Going Back to Pakistan: 70 Years After Partition | Witness
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ส.ค. 2017
- "Before I die, I want to go back to where I was born." Krishan Kumar Khanna grew up just outside Lahore, Pakistan's second-largest city. After a childhood he remembers fondly, his life changed dramatically in August 1947.
As Britain left the Indian subcontinent, colonial planners hastily split it into Hindu-majority India and Muslim-majority Pakistan.
Khanna was forced to join one of the largest migrations in human history, as sectarian violence erupted and millions fled in both directions to save their lives.
He has dreamed of going back ever since and, after trying for several years, Khanna finally obtained a visa to return to Pakistan.
Despite deep tensions, he's determined to show that people in the neighbouring nations still have much more in common than that which divides them.
More from Witness on: TH-cam - aje.io/witnessYT
Facebook - / ajwitness
Twitter - / ajwitness
Instagram - / ajwitness
Website - aljazeera.com/witness - บันเทิง
As a Pakistani I felt very emotional to see his story. Sir you are truly a person of a nobel character. Pakistan is yours too and you are welcomed here any time you want.
ahmedmujtaba007 but who will give her a assurety of not being killed or have to conversion...
ahmedmujtaba
,.At the time of partition those were your four fathers who killed Hindus and Sikhs living there....
Anuj ShrivastavaTM what about those families who were killed in Hindustan at the time of partition
right bro
Hey please contact me on this no. 9416976783.
I have to get some information for my grandfather. ahmedmujtaba007
A legend has said " if you see two group of same land fighting with eachother understand that a British has passed over from history".
Truth
Absolutely correct "Britishers divide a united land into a two country hindustan and pakistan.
Really true
Rishabh Aryan and left the kashmir issue unsorted so both the countries may fight , and the result can be seen today both the countries are left behind in economy and see their countries emerging into the sky
Exactly bro
I'm a Pakistani. I can't stop my tears and cried after watching this video.This video is so heart touching. The main cause of hatred and all the problems is Britishers i.e. their policy was divide peoples and rule over subcontinent. They fought the peoples for their occupency. And the hatred is continue yet that was aggravated by British government at that time. There were peace and prosperity before the British government occupation. ✨✨ Hope for the best ❤️
love from India...take care guys and stay happy...
Hatred among the religions was already there. They just ignited the fire. This too can be debated as a large mass of people demanded a partition based on religion.
Very positive thinking my brother stay blessed
It is heart touching emotion. Words cant express it. Partition makes wounds to both d countries. After 75 years still unable to meet each other. All because of terrorism. If it is not supported by military or others , all are eagarly waiting for my brothers, sisters and all. It is a dream to all
The Real Truth is British aside by USA need country which supports their interest in South Asia so they created Pakistan.
Throughout the story...my eyes were filled with tears listening to Bau Ji's emotions... made me recall, my mother used to tell me that in those days, my naana ji had to spend 3 days and 3 nights on a tree in fear of being killed from a mob chasing him on the way to home, then on 4th day a hindu gentleman and his famiiy came forward to help. They had hidden naanu's identity to save my naana ji....whosoever came in their house, they introduced my naana ji as their own son given with a name fake name of Aatma Ram. Few days later they dropped my naanu at home in dark. People never wanted divisions but Hunger of power and politics did so.
Ya bhai that's the toughest time for all
War only brings casualties and hatred ...
It's usually the greedy .. greedy for power & greedy for wealth ... & most politicians want at least one, but often both, even if they won't admit it. It's the rest of us who pay the price for their greed.
His body migrated from Pakistan 72 years ago, but his heart still resides there...
*India
All this pain caused by religion
@Ęxtřəmé Hűñteŕ brother , you have too much hate in your heart and the thing you need to realize is that,all this hatred never solved anything .
@Ęxtřəmé Hűñteŕ shut up ok Pakistan was not created on the base of any hateness against any religion including Hindu religion
@@mohammadtila7746 well said ..... Hatered never solves anything
This made me emotional.. my mom said that my grandpa was one of the people who helped his Hindu friends to cross the border and reach India safely.. never saw him but I m definitely proud of him
i didn't just happen to bump into an army
@@abeeeha Yes you did.. hiieee hehe
@@abeeeha Yar kamsekam idhar toh start nahin hojao 😑
I'll pray thanks for your grandpa.
@@HolyRamanRajya please do.. thank you ✨
Next time whenever any indian visits pakistan, come to my home, i would love to host you. love to all indians, those who love piece and want unity
@Lord Voldemort shut up soch soch ki baat hoti hai or pakistan 70 saal phle alag hua tha Hazrat-Ali-Jinnah ki wjh se nahi toh aaj agr hum or pakistan ek hote toh sabse takatwar country hoti
Hindu Muslim sikh isayi
Apas me hai bhai bhai ye toh media or politics ki wjh se drare badi ho gyi or rahi baat acche bure logo ki toh woh har jagah hote hai even India also or kisi ek ki wjh se hum poore desh ko judge nahi kar sakte...!
@Lord Voldemort mene kia kya hai afterall mene toh nahi kha unse ki esa karo...?🙄
@Lord Voldemort kya karungi jankar jo hona tha ho gya or wese bhi namse toh tum bhi British lagre ho 😂😂😂
Would love to meet u soon brother
@@shubhmadan100 ❤❤
9:42 " THE LAND IS THE SAME, THE PEOPLE ARE THE SAME " that line hit so hard. ❤❤ love to Pakistani and Indian friends 🇵🇰🤝🇮🇳
Yesss it’s like that song in veer Zara, my land is the same as your land 🥺
Love and Peace from INDIA ❤
"The hatred isn't between people,its between goverments" 🇮🇳💓🇵🇰
Well said
not now....Imran Khan wants to have peace with India
@@alraajbuilders6453 INSHAALLAH
@Rahul Singh Ppl like you never want peace!
