Homosexuality - Hamza Yusuf
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.ย. 2024
- Get 1000 free mp3 files of Hamza Yusuf,
Siraj Wahhaj, Ayden Zayn and others!
www.aydenzayn....
This is Chapter 17. Watch the full lecture here: • Articles of Faith - Pa...
Listen to on Apple Music/iTunes: www.islamondem...
Buy the DVD for this title: www.islamondem...
Find more Islam On Demand lectures here:
iTunes/Apple Music: www.islamondem...
DVDs and MP3s: www.islamondem...
Please share our TH-cam channel and support our various websites:
www.IslamOnDem...
www.30FactsAbo...
www.AydenZayn.com
www.Islamogram...
Subscribe/Follow:
Newsletter: www.islamondem...
TH-cam: / islamondemand
Facebook: / islamondemand
Twitter: / islamondemand
TikTok: / islam.on.demand
Instagram: / islamondemand
And please don't forget to like, share and subscribe!
TERMS OF USE:
If you use any part of this video or audio in your own production, you must do AT LEAST TWO of the following (and they MUST REMAIN as long as our content appears on your channel):
1) Add an end screen that either links to our channel or links to our video that contains the content you used. For instructions on how to do this watch this video: • How To Add End Screen ...
2) Add a card that links to our channel. The card's teaser text should say “Check out Islam On Demand”. For instructions on how to do this watch this video: • How to Add a Card to a...
3) Add our channel to your list of recommended channels.
4) Add the following text in the VERY TOP of your video's description: Check out the Islam On Demand TH-cam channel: / islamondemand
5) Add a legible and clearly visible text overlay that appears in the FIRST HALF of your video and remains on screen for at least 7 seconds that says “Support Islam On Demand at www.IslamOnDemand.com"
Just putting this out there to help others after reading some comments here. I am a sister who desired women as a teenager and honestly Allah healed me. I gave up on everything in life except for Allah and I didnt expect any relief and one day the most amazing feeling came over me and I felt that my body and brain had changed (I was transgender too) I felt full of light. After that I never felt desire towards women again alhamdulillah and it's been nearly 10 years now. Although I did suffer before it, when you completely give yourself to Allah and become so close to Him that He is more real to you than anything else, I feel that it was knowing Allah and His Oneness that healed me. There is light at the end of the tunnel for you insha'Allah. And for every struggle you go through even if it never ends, you are increasing in reward.
This is amazing. It’s the power of sincerely and completely submitting our will to Allah. Thanks for sharing.
I would like to add that Quran itself has the power of healing the ailments of the soul, heart and mind. This aspect is one of the most neglected aspects of the power of Quran.
Dear Sister Ma Sha Allah. I am so happy for you. May Allah always protect you and bless you. I also have a situation with someone I know who is struggling. Is it possible to message you about it. Maybe you can become a Ziriya (the one who Allah sends as help) to help me, help the other person. I will wait for your reply. Jazak Allahu Khairan sister and May Allah always bless you abundantly
Why do you use the words suffering and healed in this context? Would the same apply for "healing" a "suffering" Muslim and converting them into Norse paganism?
@@amoondar69 Did you heal ?
Most supposedly ex gay ppl who find Jesus say the same thing as you. Yet many of them realize they are just fooling themselves and they recognize it and go back. I hope you aren’t playing mind tricks on yourself.
Surah Al Anfal [8:30]
"But they plan, and Allah plans. And Allah is the best of planners"
brilliant idea of your alla to spread the most important message he has by using a child raping terrorist who believed in flat earth
Christianity still is the greatest religion by far
even bigger than facebook, with over 23. billion users
oh yes, the plans of your alla amazes me
and thanks for proving your quran is a most stupid lie
@@worfoz
Seemed kind of unwarranted. I love that the brother had no evil things to say to you. I hope that this stands as a testament to how even beautiful Faith's can lead to ugly reflections. And the humanity we reflect as imperfect spokespeople for our religions.
@@Rabbittavo no evil things?
promoting child rape and homophobia are evil, islam is not really "beautiful", dearest child rapist worshiper, and six billion people do not think that your alla is a very nice god, and we do not like the plans of your alla either, right?
you should know and respect that
we know why your alla loves a child rapist but hates gays
, women and religions so much
muhamed created this alla as his associate, so alla likes everything muhamed did and hates everyone who rejects muhameds weird lies.
