KTM 1290 Super Adventure or BMW R 1250 GS?

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 พ.ย. 2024

ความคิดเห็น •

  • @barney3417
    @barney3417 ปีที่แล้ว +25

    I had 4 GS's before 2017 and decided to got the KTM way and bought the 1290 ADV , fantastic to ride!! 18 months, new switch gear, new rear shock, new indicators, Red engine warning light . it went . GONE back to a GS !!

    • @Scootir185
      @Scootir185 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Yup - mine was fun but a piece of crap too.

    • @paulwelsh7834
      @paulwelsh7834 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      With KTM building the new 790 at CF Moto in China it begs the question of what other components in the rest of their line up are made in China. I really struggle with the capital outlay vs quality and reliability topic. If we are spending our hard earned cash on these machines they need to deliver on a number of balanced fronts in my opinion. I really really want to try a KTM but just don’t want to spend $20K of my own money on the experiment.

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      Oh, that's quite an experience. It's sad to hear because even my first thought is now "I'm not surprised".

    • @davidkendall1614
      @davidkendall1614 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      There should be a KTM support group

    • @DieTabbi
      @DieTabbi ปีที่แล้ว

      I had the KTM 990R, a truely beast of bike. Loved it. Not many girls rode it. after lot of trouble gone to BMW dealer, trade in my KTM come out with R1200GS Rally Pepsi. Oh girl what differnt so easy to ride.

  • @Scootir185
    @Scootir185 ปีที่แล้ว +32

    Had the KTM and now have the BMW. Loved the KTM engine and great off road but just like with my other KTM's reliability was a big issue and soured me on the bike. A fragile adventure bike doesn't inspire confidence. The BMW isn't as exciting on the highway but it's far more comfortable and has been bulletproof reliable with amazing low speed performance. Overall the GS is just the better bike.

    • @GrandSolarEclipse
      @GrandSolarEclipse ปีที่แล้ว

      Did you mean low gear performance?

    • @Scootir185
      @Scootir185 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@GrandSolarEclipse Low gear/low speed performance yes. It's remarkable smooth and balanced at slow speeds which is awesome off-road and in congested traffic.

    • @stephengreen9053
      @stephengreen9053 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      My gs has 91k on it and I still ride it everyday. Amazing bike

    • @stellaracrobat
      @stellaracrobat ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I had a KTM for 6 mths - more time at the dealer than on the road, not ready for anything, sold it. Great bike when it is going but otherwise not. I also have a 1250GSA always can be counted on.

    • @HendersonRednecks
      @HendersonRednecks 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      What failures did your KTM have?

  • @valefur72
    @valefur72 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I have had many motorbikes, and 4 BMW among them. I have had also 2 KTM. Living on the Dolomites mountains the two KTM gave me the best amusement, so my next bike will be the KTM, used, for shure.

  • @vapidsmiter9485
    @vapidsmiter9485 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    The pricing of the bikes is different in the US. MSRP is about 5k difference with the KTM being cheaper. I've ridden both and I prefer the KTM1290 S hands down over the BMW. I've owned both. BMWs are EXPENSIVE to have serviced. The tools are custom and expensive if you want to do the service yourself. I service myself or have my KTM serviced, depending if I have the time. Servicing the KTM doesn't break the bank. I do experience the shake if I let the handlebars go. I just don't let go of the handlebars. I move through stopped traffic effortlessly, but my hats off to your mad traffic filtering skills.
    I rode this KTM from Mexico to Canada and then back with no issues. I've not had any issues that originate with the bike's manufacture.

  • @motosurus
    @motosurus ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I had 35000 km on a 2019 model r1250gs with battery problem that i had to deal with a wrecker and had to carry jump starter until i found the problem .. corrosion on suspension springs even stored in a closed garage and some other minor issues so that it is also not perfect but I am sure that more reliable and bmw will better deal with the problems .. just traded with 2023 model 1290sas and no signal button issues no error messages due to the suspension preload etc. Overall it is really a fun bike .. far beyond than gs in terms of fun factor another world... it is stable enough until 230 with oem tires and top case. Better at cornering every speed (i am not just countersteering guy love to use body positioning), lower weight feel, a real quick shifter and smooth transmission, corner exists way way perfect, better wind protection for the head too less wind buffeting agains normal and adventure windshield of gs, slightly better heat management, better suspension for sport riding, longer distance by bigger fuel tank but with the same consumption only the downsides are worse breaks, more vibrations, stone seat :) so that less comfort and service .. for the people who loves to fun on a bike should definetely check 1290sas esp 2023 model which is less viby more stable and with no issues. Cheers