@@lakshmikalluri5501 =)
I cried watching this video.. It made me remember my Dadaji who came from Dera Ismail Khan. He told us many stories of his city..
I grew up in Dera Ismail Khan! Greetings from this side of the border to you!
we love you as a human being
i live in faisalabad.. 3rd largest city of pakistan.
its famouse for thwe clothing.
Such a lovely story. She people of both sides get along.
Gaurav Kalra
Hi
A man who does not carry the history of the subcontinent only, but also the undivided love and harmony. May you live long, Krishna Sahib.
Bengali or Punjabi people knows the pain of partition.. my dad was from East Pakistan, now Bangladesh.. my dad always says about his village , his Home, the river behind his house, that pond, that tree, those plants.. I understand that he misses a lot but today I understood how much pain is still hidden in his heart.. I cried.. I am crying very much now.. uff it wass very terrible period that our ancestors spent.
Only 2 people are responsible for the whole historical disaster. 😭😭😭
Come to Bangladesh with your father. You're cordially welcome to Bangladesh 🇧🇩
@@al-aminfarazi7314 অবশ্যই যাবো। আমার অনেক দিনের ইচ্ছে। ❤️❤️❤️ ভালোবাসি বাংলাদেশ কে আমি। ❤️❤️❤️
@@asiandramafan2669 বাংলাদেশ আপনাকে সবসময় স্বাগত জানাবে। বাংলাদেশে আসলে আমাদের ঢাকা বিশ্ববিদ্যালয় থেকেও ঘুরে যাবেন।। আপনি এবং আপনার মত সবার জন্য ভালোবাসা রইলো।
@@al-aminfarazi7314 নিশ্চই। এশিয়ার অন্যতম বিখ্যাত বিশ্ববিদ্যালয় ❤️ ❤️
@@asiandramafan2669 didi chole ashun, I would love to host u❤️
I'm a Pakistani girl and whenever my grandmother would tell me about partition , tears would come out of her eyes as she lost a lot of her relatives during coming to Pakistan . She was a little girl when she came to Pakistan and became a doctor here . I'm really curious what was her homeland there in punjab . Unfortunately, she passed away on 10th March 2020 . May her soul rest in peace . (Ameen) This man is really a legend .
Hi ! I have heard that my family was from Hisar Tehsil Lali village .
Sorry but I don't know a lot about like Indian states but thanks for telling .
@@rajnigarg5920 Thanks for recommending . I would love to visit if I ever come there( inshallah) .
Why is he a legend? Did he say a word about Quaid? Na however he mentioned Nehru.
It’s a drama which is called a Hindu darama
@@sadiakhan7718 Jinnah was responsible for partition. That's why
Peace
"The hatred isn't between two peoples, its between the two Governments. Well said Sir👍
nope
Yes it was. But several times india wanted peaceful situations whether it was atalji in 1999 and this modi also tried ones but ur government . Pata nahi sala kis mitti ke bane hai vo Unko to military rule chaiye Jaise ki parveez mshrafff . Ur government 1st started war for the sake of power due to which people still suffer. NAHI mere galat to bhaut ho chuka hum logo ke beeech abhi to koi aashaa hi nahi lagti. FIR BHI AAAHS HAI HUM KABHI JUDENGE FUTURE ME. Abb kashmir ka aadnga hai hum logo ke beeche me . Jiski to puri sacchai me nahi janta lekin kashmir ke muddhe pe war sabase phele Pakistan ne hi start ki thi 1948 me. Kashmir thodi tuti futi history janni hai to desh bhakt karke nam se ek channel hai utube par search kar lena
Hatred is also between people
@@Ankit-rx5db no asa nahi ha hum kabi b larna nahi chahta ,sara pakistan peace chahta ha , media ko chor kr kabi khuli ankhu se dekhean k qasoor kis ka ha , kashmir ko azad ku nahi krta , hum usa b pk ma shamal nahi krna chahta hum bs ye chahta k wo azad ho jaen apni merzi se zindgi guzarean
@@Ankit-rx5db modi na kb koshish ki , ma nawaz shareef ko b sahi nahi kehta , but imran khan is first who i like as a leader , who is our voice in the world
It breaks my heart that he wanted to stay for two more days but couldn't.
I had tears watching this 😭I wish everyone thought like this old man. He might be old but he has a much forward thinking than most of the present generation people. I wish India and Pakistan was One today ❤️
@Real larka Apne pm ko bolo atankwad Kam Kare
@@anengineer152 tum pehle Modi Ko Bolo
Atankvad pe invest karna band kare
I also have d same dream. I think both d people are thinking d same and d emotion and affection is d same. God will send a hero for this like a hero in KGF movie
@@waheedkhanofficial5313 🤔 o esliye Pakistan Gray list mai hai
@@waheedkhanofficial5313 India me kaha hai athankvadi 🙄 kuch tho sharma karo bai
The only video that makes Indians and Pakistanis happy
Right 🤔😊
AGREE WITH YOU BROTHER.
No it doesn't makes me happy it makes to sad to see such good ppl HV faced so much
@@arundhatiroy5105 this is part of life my friend, there are ups and downs, there are some easy times and hard times but the best option is to always smile and be thankful to God. Love from Pakistan ❤
Include pawri video also
To everyone born decades later and behaving like a partition expert, it's very hard to understand the pain that people like this old man has gone through. Losing home, friends, family and living most of the life wondering what could've been. Everyone I know/knew from his generation has the same emotion.
As an honest and patriotic Indian, my sincere thanks to everyone in Pakistan for welcoming and making the trip happen for him.
Kaushal Singh feelings expressed in word
God bless you.