Your faith leads to the most ugly reality of rape, lies, invasions, terror and abuse.
You pagans reflect the inhumanity of your child raping terrorist muhamed, but you love evil, we understand your condition well:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybristophilia
@lee sherbourne Oh yes, halla, you're right
th-cam.com/video/cZ8RA4jnJR4/w-d-xo.html
demon alla is muhameds associate, but halla is cool
halla fakbar
@@worfoz where does islam promote child rape and homophobia? not agreeing with the act of homosexuality isnt homophobia, it is opressing them and trying to get rid of them, completely against what Hamza said. Also child rape and rape is not allowed either
I miss these old talks of Sheikh Hamza Yusuf, they were much more open and directed specifically to the problem in question where he shows so much love and energy for Islam, they have now become much more political, however I still think he is one of the very best if not the best in portraying Islam for what is really is, a peaceful and spiritual religion.
Beautifully put. Much respect to his Muslim Brother, highly educated and a Gem in our Ummah.
@@worfoz dude do you want to be a Muslim or something?
Ameen
I don’t see how anyone could of answered this better.
@@worfoz 1. That was TOTALLY out of context.
2. Prove that he was a "child rapist"
3. He NEVER said "belive me or I kill you". He has NEVER forced Islam upon anyone. He would allow people who are Jewish or Christians to practice their faith and would never threaten someone to end that worship and force them to join Islam. He said to "invite" disbelievers, not to kill.
4. He never feared gay people or disbelievers. A gay man may have urges, and that is something that could be natural. But acting upon it would be sinful. The prophet would try to improve the lives of sinners and those who wish to improve their lives and ask forgiveness to Allah.
@@fuaadjafree5395 I agree with you, and in fact, God said in the Quraan that "There shall be no compulsion in religion; the right way has become distinct from the wrong way." so whatever worfoz has heard is absolutely the opposite.
@@worfoz Is that the "love" the Evangelists preach about or is this the neo secular liberalist islamophobic hatred? Also are you insulting or actually accusing Mohammad the Islamic prophet, and ruler of the first Islamic kingdom to be a child rapist? State your sources, either from Roman, Persian, Byzantinian or any non Arabic sources.
@@worfoz you're are the most stupid thing ever you'll definitely regret this statement if you don't repent
@@worfoz first of all aicha was fully adult in the standards of that time
2nd of all the prophet said if smwn hurts an inocent non muslim than the prophet himself will be against the muslim in judgement day
3rd of all stop just stofing ur face wid what preists say u have a brain use it
open minded doesn't mean correct..don't forget that.
open-minded person doesn't mean he is smart as well
@@ghostghost514 so open minded, his brain fell out.
@@dontletherspeak7575 hes not being open minded, hes telling the truth that many scholars throughout Islamic history have said
Amon actually the opposite. Do you think being close minded is shows any form of intelligence. How smart is a person who’s very opposed and has a huge ego gonna achieve. While an open minded person even if their arguments and try to take the strongest position on a topic
@@qwite9309
That is quite contradictory
Like absolute liberty
Being fully open minded will mean you must not have an opinion
If someone stands for a moral debate then he must be dogmatic to an minimum extent
Unless the debate is based on logic and numbers no one can accuse the other or dogma
I think people of faith in all religions should study this issue more. I think Hamza Yusuf really made some excellent points. But I also feel like there are other questions and answers on this issue that haven't been dealt with yet.
Brian The Science Show agreed, I still don’t have all of the answers I need..
@@galleryg998 such as..?
@@galleryg998 It is a test from God, just as being a paedophile or psychopath, born with the urge for murder or to manipulate people is also a test.
Even though many people might argue that it doesnt cause any harm, it actually does cause harm to a society (if you do your research) and the feeling is driven by desires, which are caused by hormonal and psychological changes in the womb, which are then triggered by environmental factors, not genes. So it's infact not even entirely natural and can be reversed if a homosexual person protects themselves for desires that could corrupt their hearts.
Why do you think in biology it's always xy or xx and this has nothing to do with how a person feels? When you allow people to change who they objectively are based on feelings then you open the doors to all sorts of weirdness (eg there are currently people identifying as amputees and cutting their limbs off) and now they are even forcing these things on everyone.
Anyway reguardless of all this, if God dislikes it so much and warns us to abstain from it, we should just obey on the account of who he is period.
