If the Winds of Winter and Dream of Spring never come out, don't worry. We can just have Robert narrate to us all in two three-hour videos in his own words how he thinks that each book should go and what happens to all the characters. Then we can all go away satisfied and content.
I always like the idea that Tywin was either involved in joffreys murder or didn't try to stop it. Joffrey would eventually become too much for him to handle so getting him out of the way kind of plays into his hand, and keeps Tywin firmly in control.
Radio Westeros has also theorised that Marwyn was the maester on Dragonstone when Dany was born. That’d explain why he’s considered an outsider. He’s not a Targ, but he’s associated with them. Also explains why he had no shred of doubt about going to her. Though I’m fascinated as to whether Dany remembers that he trained Mirri Maz Duur.
My tinfoil theory is Walder Frey will be seiged in his castle and have to start eating his own family to survive. This being karma for killing someone under guest right. This mirrors the story of the rat-king in the abandoned castle on the wall
Here's my breakdown of why the immortal Bolton theory for me feels very possible. Roose mentions how in his youth he used to be more hot blooded and it's the leeches that purge the "bad blood" and allow him to be his cool calm self. We know that skinchangers have an easier time warging an animal that they have a bond with and that has already been broken in. Roose i feel has somewhat mentally broken Ramsey in that Ramsey feels cowed by Roose instinctively. Roose has already established a relationship of dominance woth Ramsey and so perhaps when Roose attempts to warg into him it will be easier because his consciousness already has a dominanxe ocer Ramseys. Secondly maintaining his control of the body over the lifetime and allowing his consciousness to not become subsumed by the hosts consciousness over time like supposedly happens with a skinchangers second life. Perhaps it is the leeching that allows him to maintain dominance over the host consciousness, keep the body somewhat weak, so that it is easier to dominate. Not ti mention the possibility of there being special herbs in his hipocras that may be helping also. Thirdly, wih the Bolton's long history of being seeming Stark hunters, and with GRRM having established in another story that the abilities of a werewolf can be gained by skinning a werewolf and wearing the skin, this could possibly explain how Bolton's were perhaps able to acquire the ability in the first place, and also how they are able to maintain the ability for many generations if no offspring have it naturally. Hunt a skinchanger and wear there skin and you once again have secured the powers of a skinchanger for your house. I feel we will never have a clear answer for this, but i definitely feel like GRRM is making subtle allusions to all this so that we can all guess at the uniqueness of house Bolton.
Okay so, my crackpot theory is that the real father of Ashara Dayne’s child was not any of the Starks or Howland Reed or Pedro Pascal, but Ser Arthur Dayne. Which is why Ned was so quick to figure out Cersei was banging Jamie. He had already seen it before. My crackpot theory is that Ashara did have a short romance with Ned, but she was ultimately in love with Arthur, and Ned discovered it. Because he loved her-even if it wasn’t reciprocated-he kept her secret, and returned the sword, and told the Daynes about Arthur’s fate. Arthur and Ashara also mirror Cersei and Jaimie: the perfect knight and the most beautiful maiden in the seven kingdoms-which is how both of them aspire to be seen. Meera is still taken by Howland as part of Ned’s plan to hide suspicious kids in this theory, tho I still don’t know why. This covers why Howland would tell the story as “the most beautiful maiden in the kingdom”-because Ashara still is Meera’s mother, so he has an incentive to hype her up-and why Ashara jumped to her death-she was truly heartbroken at her lover having died, that part is true. More sinister and more numerous reasons may have been involved in any of these steps, as well, but I think you can see the skeleton. Anyways, that’s my theory.
