ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 มี.ค. 2019
- One of the best scenes from the film Hostiles
Rory Cochrane as Master Sgt. Thomas Metz
Wes Studi as Chief Yellow Hawk
Christian Bale as Captain Joseph J. Blocker
Directed by Scott Cooper
Music by Max Richter
© 2017 - Entertainment Studios Motion Pictures - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
Rare depiction of PTSD in a Western, a time when no one had any idea it existed. Such a powerful scene and sensational acting
Ayrton senna
Was called “ Soldiers Heart “ I believe back then
They just told you to hit the bottle!
Why, in the hell do you think people back then didn't think it existed? 😂 🤣 Your not to bright! Lol! No, it was just called something else! You really don't think for yourself do you. Is that what you read somewheres? If so, it isn't true. Lol
@@oldeays5085 Yeah, it existed but it was usually regarded as weakness or lack of mental fibre, and the men suffering from it got treated extremely harshly.
This movie is so underrated.
Extremely. Such a wonderful piece of art
yes :(
Definitely
you prolly dont give a shit but if you guys are bored like me during the covid times you can watch pretty much all of the latest series on Instaflixxer. Been streaming with my girlfriend recently =)
@Muhammad Dominik Yup, been watching on instaflixxer for years myself :D
can’t even feel the rain, giving in to the pain, the numbness, the past, stepping into oblivion, like we all do in the end.
No he knew something many don't and thats in the end when its all said and done The most high will redeem us from all the evils that were done to us in this life and world and we could extend the amount of mercy u bestowed upon us. But only at that time.
If I were in charge, this film would have cleared the table of awards at the Oscars.
Cochrine absolutely should have won
"I don't feel anything." Such a powerful sentence, especially for that time.
Rory Cochrane was incredible in this movie. As a vet myself, I noticed that he authentically captured the feeling of being at the end of your rope; no longer able to laugh, no longer able to cry, and your only companions are haunting memories. I hope to see more of this actor. And Wes Studi? Awesome as always.
He's there. Great character actor. I knew it from the time he told him that he needed to leave.
I agree, Wes sadly is 71 I think though, not as young as he once was.
"Part of me dies with you."
That’s Rory Cochrane? The stoner kid from Dazed and Confused?
Wes Studi is an ex-11 Bravo (Infantry), joined the Oklahoma National Guard, and volunteered for a 12 month tour of duty in Vietnam, joining Alpha Company, 3rd Battalion, 39th Infantry Regiment, 9th Infantry Division. That 100 yard stare he gives in some of his film scenes ain't fake.
The performances in this film were remarkably powerful. I was awestruck by the raw human emotions conveyed by these incredible actors.
I’m a combat vet and this truly hit me hard I just finished the movie absolutely loved it they all did amazing
Greatest scene in the entire movie
And the competition is big!!
I think the same
I don’t care what anyone says. One of the best scenes I’ve seen.
Legit one of my favorite “westerns” ever made
This scene made me tear up, he was at the end of his straw, all the terrible things he’s done, finally caught up and he realized now at the end he’s lost so much because of his hatred and these things he’s done. So in a final act to regain some semblance of the peace he once knew, he ask for forgiveness from a once enemy, the enemy that has done the same things, the enemy that knows him perhaps quite well because of the same terrible things they’ve done. Because in a world of unjust sometimes maybe only an enemy can understand and forgive you. Because at the end we all die and as Broker put it meet our due, hatred should be the last thing we leave with. This scene was heartbreaking.
CheetoThief yes we all die and to die right we need this forgiveness and just , he found found his patch at the end , you have to learn it all thru your life to know at end , no regrets, see you again one day
I believe many veterans from Vietnam and after would be feeling the same
Wise words... wise words... thank you
Brilliant analysis cheetoThief 👌👌
Well said
This scene is gold.
As the movie is....
I am a veteran of Afghanistan. This is one of the most honest and truthful scenes I have ever watched. This scene says it better than I could possible say it myself.
Thanks for what you did brother. Anyone who signed up, went to MEPS, and served has my respect. I wasn’t combat oriented, but I was a flight line airman in the AF. I worked a special detail in which I helped transport HRs (human remains) of our fallen soldiers, marines, airmen, and sailors while I was deployed to AUAB. I always researched each one to learn about them. I’ll never forget draping the flag over the caskets of the fallen and lifting them up into the aircraft to start their journey home. I’ll never forget the weight… and the experience. The guilt of being alive coming home to my family. I dedicate my life for our fallen brothers and sisters. Please take care sir.
@@hollytree3379 You’re talking about the actions of a government. I’m talking about his individual service. I was in for 10 years and was part of many humanitarian missions and relief efforts for countries needing it (such as Japan during their nuclear crisis). Don’t be so closed minded. Afghanistan wasn’t the only military operation we have/had.
