Why are FDI flows into India at their lowest level in 16 years?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มิ.ย. 2024
- #fdi
FDI inflows into India are the lowest they have been in 16 years in absolute dollar terms, and the lowest in even longer when seen as a percent of GDP, and analysts say this is because of the policies of the Modi Government. ThePrint's Deputy Editor TCA Sharad Raghavan explains in #ThePrintVideo.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Hi. The report fails to point out that the share of tax havens in the total FDI has reduced. FDI from Mauritius, Singapore, and Cyprus is often seen as domestic money masked as FDI. We should see if the FDI from the USA, the UK, and other such countries is increasing to understand if the real FDI is increasing. I believe those have increased significantly.
Also avoided differentiating the kind of fdi India receives. For example we need fdi in manufacturing and technology areas where they bring new technology in India and not fdi in consumer market like Walmart which is just looting the Indian market just like they did in Pakistan.
🤣...bhai video dobara dekh le...
Also Judiciary. Nobody wants to invest after looking at the State of our courts
TYPICAL ANDH BHAKT MINDSET. THE FDI FROM THESE TAX HEAVENS AREN'T ENTIRELY DOMESTIC MONEY. FOREIGNERS PREFER TO INVEST THROUGH THESE COUNTRIES BECAUSE OF THE TAX CONCESSIONS THEY PROVIDE. EVEN IF YOU CONSIDER ALL OF IT AS DOMESTIC MONEY, WHICH IS OBVIOUSLY NOT TRUE, STILL THE FDI FROM THESE TAX HEAVENS STOOD AT 22 Bn FOR THE ENTIRE YEAR. FOR THE FIRST HALF OF 2022, LETS SAY IT WAS 12 BN FROM THESE COUNTRIES, WHEN THE TOTAL FDI FOR THE FIRST HALF WAS ALMOST 50 BN. NOW YOU MUST SAY THAT AT LEAST THE REST 38 BN WAS LEGITIMATE. WHY HAS IT SUDDENLY DROPPED TO 10 BN??? AND ANOTHER QUESTION, IF I AGREE WITH YOUR POINT, EARLIER DOMESTIC MONEY WAS COMING BACK INTO INDIA AT LEAST, NOW IT MUST BE GOING SOMEWHERE ELSE. HOW HAS THE FDI INCREASED??? IT'S STUNNING TO ME THAT ANDH BHAKTS WILL SAY ANYTHING TO DEFEND MODI & BJP, NO MATTER HOW DESTRUCTIVE IT IS FOR OUR MOTHERLAND!!
FDI have internationally moved from older industries of electronics, pharmaceutical etc to new frontiers of EVs, hydrogen fuels, data centers, AI etc.
Reasons for decreasing fdi flow.
1:- adoption of protectionist polices around the globe
2:- ease of doing business is on the paper
3:- termination of bilateral treaty agreements
4:- favourable usa market
Population is there but not the skillful workers.
AI adoption also
@@sarangakarte9168 how? I think ai adoption will boost the fdi in tech sector 🤔
@@satyajitsahu2852 that will be only for highly skilled programmers. It will replace base level programmer, which are major part of Indian resources.
@@sarangakarte9168 we are discussing the fdi flow not the unemployment rate.
still govt has not come out of its protectionist mindset.
That's exactly opposite of what the report. Investors are vary about India's judiciary rather than govt. Bilateral investment treaties allows investors to litigate outside India. We want the opposite of that, we want them to litigate in India - investors don't trust our courts to deliver judgements on time.
Actually you are both correct. The BITS concern is mainly about India's courts being dysfunctional. There are very few countries where court decisions can take a decade to be resolved. Most former colonies using the British legal system like Singapore, Hong Kong, etc have functional systems. I don't know how or why the system has failed in India, but it's certainly an issue for investors. Some companies are also worried about government or private firms using political leverage to pressure decisions. The Reko Diq episode in Pakistan is one example of what they are worried about. Ultra-nationalism and reflexive suspicion makes this kind of thing more of a concern.
