Nexon EV vs XUV 400 vs ZS EV - EV Cars in India 2023 Comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 มิ.ย. 2024
- Here we are with the first-ever Maha Comparison of EV SUVs on the Motoroctane. This video has been made on the demand of our beloved subscribers. In today's video, we are comparing the Nexon EV Max and the MG ZS EV with the new entrant, the XUV 400. As always we are doing a detailed comparison of each and every aspect of all three EV SUVs. We have compared aspects like features, space, practicality, performance, ride and handling, and many other minor details like wipers, keys, horns, and much more that no one else does for you. So guys watch the video till the very end so that you will get complete clarity about which car is the suitable choice for you. Also, we are adding timestamps below so that you can jump on any part with ease. However, we recommend you watch the complete video so that you do not miss any of the details.
00:00 - INTRO
02:00 - DIMENSIONS
02:30 - KEY
02:52 - GROUND CLEARANCE
03:05 - HEADLIGHT
03:27 - WIPER
03:39 - TYRE
03:54 - ROOFRAIL
03:58 - BOOTSPACE
04:37 - CAR CHARGER
04:54 - SPARE TYRE
05:13 - XUV400 INTERIOR
06:17 - NEXON EV MAX INTERIOR
07:33 - ZS EV INTERIOR
08:37 - GETTING IN & OUT
09:19 - SEAT ADJUSTMENT
09:42 - STEERING ADJUSTMENT
09:54 - TOUCHSCREEN
10:20 - REVERSE CAMERA
11:04- MUSIC
12:04 - HORN TEST
12:14 - DOOR THUD
12:24 - STORAGE SPACES
13:48 - CHARGING PORTS
14:23 - PHONE STORAGE
14:39 - SECOND ROW SEATING
15:27 - XUV400 DRIVE
19:38 - NEXON EV MAX DRIVE
23:17 - ZS EV DRIVE
26:18 - SPEED BREAKER
26:33 - BRAKING
26:44 - HILL CLIMB
27:21 - HEADLIGHT THROW
28:05 - VERDICT
Car Consultancy Form: motoroctane.com/car-consultancy
OWNER'S Car Review
Want us to review your car/bike? Share your details -forms.gle/BAr48SScVUz9igkZ9
Follow us on
Subscribe us @ TH-cam : bit.ly/MotorOctane
Facebook: / motoroctane
Twitter: / motoroctane
Instagram: / motoroctane
TH-cam: / motoroctane
Website: motoroctane.com - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
Hope you liked the video? For car buying doubts, our experts recommend the Best Buy worth your money, after analysing your requirements. motoroctane.com/car-consultancy Click on this link & submit your query.
That what i want🤗...can motoroctane team bring safari adas feature with practical..please😊
That what i want🤗...can motoroctane team bring safari adas feature with practical..please😊
Yes motor octane is best
New safari vs XUV 700
Please help me out, which car should I buy? Nexon EV or Nexon petrol ?...monthly I drive 500 kilometers only & also I don't have separate parking..we park the car on ground that's is common for all....no fix place and no security.
Generally Mahindra vehicles maintain all kind of safety for its users, except one issue is the outdated display and missing rear ac vents of xuv 400
@@RAHULSHARMA-rx7gx i own xuv 300 w8 o diesel, so i am familiar with xuv, xuv 400 has a bit more boot space and is electric, thats all the difference, rest is same as xuv 300.
No cruise Control, Ventilated Seats etc.
Mahindra uses NMC batteries which have high density but has lesser lifespan(fewer charging cycles for degradation) and more fire risk too.Considering indian climate they should have launched car with LFP(byd,mg and tata uses LFP only)
Rear AC vents are useless they only divert the air from front and provide it to rear passenger. There is no cooling coil at rear.
