Sohyang's flat and sharp notes sound virtually the same because her perfectly balanced mix allows her to traverse the 5th octave easily to make the note closer to perfect than flat or sharp
I was waiting for the iconic flat D5 of Jessica Simpson from Take my breath away lol i love the concept of this video, for me it's a bit difficult to identify sharp notes, so i appreciate this. Thank you! Keep your amazing work
Bruh...you don't have to major in music to have an ear for music. A lot of that comes naturally to people. Do you have any idea how many Asian doctors there are in the world who are also classically trained musicians? One of them is so dedicated, he practices 40 hours a day and still manages to heal the sick.
Flat means that it isn't in the key of the song (below the diatonic note). The fact that she dodged the F#5 doesn't mean that it wasn't flat. The notes that she DID sing was definitely flat (the "answers" note)
i always thought i couldn't recognize flats/sharps unless it was very noticeable. with this video i found out that i can hear them, but my brain doesn't think it's wrong and just conclude that it was a stylistic choice. thanks for the video!
Thank you for making this video. I'm a 2 yr violin student (26 yrs old) and trying to identify when my playing is sharp or flat. For those commenting, all musicians are sharp or flat sometimes. It's not an insult to point it out, it's objective and it doesn't mean you're bad. 😊 Just means that the tone isn't vibrating at a specific pitch. All notes have a measurable pitch. As a beginning musician, it's sometimes difficult to tell exactly when I am sharp. I'm better at knowing when I'm playing flat. Having no frets is cool lol❤ Love you guys, happy listening!
Mariahs second note wasnt flat she just decided to improvise maybe in fear of not hitting the F#5 and went for the F5 instead she wss perfectly in pitch
The early singers (I didn’t listen much past them) were definitely not sharp. They chose to riff slightly, and would sing a half step, or sometimes more, above the original note. It’s very rare to accidentally sing too high, especially if you’re belting like they were (particularly Ariana Grande). The higher you sing, the more difficult it is to produce a note, at least in the upper registers. The flat notes were all in order, and are significantly more common than people might think. It’s very easy to underestimate how much -oomph- a will need.
If you're talking about One Last Time, Ariana Grande indeed sang a semitone higher than the diatonic note (A insteas of A flat). But since the song is in A flat major, it is considered to be sharp because it isn't in that key. The fact that you do it on purpose or go beyond the limits of the original song doesn't mean that you can't be off key, as demonstrated above.
That's because there is this weird phenomenon where slightly sharp (around 30-35 cents) sustained high belts can sound very good to our ears. In fact. some singers do this often (possibly on purpose). Cher did it in her final note of the US national anthem and I've even seen her do it in the studio version of a song (I can't remember the title though, but it's the one where she hits an E5)
i believe that some of this singers are having a bad day with those flats :) and some having so much adrenaline during sharps hahajaha and some are just natural inconsistent :))
Melodies are written on a particular tonality (meaning a succesion of sounds that makes sense/sounds pleasant), that's why it's important to sing natural, flat or sharp notes and not changing them, since it will sound disonant for any trained ear (admitedly, disonance sounds cool many times). Also sharp/flat are not interchangeable terms.
Some people went for Higher notes considered Sharp in term of vocal execution? And Mariah was improvising that "Answer" wasnt actually flat. Normally Sharp n Flat happens when they cnt control the notes not when you are chance the notes intentionally to your current vocal condition.
@@Maxon-x3t I’m talking about the Make It Happen performance. She didn’t phrase the F#5 in “you never find the answer”. Instead she opted for E5. It still fit the melody of the song well.
Honestly, there's a big problem with overproduced albums making the singer seem inhuman. Picking out individual notes from the hundreds of performances they've performed seems so nitpicky
I love how this person explained what a flat and a sharp is in like a minute but then there are videos that are like 10min long just trying to explain what a flat is like-
Mariah was not flat on that note, just raspy and did not attempt the F#5. Still phrased E5s tho. But she was sharp in the other clip, and also there is a „very” sharp F5 in that performance
# / sharp note - b / flat note = the original note the singer wanted to hit. 1:29 You’re safe, Taylor Swift. Hit whatever note you want in my order, and you get the original note. OR b / flat note + # / sharp note = 1 flat note and 1 sharp note - flat note = original note. Edit: The first, and last sentence was a math problem if you did not understand. Math = Music math”ish” problem
Kelly and Jessie are both sharp on their 'correct' pitches. And lol at Demi singing with no fucks given. She just goes for it when she wants, how she wants.