@@niyas.k6518 😂fr
@@m0hamed_kamz70 well put bro but i didn’t get the xy and xz part, could you reiterate, explain better pls
great answer and such an amazing scholar.
He isn't really an amazing scholar, but it is a good answer.
@@holdshiftt2run308 may you tell me how he isn't?
@@khalidmostafa3934 He calls towards and supports certain things that are baatil and contradict the Quran and Sunnah. For example: he supports bid'ah. He has a support for Greek influenced kalami/ash'ari (philosophical) ideas (in which they reject certain attributes of Allah). Imam An-Nawawi and Al-Ghazzali refuted them. He supports democracy. He says that Muslims should not have a khilafah because rulership is secular. He said focusing on aqeedah is a disease. Aqeedah is basically our beliefs and creed based on the Quran and Sunnah. There are a few other things as well.
@@holdshiftt2run308 that's very interesting! You must've been listening to him for a very long time to have 1)noticed those things and 2) compiled such a list. Did you formerly agree with his teachings and later on disagree?
HoldShiftt2Run id like a reference for most of these statements please, and also I’d like your understanding on what bidah actually is. Thank you.
i notice he get goosebump when talking about the prophecy
Thanks, Intelligent person.
That was a very good answer and delivered in a very polite fashion. I don't see how anyone can argue against that.
Tauhidul Iqbal It is coming from the perspective of a straight man.
And a scholar. Great answer.
How could he understand what a gay person feels?
@@evanhearne4020 He doesn't have to. One person can never feel another pwrson's feelings. He described the rules of a particular religion. In Islam, even if a man feels attraction for another man, he has to overcome it because in this religion, it is considered just as similar to having attraction to another person's wealth/belongings. This is one specific rule of one specific religion and he isn't forcing it on anyone. Imho, we can live wothout sex. If its love we are talking about, that has many forms and most pure forms of love are without the presence of sexual relations. If "hormones decide my fate" and I don't do anything about it, that just makes me closer to an animalistic being, not human.
@@tauhiduliqbalsampad ok, and is a man feeling attracted to a woman just as similar as being attracted to one's belongings in Islam too? Because if not, a gay person should not have to overcome their attractions as it is simply another form of the same relationship. And another thing, hormones are human properties - they are what establish everything about us, how we feel and perceive the world along with genetics.
Where can I find this man's lecture? He explains everything so beautifully Ma'Sha'Allah with no hatred whatsoever with an open heart & mind may Allah (s.w.t) soften our hearts and speeches! Ameen.
Loved every bit of this. ^^
May Allah (s.w.t) make it easy for my homosexual brothers and sister who're going through a hard time just know that Allah azzawajal sees you trying to suppress your feelings for Him for His sake that's more than you can imagine you are ALL loved by the most Merciful & Forgiving Lord. ☝🏻
Ameen - love you for the sake of Allah
@jungoo this is the playlist for the whole series of talks.
th-cam.com/play/PL83A449092F8A3CBF.html
keep in mind when he mentioned that the prophet PBUH said the homosexuals and lesbians would marry each other is BEFORE America made that legal
Subhan'Allah
The hadith he was quoting regarding '[...] homosexuality of the touch [...]' is not specific to homosexuality, the word used is 'zina' which traditionally refers to premarital intercourse.
Thank you! I've been trying to search about the hadith he mentioned. Now it makes sense.
Mashallah video 8 years old but relevant and addressed well even according to today’s debate
He’s so amazing may Allah grant me intelligence such as my brother Hamza yousif in this video
Freaking love this dude
so you are gay?
@@worfoz Worfoz again? I see you are obsessed with Hamza Yousef....
@@worfoz dude you might be a Muslimsexual... you might have an abnormal sexual attraction to Muslims. You need some help with that mate
@@YonikMalik haha comment of the year
he can talk for days and you wouldn't get tired 😂
Omg I always wanted to know whos voice this was, and now I know!
just to be brutally honest homosexual acts are forbidden both in privacy and public
i do realize that there are some people that have the tendency to be attracted to the same sex... i consider that their responsibility as it is my responsibility to keep my feelings of attraction to the opposite sex in check
and god knows best
What does forbidden mean? Haram? He didn't say it s not a sin, he said the sharia gives a punishment when it is out in the open, when you can prove it. If you do it, no matter where, it is a sin
WHAT IS TOTALLY HARAAM REMAINS TOTALLY HARAAM (FORBIDDEN) AND WILL NEVER BE ACCEPTED NO MATTER HOW MANY SINNERS TRY TO MAKE IT SEEM ACCEPTABLE
Beautiful response.
