This is so utterly heartbreaking to watch because there seems to be no hope and perspective for these patients just because of society’s view towards the mentally ill and the role of women in this society! It shouldn’t have to be like this… I am so glad, being a woman I grew up in a western country!
Saddest documentary that I've ever watched. That the ones who are better are not able to go out and make an independent life for themselves reflects on the society and country.
Heartbreaking to watch that mother reject her adult daughter who wants to come home - what on earth is wrong with these people to be so horrible to others.
It feels so crazy to keep them there against their will. Dr. Shabana and Hira can totally manage their own livelihoods. Let the out! This is imprisoning them against their will.
I can understand your perspective, but an alone women in Pakistan is not safe. Even if they go out willingly they won't find any job at all to sustain themselves. And then end up on the streets , then the cycle continues. Even if it's hell this shelter it is still better then becoming homeless.
@@arson30 why a doctor cant have a job and survive on her own? Why the country is such a hell for women that they cant earn for themselves and live a respectful life?
Edhi has been a very legendary NGO in Pakistan 🇵🇰 for years. Their an all volunteer organization that serves Pakistan's most poorest and vulnerable members of society. I'm not sure but, I think the founder of Edhi was a wealthy elderly gentleman who gave ALL his wealth to serve humanity in his country. The motto is "Serving Humanity is the spirit of All Religions"..
he wasnt wealthy at first rather poor..he started his journey out by helping ppl in his village..afterwards when he accumulated wealth he distributed them amongst others iin need and his organization
Is it is so bad in the big cities, what is going on in the countryside? That Muslim culture, so family oriented and so respectful towards the old, and so orbiting around god, ets, etc (as they would want you to believe) is a simple shit-hole.
There should be better living conditions. Each woman should have her own room. Living in such conditions like hen's cages can worsen mental condition. Even a normal person can lose sanity.
This is very typical not only of some Muslim societies but, of a lot South Asian countries also. Sadly, women and girls are not valued the same as boys. Islam teaches that women have rights, the right to marry, or not marry. The right to property, to work, and have a education. Islam also teaches, women and girls, are to be loved and protected. Male and female are equal. But, as we see, time and time again religion fails. Or makes the issues worse. Corrupt Imams and scholars push the abuse of women and girls. Culture, and religion now have become interrelated. Pakistan 🇵🇰 you can do better than this. Muhammad Ali Jinnah is rolling in his grave. I can understand poor families doing this. But, shame on the wealthier ones doing this..
This is common practice around the world. women and girls are treated like objects. In the western world it's called pimping or polymy . I am surprised these girls are not used for organ transplants. I can't wait for the A.I. replacement. There are so many Young men around the world who want to transgender over to females. Female reproductive organs can transfer to a male. and A. I.microchip can be implanted to a male's brain. And there you have it a perfect woman!!!!
this is so sad, what kind of sick society is this treating woman as property ? life in jail because of depression :( no one does anything to change this madness
I have never watched anything so backward in my life...even the doctor's stuck in there!!! my heart aches for you all 😢 I am so so sorry you've got families like this...and I thought Americans were heartless...😪 many blessings to all of you and many many blessings to the staff...atleast you have this place...just don't ever give up..there's only hole you can't get out of..take care eachother 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Thank you for your comment. We're constantly working to improve our translations, please do specify (with timestamps, if possible) any potential errors. Thank you!
The whole society is poor that unable to take care of old, weak and disabilities. The government should open more caregiver jobs. Social welfare should provide assistance to families in need, then poor families would accept their loved ones.
its not about being poor its about treating woman like objects and if they have some mental illness even something like depression the family dont want them as its seen as something shameful they rather have them in a jail for the rest of there lives
Thank you very much for your support of the channel. Unfortunately, as a public broadcaster, we cannot give information about making a donation. However, you are free to search for the relevant party online.
@STICKY_ You can help by visiting Edhi Shelter home in Karachi Pakistan or donate online to Edhi Welfare Organization different methods are available to help them out..
Thank you for your comment. We're constantly working to improve our translations, please do specify (with timestamps, if possible) any potential errors. Thank you!
I'm from Pakistan and I didnt know this. But Pakistanis dont believe in ghosts and we dont have a word for ghost. We believe in jinns, so I'm not sure about that nickname.
