GenericPie War of the Ring
GenericPie War of the Ring
  • 67
  • 30 133

วีดีโอ

A White Tree In Dark Times - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 30
มุมมอง 289วันที่ผ่านมา
Cool base game of War of the Ring on the Discord server between gforce and groeneprof.
Legolas and Pippin Don't Get Far - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 29
มุมมอง 28314 วันที่ผ่านมา
Very fun (and silly) base game of War of the Ring between bhilly and Commander Swift played via the Java Client.
Where Was Gondor When Erebor Fell? - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 28 (Feat Ituralde Co-Comms)
มุมมอง 34721 วันที่ผ่านมา
FANTASTIC game of War of the Ring between Ernie and Ituralde. Check out Ituralde's channel here: www.youtube.com/@UCR4TYy2cp7RGvpXaO-7fqrQ
Aragorn the Tree Hugger - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 27
มุมมอง 929หลายเดือนก่อน
A fun Hobbit league game of base War of the RIng between Columbo and Commander Swift
War of the Ring: A Guide To Sucking Less As The Shadow
มุมมอง 524หลายเดือนก่อน
A rambling guide to sucking less as the shadow in the board game War of the Ring based on my own failures. Join the Discord Server: discord.gg/QB95M9gM Java/Game Intro: th-cam.com/video/LXZ5oWpieKc/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=Strider656 War of the Ring review: th-cam.com/video/MvgooNB8Ck0/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=ShutUp&SitDown
War of the Ring: A Guide to Sucking Less As The Free People
มุมมอง 1.1Kหลายเดือนก่อน
A rambling breakdown of lessons I've learned losing games of War of the Ring playing as the Free People. Hopefully useful to some of the newer players out there!
2024 LoME Tourney R1G3 vs Vanali - My Worst Game Ever?
มุมมอง 288หลายเดือนก่อน
FInal game in my matchup vs Vanali in the 2024 War of the Ring (Lords of Middle Earth) World Tournament).
LoME Tourney R1G2 vs Vanali
มุมมอง 335หลายเดือนก่อน
Game 2 of my matchup with Vanali in the 2024 Lords of Middle Earth tournament.
2024 LoME Tourney R1G1 vs Vanali
มุมมอง 395หลายเดือนก่อน
Round one of my tie against Vanali in the 2024 War of the Ring (Lords of Middle Earth) Tournament.
The Last Battle - War of the Ring (LOME) feat. Disgruntled Veteran co-comms!
มุมมอง 4552 หลายเดือนก่อน
Very fun game of LoME between myself and Disgruntled Veteran. Check out his excellent channel here: www.youtube.com/@dv-warofthering-ql8fk
Can Columbo Outwit the Free People? - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 26
มุมมอง 3472 หลายเดือนก่อน
Great base ladder game of War of the Ring between Gregg110 and Columbo from the Discord server. Enjoy!
The Elves Fight Back - Peepin Tom Bombadil EP 25
มุมมอง 3912 หลายเดือนก่อน
A fun Hobbit League game of base War of the Ring on the Discord Server between Ace_xD and Pallando.
Helm's Deep Refuses to Fall - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 24
มุมมอง 3803 หลายเดือนก่อน
A thrilling game of War of the Ring between Jaxowaraxa and NiNex in the early stages of the World Tournament (Game 2 after Jax won the first)
WOME! - Peepin Tom Bombadil EP 23 (WOME + LOME Edition))
มุมมอง 4083 หลายเดือนก่อน
WOME! - Peepin Tom Bombadil EP 23 (WOME LOME Edition))
The Fellowship Get Cocky - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 22
มุมมอง 4223 หลายเดือนก่อน
The Fellowship Get Cocky - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 22
The War of the Ring Experience
มุมมอง 8153 หลายเดือนก่อน
The War of the Ring Experience
Last Stand of the Rohirrm - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 21
มุมมอง 5153 หลายเดือนก่อน
Last Stand of the Rohirrm - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 21
Minas Tirith: Where Shadow Dreams Go To Die - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 21 (LOME)
มุมมอง 5324 หลายเดือนก่อน
Minas Tirith: Where Shadow Dreams Go To Die - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 21 (LOME)
Arise, Arise, Riders of Théoden! - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 20
มุมมอง 4094 หลายเดือนก่อน
Arise, Arise, Riders of Théoden! - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 20
The Two Sides of Smeagol - War of the Ring (LOME)
มุมมอง 3224 หลายเดือนก่อน
The Two Sides of Smeagol - War of the Ring (LOME)
Gandalf Visits a Different Woodland Retreat - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 19
มุมมอง 5304 หลายเดือนก่อน
Gandalf Visits a Different Woodland Retreat - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 19
2024 WOTR World Tournament R3-G2 vs Michel
มุมมอง 5414 หลายเดือนก่อน
2024 WOTR World Tournament R3-G2 vs Michel
Gandalf vs Samwise: CAGE MATCH - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 18
มุมมอง 3584 หลายเดือนก่อน
Gandalf vs Samwise: CAGE MATCH - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 18
2024 WOTR World Tournament R3-G1 vs Michel
มุมมอง 6405 หลายเดือนก่อน
2024 WOTR World Tournament R3-G1 vs Michel
A New Power Is(n't) Rising - 2024 WOTR World Tournament R2-G3 (Feat. Ituralde Co-comms)
มุมมอง 4495 หลายเดือนก่อน
A New Power Is(n't) Rising - 2024 WOTR World Tournament R2-G3 (Feat. Ituralde Co-comms)
A Nice Leisurely Stroll Through Mordor - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 17 (LOME Edition)
มุมมอง 4555 หลายเดือนก่อน
A Nice Leisurely Stroll Through Mordor - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 17 (LOME Edition)
Gandalf and Pippin's Reluctant Adventure - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 16
มุมมอง 3075 หลายเดือนก่อน
Gandalf and Pippin's Reluctant Adventure - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 16
The Hobbits Get Comfortable On Mount Doom - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 15
มุมมอง 2945 หลายเดือนก่อน
The Hobbits Get Comfortable On Mount Doom - Peepin' Tom Bombadil EP 15
The Taking...and Re-Taking of Dale - 2024 WOTR World Tournament R2-G1 (Feat. Ituralde Co-Comms)
มุมมอง 7795 หลายเดือนก่อน
The Taking...and Re-Taking of Dale - 2024 WOTR World Tournament R2-G1 (Feat. Ituralde Co-Comms)