  • @benkelly2190
    @benkelly2190 ปีที่แล้ว +12

    Had 7 GS’s over the years. Great bike got bored, needed a change, tested em, all. Tiger 12/900. Ducati multi 4/950. Honda AT.. Then the KTM 1290 SAS, head and shoulders above the rest! on my second. I ride all year round and put big miles, on em! No issues and it is brilliant. Fuck the doubters…

    • @davidkendall1614
      @davidkendall1614 ปีที่แล้ว

      Lots and lots of “doubters” who are…or WERE…KTM owners. Not like it’s hearsay when they bring the bike back. 890s and 1290s.

    • @benkelly2190
      @benkelly2190 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I agree but there are a lot band waggon jumpers. So I’m happy, as discussed. Enjoy your bike and let’s leave others to enjoy there’s.

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Thanks for sharing the good review. I appreciate it especially since you mention that you actually tried some of the other motorcycles too. That helps to give a broader perspective.

  • @Konstantin8006
    @Konstantin8006 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +13

    If you're a dentist that learned how to ride, buy a BMW.
    If your a hard core experienced rider, buy the KTM.

    • @motorobsession3073
      @motorobsession3073 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Absolutely agree! I had bmw gs 1250 2023, gs 1300 and now ktm sas 2024 applied 1 week ago. ktm simply the best for me, incredible engine, perfect suspension, excellent comfort and very low consumption.

  • @Macedonia270
    @Macedonia270 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I own a GS 1200 Adventure and a KTM 1190 Adventure R. Bothe have the full Akrapovic systems fitted. I love both bikes and I must say, I prefer the GS exhaust tone to the KTM, the KTM only really sounds good at high revs.
    Both are great bikes but the GS is far superior in ease of use, comfort, handling and long-distance touring.

  • @TheNandis67
    @TheNandis67 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Hi V-Told. Thanks for you video and your opinion.
    After having owned a KTM 990 adv during 12 years and many good and long trips in all conditions, last year, I bought a 1290 SAR. I like it a lot. I am 1,91 m so the riding position is perfect, better than the 990. I have done a couple of long trips with it and it was great, very comfortable, insanely fast when you want, funny, very polyvalent in all different situations, on the road, twisties, mountain roads, secondary roads, main roads and highway, in all great control. Out of the road, it is really very capable for such a big bike. I love the suspension, if you know how to deal with the settings, in some minutes, you can adapt it perfectly, just a couple of turns here and there, and ready to go. It is not so automatic as the GS or the SAS, that you can do it in the fly, but once you know how to do it, the quality of the suspension is very good.
    I never had a GS, I have ridden it a couple of times. It is very good machine, and good looking. For a KTM rider, you need to get used to it, but it comes quickly.
    I think the good thing of it is that whatever the bike you buy, it is difficult to make a mistake, due to the fact that all of them are very capable machines.
    The only thing I prefer from the KTM is that you don´t see many, especially the R version, and I like that, while you see many GS’s and it is just another GS, you don’t even take a look at them any more…. Greetings and good riding

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Hi, thanks for sharing your view - I appreciate it and also believe that that last point about KTM SARs not being so popular on the roads may make them appeal to some. Myself included in fact. But there are quite a few quality features on top of that, and some that are very strong - also literally - like the amazing engine. If I had both BMW R1250GS and SAR, I would be tempted to choose a GS but likely would end up on a KTM every time. The sound, position, ease of shooting forward and uniqueness make it super exciting.

  • @korshm
    @korshm ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I'm currently an owner of 1290SAS and had S1000XR before. I think SAS version is much closer to XR with higher suspension travel. At the same time I had more than a week travel with R1250GS, so I can compare. XR and SAS's riding gives much more fun on the roads compare to GS. I disagree with V-Told about SAS engine - when you just ride, not pushing anything to its limits, your usable RMP range is relatively narrow - from 2500-3000 to 5000-5500 rpm. Above 6000rpm vibrations are not comfy. At 180 km/h speeds it feels buzzy as XR. I drive SAS in a city with heavy traffic (look vids in my account) and it feels inline with XR. I don't like big GS cilynders in filtering. I'm short (170cm) and SAS with adjustable seat height (2 positions of the seat + automatically adjustable preload) makes this version perfect to me.