Maegor is Marwyn! I am glad INC got it into your stream. I am telling that from the first time I heard about it. Just not sure if it was from meera or guys :D
Craster is def in the Targaryen bloodline. He’s Bloodraven’s son. So are his 100 sons that are turned into The Others. Meaning so is Gilly and “Little Sam”
It's the chat with his aunt that really seals it for me. "You never really knew your father". And the fact it would be so sad that Tywins only true son is the one the hates
Thats funny that Robert is named the Usurper and on his death the throne goes straight back to the Targs. Aerys told Jamie to kill his father, he is a kinslayer and a kingslayer. Targs commit incest. Antime a Targ is born the gods flip a coin. Cersei mad. Joffrey is described as Aerys the 3rd. Joffrey and Cersei both obsessed with wildfire. Tyrion is Tywin's only trueborn son.
I’d be more inclined to believe it for Tyrion given the timing of their fallout and the incident with Joanna. Jaime being told by his aunt that he’s not Tywin’s son isn’t meant to be taken literally. She’s saying that he’s not as cunning,intelligent,or ruthless. All things Tyrion has but he doesn’t. It’s why he thinks back to that conversation after threatening to fling edmure’s baby over the wall with a trebuchet.
Daenerys was certainly the Saruman in the TV shows Unless GRRM withheld information from HBO or intends to change the ending that’s probably where the books are going too.
Dark Tinfoil ahead: Bran never leaves the cave and becomes the new 3 eyed crow. Jon comes back to life changed, and unwilling to do the necessary things to fulfill the prophecy and save the world. So Bran wargs into Jon, and lives out the rest of Jon's life for him, being Azor Ahai, saving the world, becoming King afterwards, etc while Jon retreats into Ghost more and more as he can't stand to share his own body with Bran. Side note: You seem convinced Bran leaves the cave, I am convinced he does not and will integrate into the trees like Blood Raven did, and the only way he gets to leave is through the eyes he wargs. Are you convinced Bran will physically leave, and why?
Even better. Everything that happens after Bran's fall is a Wizard of Oz style dream. The final scene of "A dream of spring" will just be him opening his eyes back in his bed. He's been in his coma so long that ... Winter is now finally Coming! And, despite this being a book, it cuts to black and the Game of Thrones theme will start playing... somehow.
I have a theory that we'll get a Jon pov chapter while his spirit is inside of ghost and during this chapter he'll see his dead body get resurrected through ghost's eyes.
21:19 I found very interesting symbolic connection between some French acting school! I dont remember the name but Essentially you start off with a mask and the final phase is a clown nose! Which is said to be the hardest to embodie someone else. When Arya is serving drinks at the meeting the tiny variation of the changes to the peoples faces, are essentially phases in this schools syllabus! I recommend checking it out! I would also recommend researching Golden Chalice Roses! The lore behind it amongs native americans describes the story pretty well. I found one lore site that was way detailed years ago, but i havent been able to find it again. The sites i have find since have similar ties to the story! They do not fit as precisely though. The tyrell rose is golden and sounds similar growing all over walls and stuff, Arlon of Penny tree has a winged golden chalice as his sigil, joffery is poisioned from drinking from a golden chalice! Its very interesting! The one thing i found interesting speaking of flowers, I started researching the different flowers in the story because of Chett. He talks about spending an entire day looking for different flowers, and it didnt make sense to me. After looking into all these flowers it seems like Chett was bringing this girl flowers that would allow her to abort a child! So essentially she risk nothing sleeping with him, and hey shes already slept with everyone, so now she has no exuse in his mind. Or maybe even it was a requirement to bed her. This is why he gets so enraged and kills her, because she still wont sleep with him. So all the known flowers aside from many non existent flowers, the ones that do exist in the story and in our world are connected to contraception essentially abortive agents, bith in universe and out of universe lore. Anywho in the lore one of the flowers it gives people dreams and brings on strong northern winds. I am curious what you think about Chett being the one that buried the dragon glass cache! Its hard to catch because of the gape in when we get the information. But chett and his cronies weeks before the attack at the fist of the first men have cached food, weapons, and supplies. Chett panics when it begins to snow because he fears they wont find the caches! What are the chances someone else with a new Nights Watch cloak is burrying caches of things around the first around the time chett and his group are also doing this! Its very possible being maester Amons Steward that he heard Amon talk about dragon glass and found a cache of the stuff at castle black and brought it with! Maester Luwin has a bunch of dragon glass arrowheads. He gives some to Bran and Rickon. It doesnt really make sense that he do this besides to show us maesters have this, and to talk of the children and magic. Bran and Rickon dont have these later so it seems pointless they be given this. Chett seems much more likely to be the culprit!