ความคิดเห็น

  • @joshdavis3743
    @joshdavis3743 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    That only counts as one!

  • @mcintma2
    @mcintma2 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Such an odd game, fun to see! Thumbnail is a masterpiece BTW!

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 4 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Haha thanks man. Felt like the perfect image.

  • @angelfuentes7645
    @angelfuentes7645 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    great work¡¡¡ i enjoyed too much the two streamings, and congrats to the champion ¡¡

  • @benjaminsaffir7871
    @benjaminsaffir7871 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    This game was really LoTR as Tolkien intended it; a dark despairing situation for the Free Peoples rescued by a series of Eucatastrophes that save the day miraculously! And also the heroes played such a big role; if it wasn't for the steadfast refusal of Aragorn, Gandalf and Boromir in Dol Amroth, the daring recklessness of Gimli and his Northmen in Mordor, and the plucky bravery of Merry leading an army to take back his homeland, Sauron would have triumphed! (Ringbearers did a shit job though, no points for you schmucks) I think these sorts of stories are what I loved about this game from the first playthrough; every FP victory feels like a miracle but the deck is sprinkled in with so many miracles it happens pretty often. PS; if anyone would be willing to teach a Java noob how to use the client properly in a game hit me up! I've played a bunch of live games and enjoy the videos but didn't really understand how the Java client works and would like to try with someone who's willing to be patient for a first game! :)

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @benjaminsaffir7871 So true! A truly Herculean effort from (most of) the companions this game. Funny how what initially seemed like such inconsequential moves for Merry and Gimli ended up being absolutely pivotal. If you aren't on it already I would recommend joining the Discord server - if you look for a game on there and explain that you're new to Java you should be able to find someone to show you the ropes. Otherwise I believe Strider656 has a couple of videos on his channel that help teach new players how to use Java.

  • @mcintma2
    @mcintma2 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    WOME videos upcoming??! Nice!!!

