Islamic Law & Same Sex Unions | Dr. Shabir Ally
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.ย. 2024
- The book, Islamic Law and Muslim Same Sex Unions, makes a case for same sex unions in Islam, drawing on the Quran, Hadith and jurisprudence. What arguments does this book make? Is it a topic we should consider exploring further? We sit down and get Dr. Shabir's thoughts on this book.
___
Aisha's outfit is provided by www.khimaronlin...
Please SUBSCRIBE to SUPPORT the show!
Questions: www.QuranSpeaks...
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Twitter : / quran_speaks
![[Re:all TREASURE] EP.6 in 방콕ㅣ🚩 쩡캠의 방콕 투어 빵 마이 와이 👍](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/uyFw-nItA_s/mqdefault.jpg)
This man is a true Islamic scholar. He reminds me of the scholars of the golden age of Islam who were both knowledgeable in the religious and non-religious sciences. He makes me proud to be a muslim. I pray that he will become more and more successful.
Ameen.
Ameen.
ameen
Ameen
This is wrong. Homosexuality is haraam in islam without any doubt
it's good to see this kind of debate. theres a lot of negativity on the internet, i came here to counter some of that which i have been absorbing. subscribed.
Dear all, He is giving a feedback on the book. Now watch the video again. It will make sense.
read the Quran it will not make sense because miss representing quran
The Quran says run them out. Really that’s the end of it. Even if we don’t agree.
@@jotesoftread n made sense
Very interesting and well presented. So happy to see such issues discussed thoughtfully without prejudice.
There is a completely reasonable and "centrist" approach to Islam that is so... endangered, so muffled by the extremists on both sides.
I’m going to clear something up because you guys are hating on him for no reason HE IS TALKING ABOUT A BOOK HE READ HE NEVER AGREED WITH IT NOR DID HE AGREE WITH IT HOW CAN YOU PEOPLE CALL YOUR SELF A MUSLIM IF YOU ARE SO QUICK TO JUDGE honestly this is disappointing
I saw the whole video and the fact is Quran does not allow Homosexuality....which is infringement of human rights and Muslims aren't too keen on changing according to the modern world....then why should Islam still be allowed if it infringes on human rights.
@@aruji-sama did you even watch the video?
@@faresourtrex4069 yes I did
Well, anybody can judge, but it's based around how the person did the sin. If they did it in public, I can see why people judge.
@@aruji-sama No need of such sick rights which goes against the decision of creator.
I really admire and respect Dr. Shabir Ally and I can understand why he is not taking a pro or against stance on the issue. Well respected. At least he is open to acknowledging that homosexuality is not as black and white as it is made out to be by many orthodox Muslim scholars
Yes right
Islam bans homosexuality, stop trying to please Westerners
@@user-vk9dw7er6h You need a better version of your Islam. Your Islam is oppressive to a community who have not chosen their sexual orientation, neither have a desire to sin, but to connect with Allah in the best ways possible considering their conditions... Just willy-nilly stating that Islam bans homosexuality is about being ignorant of the lived realities of people while trying to hold on to fatwas and scholarly opinions that does not serve the LGBTIQ community. Can Muslims not see how arrogant it is to assume that only they are saved and everyone else needs to conform to a particular understanding of Islam that no longer works for our contemporary society.? This does not mean we change Islam, it only means we make Islam relevant and accessible.
Homosexuality is a mental illness and they need help rather than being punished
It's 100% haram, period. This is NOT a complicated question that requires nuance. Stop dancing around the issue.and refusing to give a clear answer.
Too bad it’s not for you to judge.
Now a days we know, that homosexualism is not a choise. (if you think it is, try to change your orientation, just for a week and see...) And we should be more inclusive. But we should not force anyone to go against their own beliefs. In my country, the same sex marriage is possible, but the state does not force the religious authorities to perform the weddings. The magistrate will always do them. I think it is a fair call. I live in democracy, and I appreciate the freedom of choise.
Mirage - no, I just know how to pic my battles. If an opponent compares gays and pedos, you know they are so deep in the dark, that even draggind the sun to the room won't help. I wish all the best for you. Salam.
Zel Elz LGBTP
@@ZelElz You have deviated soo much that you have fell of the cliff.
@@abdulazizfareh8927 and I care about your opinion because...?
@@ZelElz I swear by Allah I hate all of you liberal/secular muslims. If you follow Islam then follow it properly, do you guys have no shame?
