
Oh, so Allah has made permissible for someone homosexuality from the moment that they are born with this tendency, so they are not to be blamed?
Sheikh is confused or deliberately misleading.
Whenever you think: ,,I don’t practice lgbtq stuff but I will support the people“. - just remember that the wife of Prophet Lut a.s. was called a Kafir for supporting lgbtq of their time
EXACTLY ANYONE THAT EVEN SUPPORTS FROM AFAR IS KAFIR
Please provide reference, a book name, page number…etc
Did anyone find the reference he made of Imam Tahanawi's works about homosexuals? I could not find anything, not even with ChatGPT
Did Rasulilahi saaws tolerate homosexuality in his community? Did he saaws divide them into sections and groups and classifications. We follow what he said of them. And more importantly what did ALLAH ta ala dictate the outcome in his infallible book AL-QUR'AN of the people that practiced such acts?
Profound "What are you submitting to if you don't know what it is"
you decide what it is you want to submit to... duh. religious people are so mindshat
What do you say of Lut's story in the Quran?
Only 4 min but full of GEMS!
Hamza Yusuf, how can you accept people are born gay? When Allah (swt) says we've been created on the Fitrah? On the original disposition and natural order?
Sure nature? See lady imam s videos she is Fallacy. Nature is not of born will it is the agreement between two parties. It is a consensual agreement. So it is upon the murders 'nature' to kill? Nobody will say yes. So masculinity is the origin of murder? Homosexuality is the Envy of the opposite sex. A choice is pedophilla? No they say it's a born in-nature. Lsban pedophilla comics are accepted world wide. And many show coercion. There are no straight ones or g,8Y accepted anywhere. I have recorded the behaviour and scholarly answers from LGHDTV Muslims and alike and that of T√ans. Do Transwomen call all women ugly and be misogntsic 24/7.
Shaykh is very insightful subhanallah
If we don't see that on al Quran al Kareem nor in the actual words and practices of the blessed prophet Muhammad s.a.w, I can't accept that.
the truth is the truth irrespective if one agrees with it or not
Does anyone know the book of the imam that Shaykh Hamza mentions at 0:50 ?
Classic hamza!!! beating around the bush, going on different tangents, citing stuff he reads in books to sound legit, trying to please both sides, appealing to emotions rather than clearly articulating his position. so sad, where is the hamza Yusuf prior to 9/11??
Confused much? What he said is so clear. Acknowledging the issues these people have is just stating facts. He is not saying it is halal quite the contrary. Again his stance is very clear.
@@binthamadicamara2077 I'm sure he said certain people are born gay.
@@binthamadicamara2077 I speak to the horse mouth not his tail
agree 100%
Agree w u vehemently though this time Hamzah exert a bit strongly agst LGBT but must add some confusion of that Imams book since 250 years ago...yes classic Hamzah Sufi....
Well my first question is how is known that we are created via a creator? Is natural born sex is different than gender?
Rabbim yolunda mücadele eden bütün müminlerden razi olsun. Allah nurunu tamamlayacaktır
Islam is a religion where we should constantly be studying the universe and develop the religion around principles.
The way we have defined "binary" is based on sexual organs when we could be classifying it all wrong - binary could be a state of mind, something that Allah has given us in our experience and not our genitals.
We have selected a simple answer to an obviously complicated question - we then praise simple people for forcing these simple answers and some even kill in the name of these simple answers.
We're not worthy of Allah.
He is a great scholar of Islam and he summarized the problem very well.
He is not a scholar he is a sheikh dont get it confused.
may Allah keep Shaykh Hamza with us for a long time we need people like him he doesn't need us.
It is shameful that many Muslim nowadays indulge in such vulgar activities without considering their religion (islam ❤️)
Well said Sir ❤❤❤
Loved this explanation, thank you and may Allah bless you Aameen. We cannot just bend the rules to suit our selfish needs.
brilliantly concluded the whole lgbt debate..good sir
Have to see his full lecture. As here it's not cleared and if we want to do Dawah we should have more valid points. Jazak Allah khair
what about intersex people?
May Allah grant Shiek Yusef longevity in the flesh please 🤲👏
We need the full talk please, I want to hear the full context.
An LGBT Muslim is like a meat eating vegan. Two opposing things can't be one
Islam most importantly is a way of life .A way of life to be lived in submission to OUR CREATOR.Medical science admits and proves through research that people are not BORN homosexual.Yes there are people that are born HAEMOPHRODITE,and that is what the sh.he quoted early in his vid.means.The fact that people choose to live the life of homosexuals ( and many amongst them that do it ,do not want to but don't know how to navigate themselves out of the situation)is because a very deep rooted psychological component stemming from their upbringing in childhood.Living arrangement environments,Sexual abuse,Emotional abuse,the absence of a father figure in males and a mother figure( femininity,) in females are just some factors.
"We should just give up religion. It doesn't mean anything" Truly, wise words.
THESE are the wise words in this 4 minutes clip??? Smh. Needless to say, It's a carefully used rhetorical device that you took literally.
Way to be a Kafir
May Allah bless the Shykh and the brother in islam who is sharing. Can anyone please provide the book / name of the imam who talked about homosexuality? Almustalihat by Imam At tawanhi?