The general mindset towards foreign companies is very unique in India, there is still quite a bit of suspicion which is probably a colonial hangover. China, which was the last manufacturing powerhouse had a very different approach. Thanks to Deng Xiaoping's "Reform and Opening Up" policy their idea was to do everything they could to attract foreign companies to invest. China and Japan are basically sworn enemies, but they still had Japanese businesses invest in the North-East, including practically building entire cities from scratch. If you were a foreign business and asked them to jump, they would ask how high. Ultimately this got China very integrated in global supply chains and then they started to cut out the foreign firms piece by piece through copying. In India sometimes it seems the attitude is to try and run before you can walk where 100% indigenization is prioritized from the start.
That's not to say that everything is bad. GST was a masterstroke and something foreign firms had been asking for 30 years. But there are still many more reforms needed. I read an article in Reuters about toymakers trying to move to India describing how it is still incredibly difficult to move goods between state lines because of inspections, regulations. Just doing business across the country is a pain because of language differences. In most other countries this is a non-issue.
The way to make manufacturing in India attractive is by fixing the fundamentals. PLI can only do so much when its impossible to acquire land, labor laws are overly rigid, and power pricing is vastly higher than China due to farmer subsidization. All these are complex and painful political problems but they need to be solved for India's development. The BJP is certainly preferable to Congress for this but their attitude of hyper-focusing on their constituency of domestic traders is not productive. It matters for the businessmen, but the thousands of workers who need to move off farming won't care whether they are working for a foreign or domestic firm as long as their wages are paid.
@@libshastra
@@libshastra they don't trust any 3rd world country court. they feel pain of delay than trust. They won't trust even chinese courts inspite she being superpower because regime indirectly control it
@@JohnSmith-vn8dm1) India is like Whole EU into one. I don't think a russian will be willing to learn italian to read labels on his Lamborghini you have to get it printed in Russian for mass mkt & every literate understand English so I don't language barrier point from prospective of a foreign country. (2) North china was colony of Japan & had few setups already working there from those times even we are befriend with many Europeans who were our colonial enemies be it Portugal, UK, France, Dutch & Arabs. China & Pak who were friend & part of us resp. have become our self proclaimed enemies although we still invite FDI from china inspite of tension at LOC but they are not reliable as Japanese or koreans & often cause threat to national security so can't be trusted with anything substantial. (3) You are right with Low level corruption but labour laws are not as rigid as it used to be 60-70s with overhang of communist times Most of indians do overtime, ask for insurance & saving contribution, accident pay in case of hazardous industries with a very lenient watch by govt & 80% of employers can get away with bribes less than doing req statutory contributions, I don't think any indian law require something substantial from employer for employees apart from salaries. (4) Electricity- yes cross subsidies are issue but we have to keep food prices in check govt even subsidies fertilizers, taxes on Tractors, don't charge for dams & canals, offer subsidies for food processing & animal husbandry to support farmers & keep check on food prices, but since we have abundance of coal, large industries has started to setup private generation units or can say cooperative generation plants where they directly produce own electricity than buying from state Discom, not possible for MSME but projects with investment above $1B are doing it, some going for solar or mix of solar thermal, govt has recently deregulated Mining so that Coal production can increase with pvt participation. I don't know how cost works out there were tax rebates as well but it has been discontinued if somebody properly lobby about it they can be resumed I am sure about it. (5) Large projects most of the state govt offer land from their own exchequer, its a state subject so some states like Guj, Tamil Nadu, UP you will find easy to get it as state police help out but not in other state, still most of states are making it easier but it can be clubbed with delay judiciary problem rather than problem with Regulations or rules. (4) Where india majorly lack is contract enforcement, logistics, Low level corruption(mostly originates from State govt) talented manpower (lack of subsidized college education availability) , lack of investment in R& D as high dependence on foreign tech is there for basically everything sophisticated we manufacture due to failure of pvt & govt Research organisations & lack of motivation to change the course. (6) Attitude of indigenous development has been developed after Make in India by Govt & a development of nation pride after learning from our east asians like korean japanese chinese, it is recent change decade earlier the obvious choice used be chinese with govt doing almost nothing like PLI for domestic manufacturing. Developments in Our Chemical industry is recent example how Focusing inhouse should work where we become chemical exporters from importers from china. Although machinery used is still chinese I suppose, but this country needs that attitude if want to provide for largest population in world
FDI is $70bn so far in 2023(3 months to go), and was $84Bn last year(highest ever) Which absolute FDI are you talking about?