May ALLAH SWT Grants you all Good Health and Strength and Keep you all in ALLAH SWT Safekeeping Ameen. I Love you all with the Love of ALLAH. Ameen ❤❤❤❤❤😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
Yes, but Only Muslims by religion. They are Indian by ethnicity. But muzlim by religion. Their own identity is questionable. They are maximum converts to Islam from the centuries old invasion of Muslim invaders
every Islamic country has a very dark side women are very oppressed even a doctor can't live and earn on her own.. Hira story is very sad and 1 women who try to live with her parents again but they didn't want her they need to change their way of living and get women more rights
This is the results if people dont prioritize education especially when marrying family members like cousins,mostly there are genitec problems,they dont believe in this matter but this is already the effects..so sad for this women..
This is so utterly heartbreaking to watch because there seems to be no hope and perspective for these patients just because of society’s view towards the mentally ill and the role of women in this society! It shouldn’t have to be like this… I am so glad, being a woman I grew up in a western country!
WATCH next: El Salvador: The coolest dictator in the world? - th-cam.com/video/9dl1EK5bqXI/w-d-xo.html
My tears couldn't stop watching this I cannot believe k ye sab bhi hot a hai shittt
This is so utterly heartbreaking to watch because there seems to be no hope and perspective for these patients just because of society’s view towards the mentally ill and the role of women in this society! It shouldn’t have to be like this… I am so glad, being a woman I grew up in a western country!
Saddest documentary that I've ever watched. That the ones who are better are not able to go out and make an independent life for themselves reflects on the society and country.
Heartbreaking to watch that mother reject her adult daughter who wants to come home - what on earth is wrong with these people to be so horrible to others.
It feels so crazy to keep them there against their will. Dr. Shabana and Hira can totally manage their own livelihoods. Let the out! This is imprisoning them against their will.
I can understand your perspective, but an alone women in Pakistan is not safe. Even if they go out willingly they won't find any job at all to sustain themselves. And then end up on the streets , then the cycle continues. Even if it's hell this shelter it is still better then becoming homeless.
Absolutely right. They can survive. But it's a prison!!
@@arson30 why a doctor cant have a job and survive on her own? Why the country is such a hell for women that they cant earn for themselves and live a respectful life?
Heart-breaking documentary😢
It is no measure of health to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society. Jiddu Krishnamurti
Ppl have no patience or tolerance left. No love. Only misery and the miserable are living together
my heart is just absolutely broken after watching this 😪
Edhi has been a very legendary NGO in Pakistan 🇵🇰 for years. Their an all volunteer organization that serves Pakistan's most poorest and vulnerable members of society. I'm not sure but, I think the founder of Edhi was a wealthy elderly gentleman who gave ALL his wealth to serve humanity in his country. The motto is "Serving Humanity is the spirit of All Religions"..
he wasnt wealthy at first rather poor..he started his journey out by helping ppl in his village..afterwards when he accumulated wealth he distributed them amongst others iin need and his organization
Is it is so bad in the big cities, what is going on in the countryside? That Muslim culture, so family oriented and so respectful towards the old, and so orbiting around god, ets, etc (as they would want you to believe) is a simple shit-hole.
Crazy that even the Police station isn't safe for girls/women 😖
There should be better living conditions. Each woman should have her own room. Living in such conditions like hen's cages can worsen mental condition. Even a normal person can lose sanity.
This is too sad, in muslim society they don’t teach and bring women to be independent on the contrary and they let them down
This is very typical not only of some Muslim societies but, of a lot South Asian countries also. Sadly, women and girls are not valued the same as boys. Islam teaches that women have rights, the right to marry, or not marry. The right to property, to work, and have a education. Islam also teaches, women and girls, are to be loved and protected. Male and female are equal. But, as we see, time and time again religion fails. Or makes the issues worse. Corrupt Imams and scholars push the abuse of women and girls. Culture, and religion now have become interrelated. Pakistan 🇵🇰 you can do better than this. Muhammad Ali Jinnah is rolling in his grave. I can understand poor families doing this. But, shame on the wealthier ones doing this..
This is common practice around the world. women and girls are treated like objects. In the western world it's called pimping or polymy . I am surprised these girls are not used for organ transplants. I can't wait for the A.I. replacement. There are so many Young men around the world who want to transgender over to females. Female reproductive organs can transfer to a male. and A. I.microchip can be implanted to a male's brain. And there you have it a perfect woman!!!!
In Islam women are nothing more than object
This saddest thing I never see why do they reject them 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 they should be ashamed of themselves
This video perfectly highlights the life of venerable women in Pakistan’s society
this is so sad, what kind of sick society is this treating woman as property ? life in jail because of depression :( no one does anything to change this madness
😢💔 Heartbreaking.