We get so many bad thoughts but we ingone them because we know it is from devil and he want to deviate from Allah order.
--------
Imagine the prophecy of the prophet he said a man would marry a man and woman would marry a woman this thing is actually came true recently and countries are legalizing this things if i am not mistaken during the last 15-20 years and the prophet foretold it 1400+ years ago subhanellah
In the psalms of David there is a verse that comforts my heart about knowing & obeying moral laws about sexuality or other matters - if is to safeguard our souls from harm - it says “ Thy boundary lines have fallen into pleasant places , Oh Lord , Yahweh, My Elohim ( Allah) “ ❤️
@jpg2502
Muhammad isnt a pedo and i studied islam for 20 years. homosexuality is forbidden in every devine religion. God doesn't create sinners
A person with a rational and free mind would not make assumptions about others being blind and relinquishing freedom, especially when they have no evidence to back up their assumption. Making an assumption like this is the opposite of what it means to be free or open minded. Anyways, i urge you to watch more of this man's videos on TH-cam, especially his philosophical series on 'How to read a book' before you deem him ignorant. Good day.
some people are trying to say that it's his opinion on the matter and that Islam has no influence over it. This is not true. It's an understanding from our faith, that homosexuality is prohibited. If that somehow became a stigma for islamaphobes then you're just gonna have your prejudices confirmed. What Shaykh Hamza was explaining was the application of the judgement, that as humans we cannot judge what happens behind closed doors.
Matthew 19:12 For there are some eunuchs, which were so born from their mother's womb: and there are some eunuchs, which were made eunuchs of men: and there be eunuchs, which have made themselves eunuchs for the kingdom of heaven's sake. He that is able to receive it, let him receive it.
Who said so that a hadith is authentic or not authentic? Where in the Quran such hadith is authentic or not?
You don't have to be feminine to be a homosexual.
superstubes yeah but most do act like feminine
D Max You don't even notice the ones that aren't.
i do notice but the problem is most do act feminine just watch any homosexual pride ,,
D Max lol . I think the campest gays are IN pride parades and on the floats.
***** not all gay men like "getting F*cked".
He mis-stated this. By private space doesn't mean your home. It means an action that no others can see- not even your spouse, children, or guests. Those issues that are hidden are between you and Allah.
The moment it becomes public is when another individual learns of your deeds. And thus it must be scrutinized and something must be done to stop the act.
i love his lecture
He did not quote the hadiths correctly
Homosexuality is an addiction.
AbuYusuf KSA : Since muhammad thighed young boys and diddled little girls who are muslim clerics or teachers to preach to people about morality?
Bollocks. Its a SEXUALITY.
AbuYusuf are you attracted to female by instinct or choice...I know I like women lips,skin and genitals because of instinct...and even when I try to be attracted to a man I just can't be attracted...I can't be attracted to his lips and genitals...Homoexuality can't be a choice it's an instinct driven preference just like heterosexuality...If i choose my sexuality hey! let people choose to have sex with a statue or a chair or a rug...it's a choice right why should it be human that I must have sex with
?
No, it isn't.
sandra finder it is absolutely not a disease.
I'm not gonna say anything, but if you believe that there's GOD, you should know the meaning why God create male and female... think about it ...
Excellent video. Always love Hamza Yusuf’s clarity
Please help answer. What should an ex practising gay who have repented? He wants to marry a woman but he has no desires but he also fears that if remains single, he may be tempted to go back to his old life. What should he do? What is Islamic stance on celibate guys? Thanks
The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “O young men, if you are able to support a wife, then get married. Verily, it restrains the eyes and protects the private parts. Whoever is not able to do so, then he must fast as it is a means of control.”
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 1806, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1400
Beautifully explained...
If someone is homosexual it's not his fault until he or she act on it.he have to restrict himself from act on it.May Allah help them.we all are the Adams child.
Wow. Mind-blowing answer
Perhaps that was a mere example of the bigger point, which is not to transgress the boundary; And that if you have impulses to ACT on your desires that transgress that boundary, then you should suppress it.
Masha Allah, best answer regarding this issue. I'm impressed.
9 gays disliked
Men marrying men and women marrying women is just bizarre.
Leon612 Ameen aki
No it isn't.
Nah its not. Society and religion made you think its bizarre.