Ya but still he said it got the best display... shows the reliability of such channels
Yesterday we Said We need a comparison and Today the video is here Of Ev's Comparison This is Why we love Motoroctane❤️
uske pehle hi shoot kiya tha bhai
@@pushparaj3908 correct 💯
Who is we
@@rousbagaming bhai gammer left the chat
@@pushparaj3908 🤣
The headlight throw part made me really appreciate how much you listen and cover things . Appreciate it. Thank you and keep it up
कंडारी जी😍
Excellent video...and hats off to the effeorts you are putting for such a detailed analysis.
Any idea about plug in hybrids coming in India ?
Thank you so much Team for Maha comparison between 3 EVs. I have commented in XUV 400 video for the comparison and the video is out now.. wonderful 🥳
Tata Nexon ev max value for money 💰🤑
Yes
XUV 400 look beast
Lovely.... Was waiting for such a detailed review on EVs... But wud have loved if you had atleast added subs so that viewers from other states cud also get the most out of this content....
Sir i was really thrilled and was waiting for this video for so long .Thank u team motor octane for delivering this video so fast
That's why I love ❤️ this channel... Whenever I have questions in my mind regarding various cars and it's comparison it is uploaded by motoroctane in few days
Yes thanks to Motoroctane team for the videos of Maha comparison Top selling Ev cars... That's why we love this channel... Keep it up to all team... 👍👍👌👌
Been following you since a year
I have I 20 2019 DT petrol.
With your detailed comparison I have booked nexon ev max Top model yesterday.
Thank you for your Guidance 🙏
Hi Rachit, it was a good comparison among the cars. It could be more better incorporating the expected battery life, cost of battery replacement and other costs to be incurred in future. 👍
very nice comparo. Thanks for the efforts. Would like ADAS comparison of the cars if possible. Thanks
Nexon & Xuv are good and our indigenous product.
Full support to both⚡
then why are you buying imported phones buy intels dude get out of that mentality dude
@@pushparaj3908 I am not one of those who just for 0.10% profit move to foreign brands , if I am getting a good product from our own country so, why don't I move to made in India products, it not only a proud for me but it also helps my country to reduce to trade deficit with other countries.
Right Bro.
Our neighbor had bought MG ZS EV 1st generation. After one year the range has drastically reduced.
Due to unavailability of MG service he is suffering like hell.
What can you expect from Chinese Brands?
@@pushparaj3908 my iphone 13 is made in india so...
Nikal 🅱️aude
@@pushparaj3908 Brands maybe of the other countries but assembled in India. Those are not imported at least till ₹50,000 range.
King of compact SUV Nexon
Yh come and race with any engine of xuv 300 u never gonna win noob
@@Shetthalli Not a race car though😊
King of ev suv is zs easy
Love Your Work Team Motoroctane. Keep it up 👍🔥
Thanks for the video. Having range numbers would have been very handy.
We are working on it
Mahindra has gave you money, why you criticise Nexon every time and you praise Xuv 400 every time and not that only you criticise whole Tata motors and praise Mahindra always.
Mahindra is actually pretty good
@@prateekdhingra292 Mahindra is good but a Tata is also good but rachit bhaiya everytime criticise Tata and praise Mahindra, that's not equality
Hi Rachit, the Maha comparison was really good, but there was no mention of the cost. Please include the cost in description at least. Thanks
Please do MAHA comparision of LOWER Price EV. I loved the way you have done the comparison. wow !
Brilliant and best comparison on youtube
Woww😍😍
What a Electric comparo video, Thank you very much Dear MotorOctane Team for this stunning & mind blowing Comparison video of EVs ❤️
Keep Giving us this type of Precious Content
Best camparision .wish you great success
That what i want🤗...can motoroctane team bring safari adas feature with practical..please😊
I appreciate the growing market but Nexon EV is my pick ❤
Super bro, eagerly waiting for this video
excellent work sir! can you kindly compare ev with hybrid...
Great Much needed Video
Very nice and detailed comparo, but disappointed not to see real world efficiency comparison for the similar or same drive.
Thank you for the comparison video. But, you have not covered the Battery technology part which is one of the most important factors right??