I`m a lesbian and very happy I was born in this way.
cya on judgement day nour :)) . i hope i see you there and remind you this
@@x7amo490 Allah made her this way shame on you
@@ithinkiknowme6450 Allah has not made her that way its her own choice to choose the haram and Allah knows best why did she do that
Get woke Go broke !
Allah made you a woman if you feel a desire for another woman you can feel it but doing it is Haram in Islam but if you don’t care about islam and what Allah said then you’re free.!
Knowledge and wisdom mashaa Allah!
subuhaanallah this is one of the sighn of the day of judgement "The disappearance of knowledge and the appearance of ignorance" (Bukhari, Muslim, Ibn Majah, & Ahmad)this is clear matter it is well said in the Quran in surah 26:verese165&166{أَتَأْتُونَ الذُّكْرَانَ مِنَ الْعَالَمِينَ
وَتَذَرُونَ مَا خَلَقَ لَكُمْ رَبُّكُمْ مِنْ أَزْوَاجِكُم بَلْ أَنتُمْ قَوْمٌ عَادُونَ} Do you commit unnatural offence with males from among the creatures.And leave your wives whom your Lord has created for you? Nay, but you are a people exceeding the limit.
alhamdhu it is said in authentic hadith that Abdullah ibn Amr reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Verily, Allah does not withhold knowledge by snatching it away from his servants, but rather he withholds knowledge by withholding scholars, until no scholar remains and people follow ignorant leaders. They are asked and they issue judgments without knowledge. Thus, they are astray and lead others astray.”
@@ibrahimjinaah9046 the above article could literally mean that they were committing adultery with men while still being married to women which is Zina which is a sin but what about the fact when Allah says that created us and our mates from the single soul and if a man is only attracted to only men and no women…doesn’t this means that his soulmate is actually a man…and if he hasn’t already taken a wife he could take him as his husband
I was raised catholic, this is a beautiful religion!
Welcome to the religion of islam
After hearing to Zakir Naik's video regarding the same topic I got suicidal and really depressed. Hearing Naik's video made me feel less of a human and more like a curse in Islam, as an abomination of Allah. However, after watching this video it makes me feel more better as a person and once again MY FAITH IN ISLAM WHICH WAS FADING BECAME STRONGER. PROUD TO BE A GAY MUSLIM. MAY ALLAH BLESS US ALL. AMEEN.
So trueeee ☺
Very true live with proud you are made by Allah u are normal and have same rights
And natural also
Make tawbah before you die, man.
may u have a good life
the people talking down and being judgmental about allah’s creation in these comments are being blasphemous. allah says he created a variety of humans and none of you are in the position to judge his creation.
Homosexuality is a fithnah, a test from the Creator. In Jannah, muslims will get whatever their heart desires. But on earth we must do as we are told. But, to mistreat a homosexual is wrong. People are born like this. But keeping a covenant with your Creator is more important than fulfilling your personal desires. Life is fleeting so the test is short. Eternity is forever. And it is your choice whether you want to burn in hell or be in Heaven with the one you love. And Allah Knows Best!
Jack Stewart maybe bc he loves u. Allah tests the people whom he loves. If you put away all your desires for Allah in this short temporary live you‘ll get rewarded big. It is allahs law. By listening to the shaytan who tells you to just live your life to the fullest and not let anyone tell who u are allowed to sleep with you won‘t see any jannah. However I suggest you to make Dua make daily prayer and Ask allah what to do. He will show u.
@Jack Stewart God didn't give you that your government did they are trying to kill us.
@Jack Stewart everyone has different challenges to overcome and deal with in this life.. we need to remember to have patience and faith.
@Dahir Abdiqadir SK06b God doesn't allow homosexuality
@Jack Stewart U also get rewarded more
Dr. Shabir, why does Allah allow all this suffering in the middle east?? It makes it hard to keep my faith when most of the people dying are innocent Muslims. I wish peace upon the whole world 😔
Geopolitics.
I'm not a scholar but I think its because that Allah (swt) gave us free will and gave us guidance through His past interventions as described in religious texts. So what we've done with the world (and each other) since is all on us. We have full range to hurt or help each other and _we_ are deciding to hurt.
***** agreed :) inshaAllah paradise for us all
M As Allah says in The Qur'an "Do people think that they will be left alone because they say: ‘We believe’, and will not be tested?"
The believers will be tested the most. Just have patience and trust in Allah.