Kaushal Singh very well said bro
I agree with you 100%
man his eyes...
Kaushal Singh this is probably one of the most sensible comments I seen on this comments section
So much respect for Dada Ji....I hope he is fine and healthy...Lots of love for him from Pakistan
What a lovely man! I was so happy that he was able to see his old house and shop. He greeted everyone he met with smiles, good manners and an open mind, and the people treated him in the same way. It is wonderful to see.
He lives near my house. I've met him multiple times. Has a beautiful family. Golden man with a golden heart. ❤️
Kahan rehte hain yeh uncle ji, Please tell me. I want to meet him. Please give me full address.
@@Anonymous-br7lb Kaha rehne waale hain aap janab?
@@ashishgoyal47 Please contact me on wtsp 00966 5971 99 173
Nabeel Minhas
Brother Asheesh send me his fone number
WhatsApp etc
Thanks
00-92-315-2449182
Say my greetings
His younger brother didn't understand that his elder brother wasn't there to meet people or to see places....but to RE -LIVE those nostalgic memories that roam in his mind and subconscious .
I think he was more scared to stay another day there then re-living the childhood memories... Which I cannot say is completely wrong
@Truth Humanity yes he didn't wanted to.. He came for his brother
Sahana Biswas, our country is as safe as India nowadays so he really shouldn't worry that much
He said that because they have to renew the permission
@@1A_B_C1 yes that was also one of the reason.. But he was not enjoying like his elder brother was.. He even said he didn't wanted to come but he was coming for his brother... The wife of old man was scared too..
That baby and the old man hugging each other brought tears to my eyes. One has yet to experience how ugly the world can be, and is full of trust and hope, and the other has experience it all and is filled with despair.
As a history student from Northeast India, i have learnt about partition in the book . It's so sad for both sides . Pakistan and India are like brothers, fight every time but deep down we love each other no matter what 🫶🇮🇳🇵🇰 including Bangladesh 🇧🇩.
We are brothers with Bangladesh, not with Pakistan
The people you are calling brothers had demanded partition of India 🇮🇳. Even some friends of this gentleman
Only punjabi and bengali knows what really is partition!!
When your people are separated from you just because of religion.
~ punjab. india💛
Yeah.. True... I'm from Tamilnadu.. We too understand your felling... Because we have 5 million tamil relations in srilanka.. ❤❤
And Bengalis too
@@oscarivancordon1021 yeah bro
Yes, bro. we are bengali knows the pain.
Bengali here 😢
I cannot stopped my tears to see this story. I am a Pakistani. I love both Pakistanis and indians
Love from the India, brother♥️
Love from India 🇮🇳❤️
Love you
@@rahulchatterjee4386 you are right bro
..
One Pakistani group (4ppl) stole my heart with their love and care.i feel so blessed on meeting them.
Same story of my Grandpa he was born and grew up in India but after partition he was migrated to Pakistan 🇵🇰.He always talked about his own house in India that was so emotional for all of us to listenend him. May Allah grant him Janna (Ameen).
It's so emotional it reminds me my grandfather.
Please do visit your ancestor's place. Love and Peace from INDIA ❤
From where did he came?
He left coz He wanted a muslim homeland not because Hindus threw him out there's a difference
❤️❤️❤️
@@okaygaurav are u stupid? He had no choice and was forced to leave.
Scars of partition are not yet healed even after 74 years.
It cannot heal completely
"Gujranwala, Undivided India" - He is a living testimony of the history of the subcontinent ❤️
We were from gujranwala gujrat
I wonder if he is still alive.
*Indian subcontinent..
It touched me when he said
"Maybe I'll find some of my old friends" 😢
MLG Sonic may be all of his friends also migrated to india and living there
@GSB 144 hahaha
@@mansurian6403 his Muslim punjabi friends that stayed in Pakistan he's talking about
GSB 144 u look like one of a
mulla extremist lol 😂
toocharged 😮
"THE HATRED ISN'T BETWEEN PEOPLE, IT'S BETWEEN GOVERMENTS". SUCH A POWERFUL AND TRUE STATEMENT.
Loving greetings from Pakistan🇵🇰 to the great people of India🇮🇳, may Allah Almighty grant development and prosperity to both the countries🇵🇰❤️🇮🇳.
Shukriya bhai❤️❤️
This gentleman deserves dual citizenship his is full of joy.
Unfortunately there is no provision of dual citizenship in India and China...Only in these two countries...
Yashasvi Pachauri mai samjha nahi sorry
@Yashasvi Pachauri I know the meaning because I got two citizenship somali and British
Yashasvi Pachauri now I understood thank you
Totally agree bro❤️
This is one of the few comment sections on youtube where people talk like humans.
So true man
Because bhaqts don’t watch such video..
@@daviddulom8258 true 😆
Because BJP supporters ain't here
@@zay_kash better than Jaish e Mohammad, Lakshar e Qamar, Lakshar e Taiba, Taliban, ISIS, Al Qaeda supporters
He is diamond hearted person.... Watching this missing my dadaji a lot he was as cute as him.... Left us 4yr ago.... I still miss him a lot
I am proud to say that my grand father and his family lived happily with Hindu and Muslim in Pakistan before 47
His heart is more Pakistani then any other in Pakistan.
I wish he could stay a whole day and live like old days. Before partition.
Love to Him
Sorry mate, his heart is not Pakistani, it was India. He is visiting and remembering his past. Both countries were one.
@@nileshparmar987 : correct but see in his eyes bro and try to feel.
He wanted to stay there even after partition.
@@vinaypandey4752
If it's me, i feel the same way as he
I would like to stay. But did you see how his brothers were scared. It was past for him.