    • @Superadventurespms
      @Superadventurespms ปีที่แล้ว

      I have 1290 and just back from a 3000 mile trip, 2 up and fully loaded. Through 6 countries and no issues at all. Obviously not as comfortable as the GS but depends what you compromise. My previous bike was an explorer 1200 and was comfortable but way too heavy at low speeds. 1290 one of the best bikes I've had.

  • @julianmorris9951
    @julianmorris9951 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    They’re two totally different bikes, just put my 1290 in for a gs12 adventure, it struck me as to how different these bikes are and why people compare the two, the ktm is a more exciting ride for sure, the gs does touring better in my opinion, the gs feels super stable on fast roads and motorways, the ktm territory is fast twisty roads!!! they both do what they do very well, now I’ve ridden both bikes at length I would say I’ll swap back and fourth between them, these two bikes are in a class of their own.

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      Thanks a lot for sharing - that's very useful since you've experienced both too.

  • @julianmorris9951
    @julianmorris9951 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    If only Suzuki would make something like the 1290 but reliable 🤔🤔🤔🤔

  • @hienhuynhhuy3365
    @hienhuynhhuy3365 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Thank you for the real sharing, not for receiving money to advertise. I subscribed to the channel to follow you

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      My pleasure and yes, this is what it's all about here. Cheers!

  • @katsiox
    @katsiox ปีที่แล้ว +1

    My 2021 SAS just “died” on a road. ECU fuse was blown up. Replaced it, and same happened within next 100 meters. Now waiting for appointment at a dealer shop. Warranty just ended 4 months ago.

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      I'm sorry to hear that and let's hope it gets fixed as quickly and cheaply as possible.

    • @katsiox
      @katsiox ปีที่แล้ว

      @@VToldsMotoShow fingers crossed :)

    • @katsiox
      @katsiox ปีที่แล้ว

      @@VToldsMotoShow 250EUR, some self-damaged wiring loop in most unconvenient place of a bike... New model baby issues... I guess :)

  • @RandomGRK
    @RandomGRK 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Any idea which bike runs warmer? Which one makes your legs/feet sweat more during the summer?

  • @stephengreen9053
    @stephengreen9053 ปีที่แล้ว

    I had a 1290 adventure r, loved the bike.. I currently own a r1200 gsa.
    I agree with 99.9% of your review.
    My choice to choose the gs is complete package. I had no remorse selling my 1290, no way id sell my gs.
    In a year I have done 2 different 700 mile day trips on my gs and felt as good as one could after 700+ miles. I couldn’t make it 200 miles on my 1290 with out a nap and a half of a bottle of advil. They both are amazing bikes but its the GSA for me………

  • @davidkendall1614
    @davidkendall1614 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Good summary! Was going to buy a KTM SA 1290R. But then I rode the GS (identical to the one here btw) and had a better experience with the BMW dealer. Then I started reading and viewing videos about KTM horror stories. And a very much liked the BMW on the road vs the KTM, despite the rockin’ motor of the latter. I also rode Ducati MS V4S and Desert X (no dealer nearby), Triumph Tiger 900 and 1200 (no dealer nearby), Honda Africa Twin, and Kawasaki Versys (more streetbike aligned to the BMW XR). The GS cannot be defined by its spec sheet. Riding it long term is the only way to truly appreciate the capabilities that one bike has no right to possess on road and off. Used KTMs seem to sell for a song, whereas GS seems to hold its value better. BMW is more refined and better put together. Check out KTM switch gear as an example, leaking brake master cylinders, shoddy bearings, unreliable electronics and things falling off KTMs.

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      At first I thought that you were willing to switch from buying a KTM to BMW because of a dealer experience. Now I assume that it wasn't the only reason. Dealings with a dealer is still a marginal concern I believe. The rest - I see your points but GS can impress after the 1st meter ridden I think. It's such a different experience in terms of how it moves around, incredible. Then BMW is a huge manufacturer with a lot of background in the industry whereas KTM may at the same time have much more limited resources and hence the build quality. Which pains me to say. But when they work - and you may always happen to get a perfectly built one - their engines make them fly.