Raymond Tung the honeymoon tour version is a semitone higher then instead of a F5 she sung a F#5 she wasn’t sharp! She addes an A5 because in the studio version there is a G#5 then she replaced that in another place but it was an A5 (a semitone higher than G#5)
a bit confusing. a sharp is defined as being a half step above the natural note. a flat is just half step bellow. being sharp or being flat is above or bellow the pitch that is wanted. edit: after watching, a lot of these are just different notes that fit into the song. some of them are straight up out of tune but a lot of them are fine.
Almost everybody can have bad day.A lot of it comes from finding your happy medium with rehearsing.If you push your voice to hard for to long you can mess it up for the nights show.Its also possible if the audio equipment is not tune it can mess you up a little too..
If you don’t mind me asking, with Xtina the first note was a G6 and the second was an A6. Was the A6 just sharp or were you saying it was the wrong note?
@@fedsax9888 If I get it right sharp is a semi tone higher and flat a semi tone lower more than that it's just a different note and you are just pitchy
There is a profound difference between singing transposed (by a halftone for instance) and flat/sharp. Bach could tell you more about that. ;) Most of these performers sing with a variation or transposition that sounds perfectly in place. Others though, like 3:12, are just plain out of tune.
i don't if its just me, but i still don't get it. I mean you guys have good hearing ability to idetify if its flat or sharp. sometimes flats and sharps kinda sounds the same to me in this video
The first and the second clips of Xtina's song isn't the same song. The first one was What A Girl Wants (G6) , the second was Por Siempre Tu (the one you called sharp)
so, essentially, sharp notes are demonic screeching while flat notes just sound sad and depressing (but not in the "sad and depressing" way you'd call a sad song)
The first ariana and some of the clips isn't sharp or flat. Basically sharp is a condition when you want to sing E5 but you sang it a lil bit higher but doesn't high enough to be counted as F5. So you ended up hitting something between E5 amd F5 notes. Flat is similar with sharp. But flat is you hit a slightly lower notes from the notes you supposed to be hit. Sorry if my english is too hard to understand
A5 is not in the key of the song, so not diatonic. It's in the key of A flat major, so an A is sharp. You can't say it isn't off key because the singer does it on purpose.
Lmao Taylor swift is so random, in some performances she sings in 5 different keys. Hell that ain't no bad day that's being a bad vocalist and tone deaf lmaoo
Actually taylor is a very decent vocalist she sure as hell showed some improvements in her latest tour and her range is noticeably wider and she does some vibrato from time to time so she's reaaallly good and she has a musical coming so she probs had to take some vocal coaching
fA 13 yeah actually that is true, she is now being more vocally consistent, and she clearly has worked hard on her voice, but rewind a bit to when she used to sing in multiple keys and would either go sharp or flat (most likely flat), she still does that but she's improving, so I think we are going to be seeing a more respected Taylor when comes to singing, because right now she is still kinda seen as that little princess who can write good songs but not sing so good
I've seen so many vocal coaches react to Taylor and giving her credits for being a great singer. I don't understand why I shold listen to a hater like you than a knowledged vocal coach.
Isn't singing sharp and flat notes supposed to be out of tune and not off key? I thought off key is singing different notes that are not harmonious to the key the instrument plays. I feel that many times the phrases off key and out of tune are used as if they are the same thing
Can I put in a note here... Some bands tune their music down a semi tone live I see this allot with Rock and Metal Artists but could also apply to pop singers so basically they’re singing flat but it sounds okay because they’re tuned flat like for example check out Avril Lavigne’s song “I’m with you” on some live performances she sings it tuned 1 semi tone lower than the original because they tuned there instruments like that to accommodate her voice or save her voice but anyone can go off key while singing
Honestly tori kelly can make any sharp or flat sound amazing
Some of these are genuine flat/sharp notes, some are just when the artists decided to sing either a higher or lower note...
i think it’s the fact when they tried to go lower/higher they still weren’t on key
Ailee. she knew what she was doing
I also observed this some are just escalating and then labeled as sharps
Ik
Yes
this is possibly the only proof that sohyang is human
Dangerous Grande sohyang is a goddess, hard to believe she’s human ;))
@@kimah-ra4858 well shes a livin proof of what a human voice is able to do
@@arianavevo5280 stfu
She ain't human bruh
Nop, Sohyang is a excellent vocalist and all of you have to stop discrediting her saying she isn't human.