In Season 8, I really wanted everyone to be preparing to defend Winterfell only for the final shot of an episode to be them seeing the army of the dead just march past it on their way south to the God's Eye Lake or King's Landing: "The Dead... Where are they going?!" (With horrified confusion) "I don't know..." (Cut to black and scary music) But yeah, the idea that it's all about Winterfell or even just killing the living is kinda simplistic. They aren't Morgoth or Sauron's army of orcs bend on world domination or destruction, they have an interesting purpose and I think it's way more likely that they want to destroy the Isle of Faces (that thing that bothers to be defended by water on all sides) than that they just want to kill everything. I theorize that's the only way to end their curse or whatever and finally die or get sent back to their home dimension.
@ One thing that ASOIF has done well is how much death exudes from King’s Landing. It’s a pre-modern city so the number of small folk who fill paupers graves in Flea Bottom are staggering. I envisage the Others hearing the screams of the dead and suffering from beyond the Wall and seeing their invasion as raising them from their state of death. For to be undead is to triumph over death. And victory for the living should only be possible with the help of ALL the living especially the low born.
@@EtruskenRaiderNot to mention, the worst fighting in Westeros has always taken place in the Riverlands. If the WW wanted the biggest and best undead army, they’d want to march there, and from there they could match on king’s landing
I think the term for twins with different fathers is as simple as "heteropaternal twins". Actually, I guess I could google that. . . yep, heteropaternal twins are typically created by the process of superfecundation, which is a slightly harder word to remember in my opinion.
I looked it up too and find it hilarious that the word for it is literally just "twins with different fathers" but in another language so it becomes cool and official sounding.
commenting before finishing the video (I know I'm the worst). I don't know why but I feel like Dany has a very real possibility of going to old Valyria and getting infected with firewyrms. something about them just sorta feels like it's gonna come up again
Azor Ahai was a Dayne. Dawn brings the light = Lightbringer Sword of the Morning = Sword of the MOURNING Because Azor Ahai had to kill Nissa Nissa to create the sword, and thus he mourns for her. They say Dawn was created from the heart of a fallen star. The fallen star being the wife of a Dayne, who’s heraldry is that of a falling star. Lightbringer was forged by plunging a blade into the HEART of Nissa Nissa.
In a nutshell and from memory: Alleras is Sarella spelled backward, Arianne (I think) mentions that Sarella is currently in Oldtown, they are both dornish with a mother from the Summer Islands, their looks are described in a similar way, Aemon tells Sam that the sphinx is the riddle not the riddler and Alleras' nicname in the citadel is the sphinx and Lazy Leo Tyrell believes and says that Alleras is the son of a lord which Alleras disputes ( because she is actually the daughter of a prince not the son of a lord)
Funny that you use the name Ian in your example of names changing. Ian is actually just the Scottish Gaelic version of the name John. John is also the same name as Ivan, Juan, Hans, Sean(this is the Irish version), and many more very common names worldwide.
My Theory? There is no water on Namek because Robert Baratheon, Protector of the Realm and so fort drank it all. That caused the downfall of the greens.
Just to respond to your points on the Marwyn Brightflame theory: there are two possible reasons INC put forward for why he wouldnt be named Maester Maegor. The first is because he was at the citadel to hide him, so of course he was renamed. And the second option is, he was never actually called Maegor to begin with and the idea that he was was just political slander to keep him off the throne. I think you're right that Marwyn being an archmaester disproves it though, he believes that a Targaryen would never be raised to the position, so him think that his own untrustworthy blood is Targaryen would be a contradiction of that.