@@nileshparmar987 phir India Pakistan shuru ho gaya had hy wesy yar ye behes khatam ni hogi sari zindagi
@Hassan Ali :do you even after partition, Paksitan and India had train services. People from lahore would come in the evening to Amritsar, would watch bollywood film, and went back to lahore in the evening. But it was stopped after 1965 war. The problem was/is with your Pakistani Army. See, Bangladesh and India so much cordial relations. Due to Your Army, you people lost east Pakistan (now Bangladesh). ...Hum to aaj bhi kehte hai, jio aur jeene do. Jo ho gaya 1947 mein use badal to sakte nahi....Hum to us jagah nahi ja sakte, yahan Hamare Bhagat Sinhh, Rajguru and Sukhdev ji ko fansi di gayi thi. Lahore ke saath woh bhi chali gayi. Woh jail, yahan par krantikari jatinder nath das ji ne apne pran choode the, jab sab log hunger strike pe the. Sab se poojniye sathan hai woh, hum Indians ke liye. Chala gaya, lahore ke saath...pata nahi aap logo ne us jail ko salamt rakha hai, ja gira diya...India mein hoti,....to use roz poojte
This man Is a diamond. Last of a great generation.
I was not talking about allama Iqbal. But yes alot off people did die on both sides very sad.
@Ram Ohri Are you serious, then I can also say that your American president, Abraham Lincoln also killed alot of people, what a joker.
@Ram Ohri what a nonsense comment. You did not have mind, those who slaughter daughter they are criminal not Allama iqbal. On the basis of your theory - the one who made Gun are criminals because they are responsible for firing gun on innocent people. Please think 1 minute before comment on Allama iqbal
I agree this man is really diamond 💎 great thoughts.
I am British-Jamaican watching from London . My heart is sad for this old man. His brother has no empathy with him. I'm glad he saw the land of his birth and re-lived some good memories of his younger days. Bless him.
I cried during this whole video, people who never lived this can't understand that pain which this dadaji has inside. Really Salute to this legend 🙌
Same language
Same people
I am from Pakistan 🇵🇰 and I in my entire life never saw hate for any Indian from Pakistan.
We respect Indians.
Same here brother
Same genetics, same food, same everything
Imagine something like a European union in the sub continent
We Know How Much You Love
And a lot of Pakistanis speak Punjabi, which I speak at home with my family
Mitti vi eko ji bande vi eko je
Idk why I'm crying while I see this. He is one of us. You are us. This man is like my grandfather and he speaks just like my grandfather who left India in 1947 and has the same feelings for India.
My grand paa just died a few days back at 104 .
Love from Lahore pakistan.
Pls come wth him",yaaahan bhi wahi sham hei wahi sabera,jaisa desh hei tera waisa desh hei mera,"... A lot of rspct and love fr ur grandfather frm india..❤️ dont believe the media and politicians...
Muscle 101 Love from India.
Love from India ♥️
Come to India and visit your places. You are very very welcome.
@@akarshsingh8404 Guru nanak sahib temple is also in Pakistan . Why dont you call your religion,s head " aatankwadi" ???
Anyway Grow up Akrash singh .. Dont go with media & politicians ...
His love for Pakistan is so great, I'm sure it will break everyone's heart. His love goes further than borders.
He is not love pak love his home land
S we love all nation because we are Indian..
He doesn't love pakistan lol
@@okaygaurav lol he loves his homeland and apparently, Pakistan is where his homeland was. use thy head
My grandparents migrated from village Bassi, state Patiala. Every time anyone narrated the story, they couldn't keep their tears. Now, no one of them is alive, but we have a lot of memories to cherish from our ancestors!!
there's a saying In Turkey
"If in the same pond two fish hate each other, rest assured the british were there"
Edit: thanks for so much likes
Then the two fish lacks wisdom, true education...
Well said.
Good point
@@neoalpha9996 😊
@@mustafamahendro7671 thanks
It feels so good to read lovable comments from both sides. Loads of love to beautiful people of India and Pakistan from Nepal.
Joshi in Nepal?
thanks jazakallah
@@shailabhagwat6356 yes there are two type of joshi 1 brahmin 2 Newari
Shaila Bhagwat Nepal nepalm......
@@shailabhagwat6356 ...not only joshi, almost all surname you can find there in nepal..like pandey, giri, tripathi, Rawat,rautela, Sharma,upadhya, pant,konwar, choudhury, negi,bista, Bhatt, pathak, etc even your title bhagawat.
This documentary is 4 years old. Hope grandpa is still in great health. Do any of you have any updates on this?
I dnt understand how can someone dislike this video.Partition have affected people on both the sides
Paid war mongers Kavita ignore them all
I am neither from pakistan nor from india but this brought tears in my eyes. The old man's passion, his little steps, the emotions!! Man! This is too good of a documentary. And yes, the partition did hurt many!
true dat by the search about hunza valley and swat valley you will know the truth
hunza valley and swat valley is the peace full area in Pakistan
Yes it did hurt brother.
Look at that warm smile on his face after discovering that no people will not hate him by the fact he is Indian, we can’t even imagine how this man must be feeling after seeing his birth place, 70 years is a heck of a time. Lots of love from Pakistan 🇵🇰
Asliyat me toh tum log humse bahut nafrat karte ho
Sheikhupura is my hometown, this is my old mohalla, my father actually studied in that school. I have read and heard alot about the history of the subcontinent but seeing something so relatable, makes it very personal, i am pretty sure my grandfather would have known this man. I think stories like this actually show how tragic this was.
I would love to get in touch with this gentleman. His feelings are so pure. Lots of respect for you sir. I am Pakistan Canadian. My grandfater migrated with his whole family from Ludhyana to Lahore. Still my grandmother recalls her memories along with her house, neighbours, community and her childhood in Ludhyana. I am see spark in her eyes and joy on her while discussing her life in India.
