Israeli woman explains why she went to prison instead of joining the IDF | LBC
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 พ.ค. 2024
- Sofia Orr is the first Israeli woman since October 7th to be jailed for refusing military service. She's just been released, and tells James O'Brien that she believes it is ‘wrong to take children and make them into soldiers’. Six months on from the start of the war in Gaza, are young Israelis becoming more anti-war?
Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalplayer.com/Br0x/...
#JamesOBrien #Israel #IDF #Gaza #Palestine #LBC
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
![[TH]FFWS SEA Spring 2024 Knockout Stage - Day 18](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IfsyX-nCiZQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![BOWKYLION - ส่วนต่าง (do it without me) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/7x-pwcMopzE/mqdefault.jpg)
She resisted brainwashing. What a strong young lady.
Hardly.
@@jittmet7766 hasbara 💩
How can you refuse to protect your nation from those who says you should not exist? Makes no sense.
@@REBUILDINGLIVES-lk4rm get a therapist. You are unworthy of a response
@@jittmet7766 hasbara II 💩
She refused to join terrorist group, well done.
She is a teenager. And she has more intellectual clarity, eloquence, and moral backbone than most mature adults. Absolutely admirable.
My point exactly!
100%
Sad to see how weak most teenagers are today
@@tomocchiior most adults
An Israeli women says this is not right, how can anyone continue to support the IDF
You want to support Hamas instead?
@@bjjblueno one supports hamas as they don’t support the genocidal zionist regime!
People stand with the Jews and the Palestinians
@@bjjblueYou aren't?
Because they still watch GB News and TalkTV and their thoughts have been subconsciously implanted for them
Thing is, many Israeli say it's wrong. But as long as those in power say its right, there isn't much they can do.
Zionists will label this girl Hamas 😂
Evan Hamas preech this
for 😂😢😂
the wolf eats the isolated sheep.”
Source: Sunan Abī Dāwūd 547
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Nawawi
@@shaheerbabu1078All you are demonstrating is the Jew hatred contained in your holy book. Thanks for clarifying.
@@mogznwazthe narration has nothing to do with Jews yet you manage to find a way to be offended and make it about Jews.
Let's see what the narration says:
If there are three men in a village or in the desert among whom prayer is not offered (in congregation), the devil has got the mastery over them. So observe (prayer) in congregation), for the wolf eats only the straggling animal. Sa'ib said: By the word Jama'ah he meant saying prayer in company or in congregation.
@shaheerbabu1078 that hadeeth is talking about the devils attack on a lone human. You are very ignorant 😂
@@yousifshakoor6496 Truly bewildering
Many American youth went to jail rather than fight in Vietnam. They were punished for following their moral compass. History has proven they were right. I am proud you and you are an inspiration for all.
The 2 wars are.not comparable. This is a war on the very border, Vietnam is oceans away from the US. She will be punished for a long run anyway
@@KV-kt9tmVietnam was the human testing laboratory for arms....gaza has since been the human laboratory, which is what it is known as in the military arms industry
@@KV-kt9tmnonesense, 2 immoral wars
@@KV-kt9tmLogistically I'd have to say, you're absolutely right.
But I think there are a lot of similarities: the disingenuous execution of the 'war' and the political and social fall-out, as a result of the 'war'.
@@KV-kt9tm
"If you want to keep a secret, you must also hide it from yourself." ― George Orwell, 1984.
40 days in prison, or be ordered to potentially commit a war crime? That is an easy choice.
40 days and if you still don't join the IDF, back you go for another 40, and another and another until you either join or die of old age in prison.
Not quite as easy a choice as you suggest. Stop belittling the bravery of others, what have YOU done for anybody lately?
@@acrodave9287 Whose choice am I belittling, exactly?
@@hobanagerik Do I have to spell it out? H.E.R.S.
@@acrodave9287MLK said that it’s always the right time to do the right thing.
Unfortunately it isn't in Israeli society. She will have her career prospects affected as most young people in job interviews get asked about their conscription activities. She will also face being a social outcast as the vast, vast majority of Israeli society does not share her beliefs on this topic.
She’s a woman of honor
Only 18 and so wise and brave. Very admirable. We will see more of her in the future.
I hope she will continue to reach out and show the world that there are Israelis that care for peace
not in israel you won't. she's on their list now
@@neilbower9052 Let's make her on our list!