In 610 AD Mohammed said to his tiny minority of followers In mecca, Arabia: “One who treads a path in search of knowledge has his path to Paradise made easy by God.” Arabia was the most uninhabitable place on earth, the middle of nowhere (desert), Alexander II arrived in Arabia to “conquer it” before Mohammed and he was like "forget it, lets go back to egypt". Consider that in less than 100 years after the death of Mohammed his followers ruled from Morocco to China as a minority. During european dark ages, after Islam became prominent, out of the blue, this region started to develop and prosper. Ancient Greek texts started being read and translated. Science and philosophy books started being written.
God's very first command to this illiterate man… READ.
READ. READ. READ.
Not worship me, bow, kill non-muslims but simply… READ
…eradicated? You wish.
One of my favourite islamic scholar.
Dr Shabir Ally is one of my favourite Scholars!!!!
Always well presented Mashallah
Muslims need to talk about sex to their children when they get a certain age like when their experience purity. But Muslims parents don't do that so I blame the parents when boys and girls get certain ages they body begin to develop in ways that parents need to explain to them these changes but the parents parents did not explained the facts of life to them either.
Jazak Allah o khair, great job but I was bit uncomfortable with low volume of the video, really difficult to catch on few points because of poor audio quality. Hope you take care of that. Regards
Really balanced and honest approach than you and jazakAllah Khayrun
Even as a non Muslim I can say - this book's view is wrong. The authors of this book have discarded centuries of scholarly Islamic jurisprudence by over analysing Quran grammar by themselves. By this logic, one can self interpret the Quran in whatever way one pleases by ignoring centuries of Ifta and Ijma by qualified Mujtahids. Which is completely unacceptable for any Muslim.
And I repeat, I'm a non Muslim myself but this would be my stance even if I had to play the game of pretending to be a Muslim.
But like, what does a gay Muslim do? Like should they get married to the opposite gender? Should they supress themselves and remain single forever? Like we all know it’s haram, the action (not the feeling), so what shall they do?
He should remain single forever yes. He will be rewarded higher and his ranks in jannah will be raised more easier since Islam has the concept where even not acting upon your sin you get rewarded.
@@kanepane3461 how about you stay single forever to support those millions of Muslim brothers and sisters who you think should be alone fore ever
@@kanepane3461 it’s not safe to advice thousands of homosexual Muslim to stay single forever since that pushes them to the brink of suicide, depression and fornication…. So maybe there should be an acceptance for them since Homosexual people aren’t going to stop being born just because we don’t accept them….it not about sin at this point it’s just necessity…
@@ithinkiknowme6450 we’re not changing the religion God has perfected for us because it makes people sad
لَا إِلَٰهَ إِلَّا ٱللَّٰهُ مُحَمَّدٌ رَسُولُ ٱللَّٰهِ
@harundaniel7705
well there are a lot they can do to block those harmful thoughts.
- Reduce your food, we eat too much to the point where we cannot control our thoughts. the prophet was spending nights without food and resisting the hunger as well as many of his companions so they didn't have time nor they thought of the perversion we are constantly thinking of.
- fast two days per week, again this a part of the treatment.
- read quran, another effective medecine
- pray obligatory prayers and volunteer night prayers
- occupy yourself with community work such as feeding street animals, rescuing kittens, feeding homeless....etc
- start thinking how you could take your mind away from the parts of your body that you want to offer to homosexuality to something that benefit your society.
the list is long,
Definitely the best Muslim scholar. Wish he would come to the UK.
Appreciate the review, thank you.
As a general rule - If it took you over 1000 years to suddenly start questioning traditional scholars, you are likely deviating from the right path.
why is that? Traditional scholars might lack insight on human psychology and neurology and could only and exclusively rely on interpretations without understand how humans fundamentally function. The scriptures were formulated in a way suiting the intellectual average of the people of its time, because back then no one would have understood complex psychology and medical reasons behind certain human behaviors and feelings. It is important to respect and live upon what was revealed, however we should not reject scientific discoveries of any kind, especially those that we need in order to be more understanding and kind towards one another.
Lol okay so you stll believe the sun orbits the Earth then?
@@cf5397 No. Only the uneducated believe in that. Islam never believed in the Geocentric model - But scientists did for a long time. The Qur'an suggested that the Earth, Sun and the Moon were all in their own orbit. Under the Geocentric model, the scientists believed that the sun never had its own orbit, hence tried to discredit the Qur'an as a result. However, when it was realised that the sun does, in fact, orbit around the centre of our galaxy, they were forced to revise their understanding. The Qur'an also hinted that the Earth revolves on its axis. If you keep to your faith, it shall not blind you.
well said, there are many deviants nowadays to make a lot of profit and unfortunately there are many like shabir who is facilitating this deviance, may allah protect us and out descendants.
