วีดีโอ

The difference is in their personalities. Roger always came off as a very opinionated and domineering personality, while GIlmour is laid back and cerebral. Roger came to be a creative force, while the rest of the band was the talent of the music. There were many interviews with Gilmour when Pink Floyd went solo taking shots at Waters' limits at even playing bass. The feud is more like the writer of a show having a huge disagreement with the cast. Not sure what was going on with Pink Floyd between "Saucerful" and "Meddle", but they became a huge band because of their overall achievement together. Time has shown the personality of Waters (just read some his lyrics "Animals" and on), his interviews and actions. Then look at GIlmour, laid back, genuine, a creator or fantastic and soulful guitar music who held the band together in a collaborative process.

So it wasn't over how antisemitic Roger is then?

Well Ray and Dave Davies just happen to be Brothers lol

Who cares make music and stop being jackasses

Team David all the way. 😂

Leave Elvis rest in peace😢😢❤❤

The situation is similar to divorce. It's the kids that suffer the most. In this case, it's the fans that suffer as there will be no more amazing music from Pink Floyd as we have come to love so much. Sad. So very sad.

David is a Rock God and a humble decent bloke

waters is a loud mouth sociopathic fool. is not about Gilmore, its about out of control idiocy. one step from being locked up.

You are irrelivant. You need a therapist. Im with David.

Mr Waters is a putz. That’s what caused it. Problem solved. 👍

Roger Waters is brilliant. I don’t understand why he thinks that he can’t be out of a band he started, when he was instrumental in putting Barrett out. You don’t get to decide for others. You get to go your own way.

Oh I believe this I've seen Carl Perkins interviewed. I do know that I'm 74 I remember very clearly significant things that have happened in my life. And how could either one of them forget this.

In the 90s I saw “ Momentary Lapse of Reason “ tour , No Roger Waters. / David Gilmore was absolutely flawless w his vocals and musicianship

Roger.... you left the band. It's there's.

The side I'm on: Is all this feud. I think without this endless debate, the Pink Floyd would actually have been "a spent force". This fire keeps Pink Floyd burning. And they know that much better than all of us.

Here in Argentina we love The kinks! to me is the best band by far of all times. You can not event compare Beatles with The kinks. The Beatles only played 2 years in live, their las show was in 1965, only 2 years after their creation as a band. The Kinks played until the 90 improving and making one song better that one. You can compare Kinks with the Stones. Beatles should be compare with the Grassroots. The Kinks is to much for the Beatles.

Only a feature length Movie could explain their feud, and uprising in the world of 20th century music. No other Band, brotherhood, has ever been so well documented in their historic moments. They got banned from the US! How bad do you have to be to get banned from the US? No other band has gone so far. I think there needs to be a Movie about the Kinks. Or perhaps, a series of episodes to culminate the historical adventures of these talented brothers journey through their professional music odyssey. Who the HELL has the BALLS to make such a film?

Great video. Have you heard of The Clockworks, they're another irish band that kind of remind me of fontaines' earlier stuff. If not I highly recommend

Like any group its always about control and who makes the decisions thats what the feud is about.

Roger waters is ❤❤

Dear God, when I first looked at the thumbnail for this video, I thought it was a picture of Mitch McConnell.

They are literally Cosplaying Our Generation

Roger is the song writing genius that kept this band relevant and popular from its inception. W/O him, no The Wall, Darkside of the Moon, Wish You Were Here, etc.... It's like Mick Jagger leaving the Stones, rather "Pear Shaped" is all as a band from 85' til they stopped touring. Oh, and R9ger is still touring at 80 with great performances and always changing artistry and song arranging to better suit the fans wants!!! David plays the the guitar well and sings great too, but he's 1/4 of Pink Floyd, not a founding member and has a stalled out career since 2000s began. The argument is onesided on this video in the direction of Gilmour too much is all!!!