2:05 She immediately thought, "oh crap"!
Let me be your first reply.
Funny how the screen behind her showed "sorry" (intentional or not) :D
She just pushed her voice too much
Credits to her for not lip-syncing during whole career of singing
I would've been like "CUT THE MUSIC OFF.. IM GOING HOME."
2:20 Kelly was only having fun, she wasn't caring about the notes 😂
Plus it sounds reeeeal good
No matter what pitch, it’s still better than me. 😂😂😂
Marie Day i felt this in my throat
🤣🤣
ME TOO😂😂
Pitch or sing on tune like ur skin if ur skin is removed look very scarry so it is very important
hey don't do it
Sohyang's flat and sharp notes sound virtually the same because her perfectly balanced mix allows her to traverse the 5th octave easily to make the note closer to perfect than flat or sharp
Yeah and she almost never uses in ear monitors. Imagine being this consistent without hearing yourself!!
@@rebin_cgn1231 i think she has perfect pitch. So she knows what note she is singing without hearing it properly.
@@takemyhand1988 truly amazing in my opinion
Christina's 'correct' pitch G6 is from What A Girl Wants. Her 'sharp' A6 is from Por Siempre Tu. Different songs.
why is nobody talking about morissette? so beautiful
immissliss ikr her whistle is divine i caaaant
Yusss 😤
i love morrisette's belting tone, but her whistle sometimes heard are not fully controlled. but she's very talented
I was waiting for the iconic flat D5 of Jessica Simpson from Take my breath away lol i love the concept of this video, for me it's a bit difficult to identify sharp notes, so i appreciate this. Thank you! Keep your amazing work
veronica acosta yassssss i live for that one hahaha
I laughed in 5:37 because it was Correct pitch then goes flat lol
ROFL
Same lmao
I think that one was on purpose so that she could get out of the note without getting a voice crack because she probably started the note badly
5:52 jesus it scared me😭😂👏👌
Wow, cant believe everyone in the comment section of this video majored in music!
You don't have to major in music to know the difference between flat and on pitch.Taylor sings flat 90% of the time.
@@HeatherLorien38 tru
Julian I watch often videos like that and always l am asking myself the same question ! How they all know thoses technical things etc...
Mylena zvezta yup
Bruh...you don't have to major in music to have an ear for music. A lot of that comes naturally to people. Do you have any idea how many Asian doctors there are in the world who are also classically trained musicians? One of them is so dedicated, he practices 40 hours a day and still manages to heal the sick.
3:52 that wasn’t flat, she dodged the f#5
Period.
Flat means that it isn't in the key of the song (below the diatonic note). The fact that she dodged the F#5 doesn't mean that it wasn't flat. The notes that she DID sing was definitely flat (the "answers" note)
Hiy you mean the E5s?
@@hiy9846 she strains but is not flat. "ANSwer" is centered Eb5
@@hiy9846 No, she was not flat. She just sang different melody to dodge that F#5. But it was perfectly on key.
Morissette’s omg 😍😍
i always thought i couldn't recognize flats/sharps unless it was very noticeable. with this video i found out that i can hear them, but my brain doesn't think it's wrong and just conclude that it was a stylistic choice. thanks for the video!
Thank you for making this video. I'm a 2 yr violin student (26 yrs old) and trying to identify when my playing is sharp or flat.
For those commenting, all musicians are sharp or flat sometimes. It's not an insult to point it out, it's objective and it doesn't mean you're bad. 😊 Just means that the tone isn't vibrating at a specific pitch. All notes have a measurable pitch.
As a beginning musician, it's sometimes difficult to tell exactly when I am sharp. I'm better at knowing when I'm playing flat.
Having no frets is cool lol❤
Love you guys, happy listening!
5:21 Morissette's "flat" whistle sounds even better than her other performances. It sounded beautiful.
It was flat tho
@@mrs_bungle like you
Mariahs second note wasnt flat she just decided to improvise maybe in fear of not hitting the F#5 and went for the F5 instead
she wss perfectly in pitch
How you all know the note they sang !? I don't understand !