@@hollytree3379 I agree that Afghanistans war was not entirely to “stay free”, but when people thank others for their service it’s about the individual who volunteered to sign up and protect his country. There’s many vets and soldiers against the wars in the Middle East.
@@scott8908 so much cope.
@@deontaywallaceescalade Simple minded people use the word “cope” when they can’t make a counter argument or rebuttal. It’s easier to use an overused word that sums up your lack of knowledgeable then it is to have an intellectual conversation.
The scene were they find his body and Joe breaks down 😭😭
Imagine having PTSD, in a time when no one knew what PTSD was.
*I don't feel anything*
What a phenomenal Film
Have mercy on us....
I just caught that he uses the past tense "you've been a good friend Joe"....he is already gone in his thoughts.
My goodness my heart broke for him when he says "I dont feel anything" anyone who's ever dealt with depression and PTSD understands this like no other, and our mistreatment of the natives alongside slavery was a self inflicted wound that has never and will never heal ... his character illustrates why we as humans while we are capable of so much evil, we are meant to love and create love not hate
It's fucking heart breaking ... I've had to fight similar demons, not nearly as bad as this.... but seeing it in another man's eyes is absolutely soul crushing (even when it's just acting). I may wish violence upon truly evil people, but I don't wish THIS on anyone.
Well that's stupid, he chose to kill those innocent people. I feel no remorse for someone with depression/PTSD when they commit crimes against humanity.
@@saeedvazirian we are talking about a fictional soldier from over a century ago, the concept of crimes against humanity did not exist. What he did was immoral, but also what he was ordered to do as a soldier ... so it may have been voluntary, but he did not necessarily have a choice. If you don't follow orders back then, you get shot.
@@cross-eyedraven5651 yes it did, because the movie was made now. Civilians didn't enjoy getting killed a century ago. Crimes against humanity aren't wrong because they're illegal but because they're immoral. We decided the Nazi high command committed crimes against humanity after the fact, nit during or before it.
@@cross-eyedraven5651 nope, he had no obligation killing civilians. Either way, how's getting shot worse than killing civilians.
This whole movie is just epic. So well acted, directed and filmed. Good wins in the end, but there is no joy in the victory.
"I dont feel anything" true numbness, people say they dont want to feel pain but if you're ever at this level....all you want to do is feel and you cant even cry or yell, speaking physically hurts, and you cant even fake emotions anymore. Your face starts to feel like useless skin and your body doesnt listen to you anymore because moving or performing any action fills your mind with "why?" And complete hatred for moving for something you could care less about. Your mind is so focused on wanting to feel but at the same time the controlling numbness keeps the phrase "for what?"
Anybody who feels this please talk to someone, you can snap out of it, trust me! Anyone, talk, yell, scream, you cant let that shit beat you.
Your words made me tear up. Explains me perfectly. I deal with depression and PTSD after two combat deployments to the Middle East. Alcohol seems to numb the pain, but it’s temporary.
@@scott8908 please sir, it won't hurt you to talk or speak up about it. I've never been through what you've been through but I was surprised how easy it was to say something, I didnt like the whole therapist set up or anything but the more you work on expressing shit to break free from this infection you hate or love, it becomes manageable, it won't go away but it becomes manageable and you start to see the light and the better in things. You'll find your way sir.....please don't give up.
@@scott8908 holy shit!
@@scott8908 I'd be lying if i told you that my prayers go to you, since im not religious. All i can say is, thank you for your service, I'm sorry; i can't imagine going thru what you went through. I wish you find peace within, and to look at the positive aspects of life that define what it is to be human, because although you will never forget what you saw, you can be forgiven and find something to keep you going, rather than to be forsaken for the rest of your days.
This movie is has amazing acting, i had tears in my eyes with this scene
One single shot of rory cochrane lifted the whole film into next level -His eyes carry an ocean of sensibilities and possibly single take !
I really struggle not to cry on this scene...
This scene hit straight to my heart. Shed a tear...
Superb acting from Rory Cochrane, war leaves wounds that don't heal
Hard to believe that actor is Slater from Dazed and Confused. He was also really good in Oculus.
And Black Mass
I cried in this scene, and pressed rewind a few times to experience the feeling
I cried when you didn't give me your phone number.
This part of the film moves me the most as a
Native American. His small offering of tobacco was more than enough to heal the divide he felt and the suffering he caused and bore. That symbolism runs deep in Indian culture. It's sad that he ended up taking his own life.
He was an empty man, nothing more to give. Such great movie
He could not forgive himself for what he had done. The chief? He looked ready to forgive the man to avoid more suffering (and bloodshed) but realized that the man was beyond saving.