Wacky Theory: Euron wrote the Pink Letter. Proof: 1. Euron is very versed in magic and can definitely of heard of the Azor Ahai prophecy. If Melisandre can see Jon Snow in the visions then it’s safe to say other magic users can as well. 2. Euron believes Jon is Azor Ahai, a rival that can stop him from mantling the title or someone that can stop his Dark Apotheosis into Godhood. 3. Euron learns about Jon through spying with Mormont’s Crow.
4. He simply writes the Pink letter or magically influences Ramsay to write it playing into all of Jon’s Insecurities. 5. Jon is killed, problem solved for Euron and now he is free to do whatever evil scheme he wants. This can probably be easily disproved by more knowledgeable Loremasters so let me know! :)
Ive had a few theories..one being that shae and bronn where always in tywins service..bron entered into tywins service at the greenfork when he brought shae to tyrion for the 1st time..i also believe shae is tywins bed warmer(youtube friendly)........a TIN FOIL theory i have is that moonboy is cersis valonquar...he is cersis illigitamate brother and her kids are moonboys children..jaimie will catch them sleeping together when he returns from the riverlands , walking on them preforming a little bit of bdsm with his gold painted hand wrapped around her neck and she accidently expires( youtube friendly)
I still think Jaime is going to strangle Cersei with the Hand's chain of office. Myrcella is supposed to already be dead by then, per Maggy the Frog. I thought Jaime would be the one to trip over Balerion. I thought he'd fall down the serpentine steps and break his neck, given how often that's mentioned. But falling onto the Iron Throne would fit him too. Either way, I think Jaime deserves a comical death.
So the story of the second moon cracking open and dragons pouring out, what if it's true? What if the second moon was actually a space ship (Martin's Sci fi writing bleeding in) and the dragons that came out were a race that lead to the Valerians and the Dragons themselves? Genetic engineering allowing for crossbreeding and special abilities and the like
Respect Jamie throwing his honour away by killing the mad king to save 500 thousand people why not then dedicate your life to the prince and princess keeping them safe tools the easy way out no wonder Ned stark would have never changed his opinion
Hello! Recently watched a breakdown from Joy Achill (on TH-cam) about the misogyny of G R R Martin's writing. May be good to have your views, although I do realise it's not really your usual topic!
Post not-live live stream engagement boost. Your time and content is always appreciated Robert. Thank you.
Tinfoil theory: GRRM never planned on finishing the series
I almost always miss the livestream so this experience was the same for me. Excellent topic and great questions/theories by everyone.
If winds of winter never comes out this is all cannon.
If the Winds of Winter and Dream of Spring never come out, don't worry. We can just have Robert narrate to us all in two three-hour videos in his own words how he thinks that each book should go and what happens to all the characters. Then we can all go away satisfied and content.
*canon. A ‘cannon’ is heavy artillery. 😂
The Stark family sword, Ice, was made for a literal giant.
I was literally just thinking about how much I missed these streams. Thank you so much.
I always like the idea that Tywin was either involved in joffreys murder or didn't try to stop it. Joffrey would eventually become too much for him to handle so getting him out of the way kind of plays into his hand, and keeps Tywin firmly in control.
I love when we do Tinfoil Thursday!!!
Radio Westeros has also theorised that Marwyn was the maester on Dragonstone when Dany was born. That’d explain why he’s considered an outsider. He’s not a Targ, but he’s associated with them. Also explains why he had no shred of doubt about going to her. Though I’m fascinated as to whether Dany remembers that he trained Mirri Maz Duur.
This is the content I’m here for.