@@mylenazvezta8486 you can verify with a piano but there are really people who have perfect pitch and can identify the notes by themselves
@@mylenazvezta8486 Some people have a great ear.
Ok, but "ANSwer" is Eb5 and not F5. She sang Eb5 instead of F#5. I mean you don’t know what you’re hearing
right
The early singers (I didn’t listen much past them) were definitely not sharp. They chose to riff slightly, and would sing a half step, or sometimes more, above the original note. It’s very rare to accidentally sing too high, especially if you’re belting like they were (particularly Ariana Grande). The higher you sing, the more difficult it is to produce a note, at least in the upper registers. The flat notes were all in order, and are significantly more common than people might think. It’s very easy to underestimate how much -oomph- a will need.
If you're talking about One Last Time, Ariana Grande indeed sang a semitone higher than the diatonic note (A insteas of A flat). But since the song is in A flat major, it is considered to be sharp because it isn't in that key. The fact that you do it on purpose or go beyond the limits of the original song doesn't mean that you can't be off key, as demonstrated above.
Hiy she just raised the whole song by a semitone during her tour. That’s why it’s a A5 and not an Ab5.
Demi was just having a bad day when she hit that A5 in the AMA's
She has a lot of those
I mean, belting A5’s is not even a little easy.
And that's ok. Nobody is criticizing them. They're just giving examples of flats and sharps so that aspiring singers will know what they sound like
@@nymphohalo Credits to her for not lip-syncing during her whole career in singing
She has performed it nearly 80 times. She missed/dodged only around 10 times. The percentage is too low
Tori's sharp was so much better than the original
That's because there is this weird phenomenon where slightly sharp (around 30-35 cents) sustained high belts can sound very good to our ears. In fact. some singers do this often (possibly on purpose). Cher did it in her final note of the US national anthem and I've even seen her do it in the studio version of a song (I can't remember the title though, but it's the one where she hits an E5)
i believe that some of this singers are having a bad day with those flats :) and some having so much adrenaline during sharps hahajaha and some are just natural inconsistent :))
Rv Arrow not Taylor tho. She’s consistently off keys. Lol
Melodies are written on a particular tonality (meaning a succesion of sounds that makes sense/sounds pleasant), that's why it's important to sing natural, flat or sharp notes and not changing them, since it will sound disonant for any trained ear (admitedly, disonance sounds cool many times). Also sharp/flat are not interchangeable terms.
0:44 sounds like my kettle when my tea is done
Some people went for Higher notes considered Sharp in term of vocal execution? And Mariah was improvising that "Answer" wasnt actually flat. Normally Sharp n Flat happens when they cnt control the notes not when you are chance the notes intentionally to your current vocal condition.
heavenly So Hyang headvoice please 😍
Mariah wasn't flat, she just didn't sing the highest phrase. Instead she dodged going up
It wasn’t on key
@@Maxon-x3t I’m talking about the Make It Happen performance. She didn’t phrase the F#5 in “you never find the answer”. Instead she opted for E5. It still fit the melody of the song well.
Oh my what happened there JLo?!
4:55 how is someone’s voice even able to go that high 😳
Its a talent. A horrendous one, but a talent nonetheless.
SHE TURNED INTO A KETTLE
Sohyang's was different because she took the microphone out of her mouth before the treble ended. For me it was so much more beautiful.
This video proves that even great singers are only human.
Kelly was amazing I think she added a extra grindge to it
I was thinking well damn that's the whole genre of rock down the drain if that's considered bad singing
Morissette's amazing whistle note looks so easy for her even in sharp Haha 💓
Mariah sounds good to me even when she goes flat or sharp lol
Honestly, there's a big problem with overproduced albums making the singer seem inhuman. Picking out individual notes from the hundreds of performances they've performed seems so nitpicky
i don’t think mariah’s second attempt was flat, she purposefully dodged the F#5 bc she couldn’t hit it, plus the note wasn’t off key
Love Jessie ❤️ she can sing sharp or flat to me any day 😁
I love how this person explained what a flat and a sharp is in like a minute but then there are videos that are like 10min long just trying to explain what a flat is like-
Just think this. The note that need to be hit is a 1. Flat would be lower than 1, like 0.9. Sharp would be 1.1 or something like that.