    • @hazarddavid6987
      @hazarddavid6987 ปีที่แล้ว

      Can't put 20k and feel like i m rolling a dice...no way bro.
      Also if KTM is having fewer resources than BMW, they shouldn't be charging the consumers as high...

    • @doctorstrangelove8587
      @doctorstrangelove8587 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      So how is versys holding up in your raking? Cause i m looking only a street touring not adv

    • @davidkendall1614
      @davidkendall1614 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@doctorstrangelove8587 I had a Kawasaki Concours14 (GTR1400 in Europe) and a Z750S prior to that, so I am partial to Kawasaki inline fours. Loved them both, and totally trouble free. The Versys 1000 was very nice on the street. Good power, very smooth, good performance, good value. Very much UJM (universal Japanese motorcycle). Viceless, reliable, everyday bike. I liked riding it. Didn’t so much like looking at it. For that reason, in the Kawasaki stable I would maybe opt for the Ninja 1000SX sport tourer with the hard panniers. Very similar mechanically, but still with upright ergonomics. Other Japanese options might be the Suzuki GSX-S1000GX for pure street, or V-Strom 800 or 1050 from street with light adventure capability. Yamaha Tracer 9 GT. And then there are the European bikes…

    • @doctorstrangelove8587
      @doctorstrangelove8587 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@davidkendall1614 tnx men. More that i try to run from the bunch more i retrn to gs. In my country well equiped versys is around 20k. For that money i will take low miles used gs. And im waitng to see that new gx,love suzuki i used to own 2stroms in a past but i got the fiiling by looking new gx that it does not offer much comfort and i am i tall guy with the belly and bad beck in my middle age so that sx would not work for me. Maibie if i found some young girl 😂

  • @killjoss14
    @killjoss14 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    this is so easy...who sold the most ? why?

  • @JW-cq4ez
    @JW-cq4ez ปีที่แล้ว +1

    KTM is improving all the time the 2023 is for sure better and more reliable, and the value for money is good.

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว +2

      That's right at least considering big stuff like the indicators switch which is fine for 2023 in 1290. I've very glad that they listen and act.

    • @davidkendall1614
      @davidkendall1614 ปีที่แล้ว

      Hmm…see what you get when you try to sell a KTM SA. Residual values are lower. The things depreciate faster, which does not equate to value regardless of the initial cost of ownership.

  • @talalhantes
    @talalhantes ปีที่แล้ว +1

    you forgot talking about heat dissipation... BMW wins it by far... for most of us, this alone will make the difference...

  • @787APZ
    @787APZ ปีที่แล้ว +2

    You should also compare tiger 1200 explorer with these bikes

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      Yup, here is R 1250 GS vs Tiger 1200: th-cam.com/video/oBLbu_Amvjo/w-d-xo.html and KTM 1290 SA vs Tiger 1200 is a work in progress - likely for later this year.

  • @wowoped
    @wowoped 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

    What would you say: super duke or super adventure? Is it worth sacrificing the offroad for less weight?

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  6 หลายเดือนก่อน

      It’s two different segments and so the purpose and the whole idea is different. Unless you mean Super Duke GT that I personally would be interested in in comparison to the Super Adventure. I like them comfy so Super Adventure is generally my pick.

  • @michaelpayne-bailey8274
    @michaelpayne-bailey8274 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I just love the BMW GSA and the colour option are great. Disappointed you have not mention service cost or warranty as this is a huge cost to owning a motorcycle. BMW offer Cap price service for up to 100,000 km or 10 years and they offer 5 year warranty.

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      Costs vary depending on a market and specific dealers, so it would not be reliable information anyway. Best to check with your nearest dealers.

  • @kohinoore
    @kohinoore ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Kato should move their production lines outta the Mainland or at least inform customers about exact manufacturing location. Like some parts or tool brands do, for example - specifically indicating where it is made - china, india, taiwan, japan, slovenia, slovakia etc. The fact that KTM applies different standards to its bikes, doesn't require a proof anymore

  • @martyn_g
    @martyn_g 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Comfort, support and more included equipment? GSA all the way.