The moment he said "mazhab nhi sikhata apas mein bair rakhna"
History cried on that
@suviram das but now the right wing Extremism is changing the perception fo hinduism in India
Muhammad Ismail Rowther ब्रिटिश भारत मे मुस्लिम लीग पार्टी के Madras Presidency के बड़े नेता थे, जिसका जन्म वर्तमान तमिलनाडु तिरुनेलवेली जिले में वर्ष 1896 में हुआ था। वर्ष 1918 में Majlis-ul-Ulama (Council of Islamic Scholars) की स्थापना में महत्वपूर्ण भूमिका निभाई और 1918 में ही मुस्लिम लीग पार्टी में शामिल हुए।
वर्ष 1945 में Muslim league party की Madras Unit के president बने। मुहम्मद अली जिन्ना ने Muslim league ने 1946 के provincial assemblies elections ब्रिटिश भारत के मुसलमानों के लिए अलग देश पाकिस्तान की मांग को पार्टी manifesto में रखते हुए लड़ा था। वर्ष 1946 के provincial assemblies elections में मुहम्मद इस्माइल ने मुस्लिम लीग पार्टी की Madras Unit का president रहते मुहम्मद अली जिन्ना को मद्रास प्रेसीडेंसी की सभी मुस्लिम रिजर्व 28 सीटें जिताकर दी थी ताकि जिन्ना अलग इस्लामिक देश पाकिस्तान बना सके। 14 अगस्त 1947 को पाकिस्तान बन गया लेकिन आपने आज तक एक भी मद्रासी मूल का पाकिस्तानी नहीं देखा होगा क्योंकि जिस मोहम्मद इस्माइल ने 1946 में जिन्ना को मद्रास में विजय दिलाई वो ना तो खुद पाकिस्तान गए, ना उनके कहने पर 1946 में जिन्ना की पार्टी मुस्लिम लीग को वोट देने वाला उनका कोई समर्थक।
तो अब सवाल ये है कि ब्रिटिश भारत के मुसलमानों के लिए नया देश पाकिस्तान बनवाने के बाद पाकिस्तान नही जाकर मोहम्मद इस्माइल ने भारत में रह कर क्या किया। मोहम्मद इस्माइल ने 10 मार्च 1948 में एक नई पार्टी बनाई और उसका नाम रखा Indian Union Muslim League (IUML) और स्वतंत्र हिन्दू (गैर-मुस्लिम) बहुल भारत को ही अब दूसरा पाकिस्तान बनाने के काम में जुट गए। वह 1946 से 1952 तक मद्रास स्टेट provincial असेंबली के सदस्य रहे तथा इसी बीच 1948 में उन्हें मद्रास से Indian Constituent Assembly का सदस्य भी निर्वाचित किया गया। Indian Constituent Assembly (In the chairmanship of Dr. Bhimrao Ambedkar) 1947 से 13 मई 1952 तक स्वतंत्र भारत की प्रथम parliament के तौर पर प्रथम लोकसभा निवार्चित होने तक काम करती रही।
मुहम्मद इस्माइल को मद्रास प्रेसीडेंसी से Indian Constituent Assembly का सदस्य चुना गया। स्वतंत्र भारत में प्रथम लोकसभा एवं विधानसभा चुनावों के उपरांत वे 1952 से 1958 तक Indian Union Muslim League की ओर से राज्यसभा सांसद रहे। राज्यसभा सदस्य रहते हुए वे मुस्लिम शरिया law (Muslim personnel laws) को बनाये रखने की वकालत करते रहे, जिसके कारण आज तक हिन्दू (सिख, बोध, जैन भी शामिल), क्रिस्चियन तथा पारसी धर्म की तरह भारत मे Muslim Code bills नही बन सके। Even today also, The Indian Union Muslim League (IUML) opposes the Child Marriage Act on the grounds that it contravenes the Muslim personal law.
वर्ष 1956 के State Reorganisation Act के बाद भाषायी आधार पर केरल एवं तमिलनाडु राज्य बने। केरल के नए राज्य के रूप में अस्तित्व में आने के बाद मद्रास राज्य की मुस्लिम बहुलता केरल की ओर चली गयी, इसलिए मुहम्मद इस्माइल ने IUML की आगे की राजनीति भी केरल राज्य से लड़नी चालू कर दी। और 1962, 1967 तथा 1971 के लोकसभा चुनावों में उत्तर केरल (मालाबार अंचल) के मुस्लिम बहुल क्षेत्र Malappuram (Manjeri) constituency से जीत हासिल कर तीन बार लोकसभा सांसद बने। लेकिन 5 अप्रैल 1972 को लोकसभा सांसद रहते हुए उसकी मृत्यु हो गयी। आज भी उत्तर केरल के malappuram, Wayanad, Kozhikode, Kannur, Kasarkode, Palakkad आदि जिलों में मुस्लिम बहुलता के कारण IUML पार्टी का अच्छा खासा प्रभाव है। तमिलनाडु तथा केरल के मुस्लिमो के बीच मुहम्मद इस्माइल को "Quaid-e-Millat" से सम्मानित कर पुकारा जाता है, जिस तरह पाकिस्तान में मुहम्मद अली जिन्ना को "Quaid-e-Azam" से सम्मानित कर पुकारा जाता है।
लेकिन सबसे बड़ी विडंबना यह है कि जिस कांग्रेस के खिलाफ 1940 के दशक में मुहम्मद इस्माइल, मुहम्मद अली जिन्ना के नेतृत्व में मुस्लिम लीग पार्टी की ओर से ब्रिटिश भारत के मुसलमानों के लिए अलग देश पाकिस्तान की मांग के एजेंडे पर लड़ रहे थे, आज उसी कांग्रेस के साथ मिलकर IUML के नेता केरल में चुनाव लड़ते हैं। साल 1946 के provincial assemblies elections में जिन्ना के साथ मिलकर पाकिस्तान बनवाने वाले मोहम्मद इस्माइल के सम्मान में भारत सरकार द्वारा वर्ष 1996 में डाक टिकट जारी किया। देश को विभाजित करने वालों का ऐसा सम्मान विश्व के किसी और देश ने नहीं किया होगा।
कल जो पार्टी जिन्ना को जीताकर पाकिस्तान बनाना चाहती थी, आज वो ही पार्टी राहुल गांधी को वायनाड से जीताकर पीएम बनाना चाहती है।
और हमें क्या बताया गया ?