My tinfoil theory is Walder Frey will be seiged in his castle and have to start eating his own family to survive. This being karma for killing someone under guest right. This mirrors the story of the rat-king in the abandoned castle on the wall
Very enjoyable listen, thanks for this!
Thank you mods
Yes! Some great folks who do it for this channel. I agree with you
Here's my breakdown of why the immortal Bolton theory for me feels very possible.
Roose mentions how in his youth he used to be more hot blooded and it's the leeches that purge the "bad blood" and allow him to be his cool calm self. We know that skinchangers have an easier time warging an animal that they have a bond with and that has already been broken in. Roose i feel has somewhat mentally broken Ramsey in that Ramsey feels cowed by Roose instinctively. Roose has already established a relationship of dominance woth Ramsey and so perhaps when Roose attempts to warg into him it will be easier because his consciousness already has a dominanxe ocer Ramseys.
Secondly maintaining his control of the body over the lifetime and allowing his consciousness to not become subsumed by the hosts consciousness over time like supposedly happens with a skinchangers second life. Perhaps it is the leeching that allows him to maintain dominance over the host consciousness, keep the body somewhat weak, so that it is easier to dominate. Not ti mention the possibility of there being special herbs in his hipocras that may be helping also.
Thirdly, wih the Bolton's long history of being seeming Stark hunters, and with GRRM having established in another story that the abilities of a werewolf can be gained by skinning a werewolf and wearing the skin, this could possibly explain how Bolton's were perhaps able to acquire the ability in the first place, and also how they are able to maintain the ability for many generations if no offspring have it naturally. Hunt a skinchanger and wear there skin and you once again have secured the powers of a skinchanger for your house.
I feel we will never have a clear answer for this, but i definitely feel like GRRM is making subtle allusions to all this so that we can all guess at the uniqueness of house Bolton.
I like how politely Rob sidesteps and puts aside ridiculous theories some people are clearly very invested in 😂
Cheers Robert!
Okay so, my crackpot theory is that the real father of Ashara Dayne’s child was not any of the Starks or Howland Reed or Pedro Pascal, but Ser Arthur Dayne. Which is why Ned was so quick to figure out Cersei was banging Jamie. He had already seen it before. My crackpot theory is that Ashara did have a short romance with Ned, but she was ultimately in love with Arthur, and Ned discovered it. Because he loved her-even if it wasn’t reciprocated-he kept her secret, and returned the sword, and told the Daynes about Arthur’s fate. Arthur and Ashara also mirror Cersei and Jaimie: the perfect knight and the most beautiful maiden in the seven kingdoms-which is how both of them aspire to be seen. Meera is still taken by Howland as part of Ned’s plan to hide suspicious kids in this theory, tho I still don’t know why. This covers why Howland would tell the story as “the most beautiful maiden in the kingdom”-because Ashara still is Meera’s mother, so he has an incentive to hype her up-and why Ashara jumped to her death-she was truly heartbroken at her lover having died, that part is true. More sinister and more numerous reasons may have been involved in any of these steps, as well, but I think you can see the skeleton. Anyways, that’s my theory.
I like it.
Maegor is Marwyn! I am glad INC got it into your stream. I am telling that from the first time I heard about it. Just not sure if it was from meera or guys :D
Craster is def in the Targaryen bloodline. He’s Bloodraven’s son. So are his 100 sons that are turned into The Others. Meaning so is Gilly and “Little Sam”
1:24:11 Welcome to Winterfell Crypts, where the spirits aren't there so the swords don't matter.
Catelyn Tully is a highly magical person and thats why all her kids have skin changing abilities
I think Jamie and Cersei are both The Mad Kings kids. Jamie is told by his aunt and in his dream that he is not Tywins Son.
It's the chat with his aunt that really seals it for me. "You never really knew your father". And the fact it would be so sad that Tywins only true son is the one the hates
Thats funny that Robert is named the Usurper and on his death the throne goes straight back to the Targs. Aerys told Jamie to kill his father, he is a kinslayer and a kingslayer. Targs commit incest. Antime a Targ is born the gods flip a coin. Cersei mad. Joffrey is described as Aerys the 3rd. Joffrey and Cersei both obsessed with wildfire. Tyrion is Tywin's only trueborn son.
