- 325
- 235 776
Grail Country
เข้าร่วมเมื่อ 16 ส.ค. 2015
Nate, Michael and Shari discuss enchantment and mystical Christianity together and with guests.
Grail Country with Jordan Hall Part 1
We warmed up with a little banter about RPGs and moved into a conversation about freedom, love and creativity. We hope to do a follow up soon, as we really were just getting warmed up.
มุมมอง: 410
วีดีโอ
The Path of the Hermit with Dr. John Vervaeke
มุมมอง 2.2K14 วันที่ผ่านมา
Dr. John Vervaeke was gracious enough to accept my invitation to talk about his relationship to Hermes and we explored the path of the Hermit and the challenge of synthesis together.
Brendan Graham Dempsey: Where's the Meta?
มุมมอง 72114 วันที่ผ่านมา
Brendan Graham Dempsey: Where's the Meta?
Bulgakov's Apocalypse of John Chapter 13 :The Two Beasts
มุมมอง 339หลายเดือนก่อน
Bulgakov's Apocalypse of John Chapter 13 :The Two Beasts
Bulgakov's Philosophy of Economy Part One
มุมมอง 422หลายเดือนก่อน
Bulgakov's Philosophy of Economy Part One
James Raggi on Gaming, the OSR, the origins of LOTFP and his upcoming projects.
มุมมอง 7653 หลายเดือนก่อน
James Raggi on Gaming, the OSR, the origins of LOTFP and his upcoming projects.
Bulgakov's Spiritual Diary with Dr. Roberto De La Noval and Fr. Mark Roosien
มุมมอง 7534 หลายเดือนก่อน
Bulgakov's Spiritual Diary with Dr. Roberto De La Noval and Fr. Mark Roosien
A Child In The Midst: The Childlikeness of God and the theology of play with Rafe Kelley.
มุมมอง 5285 หลายเดือนก่อน
A Child In The Midst: The Childlikeness of God and the theology of play with Rafe Kelley.
The Luminous Depths - Tarot for Spiritual Practice
มุมมอง 5965 หลายเดือนก่อน
The Luminous Depths - Tarot for Spiritual Practice
Evolution, Creation, and New Creation
มุมมอง 1.3K6 หลายเดือนก่อน
Evolution, Creation, and New Creation
Meditations On the Divine Comedy, Inferno Canto VII
มุมมอง 1546 หลายเดือนก่อน
Meditations On the Divine Comedy, Inferno Canto VII
Meditations On The Divine Comedy, Inferno Canto VI
มุมมอง 2296 หลายเดือนก่อน
Meditations On The Divine Comedy, Inferno Canto VI
Bulgakov's Eschatology with Dr. Chris Green and Jedidiah Paschall
มุมมอง 1.4K6 หลายเดือนก่อน
Bulgakov's Eschatology with Dr. Chris Green and Jedidiah Paschall
Meditations On The Divine Comedy Canto V
มุมมอง 1687 หลายเดือนก่อน
Meditations On The Divine Comedy Canto V
Owen Barfield: Coleridge's Philosophy
มุมมอง 3817 หลายเดือนก่อน
Owen Barfield: Coleridge's Philosophy
Meditations On The Divine Comedy: Inferno Canto IV
มุมมอง 2217 หลายเดือนก่อน
Meditations On The Divine Comedy: Inferno Canto IV
Meditations On The Divine Comedy, Inferno Canto III
มุมมอง 2698 หลายเดือนก่อน
Meditations On The Divine Comedy, Inferno Canto III
Dr. Greg Gillespie on his Upcoming RPG Dragonslayer
มุมมอง 1.2K8 หลายเดือนก่อน
Dr. Greg Gillespie on his Upcoming RPG Dragonslayer
Meditations On The Divine Comedy Canto II
มุมมอง 3398 หลายเดือนก่อน
Meditations On The Divine Comedy Canto II
Alexander Macris: Zoroastrian Metaphysics, Bronze Age Ethics, and the Warrior Instinct in RPGs
มุมมอง 7088 หลายเดือนก่อน
Alexander Macris: Zoroastrian Metaphysics, Bronze Age Ethics, and the Warrior Instinct in RPGs
Mediations on The Divine Comedy: Canto I
มุมมอง 4708 หลายเดือนก่อน
Mediations on The Divine Comedy: Canto I
Ryan Howard of Rollin' Bones D&D, Faith and Kierkegaard?
มุมมอง 3039 หลายเดือนก่อน
Ryan Howard of Rollin' Bones D&D, Faith and Kierkegaard?