Islam was more tolerant of homosexuality before British colonialism
The roof top waits
The Emon sighs
A tear drop falls
From in his eyes
One hug he gives
then swift good byes
He'll bless you once
You take to flight
Did you compose this? It's very sad, but captivating... is there any more to it? Please reply... I Really need to know... Best wishes...
To those in this comment section confused about your orientation and at a loss listen,
If your sole purpose is to serve Allah you will know he knows you better than you yourself. These feelings you may have are a test from Allah swt, thoughts are *not* *SIN* but *ACTIONS* are *sins*. Control ur urges and your desires, this is your jihad. Your reward will be equal. May Allah swt guide us all and forgive us Ameen.
Brothers and sisters if I have made any mistakes may Allah SWT forgive me, Allah knows best.
Please feel free to let me know if I have made any mistakes by your account brothers and sisters. Jkz
sammy don’t listen to those who are close minded, remember only Allah can judge you sister ❤️
@@sam-ui5lc youre jihad is the greatest of all and you will be rewarded accordingly. May Allah grant you peace and inner asylum.
@@sam-ui5lc Though I'm completely confused about the issue and still struggling to take my research to a proper conclusion, I don't know why I'm glad for you. ❤️
sammy I feel bad for you, and everyone here seeking advice. Why should anyone or anything dictate who you love? Why? You should take a step back and think of how much Islam is distressing you (this coming from an ex-muslim). I have no right to dictate what you believe in, but I am truly concerned for you. The fact that you are willing to never find love for some religion is alarming. Again, believe what you want to believe, but IMO a religion that tells you loving is wrong, is one trashy religion.
btw, I don’t mean to come off as pretentious or rude, just stating facts and opinions x
@@august779 what's your religion now?
tHIS MAN DOES NOT KNOW HIS QURAN
IT IS A SIN SURA 80 TO 81 And (remember) Lut, when he said to his people: “Do you commit lewdness such as none preceding you has committed in all of the nations 81. “Verily, you practice your lusts on men instead of women. Nay, but you are a people transgressing beyond bounds.”
he knows like the back of his hand his Quran, but he has chosen to bend it like he did in many other topics to keep his notoriety .
Allah told us "woe to those who write the Book with their own hands and then say, “This is from Allah,” to purchase with it a little price!"
Woe to you shabir.
Hello there , is there a continuation of this topic in any other videos? please suggest.
Tuaha Badar dr. Shabir decides to be neutral, in other video he says "you can use this interpretation (homosex is permissible) to do what you want to do
Hi Kumpulan, thanks for your response, mind if I ask you if you work for Quran speaks? or by any means related to it?
Hi how are you?
we all want to marry in our hearts and unite in soul and its beautiful i want to marry and here in montreal its allowed since 2005 so i have that right and i am happy on it here , everyone is equal and should be able to do what they want in life
Not as a muslim. Not permissible in islam, respect that.
@@emrich4797than let people who want to live their lives leave islam safely
@@ithinkiknowme6450 the person said they’re in Montreal, who’ll stop them?
Why do I question my sexuality but the thoughts in my head don’t match my beliefs
And [We had sent] Lot when he said to his people, "Do you commit such immorality as no one has preceded you with from among the worlds? Indeed, you approach men with desire, instead of women. Rather, you are a transgressing people."
- Quran, 7:80 - 81
As simple as that.
@Local host It is.
That is something else😑
Out of context verse
@@heg1098 Do you also think that Islam isnt homophobic?
Title is fully misleading,he is not clear on anything but he is promoting his book
How dissapointing.... and even more shocked at the comments !. What is written in the quran is clear. You can try to twist YOUR interpretation and find a way to make homosexuality accepted but this will never happen. This comment is not coming from hate or anger, his argument is very weak with no proper dalaal to back his ideas. Astaghfirullah
Allah will never ever punish u if u have a feeling for a same gender. But Allah will punish u if u doing the intimacy with the same gender. Just it. Actually it goes same for a straight person too, an intimacy before married is not allowed. But married in islam cannot be doing with the same gender. It should be the opposite gender. So if u’re part of LGBTQ+ and ISLAM... just dedicated your life to Allah. You’re not wrong if you have a feeling, but u’ll wrong if u doing an intimacy. May you stay to the right path. And may Allah bless your life.