केरल सबसे पढ़ा लिखा राज्य है, इसलिए लोग इतने समझदार हैं कि आज तक सांप्रदायिक पार्टी बीजेपी एक भी सीट नहीं जीत पाई।
ये किसी ने नहीं बताया कि पढ़-लिख कर liberal बनने का शौक एक ही कम्युनिटी को है, दूसरे तो आज भी अग्रेज़ों के जमाने की league बनाकर बैठे है किसी जिन्ना के इंतजार में...
What does it mean in English?
@@Art2Heart1234 , Unless you think about the reason for it, a nation has right to defend itself if you dont know.
@@gshrdy5415 I know a nation has a right to defend itself but that doesn't not mean that you have to spread hate against minorities
I can't believe this old man reached their school after 70 years
I think no more than Sikh people can relate this story from the heart .truly partition also divided Punjab in half and Sikh people cant go to Guru Ji's birth place.
I am 23 from india.. and i felt emotional.. i always want to visit pakistan once in my lifetime. Love from india ♥️
iam from Pakistan rawalpindi after watching this video iam still crying plz no war just peace and love plz😥😥😥
Agree with u zeeshan malik
my grand father came from distt.ralwalpindi the town was known as dhala.
+Satwinder singh confirm karo bhai
Zeeshan Malik I m also crying bro
😥😥
When he cried at the park with happiness it was really touching. I wish both countries allowed more tourism based VISAs.
Imran khan had offered peace. But moodi declined. I would love to visit Hoshyarpur , where my parents came from. We want peace between two nations. Hatred will eat up both countries.
Imran Khan's offers of peace are just as good as China's. On one hand they say they want peace while on the other they will fund terrorism and insurgency. Neither Xinping nor any PM of Pakistan is to be ever trusted.
@@muhammedwasim8272 imran Khan himself doesn't know what he is doing
@@muhammedwasim8272 sorry but free terrorism with peace is not really a good offer. And we voted for Modi to reject such a worthless offer
The people that lost their lives in 26/11 don't think so
this is the most emotional thing I’ve seen
this man has a beautiful heart, he shares love for both sides, and it’s true “the hatred isn’t between the people but it’s between the governments” but the influence of the government changed peoples minds, I hope one day we can show love and care towards each other freely ❤️🇵🇰🇮🇳
The documentary shows that we love each other 💜
Hindu not welcome to Pakistan 👹👹👹👹👹👹👹👹👹👹👹
This made me cry... Y so much hatred... ?We all are same.... Same soil..same language...same people...
@@lavish_1717 you are very beautiful love you from india
Absolutely right
Lov from pak
Agreed Neha
So sweet to hear such peace-spreading statement especially when currently BJP is in power
No!we are not same.we are different and we will be....
When uncle cried, I cried too. 12:21
So much love from India. 🇵🇰💝🇮🇳
Notice, no Indian, no Pakistani, kitni izzat sy uncle ji keh rhe hain. 12:21
Yes...Behadd pyar hai logo mei hamesha.
I wish ki jaldi hi India Pakistan ke relations acche hojaye, aur log ek duusre se mil sake.
Nd love from pakistan too💗
@@Bajrang.707 Allah kary aesa hi ho lekin ye namumkin hai...q k Indian leadership aesa ni chahti.... jb tk Inian media daily base py 8,10 terorrist imaginary mar ni deta Pakistan sy onhen sakoon ni aata ...apka media hate barha raha hai....... Or Mashallah Government b elections k time AntiPakistan formula na use to kesy vote hassil kry ?........Pray for your country.....I also belong to GurdasPur my grandparents were from FerozPur i want to visit India ....but indian terorrist will never happen this.... we just want to see happy both sides
@@damselgoals8532 Sarkaare toh sabhi ek jaisi hoti hai...
Aur rahi baat media ki...toh aaj ki media par log vaise bhi bhaut kam dhyan dete hai.
Logo mei bas pyar bane rehna chahiye.
Important ye hai bas.
Hum sab pehle insaan hai... bhai behen hai, dost hai....pyar se rehna hai....ek dusre ki respect ke sath rehna hai....har religion ki respect karni hai equally.
Aur dunia mei jo burai hai uska ek saath saamna karna hai.
🇮🇳💝🇵🇰
Mil sakenge hum sab ek dusre se....rabb par bharosa rakho....😊
Man.. this uncle made me emotional.😔
I wish everyone could live together with peace and love.
"One day this nations will be united into one!", I'm into tears!🇮🇳🇧🇩🇵🇰
~Love from Present INDIA🇮🇳💖
oh hello no please no we Pakistanis don't want to be massacred by bjp and rss.....get rid of your right wing hindus then talk about this
We are happy as an independent nation. So keep dreaming the union of India and Pakistan
Kya bol rha hai yaar… half illiterate Pakistanis out of 3 generations worth of madrassah chaap propaganda… why would you want to give them Indian passports and citizenships…. See what joke they are in the world now .. let them carry on their self destructive path… don’t bother them when they are destroying themselves with such efficiency
@@burwayes For the first time in my life I'm agreeing a Pakistani.