If world recession is cause of low fdi, how come Mexico and indonesia can attract bulk of it?
I believe it's because of uncertainty on democracy in this nation, plus increase in corporate corruption , you can clearly see how gov handed out tenders by taking bribe as electoral bond
Sharad Raghav - TCA Deputy Editor-WOW you should be something, Analysis by print of data give by RBI that's the punch- And one line that that takes cup , the The reason for fall in FDI as percentage of GDP is due to polices of the Modi government. Without explaining a simple economics 101 of the Need for FDI without giving background of BITS and its abuse by foreign companies (to avoid adverse judgement in litigation), you tainted the govt in one clean swoop
BITS gave more protection to FDI and forced responsibilities to indian govt. For example the first BITS was signed by India with UK 1993, there was no reasonability of UK towards hosting of economic offenders from india (Like Vijaya malaya, Nirav Modi and likes), the UK court has cleared extradition of malaya in 2020 yet the extradition is held up for more than 3+years now due to some secret proceedings by UK government.
where as FDI had all the protection rights against litigation to protect its investment under the grab of this protection they were getting way from tax litigation which companies like vodafone, crain and white industries used to get away
Does indian investor would not get the same kind of protection.
Investments in any countries economy happens by either FDI or savings.
FDI in india at its peak is 3% of GDP as you showed in your own graph, Compares this with savings (Domestic investor) which averages at 30% to 32% of indian GDP (nearly 10 times more than FDI),there is no level playing ground between domestic investor and FDI, the scales were completely tipped in favour of FDI
Further more as per World Bank there is broad consensus among economist that FDI has very little impact on GDP growth of large economies, you can find 100's of research paper on this, as per them FDI can has good impact for small economies like singapore or hongkong that too for limited period only and in specific area..
Now coming to your numbers on FDI Numbers are statics can be sliced and expressed in as many was as possible like below
Total FDI from 1947 till recent 2023 (900 months considering 75 years) $ 950 billion in ,
FID received in last 90 months $ 532 billion i.e 56% in last 10% of period
the above $532 billion is received from 160 countries covering 61 sectors and in 32 states & union territories all gobal records
and starting 2014 for eight consecutive years the FDI has been record highest each year. In the mean time our GDP started growing better and hence the percentage wise it will be showing as lower. If you want to blame the govt for lower FDI in six months without mentioning the record peformance of the same modi govt from 2015 onwards.
hmm. right.
The ease of doing business in india is still not easy, the long process of approval and the countless prosedures and delays put off investors.
Countries like china, singapore, vietnam , indonesia move faster and provide favorable terms and conditions for investors.
It is state by state problem. In Gujarat, the process is quite streamlined and super easy. Other states have a huge bureaucracy. Except Gujarat, all other states are laggard in terms of doing business.
Humko FDI se matlab nhi, we are already superpower. Gurudakshina do baas, viswaguru h hum.
Naukri wagera nhi chahye, na chahye food security. Humko toh baas Pakistanio jesa truck ke headlight k picche laga dete h aur hum usi k picche bhagte rehte h.
Abe gandu.... economics smaaj ta hain....fdi is just a part of gdp.....our gdp is driven by capex...what's the problem....avg TMC chamcha
India changed laws anytime, frighten the investors.
The problem with the current government is that it is driven by the bureaucracy. Barring about half a dozen ministers, all depend on bureaucrats, who are steeped in the protectionist era. Just look at the way GST is administered and the ministry of commerce functions.
Investors are looked at with suspicion and even distrust.
Still improved infrastructure attracted manufacturing fdi
Beurocracy is backbone of india ...I am aware that it's not perfect but without that india would be less developed definitely ..12 th fail ministers can't do anything
While the bureaucracy part may be true, that cannot be the reason for this particular decline. You can see that the FDI numbers were very high till 2 years ago. Did beauraucracy suddenly become worse in just the last 2 years?
Nothing wrong with that, bureaucrats are the more educated and hard working individuals than old politicians in our country. They know better about economic stuff and all, and are also young. This decline is only for just a year or two, again it will go up.