Unfortunately PTSD doesn't become recognized till WWII and before that and even then the "treatment" was to just get back into the combat. Idea was that the PTSD wasn't experienced during but after, so as long as you were in the middle of it you weren't suffering from it.
Square your shoulders, face the problem, and lean in to it was the treatment.
It was recognized during WWI, it was just called "shell shock".
@@AMS-my3ec Shell shock is not the same as PTSD. It was treated vastly differently.
"They took my guns Joe" Early in the movie when Cochrane said that, the way he said it, I knew he was gonna be a standout in this movie. He was brilliant. And then this scene confirmed it all
never seen a scene so powerful .
This movie is so underrated. And Rory should have won an Oscar for this.
How he didn't is beyond me
PTSD he said at the beginning of the film he had melancholy which was PTSD. Those soldiers that faught in the civil war then in the Indian wars seen some horrible things but when they fought the Indians they really seen the horrors of battle leaving both sides to commiting atrocities beyond our imagination. Yes our country is young but it's so rich with history already. Also I like the part where he says it's freezing out here and the other guys says I don't feel anything. The acting was great by him, you can truly see in his eyes his demeanor from the beginning that he's a man truly broken from the things he's done and seen in life. great movie so underrated.
I dont feel anything.....just so powerful, just shows that we move by the emotions if that is gone, we are gone.....
"I don't feel anything."
“ I don’t feel anything” damm that hurts.
This scene make me watch the movie over & over again. The pain that we can't explain in our life is showing here clearly in this scene.
Rory got 100%
For him Its Ptsd + Depression right ? Because i surely often feel completely "empty" and i can't put a word on this feeling...
this is so pure, every now and then i come back to this and cry watching it... cry and laughter are the purest emotions..
That look at the end....
I can honestly say this is possibly the greatest film based on real times/events I've ever seen..
That look at the end.. absolutely kills me, the guy who plays him stole the movie..
Damn...this is such a sincere scene. Finally deciding to let go of that life the only way possible... So much said with so few words.
I only have one thing to say. This movie is a piece of art.
At that moment Metz was completely broken.
It's such a beautiful and tragic scene. Rorys body language is perfect. When he speaks to Yellow Hawk, he doesn't say sorry. He knows it's meaningless. He simply acknowledges how wrong they were and begs for mercy. It's an immensely powerful moment.
i broke down watching this scene. those words send chills down my spine, how real and terrible the things we did to the natives back then, almoat wiped them from history...this movie captures that so well
Yes, same here. He is absolutely war torn... what happened to the Native American population was genocide and it is obviously a curse on his conscious as it is eating away at him. But, this isn't everything. Remember that in this movie, Sergeant Metz was also once a Confederate soldier in the Civil War.... and I would venture to guess that his "melancholia" (PTSD/Depression) was severally exacerbated or even stems from that war. Now add the Native American mistreatment, and you have a real recipe for disaster that you can clearly see in his eyes. Great performance by Rory Cochrane
@@cross-eyedraven5651 Who would've thought Slater from Dazed and Confused would ever play a role like this. Rory Cochrane has range, and this performance alone really made me tear up. When Christian Bale's character found him under the tree, its like he found his way out, by doing one last job: killing a former comrade who'd gone vigilant and committed heinous crimes. For me, this movie is a 10/10. Some people might say the pacing is a bit slow, but i dont give a fuck. This movie really tackles the idea of what it means to be human, and how it can affect the people around you.
I didn't know Rory Cochrane was slater. Huh the more ya know. 😂
@@the_henchman4268 he is good in Black Mass too w Johnny Depp
“We?”
I didn’t do shit
Seriously the most underrated movie of the last decade. A powerful tale about overcoming hate.
This brought me to tears!
🥺
What a great scene. Rory is a tremendous actor!
incredible acting
I saw this scene once and it never left my soul. Powerful stuff.
Worth pointing out how real this is. Thomas is haunted and destroyed by all the things he has done, not what has been done to him. He is a great solider, but also a man with a strong conscience and moral compass. A true warrior that was to honorable inside for all the things he was ordered to do.
As a western movie, I think this movie ranks up there (even higher) than Eastwood's Unforgiven in terms of the effect of killing and war does to people. Amazing moment
Rory Cochrane best performance
"I don't feel anything"
Having ptsd during that time must have been hell
You don’t even know what is happening to you
Others like you understand you but don’t know how to help you
Loneliness is your only friend
Rory Cochran is a fabulous, underrated actor. He always blows me away. First noticed him when he stood out in A Scanner Darkly. Been a big fan since. He was excellent in Black Mass too
a fantastic scene of asking for forgiveness
"have mercy on us"...man that's powerful stuff
it's despicable what happened to these people of any of the nations.