  • @steave435
    @steave435 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Wow, insane game. Technically wasn't even over at the end though, with how insane dice were this game, I would only have been half surprised if SP managed to use the last die to take DA after all!

  • @NigelIncubatorJones
    @NigelIncubatorJones 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Wow, that ending was hilarious.

  • @VayzeWOTR-gq3nu
    @VayzeWOTR-gq3nu 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    A great example of why I love and hate this game at the same time. Fantastic commentary. Yes to all you experts, many things I could've done differently to avoid the result.

  • @NigelIncubatorJones
    @NigelIncubatorJones 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I think it's pronounced "eye-hour".

  • @grantprice3
    @grantprice3 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    @6:010 wouldn't the triple snake eye be 1 1 1 1 1 1 ???

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @grantprice3 you're right! What is 1 1 1 then?

  • @bhilly812
    @bhilly812 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    My flabbers are completely gasted. What did we all just watch.

  • @mimmocangiano1
    @mimmocangiano1 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    (Stella Rossa here) Thank you so much for showing this. Hope everyone can enjoy it, and sorry for my mistakes, I was a very unexperienced player at that time. P.s. Marry was there because I hoped for Mazarbul to defend Dale

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @mimmocangiano1 Thanks for sharing - such an insane/funny/cruel game! Ah didn't think of Mazarbul. Makes more sense now.

  • @NigelIncubatorJones
    @NigelIncubatorJones 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    On the first turn, if I only have one movement, I'll make that move the last action. Curious why others move right away.

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Think it generally makes sense to leave at least one die. If you are hit and kill Gandy you can them use the final die to hide with Strider.

    • @NigelIncubatorJones
      @NigelIncubatorJones 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@GenericPieWOTR True, though you could always hide with Strider on the first die of the following turn.

    • @steave435
      @steave435 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@NigelIncubatorJones You might roll all movement, or have more important things to do with the turn 2 dice than the turn 1 dice. Generally, waiting to give your opponent info about what you're gonna do until as late as possible is better, so doing the things you're obviously going to do first makes sense.

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@NigelIncubatorJones Once the FSP is out of Rivendell I generally like to move ASAP if possible. Means the 'hurt the FSP' cards like Orc Patrol are slightly less effective and can't slow you down quite as much by revealing you before you move. I second Steave's point too - is there really any gain in waiting to move turn 1 anyway if it's something you're always intending to do. I suppose if you get revealed move 1 and the SP is holding a C/P an early move could leave you open to a Breaking, Lure of the Ring, Orc Patrol, etc but I think that's about the only reason it's worth waiting.

    • @NigelIncubatorJones
      @NigelIncubatorJones 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@GenericPieWOTR Well, that's exactly why. They might have a damaging card. Unlikely on turn 1 of course, but possible. Also, in Lords, it opens the possibility of the Chief arriving. I'd flip the statement around--is there really any point in moving right away when you can just wait and move at the end of the turn? Early Gandalf the White, maybe, if you're holding a Will.

  • @aleksanderkopydowski775
    @aleksanderkopydowski775 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Great and surprising gameplay :) But I have two questions: - why did Vanali reduce VP to 7 (time 1:09:09)? He should have 8VP. - am I right that Vayze should remove the regular unit after winning the defense of Rivendell? (time 1:16:00)

  • @strider656wotr
    @strider656wotr 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Where’s the “gg wp” lol

  • @MicheleCampolo
    @MicheleCampolo 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Another nice commentary, thanks for doing this!

  • @mcintma2
    @mcintma2 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Absolute classic. Just watched again. A tour de force!

  • @mcintma2
    @mcintma2 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Great work GP and GB - thanks for covering this! Can't help but feel bad for how it went. But no doubt these are 2 amazing players! LF to next tourney!!! Hopefully we get another WOME tourney and y'all join in :)

  • @NigelIncubatorJones
    @NigelIncubatorJones 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    How do you guarantee that neither player can watch this live stream during the game?

  • @mcintma2
    @mcintma2 12 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Great one! Tricky whether to keep Gandy in the FSP - you could go the next 25 dice with no W (as in 90% of my FP games). Also, SP player was trying to troll FP into mustering the S & E to War for him, so I think it was good play. I think you nailed it - the timing was slightly off for the attack on Mordor. But how can you blame the FP player for jumping on a SP 5E roll? Super tricky. But generally, given time, SP will get those 2VP back. So timing FPMV has to be precise!