Eleven Hidden Gems In The Works of The Inklings
มุมมอง 4669 หลายเดือนก่อน
Eleven Hidden Gems In The Works of The Inklings
Chino Encounters: John Schultz Barnes
มุมมอง 2169 หลายเดือนก่อน
Chino Encounters: John Schultz Barnes
Chezi and Nate, a long overdue conversation.
มุมมอง 5639 หลายเดือนก่อน
Chezi and Nate, a long overdue conversation.
Nate, sorry for raiding your comment section, but now that I know we met IRL, it seems necessary. Why doesn't Dr. Vervake talk about any other senses? Like the way a smell can take you back to your grandmother's house? His approach seems very limited to the mind.
Have any of you read this amazing poem by Derek Walcot? Your conversation sounds very much like this. Love After Love The time will come when, with elation you will greet yourself arriving at your own door, in your own mirror and each will smile at the other's welcome, and say, sit here. Eat. You will love again the stranger who was your self. Give wine. Give bread. Give back your heart to itself, to the stranger who has loved you all your life, whom you ignored for another, who knows you by heart. Take down the love letters from the bookshelf, the photographs, the desperate notes, peel your own image from the mirror. Sit. Feast on your life.
"Quantitative infinity doesn't exist" Exactly. Number is always discrete, by definitional necessity.
Just caught a small portion of this livestream this morning, but I did have one thought. Islam is conversionist and practices Sola Scriptura with their own text, just as Christianity does. I think this is what separates both from Judaism. Although Islam is “monotheistic”, I would argue that Christianity is too, that is all it shares with Judaism, apart from genealogy. All that to say, if we can criticize Christianity for its conversionist and Sola Scriptura take on things, we must also be free to criticize Islam for the same things. I’m not sure how that can be done without any Muslim participation here, I personally would be loathe to criticize it from the outside. But maybe there are Muslims out there who feel the same way about these things as many Christians do. Judaism suffered under Christianity and Islam for these reasons.
Good points. I feel very similarly. Thanks, Shari. ❤
Could’ve been an insightful chat between friends but the dude on the rights smugness really destroyed the talk.
How do you guys find each other? I want in😂
There is a Discord server: discord.gg/ja6aZfGc
Starts with D&D and goes deep into territory that 'the church' should really be discussing if our faith is going to achieve anything of note in this world!
18:02 property concept of freedom. This is flowing through tlc and my thinking. It’s part of the authentic/sincere discussion.
Hope comes from a deeper place than Faith, both leading towards Love. ❤️ I needed to hear that. A lot of everything else flew over my head... But this was gold 🏆
Are there any book clubs/groups in TLC focusing on George MacDonald? I've dedicated this year to only reading him, and would love some people to talk about it with. I've heard Shari and Luke draw from his work recently.
Hey Cord! Grail Country has a discord server and a couple of us are planning to read Lilith later in the summer. Would love it if you joined us!
And I also went through his two Imagination essays here on this channel, if you’re interested.
Thanks, Shari. Yes I’d love an invite to that server and I’ll read along.
47:00 unity/intimacy 🎶”Bring me a higher love..” They is always an implicit unity behind any distinction.
Made in God's image is, in some ways, mean we contain the universe. Naming things to create harmony(good order). "...we teach kids language to name things as nouns. There are no nouns, right? Call it "tree"...billions of biochemical interactions and biological interactions and physical interactions that give rise to that thing. It's a process, right? You are a process. All the things that you think of as nouns [seem this way] because you're not observing very well." -D Schmachtenberger
Hope. Yup. Edit: Faith. Yup. We can’t talk about the anachronism of either.
Re: True Freedom In the words of Wendell Berry, “So, friends, every day do something that won’t compute. Love the Lord. Love the world. Work for nothing. Take all that you have and be poor. Love someone who does not deserve it. Practice Resurrection.”
11:48 Don't tell me how to parent!
Yes, more RPG talk is always welcome!
Despite my screw up... I really loved this conversation... y'all have a lot more to continue with
Love you Lance! And love the edits! 😂
@@shari6063 thank you lol
I agree, Nate. I do not believe God created out of nothing per se. I think he created from his imagination the way an author does a novel
Creation Ex Nihilo is the other side of the coin of Creation Ex Deo 🙂🦅✨
@@andyramirez6016 how would you define creation Ex Nihilo?
an omnipotent and omniscient being would create everything and every possibility just by imagining. if god can imagine it, it happens and since god can imagine anything, everything happens. that means things like alternate universes are all reality, somehwere
Never played Dungeons & Dragons but I've read about 50 books from that realm and I found it positively enchanting
My faith isn't absence or some vain hope, it is things seen and hope realized. Faith must be justified.
We were playing pre-D&D in college on the school computer, via teletype text, against the algo.
What game specifically? To my knowledge none of those games existed prior to 1974 when D&D was published.