Tyrion is the one with the dragon dreams. Hes the most likely to be a secret Targ.
I’d be more inclined to believe it for Tyrion given the timing of their fallout and the incident with Joanna.
Jaime being told by his aunt that he’s not Tywin’s son isn’t meant to be taken literally.
She’s saying that he’s not as cunning,intelligent,or ruthless.
All things Tyrion has but he doesn’t. It’s why he thinks back to that conversation after threatening to fling edmure’s baby over the wall with a trebuchet.
Tywin tells him that too, right?
Daenerys was certainly the Saruman in the TV shows
Unless GRRM withheld information from HBO or intends to change the ending that’s probably where the books are going too.
Eldric Stoneskin is my favorite underrated ASOIAF TH-cam theorist
Dark Tinfoil ahead: Bran never leaves the cave and becomes the new 3 eyed crow. Jon comes back to life changed, and unwilling to do the necessary things to fulfill the prophecy and save the world. So Bran wargs into Jon, and lives out the rest of Jon's life for him, being Azor Ahai, saving the world, becoming King afterwards, etc while Jon retreats into Ghost more and more as he can't stand to share his own body with Bran.
Side note: You seem convinced Bran leaves the cave, I am convinced he does not and will integrate into the trees like Blood Raven did, and the only way he gets to leave is through the eyes he wargs. Are you convinced Bran will physically leave, and why?
Even better. Everything that happens after Bran's fall is a Wizard of Oz style dream. The final scene of "A dream of spring" will just be him opening his eyes back in his bed. He's been in his coma so long that ... Winter is now finally Coming!
And, despite this being a book, it cuts to black and the Game of Thrones theme will start playing... somehow.
I have a theory that we'll get a Jon pov chapter while his spirit is inside of ghost and during this chapter he'll see his dead body get resurrected through ghost's eyes.
21:19
I found very interesting symbolic connection between some French acting school! I dont remember the name but Essentially you start off with a mask and the final phase is a clown nose! Which is said to be the hardest to embodie someone else. When Arya is serving drinks at the meeting the tiny variation of the changes to the peoples faces, are essentially phases in this schools syllabus!
I recommend checking it out! I would also recommend researching Golden Chalice Roses! The lore behind it amongs native americans describes the story pretty well. I found one lore site that was way detailed years ago, but i havent been able to find it again. The sites i have find since have similar ties to the story! They do not fit as precisely though. The tyrell rose is golden and sounds similar growing all over walls and stuff, Arlon of Penny tree has a winged golden chalice as his sigil, joffery is poisioned from drinking from a golden chalice! Its very interesting!
The one thing i found interesting speaking of flowers, I started researching the different flowers in the story because of Chett. He talks about spending an entire day looking for different flowers, and it didnt make sense to me. After looking into all these flowers it seems like Chett was bringing this girl flowers that would allow her to abort a child! So essentially she risk nothing sleeping with him, and hey shes already slept with everyone, so now she has no exuse in his mind. Or maybe even it was a requirement to bed her. This is why he gets so enraged and kills her, because she still wont sleep with him.
So all the known flowers aside from many non existent flowers, the ones that do exist in the story and in our world are connected to contraception essentially abortive agents, bith in universe and out of universe lore.
Anywho in the lore one of the flowers it gives people dreams and brings on strong northern winds. I am curious what you think about Chett being the one that buried the dragon glass cache! Its hard to catch because of the gape in when we get the information. But chett and his cronies weeks before the attack at the fist of the first men have cached food, weapons, and supplies. Chett panics when it begins to snow because he fears they wont find the caches!