Yeah, because in that manner, reproduction is absolutely impossible which is the complete opposite of nature or ,as atheists believe, evolution.
What is the narration of this haidth you said I've searched for it in Arabic and I didn't find it
I think it may be fabricated or extremely weak.
the hadith in question is about 'zina', not homosexuality as such. but his point still stands wa allah u a'lam.
@@toothcap66 I didn't find it in any Arabic trusted source. Sharing controversial not strong hadith is a huge mistake... no one should share hadith without narration specially when it is contradicting with Quran.
@@lamisashraf3534 you’re right, the sheikh should have been a bit more careful. thank you for informing me
And thank God for that! The Prophet (S) married many women only because it was politically necessary and because those women were in need of protection. In the western world, i really don't see how marrying multiple women is beneficial. Also he (S) encouraged men to have only one wife. I really don't care what the non believers do. And seeing that marrying multiple women is vehemently abused in the Middle East, i'm glad it's barred in the west and most of the world.
So basically Allah was talking about straight people who might feel some sort of attraction towards same sex at some point in their lives?! But what about people who are 100% gay from the first day? They are attracted to same sex the same way straight people do!
This is the first time I heard the hadith and it is very accurate to what's happening now. Can someone help me to give the source? I would like to read its matan. I tried to search it but it's hard for me to find it. I didn't find it yet...
فعن ابن مسعود رضي الله عنه أن رسول الله -صلى الله عليه وسلم- قال: "إن من أعلام الساعة وأشراطها أن يكتفي الرجال بالرجال والنساء بالنساء.." (رواه الطبراني والبيهقي).
@@amandaher1545
I have looked it up and it seems to be very weak or fabricated ضعيف جداً أو موضوع
At one point in the video was he preaching intolerance? He says what you do behind closed doors is between you and god, Not anyone else's business. I think you've missed the point.
spot on. I accept your answer. thanks.
This is utter crap in that you claim a person who is effeminate should not lead prayer is equivalent to saying feminism is should not be permitted in prayer or that women should not pray because it devalues prayer. If Allah decided to respect women and their prayers, why should a man be permitted to devalue women or men who choose women as a better example of behaving? God obviously created gay men and women just as easily as He created heterosexual men and women and it is not a straight man's or astraight woman's purpose to judge them at any level. The task of judgement has always been That of the individual best qualified to judge which is Allah. Muslims must choose to be angry at Allahs creations or accept His creations. Please tell me which of Allahs creations are to be condemned by the arrogance of man?
"I really think that's the way Muslims would look at it." Akhi. My brother in Islam, you're right only insofar as what is required of a Muslim. But what is required of a Muslim and what is done BY the Muslims today a
Does anyone know where to find the ahadith he references concerning signs of the end of times?
Suppression... depression... suicide...
That’s what’ll happen. If I suppress who I am, that is what will happen. I am a pangender asexual lesbian who is also a Muslim and proud.
That beauty itself is not that of the creature but the attribute of that creature's maker, creator. Beauty is an attribute of Divine nature, a metaphysical attribute of Allah, not the creations.
the lord guides whom he pleases ;)
Correct doesn't equate to Liberal and Liberal doesn't equate to correct. "If you are tolerant of everything, you stand for nothing."
May Allah Protect us from the attrction of the Evil. Ameen
alla should have protected poor little aisha
muhamed worshipers are gay AND homophobic
Knowledge is power.. may Allah bless this man
You talk about how this person was indoctrinated into his faith and then end your argument with 'may Thor guide you'...that just discredits everything you said. Fail.
U know how much its hard to control
I mean look at straights getting marrying, if they love there spouses it raises them in the eyes of God
On the others hand
We cant love think and marry
Imagine the extent of this test
I would want all heavens for this
muhamed raped a child, listening to you MUHAMED WORSHIPERS defending child rape and homophobia is mindblowing
how can you defend the 7th century CRIMES LIKE TERROR AND CHILD RAPE, while using modern internet?
I am not sure if comparing the impulse for stealing to the impulse for sexual attraction to opposite sex works. Sex is a very basic need of humans whereas act of stealing is not. Likewise hunger is one of the essential needs of humans like sex. I think comparing hunger to impulse for sex works better. And we are to compare these two, we can see that it is impossible to suppress the impulse for sex like it is impossible to suppress impulse for hunger. I am a muslim. I just look for a satisfactory answer for the wrongness of being gay from a islamic point of view.