  • @AlastairT509
    @AlastairT509 ปีที่แล้ว

    Hard to disagree. Had a 2019 SAR, loved it but a little too tall and top heavy for me but very comfortable. Traded it for a new SAS in 2021. Easier to ride with lots of toys and tech - but purchase experience wasn’t great, optional extras took ages to arrive, lots of electronic teething issues (what error messages will I get today on start up and how many re-starts to clear them). Again dealer not amazing but struggling with staff turnover. When everything was working on a sunny day on the right road amazing - but quite tiring over long distance as it is so eager especially on back roads. Not as comfortable as the previous model R even with the comfort seats. Had the GS like the one in the video for a couple of days last summer. So, so easy to ride - and comfortable. Did everything very well indeed, felt classy - but TBH did lack excitement engine wise (but far from slow). However, just traded the KTM SAS in against a Desert X (depreciation absolutely horrendous!) which is obviously overpriced and from a “top trumps” perspective the lesser bike. The KTM just wants to go far too fast everywhere and I worry about the long term reliability (although great tech when it is all working). But most of all never induced a wow when I opened the garage door.

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      Thanks for sharing. I would see a potential for a "wow" effect after installing an aftermarket exhaust on a KTM. Design-wise it's very personal. However, DesertX may have a lot of that effect in turn. I just had my first rides on one today and it's a pretty competent midsize adventure motorcycle I feel.

    • @RJ-yn3nu
      @RJ-yn3nu ปีที่แล้ว

      I rode most big adventures and went with the 1250GS, but recently bought the Desert X for a contrast. The downside on the Ducati in Thailand it the heat..its HOT! I've had a KTM and had no problems. Thinking of trading the 1250 for the new 1300 in 2months when they come here. Would love the KTM for the engine... but worry about all the reliability comments.

    • @AlastairT509
      @AlastairT509 ปีที่แล้ว

      Happily heat won’t be a problem in the UK Midlands. Dealer called literally an hour ago to say my bike has finally arrived (in time for the winter). Had the option to change to a Desert X Rally. Really tempted as they look great but the seat is too high, the hardcore off road kit would be wasted on me and very expensive! 1300s look very tempting.

  • @inspectorclouseau3880
    @inspectorclouseau3880 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    I'd like to see a KTM with 50k miles on it let alone the 200k and more BMW bikes can do

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      It doesn't sound impossible I think.

    • @karl-josefmertens1472
      @karl-josefmertens1472 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I have a KTM with 62000 km without any trouble. I had a BMW 1200 GSA with much trouble in all the years!

    • @tubejorrit
      @tubejorrit ปีที่แล้ว +1

      go to the adv forum and you see a lot of 1190 and 1290 engines with over 80.000km without a problem. Have fun changing a clutch on a GS...

    • @jonathanme94
      @jonathanme94 ปีที่แล้ว

      My 1190 with 120k km in the odometter 0 problems, only 2 battery changes. My father's GSA 1250 with 10k and 1 year old has the drive shaft rusted, and never has been used out of the road...

  • @fabiocrescenzi4056
    @fabiocrescenzi4056 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Hi Vito! I watch all your videos and love it. First let me ask you, are you Italian ?
    My experience: I own and owned 4 GS so far and was going to by the KTM S version because I like everything of this bike, I like to go pretty fast and also I am cm 190 tall so I didn’t considering buying a Ducati Multistrada v4 because it’s small for me 😢. Unfortunately (or fortunately) I couldn’t buy the KTM because as soon as I did the test drive I observed a different general quality compare to my GS. Also approaching curves at high speed I felt the front suspension not very safely always compare with my GS. Of course I know that 3 hour of test ride isn’t enough for the right decision but nevertheless these two feelings made me change my mind 🤷🏼‍♂️😬😬. I have to wait for the new GS 1300 and spend once more much more money than KTM 🤷🏼‍♂️. Sorry for my English, I hope everything was clear. p.s. I drove the KTM in street mode, do you think I didn’t set up properly the bike ? Thanks 🙏

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Hi, I'm not Italian - if I were, that would be likely the first thing that I would mention in my videos. But then I'd have to ride a Ducati, so a slight disadvantage there ;)
      I get your experiences of the front end of the bike. GS with its Telelever front suspension is amazing there. KTM needs a very specific rider that would appreciate its different character.
      Street mode sounds totally fine and there's nothing that can be done wrong I think. GS simply will suit more riders. I feel it's generally a more pleasant thing to ride in any circumstances. Just that sound... ;)
      All the best!