*Divided by Politics*
*United by TH-cam*
divided by borders
united by people
By RELIGION
❤️
very wrong. just check any other video that goes a little against either of the countries.
partition hona hi nahi chahiye tha
The moment when the Pakistani holds the hand of Hindustani n showing his school was magnificent ❤
My Nana Abu (late) always got into tears while talking about partition... His city was Jalandhar... He used to recall those beautiful days of his life.... Unfortunately he couldn't visit his city and village...
Sir, do you believe in 2 nation theory. And if you do then why your nana abbu used to miss jalandhar. He might have many hindu friends here.
I’m from JALANDHAR
My grandfather used to send a horse rider to buy pastries from a famous bakery in Lahore until the border closed after 1965 war…. There wasn’t any visa required also … but then some genius Pakistani general decided to launch operation Grand Slam and other such nonsense to test our military’s mettle … so you know who to blame for now hard borders between Pakistan and india …?
I cried so much after watching this story and I love this uncle he is kind heart and very sensitive person 😢😢
I was literally crying. No one No one should displace from their homeland where they born irrespective of any religion or caste or politics. whether Palestine, Kashmiri Pandit or any. May God/Allah/Ishwar bless you dadaji
Islam spreads terror which is what it shown all thru out history and during partition. Kuran is a violent terror manual. Stop following a terrorist mass murderer who raped nine year old girls and married dozens of women including his own daughter in law. there should be an end to this madness cult called islam
@@panirajn im ex hindu and want to tell you that islam is way more better than your hinduism
😭 a Muslim talking about kashmiri pandit you know you're gem.
@@sasmitvaidya3594 your the biggest fool I have ever seen. Terrorism with Islam??r u talking about politics with Islam ??
@@khalidmahmood858 says a mohammadpuri bnp & hifazat supporter haha
No partition meant:
No Kashmir issue
No terrorism in India
No border tension
No Indo Pak wars and blood shed
Economic well being
Huge dominance on South East Asia
Best cricketing team in the world
No poverty
Massive development
As lot of money will be saved from defence .
Probably whole world would listen to that undivided india
"No terrorism in India" as if you are implying Pakistan is responsible for the terrorists... No wonder partition took place because of people with mentality like yours and the British gave such a partition that the hatred is ongoing.
@@PrechtGaebolgHades wow..so u meant to say that India is responsible for terrorists in India n world..Dawood,Hafiz Saeed ,Masood Azhar Osama to Indians ha na..JeM lashkar, ye sb to indian organization ha..India m hi bkchodi krte rehte ha..26/11 to Karachi pe hua tha aur pulwama to pok pe right??
@@ujjwalkumarsingh812 I'm glad partition happened.
No partition would mean no terrorism in Pakistan. Pakistan has captured multiple Indian spies.
My grandmother was born in Amritsar, she died before I was born, but my mom tells me that she always wanted to go see where she was born. This video brought tears to my eyes, I wish I could have helped Mr. Khanna to make his trip easier.
Most welcome SIR .....We welcome more Indains. PAK IND LONG LIVE
LOVE FROM PAKISTAN
We Bangladeshis, Indians and Pakistanis are made from same blood and mud and by the same creator. Media and governments’ hatred, greed and gossip has made this sub-continent divide into three countries (1947 & 1971).
🙏 💜 kind words .
British also had a big hand in it.
Absolutely Ferdous we have lot many things common and we All love each other
Sahi bole bhai
Can I say something ? Please don't mind I always had a wish to say this to Bangladeshi and I am an Indian bangali ,"Amar Sonar Bangla ami tomay valobashi"
I'm 27 years old, I left my school 10 years ago and I stll get emotional when I see my school and touch their wall. Basically I'm saying I can feel his emotions when He reached his school after 74 years. I can't describe that feelings in words. Salute to u sir.😰😰😰😰
I feel sad about about dadaji can't get her old friends and old people love from NEPAL DADAJI❤️❤️❤️❤️🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
imagine the same subcontinent was today, living together with peace, love ,and harmony. what a powerful nuclear state it would have been with 1.8 billion population.
Mr. Krishan Khanna has a very warm , non- judgmental personality ; a winning attitude - a precious soul.
I'm a Pakistani, I got in tears after watching this video
I hope that he got back to his native country
It would be great if pak govt. host this old man a month trip to his native home🙏
@@AMANVerma-cp3pw If this kind man get popular on social media then he will definitely see Pakistan
Bhai native country kya pehele sab ek hi tha na ek hi desh tha
@@bikashranjannayak4211 han
But ab nahi hay na
@@bikashranjannayak4211 i think he/she means his birthplace...currently its in Pakistan...pehele toh saab he same tha..abb different ho gaya hai na bhai :(
"I want to stay 2 more days". I wish we were still one strong country.
When he said mera gar waha hein....😭😭💔 14:21 it hit very badly
True 😢
I Love all my Pakistan brothers & sisters...
Love from India... 🇮🇳
Love you too
Pkmkb
pramod malu thanks finally an Indian I’ve met that doesn’t want all islamists die
Love you too
Nikal mc katmulle pakistan
All Indians over 70 who have roots in Pak should have visa free entry in our Country , its their Birth right
I agree, dont you think India should apply the same... They wont even give visa for a funeral visit.. shame
@@symals same on both sides
@@symals The same country gives hundreds of special visas for urgent medical emergencies to Pakistani's every year on humanitarian grounds. Visiting visas are banned on both sides. You are talking like Pakistan is giving visas to Indians. For the betterment, work should be done on both sides.