The speaker should quote more of what the Allah and his messenger pbuh and those whome they told us to follow more. Less of what people say.
The other people you are referring to here, are actually great scholars of Islam subhanAllah..
@@zubeidafester1173 Hamza yusuf is a deviant.
Is there a book by imam At Tahanawi we can access?
Alhamdulilah, whatever I want, lol. Accurate statement
Hadith of Prophet sallahu alayhi wa salam “Do not have ill-will towards one another, do not be envious of one another, do not turn your back on one another; O, servants of Allah, be brothers (and sisters). It is not permissible for Muslims to remain angry with their brother [in religion] for more than three days.[Bukhari, Al-Adab (Good Manners); 57-58]"
He is contradicting himself, if Allah says there is only male and female then that is the truth, nothing more
I think it's called double talk or double speach
He’s talking about the eunuches who dress up as women and go to weddings dance and collect money, we have these people in most of the cultures.
The problem with modern day gender movements is that they are pushed on our faces with a certain evil agenda.
I think you missed the point, he does say that but he says “some” people think they are otherwise which doesn’t mean they necessarily are. He’s quoting a scholar from 250 years ago, who made profound predictions of the predicament of the modern age regarding these people.
I agree with Usman. He’s definitely contradicting himself. He obviously didn’t think it through. 🤦♂️
May I ask the name for the whole lecture? jzkAllahu Khairan
I love my religion
What's the name of the book and the imam the shaikh quotes of?
I can't believe people still don't understand what he's saying and going at him like🔪🔪🔪.
He is pretty clear in acknowledging the predicament yet defining the limitations set within Islam, which is 👌.
Didn't he say some people are born gay?
Yea so?
@@ssarah802 So Islamically, being gay isn't a sin? Since they're born with that sexuality?
Yea no not gonna argue. If you get it you get it, if you don't you don't.
@@ssarah802 Looks like you know I'm right but somehow you don't have the courage to admit it.
It is nice to see that the author of the book is acknowledging that homosexuality is a genetical thing. So no need to be ashamed of how you are born. Allah has made you this way. So its okay.
ماشاءالله اللهم انصر الاسلام والمسلمين ☝️
Man it's hard being a public figure, he can't confidently say we should be tolerant towards transgender, he had to quickly resort to non-binary being haram. But I'm not afflicted with fame so I'll say it. Even if God has intended us to be in a certain orientation, there are people who are internally different then their physical form without their choice. We need to be tolerant and understanding, because I think mercy and compassion is the truest marker of a believer, not how straight or manly you are.
I think we should respect them as human beings but not accept their act or beliefs as true or right. We shouldn't prosecute or harm them but still disagree with them
God says "no non-binery" but again you want tell us a certain sheikh says there are.
God says full stop. No body's claims are considered relevant against God's commands.
You misunderstood what he's saying
Mohammed Hussein Brother I agree 100% with you
I think they call that double talk or double speak
The quoted sheikh is not necessarily saying there are non-binary people, it was said that there are people who grow to think they feel that way. It’s just one of the many perverse directions a person can take when they abandon their fitrah. More and more common in this terrible society as it wanders further and further astray from the Straight Path.
Yes we agree vehemently...Shk Hamzah is a double talk Sheikh..
So far as I understand, as a Muslim who spent 8 years in a Quranic study forum, the primary issue is of avoiding extramarital relationships. So as long as two are wedded, any romantic interaction is acceptable to Allah. In fact, in the Quran, Allah writes that husbands and wives are like each other's clothing! So not much analysis needed there.
I’m not sure if ur already aware but obviously only Men and Women can get married to each other like the only correct way to be in a relationship in Islam is for the ppl of opposite sex to get married for the purpose of procreation, that’s all
@@user-zv5dy8ye1s Why? Who said? Tradition? What is traditio? Did Allah establish tradition? When the Allah writes about Lut in the Qur'an, what sins does He refer to ? What ayat and sura does Allah present in the Qur'an that same gendered people are not allowed to wed?
Why Hamza Yusuf always says so and so imam said that? Firstly, who are this imams he always quotes and secondly, are these imams opinion more important than the Qur"an and Sunnah.
I wish Hamza stops saying or quoting that particular Imam or philosopher say so and so
double speacb
The reason is to sounds righteous . And knowledgeable 😁😁The Quran is clear in this matter, so the opinion of those scholars is NOT needed at all, especially if it contradicts the Quran and the Sunnah.
@@RJ-sv7tr I agree with you brother, we should take knowledge from unknow sheikhs and those who contradicts against the qur"an and Sunnah.
Brother Hamza should only concentrate quoting from the qur"an and Sunnah, and those well known and reliable scholars
most people identify as non binary because they dont like the stereotypes given to men and women, you know, men are manly and muscular and protective and stuff, women are shy and petite and always need help or something, these gender roles have become so sexual in nature that people have started to go against them completely, not by changing the norm, but by denying the norm even exists, acting as if these problems are not real as long as we dont pay attention to them. In my opinion we need to start accepting that some men are weak and shy, and some women are assertive and strong, that doesnt mean their no longer their assigned gender, it means that gender roles and expectations like these should not exist.