Very insightful analysis. Thank you! Keep up the good work 👍
Actually it is not. They are no longer a journalist medium, they are like Al Jazeera who are getting funds for generating particular agendas. They (Print)are asking funds from us online, but actually they are getting funds from outside. Without external support or provided agenda from their upper house they don't know what to represent. They are specifically targeting one FDI period as outcome. Then what about others stats shown which showed FDI at all time high consecutively. And most importantly this is election time. So I hope u understand what I am trying to say
I don't get your logic that FTA with Aus, EU and UK, leads to investment happening there instead of India.
But these countries have a labour shortage. They end up hiring Indians to immigrate there instead. So, ultimately Indians get jobs.
But that money needs to be brought to India, than staying in foreign bank accounts.
Thats what India should focus on.
Encourage NRIs to buy Indian govt bonds. Make NRE account easily repatriable i.e. you should be able to spend that money easily abroad as well. That will encourage people to use NRE account more, and then spend the money in India. Allow foreign credit cards to be used for online transactions in India. RBI has put so much restrictions.
Don't forget there are many many Indians living in Muslim countries while singing hymns to Modi😁.
As far as FDI's share in GDP is concerned, could it be possible that its because of the rising share of Govt. Capex in GDP ?
That actually makes sense
THAT MAKES ABSOLUTELY NO SENSE. GOVERNMENT CAPEX DOESN'T INHIBIT FDI, LACK OF BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT DOES. THE HUMUNGOUS HUNGER OF INVESTMENT A LARGE POPULATION LIKE INDIA HAS, CAN NEVER BE SATIATED BY GOVERNMENT CAPEX.
Good factual reporting. Won't get this information on our Main Stream Media.
A robust and growing economy without FDI a good or bad sign ?
Robust growth of economy is due to government spending in infrastructure (roads and others), but this is by loans and aids mainly from Japan and loans from other institutions AIIB etc. Few years back Sri Lanka was spending much on infrastructure and later it crumpled.
@@manut1349Indian economy toll returns easily gonna cover those loans its not small country with low population like Sri Lanka use ur half gram brain bro at least compare with proper country ! 🤡 !
@@manut1349 Srilanka was not just about public spending. Look at some videos to understand the bogus work by govt, for example, freebies and tax concessions.
Good sign and bad sign both.
@@manut1349 the economic crisis in sri lanka was mainly due to the freebies, excessive subsidies and organic farming.
One reason companies moving from china are going to different countries is that they don't want to put all their eggs is the same basket again, like they did with china.
What is the total FDI amount in last 10 years and previous 10 years and how many are beneficiaries in each case
Ask Modi to conduct a press conference on it😁.
From 2004 to 2014, gross FDI was $267 billion and from 2014 to 2022, the gross FDI was $596 billion.
Any insight into why were bits terminated without alternative measures being put into place?
During Congress Rule, Indian wealth was routed out and then routed in as FDI for black to White Conversion... there was no real investment in any sector
how ? Can you explain me by showing some facts and datas (if you have). I really want to know. 🤔🤔.
5:31 seconds, please show correct map of India. As Indian we have to very careful to present correct map of India. I hope so your team will recognise this mistake. Jai hind
WHAT CAN YOU EXPECT FROMPRINT
After all it is only a map, we can even show Pakistan as part of India😁.
lol that’s the reality. POK is not part of India. As an Indian, I advice you should stop living in your fantasy world. Perhaps start reading credible news for outlets like the economist, Financial Times, BBC, New York Times, the diplomat, and le monde while you are at it
IMHO simply looking at the FDI percentage decline does not tell the full story. The overall picture needs to be looked at with aditional details. What happnes when we become 5 T economy. Would we expect the same growth across all countries so that they could keep the FDI flow percentage same ? The abolishment of the retrospective tax laws (though forcefully ) introduced by sheer venegance by Pranav Mukherjee clearly says that the sense prevails.
“It’s hard to get anything done in India. And the bribes are just awful…The Indians I know are fabulous people. They’re just as talented as the Chinese, I’m speaking about the Indian populace. But the system and the poverty and the corruption, It mires India with problems" - Charlie Munger
And the movies they make, simply the crappiest, he should have added😁.
Good analysis, but would like to understand more data on each sector with regards to FDI.