What are the chances someone else with a new Nights Watch cloak is burrying caches of things around the first around the time chett and his group are also doing this!
Its very possible being maester Amons Steward that he heard Amon talk about dragon glass and found a cache of the stuff at castle black and brought it with! Maester Luwin has a bunch of dragon glass arrowheads. He gives some to Bran and Rickon. It doesnt really make sense that he do this besides to show us maesters have this, and to talk of the children and magic. Bran and Rickon dont have these later so it seems pointless they be given this.
Chett seems much more likely to be the culprit!
My tinfoil is that the Other’s real target is King’s Landing and that should they breach the wall, any siege of Winterfell will be a diversion.
In Season 8, I really wanted everyone to be preparing to defend Winterfell only for the final shot of an episode to be them seeing the army of the dead just march past it on their way south to the God's Eye Lake or King's Landing:
"The Dead... Where are they going?!"
(With horrified confusion)
"I don't know..."
(Cut to black and scary music)
But yeah, the idea that it's all about Winterfell or even just killing the living is kinda simplistic. They aren't Morgoth or Sauron's army of orcs bend on world domination or destruction, they have an interesting purpose and I think it's way more likely that they want to destroy the Isle of Faces (that thing that bothers to be defended by water on all sides) than that they just want to kill everything. I theorize that's the only way to end their curse or whatever and finally die or get sent back to their home dimension.
@ One thing that ASOIF has done well is how much death exudes from King’s Landing.
It’s a pre-modern city so the number of small folk who fill paupers graves in Flea Bottom are staggering.
I envisage the Others hearing the screams of the dead and suffering from beyond the Wall and seeing their invasion as raising them from their state of death. For to be undead is to triumph over death.
And victory for the living should only be possible with the help of ALL the living especially the low born.
@@EtruskenRaiderNot to mention, the worst fighting in Westeros has always taken place in the Riverlands. If the WW wanted the biggest and best undead army, they’d want to march there, and from there they could match on king’s landing
I think the term for twins with different fathers is as simple as "heteropaternal twins". Actually, I guess I could google that. . . yep, heteropaternal twins are typically created by the process of superfecundation, which is a slightly harder word to remember in my opinion.
I looked it up too and find it hilarious that the word for it is literally just "twins with different fathers" but in another language so it becomes cool and official sounding.
commenting before finishing the video (I know I'm the worst). I don't know why but I feel like Dany has a very real possibility of going to old Valyria and getting infected with firewyrms. something about them just sorta feels like it's gonna come up again
I think Hodor is the son of Tormund and the Giantess that he got his name from
Allar Deem is the Hooded man
Azor Ahai was a Dayne.
Dawn brings the light = Lightbringer
Sword of the Morning = Sword of the MOURNING
Because Azor Ahai had to kill Nissa Nissa to create the sword, and thus he mourns for her.
They say Dawn was created from the heart of a fallen star. The fallen star being the wife of a Dayne, who’s heraldry is that of a falling star. Lightbringer was forged by plunging a blade into the HEART of Nissa Nissa.
1:00:40 hi I'm relatively new to a lot of these theories, what is the alera sorela theory?
In a nutshell and from memory: Alleras is Sarella spelled backward, Arianne (I think) mentions that Sarella is currently in Oldtown, they are both dornish with a mother from the Summer Islands, their looks are described in a similar way, Aemon tells Sam that the sphinx is the riddle not the riddler and Alleras' nicname in the citadel is the sphinx and Lazy Leo Tyrell believes and says that Alleras is the son of a lord which Alleras disputes ( because she is actually the daughter of a prince not the son of a lord)
This will be some tasty tinfoil, gang
Funny that you use the name Ian in your example of names changing. Ian is actually just the Scottish Gaelic version of the name John. John is also the same name as Ivan, Juan, Hans, Sean(this is the Irish version), and many more very common names worldwide.