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 12 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @mcintma2 ah never considered they mightve been trying to bait a S&E muster - interesting idea. My guess is they wanted to make sure they held OSG by getting an army there ASAP but I think SP had time that turn unless FP actually predicted the Shadows Gather. More likely the FP takes some time to muster rather than using a precious die to kill single reg.

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 12 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @mcintma2 and yeah super tricky to time the FPMV attempt. I think maybe if they'd gone for Barad Dur instead and used that as a way of evacuating Aragorn, the 6 dice could've made a big difference. Personally I woulda played Wizard's Staff (as I predicted, corruption became a big issue) and gambled on rolling another W soon. With the 5th die in play your odds of rolling a W are quite a bit higher so less chance of getting dice-starved (and FP on 5 dice isn't terrible anyway).

    • @mcintma2
      @mcintma2 12 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@GenericPieWOTR Right. As happened in this game, I've noticed that every time I separate for FPMV (like, every time) - suddenly SP hits the FSP every step on 1 die at 6s, and FSP are dead-men-walking, and FPMV becomes the *only* option (as both players clearly see).

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 12 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @mcintma2 classic Java!

  • @Mittens1776
    @Mittens1776 12 วันที่ผ่านมา

    6:00 You must retreat the entire army when attacked, so you can't split off characters from an army this way (you can when moving an army). 10:05 Yeah no reason to use a will instead of an h when s&e are not at war, also you probably want to at least have the option to get gandalf the white. 11:00 I think the idea behind the shadows gather play is to protect osgiliath since Fp can't attack it without giving you a free s&e muster, plus then that army can retreat into the wk (although those extra units could only be used defensively). 15:14 As FP I would definitely be thinking about a Mordor charge here (west harondor-> south ithilien-> minas morgul, then one of the other mordor strongholds next turn). They only have 1 hybrid which they need to put an orc in barad-dur and morannon to stop me from getting those strongholds for free next turn, and they've only drawn 5/24 strategy cards, and have already played half orcs, I'd be willing to see if they had one of the remaining reinforcement cards. 23:20 Yeah SP could've brought MM up to 4 hits here, which seems much better. 27:50 As FP I might've stayed for a field battle there, you're definitely not the favourite to win it, but if you win it you're in a very good position, plus you can play fateful strike as well to try get rid of the wk and then retreat if you don't win the first round. Retreating into siege means that you're counting on your next action dice roll to win the game. 32:05 Probably best to hold your presses, you have the extra attacks to whittle aragorn down in a slightly less risky way. 34:45 See above, if you had an extra 2 hits here you could take 2 hits on the relentless assault without losing combat strength. 41:30 I think there is a realistic chance of getting a SPMV well before the FPRV though. Lorien + DA + Rohan is 10 vps, with new power is rising in hand, the only issue is opening up cirdans by attacking lorien before DA. So isildur's bane's event effect is probably a lot less useful than the cruel as death. 51:55 I would probably get rid of Saruman while I can, take shadow down to 7 dice for the next turn, you've hidden so no automatic corruption, and you can then react to a muster or eye heavy roll next turn. Then you can chain into gwaihir to move gandalf into HD for free. 55:25 I would kill the mouth while I could here. Even if you lose the will to day without dawn, you can move with a ring to stop the automatic corruption, and then you're on 5 dice to 7 for the rest of the game, plus no leadership against gandy in HD.

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 12 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @Mittens1776 At 11:00 I still think it's worth using a more efficient shadows gather rather than rushing in the S&Es to OSG. I think it's unlikely the FP is going to rush to attack a single reg in OSG anyway (surely the priority is mustering in Pel) and v.unlikely they read SP is planning to play Shadow's Gather. And if the idea was to bait a muster it didn't work anyway.

  • @NigelIncubatorJones
    @NigelIncubatorJones 12 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Great stuff. Cool balrog play.

  • @joshdavis3743
    @joshdavis3743 12 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Where was Gondor?