What’s your favourite Queen song? And if you enjoyed the video please do like it and subscribe to the channel. It helps me out massively. Cheers! 😁

Roger Waters Definitely. He is not anti-semitic. He is a hero. Free Palestine.

Billy Shears...he features in name on the Sgt Pepper album

My No.1 Jimmy Page is the GOAT Guitarist. He is a Master Guitarist and Musician who raised the bar for any artist, in a career spanning decades. His group, Led Zeppelin, created the most epic tunes from Blues, Ballads,Classical and Rock and Roll! Still, today, many younger generations from the first fans in 1969 are still picking up their first guitar, while watching videos of Jimmy's brilliant technique, to play like the Rock God they first heard, and try to perform the magic only Jimmy Page created. God Bless Jimmy Page 🙏🏻 ❤ 🇬🇧 🎸 🎶 🇬🇧 🎵 🎼 💙🔥 💯 🎸

Does anyone know if it is Barrett saying "I think it's marvelous" near the end of Brain Damage ( right before Eclipse) on DSOTM ?

Roger was, and still is, a political radical. He wanted to move the band towards his political leanings, and even insert it into the music. They refused, and told him to get lost. They were better off for it.

I'm on Roger Water's side because of his moral wisdom, humility and of course, musical genius.

love the band, saw them live once in 2019 and it was the best experience. Very well-structured video, it's nice to see your appreciation to the band through your delivery

Quite strange enough that the Stones don't have a drummer and bass guitarist,while the Beatles have.😂

Nobody cares about Faul the Faker!

Eh, the "hidden" messages don't really do it for me. Am I really hearing what they're saying or am I hearing what the video tells me I'm hearing, you know? What has me believing Paul is dead, is all of symbolism in the album covers and the photo shoots for different magazines of the time.

George Roger Waters GENIUS. The others are replaceable.

This video is nothing than a collection of bad judgement and gossip , someone trying to create bad feelings of a time long past. It's poor writing or whatever you choose to describe it. Go start a war elsewhere creep.

Only discovered this band last week!!! Great video, PUNKS DEAD IS A BANGER

Sorry bruv. No way did LZ overshadow The Who.

Two alpha dogs!

It’s basically Dustin the turkey at the Eurovision.

I'm always appreciative of how Eric has played with so many different people without even thinking of hogging the limelight. The Harrison tour in Japan is a perfect example, and his appearances with people like Mr Knopfler and John Martyn are further examples. And yet he is so brilliant himself! Love him!

Twat. Laughing Gnome was a great song , I used to listen to it on Radio 1's Junior Choice.

I try to watch these sorts of things. But its never anything new or revealing. Basically, anyone can do this. Re-tell all the stuff thats already out there. My point is where will it end up. A zillion hours of rehashed and repeated band stories, which may well have saved a large section of rain forest, had they never been made. TH-cam should offer monetisation for some people to NOT make content. Let's hope their upload facility soon develops the ability to dump re-hashed stuff before it goes live.

I’m actually on Roger’s side. And I know it’s an unpopular side because he was (past tense - “was”) kind of an asshole. I used to be team Gilmour, but the more I thought of it, the more it feels like Gilmour was a total opportunist and basically moonlighted as Pink Floyd and played all Rogers songs/concepts and made millions upon millions. Momentary Lapse and Division Bell were both mediocre. Roger was the visionary of the band, he wrote 99% of their music and lyrics - and Gilmour got filthy rich from it and because he was butt hurt about how Roger treated him over the years retaliated by going on as Pink Floyd with a glorified cover band of A-list musicians to tour arenas and make Roger out to be a bad person. I can’t imagine having been Gilmour and having the gall to not only keep the name for touring, but even hiring people to come in and write Pink Floyd songs for the band is actually kinda pathetic, and totally unnecessary. But the fact that Gilmour’s camp was able to gaslight everyone into thinking it was still legitimately Pink Floyd by playing all of Roger’s certified bangers live just seems like the side I can’t see eye to eye with.