Reminisce of Sofie scholl of the White Rose
No you only think she’s ‘wise and brave’ because you agree with her.
i am shocked that only so few people refuse to join the military service. How crazy brain washed are these people?
Look at some of the orthodox Jewish protests against forced enlistment. The Isreali police beat them so much.
There have also been Rabbi's that say if they try to force us to enlist we will leave the country.
You aren't shocked by it, you are ignorant
@@monologic4806 you are correct. He is ignorant of the fact that how horribly extreme and hateful Israel society is.
Those ppl need to know the army is doing it so ppl like her can have a life, she should thank those who are defending their country for her an others like her with the same thoughts in their heads
You’re shocked because you don’t live there. Would you describe young Palestinians joining Hamas as “crazy brain washed” also?
Basically punishing someone for following their logic and morality . Disgusting unchecked behavior
An extremely brave woman.
In Russia such people just vanish, never to be heard of again.
@@johnrussell3961 same in Israel unfortunately
@@johnrussell3961 Russia isn't maintaining an occupation where they treat others as beneath them. Yet cry victim the moment the cornered people retaliate. Pro Occupation people are zubhuman.
@@flare-4779 Hold on, Russia is not occupying a country? What do you think is happening in Ukraine?
@@karmehedthe western world sanctions Russia, they certainly don’t defend them on the international stage and provide them with materials to sustain their occupation.
Imagine a society which demands you be a part of ‘genocidal war’ or go to prison.
Where is the democracy & freedom in that?
I made a very similar comment just before you wrote yours.
I think with I a r a e l if they keep saying they are a democracy, then this delusional is real in their minds.
Almost like they are using their children as "human sheilds"
@@shamanicrevolution2204 that maniac satanyahu would sacrifice his country & all isræIis to avoid the inevitable jail time.
@shamanicrevolution2204Even the Israeli prison system is SEGREGATED in the tiered Apartheid system...
It’s not genocidal. What IS genocidal however is Hamas’s openly declared intention in its charter to erase Israel and all Jews.
What a remarkable, brave young lady.
Israeli authorities must be held accountable for committing the crime of apartheid against Palestinians - Amnesty International
Kudos young lady. Brave and on the right side of history.
And in the dead side if Hamas and their ilk had their way
100% agree
@@youtubeyoutube936Please explain your comment.
@@youtubeyoutube936: Israeli money to HAMAS , creators and Sponsors, suitcases of money from Israel .
Remember the logo, by deception we shall do War !!!
But Go On , use the technology You Have, type suitcases of money to HAMAS *NOW* !!!
cowardice
Very brave woman must be protected at all costs
Love your show James killing it with the Gaza war coverage
This is why she was put in Prison@@jittmet7766
@@jittmet7766 hasbara 💩
he truly is. And Sangita is just an MVP too
@@jittmet7766 She lives under a fasc((istic geno((ciadial government commiting countless war cri((imes.
Of course, she needs to protect herself.
@@jittmet7766 "nothing will happen to her" meanwhile she was jailed by 1sntreal.
I’m Palestinian. I’m grateful to this girl but especially her parents. She was clearly raised to have humanity.
I say exactly the same to the Palestinians who oppose Iran..(Hamas)
@@its_rick_james_bich2575 if there was no occupation of our land, resistance groups would not feel the need to fight for us. You do not blame the oppressed for the crimes of the oppressor…
@@karimfarangfromthejungle6027 “Resistance groups”? Why not just say..Hamas!
And do you believe Hamas exists and
operates with the Palestinian people’s best interests at heart?
@@its_rick_james_bich2575not every Palestinian resistance is Hamas. Are you aware there’s unarmed resistance? Resistance in the west bank and al-quds isn’t Hamas and I’m sure even in Gaza not every resistance group is automatically Hamas. Whatever Hamas’s motives are, they are opposed to Israeli occupation. Armed resistance is the only way by which Palestinians can free themselves from armed occupation. Palestinians don’t have the luxury to abide by Western standards as they’re left to fend for themselves while Israel is backed by every western power.
@@RawiahAlshehri Hamas isn’t just for “freeing Palestinians from armed resistance” it’s for the total annexation of Israel as per its 1988 charter. But yes, there are indeed other resistance groups other than Hamas who support Hamas and the destruction of Israel. Including Iran, Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan, Iraq, Yemen, Qatar, Lebanon…so literally almost every Arab league state!!