  • @mcintma2
    @mcintma2 17 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Hahaha the infighting started 1 step out of Rivendell, the Fellowship is Broken as Elrond is watching from his porch, shaking his head ;) Wild game & luck swings, never give up! Thx for making this GP!!!

  • @RIP_Sinners
    @RIP_Sinners 18 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Java dev be like, "Why would I need to code for more than 7 dice in the hunt pool? No one plays like that; it's not a real game state."

  • @georgemcdonald8470
    @georgemcdonald8470 18 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Thought process behind separating legolas by the way was 1) I'd already mustered into WLR through thranduils and if i have to defend moria figured rivendell could need some defending, 2) allows me to move those companions 2 tiles instead of 1 should i get fear fire foes, 3) having kept gandi in I felt i could afford to take an extra corruption :) Also separately - I didn't move into mordor on T7 for a couple of reasons. 1) had to assume that shadow had cruel weather so better to move twice this turn and twice next turn 2) moving only 2x allowed me to defend HD, DA and Rivendell. If i had not defended all 3, one of them would have fallen a turn earlier which would have lost me the game and nullified any advantage gained from getting into mordor a turn faster 3) Corruption was already starting to become a significant issue after the 2nd move. Had I been hit again and revealed into mordor on my 3rd move i would have been in a lot of trouble. As things stood I still only won through sheer luck not drawing any reveals (let alone 8 C eyes or reds!) on my mordor run :)

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 18 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @georgemcdonald8470 hey, thanks again for sharing the game - really fun one! Can defo see your logic on both counts - sometimes when commentating it's hard to take stock of the finer details and yeah on reflection defending HD makes a lot more sense - lose that cheap 2 VP and you're almost certainly doomed in mordor regardless.

    • @georgemcdonald8470
      @georgemcdonald8470 17 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@GenericPieWOTR for sure! Not saying moving would necessarily have been a bad play. I tend to err on the side of caution when it comes to rushing the fellowship and focus a little more on defence - just part of my playstyle :)

  • @bhilly812
    @bhilly812 19 วันที่ผ่านมา

    This was such a fun one, well done by swift!

    • @georgemcdonald8470
      @georgemcdonald8470 18 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Haha the entire game was a total mess - the java gods just laughing hysterically at both of us

    • @bhilly812
      @bhilly812 18 วันที่ผ่านมา

      "Creatures of middle earth make plans and Java laughs"

    • @TheMasterPlumber
      @TheMasterPlumber 17 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Did you see or consider to try and win the turn before the dunk? You had the resources to take Rivendell and DA with decent odds and full leadership. I can't say I would have tried because FP was extremely unlikely to win how they did, but going for GH really threw me for a loop. Fun game to watch.

    • @bhilly812
      @bhilly812 17 วันที่ผ่านมา

      ​@TheMasterPlumber definitely considered it, problem was if either failed I wouldn't have a path to 10 the turn after. FP hand was full of c cards, so I had to assume a couple were brave stands, or a wpts to get gandy to DA. given the odds of rolling enough moves and not getting revealed from step 1 was close to 0, I took the higher probability play of waiting until the next turn to win.

  • @nponou1
    @nponou1 20 วันที่ผ่านมา

    TY 4 this game! make more videos please)

  • @Corngunderer
    @Corngunderer 22 วันที่ผ่านมา

    War of the ring looks so interesting but I can't find anything about it as a computerized version, where do you play this?

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 22 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@Corngunderer We play via a free Java client and arrange games via a Discord server. Try this link! boardgamegeek.com/guild/1733

  • @mcintma2
    @mcintma2 25 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Another great thumbnail love it! Really fun game, could not be closer. It's so hard as FP to decide Ring/FPMV and you get to a point where you have to commit instead of splitting your resources. Wonder what a ring attempt would have entailed ... hard to say!

  • @ernie-sliter
    @ernie-sliter 27 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Ernie here. Great commentary by you two, and appreciate all the video content yall make, it's very entertaining! It was a fun game and as FP, I love creating a dual threat for Shadow, balancing and pivoting back and forth from fellowship progress to military options, based on the dice and opportunities you see. Makes it very fun and dynamic. Anyway subscribed to both of yalls channels and will continue to enjoy the content!