@@nikmon3591 100s of visas on medical ground? Any statistical data to back that claim? Feel you are getting defensive and protective. There is no need for that, as this is a discussion and my comment of SHAME is at the system and situation, not any person... Btw You forgot to add cultural visa to artists lol.... But thats not the point. Point of discussion are "ordinary folks" millions with links on both sides, not artists not diplomats and not people with esp. circumstances... These people like this old grandpa are the victims.. and my grandma.. who passed at the age of 85 with wishes and dream to visit her ancestral haveli on the indian side...
Mr M.K yes and thank you
I was crying while watching because my mom was from Borishal Bangladesh, everything looks same, Lahore markets looks like old Delhi markets. I wish I could also visit there and can meet Fawad Khan, Sanam Baloach and all🙂👍🏻🙏🏻
Very emotional video
I originate from Shiekhupura ... brought tears in my eyes ... Pakistan and India are brothers please reconcile spread love ...
MAK KHAN my dadi ma is from Sheikhupura. She came to Delhi in 1947
Love from Mumbai, India.
Hate From India ... Die Pakistan die
But first you must back to Hinduism
Those who fed cows and those who fed on cows can't be brothers i guess
My Grandpa came from Amritsar, he told me many stories about his city
May ALLAH rest his soul in peace
I'm from Amritsar veere
Bhai visit India to live on the stories that your grandpa told you. We welcome you.
Love from India
There is no alla salla... Only one god.. I. E. Bagban+jesus+alla = one God...
AMEEN
Allah is not real, it was Muhammed his fabrication to get away with every crime. He was selfish and misleading. Too bad you believe in a ''religion'' that was created to serve Muhammed himself. Look how terrible islam is, at what it teaches and where stands for. Nothing more than a cult.
Let's boycott our governments!!! we love each other💞🌼❤️❤️❤️
This was a truly eye opening documentary. Absolutely amazing man!
Tears came out when he held the baby, and mum didn't know the background.Myself a son of an immigrant from Amritsir settled in Multan.Baba ji travelled for all of us.
I am from Serbia and dont have any conection with your part of world, but i was crying like a baby...
did you understand it ?
Even your country faced same kind of trauma at a point of time. Eventually India breaks into 3 and Yugoslavia breaks into 6.
I am from germany and it made me so sad to see the grandpa remembering all the pain and suffering he saw and lived through but it also made me so glad when he was greeted so happily and him enjoying it. Yes it doesnt have anything to do with me but i was very emotional.
Do you feel the same for people of Kosovo and Bosnia?
huge love for this, & thanks for making this
i cried the whole video..the feelings everyything was so pure
*To every Muslim who reads this , please understand this country does not hate you , do not allow the remarks and actions of* *the ignorant and hateful blind you from the love and compassion the majority will always have for you* .
*We are all one ❤*
*love you from india*
Akash netke ❤❤❤
Speak for yourself ! you do not & you will not represent India. Pakistan will fall. Dismembered & Depopulated.
Every where good and bad peoples.
Akash netke appreciated
We love all we stay united no matter what’s haters think .💚💚💚
This made me cry!
Love from BANGLADESH
yes, we are the same human being❤
@Hassan Ali I wish we were all one again with no fighting 😭😭😭
Thanks bro
السلام علیکم و رحمۃ اللہ .....
Ofcouese, My DEAR Muslim Brother, We Were : 1 , But Every HOme is to b divided untiill the New Ones are not Built) one day, even amongst the Real BROTHERS . Destiny ...
AL ARAB ISLAMIC MEDIA LAHORE , PAKISTAN !
*east Pakistan*
Religion divided us
I have never really felt emotional watching documentaries, but this one had me. Uncle ji I hope you felt better in your heart. To have been forced to leave the place of your childhood memories, i understand the pain. My grandparents and great grand father also left in haste and ran away and though he never wanted to go back since half his family got killed there ...we as family are still curious.
I was literally sobbing, it's painful, division brings sorrow. The longing n void people face is unspeakable. Dadaji God bless u n ur family, thk God u got a chance to visit ur birth place, many r not so fortunate enough to do so. Bless u .
This is so heart touching.
My parents were also from India who migrated to Pakistan during partition.
Welcome to Pakistan Sir! :')
what he says about india. Ask him to visit his birth palace he would love to see it. show him this video .. this may motivate him
Aisha Ahmed Assalamu walaikum...plz visit india one time with ur family ...Insha Allah u ll love india so much ....Tahe dil se Isteqbal h aapka Hindustan me...
Love from INDIA to your parents and all of you all
india main kahan se ??
Aisha Ahmed where from india
Just reminded me of my grandfather. He was Pakistani Sikh. He kept longing for Pakistan until end of his life. He was also from Shaikhupura. I just realised and felt tiny bit of his pain and grief. I swear, when I was growing up there wasn't even a single day when he didn't talk about Pakistan or mentioned something about Pakistan and his friends there. I couldn't stop crying throughout the whole video. Wish these two countries can become one once again and may we can see end of this hate in politics and media that keeps putting nails in the coffin of the love to bury it forever. Thanks Aljazeera.
im also from sheikhupura
Abhishek Singh m also frm gujranwala but humare bare kashmir se the....apne kia horrible stories sunien kindly tell me
Punjab should have never been divided. Horrible decision and it also destroyed Kashmir.
Amardeep Singh we welcome all with love but it is not possible neither desirable to reunite.. rather we shoshoud have better relation and live like Canada and usa or European union. That is the model we should follow
But that can only happen after the solution of kashmir dispute. It's really not in interest of India to delay this matter any long. It.will be good for the whole region and.all countries involved to get out of this mad war tensions and resources wasted on defence and offence machinery. Rather making open borders and friendly relations will allow for using that money for education and health care. Infrastructure development etc. Peace is the way forward.
Thank you for making this
So heart touching 😢😢