Sofia is a courageous, moral Israeli girl who deserves a hero's welcome from all of us. Israel has made everyone in the country feel they have to yield to the cruel pressure of society's pointing fingers at you!
With tears in my eyes as I type this message: thank you for your bravery and moral conviction, young girl. And thank you for giving me hope.
"It is important for me to stay clean". This young woman values real honor and humanity far more than most of so called leaders. Stay strong honorable Lady.
Respect to all Israeli's that refuse to join the IDF!
If Israelis don't join the IDF then who will protect the civilians?
Agreed. After all there are only 3 of them!
IOF u mean
that's bs. every year there are guys and girls that are jailed for not joining
@@shadyelaraby87💯 still trying to come to terms with how an occupying force can be called the defence forces
Very brave and intelligent for her age. Well done.
Great woman advocating for peace
A great difference between being Jewish and being a Zionist, do not conflate the two ever.....bless this beutiful soul.
👏🏽
👏🏽
This war has shown us some of the worst of humanity and some of the best of humanity. She is one of the best.
Very Well said Indeed.
Fair point girl, there is a difference between defending the country and dragging it into the dark ages.Stay strong.
You are a very moral girl and your head is in the right place and I’m really proud that you stood up and spoke your truth to the world. Thank you!!
What an amazing person. Salute her bravery and independent mindedness.
You only think that because you agree with her
Yes. Anyone with a brain agrees with her.
@@mogznwaz no , because she makes sense. Tell me one thing she said wrongly ?
@@zofiarosenwerth2007 nah.. she should leave the country or move to West Bank. She’s staying under the sacrifice made by others. No Palestinian or Arab can speak against their government and remain alive. I’m proud of Israel. This is democracy at its best
A beautiful young woman with courage and heart. A rolemodel for us all. Much needed in these times.
FREE PALESTINE STOP JEWISH TERRORISM
Very true. She symbolizes the epitome of light in the midst of a terrifying darkness.
I agree, she is beautiful, and it's a beauty of the heart.
As well as a strong conviction of what is right and what is criminal. She really gained my respect.
@@bvanpelt8 she's far from beautiful. She is a freeloader who could have chosen a non military service option but... I'm not sure what her real motives are but look at all the attention she's getting. The best thing she could do for her country now is leave. Perhaps they'll take her in iran or Syria. She can go and help their cause. Just disgraceful. I'm glad I'm not her parent.
Many Israeli youth chose not to serve in the idf for many of the same reasons but non of them get sent to prison...in fact, I know quite a few, unfortunately. The ones who go to prison do so to get out of any kind of national service and that's not something to be cheered. That behaviour is deplorable.
Highest respect for that young woman!
Thanks James.
What a brave young girl.
Gives me hope for Israeli society when I had lost all hope for them.
From Ireland 🇮🇪
It's an extremely courageous thing to stand up for your principles within your own country, family, friends.
Most Israeli people will now despise this wonderful girl. This is true courage. ❤
The demonstrations worlwide and in Israel confirm the tide is turning against Netanyahu's Facisst state.
It’s only courage in your eyes because you agree with her
@@mogznwazcalm down mr genocidal
@@mogznwaz Incorrect. To stand up against your own peers, and defend something you strongly believe it, takes great courage. Regardless of whether you agree with her or not.
@@mogznwazyou lot just cannot handle any type of solidarity towards the Palestinians, go and get to know yourself properly, go to an energy healer and slowly your heart will begin to open from your life of brainwashing and distortion
How is i s r a e a l a democracy if this young lady is being imprisoned?
Err… that’s how conscription works, even in a democracy.
Do you not understand that we have conscription in democratic countries?
@@TheZackkary1 The wanton ignorance of these people is appalling.
@@TheZackkary1 like Russia. And North Korea.
@@leedavis6000 well done, you’ve listed 2 dictatorship countries that have conscription. I can’t be arsed listing all the democracies that conscript when they have to, it would take far too long.
@@TheZackkary1 come on Zack we all know it ain’t no democracy. 4 elections in like 5 years. Apartheid for some groups of people and so called democracy for Israelis. Even the Israeli wouldn’t call it a democracy with all the political and judicial changes.
What a lady. So much respect to her ❤
Hope for humanity 🙏❤
She's braver than those that fight
And a lot more intelligent too to be able to analyse the situation correctly.