Corporates will invest taking legal risks if the benefits are high. Indian domestic purchasing power is quite poor so only incentive remains export. Signing FTAs with developed countries with favourable terms ( not like ASEAN or korean FTA) is the best way forward.
16 years before it was 22 बिलियन US dollers. Last year it was 84. This year it is around 70. How it lowest in 16 years I fail to understand
Inflation, and he is talking about the "flow" not total
A large part of the reason for the decline is increase in Fed rates.
After accounting for hedging, FDI money becomes too costly for larger coporates (the ones that move the numbers)
Thank you. Occam's razor. Otherwise, we know this govt and PM has generally showed the resolve to woo investors.
Investment in a unlisted firm is classified as fdi, even if done for capital gain. As indian firms are rapidly getting listed so the capitsl inflow is categorised as fpi( below 10% share] . So a more comprehensive analysis would be to categorise fdi as green field and brown field and then compare.
Further after scrapping of EoDB, NITi ayog should come up with a comprehensive eodb ranking of all states in collaboration with academic institutes and industry bodies.
Very good point! Also, see my comment regarding how USD reserve to GDP ratio is 2 % points higher under Modi than it was ever under UPA.
And now again some bhakts will bark that print is anti-national whereas few days ago, they reported positive news, when the reaction was like, "too late".
Because we are developed nation now. We don't need fdi we all are rich like our ministers
Net FDI during Mody years is showing much higher than UPA time , that I saw in your data, l am confused
1 rupee in 2013 and 1 rupee now, there's difference in value, you have to consider inflation
Thanks The print for negative news about india.....you people are work hard to demean india's image at any cost....Hats off to your dedication
A very good report. Thank you
Good attempt. Additional research may be required on this. The current Government is leaving no rock unturned in trying to attract investments. The perception about India is definitely changing. Does the US or UK also have to have the third country arbitration requirement?
Ya we really need serious Judicial reforms. Most investors are looking at our court system and they are keeping away.
Is that why share of FDI as a percentage of GDP is decreasing?? Is that why India's share in global FDI decreasing?? Perception is changing only in the GODI MEDIA, not among foreign investors.
@Amitkumaralphax: Media and editors will always have their biases and leanings. Looking beyond, I try listening to business and investment managers. One person who's quite incisive is Ray Dalio, investment officer of one of the world's largest hedge funds.
They are trying, but UPA actually attracted FDI as per this video😁.
@@HeartistMurali OF COURSE UPA GOVERNMENT DID ATTRACT HUGE FDI. THAT'S WHY THE AVERAGE GDP GROWTH RATE OF 10 YEARS OF MANMOHAN GOVERNMENT WAS 8% & THAT OF THE 10 YEARS OF MODI IS JUST 5.5%.
Isn't it a good sign that GDP is growing @7+% even with less FDI. In last 3 months stock market has also done fairly well. You have to give credit to Make in India policy which is working well. If free trade agreement signed then Indian companies will also have access to foreign countries. It is good for our economy right?? Bottom line is FDI is not the only measurement how our economy is doing.
Our economy will do good as long as Modi says so 😁.
what exactly is this make-in-India policy?
manufacturing sector's share has decreased in the Indian economy both by productivity and labour involvement instead labour force is now moving towards agriculture.
what exactly were India's exports in manufacturing after this 'Make in India".
@@ashwinvk4124 Not in distance past there was a single toy in the market which was not made in China. Every electronics product from TV to mobile was made in China. Now we have started to see made in India products in these sectors. Even Iphones are now made in India. Yes we are still importing chips and few other components but at lase we have made some progress. We are now reducing dependencies on China for Active ingredients required to produce medicine. In defense sector also we are producing lot of things and trying hard to build our own jet engine. We have started exporting missile and other equipment to many countries. Only a cynical person will not see the make in India progress.
@@ashwinvk4124$470 billion of merchandise exports.
@@ag564 First of all we do not have the supply chain in place for most of the manufacturing industries neither do we have the amount of skilled labour or funding for R&D .
Things like make in India is just a tag line not a policy.
I don't know how far will we go in terms of manufacturing but anyways time will tell .