We will do a detailed video on battery tech alone. This was already a long video
Excellent Explanation Rachit Bhai
Everything was crisp and clear.
Thank you so much 😊..
Very Good Comparsion Video For Nexon EV MAX, XUV400 & ZS EV Ki Motor Octane.👌✌
Tata electric ev is the best 👌 car 🚗 😍
Excellent Comparison
💯
This video feels like a comparison between Nexon, XUV 300 (with bigger boot with outdated Interior), MG Astor. All the key points that are required for an EV such as Battery capacity, Type of battery Used, Regen Situation , Charging costs outside , How battery charging fares in different climate conditions etc are totally missed. All I hear is XUV 400 this and XUV 400 that . That's all.
Agree with you. Some features from the ZS EV have been overlooked in the video
Rachit is a xuv fan boy and he owns xuv700. So that is expected .:)
@@Questlogscribe ZS EV is literally the range king in its segment and he didn't bother to mention it at all
@@JayeshAmbali Well we do expect some unbiased videos as well.
@@Questlogscribe what features did he miss?
Great effort 👌
Why Motoroctane Is Getting Biased Towards Mahindra After Rachit Hirani Bought XUV 700 And Also Booking Of XUV 400
No technical comparison, no mention of battery chemistry , no mention of technology maturity....
All gyan based on WATER BOTTLE fitment test ....
True observation
Bhai mujhe ye to nhi laga me inki video regular dekhta hoon lekin haan tata aur mahindra ko bhai support jarur krte hain jo ki mere hisaab se sahi bhi h
❤️❤️
Yeah biased.... And conclusion everyone is best😂😂😂
@@ArmanKhan-35788 Tata Aur Mahindra Ko Support Fanboys Kare To Theek Hai But As He Is Auto Journalist He Should Give True Opinion Not Everyone Want Tata & Mahindra Cars Sorry If You Hurted ❣️
Hello sir, do a video comparing Atto3, ioniq 5 and kia ev6, would be great...:), thanks for the content
Can you make a video on chargers. Like what type of chargers are there. Howto use them in different situations. What are the adv and disadv. Which car comes with what. Whether we can install chargers in apartment. What kind of chargers are available in public chaeging stations. How is the mobile app. Is it helpful. How to optimally use the charging, when to charge how often we should charge.
Which one allows more choice of Regeneration level?
Amazing comparison.
Overall loved the video comparison.
15.55 : Factually wrong “Xuv400” doesn’t have the highest torque or power under 30 lakh Ev cars 🚗
Zs ev : 176 PS power (150 Ps Xuv400)
Kona ev : 395 nm torque
(310 nm XUv400)
Light steering is disastrous considering Evs at high speed !!
Tbh the light output in ev max,xuv400 is same as it’s Ice siblings.
Zs ev led set up is far far better that our two eSuvs (sadly Zs ev is a segment above )
Again,Nexon ev Max any day over a Xuv400
dey r all paid reviews...Their Excitement is for showoff
Not acceptable from a reviewer. Bias towards Mahindra is consistent for some time. The biggest topic with EVs, that is range, is not covered till the last quarter of the video…
XUV400 has a lighter steering than 300. And we meant the power and torque in real life. Not in numbers.
Biased video for XUV400 it doesn’t get hill descent control hill hold assist and on hill climb video 10/10? I mean seriously how can you fool your loyal viewers for some extra money. Completely lost respect for Rachit & his team.
@@motoroctane you said it's the highest torque and the most powerful motor if not numbers what other comparison is there
Rear AC vents are the most helpful feature with the USB outlet missing in XUV400.
Listing USB outlet as an important feature itself is absurd.
Watched the whole 32 minutes video without skipping even 10 seconds. ❣️❣️
Maine aap k video dekh kar 09-06-23 mg zs ev purchase ki hai thanks aap ka kafi aachha detailed video thaa maine car 4000 km chala li hai and now i am happy to buy this car
Thanks again
Music system quality can be a subjective opinion like the car design coz music is not every people's liking. Though great comparo!