What if you look at the same gender. Is it haram
@@acupofjoe7658 check this out th-cam.com/video/ECTD0d0W5ug/w-d-xo.html
What if i fall in love with the same gender since childhood. Is it haram?
YAAAAAAASSS i knew it halal sexuality is not a choice and laos god also said that he created every self with its own partner which means that he create diffrent sexualiteis and boom shoot this in the face homophobic and transphobic we are all human
No. This is not allowed dummy
@@emrich4797 they have the right to their own imaan don’t push your own mentality on them
@@ithinkiknowme6450 you mean don't push what the Quran says and instead follow my whims and desires. This is what you are saying.
I like how his last name is ‘Ally’ hehe
How did the companions understand the verses?
My allah guided me to the straight path. ( If u interpret the Quran by yourself, this happens. Every chapters of Quran can be played with to make it sound appealing to hear the same way as it can be done the opposite way. Ill i can say is that we are seeing the true faces of the preachers that we grew up with 😢😢 am sad about this
the interviewer is not having a good time at all😂😂
Very good MashaAllah
Mashallah , god bless you
Homosexual acts and homosexual marriage are no doubt forbidden in Islam. The Quran itself (even if you reject hadith) makes it absolutely and abundantly clear. However, if people are born with homosexual tendencies then we should sympathize with their affliction and encourage them to stay on the straight path and not go forth with their lower desires, and it is important to explain to them that everything on this Earth is a test and they must strive to stay away from what Allah (SWT) has forbidden.
kdMalk absolutely
kdMalk You are right
Niall Hagan Quran "Do you lust over men in preference to women, nay you are people of transgression" if this is talking about rape, then the verse would be calling to rape women instead of men, this verse is condemning homosexual acts.
Niall Hagan you misunderstood the whole verse. Btw no body said you can't love the same sex or have desire for the same sex- this is not haram. 2nd of all lust means "very strong sexual desire" so the verse is saying "do you approach men with a very strong sexual desire instead of women" again this verse is referring to having sex with the same gender or approaching men in some means "homosexual acts" such as kissing and all that. Again had this verse been talking about rape, it wouldn't say "instead of women" in that case the verse would be saying "do you rape men with a very strong sexual desire instead of raping women, indeed you are transngressers" I mean just stop it you are playing around with the verses and words.
Niall Hagan lol- it's funny how you would like every verse speaking against homosexuality to mean rape- what do u mean by "self protector"
Interesting dialogue.
I ghink this scholar implisitly explain to us that homosexuality is acceptable
Oh my God finally I found this comment. He made me confused he is more like supporting homosexuality
i get you but i think he's just trying to explain about the contents of the book rather than argue with it
You are very right !
Maybe you did not comprehensively understood writings in quran...?
I dn know about the book. But can anyone tell me what really Quran says about homosexuality. Is it haram?
It’s forbidden. There’s no difference about the forbiddance of this major sin.
Does this sound like a good kingdom to you?
And you and your Father
Will never be missing each other anymore
You are going to spend so much time together having fun,
You are having so much fun that I have to go to force yourself to separate for you to hang out with me. All the childhood traumas will be replaced by endless goodness and warmth,
So I complain to God you hang out with your dad and not hang out with me , and God says no problem,
Let me make you all omnipotent
To dwell in my kingdom like me.
So you can be all ages, with each other all at the same time
You see why we need eternity to enjoy each other now? It can be never exhausted.
We will create new ways to amaze
Your neighbor who used to hate you,
Now you enjoy each other’s companionship to learn about each other with nice conversations
All the animals are friendly
You are not only going to see your mother again, but also your grand mother and every single ancestor ever come across
And then
All the kingdoms and nations and even the future ones with the Almighty
So how does this compare to the heaven of 72 virgins with swelling breasts.
I mean, you can only choose one because the first one is from Jesus the Son of God, he is our brother.
The other one is the kingdom and the reward for Muhammad. And everyone is comparing to one another , there are so many eyes everywhere you cannot escape at all, and endless haram to enjoy.
I don’t know , you choose
Oh by the way, in Jesus’s kingdom
you and your husband will be so loving to each other, you apologize and hug
And will never blame each other
You have the access to know everything about each other and go everywhere
An intimacy that only the two of you can share
You are one with each other
Do you want this living God, who is constantly speaking truth and blessings into me, or do you still want the 72 …. With.. you know.