  • @viclazo2839
    @viclazo2839 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    nice review, nice video quality - thanks! The comparison of motor bikes is not really a thankfull job, as it is so an individual topic.
    Taking into consideration BMW GS and KTM SAS, for me is KTM a much better, sportier adventure bike, much quicker and much more powerfull on twisty and straight roads, much more value for money, an engine which pulls and goes like hell up to 9.500 rpm. Not really relevant for me is low speed handling (in big cities!??), these are both not really urban city bikes. It could be relevant off road, but you have there SAR and GS Adventure to compare.
    Again something very individual: look at design of GS with these cilinder heads coming out "half a meter" left and right. It looks simply horrible, adding all this plastic edges, metal bars, grids above and below.... this looks like a never finished project. Appologize to the people who like this "design", but that´s really strange and not well designed.
    About suspension: GS is in deed a soft, comfortable chair, for sure much softer than a KTM SAS. But is there any road feedback you ever get from BMW GS?? I tried it already couple of times and it is always the same feeling - especially compared to KTM - there is zero feedback from the road. nothing, niente, nada...
    so I summarized, for people who like a soft chair bike with good traveling performance and like beeing disconnected from the road, they could be fine with GS.
    For people who like a sharp, sporty, very fast (adventure) bike for a lot of fun and active road feedback, they take KTM.
    All the best to all of you, what ever your choice is.

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      I actually personally like a soft chair very much. I wish KTM was softer suspension- and seat-wise. But that's right that judging a lot of things depends on one's taste and preference. So the key is to describe why you like certain things the way you do and then most can decide whether this is how they like them too or not. You know - to have common understanding in the first place. Thanks for the input! Cheers!

    • @viclazo2839
      @viclazo2839 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@VToldsMotoShow look, I came from a Kawa Ninja SX1000 and I never though I ever could like or need an adventure or travel-enduro bike. A lot of people recommended to try 1250GS, best bike ever - they said. I tried 2-3 times and one thing which is true, it is better, let say easier to steer for any kind of driver at very short curves, low speed easier to handle, may be at short distance curves, twisty roads.... But ☝️☝️☝️.... if you like to drive long, high speed curves and to compete from time to time with strong sporty bikes, to feel and be connected to the road, no way with a GS, sorry... but no way.
      I tried twice the KTM 1290 SAS within 2 weeks... and I simply ordered. That's a rocket, that's an emotion, that's simply power without end....
      About suspension: you set up COMFORT, and you can chat with your wife on back seat at 100 km/h, but you still feel the road ☝️

    • @davidkendall1614
      @davidkendall1614 ปีที่แล้ว

      KTM a “better value”? Not in my part of the world! When you look at resale values on KTM SAs here, the residual value is much lower. They sell very cheaply. Value is derived from total cost of ownership over the product’s life, not initial purchase cost.

    • @viclazo2839
      @viclazo2839 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@davidkendall1614 don't know where you live.... in Austria I paid for a nearby fully equiped KTM SAS, something below 24.000 Euros - 23.800 ito be exact, incl. a black Arrow Sonora...
      In comparison I'd pay here at least 4 to 5 k€ more for a 1250GS - hardly negotiated ☝️
      So, if once I get 4-5k less for the KTM, I'm absolutely fine... in my opinion for a better and allover more powerfull bike

    • @davidkendall1614
      @davidkendall1614 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@viclazo2839 👍 Good for you. Maybe Austria likes Austrian more 🤷‍♂️. In Canada you do not have to look very hard to find hugely depreciated large (1050 to 1290) KTMs of recent vintage and low km. Even new past model year unsold models sitting at dealers.

  • @christianmouraux7269
    @christianmouraux7269 ปีที่แล้ว

    Thank you for this super well done comparaison 👍 Regarding confort, my experience is that the 1290 SAR works much better for me. For some reason I had kind of back pain with my GS after long highway rides, and absolutely no pain with my 1290SAR. For all other categories, I share your scoring.

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      It got me thinking and I believe that it's possible due to GS's wide handlebar which some may need to bend forward more in order to reach as opposed to the position on a KTM with a narrower one. It seems like the most reasonable guess to me. But it may just as well be something totally else and a combination of factors.