Right now there are two wars and many companies are refraining from investment, add to that the fact that there are elections. There are multitudes of reasons one being governments policy too, overall even if they were optimal things wouldn't have been different from big margins. Secondly the FDI from tax havens have decreased ( from what I know ), we should focus on how much FDI was flowing through them. A bit disappointing how this is not nuanced.
Why there is a 2024 value on the graph when 24-25 fiscal year hasn't even started yet? Also, per my knowledge, FY 23-24 will end on March 31, 2024.
When a FY is named using only one of the two calendar years across which it spans it is always the calendar year in which the FY ends, not starts. So FY24 starts from 1 April 2023 and ends on 31 March 2024. Three quarters of FY24 have already passed.
Make in india is just protectionism renamed
What is FDI?
😅😅😅
Ok I googled it...
Great clip
Good 👍👍 stuff
Explained clearly and succinctly.
Thanks 👍👍
Most informative video from print in a long time
I support the current government and will still do but companies should not feel unwelcomed or feared of regime change one time investment are not all they should reinvenst back in our loving nation of india.policy should be rectified and we need alot of effiiciency in courts mechanism so companies can resolve their disputes faster.they dont need to get struck for longer time.alot improvement in are required but yes this govt can do i believe they should look in to this matter.
Yes...companies prefer political stability....after 2024 general election....we may see a rise in fdi.
@@dibakarsaha6807th-cam.com/video/y_cHL34LCwo/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Kr06PLUB9O1QRU0c
Modi thinks that only making roads and highways is everything. Only making roads and highways is just a small drop in the development of the nation. Major development happens when the country gets FDI . MMS was successful in bringing FDI but Modi failed. All major MNC companies and IT parks we see today are all the result of FDI by MMS. Modi has destroyed all the small and medium scale industries and only filled the pockets of rich industrialists to extend of selling the nation now.
@@dibakarsaha6807bullshit they will invest in India 😂
Good point
Will FDI continue to increase infinately ---- If the local levels do not support FDI future prospects and local investments & competition can overtake FDI then why would FDI come in ???
excellent analysis
👍 thank you
why is India's current dollar reserves to gdp percentage quite higher than that during UPA I and II? Something, doesn't add up. How come India's dollar reserve keeps increasing faster than its GDP under Modi despite lower FDI inflows compared to that during UPA term. Print team needs to explain that. You can go to World bank data and verify that under UPA in 2014, the USD reserve to GDP ratio was 14.9%, whereas currently it is 17.6%. Someone, needs to seriously explain this paradox.
yes you are right. Actually the gdp growth rate was more under UPA era than NDA era but that also driven by high inflation which was not the actual growth of economy. According to my opnion.
UPA era:
2004- $709 billion
2014-$2.03 trillion
Average gdp growth rate: 6.8%
Inflation: 8.1%
It was mainly driven by inflation which is not real economic development.
but from 2014-2024 the gdp growth rate averaged between 5.5-6.0% (Including COVID-19)
2014- $2.03 trillion.
2024- $4.1 trillion*.
Average gdp growth rate: 5.5%
Average inflation: 5.1% which is relatively stable and shows the actual development.
@SumanaGhosh-nc8js i am afraid you are wrong. The gdp number is the real gdp not the nominal gdp. The gdp numbers have already factored the inflation.
7:34 very disappointed u didnt point out that i gave our own companies market in those countries without us having to invest there we want to sell low cost goods and USA UK EU are big markets for low cost goods free trade is benifical for all
BJP bhakt where are you now. Aren't you going to bash him
Basically, investors are vary of our Judiciary rather than the govt. Reform the judiciary attract more FDI.
BTW NCLT and NCLAT have been back to their old habit of tareeq pe tareeq.
FED increased rates by 500basis points-
Not one look at FPI and market capitalization equity flow. You do realise where the unicorns get their funding from right?...and why that is? Trust has grown in Indian corporates to handle the legal side of things with the govt. God this guy just reads off a script, no wonder the lady is far far smarter and he has to take backseat when she is here lol.
Taxes, corruption, politics at local level, permissions, complicated laws state level & central level, law & order, high electricity costs, high freight costs.
Thats bcz the entire cabinet of ministers is busy temple hopping.
You mean to say that Modi is a stupid?
How sad
Well said...i hope if you would have have mentioned about cronyism that would have been the real reason for India's free market capitalism is completely flawed and not trustworthy.