One of the most raw and real movies out of Hollywood in decades. Incredible acting. Every actor went deep into there roles. Powerful and profound.
Best movie I’ve ever seen. Metz character is so well done
"How we treated you in this life can not be forgiven, I offer you this as an apology. I wish to make peace with you in this life, for I know in the next we will be judged. Please have mercy on me, when we both meet our maker"
This reminds me of iraq vets so much. It's heartbreaking. I get it. Seriously underrated movie. Good noise.
The sandbox is no joke. I appreciate the Viet Vets. They didn't ask for it, and still pushed through. Some reception they received when they returned. Same goes for the Korean Vets.
this scene made me cry, the pain of a man weary of chaos !
The double meaning of what Tommy says to Joe - it absolutely breaks your heart.
The acting in this film is up there with the best I've ever seen. The sense of numbness in Tommy is palpable. His eyes alone tell you he's become lost and can't be found and that is why he had to 'move on'.
Takes the heart away
Experiencing this in the Cinema was heart breaking
everyone knew it existed we rarely spoke of it for centuries
I forgive him
this film is a reservoir of tears.
Forgive them, for they know not what they do
So sad. So real life. Amazing raw and real movie. No Hollywood showbiz here.
Very touching moment and truth speaking part of the movie. Let us not forget our past and how we have gained some much as a society, but by the destruction of others society. May God have Mery on us all.
I didn’t do shit
You can actually feel this guys pain when he says " I don't feel anything" heartbreaking
Christian Bale is awesome in this movie. You can see how much in pain he is. He's on the verge of losing it but just manages to keep it together.
Great scene, keep coming back to this one from time to time.
"Tommy! Get back here Tommy! Tommyyy!!" the scene when tommy runs on a horse.. Joe and I knew that he's gonna die doing something noble. So emotional!
Literally my favorite movie with the most deepest moving score
Now these feelings that resonate with the inner you can only be found in some movies, its truly very hard to create such a powerful scene full of remorse and a bit of guilt while having cold blooded killers as characters. Although the movie doesn’t show the past, the devastating wars between bale and wess studi the movie helps you imagine those brutal moments with words full of sorrow .Its not just shown in this one scene its shown in multiple scenes and the whole movie is filled with these beautiful scenes every scene stands out the most and gives you a better perspective over the past god its a great movie.
what a scene, so powerfull and sad, this film is a diamond.
This is a very emotional film.
Tommy, oh Tommy. My heart went out to you in this film. From the moment early on in this film, you mentioned to Joe you were not fit for duty as they said you had "the melancholia", I watched your character intently. I've struggled with it, too. And then this scene and the following scene made the tears spill from my own eyes, especially when you say "I don't feel anything." It's like that. The numbness overtakes you. It's real.
Scene blew me away
His breaking point was when the prisoner started making blocker feel guilty by bringing up the horrendous things they’ve done in the war , I believe tommy just felt that everything up to that point in his life became meaningless so the only good thing he can have was the closure of seeking forgiveness but also mercy from the natives especially the chief. Man this movie was heartbreaking and intense.
This scene hit so hard
One of the best scenes in movie history!!
Best movie of the last 25 yrs
"I don't feel anything'" you can hear it in his voice.
Been Across the pond multiples times to Iraq/Afghan. Now I’m retired and at the point where I’ve officially lost more friends after the wars than during them. I’ve watched this scene over and over and over. Sometimes it’s the thing we say, and sometimes it’s the things we don’t say. This scene says it all.
I cannot imagine ever going through this , but back in the day- no therapy, no counseling , no medications to help .
Thomas’ death was literally red dead redemption. He lived as bad man, but he died as a good man.
Chef-d'œuvre, ce film ne m'a pas laissé de marbre, du pure cinéma
This scene got to me. People always talk about the lasting pain of trauma, but rarely talk about the numbness. I remember what it was like to be so tired and spent you felt nothing at all anymore. You can’t sleep, food loses its taste, and you’re tired, but not in the saddle.
Out of the entire movie this particular scene stays with me. Those feelings men like these had are still the same feelings that you see almost everyday
masterpiece
The fact that’s Slater from Dazed and Confused shows his actual range of acting
As a Grown man, and a U.S. Army Veteran... I must admit, this Movie, and this scene brought me to tears.
Esau/Edom has always considered them, Savages When it has always been The U.S. Government, that has been The Savages.
Until you've served, and been out in Battle, and you see What these Government is Capable of...you will never Comprehend what is going on.
"You are a pale face/a ghost who speaks in forks tongue/snake tongue... You speak in Mendacites.
You say one thing, but do another..
That is how the Apache/Comanche thought of Whiteman.
Greatest Scene!
The horse neighing at second 20 is epic
Damn that’s deep
Scott cooper a real 1