Mariah was not flat on that note, just raspy and did not attempt the F#5. Still phrased E5s tho. But she was sharp in the other clip, and also there is a „very” sharp F5 in that performance
# / sharp note - b / flat note = the original note the singer wanted to hit. 1:29 You’re safe, Taylor Swift. Hit whatever note you want in my order, and you get the original note. OR b / flat note + # / sharp note = 1 flat note and 1 sharp note - flat note = original note.
Edit: The first, and last sentence was a math problem if you did not understand. Math = Music math”ish” problem
I love Morissette thank you for adding her in this video😊
Ariana grande was literally barely out of tune, I’m saying like one or two cents
The second one yes. But in the sharp note, she's really out
The way the Mariah flats&sharps still sounded good-
This just shows that they are human and make mistakes, which makes me feel way better about my aiming ability
The shade of jlo only being “correct pitch” for half a second omfg 💀
Kelly and Jessie are both sharp on their 'correct' pitches. And lol at Demi singing with no fucks given. She just goes for it when she wants, how she wants.
1:06 OMG ARIANA, IM NOT ARIANATOR BUT ARIANA SURPRISED ME.
I believe that Ariana's "One Last Time" as shown in the video is not sharp. She just added an A5.
Raymond Tung the honeymoon tour version is a semitone higher then instead of a F5 she sung a F#5 she wasn’t sharp! She addes an A5 because in the studio version there is a G#5 then she replaced that in another place but it was an A5 (a semitone higher than G#5)
Iosonoio Ebasta Same thing 😂
Searching this post hahaha its true
the F#5 did sound a tad sharp but that's about it
I still can’t hear the difference most of the times.... I’m just getting into singing and the techniques and I’m so confused by everything
Great video! I still have to give them credit. My voice would tire so fast if I attempted to hit half of those notes.
I'm proud of Gaga she's on key
3:53 wait i thought this is just mariah usually dodging the F#5? or this particular one is flat or something?
no this is just mariah dodging the F#5
a bit confusing. a sharp is defined as being a half step above the natural note. a flat is just half step bellow. being sharp or being flat is above or bellow the pitch that is wanted.
edit: after watching, a lot of these are just different notes that fit into the song. some of them are straight up out of tune but a lot of them are fine.
2:06 wtf
Cassidy Goya she didn't crack it was just hoarse
Is there a list of the names of these artist. I don’t know some towards the end of the video.
Almost everybody can have bad day.A lot of it comes from finding your happy medium with rehearsing.If you push your voice to hard for to long you can mess it up for the nights show.Its also possible if the audio equipment is not tune it can mess you up a little too..
Mariah’s flats are still better than literally everyone else’s correct pitches lol
Jlo can't even sing her hit xD
Omg wat about shakira
Lets shut uuuuuuuupppppp
@@herewego9352 Shakira actually has perfect pitch. She can sing. Her tone maybe be weird. But she can actually sing on key.
What is the first performance from sohyang?
Murilo Santos running in the sky
dario sassaroli thanks
No Beyoncé?
- I'am Not suprised. lol
Morissette is 😍
I feel like Ariana's one last time performance was not sharp at all😕
It was definitely sharp at the end. But the flat one is a little more close to the correct pitch.
Can i ask something? If we can say that the singer will go flat or sharp without music instruments? Sorry for my english.
Mariah is so perfect, omg
If you don’t mind me asking, with Xtina the first note was a G6 and the second was an A6. Was the A6 just sharp or were you saying it was the wrong note?
In the second clip the pitch was higher than the pitch she should have hit =sharp :)
FeDsax98 but she was singing a totally different song.
Justin Metcalfe No, both were What A Girl Wants
Lichy Guevara Actually in the second clip (G#6) she is singing Por Siempre Tu (Spanish version of “I Turn to You”), not What A Girl Wants
@@fedsax9888 If I get it right sharp is a semi tone higher and flat a semi tone lower more than that it's just a different note and you are just pitchy
There is a profound difference between singing transposed (by a halftone for instance) and flat/sharp. Bach could tell you more about that. ;)
Most of these performers sing with a variation or transposition that sounds perfectly in place. Others though, like 3:12, are just plain out of tune.