Very nice and detailed comparison 👍
Great Video
Tata is best 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Yes
Good explation
What about after sales experience? I think it is also an important point for buy decision.
Can u make a video on issues which future ev users might face…such as tyre puncture!! Can we change gyre on our own jus as on petrol
Only negative point about XUV 400 is it has NMC chemistry cells compared to Tata Nexon and MG ZS EV which use LFP cells.
NMC supports less charging cycles and more vulnerable to heating issues.
Manish - NMC batteries are used by Merc, BMW, Hyundai, Kia for all their cars in India. NMC has lesser charge cycles of about 2000, and LFP is about 3000. You are right on that. Still 2000 is about 6 lakh kms.
And heating issues won’t be there when you have liquid cooling. As these aren’t air cooled. Just a request - also study the reacting temp on NMC and LFP. You will realise it isn’t anywhere close to the temperatures we face.
@@motoroctanefor thermal runaway the temperatures of LFP is higher than NMC plus NMC directly emits fire whereas LFP emits smoke giving time for its driver to escape
@@motoroctanethe BMS of Kia, Merc , BMW are more calibrated well the liquid cooling system is more efficient since their prices are also high those companies have tested their products thoroughly unlike XUV400 which has lot of glitches bugs
@@motoroctaneWhy is then Mahindra switching to LFP chemistry in their future cars if ur team is justifying NMC For their cars
XUV 400 is rushed product. Apart from battery it lacks many basic features and looks dated with poor stearing and ride without traction or hill desent or cruise control or esp features apart from modern feature like ventilated seats etc. Also it has poor ground clearance hopefully risky in the country side considering ev. On the other hand ev Max is much sorted and practicle.
I was looking at the knees up concern on rear seat of both xuv and nexon comparo... Because I heard it is a concern of both these cars... Whereas one more point is... Cruise control is a very much needed feature in EV... Because that is what defines the ease of one pedal driving...
nice review but please change ur music while testing sound system its not good at all
That's awesome 😎
Overall, Nexon is the best pick of all. This is calculated in terms of
Safety
Budget
Ergonomics
Comfort
Stability
Long drive
After sales
Part availability
Warranty of Battery and service cost comparison ?
Waiting For Altrroz EV Automatic ❤️
All ev are automatic bro
Not be coming
Hello MotorOctane Team so can you exactly tell the range of these 3 vehicles
Request a Maha Comparison of compact SUVs in India. More than 6 months since the last one 😎
The Comparison is biased toward XUV400. If I wanna buy an EV then I will keep 3 most essential things in mind before choosing one:
1) EV Cars are software driven. You cannot verify the quality of software before using it for a reasonable period, for myself, I cannot trust XUV400 being a completely new vehicle on the other hand, Nexon EV is tested and trusted,
2) Battery is a significant component of an EV. XUV400 uses an NMC battery type which is primitive technology compared to LFP Battery used in Tata Nexon EV. NMC batteries have low life cycle than LFP Batteries. Also, LFP batteries are good at managing heat and temperature considering the hot conditions of India and
3) Chargers: Tata has invested hugely in charging infrastructure I have not heard from Mahindra regarding this.
This review doesn't talk about any EV specific features. Such as charging speed or charging curve
Or even regen capacity. It's a joke
This was the comment I wanted to see! These people never talk about all these crucial technical points like battery chemistry etc.
@@nujjigram Absolutely right, EV buyers usually are not traditional buyers. We will evaluate every single detail before buying. XUV 400 is not doubt bigger than Tata Nexon EV in size but nobody talks about software and NMC battery of xuv 400. I don’t want be a test subject of Mahindra.
@@RAHULSHARMA-rx7gx ncm and LFP are well tested . My criticism is limited to the review, not to the car's
We all know the limitations of ncm and the energy density of LFP. That's not the complaint here.