Johnny Depp - Secret Window
Hamza, Hadiths were considered the spoken word of Mohammad, but who really knows what they were,they could have been made up by some individual with a strong presence in the community and accepted as fact,but this is open to conjecture.
Agreed, however there is a chain of authenticity, from where a Hadith was report from. And those Hadith that have a trace back to the orator are considered Sahih. And these will be found in Sahib Bukhari and Tirmidhi
The science of Hadith is meant to ensure the authenticity of hadith...
@@onyx9943 Authenticity, Science? there is no Science. But Hey, If it feels good and the violent side of Islam is not alluded to, then it's ok.
@@adoreslaurel
No one will shame you if you admit that you don't know much about it. You're always free to educate yourself on the matter, but it is your responsibility not to be as ignorant about it as you are now...
@@onyx9943 Well you can keep pushing the line that Islam has something to offer the world but the fact that the Islamic world has lagged so far behind the rest of the world for so long would appear to give the lie to that, until oil became the biggest thing in the middle east, there was nothing of any consequence happening there, you could talk all you want about the great scientific discoveries made thousands of years ago,but since then, the Islamic world has ground to a halt. Can you point to one Islamic country that is showing any signs of making significant progress in social reform, womens rights etc.,look at the way Salman Rushdie is still persecuted, where is the tolerance? lets face it, there is none. an what about cutting the hand off a thief, so the he cant work and his wife and children starve to death.look at the Taliban, denying women an education, you are welcome to dream on.
And the punishment for apostasy and blasphemy in Islam is a big warn hug, is it? Actual death, or imagined damnation... which is more loving and special...
Here from the 2050: "Necrophilia is Legalised"
@@Haseeebo you're a dumbass!! Did you even understand what he's saying ?!
You can be Muslim and GAY. The catch is that Islam does not allow homosexual interactions or marriage (homosexual sex). People do not choose to become gay. Think about this for a moment, what kind of sane person wishes they were gay? If people can be born with autism, or have the potential to develop schizophrenia or alzheimer's (both mental disorders have genetic and environmental factors). Do you seriously still think it is impossible for a person to be born gay? Homosexuality is the result of biological, genetic, and ENVIRONMENTAL factors. To condone and insult gay people for existing is absurd. As Muslims, we should not be sending them death threats. We should instead pray for them and help them.
Here is proves for you
Mukhannathun
-A hadith is Sunan Abu Dawud 41, 4910
A mukhannath who had dyed his hands and feet with henna was brought to the Prophet. He asked: What is the matter with this man? He was told: Apostle of Allah! he affects women's get-up. So he ordered regarding him and he was banished to an-Naqi'. The people said: Apostle of Allah! should we not kill him? He said: I have been prohibited from killing people who pray. AbuUsamah said: Naqi' is a region near Medina and not al-Baqi.[2]
This hadith proves that Islam does allow gender none conforming individuals to express themselves without punishment as long as it is natural to the individual.
-Sunan Abu Dawud 32, 4095, in which Aisha says:
A mukhannath used to enter upon the wives of Prophet. They (the people) counted him among those who were free of physical needs. One day the Prophet entered upon us when he was with one of his wives, and was describing the qualities of a woman, saying: When she comes forward, she comes forward with four (folds of her stomach), and when she goes backward, she goes backward with eight (folds of her stomach). The Prophet said: Do I not see that this one knows what her lies. Then they (the wives) observed veil from him.[3]
-The phrase "free of physical needs" could describe an asexual person, homosexual person, and other sexual orientations. I personally think this saying is alluding specifically to homosexual men. Men, generally, in Islam are not allowed to enter women quarters but a mukhannath can. This implies a mukhannath is a man who is not sexually attracted to a woman.
Organic Tide pods thats a false hadith
I truly admire his behaviour, maturity and respect. Although the idea that sexuality and stealing are equivalent comparisons is very ignorant and problematic.
There is much scholarship and history to be debated (I will not debate it as I am not qualified to do so) but if scholarship developed to specifically condemn homosexuality then scholars must think outside and away from that to fully legitimise any view on the issue. There is no one way to understanding Islam and its greatness and so we must be open to challenging every aspect of our arguments.
Why would Allah swt. test any creation in such a way that no other creation has every been known to be tested before (and I am not aiming to dismiss that we can never truly understand Allah swt and the divines actions), but sexuality is uncontrollable, and how does two people loving one another insult the almighty ? This obviously exists outside of the procreation argument.