So;
Come to Jesus
This is misleading answer and misinterpreted the versses
This dude makes everything halal what Allah made haram. May Allah protect us from fake scholars
We are not sympathizing sin.
We are all born w/ desires.
If these desires are vain, lustful & defiled...the we shall repent.
Every time i ask my 3yr old if he brushed his teeth his says he did when he did not. I correct him & encourage him to follow doing the right thing.
This is a twice a day thing. He doesnt choose to lie, he chooses the less challenging thing "doing what his Father asked".
Shalom.
What is the upshot, can anyone explain!?
All the wrongs the mistakes the regrets are removed
And we are reconciled with each other
God’s children.
Celibacy is an option. Lust is not Love. Prayers sent.
So you're saying gays can't fall in love? 😂
@@rim2955 It looks that way, but a person can't help who they fall in love with so it lacks understanding and sympathy
@Sérgio Silva and you obviously know better dont you? lmao dont speak on things you dont have knowledge on. youre making opinions based on assumptions and by hearing other opinions based on assumptions. so educate yourself
@Sérgio Silva youre clearly mistaken because quran doesnt say that two men or women cant love each other. stop misusing the holy word
81. ‘Verily, you practise your lusts on men instead of women. Nay, but you are a people transgressing beyond bounds (by committing great sins).’
82. And the answer of his people was only that they said: ‘Drive them out of your town, these are indeed men who want to be pure (from sins)!’
83. Then We saved him and his family, except his wife; she was of those who remained behind (in the torment).
84. And We rained down on them a rain (of stones). Then see what was the end of the Mujrimoon (criminals, polytheists and sinners)”
[al-A’raaf 7:80-84]
What about lesbianism?
@@user-ww3ph3ht5ssame thing
@@user-ww3ph3ht5s All homosexuality is haram
you don't even provide Al A'raf: 80, which the homosexuality here has a context, not as a whole.
Allah knows your intentions, may Almighty open your eyes and heart to clearly see the true
HE IS GIVING THE FEEDBACK ON THE BOOK....ITS NOT QURAN!
Taar Karsi he already tell us that it's not quran you don't speaker english or what
"For ye practise your lusts on men in preference to women: ye are indeed a people transgressing beyond bounds." (7:81)
Of course, we are not homophobic and we should treat those who suffer from same-sex attraction with dignity and respect. But you can't make a case for it being allowed in Islam in light of the above verse.
Practice means acting on it
@@fajaraftab497 Exactly
and yet the super doctor shabir tried to make a case for homosexuality and said that Allah didn't punish the nation of Lut peace be up on him for their homosexual transgression but because they didn't believe in Allah and his messenger.
incredible to see these sell-out imams flushing down the toilet islam.
I guess this video is more useful for today's Is'l'mic countries
Democracy is peaceful Is'lm according to many of Shabir Ally's positions/videos/interpretation of I'slm
They will give homophobic comments only
Who is they?
We can argue?
Who is we?
Interpretation all subjective. God made Eve for Adam not Steve. He made Adam for Eve not Sarah.
Yes?.
Haram!! I cannot believe I sat here for 12 minutes listening to this malarkey! May Allah have mercy on us all.
I don't even know what he says. He talks and talks, without saying much. Just trying to talk things out of the truth.
Why do you say Haram?
@@breakdown7553 He is just avoiding offending anyone by not confronting the Islamic moral that homosexuality is not permissible.
@@seriousperson2065 yeah and that eventually goes on the cost of some brothers and sisters in the ummah, who are already muslims and by his weak words then think: oh well, it is not that bad! So i can go for it...
If you make sacrifices to your own religion to not offend those who don't believe...then wallahi, you are doing something clearly wrong. Allah knows what his intentions are, for what he is saying there but I don't think it's good, in fact it is the opposite.
Allah will never ever punish u if u have a feeling for a same gender. But Allah will punish u if u doing the intimacy with the same gender. Just it. Actually it goes same for a straight person too, an intimacy before married is not allowed. But married in islam cannot be doing with the same gender. It should be the opposite gender. So if u’re part of LGBTQ+ and ISLAM... just dedicated your life to Allah. You’re not wrong if you have a feeling, but u’ll wrong if u doing an intimacy. May you stay to the right path. And may Allah bless your life.
Shabir is recommending to read a book that twist the words of Allah to fit their desires.