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 27 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Thanks for letting us share the game, Ernie. Really loved this one - it's very rare to have a game where all 4 win conditions were on the table - this game could've gone in so many different directions.

  • @Lancer234
    @Lancer234 27 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Not having a regular does change things quite a bit, makes the elite decision make a lot more sense. I guess what else do you do. Dwarves have a very limited force pool.

  • @NigelIncubatorJones
    @NigelIncubatorJones 27 วันที่ผ่านมา

    This kind of game is a hoot. Definitely some mistakes by both sides there. That last muster, ouch.

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 27 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @NigelIncubatorJones After the commentary finished we realised Ernie had no regular dwarves left to muster so it was actually a much harder decision for Ernie that we'd thought. He probably did the best play given the circumstances (although maybe an elite on Erebor would've been better? Very hard to say).

  • @christopherkulander3236
    @christopherkulander3236 27 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Enjoying this! Idea: it seems that everybody tries to avoid reposting boring "by the numbers" games in favor of wacky ones filled with running around and military hi-jinx. But maybe consider posting one or two more "average" games to show us newer folks what exactly such games entail.

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 27 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @christopherkulander3236 yeah I know what you mean. If you watch the tournament games on the channel those are probably more representative of a "typical" game as they aren't picked for entertainment value.

  • @CaptainOfTheRing
    @CaptainOfTheRing 27 วันที่ผ่านมา

    A pleasure to do this with you - always a good time. We did notice one thing after the cast that changes our last little bit of analysis: (Spoiler spacing) There were no drawrf regulars left at the end

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 27 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Yeah apologies Ernie for doubting you if you read this!! It was much less straightforward than we assumed in the comms.

    • @NigelIncubatorJones
      @NigelIncubatorJones 27 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@GenericPieWOTR With his last Will, he could have moved a regular from Dale into Erebor, hedging bets a bit. The 3 vs. 3 against Dale favored him still.

  • @Chris-th4zr
    @Chris-th4zr 28 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Great video as usual! I can’t find reference to the two FP tokens in the rules. Where do these come from?

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR 28 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @Chris-th4zr Thanks, Chris! The tokens are an optional addition used online to help balance the game slightly (without tokens shadow wins ~55%). They aren't in the main rulebook but do exist in the LoME rules which is where people got the idea from I guess?

  • @MichaelAndersen1
    @MichaelAndersen1 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Really useful series! Thanks

  • @alexisruessmann8928
    @alexisruessmann8928 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Thank you so much for this great video! I'm only starting and in my first game alone I have made half the list of mistakes you explain here. This video is a pure gem, thank you so much for taking the time for it!

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR หลายเดือนก่อน

      Glad you found it helpful!!

  • @agressia5582
    @agressia5582 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Giving tokens to Free People is redundant in LOME.

  • @mcintma2
    @mcintma2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Goddamit GP, cant get image of Aragorn fellating Ents out of my head now! This was a fun game, nice to see players that play a bit differently, like I would not in a million years attack that massive Moria army - I would expect the standard 'no 6s on the next 20 dice' and then you are royally screwed. But it worked!

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR หลายเดือนก่อน

      @mcintma2 bwahaha and what a glorious image it is!!

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR หลายเดือนก่อน

      I actually just re-watched that fight and with fresh eyes...yeah I've seen many a big FP size fall flat on its face against a much smaller defence than the one in Moria before (and that's before you consider the huge warg army they then had to hold off). Even a single average round of combat and another forced downgrade v.likely loses the game for the FP. I suspect there was probably another, more reliable route to FPMV there but not sure what it would be exactly.... Think Aragorn + Anduril would definitely need to get involved, though.