How can the mass slaughter of unarmed civilians be referred to as a fight?
@@terrapyn99 true, wrong choice of words
LoL 🤡🤡🤡🤡
A wise woman 👍👍
Indeed
Every individual should aspire to live in TRUTH just like this woman.
Was waiting for Sofia’s story! Such a courageous and brave woman.
Anyone who thinks the support against the Israeli gov is down to anti-semitism needs to read this comments section. Nothing but admiration, love and respect for this brave young woman. People like Sofia give me hope that there can one day be peace
Brave and intelligence woman who can see beyond the propoganda.
The only propaganda I see is coming from Hamas and its gullible left wing enablers
Indeed. I listened to this live and was blown away by Sophia's magnificent articulacy. It makes me think that there must surely be many Israeli people who feel this way, but the local sanctions against them if they dared to speak out are just too brutal. This makes me think of Jerusalem teacher Meir Baruchin who was brutally sanctioned last year for criticising the military. Brave, brave souls.
And this is the most Democratic place in the middle East 😅😅😅
Such a brave and articulate human being, she sees through the propaganda. Utmost respect for her 👏 👏👏👏
@@starmersbarber sorry, I have to ask, do you really cut starmers hair?
@@user-id3xd1nx1m I really like this question! I don't, but do actually reckon he has magnificent hair going on, which is a bit uncharacteristic of me to focus on something like this! When I was thinking of an alias YT name, one of my pals came up with this. I like to add some mystery- although I'm looking forward to the Tories being kicked out, I'm certainly not Labour (but have no particular antagonism against Sir Keir and his crew).
I'm writing this in complete tears, I've been in despair over what is happening in Palestine, this young woman totally and utterly restored my faith in humanity. What an exceptional himan being. Compassionate and principled. I really hope she remains safe. Her parents did a fantastic job.
She'll remain safe thanks to the IDF and the iron dome.
@@SKAC botttom
@@SKACIf they aren't busy protecting settler terrorists in the West Bank, like on October 7.
Sadly, she is in the minority in Israeli society.
@@SKAC You totally forget how many fellow Israeli citizen the IDF has killed since 7/10. Israelis are safer in a place without the IDF
This young lady is very courageous and is on the right side of history. No one is allowed to stand up to Israel from outside or within.😢
Young ladies like her need to be encouraged and protected.
She's only 18 years old, what a wise and wonderful young woman.
I hope she's well protected.
She is, by the IDF!
@@SKAC Botass
@@SKAC she has more courage than the whole of the IDF put together. She will be remembered as the real hero's of Israel
@@Nikkimorox1for the wolf eats the isolated sheep.”
Source: Sunan Abī Dāwūd 547
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Nawawi
@@noramartin96 Personal abuse is not an argument.
I am moved deeply by Sophia’s conviction and for making a powerful stance for peace . Thank you.
🇧🇷🫶🇵🇸
Biden sets new conditions for US military aid amid calls to limit support for Israel
“One person is still an impact”… very powerful! ❤
Sofia, you are such a smart, strong, wonderful-hearted person. I’m so proud of you. ❤
She says she's in the minority. Most people who make a difference begin in the minority.
And It All Starts With ONE.
This kind of story has been happening long ago. It has over 75 years Palestinians lived under oppression, we always heard this kind of story but sadly those minorities will end up moving out of Israel.
You have no idea how those people are treated in Israel.
Amazing young girl and a true inspiration
We need more young souls like this girl to make the world a better place
She compels you not to be silent!
She’s smart and courageous.
Hero. Your a real soldier for humanity
You are an inspiration♥️. I love you from South Africa🌍
Thank you, brave and humane young lady. 🙏
Well done to this young lady. I'm very impressed with her convictions and strength of belief 💪🏾 👏
I respect her, she is a human being.
Legend. Very strong. I know some of Israeli young people think same way. But they wouldn't go public.
She is extraordinary.
Incredible young lady young. The world needs people like this.
At least she can hold her head up high She has self respect that no one can take away Well done her
What an admirable young woman!
Bravo young lady.
What a brave young lady! There needs to be a lot more of her in the world. ❤
Massive respect to this brave, smart, & empathic young lady 👍
Her accent sounds so _cute._ If she was an IDF soldier,🪖 her accent would repulse me.