@@grailcountry Hunt the Wumpus
My actions are evidence of faith, full stop. What I do shows you what I trust, have faith in, believe to be true. Not propositionally but embodied. Every action aims at an outcome, and that outcome is that which is hoped for. In any action resources are put at risk, in faith aimed at a hope. Sacrificed in faith toward a hope. That's action as a aimed or targeted or purposeful being. Faith -> Love(Charity/Sacrifice) -> Hope. This is the fundamental ground of human action, activity.
1:19:50 I wonder how many people will pick up what is really being said here. “Ye are gods.” Acts 13:47 “For so the Lord has commanded us: I have sent you as a light to the Gentiles, that you should be for salvation to the ends of the Earth.” Who is salvation?
1:19:00 Yes yes yes Shari this is why I keep pushing to be more open and sympathetic (empathetic?) to the occult and Wiccan practices
1:11:00 Check out the sermon on the Mount in Matthew and in Luke Be perfect as your father in heaven is perfect. Be merciful as your father in heaven is merciful. It’s about the mercy/atonement seat, upon which the judge of all the Earth sits, it was between the cherubim. Forgiveness makes perfect. Perfection is on this side of eternity. We can attain to it. It is at our fingertips. The kingdom of heaven is at hand.
excellent....( and your throw for wisdom is a 13. )
47:04 intimacy requires vulnerability of the elements in the relational. Meaning, the elements are open to being changed by the other.
32:00 “the distinguishable unity” the unity is in the perceiver, the person, who is naming. The unity is through him who names
30:45 I think before the name, it isn’t in relationality to the person. So with consciousness being centric, then yes, it does not yet exist
Ooo mild epiphany I just had: before the name, the relationality is uni-directional- the “thing” can harm/threaten you, but until the name, you are not in relationality to IT.
Naming is the conscious positioning of relationality of oneself to the thing
36:00 This is so good. “It’s like the silent state of awareness.” Going back to that womb, the essence of potential, where everything waits silently, patiently, for you with joy.
I wonder if it would be cool to have Jed should talk to Vervaeke about this.
“Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you.”
31:20 “Out beyond ideas of right and wrong is a field. Will I meet you there? - Holy to the Lord on the bells of horses.” - MeWithoutYou, Julia
28:45 🔥
30:18 - when you name something it becomes part of the story
Whose story?
@@Neal_Daedalus do stories really have owners?
@@GrimGriz owner? Or participant? But i would say, the perceiver has to be first, before there is something to perceive
🍿
The 2020 version was after my time :p
CP 2013 was in 1989 and CP2020 was 1991. You ain't that old.
Oh, nice! Listening now.
Still wrestling with this notion of home being the place of freedom to go in & out. How this relates to integrity, vulnerability & the place of belonging. “To know as you are fully known” type stuff.
I don’t know how to say it better. When God remained quiet & calm when I wanted a hyperbolic intrusion, my experience of reality thenceforth opened. Gods absence suggested I wasn’t attentive or patient enough to recognize what was already happening all around me. The looking is rote in modernity, how does one expect to see?
This is so good. Re-watching what I missed from the livestream this morn.
lots of great stuff on this stream, here's my thoughts on the various subjects as I remember them being discussed - when husbands struggle with 🌽, the wives often are hurt because they are comparing their bodies to those of the women on screen and feel they can't measure up physically, but that's almost never where the appeal lies. It's the complete absence of rejection and judgement that makes it appealing to men, so Shari is right in saying that wives are making things far worse by slandering their husbands. Not that it's an excuse; men need to get serious about really walking away from that stuff because their $ and attention fuels the whole system of abuse. When the demand dries up, the supply will dwindle; there's always going to be some appetite for the illicit but we are drowning in it right not. second point, I think there has been a lot of harm done by the "traditional' teachings and emphasis on marriage and s-x in the church, and the downplaying of the eschatological significance of the physical union of man and wife. Pageau for example glosses over so much symbolism that the "pagans" would have spotted immediately in the text because of his acceptance of the traditional views. I really recommend the book "beautiful union" by Josh Butler, its the one that caused a bunch of controversy, but he handles all the hot button issues of our day by pointing to the iconic and symbolic significance of married s-x in the Bible (including the circumcision of the "fractal man" and his entrance through the "torn veil" of the woman's "fractal temple" 3rd I think there is much to say about the redemption of the women of ill repute; Christ "marries" the woman at the well, and the woman annointing his feet with perfume. My take is that King Solomon understood the role of the messiah as the bridegroom of the nations; his writings in proverbs and SOS show that he understood the ideal of monogamy, and would have been content with his one love, yet he played a symbolic role, although imperfectly, in taking so many wives. The common assumption about his foreign wives "leading him astray" is that it was due to the urges of his libido, but he could satiate those at anytime; his willingness to sacrifice with them was an act of spiritual idolatry for his LOVE of the wives; he desired to redeem them and bring them into the proper form of worship, but this was something only Christ could accomplish. Lastly, I think we have to take into account that women outside the church have been hearing that s-x is meaningless for the last 70 years, and so we need far more grace for such women when they come to Christ; we can't clobber them with our traditional understanding of the sacredness of s-x. The poor response to the recent conversion of the OF girl Nala is prime example of this.