Could it be the corruption index is higher.. And it's co related…
References of these analysts?
Why india cannot match south korea and Vietnam in attracting fdi inflows.
Ache din aagaye😢
Abe gandu fdi se gdp main farq nahi parta
....GDP growth sahi hain... tere revdi chacha se bhi
UPA drink West's piiiii
Now we drink cow piiii
Cow piii better than West's
We don't care about economy because Hindus working hard but that result eating by hum dho humko bara wala 2/12
Sir, we are Vishwaguru. We do not need FDI, only Guru Dakshina 🙏
🤣
😂😂😂
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Government is busy calculating fake gdp numbers and projections😅
Wtf....avg pappu bhakt with knowledge of economics...capex expenditure to tere pappu govt bhul hi gayi thi
How the gdp numbers are fake ? Can you explain me.
I started watching in a hope that there will be real economic factors but here everything seems to be anti Modi government. Valuations & growth attracts FIIs. Anyways, I think he is talking from Stock market perspective only and not overall.
🟥The REALreason for the decline is this: As wars spread, more western companies get scared of "global-uncertainities". Appetite for investments in Emerging economies decreases. That combined with the fact that most companies have been investing heavily in India in recent years, (till 2021) makes them want to pause a bit.
Yeah. Modi is planning a press conference on it😁.
@@HeartistMurali Some people cant get over their pro-Modi or anti-Modi sentiment.😊 They view everything from a Modi-centric lens : Economy, black-holes, Monalisa, subatomic-particles, chemical-reactions .... everything. 🤪
@@a0756536 Yeah. I forgot. Domi was exclusively elected to cause riots and roam around for inaugurations. He got nothing to do with FDI😁.
What is this Video??The host is speaking as if FTAs with UK,US and EU have already been signed 😂😂He is simply saying whatever he wants,even thou FDI as a % of GDP declined,The Total FDI Flowing into India was appx $ 450+ Billion USD in last 9 years, Didn't they know about BITs,EODB etc 😂😂
$550 billion +
Fdi% to gdp - base in UPA was around ~$1.7T to $1.9T and now it is ~$3.8T to $4T. Bad analysis. FDI in absolute amount increased YoY with few exceptions. Economy is not good in western countries. Forget about investing in India, they're not investing in their own country for now. Not discrediting UPA also.
We need only ram temple no need fdi , we are happy to have temple even if petrol reaches 1000 rupees, we will put wet cloth on our stomach but we want only ram temple
Not clearly mentioned the subject.only he is blaming
Why 2024 is on the graph?
Log potti kha lenge lekin button toh Kamal ka dabaenge
Lagta Hai apane bohot kha liya hai potty, isilye content samaj nehi aya
@@ssb9054yeh bhi kauwa, सियाना कौआ सुबह सुबह गू खाता 😂😂
Abe gandu...GDP growth ka part hain fdi dono farq dekh.....tere revdi bechne walo se to acha hain....pappu bhakt sala economics ki samaj nahi
With just 2 graphs trying to explain India FDI inflows is just shoddy work. Neither there is data on different states and sectors.
Ek ED raid to banti hai 😅
Map of India shown wrong at 3:56. The border betn Afghanistan and India does not exist in shown map, this kind of sensitive topic needs to be adress. As Indian media portal must be show correct map of India.
PRINT IS NOT EXACTLY INDAIN MEDIA
Problem hai isko manenge tab to uspe sochenge aur solve krenge..... Yahaan to govt sab bhut jyaada accha ho rha hai k ghamand mein chal rhi hai...
Abe gadhe fdi sirf gdp ka share hain.....zyada tar fdi jo mauritius cyprus se aata hain woh tax havens hain....foreign money nahi
2 main reasons i think, Strong Dollar, Election year of our country..World is watching cautiously..
Why do u think 😂😂😂😂
Good analysis…. But all what happens in the world is relative…. Having said that…. Do we want unbriddled inflow of bad foreign money… also look at domestic investments…. Have they improved… just asking
Additionally, the quality of FDI also matters. Any FDI that takes out more than it gives to the Indian economy is useless.