2:04 thats just a vocal fail not flat.
exactly
What song was sohyang singing
Last one for jessie it wasnt a flat .. the key of the song is lower so that she hit a G5
i don't if its just me, but i still don't get it. I mean you guys have good hearing ability to idetify if its flat or sharp. sometimes flats and sharps kinda sounds the same to me in this video
Me too lol 😂
Oh my God, Jessie J was totally AMAZING, her voice is so powerful
It’s nice to know professional singers make the same mistakes I do while in my car
2:05 I can't stop laughing 🤣
Sharp is raised by semitone, while flat is lowered by semitone.
trying to recall what or which poem or song contained these words - in fifty different sharps and flats
Tori is so good even her sharps and flats sounds so good
The first and the second clips of Xtina's song isn't the same song.
The first one was What A Girl Wants (G6) , the second was Por Siempre Tu (the one you called sharp)
so, essentially, sharp notes are demonic screeching while flat notes just sound sad and depressing (but not in the "sad and depressing" way you'd call a sad song)
Thanks for this, I always wonder what pitchy is. I'm not musically inclined so for me it sounds good either way.
The first ariana and some of the clips isn't sharp or flat. Basically sharp is a condition when you want to sing E5 but you sang it a lil bit higher but doesn't high enough to be counted as F5. So you ended up hitting something between E5 amd F5 notes. Flat is similar with sharp. But flat is you hit a slightly lower notes from the notes you supposed to be hit. Sorry if my english is too hard to understand
So a sharp note would be like strained?
Not necessarilly
Sometimes when singers in award shows are sharp or flat is the sound technicians fault because they can’t hear themselves.
Ari's note for one last time was an on purpose A5 not sharp
A5 is not in the key of the song, so not diatonic. It's in the key of A flat major, so an A is sharp. You can't say it isn't off key because the singer does it on purpose.
@@hiy9846 it was on key. During the honeymoon tour the key of the song was one semitone higher
The fact that their off key singing is still great!!
Lmao Taylor swift is so random, in some performances she sings in 5 different keys. Hell that ain't no bad day that's being a bad vocalist and tone deaf lmaoo
Actually taylor is a very decent vocalist she sure as hell showed some improvements in her latest tour and her range is noticeably wider and she does some vibrato from time to time so she's reaaallly good and she has a musical coming so she probs had to take some vocal coaching
fA 13 yeah actually that is true, she is now being more vocally consistent, and she clearly has worked hard on her voice, but rewind a bit to when she used to sing in multiple keys and would either go sharp or flat (most likely flat), she still does that but she's improving, so I think we are going to be seeing a more respected Taylor when comes to singing, because right now she is still kinda seen as that little princess who can write good songs but not sing so good
@@versecorner507 in about two weeks she will release a single so i'm really excited to see what she has in store for us
fA 13 I hope to see her improvements, I mean we all are. Only this time I wish she would be more versatile with song themes
I've seen so many vocal coaches react to Taylor and giving her credits for being a great singer. I don't understand why I shold listen to a hater like you than a knowledged vocal coach.
Isn't singing sharp and flat notes supposed to be out of tune and not off key? I thought off key is singing different notes that are not harmonious to the key the instrument plays. I feel that many times the phrases off key and out of tune are used as if they are the same thing
Mori was not flat,She just like to challenge herself and did an amazing performance
She was flat admit it. I'm her fan but I don't deny the fact that she makes mistakes sometimes. That doesn't take away how great she is though.
1:05 was a purpose key change so not sure if it really counts...
Morisette ... The 👑 👑
So Hyang messed up? God herself?
No. Thats Kirstin Maldanado or Mitch Grassi, depending how you look at it
JESSE js flat note was still pleasing to the ears
Was Tori actually flat in the third clip or was it a note change
I understand that a singer sings sharp or flat sometimes. It's a matter of how often do they do it!
Ariana..Demi and Kelly..Aile still sound goods tho without or with correction pitch..oh ya Tori also.
2:05 she looked like she wanted to do the note but just thought "nah not today"
I'm not even doing these notes yet my vocal cords or whatever is hurting
That Mariah note was not flat...
Are sharp notes bad ? I think it’s good that it’s higher than the original ? Can someone explain pls I’m not an expert
Can I put in a note here... Some bands tune their music down a semi tone live I see this allot with Rock and Metal Artists but could also apply to pop singers so basically they’re singing flat but it sounds okay because they’re tuned flat like for example check out Avril Lavigne’s song “I’m with you” on some live performances she sings it tuned 1 semi tone lower than the original because they tuned there instruments like that to accommodate her voice or save her voice but anyone can go off key while singing
oh my god guys sohyang actually messes up