  • @mahersoukieh6464
    @mahersoukieh6464 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I want your advice guys what big adv bike is good to buy in usa mitchigan .. bike that service and parts are available everywhere and easy to sell
    Is buying ktm super adventure s ok or bmw is better or maybe afrika twin

    • @gendarmecommando
      @gendarmecommando 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      All of them are nice models but it depends on your preference
      - BMW is comfort and reliability
      - KTM is speed and appearance
      - Africa Twin is durable and long-lasting spare parts are cheap. But in general, if you want economical and efficient, Africa Twin should be your choice.

  • @maldridge7630
    @maldridge7630 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    My weekly drug 😁

  • @darekz9777
    @darekz9777 ปีที่แล้ว

    Hi Vitold, what bike do you actually own?

  • @MrBlind0ne
    @MrBlind0ne ปีที่แล้ว

    What is the story behind the yellow H1 and its sometimes awkward position?

    • @kohinoore
      @kohinoore ปีที่แล้ว

      it's been taking part in reconnaissance operation in ukraine, parking differently every time upon return. There should be a blue one too, but it's said to be used as taxi on the other side ;)

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Oh dear, after @kohinoore's investigation of the matter, I should only agree and confirm. But at first awkward positions were somehow meant to reflect how good a given bike does. Now, in the comparisons it is irrelevant and well, generally at this point with never videos the position has nothing to do with the videos' content. I'm glad you asked, I may attempt to come up with some new positions for it.

  • @krzysztofszakiewicz40
    @krzysztofszakiewicz40 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    vitold, naprawdę, porównujesz dwa motocykle adventure w city? są lepsze do tego celu. porównaj je w wyprawie lub off-road.
    🤣🤣

  • @zied5663
    @zied5663 ปีที่แล้ว

    What is the country of the videos thx

  • @TheAwakenHD
    @TheAwakenHD ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Got a 890 adventure brand new so many issues

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      Both good and not good news. What was happening with it?

    • @TheAwakenHD
      @TheAwakenHD ปีที่แล้ว

      @@VToldsMotoShow electronical issue with the headlight , front frame came loose , high pitch whine occuring when exceeding certain speeds

  • @jerrylags
    @jerrylags ปีที่แล้ว

    Very nice review but I was a little amazed that you paid such scant attention to their off-road/unimproved-road capabilities. These are adventure bikes. There are dozens and dozens of road bikes. You obviously live in an urban environment so your slant is understandable but does limit your reviews usefulness. Maybe you should consider a ‘Part Two’.

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      I simply wouldn't take any of them to do any offroading. And getting through a gravel road, they all will manage it regardless of specs, so I wonder what to evaluate. I'm not taking the mid-size adventure bikes for brief rides off the road and all I can actually judge is suspension comfort, steering precision, if I can stand on the foot pegs and whether I can reach the ground. All that can be tested on the road. Maybe - just maybe - also how quickly they bottom out which may be a purely offroad-related thing. But nah, it wouldn't be something that I feel could be reliably judged by anyone as the areas of comparison might not be that clear. Not sure I myself am even expressing it clearly now just writing about it.

  • @jdub264
    @jdub264 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    For months I’ve been back & forth down the 1290 vs 1250 rabbit hole.
    KTM resale value is bad compared to BMW. I’m looking at a 2020 SAS w/2k miles for $12500, looking at same year GS, same miles for $18k.
    Best advice to give for shoppers is buy the KTM used, preferably with warranty remaining. Buy a BMW new or used and won’t be much of a difference.

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      Then I'm curious what your final decision will be.

    • @jdub264
      @jdub264 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@VToldsMotoShow Thanks for checking in. I’ve decided on a 1290.
      The one I mentioned sold before I could make up my mind, but about to say yes to a low mileage (2k) 2018 SAS with all the bells & whistles for $13,500.
      No warranty of course ☹️

  • @StuHNomadBiker
    @StuHNomadBiker ปีที่แล้ว

    On my 4th GS, 1250 now, i just cant fault them, theyre not slow, get a good rider on one and theres not much that will live with one on a twisty road, yes granted the KTM will have the legs on a straight. I rode my friends SAS and just didnt like if, seat was hard as a plank, bars felt narrow and body position felt slightly hunkered forward, engine vibration and could feel every stone on the road due to the stiffness of the package, you cant leave them in higher gears and try to use the torque as the Vtwin doesnt like that, GS just wafts along in total smoothness and grunt with plenty of comfort thrown in for good measure 🙌💯

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      Valid points, yet some of them matter in a certain style of riding and preference first of all. But yes, these seem fair and in favor of BMW. Maybe except for the engine vibration that I feel would be more of a BMW's boxer issue.