Hail Chairman Mo 👏 ✋️
Covid also
Fdi s are made using leveraged positions against bonds. W rates rising, the leverages are themselves ve become smaller. Add to the fact that US banks face massive collapses in 24. On top of that sebi guidelines are targeting mkt manupulation. And why would gov give bta s? Remember Bhopal?
galat information kyo de rhe ho, FDI is at highest level
3:50 pls use correct map look at pakistans pan handel to the north we dont expect such things from a trust worthy news source as Print
Shame on bjp
xiaomi vivo love it very much
Andhbhakt fir bhi Modi ko vote denge
Aur chatukar Bas Rahul ki chatenge . 😂
I may not be knowing guy with a collar up and down must know more, my thoughts: All FDI are waiting for 2024 election, And if BJP wins see the inflow of money, there was a small glimpse from last 3 state election win.
So what the nse is highest that is people are investing and IPO are oversubscribed.
Can you explain at this point where India is becoming self sufficient why FDI required.
Example 52% of FI investment and share buthered from 1750 to 1350....
Baised data....
No sectoral analysis? Maybe the IT sector has been disproportionately hit.
And No examination of round tripped money from Mauritius (PC's infamous P notes!).
What a poor analysis.
Your FDI inflow for FY 2023-24 is incomplete & not true
They need us more than we need them. Where else will they go to invest?
General FDI, all over world FDI is down because of recessions or slow down of all the major economies.
IN FACT we received better portion of total fdi...
The great Modi effect : capital flight!
Who are these economist providing these faltu info.
Print is toeing the US line.
This is because our markets are pricey is what global investors say
Low level Corruption is of State Matters,How Modi Govt has control over massive Power sector Corruption in Tamilnadu
sent a junior guy to do the video? keeps repeating the same points about ease of doing business and bilateral treaties and does not cite any analyst or economist? also, very cleverly the graphs dont have legends - one graph shows the absolute amount in FDI is growing y-o-y but all he is focusing on gross and net % of GDP - the current GDP is more than what it was 20 years ago! Not an unbiased reporting - the data is not discussed holistically!
What's wrong with you? OF COURSE CURRENT GDP IS GREATER TODAY THAN 20 YEARS AGO. GDP is supposed to grow. Percentages of current gdp IS the correct metric. That is how you assess what is happening in the here and now. Common sense my guy. The nonsense you just spouted is like me saying "Female labour force participation in India is happening perfectly because its better than 20 years ago. How dare I compare it as a percentage of population today! How can anyone say there was a drop in FLFPR after covid? Sex ratio? Whats that? Throw it out the window!" This is your logic. Boss, more people are employed in India than during independence cuz the population is 4 times bigger. Doesn't mean unemployment has disappeared.
@@person1858 dude you need to chill! read my comment once more - i clearly mentioned NOT ALL data was fairly presented and discussed. I understand how the %s work, but this guy didnt discuss all data accurately. Also, you think it is ok for a journalist to just repeat "many analysts and economists" without citing any reference or data? Also, money is coming from outside India in other ways as well - not just FDI - alternatively, if his argument is to be believed, then DESPITE historically low FDI, India is still growing, so the Governments policy of self-reliance (there are pros and cons) is actually working because we still have growth!! There is also an argument that low FDI means less money coming from offshore shell companies/tax-haven countries! I am all for course correction - but when you are trying to show an analysis, dont embarrass yourself! have all details ready and read up properly.
One of the reasons for supporting bjp government is that they will do better in economy but seems like they are failing and we may lose the opportunity created by current geopolitics where companies are moving out of china
They are going to other countries like vietnam indonesia mexico etc
They need to fire this guy for his amateur and quite literally an uneducated analysis.
First, what was the GDP of India for each of these years? FDI cannot keep up with this, unless it turns into the manufacturing destination of the world. India’s economy is different from China and as such investment buildup for a services based economy is slower due to limited need for capex investments.
Also, what about the effect of COVID and BITS? Which have been the two of the biggest contributors to this effect.
This is election season and as always, for the shameless human that Shekhar Gupta is, has to get his woke commi news anchors to peddle news to appease his Congress masters. The Print is just that, another mouthpiece of Congress. What a shame…
In UPA rule it was max in 2009 at 41. In NDA rule it was 84 last year. I do not understand your theory of lowest in 16 years. Do not spread lies.