I have never watched anything so backward in my life...even the doctor's stuck in there!!! my heart aches for you all 😢 I am so so sorry you've got families like this...and I thought Americans were heartless...😪 many blessings to all of you and many many blessings to the staff...atleast you have this place...just don't ever give up..there's only hole you can't get out of..take care eachother 🙏🙏🙏🙏
the translation is so trash, the lady at the end said a woman has to be in her house or with a husband to be safe.
Thank you for your comment. We're constantly working to improve our translations, please do specify (with timestamps, if possible) any potential errors. Thank you!
Music therapy, physical exercises are crucial to regulate their emotions, cleanliness as well.
The whole society is poor that unable to take care of old, weak and disabilities. The government should open more caregiver jobs. Social welfare should provide assistance to families in need, then poor families would accept their loved ones.
its not about being poor its about treating woman like objects and if they have some mental illness even something like depression the family dont want them as its seen as something shameful they rather have them in a jail for the rest of there lives
The most saddest documentary I have ever watched. My heart is crying for Hira Mehfooz, Nazish, Najma & Dr Shabana life stories.
It moved my heart.
Does the doctor have a gofundme?? i’d like to help her!!
Thank you very much for your support of the channel. Unfortunately, as a public broadcaster, we cannot give information about making a donation. However, you are free to search for the relevant party online.
@STICKY_ You can help by visiting Edhi Shelter home in Karachi Pakistan or donate online to Edhi Welfare Organization different methods are available to help them out..
Nothing promising comes from Pakistan.
What story do u expect from shelter homes nd asylums
you don't have psychos in the other place ij the world؟
Also which country has a positive system and actually cares
😂😂🐂💩🇮🇳
Pauvres femmes. Que Dieu leur vienne en aide.
Tears in my eyes 😢
the subtitles are not accurate at all
Thank you for your comment. We're constantly working to improve our translations, please do specify (with timestamps, if possible) any potential errors. Thank you!
This is so sad 😥😥 it's heart breaking 😢...
Such a sad sad documentary! May Allah curse their relatives who have left them here to live a miserable life!
Feeling very sad for Doctor Shabana and Hira, they deserve their families love and support
YA ALLAH help them❤
Women are completely at the mercy of males in your country. The sooner you females understand that, the better it will be for you all. Thank you.
This what happens when you mix the same blood generation after generation .
Cannot watch this.
If they are rejected by their family release them out of that jail let them go search for jobs so that they survive 😢😢😢😢
I'm from Pakistan and I didnt know this. But Pakistanis dont believe in ghosts and we dont have a word for ghost. We believe in jinns, so I'm not sure about that nickname.
May ALLAH SWT Grants you all Good Health and Strength and Keep you all in ALLAH SWT Safekeeping Ameen. I Love you all with the Love of ALLAH. Ameen ❤❤❤❤❤😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
That one lady who's mom didt what her back really hit me , these ladys should be loved by there family not dumpt, this is very backwards thinking 😢😢
Happy I dont live in such a country.
i love pakistani women
I don’t get it
It’s poorly constructed
They work together break the walls and there ya go freedom
17:34 See what her mom clearly said? She doesn't want her daughter back as "she is of no use". There goes the freedom.
So Pakistan are Indians in another country 😮😮
Yes, but Only Muslims by religion. They are Indian by ethnicity. But muzlim by religion. Their own identity is questionable. They are maximum converts to Islam from the centuries old invasion of Muslim invaders
😢
every Islamic country has a very dark side women are very oppressed even a doctor can't live and earn on her own.. Hira story is very sad and 1 women who try to live with her parents again but they didn't want her they need to change their way of living and get women more rights
This is the results if people dont prioritize education especially when marrying family members like cousins,mostly there are genitec problems,they dont believe in this matter but this is already the effects..so sad for this women..
And This newly formed country is topmost in gender discrimination.
I literally don't trust these ngos and in this sort of situations It didn't seem hospital rather a place to make psychiatric patient
🥺😭😭😭😭
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏😭
Ye gharwale bhojpuri awadhi bol rhe Hain bich bich me?
ye India se migrated hein zuban tho wohee rehe gee
@@NasirKhan-bx8qv mtlb abhi bhi bolne wale log hain
@@rajasveersingh2569 jee apni zuban tho koi nahein booltha ,mazhab badlee ho saktha hey per sakafath badlee nahein ho sakthee
Stop marrying family members
This is so utterly heartbreaking to watch because there seems to be no hope and perspective for these patients just because of society’s view towards the mentally ill and the role of women in this society! It shouldn’t have to be like this… I am so glad, being a woman I grew up in a western country!