  • @davechavis4275
    @davechavis4275 ปีที่แล้ว

    bmw for sure

  • @pierrekawa76
    @pierrekawa76 ปีที่แล้ว

    Bonjour ,vous adoriez la KTM 1290 ADVR 2022 pour son coter sportif véloce ,léger , et maintenant vous prėferez la BMW🤔😢moi je garde ma 1290ADV R 2023 pour rouler différent des autres,dans ma région,il en ont vendu que 2 ADV R 2023😅on voit trop de BMW 😩

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      I'd still take 1290 Super Adventure R home now. It wouldn't be my general recommendation vs R 1250 GS, but it suits my very personal preference better. And I really struggle with accepting BMW boxer's sound.

  • @peterssemaganda3526
    @peterssemaganda3526 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Bmw

  • @UARider
    @UARider ปีที่แล้ว +2

    In 2 month you should make a new video 😀

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      I hope so and I - like others - am expecting insane things. Better than a new iPhone launch ;)

    • @UARider
      @UARider ปีที่แล้ว

      @@VToldsMotoShow Always more insides. Really like an IPhone 👍😝👌

  • @weekendenduro1111
    @weekendenduro1111 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    WROCŁAW POLSKA !!!

  • @philwoods2534
    @philwoods2534 ปีที่แล้ว

    I'm still wondering how your still alive riding the way you do - SAS all the way for me - BMW too bulky and clunky....

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      Loud pipes and good lights save lives.

  • @Raf13Raf11
    @Raf13Raf11 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    You can't compare 40y of experience with this wannabe adventure bikes from KTM, they have more hp and they are faster on motorway. There is no KTM that will outrun GS on local roads or on off road. Even on motorway GSA will win on 5000km race do his bigger tank. KTM is nice and fast touring bike that is in same category with V strom or Versys but on general GS is proper adventure bike and 1 milion sold units confirm that. In my opinion Africa twin is best bike for off road, GS for road and that KTM is fast on motorway but only untill Multistrada show up and fly next to him.
    And now when new GS 13 show up with everything new, all this other can take seat and look and learn like they do allways before.

    • @benkelly2190
      @benkelly2190 ปีที่แล้ว

      Utter bollocks..

    • @badcaptaintrx
      @badcaptaintrx ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Don’t get me wrong but KTM is known for its off-road motorcycles (enduro, motocross and supermoto) since the late 1990s. The grew-up with dirt bikes. The offroad capabilities of their ADV bikes is definitly superior to their competitors. The 790 ADV profits from their 450 dakar bike. The 1290 is bigger but still very capable. Check out videos from Chris birch. This is hard to compete with a GS or an africa twin (onroad and reliability is rather the strength of the others).

    • @Raf13Raf11
      @Raf13Raf11 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@badcaptaintrx i didn't talk about smaller bikes where is KTM one of best in category, video and my coment is about big bikes

    • @viclazo2839
      @viclazo2839 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      KTM is faster on all roads, local, non local, twisty, straight, motorway.... tested already a lot of times ;-)
      off-road is not "my area", but I´ve heard KTM is also there not so bad

    • @davidkendall1614
      @davidkendall1614 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@viclazo2839 Other than in a straight line, it comes down to the rider. I have ridden both. I am more confident and faster on the GS. It has better COG, handles better and lighter at the controls, and I am more confident hard on the brakes without the dive. BMW has more low end torque…KTM has a better top end and more HP (and more vibration).

  • @carlosprieto4580
    @carlosprieto4580 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    KTM

  • @benkelly2190
    @benkelly2190 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    KTM! if you have pulse…

    • @davidkendall1614
      @davidkendall1614 ปีที่แล้ว

      If you ever have to deal with KTM on a problem, which sadly are pervasive, you will wish you DIDN’T have a pulse. That is the only way to avoid the pain.

  • @janw4725
    @janw4725 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Gs keeps its value

    • @VToldsMotoShow
      @VToldsMotoShow  ปีที่แล้ว

      I can confirm that too.

    • @killjoss14
      @killjoss14 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      yes you are right 100% and don't forget the build quality, that is why it keep his value.