I urge us to afford queer people a safe and respectable space in our communities and spaces and I pray we can be amongst those who critically and seriously engage with ideas and beliefs, may Allah swt always guide us and may we never stand against our creator.
Mohamed Riyaadh Loonat Well said!
Treat others how they would want to be treated . We can get so focused on being religious, but this is the most important law in the universe.
loved it!
He should know about feminine men! 😉 he looks very feminine.
this literally is the only guy who actually isn't repulsively ignorant
what lol
This what the vast majority of Islamic Scholars believe and say...
Wayne Johnson He isn’t saying to stone them to death at least. Have some gratitude that this guys more open-minded than most Imams
@@kasimmalik9806 exactly
@@kasimmalik9806
Open minded as in "disrespects the boundaries of God" ??!
He is explaining why it is condemned in Islam... He hasn't commented on the punishment for such a crime...
لَا إِلَٰهَ إِلَّا ٱللَّٰهُ مُحَمَّدٌ رَسُولُ ٱللَّٰهِ
• (lā ʾilāha ʾillā llāhu
muḥammadun rasūlu llāhi)
There is no deity but Allah; Muhammad is the messenger of Allah
search on youtube hamza tzortzis
may god(allah) guide you
As far as know, the Hadith is about Zina of eye, hand, etc. and not homosexuality. I would like a proof from thus so called scholar that word "homosexuality" is in this hadith.
Mash Allah Shayekh. What an answer!
If you find clarity is because Islam make everything clear. God is the ultimate source of clarity.
so that is why muhamedans kill each other ever since the battle of the camel: you are so clear
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Camel
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ridda_wars
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Islamist_terrorist_attacks
www.thereligionofpeace.com/attacks/attacks.aspx?Yr=Last30
sunnah.com/bukhari/67/70
sunnah.com/bukhari/67/93
sunnah.com/abudawud/12/76
sunnah.com/nasai/26/60
sunnah.com/bukhari/63/122
sunnah.com/muslim/16/82
sunnah.com/nasai/26/61
sunnah.com/muslim/16/84
sunnah.com/urn/1261940
sunnah.com/muslim/16/81
Don't...type...it...argh I can't resist!
Ahem,
That's a pretty gay question.
Please make dua for me.
Wow, my impulse control sucks. Alhumdulillah Allah didn't give me the fitnah of being gay.
PFFGGGVGGGMFFFNFFHAHAHAHAGA
Most scholars should take a lesson for Sheikh...ive seen too many ulama give a very blunt answer..or sidestep the question or take offence childishly or answer it like a politician.
Same here kinda sad because of the WAY they answers questions about homosexuality like it's some disease or DIRT it's just sad that's what pushes our muslim homosexual brothers and sisters away from Islam.... We should always be kind to the point people can't wait to take their Shahada and be a part of this beautiful Ummah! (For the non-muslims) and as for the believing we should make them fall in love with ISLAM people are filled with hatred nowadays. May Allah (s.w.t) guide us all. Ameen.
Allahumma barik Lana fee ulemaina
Assalamualaikum
I'm 18 now (Female)
In Short, I am a man inside and body is of a female.
May Allah guide u understanding.
Bro, I'm Gay (Lesbian). I don't do Zina nor am I willing to. Will I be a father and of course a husband in Jannat.
I know y'all are thinking,
"This kind of words we have never heard from an individual.........."
I'm sure whatever your reward it will be fulfilling.
In Jannah, Allah promised you will get EVERYTHING you desire. ANYTHING. So there’s no need to ask specifically will you get this or will you get that because if you desire it in Jannah, you will receive it. You have to trust Allah and follow his commands in this world. For example, one may want to drink wine but they will refrain for the sake of Allah. Allah (swt) will reward them.
Well, good luck... I have similar problems
@@yusuffulat6954 Instagram @___anink___
wtf is that even? sorry not trying to be rude. im gay myself but im very feminime and i like girls who are feminine. thats the whole point of being a lesbian.
oh thats so cool, what happens in your own home thats your bizniz, outside thats everyones aha
CRAB JOON Yeah, that’s called invading the social circle while you don’t have to. If you eat beef in front of Hindus, they will get seriously upset and disgusted but you don’t have to eat it in front of them. Simple.
It's more than likely the term 'Muslim country' in the comment refers to Islamic states or even Islamic republics. Using Islamic religious law as a basis for government doesn't leave much room for secularism.