  • @nadavbenassa632
    @nadavbenassa632 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Great analysis. I think going for MT in the beginning is a good idea. I also think that last turn SP should've gone for the military victory, this way free do not have enough action to both reclaim lorien and moria. Then next turn you just need 1 more point and you still have a huge army around MT. going to the shire from MG might also be feasible depending on the rolls

  • @Mittens1776
    @Mittens1776 หลายเดือนก่อน

    6:00 I think killing Gandy is definitely the play here, the 6th dice is too valuable, the extra corruption can be burned off in lorien along with wwsat, if necessary. 13:00 Balrog seems way better here, if they declare somewhere other then lorien you can potentially reveal them with the extra tile to get your moria tile, and if they do declare in lorien you can hold off on triggering it so you can use durins bane to quickly bring down lorien to get the extra reroll in lorien instead. 19:25 Not just devilry of orthanc, but fighting uruk hai could be played as an event card here, for the 2 free presses. 27:30 I don't hate moving the fellowship here, to force shadow to allocate an eye, but I wonder if maybe using boromirs muster ability to bring gondor to war (with the other muster) would be better here, to threaten fpmv next turn more easily. 31:40 One problem with that plan is shadow can use 1 army to merge up in gorgoroth, and then hold the other until fp commits to either north ithilien or dagorlad, then moves the full 10 orcs into the stronghold they want to defend. 35:00 Now that you mentioned it, this is another big problem with the plan, and the shadow is moving (+ similar cards) aren't necessary since you would be giving shadow a ring (if you brought in aragorn to play anduril). 38:30 Commander swift forgot to downgrade an elite for the press here. 42:30 Fellowship was not revealed here, Columbo just uses the reveal + hide shortcuts to declare the fellowship (changes the fellowship track to 0). 53:00 Either way looks like a long shot for commander swift, but maybe you stay for the field here, you have more hits than the free people do, you can play devilry or dread and despair, and if the free people stop you can muster another elite and waste one of the free peoples dice. If it goes well enough, maybe you even stay for a field battle against the other army since you have leadership and they don't.

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR หลายเดือนก่อน

      @Mittens1776 great comment! I addressed a couple of those in game (I guess you were writing these as you watched). Not sure I fully agree on #1. Being able to park in Lorien is never a guarantee and from what I remember it fell pretty quickly. I've lost games due to a single corruption when killing gandy cheaply and going Aragorn. Corruption would've likely been veeeery tight at the end if the FP needed to rush for a dunk. As I say in the video it can go either way, though and you'd be kicking yourself if you don't roll another W for 3 turns.

  • @nin_4_me58
    @nin_4_me58 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Nice! I have done most of these…

  • @CaptainOfTheRing
    @CaptainOfTheRing หลายเดือนก่อน

    29:00 was a little surprised no balrog muster by this point. It would pu dwarves closer to war but DEW wasnt happening much anyway and it would be an elite and a die

  • @mcintma2
    @mcintma2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    WTF is a musterling ;) ... another great set of advice for newer players, and reminders for vets, great video Ross!

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR หลายเดือนก่อน

      I thought you of all people would know, Marc! They're close relations of the Dunlendings ;)

    • @mcintma2
      @mcintma2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@GenericPieWOTR LOL! I am half Dunlending on my mother's side ...

  • @buondiavolo5244
    @buondiavolo5244 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I believe point 2) and 3) are a little in opposition... Ok if you go military , go 80 % and use 20% of dices to use cards that hit the fellowship, But moving nazgul and orcs some time need 2 eyes to be effective. I not believe there is a right percentage of corruption strategy mixed with military it is more an alchemical potion of intuite and luck. Try to kill Strider is good and right things to do(from the Gospel of Sauron ⚔ )also if you wish conquest middel earth !

  • @CaptainOfTheRing
    @CaptainOfTheRing หลายเดือนก่อน

    6:10 yes you did. That was a wild game.

  • @NigelIncubatorJones
    @NigelIncubatorJones หลายเดือนก่อน

    Oh yeah, Lorien can go sideways hard in LoME if you're not careful.

  • @gregg1109
    @gregg1109 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Loving the replay commentary! On my first rewatch, I’m surprised how many silly misjudgements I made throughout, but it was a pleasant first FPMV nonetheless!

  • @richardhampton3260
    @richardhampton3260 หลายเดือนก่อน

    So what is the game how do you play

    • @GenericPieWOTR
      @GenericPieWOTR หลายเดือนก่อน

      It's a (fantastic) board game called War of the Ring with a reasonably-sized online Discord community that play it competitively via a free Java client. To learn more about the game check this out: th-cam.com/video/QCwj9WO3-To/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=RTFM and for Java/Discord: th-cam.com/video/4iXisnGuBBw/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=Strider656