We really need to talk one of these days. This is spectacular comment.
Really love this Michael! Thank you so much! Everything you said resonates 💯 for me and with me. Thanks.
Well said. Thank you.
For a certain reason I don't want to make this comment while displaying my name. (I've interacted with you guys multiple times) Some time ago I found a taoist book on sex. It tells that males can train (they say "cultivate") to separate orgasm from ejaculation (Multiorgasmic Men by Mantak Chia) Long story short: Males can have multiple orgasms if they train for it. (They even say that both males and females can have full body orgasms that last minutes, but I cannot confirm this part sofar.) I don't know what to make of it. (If I read them right orgasms are limited by the body. You just get stronger and stronger muscle cramps at some point, so the orgasmic potential is not reachable.) I don't know what the effect is once I have sex with my future spouse. And I mainly have the technical aspects in mind, but I see that there must be something mystical to it. Concerning future spouse: My girlfriend broke up with me some time ago.(I never had sex with her. She is from another culture and no Christian.) I can't convince myself to not like her. I'm dating another girl now but I hate myself because I do not even remotely have the same attitude/love/feeling for her that I had towards the first one and I think I should. I kinda have the feeling that from now on anyone is just a secondary option. I don't care if my future spouse loves me, i just care about my ex girlfriend. I don't know how that relates to sex if the spouse is someone you don't love. Maybe that issue resolves itself over time. Maybe good Christians shouldn't write such lines. Or let their curiosity run into trying out such things. Confession over
Love is real. Love is painful. Love is sacrifice. Love isn't about your fulfillment ... it is about her/his fulfillment.
Thanks so much for your vulnerability here. These are the kinds of comments I love and also that others need to hear. I’m sure you are in a difficult position right now. I like William’s comment here as well. Sometimes tho this can be misconstrued by people hearing it and leads to much suffering. I am confident that if you ask yourself and God what the right move is, you will get the answer. I hope you have the courage to follow through.
@@williambranch4283 I totally agree here. That's why I'm (currently) hesitating to engage in a new relationship at all, because I know what I'm supposed to give to my spouse. But thanks for the answer!
@@shari6063 @williambranch4282 Thanks both of you for your answers
@@user-en4gi1jv9x It takes some blindness and some foolishness to take action. This is more natural when young.
I enjoy your chats so much! I have been listening to the seies on the Imagination by George Macdonald and my mind is blown- Shari you do such a great job explaining things that are hard to understand. Thankyou for sharing these!
Yay! Love that you are enjoying the Imagination series! ❤
Side tangent here…Jed, is the Buddhist meditation practice of emptying your mind beneficial to fasting? Shari was mentioning in another stream how when you fast, you notice all your other vices surface (I’m paraphrasing). I have noticed this and I think it’s often because my mind is looking for something else to attend to. But would this meditation practice prepare the mind to be “weaned”?
Jason! Yes, Zen, and other similar forms of meditation are much akin to fasting. However there are forms that are much more like feasting.
28:45 “It is out of the infinite goodness of God that he should allow evil to exist and out of it, bring the higher good.”
51:55 I will say it again. God is omniscient because he loves, and omnipotent because he forgives. In that same way, we can’t be like him.
My Grail Country tantra would be big enough to include Babylonian Ishtar Temple courtesans. Because of sanctification.
I'm not sure I can grok that but we should discuss sacred prostitution sometime, William.
Does the Salt Boy represent incarnation? That isn't Christian, it is Buddhist. My marriage wasn't an imperfect annihilation of our individuality. We achieved a more entwined and mature individuality. Our mutual sacrifice wasn't cost free or smooth.
Familiarity breeds contempt? I didn't start with much idealization and worked down from there ;-) But I know her (good) character better, of course, because I barely knew her at first.
Difference between lust vs. Love i woud say- Love is what occurs when the projection of the image collapses into the reality of the person- and the relationality blossoms. Love is there only insofar as it is not a projection
The projection of God we call reality
Per Shari ... images = danger of objectification. With people, the real person is on the inside. Shari as usual has the purest expression ... sheep-wise.
TGrog, thank you. This was incredibly enlightening. I look forward to hearing more from you.