OMG, it's really is the end time, look at people around you, man marry man, women marry women.
That’s how nature works sometimes.
With all due respect i think this is the last person to be deemed ignorant. I don't think he would be where he is today if he was. As for the rest of us it is a different matter, and we're not really qualified to judge him or others.
But the question that remains is; why do we have to be so intolerant? For me, not liking someone purely and solely just because the person is gay is like not liking someone just because of their skin color!
2:30 Just a small question ,isn't this case the same for straight people?like if gay people cannot be openly gay in public then straight people can also not be right?
Bismillah ♡
Hadith is forbidden in Quran 7:3 & 69:44-46. Quran is a complete Way of Life with nothing to add nor deduct.
What do u even know the meaning of hadith
so, if I take drugs in private place then it is ok
Also, I don't see how homosexuality is harmful to the public anyway
maroom1 how about the increased risk of serious STDs? HIV? Just a minute public health concern...
+superman88 heterosexuals can't spread diseases?
nicholas harper they can but the rate of incidence in homosexuals is many times higher.
It's not ok, nobody can see what you're doin at home. But the religion of Islam does not encourage to prosecute people based on assumptions like the West suggest. So sinful acts are never "ok". But we can only take action in an Islamic system, once the acts becomes known to the public.
nicholas harper Not if we restrict intercourse to marriage, like Islam, Judaism and Christianity suggest. That's what separates us from animals.
This is the best explanation ever heard in my life that is straight forward.
he's so open minded , mashallah :)
So true Ma'Sha'Allah the way he talks and explains stuff with a softness may Allah (s.w.t) bless him.
I would really appreciate being shown that hadith about men marrying men
+lovingsingleton Its pretty obvious by now when the law has passed allowing same sex marriages.
me to lol
He quotes in video titled devil's trap
Adam and Eve. Not Adam and Steve.
Moz Dee grow up.
Jordan Grice Moz Dee made a good point.
lex t clapping 👏
But God is a man??
That is the funniest phrase ever... as soon as I hear Steve.
Can anyone please direct me to the hadiths that He is talking about here?
The best cure for islam is education
+Addy Waza defend your claim, specifically with respect to this video.
You must not be educated on the Islamic Golden Age. Isnt it ironic....don't you think?
the best cure for islam is an atomic bomb
The best cure for hate is medication
Addy Waza Rather The Best cure for education is ISLAM !
It would be interesting to see how muslims would react to being told that they're free to practice their religion in the privacy of their home, but it could cause harm when it emerges into the public space.
Bigotry is impossible to hide, no matter how reasonable people might try and make it sound.
If that was a rule implemented than the other religous groups would also have to be affected. You cant have double standards.
Why did God (not allah idol) put a gay instinct in me?
You were born that way. Nothing you can do about it
Why do you call Allah an idol ?
Allah didn't put those feelings in you, your society and surroundings did. Allah made you as well as everyone else susceptible to those feelings.
And why he gave some people the tendency to be killers more than the others? just bear with it man
fine killer Agreed
Saying gay people can be gay in private but not in public is contrary to Americanism's values of equality and separation of church and state.
So it practically follows that applied traditional Islam is incompatible with any modern, "western," democracy.
Thanks for all the honesty, Hamza Yusuf!
*****
Well... It does work... And that substantially better than any other sytem that has been tried as of now... ;-)
*****
"increasing international debt"
More or less irrelevant in the bigger picture or long perspective. On the other hand; the past societies DID NOT function any better. To the contrary, they were far worse across a whole spectrum of observables...
"poverty"
Wrong... In the past poverty was a substantially bigger issue than it is now. And that by orders of magnitude if we start quantifying...
"Ancient Greeks"
Myth galore...
*****
"Not at all"
Absolutely 100%. You simply dont get it and keep babbling utter nonsense without having any relevant clue how it _really_ was "back then."
*****
Ridiculous quackery.... You may improve your miserable intellectual condition if you finally start reading stuff. And that piles and piles of stuff like history books, and visiting archives, and museums, ect.
And; until then...
First of all. Not everyone is supposed to agree and accept Western culture as the end all be all and no one is to be condemned because they don't adhere to "THEIR" rules. whether people want to admit to this or not, being gay is not a natural thing. People committ suicide, become depressed, lose their families and they cut off their families bloodline. So yes... its a sin.