With the absence of a DNA test. What would be tangible proof that Jon is Rhaegar and Lyanna’s child? And not someone else
My Theory? There is no water on Namek because Robert Baratheon, Protector of the Realm and so fort
drank it all. That caused the downfall of the greens.
💗Mod love!
Joe Haldeman, still kicking!
I tried the interesting nerd club. They certainly think they're funny.
Great not-stream stream
Daario is Euron
Just to respond to your points on the Marwyn Brightflame theory: there are two possible reasons INC put forward for why he wouldnt be named Maester Maegor. The first is because he was at the citadel to hide him, so of course he was renamed. And the second option is, he was never actually called Maegor to begin with and the idea that he was was just political slander to keep him off the throne.
I think you're right that Marwyn being an archmaester disproves it though, he believes that a Targaryen would never be raised to the position, so him think that his own untrustworthy blood is Targaryen would be a contradiction of that.
Dang! Missed it
Wacky Theory: Euron wrote the Pink Letter.
Proof:
1. Euron is very versed in magic and can definitely of heard of the Azor Ahai prophecy. If Melisandre can see Jon Snow in the visions then it’s safe to say other magic users can as well.
2. Euron believes Jon is Azor Ahai, a rival that can stop him from mantling the title or someone that can stop his Dark Apotheosis into Godhood.
3. Euron learns about Jon through spying with Mormont’s Crow.
4. He simply writes the Pink letter or magically influences Ramsay to write it playing into all of Jon’s Insecurities.
5. Jon is killed, problem solved for Euron and now he is free to do whatever evil scheme he wants.
This can probably be easily disproved by more knowledgeable Loremasters so let me know! :)
So a bit like Eowyn and the witch king but instead of no man can kill me it's no one can kill me.
While we got our Tin foil hats on..George like to drop iin hints of the colour of Cersei's eyes which are GREEN And how they dance like Wildfire
Oh no, i thought i had finaly caught a livestream live
Great to see you anyway. I'll be live again same time next week!
I have a theory that the books will be finished
Will Lyanna come back if the Horn of Winter is blown?!
Perhaps as the new nights queen 😂
Ive had a few theories..one being that shae and bronn where always in tywins service..bron entered into tywins service at the greenfork when he brought shae to tyrion for the 1st time..i also believe shae is tywins bed warmer(youtube friendly)........a TIN FOIL theory i have is that moonboy is cersis valonquar...he is cersis illigitamate brother and her kids are moonboys children..jaimie will catch them sleeping together when he returns from the riverlands , walking on them preforming a little bit of bdsm with his gold painted hand wrapped around her neck and she accidently expires( youtube friendly)
Never mind found it love ya king
I still think Jaime is going to strangle Cersei with the Hand's chain of office. Myrcella is supposed to already be dead by then, per Maggy the Frog. I thought Jaime would be the one to trip over Balerion. I thought he'd fall down the serpentine steps and break his neck, given how often that's mentioned. But falling onto the Iron Throne would fit him too. Either way, I think Jaime deserves a comical death.
When can we hang out and have some beers together???
So the story of the second moon cracking open and dragons pouring out, what if it's true? What if the second moon was actually a space ship (Martin's Sci fi writing bleeding in) and the dragons that came out were a race that lead to the Valerians and the Dragons themselves? Genetic engineering allowing for crossbreeding and special abilities and the like
So this is what you look like, great video
Respect Jamie throwing his honour away by killing the mad king to save 500 thousand people why not then dedicate your life to the prince and princess keeping them safe tools the easy way out no wonder Ned stark would have never changed his opinion
The WOWinter is Done! He is working on A Dream of Spring you saps🧐
Hello! Recently watched a breakdown from Joy Achill (on TH-cam) about the misogyny of G R R Martin's writing. May be good to have your views, although I do realise it's not really your usual topic!
Wait! He’s not AI?!?!
Not last time I checked ;)
@ You just have a really consistent voice then, impressive sir. Cheers.