“Then woe to those who write the Book with their own hands and then say, “This is from Allaah,” to purchase with it a little price! Woe to them for what their hands have written and woe to them for that they earn thereby” [al-Baqarah 2:79]
shocking shocking and shocking, WOE TO YOU Shabir, WOE TO YOU.
Was never a fan of this guy but I watched a few of his videos once. You question why guys like this are even muslim let alone preach about it when they question, reject or updates are required in so much from the Quran and sahih hadith. They try to appease the Western Liberal society which has no values or morals because they're changing every second.
Shabir ally always talks too much.beat about the bush.homosexuality is forbidden.this is straight and clear.
Homosexuality is haram. The Quran is very clear on this.
which masjid is this?
as usual sound quality is bad...now I have to turn off the fan to listen to this and i'm not turning it off
Shabir cant speak out louder, he speak not like a man, its like he is afraid of his government, but shabir aren't you suppose to be scared more of Allah who give permission for all things
huh
Good
He kinda made me confused, can anyone tell me what does Quran actually say about same sexuality
Maliha Azad Allah will never ever punish u if u have a feeling for a same gender. But Allah will punish u if u doing the intimacy with the same gender. Just it. Actually it goes same for a straight person too, an intimacy before married is not allowed. But married in islam cannot be doing with the same gender. It should be the opposite gender. So if u’re part of LGBTQ+ and ISLAM... just dedicated your life to Allah. You’re not wrong if you have a feeling, but u’ll wrong if u doing an intimacy. May you stay to the right path. And may Allah bless your life.
@@wandastacy4119 By that point, you're saying that if you're apart of the lgbt and you're a muslim that's no problem. It is a problem, since it is prohibited.
@@cxarhomell5867 yes, correct
@@wandastacy4119 The double-standards are confusing. Why can heterosexuals marry as a lawful outlet for their sexual desires which comes to them naturally, but the homosexual who have no choice about their sexual orientation is asked to 'dedicate your life to Allah'? And the answer is always a heterosexist / heteronormative one, "God created heterosexuality but homosexuality is a choice'. Is God heterosexist too?
@@al-ghurbaahfoundationccine4767 Whenever i listen to my Muslim friends I also start doubting Allah. I think it is so sexist just to allow hetero to marry cause they can make kids, but there are many women in this world who can't have kids too, should they also be banned from love and family?
Well, I'll do what the prophet did regarding this. As for youuuu, don't stay near doubt (at least). Shabir, God knows you.
He's sugarcoatin i use to like this man not enymore
India may jarur band hona chahiye qanooni aur Dhara Banna chahiye Homosexuality ki saza Islam may sirf katal aur jadu se karwata Insan Ko is Amada karne ki dohri saza jadu ki saza katal + homosex saza katal bahut badtareen gunah hai Zina se hazar darze badtareen hay.
Auzubillahi minnashaitaanirajeem
May peace and mercy of Allah be upon you.
Can you describe this verse?
Chapter 7:81
اِنَّکُمۡ لَتَاۡتُوۡنَ الرِّجَالَ شَہۡوَۃً مِّنۡ دُوۡنِ النِّسَآءِ ؕ بَلۡ اَنۡتُمۡ قَوۡمٌ مُّسۡرِفُوۡنَ ﴿۸۱﴾
shabir knows the verse like the back of his hand and he won't explain it the way Allah said it.
The message of Quran that is apparent that homosexuality is not allowed; many arguments to it, and it is not not just men’s issue then why was Lot’s wife was not saved?
back bone of Islam.Hadith, majma al-zawa'id Ali ibn Abu Bakr al-Haythami,299/9 answer pls translated pls
Fast think you cover your self
every one who tried Once crispy Bacon, knows that there is no alternative to real Bacon, in conclusion Bacon is Halal ! Allah Akbar !
أَتَأْتُونَ الذُّكْرَانَ مِنَ الْعَالَمِينَ
daartagnantt ليس كل المثليين ياتون الذكران
المهم عند المثلي هو الوجود مع شخص مثله ليس بالضرورة الإتيان فقد يكون غقط حب و رومانسية و حنان مع الصلاة والصيام والخوف من الله و النوافل والحج لكن العقل يميل آلى مثله ولا يكون الميول لأي احد وإنما يكون لكل واحد نوع يميل اليه - سبحان الله
@@kamalxxful قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم ( رجل فوق رجل لايذكر اسمهما في الجنة ) -_-
فينيكس _ 4 حديث مكذوب اتق الله في نفسك
الإتيان بالاغتصاب وهذي كانت عادة قوم لوط ولو كان حرام لكان الله سبحانه وتعالى ذكر الآخرين معهم
EXUSSE ME BUT IM PIG EATHER FROM THE WOMB OF MY MOM WHY CAN THAT BE A SIN ???? IF GOD CREATED ME LIKKE THAT WAY ???????????