This young woman has such courage and high principles. We can all learn from her.
Remarkable , mature, genuine and beautiful inside out. Precious to her family, and now for the world community of peace and honour lovers.
Respect to this lady. This is the future. Not 80 year old white males.
Someone has to push both parties back to the negotiating table
Hamas hands back the hostages and surrenders and the war is over, just like that. But they won't, because they don't care. Their leaders are sitting in luxury in Qatar living off stolen aid money.
Has gone on for decades, i had a friend in the 90's who had to leave Israel to escape prison, refusing to go into the army.
They are very brave and brings disgrace on their family from others in their communities.
'The cycle of violence', the weapons sales, our undemocratic hierarchies, and so on, the violence continues.
Peace to Sophia, Palestine and many more. 💛
Well Said.
She must have incredible parents 👏
I’m glad James got to talk to this amazing women, and thank you for reading people’s comments on the show ❤
She hasn't been brainwashed. Her parents must be independent thinkers.
marxists clearly.
Just another teenager rebelling against their parents who are probably feeling very ashamed and having their lives made a misery by her actions.
@@jjefferyworboys8138 Not just another teenager. At age 18 you are classed as an adult who can make their own decisions
❤
@jjefferyworboys8138 she explicitly said she was "raised in an anti zionist family"
It takes great courage to stand up for justice, bravo 👏🏽
Respect for this beautiful young lady ❤️
I hope the other media outlets step up & give this amazing young woman the platform she deserves. Thank you Sophia your bravery & strength are an inspiration.
Is Biden listening to this brave lady with a heart of gold?
He doesnt know how to turn the TV on
Gluv je ,ne cuje dobro
Biden busy preparation for General Election, have to secure his presidential post...grandpa should take a break already
They have something in common...dementia
I don't think I have fraction of the courage that this young woman has
What a brave person. Must be an upbringing of a noble, righteous family. More power to you
One ❤ to Sophia
Very beautiful - inside and outside.
@@meetings3071 Sophia gives me faith in humanity at time when it is sometimes hard to see the light at the end of the tunnel.
This young lady is amazing.I admire her strength and bravery.What a clear thinking person.I hope we see more people like this in israel. Then there might be a chance for peace.
Sofia is the future,what a amazing young lady she is I admire her dedication and peace loving nature
Such a humanitarian young Israeli wonderful young lady!!
I want my daughters to grow up and be like you Sofia. ❤
Thank you Sophia ❤
How sweet and kind of you dear. Thank you.
What an incredible, insightful young woman. You have our respect and gratitude. ‘Sofia’ means wisdom. You are wise indeed.
Well done brave Sophia - you are a brave young lady
Thank you queen for speaking
up.
As someone who made the same stance 43 years ago (different country and different war) I admire this young person. No matter what the consequences of refusal to serve the military, your conscience is clear, you've done the right thing! I've never regretted this same decision I've made when I was 18 and the trouble I went through was worth it. Thank you Sofia for what you are and what you do for peace and justices!
Sofia is a special person who stands strong against the oppresive regime of Netanyahu, if she was my daughter I would be so proud pf her, she was raised the right way! Blessings to all who are fighting for equality, peace and the humane treatment of all members of the human race. RESPECT to Sofia, one heck of a young lady! One Love people!
Great courage..Congratulations Refusing being a soldier in IDF. She wantse to raise an awareness for peace. Beautiful soul❤
So well articulated speech this lady, she's impressive.
Such honorable and upstanding character
Israel have played the role of victim in this since 1948
No they haven't. They have simply defended themselves in wars they never started.
@@SKAC What a great pity you have zero knowledge of history or are you playing the poor H game
@@noramartin96 What did I get wrong and what's the H game?
@@SKAC Wake up !
they took land by force
"Serving in the army ...... legitimises the cycle of violence".
Well done Sofia, for your very well thought-out decisions and actions. There HAS to be another way.
Great Job James
This woman has more courage than any IDF member.
I salute you, she would make a great prime minister of Israel one day
Of a future united binational state where everyone has equal rights and citizenship is not based on ethno-nationalist supremacist policy. 🙏🌿🍈🕊️
LoL
I can see people calling her an anti-semite because they saying please stop killing women and kids is that too
Much respect to you, Sofia. You are doing the right thing, with no regrets or misgivings. We stand with you!