Im glad people like you and the other commentators here recognise the shortfall of this so called "review"
Just wait till 2025. EV car prices will fall drastically. Don't buy now if you don't need urgently.
We support made in India, lovely video.
Thanks 🙏
You must compare battery type,battery size,average real world range and max charging speed supported in EV comparison.
Yes - you will get everything :)
And number of charging points is also a big distinguishing factor while buying
TATA's charging network is good
Damn my request did really come true lol
Some features from the ZS ev have been overlooked
@motoroctane please bring comparo for all 5 long range EVs, Nexon long range, XUV 400,BYD, Kona and ZS EV
@motorOctane please do range test for xuv400
Excellent 😀
Very nice ❤❤
Should compare service offered by the brands too
You should have added byd atto 3, please comment on it when compared to these?
5 lakh km warranty on battery and blade technology stands against these for that price?
Let indian brand grow
Not xuv400 but nexon is just PERFECT 🔥🔥🇮🇳🇮🇳
Thanks bro ❤
What a video review. Its most par than international review formats. keep the good work sir.
This time they lacked many technical issues are real life issues. Not worth it .
Not bad. good vid.
Please Do a comparison Between Altroz Racer 2023 and Marutin Baleno
Hill hold and regenerative features in xuv400?
Sir i wish if you have included the byd atto 3 as well kindly do that comparison maha comparison 😅
It'll easily win although priced a little higher
Plz compare Nexon ev with Tiago and tigor ev
बहोत अच्छे से कम्पेयर करके बताएं हो अच्छा लगा ।।
first choice xuv 400 ❤❤❤❤❤
second choice tata nexon ❤❤❤❤
For the first time I felt motoroctane is biased... Seat comfort in nexon>xuv.. I admit that xuv offer tremendous comfort but this is very silly.. I drove both the cars many time and we made a trip in xuv form siddipet to maredmilli in AP and it's touchscreen is one of the worst I've ever seen and the same case with nexon..but you've given 9 for it and the fun fact is that again you've given 8 for zs screen which is leagues ahead than xuv... IDK what motoroctane is doing!
Xuv400's touch response is miles bettee than tata's offering. It runs at 60fps butter smooth which is not the case with nexon.
@@gamerslife4me938 I've used it for many days and I personally driven nexon as my cousin owns it.. Both are almost similar with those old school ui but good thing is that xuv too gets 7 inch thats it
Nope - XUV comfort > Nexon.
Nexon fabric seats comfort > leatherette ones
@@motoroctane lol... Under thigh is nexon is leagues ahead and I can't speak about fabric seats because I drove car which had leather seat covers and it's comfort is damn outstanding
M D terms of wit
Can you make real time range test of these 3 EVs
Rachit can you post a video of comparison of tiago, nios, ignis
And you missed the biggest comparison, i.e.- acceleration test
Super
Hi guys.... Please do comparison video about amt cars under 20 lakhs rs ... SUV or sub compact SUV please ... Even 2nd varient is good ... No need of top varient ... Anything but under 20lakhs ... Pls
Brother kindly make a comparison video of TATA nexon ev vs tigor ev vs tiago ev
Thank you
Sir, please make a video on 2023 new Honda City facelift with adas
Which is the best one in battery technology and longevity
one thng as a buyer we need to understand battery architecture n according to research LFP has charging cycles thn NMC
Scorpio N & Fortuner mein ek comparison video banaiye plz 🙏🏻 who is the Real Big Daddy SUV ?
25:35 plz clarify if mgzs ev has 143 bhp of power of 174 is it an error from ur end ?
Hello sir, kindly request you to recent customers review about XUV 700 L AT.
Missed out the most important thing. What is the max charging speed on DC fast charging. You don't want to be stuck on highways for hours right.
E20 Flex Fuel related Video or Short session please.
Which one the best ev car to buy sir❤
can u do comparison between byd atto a3 vs Kia ev6 vs hundai ionic 5🙏🏼