We have free will.
You choose what you eat, not who you love
Is Touching belly allowed in islam among womans. ..
Wt do you mean? Like a women touching a pregnant ladies stomach or..? Your question is very broad?
Like
This man is a civilised scholar & a gentleman. Yet, gays must always be viewed as haram. It is unclean and sinful.
There is a difference between having those feelings and acting upon doing the Haram things
zarailly yes! This is what I’m saying
We are a creation of Allah and ypu re saying the creation of Allah is unclean and sinful? I hope your family would've taught you well.
Astaghfirullah. Please do not change our religion. You are simply saying things that people want to hear, without any basis on the Qur'an and Hadith. You talk in circles and beat around the bush without answering the question face on. Homosexuality is wrong and condemned in Islam, is that so difficult to say? May God guide you.
Read the whole verse on Quom LOT, in quran. It would help you understand.
@@falconsnest886 Get woke Go broke!
so you can experience a marital bond but homosexual people can't? this is not what a loving god would prescribe. if you're going to be disrespectful to an oppressed minority like the LGBT community, don't you dare complain about people oppressing you. respect goes both ways. what's really sad is that so many members of the LGBT community rush to defend Muslims, as they understand that they are a minority group like themselves. at least extend that same courtesy to them. absolutely unbelievable. people like you make it seem like there's no choice but to be against islam and you bury spiritual wisdom underneath dogma. ://
@@avendesora_ no
Astaghfirullah rabbi min kulli zanbinn wa atubo ilaik
What?
@@Ahmed-vy1cs He said may God forgive all of my sins and I repent to him
@@lilsomething8905 oh ok then I read that wrong sorr
Being homosexual is also feeling and nature is reason for it. What if homosexuality is from dark side of the nature.
Is this LGBTQ channel?
Check the title and name.
Don't follow this channel
He could just explain in a single sentence that Islam is basically homophobic and get done. Why was he going round and round and round. Lady please remove your headscarf, your hijab has heated and melted your brain.
Freedom of choice and freedom of religion, you are fanatic.
@@FM-vo8pb islam and freedom of choice? What a joke. The fanatic has been exclusively invented for a Muslim, specifically a Sunni. Your fanaticism started right from the time when you people murdered the daughter of your prophet himself for lust of power.
You could just explain in a single sentence that you're basically Islamophobic and get done.
I think I'm going to unsubscribe from this channel
Mario Kart simpel, "let quran speak"
Any muslim is not the God, you must listen to the God itself, read the quran the arabic one.
Dr. Shabir has spoken based on what Quran actually says. Non of his statements againts the quran,
Says *mario kart*
Okay, cool. *nobody cares*
@@kumpulanvidiohiburan9801 let the satans speak
Dear Shabir Ally, be careful that you do not make lawful what Allah s.w.t has made unlawful.....because you will get the punishments of all that follow you...Taqillah and interpret what you read from the Quran correctly.....
Have allah told you that this is haram
Omg. A talented scholar is here.
Why is celibacy to much to ask of a gay person?
Why don't you become single and give us an example how its so easy
@@non_religious I was single for 6 years before I met my wife and I was celibate the whole time, now what?
@@yayorandel6048 R u serious dude ?!! Is staying single for 6 yrs equals living single forever? Like 60-70 yrs? And Do u not realise how prospect of living alone forever can be detrimental to one's mental health.
@@non_religious Jesus christ was celibate his whole life, there are people who are part of the church who take a vow of celibacy, so it can be and has been done many times by many different people.
@@yayorandel6048 so u think we simple people are like Jesus.. That's ridiculous! And tell me what percent of humans are celibate?!?
Dr Sabir Ally himself is a misguided one... How can he guide others when he himself misguided....
Please explain to the billions of people who better understood it to be haram. Homosexuality is caused by the jinn inside you.
Mohamed had a number of boy friends .
Do as I say not as I do.
Don't follow this channel. Guys speaks his own opinion
So does everyone
Frankly, i never appreciated this guy's approch,analysis or opinion. Sometimes i really have doubts about his sincerity. Homosexuality is clearly and definitly forbidden in Islam ( explicitly mentioned in the Koran ).
It is FORBIDDEN by Elohim.